Who Should I Draft?

Phil Hughes or Trevor Cahill (2014)

Looking for Start/Sit Advice?
Go to Who Should I Start.
Photo of Phil Hughes
Phil Hughes (SP)
Minnesota
Photo of Trevor Cahill
Trevor Cahill (SP)
Arizona
Composite ADP
384
454
350
N/A
305
392
381
412

View Average Draft Position (ADP) for all players

G
29
31
GS
28
30
IP
163
186
W
8
11
L
12
11
SV
0
0
BS
0
0
HD
0
0
H
172
181
ER
80
81
HR
20
14
K
134
134
BBI
44
75
ERA
4.41
3.90
WHIP
1.32
1.37
G
30
26
GS
29
25
IP
145
146
W
4
8
L
14
10
SV
0
0
BS
-
-
HD
-
-
H
170
143
ER
84
65
HR
24
13
K
121
102
BBI
42
63
ERA
5.21
4.00
WHIP
1.46
1.41
 

Plouffe's bat paces offensive outburst in series finale


Target Field should restore his confidence, and push his HR/FB clip into a reasonable area. Hughes's K/BB rate has been solid his entire career; there's ability here, and juicy post-hype sleeper value. - Brandon Funston, Yahoo

As for Cahill earning the save, don't read anything into it as the Diamondbacks had used all of their more trustworthy relievers earlier in the game.  He did have a clean inning, with 1 K, though and maybe could find a niche after struggling in the rotation. - Eric Stashin, Roto Professor