Skip Navigation to Main Content

Fantasy Football Kicker Rankings & Waiver Wire Pickups (Week 6)

Fantasy Football Kicker Rankings & Waiver Wire Pickups (Week 6)

With 5 weeks in the books, I thought I would start this week’s article with a brief review of some interesting stats and surprising bust performances. To kick things off, Spencer Shrader of the Colts has 58 points through five games, putting him on pace for 197 points for the season, which would give him the most kicking points dating back to 2001.

If you have been following this column each week and took my advice a few weeks ago to add Shrader, it looks like you might have the league winner and a huge leg up on your opponents.

Will Reichard of the Vikings is on pace to shatter his personal bests in field goals made and is on pace to post a whopping 50 more fantasy points than what he posted in 2025. What has caused such a dramatic increase? Kyler Murray. The Vikings boast one of the league’s top defenses, which continues to give the offense favorable short fields and red-zone chances, but the offense ranks 24th in red-zone efficiency as Kyle Murray continues to struggle.

On the negative side, the only thing worse than my kicking puns has been the effectiveness of kickers on extra-point tries. There have already been 21 missed extra points this season, putting the league on pace for about 71 misses on the year, a 40% increase from 2025.

Another surprising negative through five weeks has been the play of Brandon Aubrey. He has just nine made field goals on 12 tries, and has two missed 60-plus tries. One of those attempts was blocked while the other sailed wide left. He is still a top 12 kicker and should be played every week, but the cheat code that fantasy managers enjoyed over the past three years has not materialized in 2026

fantasy football waiver wire planner

Fantasy Football Kicker Rankings & Waiver Wire Pickups

Let’s take a look at fantasy football Week 6 kicker rankings and waiver wire targets.

Widely Available Kickers With Strong Week 5 Performances

Chris Boswell (K – PIT) vs. Indy: 13% rostered on Yahoo

Boswell made two field goals and all four extra points to finish with 13 points and a 6th-place finish at the position. Boswell posted 13 fantasy points in his second game in three weeks, and he has a decent matchup this week on the road against a Tampa Bay team that ranks 2nd in kicker points allowed.

Dominic Zvada (K – NYG) vs Kansas City: 4% rostered on Yahoo

Adding Zvada to this list is crazy in that he finished with 12 fantasy points despite missing three field goal tries in the Giants’ bizarre tie against the Commanders. The former Michigan Wolverine could have be a top 5 play this week if he managed to make one of those three shanks.

Widely Rostered Kickers With Dud Week 5 Performances

Brandon Aubrey (K – DAL) vs Tampa Bay: 99% rostered on Yahoo

Aubrey managed just 5 fantasy points in what turned out to be a shocking home loss for the Cowboys. Everything looked primed for Aubrey to have a strong game, playing at home against a Bucs team that has given up the 2nd most points to kickers. He almost had a chance to possibly salvage an overtime kick attempt, but instead, Jake Ferguson dropped what would have been an easy first down that could have led to a game-tying touchdown. I am not advising you to move on from Aubrey, but as I mentioned in the intro, he is no longer the top kicker in fantasy to roster.

Week 6 Rankings

Rank ECR Kicker Team Matchup O/U Spread OPP RZ D RZ EFF OFF RNK Consistency Weather K-Score
1 2 Ka’imi Fairbairn HOU at JAC 42.5 2.5 2 13 13 4 2 36.5
2 5 Tyler Loop BAL at CLE 41.5 -4.5 4 28 5 3 2 37.5
3 7 Harrison Butker KC vs. LAC 42.5 -8.5 10 19 2 2 2 26.5
4 1 Spencer Shrader IND vs. TEN 44.5 -6.5 18 25 24 5 0 65.5
5 3 Cam Little JAC vs. HOU 42.5 -2.5 13 22 15 3 2 52.5
6 4 Brandon Aubrey DAL at GB 52.5 -1.5 31 31 11 2 2 75.5
7 18 Andy Borregales NE vs. NYJ 43.5 -6.5 6 15 8 2 2 26.5
8 6 Eddy Pineiro SF vs. WAS 50.5 -7.5 32 32 9 1 2 68.5
9 8 Jason Myers SEA at DEN 40.5 -2.5 11 16 17 5 2 48.5
10 13 Ryan Fitzgerald CAR at PHI 41.5 1.5 6 23 3 5 2 40.5
11 9 Chris Boswell PIT at TB 40.5 -2.5 12 11 19 2 3 44.5
12 10 Tyler Bass BUF at LV 53.5 -5.5 29 27 4 5 0 59.5
13 11 Matt Gay LV vs. BUF 53.5 5.5 27 13 14 4 0 63.5
14 12 Chase McLaughlin TB vs. PIT 40.5 2.5 6 6 22 5 3 44.5
15 14 Cairo Santos CHI at ATL 49.5 -3.5 16 1 7 2 0 22.5
16 15 Harrison Mevis LAR vs. ARI 52.5 -12.5 28 24 1 1 0 41.5
17 16 Nick Folk ATL vs. CHI 49.5 3.5 13 26 10 2 0 54.5
18 17 Dominic Zvada NYG vs. NO 45.5 1.5 20 22 21 2 2 68.5
19 19 Daniel Carlson NO at NYG 45.5 -1.5 23 30 20 2 2 75.5
20 20 Chad Ryland ARI at LAR 52.5 12.5 22 17 23 3 0 77.5
21 21 Drew Stevens WAS at SF 50.5 7.5 6 9 18 3 2 45.5
22 23 Trey Smack GB vs. DAL 52.5 1.5 24 9 16 2 2 54.5
23 24 Andre Szmyt CLE vs. BAL 41.5 4.5 15 2 29 5 2 57.5
24 25 Wil Lutz DEN vs. SEA 40.5 2.5 26 14 30 2 2 76.5
25 26 Cameron Dicker LAC at KC 42.5 8.5 5 18 25 2 2 60.5
26 27 Jason Sanders NYJ at NE 43.5 6.5 16 5 26 3 2 58.5
27 28 Joey Slye TEN at IND 44.5 6.5 18 5 32 3 0 64.5
28 22 Jake Elliott PHI vs. CAR 41.5 -1.5 25 22 31 5 2 83.5

*Red Zone Efficiency is based on the inverse of how well a kicker’s offense does in the red zone. For example, a team ranked 30th in red-zone efficiency receives an RZ EFF score of 2. The lower the number, the better for kickers, as playing on a team that struggles to score touchdowns in the red zone leads to more field-goal opportunities.

**The K Score combines several variables that can influence fantasy kicking success, including Vegas spread, opponent red-zone defense, offensive red-zone efficiency, overall offensive production, kicker consistency and weather. A lower K Score indicates that more of these variables are working in the kicker’s favor.

Kicker rankings are based on the K Score along with matchup analysis, projected game environment and other factors that can impact kicking opportunities. The K Score is intended as a guide rather than a definitive predictor, as game script and other unpredictable variables can significantly impact fantasy kicking performance.

Week 6 Upside Plays

Andy Borregales (K – NE) vs NY Jets: 5% rostered on Yahoo

The Patriots appear to have found their groove on offense, and Borregales benefited with 9 fantasy points on a whopping six extra points last week. This week, the Jets should be another solid matchup for the Pats, but look for Andy to get more than one field-goal attempt.

Ryan Fitzgerald (K – CAR) @ Philly: 1% rostered on Yahoo

Fitzgerald has yet to score fewer than 7 fantasy points in a game while posting 15 points two weeks ago against the Browns. Expect a floor of 7 this week, with a chance at 10 points on the road against the Eagles.

Week 5 Prediction Review

Trey Smack (K – GB) vs Chicago: 16% rostered on Yahoo

  • ECR Rank: K17
  • My Rank: K19
  • Week 5 Finish: T-28

I typically do not like to recommend both players playing in a game simply because that typically means one positive game script is a negative for the other. In this case, I saw two struggling offenses and positive game scripts for both Smack and Santos. The game script did work out for Smack, but he turned a game with a chance to score 13 fantasy points into a 2-point dud with two missed field goals and a missed extra point. The opportunities were there, but the execution was not.

Cairo Santos (K – CHI) @ Green Bay: 35% rostered on Yahoo

  • ECR Rank: K12
  • My Rank: K9
  • Week 5 Finish: 32

The Bears are a hard team to predict right now with Caleb Johnson out. With Santos and his K score of 38, he looked like a player who could have put up at least 8 fantasy points if the game script hadn’t skewed. Unfortunately, that is what happened, and it did not help that he missed a 45-yard kick that would have given him a respectable 5 points on the day.

Waiver Wired

Join the FantasyPros Fantasy Football Discord Server!

Subscribe: YouTube | Spotify | Apple Podcasts | iHeart | Castbox | Amazon Music | Podcast Addict | TuneIn

More Articles

Fantasy Football Playoffs Look-Ahead Stash & Priority Hold (2026)

Fantasy Football Playoffs Look-Ahead Stash & Priority Hold (2026)

fp-headshot by Josh Shepardson | 3 min read
3 Burning Questions: Fantasy Football Lineup Advice (Week 9)

3 Burning Questions: Fantasy Football Lineup Advice (Week 9)

fp-headshot by Josh Shepardson | 2 min read
6 Fantasy Football Waiver Wire Pickups & Injury Replacements (Week 9)

6 Fantasy Football Waiver Wire Pickups & Injury Replacements (Week 9)

fp-headshot by Mike Fanelli | 4 min read
3 Bold Predictions for Week 9 (2026 Fantasy Football)

3 Bold Predictions for Week 9 (2026 Fantasy Football)

fp-headshot by Josh Shepardson | 2 min read

About Author