2012 Fantasy Baseball Rankings

ECR™ | Expert Consensus Ranking
Mixed League | AL Only | NL Only | Projections | Auction Values | ADP
Discuss   Export

Pitcher Rankings: Consensus of 42 Experts [ edit experts ]

Rank Player Name Overall Best Worst Ave Std Dev
1 Roy Halladay (PHI, SP)1 3 28 15.9 5.0
2 Clayton Kershaw (LAD, SP)2 3 23 16.1 5.0
3 Justin Verlander (DET, SP)3 8 27 17.9 4.8
4 Cliff Lee (PHI, SP)4 2 31 22.2 5.3
5 Felix Hernandez (SEA, SP)5 20 44 28.6 5.2
6 Tim Lincecum (SF, SP)6 21 46 29.5 5.2
7 CC Sabathia (NYY, SP)7 22 67 33.3 7.9
8 Cole Hamels (PHI, SP)8 22 56 35.4 8.4
9 Jered Weaver (LAA, SP)9 15 65 36.2 10.6
10 Zack Greinke (MIL, SP)10 19 73 43.4 10.4
11 Dan Haren (LAA, SP)11 25 79 44.8 10.7
12 David Price (TB, SP)12 21 72 47.0 9.1
13 Matt Cain (SF, SP)13 23 98 56.6 13.4
14 Jon Lester (BOS, SP)14 39 124 61.3 15.1
15 Craig Kimbrel (ATL, RP)15 30 89 61.5 13.1
16 Stephen Strasburg (WSH, SP)16 33 101 61.9 15.5
17 Yovani Gallardo (MIL, SP)17 39 104 64.9 14.0
18 Madison Bumgarner (SF, SP)18 46 92 69.5 13.0
19 Ian Kennedy (ARI, SP)19 34 118 75.5 17.4
20 James Shields (TB, SP)20 28 162 76.4 20.4
21 C.J. Wilson (LAA, SP)21 35 101 76.6 12.7
22 Mariano Rivera (NYY, RP)22 56 133 87.7 14.7
23 Adam Wainwright (STL, SP)23 50 155 89.8 21.3
24 Jonathan Papelbon (PHI, RP)24 32 112 89.5 14.3
25 Tommy Hanson (ATL, SP)25 59 137 93.6 18.1
26 Josh Johnson (MIA, SP)26 45 204 96.7 26.9
27 John Axford (MIL, RP)27 36 118 91.9 14.5
28 Matt Moore (TB, SP/RP)28 46 148 96.2 20.5
29 Mat Latos (CIN, SP)29 47 123 92.0 15.1
30 Yu Darvish (TEX, SP)30 61 155 97.6 18.1
31 Daniel Hudson (ARI, SP)31 63 127 97.2 12.6
32 Drew Storen (WSH, RP) DL32 50 191 106.1 25.7
33 Matt Garza (CHC, SP)33 71 160 103.9 15.9
34 Ricky Romero (TOR, SP)34 65 159 112.6 20.6
35 Josh Beckett (BOS, SP)35 51 193 109.1 22.4
36 Michael Pineda (NYY, SP) DL36 60 291 121.8 43.3
37 Brandon Beachy (ATL, SP)37 77 165 112.6 21.2
38 Heath Bell (MIA, RP)38 57 168 119.8 24.6
39 Cory Luebke (SD, SP/RP)39 66 278 130.0 37.9
40 Gio Gonzalez (WSH, SP)40 73 205 119.2 23.1
41 Brian Wilson (SF, RP) DL41 84 182 123.3 20.1
42 Jose Valverde (DET, RP)42 61 173 133.9 22.4
43 Jordan Zimmermann (WSH, SP)43 81 195 124.7 20.4
44 Joel Hanrahan (PIT, RP)44 65 222 139.2 25.5
45 Johnny Cueto (CIN, SP)45 87 213 144.4 25.8
46 Jeremy Hellickson (TB, SP)46 82 195 147.6 27.2
47 Doug Fister (DET, SP) DL47 77 231 166.9 40.1
48 Jaime Garcia (STL, SP)48 84 199 158.4 24.6
49 Ryan Madson (CIN, RP) DL49 86 164 129.6 18.4
50 J.J. Putz (ARI, RP)50 89 172 132.5 17.9
51 Shaun Marcum (MIL, SP)51 90 195 146.0 23.6
52 Anibal Sanchez (MIA, SP)52 96 200 134.0 22.8
53 Andrew Bailey (BOS, RP) DL53 99 237 153.4 30.2
54 Tim Hudson (ATL, SP)54 99 214 164.2 27.6
55 Chris Carpenter (STL, SP) DL55 100 294 143.3 39.3
56 Sergio Santos (TOR, RP) DL56 100 226 159.3 35.0
57 Ubaldo Jimenez (CLE, SP)57 100 215 151.0 27.4
58 Rafael Betancourt (COL, RP)58 103 257 161.9 32.4
59 Neftali Feliz (TEX, SP/RP)59 104 245 162.5 34.3
60 Jordan Walden (LAA, RP)60 105 235 164.0 29.0
61 Ervin Santana (LAA, SP)61 105 234 167.7 29.5
62 Jason Motte (STL, RP)62 108 196 160.3 21.3
63 Carlos Marmol (CHC, RP)63 112 235 163.0 27.7
64 Max Scherzer (DET, SP)64 114 236 147.1 25.0
65 Joakim Soria (KC, RP) DL65 117 254 171.9 40.3
66 Brandon Morrow (TOR, SP)66 122 226 155.4 22.9
67 Huston Street (SD, RP)67 123 242 174.5 28.6
68 Brandon League (SEA, RP)68 124 236 185.1 30.8
69 Scott Baker (MIN, SP) DL69 129 281 209.3 37.4
70 Derek Holland (TEX, SP)70 130 244 189.3 31.7
71 Justin Masterson (CLE, SP)71 130 227 187.6 25.3
72 Wandy Rodriguez (HOU, SP)72 134 214 179.2 21.9
73 Chris Sale (CWS, SP/RP)73 135 271 184.5 32.9
74 Brandon McCarthy (OAK, SP)74 135 240 189.6 31.8
75 John Danks (CWS, SP)75 137 301 200.4 38.6
76 Hiroki Kuroda (NYY, SP)76 137 300 180.0 35.0
77 Joe Nathan (TEX, RP)77 137 224 176.9 23.9
78 Sergio Romo (SF, RP)78 140 320 244.9 54.8
79 Ted Lilly (LAD, SP)79 144 291 198.1 41.6
80 Clay Buchholz (BOS, SP)80 144 290 198.1 38.1
81 Kenley Jansen (LAD, RP)81 144 261 189.2 33.7
82 Greg Holland (KC, RP)82 145 287 212.2 45.2
83 Francisco Liriano (MIN, SP)83 145 272 223.1 38.7
84 Daniel Bard (BOS, SP/RP)84 145 272 201.5 35.2
85 Vance Worley (PHI, SP)85 147 289 200.7 37.9
86 Colby Lewis (TEX, SP)86 151 247 191.2 27.5
87 Jhoulys Chacin (COL, SP)87 151 239 186.9 27.6
88 Chris Perez (CLE, RP)88 155 295 222.2 37.3
89 Matt Thornton (CWS, RP)89 155 282 220.6 33.3
90 Trevor Cahill (ARI, SP)90 156 265 202.6 33.4
91 Roy Oswalt (PHI, SP)91 156 260 217.2 37.2
92 Kyle Farnsworth (TB, RP) DL92 160 259 212.1 23.1
93 Tyler Clippard (WSH, RP)93 163 290 245.7 41.6
94 Bud Norris (HOU, SP)94 164 285 233.6 34.6
95 Sean Marshall (CIN, RP)95 166 246 199.0 30.8
96 Alexi Ogando (TEX, SP/RP)96 170 319 243.3 54.1
97 Grant Balfour (OAK, RP)97 170 268 218.0 31.7
98 Addison Reed (CWS, RP)98 171 277 238.3 40.4
99 Javy Guerra (LAD, RP)99 173 280 225.3 34.0
100 Tim Stauffer (SD, SP) DL100 174 306 217.7 31.6
101 Jair Jurrjens (ATL, SP) DL101 176 252 209.8 21.7
102 Luke Hochevar (KC, SP)102 178 277 227.5 49.5
103 Brett Myers (HOU, SP/RP)103 180 299 221.5 32.5
104 Vinnie Pestano (CLE, RP)104 180 287 239.2 36.8
105 Ryan Dempster (CHC, SP)105 181 315 239.9 36.4
106 Chad Billingsley (LAD, SP)106 182 310 234.1 34.0
107 Aroldis Chapman (CIN, RP)107 182 298 241.0 36.2
108 Gavin Floyd (CWS, SP)108 183 284 231.6 36.7
109 Mike Adams (TEX, RP)109 185 284 236.6 35.0
110 Mike Minor (ATL, SP)110 187 290 224.4 32.8
111 Koji Uehara (TEX, RP)111 188 256 222.0 34.0
112 Henderson Alvarez (TOR, SP)112 192 252 230.3 22.9
113 Jonny Venters (ATL, RP)113 196 284 238.9 27.1
114 Johan Santana (NYM, SP)114 197 292 243.8 39.9
115 Edwin Jackson (WSH, SP)115 197 287 242.4 26.9
116 Jonathon Niese (NYM, SP)116 198 295 249.4 33.7
117 Ryan Vogelsong (SF, SP)117 198 283 243.4 29.1
118 Matt Capps (MIN, RP)118 199 275 237.9 25.8
119 Alfredo Aceves (BOS, SP/RP)119 200 246 223.0 23.0
120 Carlos Zambrano (MIA, SP)120 202 302 252.0 50.0
121 Jim Johnson (BAL, RP)121 204 274 238.8 22.0
122 Frank Francisco (NYM, RP)122 206 274 226.9 19.0
123 Jonathan Sanchez (KC, SP)123 208 273 238.3 25.2
124 Juan Nicasio (COL, SP)124 209 250 232.7 17.3
125 R.A. Dickey (NYM, SP)125 212 285 240.5 23.7
126 Ricky Nolasco (MIA, SP)126 212 282 240.0 23.6
127 Bartolo Colon (OAK, SP)127 216 316 266.0 50.0
128 David Robertson (NYY, RP)128 219 222 220.5 1.5
129 Jeff Niemann (TB, SP)129 220 298 266.5 31.9
130 Francisco Rodriguez (MIL, RP)130 220 287 264.0 31.1
131 Mike Leake (CIN, SP)131 221 318 262.8 36.0
132 Joaquin Benoit (DET, RP)132 223 296 259.5 36.5
133 Erik Bedard (PIT, SP)133 227 298 260.3 26.3
134 Jake Peavy (CWS, SP)134 231 307 264.3 27.4
135 Josh Collmenter (ARI, SP/RP)135 231 266 248.5 17.5
136 Joel Peralta (TB, RP)136 232 273 252.5 20.5
137 Phil Hughes (NYY, SP)137 233 295 260.0 24.7
138 Philip Humber (CWS, SP)138 234 300 267.0 33.0
139 Homer Bailey (CIN, SP)139 236 301 276.8 22.5
140 Mark Melancon (BOS, RP)140 240 295 272.7 23.6
141 Jonathan Broxton (KC, RP)141 241 300 270.5 29.5
142 Edinson Volquez (SD, SP)142 243 286 265.3 15.5
143 Mark Buehrle (MIA, SP)143 247 294 266.8 20.9
144 Ivan Nova (NYY, SP)144 250 293 274.3 15.8
145 Fernando Salas (STL, RP)145 257 276 266.5 9.5
146 Javier Vazquez (MIA, SP)146 270 279 274.5 4.5
147 Brian Fuentes (OAK, RP)147 276 291 283.5 7.5
148 Matt Harrison (TEX, SP)148 285 294 289.5 4.5