2016 Fantasy Baseball Rankings

ECR™ | Expert Consensus Ranking

Pitcher Rankings: 15 of 16 experts selected
Pick Experts Mock Draft
Rank Player (team, position) Overall Best Worst Ave Std Dev
1 Clayton Kershaw (LAD - SP) 4 1 1 1.0 0.0
2 Max Scherzer (WSH - SP) 18 2 4 2.3 0.6
3 Jake Arrieta (CHC - SP) 24 2 6 3.4 1.1
4 Chris Sale (CWS - SP) 25 2 6 3.9 0.9
5 Madison Bumgarner (SF - SP) 31 3 11 6.5 1.9
6 Jose Fernandez (MIA - SP) 32 3 13 7.0 2.6
7 Zack Greinke (ARI - SP) 33 5 13 7.3 2.2
8 David Price (BOS - SP) 35 4 13 7.9 2.4
9 Jacob DeGrom (NYM - SP) 37 3 13 9.2 2.5
10 Corey Kluber (CLE - SP) 41 6 16 10.9 2.4
11 Gerrit Cole (PIT - SP) 43 7 14 11.1 1.9
12 Felix Hernandez (SEA - SP) 44 7 17 11.4 2.7
13 Matt Harvey (NYM - SP) 45 8 18 11.7 2.7
14 Dallas Keuchel (HOU - SP) 50 10 18 14.5 2.1
15 Stephen Strasburg (WSH - SP) 52 6 22 16.1 4.5
16 Chris Archer (TB - SP) 53 13 21 16.4 1.9
17 Carlos Carrasco (CLE - SP,RP) 56 13 24 17.3 3.0
18 Sonny Gray (OAK - SP) 60 16 25 18.5 2.3
19 Noah Syndergaard (NYM - SP) 61 14 30 18.7 3.7
20 Johnny Cueto (SF - SP) 63 15 31 20.1 3.7
21 Cole Hamels (TEX - SP) 68 16 28 22.1 2.9
22 Jon Lester (CHC - SP) 69 19 27 22.3 2.7
23 Wade Davis (KC - RP) 76 16 31 24.7 3.3
24 Kenley Jansen (LAD - RP) 77 15 37 25.9 4.7
25 Aroldis Chapman (NYY - RP) 78 20 36 26.1 5.3
26 Craig Kimbrel (BOS - RP) 80 19 46 27.1 6.3
27 Adam Wainwright (STL - SP) 83 17 68 28.4 12.2
28 Tyson Ross (SD - SP) 86 23 44 29.9 4.9
29 Jordan Zimmermann (DET - SP) 88 22 44 31.1 6.8
30 Garrett Richards (LAA - SP) 89 27 40 31.2 3.8
31 Danny Salazar (CLE - SP) 90 25 42 31.4 4.8
32 Francisco Liriano (PIT - SP) 95 26 51 34.1 6.0
33 David Robertson (CWS - RP) 96 26 48 35.7 5.0
34 Marcus Stroman (TOR - SP) 99 17 56 36.3 9.3
35 Michael Wacha (STL - SP) 101 28 50 37.2 6.3
36 Mark Melancon (PIT - RP) 102 26 62 37.6 8.7
37 Jeurys Familia (NYM - RP) 104 29 67 38.6 9.5
38 Kenneth Giles (HOU - RP) 105 29 52 39.9 5.2
39 Trevor Rosenthal (STL - RP) 108 25 53 40.1 8.0
40 Zach Britton (BAL - RP) 109 34 57 42.5 6.3
41 Cody Allen (CLE - RP) 111 33 71 43.0 9.0
42 Lance McCullers (HOU - SP) 113 24 67 43.1 9.9
43 Masahiro Tanaka (NYY - SP) 114 27 72 44.1 12.3
44 Michael Pineda (NYY - SP) 124 27 60 46.3 9.8
45 Jose Quintana (CWS - SP) 127 34 63 46.9 8.0
46 Collin McHugh (HOU - SP) 135 28 62 50.4 9.2
47 Yu Darvish (TEX - SP) 123 39 95 51.0 14.2
48 James Shields (SD - SP) 125 41 75 51.1 9.4
49 Raisel Iglesias (CIN - SP) 137 31 64 45.1 10.7
50 Shelby Miller (ARI - SP) 129 42 65 52.4 6.2
51 Carlos Martinez (STL - SP,RP) 132 33 112 52.9 21.5
52 Taijuan Walker (SEA - SP) 141 39 69 53.7 10.2
53 John Lackey (CHC - SP) 142 47 65 54.0 6.0
54 Huston Street (LAA - RP) 138 47 78 55.9 7.3
55 Hector Rondon (CHC - RP) 140 45 77 56.5 8.8
56 Hisashi Iwakuma (SEA - SP) 139 41 85 56.7 11.9
57 Jeff Samardzija (SF - SP) 145 37 77 57.3 10.9
58 Jake Odorizzi (TB - SP) 146 47 71 57.5 6.3
59 A.J. Ramos (MIA - RP) 144 47 86 60.5 10.7
60 Jonathan Papelbon (WSH - RP) 154 31 88 61.1 13.1
61 Scott Kazmir (LAD - SP) 157 50 78 62.6 7.2
62 Julio Teheran (ATL - SP) 159 45 75 64.6 9.1
63 Francisco Rodriguez (DET - RP) 152 48 82 64.7 10.0
64 Mike Fiers (HOU - SP) 161 45 81 65.1 9.6
65 Drew Smyly (TB - SP) 164 44 97 65.6 13.9
66 Justin Verlander (DET - SP) 155 56 89 66.6 10.7
67 Shawn Tolleson (TEX - RP) 174 55 93 69.6 9.3
68 Glen Perkins (MIN - RP) 171 56 78 69.7 6.3
69 Carlos Rodon (CWS - SP) 160 41 119 65.1 18.9
70 Gio Gonzalez (WSH - SP) 178 57 92 71.0 9.3
71 Yordano Ventura (KC - SP) 179 59 87 72.8 8.4
72 Jason Hammel (CHC - SP) 186 58 104 76.8 10.9
73 Patrick Corbin (ARI - SP) 184 56 85 72.4 7.7
74 Bradley Boxberger (TB - RP) 188 58 109 77.7 11.7
75 Andrew Miller (NYY - RP) 192 36 121 78.8 21.0
76 Dellin Betances (NYY - RP) 189 50 120 79.1 19.8
77 Kyle Hendricks (CHC - SP) 193 46 94 74.7 11.4
78 Jimmy Nelson (MIL - SP) 195 58 88 75.6 6.9
79 Steven Matz (NYM - SP) 183 41 92 71.8 13.1
80 Brad Ziegler (ARI - RP) 200 75 94 82.9 4.3
81 Santiago Casilla (SF - RP) 202 70 102 83.2 7.7
82 Anibal Sanchez (DET - SP) 205 64 95 85.7 6.8
83 Wei-Yin Chen (MIA - SP) 204 64 119 81.8 13.0
84 Alex Wood (LAD - SP,RP) 207 65 108 86.4 11.5
85 Marco Estrada (TOR - SP,RP) 212 56 107 83.4 15.4
86 Jaime Garcia (STL - SP) 211 68 101 85.4 7.7
87 Mike Leake (STL - SP) 217 78 117 90.5 8.5
88 Steve Cishek (SEA - RP) 220 76 103 92.5 8.0
89 Roberto Osuna (TOR - RP,SP) 215 60 109 84.4 14.2
90 Sean Doolittle (OAK - RP) 224 75 135 93.4 14.7
91 Andrew Cashner (SD - SP) 230 72 111 94.1 9.2
92 Edinson Volquez (KC - SP) 231 73 109 93.8 8.9
93 Ian Kennedy (KC - SP) 227 62 100 90.6 10.8
94 Drew Storen (TOR - RP) 222 40 126 86.3 20.3
95 Clay Buchholz (BOS - SP) 235 73 118 95.9 9.6
96 Luis Severino (NYY - SP) 229 55 102 81.5 16.1
97 Kyle Gibson (MIN - SP) 250 94 122 103.8 7.7
98 Arodys Vizcaino (ATL - RP) 241 70 144 100.1 18.7
99 Luke Gregerson (HOU - RP) 251 68 143 106.1 23.4
100 Andrew Heaney (LAA - SP) 247 70 108 92.7 12.1
101 Jerad Eickhoff (PHI - SP) 252 56 171 108.3 25.0
102 Jake McGee (COL - RP) 246 64 126 92.2 16.5
103 Kevin Gausman (BAL - SP,RP) 259 81 124 105.1 12.5
104 Anthony DeSclafani (CIN - SP,RP) 260 77 118 100.0 13.8
105 Trevor Bauer (CLE - SP) 254 76 127 102.5 15.5
106 Will Smith (MIL - RP) 253 69 108 89.2 12.4
107 Alex Cobb (TB - SP) 262 84 134 104.6 14.4
108 Joakim Soria (KC - RP) 309 91 192 118.7 29.2
109 Brandon Finnegan (CIN - SP,RP) 283 98 129 111.0 8.8
110 Matt Moore (TB - SP) 265 73 122 100.7 16.2
111 Rick Porcello (BOS - SP) 279 91 145 112.2 15.0
112 Ervin Santana (MIN - SP) 275 98 120 108.5 7.9
113 Eduardo Rodriguez (BOS - SP) 263 87 119 103.1 11.2
114 R.A. Dickey (TOR - SP) 270 86 128 103.3 12.8
115 Tony Watson (PIT - RP) 287 97 127 109.6 9.0
116 Wade Miley (SEA - SP) 278 89 141 111.6 17.0
117 Koji Uehara (BOS - RP) 303 84 156 113.1 22.2
118 J.J. Hoover (CIN - RP) 258 75 106 92.2 10.2
119 Darren O'Day (BAL - RP) 291 97 131 110.7 12.7
120 Tom Wilhelmsen (TEX - RP) 320 101 144 117.7 16.5
121 James Paxton (SEA - SP) 271 68 195 114.6 43.1
122 Aaron Nola (PHI - SP,RP) 286 93 128 108.4 13.6
123 Joe Ross (WSH - SP) 282 81 183 115.4 35.9
124 Kevin Quackenbush (SD - RP) 290 88 123 104.8 12.5
125 Fernando Rodney (SD - RP) DTD 305 88 126 105.5 13.5
126 Carter Capps (MIA - RP) 284 52 122 92.3 29.6
127 Kenta Maeda (LAD - SP) 294 73 113 95.3 16.7
128 Hyun-Jin Ryu (LAD - SP) INJ 310 99 121 109.8 8.4
129 Derek Holland (TEX - SP) 308 66 146 118.4 28.0
130 Hector Santiago (LAA - SP,RP) 307 92 127 111.8 12.6
131 Zack Wheeler (NYM - SP) DTD 302 55 154 116.5 37.2
132 A.J. Burnett (SP) 301 100 108 105.0 3.6
133 David Hernandez (PHI - RP) 306 91 152 117.3 22.4
134 Phil Hughes (MIN - SP) 315 90 125 106.0 14.4
135 Jason Grilli (ATL - RP) 297 71 151 106.3 33.3
136 Jake Peavy (SF - SP) 319 100 115 109.0 6.5
137 Matt Shoemaker (LAA - SP) 323 92 122 110.0 13.0
138 Taylor Jungmann (MIL - SP) 341 110 136 121.5 10.0
139 Chris Tillman (BAL - SP) 332 106 123 112.0 7.8
140 Jason Motte (COL - RP) 314 87 145 112.3 24.2
141 Chris Heston (SF - SP,RP) 329 97 136 114.0 16.3
142 J.A. Happ (TOR - SP) 321 93 145 115.3 21.9
143 Archie Bradley (ARI - SP) 337 99 124 115.3 11.6
144 Yovani Gallardo (SP) 334 106 132 116.3 11.3
145 Jose Berrios (MIN - SP,RP) 325 84 118 101.0 17.0
146 Danny Duffy (KC - SP,RP) 333 100 107 103.5 3.5
147 Joe Kelly (BOS - SP) 344 101 121 111.0 10.0
148 Tyler Glasnow (PIT - SP) 355 103 143 125.3 16.7
149 Daniel Norris (DET - SP,RP) 347 112 170 133.0 26.2
150 Jered Weaver (LAA - SP) 336 87 165 126.0 39.0
151 Erasmo Ramirez (TB - SP,RP) 361 116 153 131.0 15.9
152 Joaquin Benoit (SEA - RP) 349 102 141 121.5 19.5
153 Drew Hutchison (TOR - SP) 345 96 177 136.5 40.5
154 Josh Tomlin (CLE - SP,RP) 340 97 198 147.5 50.5
155 Hunter Strickland (SF - RP)   108 147 133.7 18.2
156 Nathan Eovaldi (NYY - SP) 367 120 162 138.3 17.6
157 Jorge De La Rosa (COL - SP) 375 125 133 129.0 4.0
158 Mark Buehrle (SP) 359 121 144 132.5 11.5
159 Pedro Strop (CHC - RP) 369 129 137 133.0 4.0
160 Ubaldo Jimenez (BAL - SP) 374 132 134 133.0 1.0
161 Bartolo Colon (NYM - SP) 368 128 143 135.5 7.5
162 Nathan Karns (SEA - SP) 371 130 142 136.0 6.0
163 Carson Smith (BOS - RP) 379 135 140 137.5 2.5
164 Ryan Madson (OAK - RP)   129 150 139.5 10.5
165 Sergio Romo (SF - RP)   138 141 139.5 1.5
166 Jesse Chavez (TOR - SP,RP)   142 193 167.5 25.5
167 Tanner Roark (WSH - SP,RP)   142 157 149.5 7.5
168 Kevin Siegrist (STL - RP)   147 159 153.0 6.0