2015 Fantasy Baseball Rankings

ECR™ | Expert Consensus Ranking

Pitcher Rankings: 35 of 40 experts selected Last Updated
Pick Experts Mock Draft
Rank Player (team, position) Overall Best Worst Ave Std Dev
1 Clayton Kershaw (LAD - SP) 4 1 1 1.0 0.0
2 Felix Hernandez (SEA - SP) 12 2 4 2.2 0.4
3 Max Scherzer (WSH - SP) 14 2 8 3.7 1.2
4 Chris Sale (CWS - SP) 21 3 22 5.2 3.7
5 Madison Bumgarner (SF - SP) 23 2 11 5.6 1.8
6 Stephen Strasburg (WSH - SP) 26 3 15 6.6 2.7
7 David Price (DET - SP) 30 4 17 7.5 2.6
8 Corey Kluber (CLE - SP) 33 3 16 7.7 2.4
9 Zack Greinke (LAD - SP) 35 6 15 9.1 1.8
10 Johnny Cueto (CIN - SP) 42 5 22 11.7 3.6
11 Cole Hamels (PHI - SP) 41 4 20 11.9 2.6
12 Yu Darvish (TEX - SP) 44 6 46 12.6 7.9
13 Jordan Zimmermann (WSH - SP) 45 8 20 12.8 2.3
14 Jon Lester (CHC - SP) 50 9 30 14.9 4.2
15 Aroldis Chapman (CIN - RP) 57 8 29 16.7 3.4
16 Adam Wainwright (STL - SP) 56 7 38 17.1 7.2
17 Craig Kimbrel (ATL - RP) 61 11 26 17.9 2.6
18 Greg Holland (KC - RP) 70 12 34 20.5 4.1
19 Alex Cobb (TB - SP) 74 16 29 21.3 3.1
20 Julio Teheran (ATL - SP) 72 11 55 21.8 8.2
21 Matt Harvey (NYM - SP) 78 10 70 24.0 13.0
22 Hisashi Iwakuma (SEA - SP) 80 16 51 24.9 6.0
23 Jeff Samardzija (CWS - SP) 81 13 51 25.5 7.3
24 James Shields (SD - SP) 84 12 48 26.3 7.0
25 Gerrit Cole (PIT - SP) 91 14 48 29.4 7.8
26 David Robertson (CWS - RP) 89 20 44 29.7 6.2
27 Jake Arrieta (CHC - SP) 94 15 50 30.2 7.6
28 Sonny Gray (OAK - SP) 87 15 62 30.2 10.4
29 Gio Gonzalez (WSH - SP) 97 18 58 32.0 7.8
30 Mark Melancon (PIT - RP) 99 19 50 33.2 6.7
31 Tyson Ross (SD - SP) 101 20 65 33.6 10.7
32 Alex Wood (ATL - SP,RP) 104 17 97 34.2 14.0
33 Trevor Rosenthal (STL - RP) 102 19 54 34.5 7.6
34 Dellin Betances (NYY - RP) 103 16 68 35.0 12.6
35 Cliff Lee (PHI - SP) 108 21 67 37.3 9.6
36 Masahiro Tanaka (NYY - SP) 110 15 71 39.0 11.4
37 Jacob DeGrom (NYM - SP) 111 11 83 39.1 12.0
38 Carlos Carrasco (CLE - SP,RP) 118 12 100 39.2 18.6
39 Hyun-Jin Ryu (LAD - SP) 112 18 70 39.5 11.4
40 Cody Allen (CLE - RP) 115 27 65 39.6 7.5
41 Koji Uehara (BOS - RP) 122 22 64 41.3 7.9
42 Kenley Jansen (LAD - RP) 121 18 93 38.6 16.5
43 Anibal Sanchez (DET - SP) 125 30 69 42.7 9.9
44 Garrett Richards (LAA - SP) 129 23 89 45.6 12.7
45 Phil Hughes (MIN - SP) 138 27 73 49.6 9.8
46 Lance Lynn (STL - SP) 141 36 83 50.0 9.8
47 Steve Cishek (MIA - RP) 134 37 110 50.3 11.9
48 Glen Perkins (MIN - RP) 142 33 67 50.8 6.8
49 Doug Fister (WSH - SP) 150 31 100 53.8 15.6
50 Andrew Cashner (SD - SP) 149 24 88 53.9 12.9
51 Marcus Stroman (TOR - SP,RP) 158 21 98 54.9 18.4
52 Chris Archer (TB - SP) 154 26 84 55.4 11.3
53 Fernando Rodney (SEA - RP) 155 41 83 56.1 9.0
54 Jonathan Papelbon (PHI - RP) 163 43 97 58.5 10.5
55 Homer Bailey (CIN - SP) 160 39 89 58.6 12.5
56 Mat Latos (MIA - SP) 161 28 96 59.0 17.2
57 Huston Street (LAA - RP) 164 38 97 59.0 12.5
58 Michael Wacha (STL - SP) 162 39 91 59.9 9.9
59 Drew Smyly (TB - SP) 165 29 86 60.0 11.5
60 Joaquin Benoit (SD - RP) 166 41 99 60.8 12.7
61 Ian Kennedy (SD - SP) 167 32 101 62.1 13.4
62 Sean Doolittle (OAK - RP) 170 29 109 62.6 21.6
63 Yordano Ventura (KC - SP) 175 44 90 64.7 9.6
64 Francisco Liriano (PIT - SP) 173 37 96 65.1 12.0
65 Zack Wheeler (NYM - SP) 176 30 98 66.5 14.5
66 Jose Quintana (CWS - SP) 177 47 89 67.3 10.6
67 Jake McGee (TB - RP) 186 42 108 68.1 15.9
68 Jered Weaver (LAA - SP) 184 33 103 68.2 12.0
69 Justin Verlander (DET - SP) 187 30 104 69.0 13.0
70 Zach Britton (BAL - RP) 188 32 98 66.9 17.1
71 Collin McHugh (HOU - SP) 183 41 97 69.5 11.7
72 Drew Storen (WSH - RP) 191 29 113 68.4 21.1
73 Scott Kazmir (OAK - SP) 196 38 105 71.5 11.7
74 Mike Fiers (MIL - SP) 198 29 104 72.2 19.1
75 Brandon McCarthy (LAD - SP) 201 31 104 73.9 15.9
76 Michael Pineda (NYY - SP) 205 36 96 77.3 12.5
77 Jose Fernandez (MIA - SP) 204 46 125 77.9 14.1
78 Jake Odorizzi (TB - SP) 207 62 96 79.1 7.2
79 Matt Shoemaker (LAA - SP,RP) 211 40 101 77.0 15.1
80 John Lackey (STL - SP) 215 48 107 81.7 12.3
81 Francisco Rodriguez (MIL - RP) 221 36 118 81.1 20.2
82 Matt Cain (SF - SP) 219 66 109 84.8 9.6
83 Dallas Keuchel (HOU - SP) 216 58 118 83.1 10.2
84 Ervin Santana (MIN - SP) 226 68 155 86.4 15.0
85 Rick Porcello (BOS - SP) 235 72 109 88.5 8.7
86 Danny Salazar (CLE - SP) 239 41 120 86.2 18.0
87 Hector Rondon (CHC - RP) 224 52 99 78.0 14.3
88 Drew Hutchison (TOR - SP) 241 57 112 89.5 10.8
89 Addison Reed (ARI - RP) 238 54 101 84.3 13.2
90 Mike Minor (ATL - SP) 249 75 136 94.7 11.2
91 Tanner Roark (WSH - SP,RP) 247 59 146 91.9 17.8
92 R.A. Dickey (TOR - SP) 250 77 114 94.7 9.6
93 Kyle Lohse (MIL - SP) 246 70 111 93.5 9.0
94 Santiago Casilla (SF - RP) 242 52 117 85.2 17.5
95 Neftali Feliz (TEX - RP) 251 51 117 91.2 16.4
96 Chris Tillman (BAL - SP) 258 58 116 95.2 12.9
97 Yusmeiro Petit (SF - SP,RP) 254 68 161 95.6 18.4
98 Luke Gregerson (HOU - RP) 263 61 125 97.4 12.2
99 A.J. Burnett (PIT - SP) 266 81 115 99.4 8.3
100 Tyler Clippard (OAK - RP) 259 54 132 93.6 19.2
101 Joe Nathan (DET - RP) 270 60 119 96.2 15.1
102 Shelby Miller (ATL - SP) 261 72 117 92.7 12.7
103 James Paxton (SEA - SP) 256 72 130 93.1 13.9
104 Kevin Gausman (BAL - SP) 268 54 123 94.0 16.8
105 Sergio Romo (SF - RP) 326 80 140 106.8 12.9
106 Derek Holland (TEX - SP) 274 76 125 94.9 12.4
107 Bartolo Colon (NYM - SP) 293 84 122 102.6 10.0
108 Henderson Alvarez (MIA - SP) 276 78 116 97.0 10.6
109 Mike Leake (CIN - SP) 290 88 124 102.3 8.8
110 Josh Collmenter (ARI - SP,RP) 320 94 127 106.6 9.3
111 Jenrry Mejia (NYM - SP,RP) 278 50 137 95.4 19.1
112 Wade Davis (KC - RP) 275 63 121 97.9 16.3
113 Matt Garza (MIL - SP) 288 78 121 100.0 11.4
114 Brett Cecil (TOR - RP) 272 55 133 91.1 23.8
115 Andrew Miller (NYY - RP) 282 69 120 100.8 15.5
116 Jake Peavy (SF - SP) 283 75 145 99.3 21.3
117 Jason Hammel (CHC - SP) 289 78 134 103.6 17.0
118 Wily Peralta (MIL - SP) 285 69 131 95.8 19.3
119 Kenneth Giles (PHI - RP) 269 55 125 84.3 21.2
120 Bradley Boxberger (TB - RP) 291 64 133 100.6 19.9
121 Jesse Hahn (OAK - SP) 308 93 124 103.8 9.9
122 Danny Duffy (KC - SP,RP) 294 82 120 97.4 13.6
123 LaTroy Hawkins (COL - RP) 286 59 147 99.9 27.8
124 Yovani Gallardo (TEX - SP) 305 76 122 104.8 13.7
125 Jonathan Broxton (MIL - RP) 311 86 216 118.2 36.9
126 Jason Grilli (ATL - RP) 375 100 227 122.4 35.1
127 Taijuan Walker (SEA - SP) 298 79 217 111.6 44.3
128 Wei-Yin Chen (BAL - SP) 313 80 129 109.0 15.8
129 Jonathon Niese (NYM - SP) 307 83 124 105.1 14.4
130 Aaron Sanchez (TOR - RP,SP) 328 77 154 115.7 21.2
131 Tim Hudson (SF - SP) 339 90 150 117.0 18.9
132 Dan Haren (MIA - SP) 408 102 171 124.5 20.7
133 Nathan Eovaldi (NYY - SP) 317 84 141 109.6 20.3
134 Anthony Cingrani (CIN - SP) 367 94 144 114.9 16.8
135 Andrew Heaney (LAA - SP) 325 77 132 104.2 19.5
136 Wade Miley (BOS - SP) 338 93 132 112.1 14.4
137 Joakim Soria (DET - RP) 314 69 199 120.3 43.8
138 CC Sabathia (NYY - SP) 337 64 157 116.8 30.4
139 Clay Buchholz (BOS - SP) 340 74 120 109.2 17.6
140 Carlos Martinez (STL - SP,RP) 333 82 187 119.6 37.2
141 Trevor Bauer (CLE - SP) 336 90 162 122.7 26.3
142 Drew Pomeranz (OAK - SP,RP) 370 92 160 124.8 20.8
143 C.J. Wilson (LAA - SP) 371 95 135 119.2 15.2
144 Shane Greene (DET - SP) 347 88 163 124.6 26.1
145 Rafael Soriano (WSH - RP) 352 91 140 120.3 20.2
146 Kyle Hendricks (CHC - SP) 376 94 129 110.0 14.4
147 Bobby Parnell (NYM - RP) 404 99 163 132.4 26.9
148 Jimmy Nelson (MIL - SP) 382 111 137 123.5 10.5
149 Chad Qualls (HOU - RP) 344 76 177 134.3 42.7
150 Kelvin Herrera (KC - RP) 395 119 174 142.6 20.6
151 Joel Peralta (LAD - RP) 383 114 178 141.7 26.8
152 Pat Neshek (HOU - RP) 452 100 173 141.7 30.7
153 Jorge De La Rosa (COL - SP) 405 107 176 143.7 28.3
154 Bud Norris (BAL - SP) 387 122 134 128.0 6.0
155 Casey Janssen (WSH - RP) 415 113 231 160.0 43.4
156 Tim Lincecum (SF - SP,RP) 461 109 224 171.7 47.5
157 Miguel Gonzalez (BAL - SP) 384 117 146 131.5 14.5
158 Alfredo Simon (DET - SP) 399 124 153 140.0 12.0
159 Carlos Martinez (MIA - RP,SP)   120 148 134.0 14.0
160 Hector Santiago (LAA - SP,RP) 487 120 204 170.0 36.1
161 Vidal Nuno (ARI - SP) 386 121 157 139.0 18.0
162 Tony Watson (PIT - RP) 388 127 161 144.3 13.9
163 Junichi Tazawa (BOS - RP) 465 126 193 168.3 30.1
164 Jeremy Hellickson (ARI - SP) 484 127 202 175.3 34.2
165 Travis Wood (CHC - SP) 481 128 218 182.0 38.9
166 Justin Masterson (BOS - SP) 390 129 169 149.0 20.0
167 Jesse Chavez (OAK - SP,RP) 393 139 184 157.0 19.4
168 Jarred Cosart (MIA - SP) 394 141 149 145.0 4.0
169 Jeurys Familia (NYM - RP) 412 144 189 166.5 22.5
170 Jason Vargas (KC - SP) 400 144 182 163.0 19.0
171 Kevin Quackenbush (SD - RP) 403 147 180 163.5 16.5
172 Jeff Locke (PIT - SP) 406 149 162 155.5 6.5
173 Vance Worley (PIT - SP) 409 151 165 158.0 7.0
174 Mark Buehrle (TOR - SP) 414 151 164 156.3 5.6
175 Darren O'Day (BAL - RP) 410 152 168 157.3 7.5
176 Kevin Jepsen (TB - RP) 430 153 189 169.3 14.9
177 Joe Smith (LAA - RP) 413 153 172 162.5 9.5
178 J.A. Happ (SEA - SP) 433 154 183 172.3 13.0
179 T.J. House (CLE - SP) 421 155 159 157.0 2.0
180 Matt Moore (TB - SP) 505 156 215 185.5 29.5
181 Pedro Strop (CHC - RP) 447 157 224 195.0 28.1
182 Scott Feldman (HOU - SP) 419 158 191 174.5 16.5
183 Kyle Gibson (MIN - SP) 495 159 208 183.5 24.5
184 Roenis Elias (SEA - SP) 423 160 190 175.0 15.0
185 Alexander Colome (TB - SP) 429 164 207 185.5 21.5
186 Dan Otero (OAK - RP) 431 165 203 184.0 19.0
187 Brett Anderson (LAD - SP) 434 166 173 169.5 3.5
188 Dominic Leone (SEA - RP) 438 167 196 181.5 14.5
189 Edinson Volquez (KC - SP) 456 167 175 171.0 4.0
190 Marco Estrada (TOR - SP,RP) 440 168 179 173.5 5.5
191 Chase Anderson (ARI - SP) 442 169 185 177.0 8.0
192 Colby Lewis (TEX - SP)   170 230 200.0 30.0
193 Jeremy Guthrie (KC - SP) 444 170 211 190.5 20.5
194 Tom Koehler (MIA - SP) 449 171 172 171.5 0.5
195 Tyler Matzek (COL - SP) 468 175 190 182.5 7.5
196 Tommy Milone (MIN - SP) 457 176 214 195.0 19.0
197 Archie Bradley (ARI - SP) 502 177 212 194.5 17.5
198 Dillon Gee (NYM - SP,RP) 489 178 205 191.5 13.5
199 Ricky Nolasco (MIN - SP) 459 179 213 196.0 17.0
200 Danny Farquhar (SEA - RP) 460 181 202 191.5 10.5
201 Ryan Cook (OAK - RP) 472 181 193 187.0 6.0
202 Anthony DeSclafani (CIN - SP,RP) 463 184 227 205.5 21.5
203 Brett Oberholtzer (HOU - SP) 464 185 198 191.5 6.5
204 Bryan Shaw (CLE - RP) 466 187 205 196.0 9.0
205 Aaron Harang (PHI - SP) 467 188 216 202.0 14.0
206 Aaron Loup (TOR - RP) 470 188 192 190.0 2.0
207 Ross Detwiler (TEX - RP,SP) 476 194 226 210.0 16.0
208 Adam Ottavino (COL - RP) 482 194 201 197.5 3.5
209 J.P. Howell (LAD - RP) 477 195 217 206.0 11.0
210 Kris Medlen (KC - SP,RP) 486 195 203 199.0 4.0
211 Brad Ziegler (ARI - RP) 478 196 210 203.0 7.0
212 Jhoulys Chacin (COL - SP) 479 197 209 203.0 6.0
213 A.J. Ramos (MIA - RP) 480 198 212 205.0 7.0
214 Joe Kelly (BOS - SP) 490 199 206 202.5 3.5
215 Ivan Nova (NYY - SP) 500 200 211 205.5 5.5
216 Ryan Vogelsong (SF - SP) 503 201 213 207.0 6.0
217 Al Alburquerque (DET - RP)   206 222 214.0 8.0
218 Tsuyoshi Wada (CHC - SP,RP) 491 207 215 211.0 4.0
219 Josh Johnson (SD - SP) 496 209 219 214.0 5.0
220 John Danks (CWS - SP) 504 214 222 218.0 4.0
221 Franklin Morales (COL - SP,RP)   231 232 231.5 0.5
222 Chris Capuano (NYY - SP,RP)   232 233 232.5 0.5
223 Ubaldo Jimenez (BAL - SP,RP)   234 235 234.5 0.5