Accuracy Scores

Who Gives the Best Fantasy Football Advice?
PAY™ | Prediction Accuracy Yield

2011 Accuracy (Weeks 1-16)

Read our summary | View weekly results
RankExpert NameOverall*RBWRQBTEDSTK
1Scott Pianowski - Yahoo63.7%64.1%61.6%69.4%60.4%56.6%56.8%
2John Paulsen - The Fantasy Shrink63.7%62.9%62.3%69.1%63.1%52.6%53.4%
3Kevin Hanson - EDSFootball63.5%63.4%62.3%70.3%58.0%51.3%51.1%
4Josh Moore - 4for4.com63.5%63.5%62.1%68.7%60.3%N/AN/A
5Sablich Brothers - The New York Times63.3%63.8%61.5%67.3%61.5%55.3%56.5%
6Jeff Ratcliffe - Pro Football Focus63.2%62.7%62.0%69.6%59.8%54.1%53.2%
7Staff Composite - Yahoo63.1%62.5%61.3%68.3%62.9%56.0%57.2%
8Gregg Rosenthal - Rotoworld63.1%61.9%61.8%68.6%62.9%56.3%55.0%
9Mike Woellert - FantasyFootball.com62.9%62.1%63.1%67.1%59.6%50.3%50.7%
10Site Rankings - FantasyFootballNerd62.9%62.5%62.8%66.5%59.5%51.4%52.7%
11Pat Fitzmaurice - ProFootballWeekly62.9%63.6%59.6%68.0%63.0%56.4%58.3%
12Staff Composite - ESPN62.8%63.2%61.8%68.4%56.8%52.2%52.2%
13Ken Zalis - Fans Fantasy Football62.8%62.7%61.5%68.3%59.5%54.2%55.3%
14Ken Moody - Dynasty League Football62.7%62.0%61.7%68.8%59.9%N/AN/A
15Michael Fabiano - NFL.com62.7%62.4%62.0%66.6%60.1%58.4%48.6%
16Russ Bliss - Fantasy Football Starters62.7%63.7%60.9%66.0%59.7%54.2%52.6%
17Chet Gresham - Razzball62.6%62.3%62.0%66.3%60.4%56.1%53.0%
18Site Projections - numberFire62.6%62.8%60.6%67.9%60.4%52.5%55.3%
19Staff Rankings - FFToolbox62.5%62.6%60.3%68.2%60.8%50.9%55.3%
20Tristan Cockcroft - ESPN62.5%61.7%62.1%69.1%56.8%55.5%49.0%
21Sigmund Bloom - FootballGuys62.4%63.4%59.5%65.4%63.2%N/AN/A
22Walter Cherepinsky - Walter Football62.4%61.8%60.7%66.4%64.2%55.5%N/A
23Christopher Harris - ESPN62.4%61.9%61.4%68.4%58.2%51.8%52.6%
24Derek Lofland - FFManiaxs62.3%63.2%61.5%63.9%59.4%N/AN/A
25Staff Composite - NFL.com62.3%62.0%61.4%66.8%59.6%52.8%48.8%
26Andy Behrens - Yahoo62.3%60.9%61.1%68.0%62.4%54.5%57.6%
27Staff Rankings - Chinstrap Ninjas 62.2%62.1%61.8%67.5%56.2%51.2%52.3%
28Staff Rankings - FantasyFootballCafe62.2%61.8%61.0%68.2%58.6%50.4%54.1%
29Staff Composite - SI.com62.2%61.8%60.1%68.8%59.8%52.9%55.8%
30David Dodds - FootballGuys62.1%63.2%59.5%66.0%60.6%45.8%50.7%
31Staff Rankings - Fantasy Football Freaks62.0%62.6%62.2%67.4%51.8%39.4%46.4%
32Site Projections - CBS Sports62.0%63.2%59.7%67.9%56.5%54.1%54.4%
33Brad Evans - Yahoo62.0%62.6%60.6%65.2%59.4%52.3%55.8%
34Eric Karabell - ESPN61.9%61.9%61.6%66.3%56.6%51.7%50.2%
35Adam Rank - NFL.com61.7%61.3%60.6%67.6%57.9%50.9%51.1%
36Mike Clay - Pro Football Focus61.6%62.5%60.0%63.0%61.5%53.5%54.2%
37Alessandro Miglio - Pro Football Focus61.4%60.3%60.4%67.5%59.5%53.0%46.2%
38Matthew Berry - ESPN61.4%61.7%60.1%66.8%56.7%51.5%51.2%
39Dave Dameshek - NFL.com61.4%61.7%60.4%64.1%59.1%56.9%48.3%
40Brandon Funston - Yahoo61.4%61.0%61.2%65.5%57.3%53.6%56.4%
41Dave Richard - CBS Sports61.4%64.2%59.1%64.8%53.6%51.7%49.4%
42Jamey Eisenberg - CBS Sports61.2%63.2%58.4%67.5%54.1%54.5%53.3%
43Matt Smith - NFL.com61.2%60.5%61.3%64.9%58.3%51.5%48.2%
44Mike Krueger - FFToday61.2%62.4%59.2%65.0%57.5%60.0%51.3%
45Eric Mack - SI.com60.8%59.7%58.8%67.6%61.0%56.4%55.3%
46Kevin Roberts - NFL Soup60.8%58.9%60.6%69.5%56.2%50.0%54.9%
47Ryan Lester - Lester's Legends60.7%59.6%61.0%65.4%57.2%53.3%48.2%
48Paul Greco - FantasyPros91160.7%63.2%57.5%63.4%57.6%48.0%52.2%
49Michael Beller - SI.com60.7%58.3%61.6%66.2%58.5%58.5%47.0%
50Patrick White - Fantasy Sharks60.7%61.1%58.3%65.0%59.8%50.6%51.8%
51Robb Perkins - Fantasy Football Trader60.7%60.9%59.5%63.1%59.7%54.0%49.6%
52Jason Sarney - Fantasy Phenoms60.6%60.4%58.7%67.6%57.0%26.2%42.6%
53Roger Rotter - Roger Rotter Sports60.6%59.8%58.3%67.4%60.3%50.4%45.5%
54Keet Bailey - NFL Soup60.5%60.0%61.6%64.5%53.5%53.2%51.0%
55Site Projections - scoutPRO60.3%58.8%59.1%66.2%60.5%47.5%55.3%
56Staff Rankings - Fantazzle60.0%60.4%58.4%64.4%57.4%49.8%51.8%
57Dan McQuade - SI.com60.0%59.3%58.8%66.9%56.1%46.3%56.8%
58Anthony Perri - Insider Football59.7%59.7%59.7%61.1%58.0%52.5%43.2%
59Site Projections - AccuScore59.7%58.1%60.8%65.1%54.3%54.1%53.0%
60David Sabino - SI.com58.9%59.3%57.8%62.9%54.7%48.1%48.4%
61Site Projections - ESPN58.5%58.7%59.9%62.7%48.0%N/AN/A
62Site Projections - FFToday57.9%61.1%53.9%60.8%54.1%N/A52.0%
63Staff Rankings - KFFL57.2%58.8%55.1%58.1%56.7%50.0%43.5%
64Staff Projections - FantasySharks56.2%60.8%51.9%59.0%49.5%59.6%50.5%
65Site Projections - SI.com55.6%58.2%52.4%58.5%52.2%43.8%51.8%
66Staff Projections - WhatIfSports55.1%56.9%56.8%52.7%47.6%50.9%46.5%
67Smitty - Fantasy Football Xtreme54.6%55.8%54.8%56.9%46.5%N/AN/A
PAY™ | Prediction Accuracy Yield

2010 Accuracy (Weeks 1-16)

Over one million predictions scored (view our summary)
RankExpert NameOverall*RBWRQBTEDSTK
1John Paulsen - The Fantasy Shrink61.3%62.8%59.3%62.2%60.8%60.0%N/A
2David Dodds - FootballGuys60.4%63.3%57.4%63.4%55.8%51.7%54.7%
3Andy Behrens - Yahoo60.2%61.6%58.5%63.3%56.1%59.4%46.2%
4Josh Moore - 4for4.com59.9%61.2%58.7%62.0%55.7%N/AN/A
5Site Rankings - FantasyFootballNerd59.8%63.0%55.6%62.8%57.7%56.7%50.3%
6Chet Gresham - Razzball59.7%61.4%57.8%61.0%58.2%54.2%48.7%
7Staff Composite - ESPN59.6%60.6%57.9%60.9%59.4%53.9%44.3%
8Staff Composite - Yahoo59.5%61.5%57.6%61.7%54.9%61.4%46.1%
9Site Projections - Yahoo59.4%60.0%57.2%66.7%53.3%N/AN/A
10Gregg Rosenthal - Rotoworld59.2%60.5%58.2%60.3%56.0%54.8%48.2%
11Pat Fitzmaurice - ProFootballWeekly59.1%59.3%57.8%62.4%58.4%53.9%51.8%
12Scott Pianowski - Yahoo59.1%60.5%57.4%62.4%54.8%60.8%53.6%
13Erik Kuselias - ESPN59.1%59.5%57.6%63.5%56.3%54.8%44.7%
14Site Rankings - Ultimate FF Strategy59.0%61.9%58.0%58.5%53.2%55.0%49.4%
15Eric Karabell - ESPN59.0%60.0%57.6%58.9%60.2%50.0%43.0%
16Site Projections - CBS Sports59.0%60.9%56.8%63.8%52.2%N/AN/A
17Ryan Lester - Lester's Legends58.8%60.8%56.1%60.4%58.0%57.2%43.7%
18Staff Rankings - Fantazzle58.7%59.1%57.9%61.8%55.6%51.6%46.4%
19Sigmund Bloom - FootballGuys58.6%59.9%55.8%63.8%55.2%N/AN/A
20Kevin Roberts - NFL Soup58.5%58.3%59.1%60.0%55.5%55.2%47.3%
21Jamey Eisenberg - CBS Sports58.4%59.1%57.2%60.8%56.5%52.3%46.5%
22Matthew Berry - ESPN58.4%59.7%56.2%59.4%59.0%56.5%43.6%
23Christopher Harris - ESPN58.3%58.8%57.5%59.5%56.9%51.9%44.8%
24Staff Rankings - FFToolbox58.3%59.8%56.5%61.7%53.7%52.6%47.8%
25Brandon Funston - Yahoo58.1%60.2%56.9%57.3%55.8%56.8%43.8%
26Staff Rankings - FantasyFootballCafe57.5%58.5%56.2%60.4%53.9%50.4%49.0%
27Brad Evans - Yahoo57.3%60.2%55.2%59.0%51.2%58.4%46.6%
28Sexy Rexy - Game of Inches57.3%57.6%56.6%59.9%54.5%N/AN/A
29Dave Richard - CBS Sports56.9%59.7%54.3%61.6%48.8%52.9%46.9%
30Walter Cherepinsky - Walter Football56.8%57.2%57.3%57.2%53.2%50.1%N/A
31Roger Rotter - Roger Rotter Sports56.6%56.1%55.1%59.6%58.5%51.4%47.1%
32Staff Rankings - KFFL56.6%57.9%56.0%57.4%52.5%48.0%48.7%
33Site Rankings - FanHouse56.5%57.8%53.9%60.7%53.7%54.4%45.8%
34Brad Richter - RotoPilot56.1%60.3%54.0%53.8%51.3%49.4%43.6%
35Site Projections - ESPN55.5%58.6%51.2%54.7%59.9%N/AN/A
36Mike Krueger - FFToday55.0%56.6%53.9%54.3%54.4%55.8%47.4%
37Staff Projections - WhatIfSports53.5%55.6%52.4%52.7%50.9%57.1%46.3%
38Site Projections - SI.com52.4%55.0%51.4%50.9%49.3%55.5%46.3%
39Staff Projections - FantasySharks52.1%56.5%51.5%50.5%41.2%48.7%52.3%
PAY™ | Prediction Accuracy Yield

2009 Accuracy (Weeks 1-16)

View our summary of these results
RankExpert NameOverall*RBWRQBTEDSTK
1Andy Behrens - Yahoo60.8%62.5%59.7%60.3%58.7%57.9%55.0%
2Pat Fitzmaurice - ProFootballWeekly60.7%63.4%60.2%58.3%57.5%54.4%61.2%
3Brandon Funston - Yahoo60.4%61.4%60.6%60.9%56.2%60.5%57.7%
4Gregg Rosenthal - Rotoworld60.3%60.0%60.3%60.0%61.2%54.7%54.7%
5David Dodds - FootballGuys60.2%65.2%58.0%57.3%54.6%49.1%61.1%
6Scott Pianowski - Yahoo60.0%61.4%59.1%60.2%58.1%59.8%61.1%
7Sigmund Bloom - FootballGuys59.9%64.9%58.5%56.0%52.9%N/AN/A
8Staff Composite - FantasyFootball.com59.5%61.4%58.2%58.7%58.1%49.7%60.4%
9Brad Evans - Yahoo59.2%61.5%57.6%57.1%59.2%59.0%55.3%
10R.J. White - FFCafe59.2%63.6%56.0%55.9%58.1%55.5%55.7%
11Erik Kuselias - ESPN58.9%62.6%58.1%56.7%52.2%57.8%58.2%
12Staff Rankings - FantasyFootballCafe58.8%60.9%57.0%58.1%58.2%47.3%57.1%
13Scott Engel - RotoExperts58.7%61.4%57.9%53.5%59.5%N/AN/A
14Eric Karabell - ESPN58.5%60.2%56.5%57.6%59.9%55.4%53.5%
15Christopher Harris - ESPN58.4%59.3%59.0%56.3%56.6%48.9%54.3%
16Staff Rankings - FFToolbox58.4%61.7%53.7%58.0%61.1%N/A60.9%
17Matthew Berry - ESPN58.1%61.7%56.4%56.2%53.6%58.8%52.8%
18Site Projections - CBS Sports53.7%58.5%50.7%51.3%49.9%55.4%51.9%
19Site Projections - SI.com53.7%55.00%54.6%46.5%56.9%53.1%56.5%
20Staff Rankings - KFFL53.5%57.9%53.4%49.9%47.9%50.7%49.4%
21Paul Greco - FantasyPros91153.1%55.6%49.5%53.3%54.5%55.1%52.3%
PAY™ | Prediction Accuracy Yield

2010 Draft Accuracy

Based on preseason player rankings (view our summary)
RankExpert NameOverall*RBWRQBTEDSTK
1Jamey Eisenberg - CBS Sports64.4%56.5%64.9%84.3%61.8%61.0%35.0%
2David Dodds - FootballGuys63.6%55.4%78.7%63.0%61.9%52.6%31.7%
3Pat Fitzmaurice - ProFootballWeekly62.6%57.3%63.1%75.9%59.9%58.9%N/A
4Bob Henry - FootballGuys62.2%52.9%71.1%71.4%63.9%49.4%20.2%
5Jeff Pasquino - FootballGuys61.7%57.0%67.9%55.8%80.7%58.0%42.2%
6Michael Fabiano - NFL.com61.5%61.2%59.7%61.9%67.9%N/AN/A
760.8%53.1%66.9%72.9%56.9%64.7%41.7%
8Christopher Harris - ESPN60.6%58.0%56.4%69.6%68.2%N/AN/A
9Staff Rankings - FFToolbox60.4%51.8%68.4%75.2%48.6%58.3%N/A
10Andy Behrens - Yahoo60.1%60.6%61.8%68.2%33.4%36.5%38.8%
11Staff Composite - Yahoo59.0%62.2%52.9%62.1%54.1%N/AN/A
12Paul Greco - FantasyPros91158.6%46.8%70.5%62.6%76.7%62.6%28.2%
13Sigmund Bloom - FootballGuys58.3%50.8%66.6%60.6%68.0%N/AN/A
14Anthony Borbely - FootballGuys58.0%49.1%72.0%50.9%77.7%49.0%34.6%
15Jason Wood - FootballGuys57.4%49.2%67.2%64.8%54.1%64.3%33.9%
16Brandon Funston - Yahoo57.2%54.6%61.7%59.4%52.0%30.4%46.1%
17Scott Pianowski - Yahoo57.0%55.1%62.6%57.7%47.8%32.7%37.0%
18Andrew Garda - FootballGuys56.7%46.6%61.6%66.9%74.7%N/AN/A
19Staff Composite - ESPN56.7%50.7%56.2%68.7%64.6%N/AN/A
20Mike Krueger - FFToday56.6%51.2%60.1%63.9%58.5%53.8%25.1%
21Clayton Gray - FootballGuys55.3%40.4%62.1%73.8%74.4%49.7%40.2%
22Brad Evans - Yahoo55.2%61.3%65.3%33.4%37.3%44.4%35.7%
23Jene Bramel - FootballGuys55.2%46.4%66.3%53.1%72.2%N/AN/A
24Andy Hicks - FootballGuys54.5%51.5%54.7%55.9%67.1%N/AN/A
25Staff Projections - FantasySharks54.1%46.1%49.5%76.2%63.9%62.6%38.8%
26John Norton - FootballGuys53.4%43.6%57.7%66.5%65.1%39.5%45.0%
27Maurile Tremblay - FootballGuys52.9%51.6%58.0%58.1%31.5%31.4%40.0%
28Eric Karabell - ESPN52.8%50.0%51.8%63.4%48.1%N/AN/A
29Roger Rotter - Roger Rotter Sports52.7%42.0%52.1%73.0%68.8%72.9%21.5%
30Jeff Haseley - FootballGuys52.6%51.1%52.1%57.1%52.3%50.3%32.0%
31Matthew Berry - ESPN52.2%49.4%46.0%66.0%57.0%N/AN/A
32Dave Richard - CBS Sports51.9%39.0%54.1%74.2%66.0%68.2%37.6%
33Jeff Tefertiller - FootballGuys45.5%42.6%47.2%44.0%59.5%43.3%N/A
34Mark Wimer - FootballGuys45.4%29.2%57.6%62.1%58.7%45.5%38.8%

* Overall PAY is a weighted average of QB, RB, WR and TE (DST and K scores are not included). The weights are determined by the relative importance of each position.

FAQView Accuracy FAQ