Accuracy Scores

Who Gives the Best Fantasy Football Advice?

Most Accurate Overall Experts from 2011 to 2014

31 of 197 tracked experts have accuracy scores for all 4 years
Rank Expert Name 2011 2012 2013 2014 Multi-Year
1John Paulsen
4for4.com
63.7%62.1%59.6%60.0%61.3%
2Sablich Brothers
The New York Times
63.3%62.3%60.6%58.2%61.1%
3Mike Clay
Pro Football Focus
61.6%62.3%60.8%58.8%60.9%
4Jeff Ratcliffe
Pro Football Focus
63.2%61.5%60.1%58.1%60.7%
5Scott Pianowski
Yahoo! Sports
63.7%61.0%59.0%58.6%60.6%
6Ken Zalis
Pressbox
62.8%61.8%59.0%58.5%60.5%
7David Dodds
FootballGuys
62.1%62.0%60.0%57.3%60.3%
8Kevin Hanson
EDSFootball
63.5%61.3%59.5%56.0%60.1%
9Pat Fitzmaurice
The Football Girl
62.9%61.0%58.9%57.4%60.1%
10Chet Gresham
The Fake Football
62.6%61.3%59.1%57.1%60.0%
11Site Projections
numberFire
62.6%61.2%58.0%57.5%59.8%
12Michael Fabiano
NFL.com
62.7%60.6%59.2%55.9%59.6%
13Andy Behrens
Yahoo! Sports
62.3%60.9%57.9%56.9%59.5%
14Staff Rankings
FFToolbox
62.5%61.0%58.3%55.7%59.4%
15Sigmund Bloom
FootballGuys
62.4%59.6%57.9%56.9%59.2%
16Brad Evans
Yahoo! Sports
62.0%60.5%56.9%57.3%59.2%
17Kevin Roberts
Breaking Football
60.8%61.3%58.5%55.7%59.1%
18Christopher Harris
ESPN
62.4%60.0%58.4%55.4%59.1%
19Brandon Funston
Yahoo! Sports
61.4%61.2%56.5%56.8%59.0%
20Alessandro Miglio
FootballGuys
61.4%60.5%58.0%55.7%58.9%
21Jamey Eisenberg
CBS Sports
61.2%59.5%58.0%56.8%58.9%
22Derek Lofland
Fantasy Football Maniax
62.3%59.3%57.6%55.7%58.7%
23Matthew Berry
ESPN
61.4%60.0%56.7%55.9%58.5%
24Eric Karabell
ESPN
61.9%59.5%56.3%56.0%58.4%
25Tristan Cockcroft
ESPN
62.5%59.8%56.9%54.5%58.4%
26Walter Cherepinsky
WalterFootball
62.4%59.8%54.5%56.8%58.4%
27Dave Richard
CBS Sports
61.4%59.4%57.1%54.6%58.1%
28Mike Krueger
FFToday
61.2%61.2%55.3%54.5%58.0%
29Eric Mack
Bleacher Report
60.8%56.9%57.0%56.9%57.9%
30Site Projections
scoutPRO
60.3%59.4%56.7%55.2%57.9%
31Adam Rank
NFL.com
61.7%57.5%54.6%55.3%57.3%

2014 Accuracy (Weeks 1 - 11)

Read our summary | View IDP Accuracy
Rank Expert Name Overall*QBRBWRTEKDST
1John Paulsen
4for4.com
60.0%61.4%64.2%56.6%60.9%n/an/a
2Justin Boone
The Score
59.8%62.1%62.1%58.2%60.1%64.6%54.1%
3Site Rankings
Bloomberg Sports
59.5%58.6%65.4%55.8%60.4%56.4%57.8%
4Kyle Wachtel
Forensic Fantasy
59.1%62.1%62.9%55.5%60.9%60.4%53.7%
5Jeff Brubach
The Fake Football
58.9%61.4%62.6%56.7%55.3%49.4%48.2%
6Jake Ciely
RotoExperts
58.9%60.2%60.7%58.2%58.7%65.0%54.3%
7Mike Clay
Pro Football Focus
58.8%58.8%63.5%56.2%62.2%55.6%57.6%
8Patrick Thorman
Pro Football Focus
58.8%61.5%61.9%57.8%55.9%63.5%52.7%
9Nick Raducanu
ProjectRoto
58.7%60.7%59.4%58.6%58.4%61.5%51.8%
10Scott Pianowski
Yahoo! Sports
58.6%61.4%60.4%56.6%60.3%57.0%54.3%
11Bryan Fontaine
Pro Football Focus
58.6%59.2%60.6%57.4%62.4%62.5%58.9%
12Ken Zalis
Pressbox
58.5%60.7%61.0%57.0%57.8%62.3%52.0%
13Matthew Hill
Fantasy Team Advice
58.4%59.5%61.2%56.9%58.6%n/an/a
14Sablich Brothers
The New York Times
58.2%61.4%61.3%55.1%56.0%60.6%55.0%
15Austin Lee
FootballGuys
58.2%59.7%59.3%58.7%55.5%59.6%52.7%
16Nathan Miller
Revelation Sports
58.2%61.1%61.9%57.1%51.3%57.7%57.8%
17Jeff Ratcliffe
Pro Football Focus
58.1%61.1%61.3%56.5%59.0%62.0%49.9%
18Marc Caviglia
Bruno Boys
58.1%59.3%60.1%56.5%61.3%58.7%55.1%
19Dawgmatica
Pyromaniac
58.1%56.9%62.8%57.5%55.4%n/an/a
20Brent Namejko
Fantasy Smack Talk
57.8%62.2%60.9%55.7%54.7%58.8%55.4%
FantasyPros Members get access to the full list of 129 experts and accuracy scores
Register (free) Login

2013 Accuracy (Weeks 1 - 16)

Read our summary | View IDP Accuracy
Rank Expert Name Overall*QBRBWRTEKDST
1Tozzi Brothers
Legion Report
61.1%58.7%63.1%60.8%63.6%51.0%58.0%
2Mike Clay
Pro Football Focus
60.8%58.8%63.2%60.4%62.6%51.1%49.0%
3Sablich Brothers
The New York Times
60.6%59.2%62.1%59.7%65.9%50.6%59.5%
4Jake Ciely
RotoExperts
60.6%59.2%62.8%59.8%61.8%52.6%57.8%
5Mike Tagliere
Tags Fantasy Football
60.4%58.6%62.3%59.4%64.3%n/an/a
6Kyle Wachtel
Forensic Fantasy
60.2%56.8%62.6%60.0%62.5%52.8%54.7%
7Patrick Daugherty
Rotoworld
60.2%57.4%61.1%59.7%64.2%45.1%56.4%
8Jeff Ratcliffe
Pro Football Focus
60.1%58.1%61.9%59.1%64.3%49.9%59.3%
9David Dodds
FootballGuys
60.0%58.3%61.8%59.8%61.2%52.0%58.3%
10Site Rankings
Bloomberg Sports
59.9%59.0%61.8%59.9%59.9%54.1%58.9%
11Justin Boone
The Score
59.9%58.4%60.8%60.2%61.3%52.7%60.3%
12Bryan Fontaine
Pro Football Focus
59.8%57.2%61.7%60.2%61.6%54.3%56.4%
13Adrian Pereira
eDraft
59.6%55.5%61.7%60.6%61.5%50.1%63.3%
14John Halpin
Fox Sports
59.6%58.0%60.4%59.9%63.0%51.8%57.5%
15Nick Raducanu
ProjectRoto
59.6%58.7%61.3%58.2%63.1%51.0%58.9%
16John Paulsen
4for4.com
59.6%57.4%60.7%60.1%62.6%n/an/a
17Kevin Hanson
EDSFootball
59.5%58.0%61.1%58.9%63.8%53.0%55.1%
18Tony Mauriello
ProjectRoto
59.5%58.6%59.6%60.0%62.5%52.2%54.5%
19Dalton Del Don
Yahoo! Sports
59.4%58.3%60.3%58.5%64.6%52.2%60.1%
20Brendan Donahue
EDSFootball
59.4%59.1%61.1%58.9%61.0%48.3%58.3%
FantasyPros Members get access to the full list of 124 experts and accuracy scores
Register (free) Login

2012 Accuracy (Weeks 1 - 16)

Read our summary | View IDP Accuracy
Rank Expert Name Overall*QBRBWRTEKDST
1Jody Smith
Gridiron Experts
62.6%59.6%66.1%60.9%63.4%56.5%57.4%
2Mike Clay
Pro Football Focus
62.3%62.9%66.3%60.8%58.0%51.0%55.6%
3Sablich Brothers
The New York Times
62.3%61.7%66.5%60.9%59.5%57.4%56.5%
4John Paulsen
4for4.com
62.1%62.9%65.8%60.9%57.2%n/an/a
5David Dodds
FootballGuys
62.0%61.6%65.4%60.9%58.7%59.7%60.4%
6Mike Tagliere
Tags Fantasy Football
61.9%59.4%67.2%61.3%54.7%n/an/a
7Bryan Fontaine
Pro Football Focus
61.9%63.0%65.4%60.3%57.2%60.7%56.5%
8Justin Boone
The Score
61.8%61.7%66.4%60.0%57.4%60.7%57.5%
9Ken Zalis
Pressbox
61.8%63.1%65.7%59.9%57.3%58.9%58.6%
10Muntradamus
Beast Dome
61.8%62.5%65.7%61.6%52.6%59.4%56.3%
11Eric Yeomans
Mr. 52 Pick-Up
61.6%60.6%66.6%60.5%55.5%54.2%53.5%
12Chris Wesseling
Rotoworld
61.6%60.4%65.8%60.8%55.9%52.2%59.7%
13Jeff Ratcliffe
Pro Football Focus
61.5%62.1%65.0%60.4%56.7%58.1%58.6%
14Austin Lee
FootballGuys
61.3%61.4%65.6%59.6%57.8%55.2%57.6%
15Chet Gresham
The Fake Football
61.3%61.9%64.8%60.0%58.3%53.6%57.9%
16Kevin Roberts
Breaking Football
61.3%62.5%65.4%59.9%52.2%56.9%55.1%
17Kevin Hanson
EDSFootball
61.3%61.5%64.6%60.4%56.7%56.3%52.6%
18John Halpin
Fox Sports
61.2%62.0%66.6%58.7%56.3%51.7%53.9%
19Brandon Funston
Yahoo! Sports
61.2%61.8%65.5%60.0%53.7%57.7%59.9%
20Mike Krueger
FFToday
61.2%59.7%65.2%59.7%56.4%52.6%52.0%
FantasyPros Members get access to the full list of 87 experts and accuracy scores
Register (free) Login

2011 Accuracy (Weeks 1 - 16)

Read our summary | View IDP Accuracy
Rank Expert Name Overall*QBRBWRTEKDST
1Scott Pianowski
Yahoo! Sports
63.7%69.4%64.1%61.6%60.4%56.8%56.6%
2John Paulsen
4for4.com
63.7%69.1%62.9%62.3%63.1%53.4%52.6%
3Kevin Hanson
EDSFootball
63.5%70.3%63.4%62.3%58.0%51.1%51.3%
4Josh Moore
4for4.com
63.5%68.7%63.5%62.1%60.3%n/an/a
5Sablich Brothers
The New York Times
63.3%67.3%63.8%61.5%61.5%56.5%55.3%
6Jeff Ratcliffe
Pro Football Focus
63.2%69.6%62.7%62.0%59.8%53.2%54.1%
7Staff Composite
Yahoo! Sports
63.1%68.3%62.5%61.3%62.9%57.2%56.0%
8Gregg Rosenthal
Rotoworld
63.1%68.6%61.9%61.8%62.9%55.0%56.3%
9Mike Woellert
Fake Pigskin
62.9%67.1%62.1%63.1%59.6%50.7%50.3%
10Site Rankings
Fantasy Football Nerd
62.9%66.5%62.5%62.8%59.5%52.7%51.4%
11Pat Fitzmaurice
The Football Girl
62.9%68.0%63.6%59.6%63.0%58.3%56.4%
12Staff Composite
ESPN
62.8%68.4%63.2%61.8%56.8%52.2%52.2%
13Ken Zalis
Pressbox
62.8%68.3%62.7%61.5%59.5%55.3%54.2%
14Ken Moody
Dynasty League Football
62.7%68.8%62.0%61.7%59.9%n/an/a
15Michael Fabiano
NFL.com
62.7%66.6%62.4%62.0%60.1%48.6%58.4%
16Russ Bliss
Fantasy Football Starters
62.7%66.0%63.7%60.9%59.7%52.6%54.2%
17Chet Gresham
The Fake Football
62.6%66.3%62.3%62.0%60.4%53.0%56.1%
18Site Projections
numberFire
62.6%67.9%62.8%60.6%60.4%55.3%52.5%
19Staff Rankings
FFToolbox
62.5%68.2%62.6%60.3%60.8%55.3%50.9%
20Tristan Cockcroft
ESPN
62.5%69.1%61.7%62.1%56.8%49.0%55.5%
FantasyPros Members get access to the full list of 67 experts and accuracy scores
Register (free) Login

2010 Accuracy (Weeks 1 - 16)

Read our summary
Rank Expert Name Overall*QBRBWRTEKDST
1John Paulsen
4for4.com
61.3%62.2%62.8%59.3%60.8%n/a60.0%
2David Dodds
FootballGuys
60.4%63.4%63.3%57.4%55.8%54.7%51.7%
3Andy Behrens
Yahoo! Sports
60.2%63.3%61.6%58.5%56.1%46.2%59.4%
4Josh Moore
4for4.com
59.9%62.0%61.2%58.7%55.7%n/an/a
5Site Rankings
Fantasy Football Nerd
59.8%62.8%63.0%55.6%57.7%50.3%56.7%
6Chet Gresham
The Fake Football
59.7%61.0%61.4%57.8%58.2%48.7%54.2%
7Staff Composite
ESPN
59.6%60.9%60.6%57.9%59.4%44.3%53.9%
8Staff Composite
Yahoo! Sports
59.5%61.7%61.5%57.6%54.9%46.1%61.4%
9Site Projections
Yahoo! Sports
59.4%66.7%60.0%57.2%53.3%n/an/a
10Gregg Rosenthal
Rotoworld
59.2%60.3%60.5%58.2%56.0%48.2%54.8%
11Pat Fitzmaurice
The Football Girl
59.1%62.4%59.3%57.8%58.4%51.8%53.9%
12Scott Pianowski
Yahoo! Sports
59.1%62.4%60.5%57.4%54.8%53.6%60.8%
13Erik Kuselias
ESPN
59.1%63.5%59.5%57.6%56.3%44.7%54.8%
14Site Rankings
Ultimate FF Strategy
59.0%58.5%61.9%58.0%53.2%49.4%55.0%
15Eric Karabell
ESPN
59.0%58.9%60.0%57.6%60.2%43.0%50.0%
16Site Projections
CBS Sports
59.0%63.8%60.9%56.8%52.2%n/an/a
17Ryan Lester
Lesters Legends
58.8%60.4%60.8%56.1%58.0%43.7%57.2%
18Zachary Fluewelling
Fantazzle
58.7%61.8%59.1%57.9%55.6%46.4%51.6%
19Sigmund Bloom
FootballGuys
58.6%63.8%59.9%55.8%55.2%n/an/a
20Kevin Roberts
Breaking Football
58.5%60.0%58.3%59.1%55.5%47.3%55.2%
FantasyPros Members get access to the full list of 39 experts and accuracy scores
Register (free) Login

2009 Accuracy (Weeks 1 - 16)

Read our summary
Rank Expert Name Overall*QBRBWRTEKDST
1Andy Behrens
Yahoo! Sports
60.8%60.3%62.5%59.7%58.7%55.0%57.9%
2Pat Fitzmaurice
The Football Girl
60.7%58.3%63.4%60.2%57.5%61.2%54.4%
3Brandon Funston
Yahoo! Sports
60.4%60.9%61.4%60.6%56.2%57.7%60.5%
4Gregg Rosenthal
Rotoworld
60.3%60.0%60.0%60.3%61.2%54.7%54.7%
5David Dodds
FootballGuys
60.2%57.3%65.2%58.0%54.6%61.1%49.1%
6Scott Pianowski
Yahoo! Sports
60.0%60.2%61.4%59.1%58.1%61.1%59.8%
7Sigmund Bloom
FootballGuys
59.9%56.0%64.9%58.5%52.9%n/an/a
8Staff Composite
FantasyFootball.com
59.5%58.7%61.4%58.2%58.1%60.4%49.7%
9R.J. White
Fantasy Football Cafe
59.2%55.9%63.6%56.0%58.1%55.7%55.5%
10Brad Evans
Yahoo! Sports
59.2%57.1%61.5%57.6%59.2%55.3%59.0%
11Erik Kuselias
ESPN
58.9%56.7%62.6%58.1%52.2%58.2%57.8%
12Staff Rankings
Fantasy Football Cafe
58.8%58.1%60.9%57.0%58.2%57.1%47.3%
13Scott Engel
RotoExperts
58.7%53.5%61.4%57.9%59.5%n/an/a
14Eric Karabell
ESPN
58.5%57.6%60.2%56.5%59.9%53.5%55.4%
15Staff Rankings
FFToolbox
58.4%58.0%61.7%53.7%61.1%60.9%n/a
16Christopher Harris
ESPN
58.4%56.3%59.3%59.0%56.6%54.3%48.9%
17Matthew Berry
ESPN
58.1%56.2%61.7%56.4%53.6%52.8%58.8%
18Site Projections
Sports Illustrated
53.7%46.5%55.0%54.6%56.9%56.5%53.1%
19Site Projections
CBS Sports
53.7%51.3%58.5%50.7%49.9%51.9%55.4%
20Staff Rankings
KFFL
53.5%49.9%57.9%53.4%47.9%49.4%50.7%
FantasyPros Members get access to the full list of 21 experts and accuracy scores
Register (free) Login

* Overall PAY is a weighted average of QB, RB, WR and TE (DST and K scores are not included). The weights are determined by the relative importance of each position.