Skip Navigation to Main Content

Fantasy Football Studs & Duds: Week 4 (2026)

Fantasy Football Studs & Duds: Week 4 (2026)

Honestly, I’m thankful that I’m in charge of writing this weekly fantasy football article, rather than my colleagues, who have to discuss the weekly apocalypse that is injuries.

Unfortunately, this weekend mirrored the last one. A multitude of touchdowns scored by irrelevant fantasy players, low-scoring games that didn’t live up to their potential, and injuries, injuries and more injuries.

Managers not only dodged players in and out of their lineups, but they also got an equally frustrating result: Players who largely underperformed for the first three weeks finally broke out (likely while riding the bench).

Marvin Harrison Jr., Brian Thomas and several other high-profile options decided to get involved — now fantasy players will need to determine if their production was a fluke or a sign of things to come.

Quarterbacks largely fell flat. Tight ends stayed quiet (outside of a few surprises). Survivor pools were decimated. Just another week around the league, folks.

fantasy football waiver wire planner

Fantasy Football Studs & Duds: Week 4

Here are some of the top fantasy football studs and duds from the week that was.

Quarterbacks

Stud: Drake Maye (QB – NE)

After three straight horrific performances to start the season, where his inability to hold onto the ball directly cost New England, Drake Maye was under the microscope heading into this weekend’s road matchup against divisional rival Buffalo. Maye put together his best performance of the season, throwing for 269 yards and three touchdowns on 22 completions and scrambling for another 54 yards on the ground.

Buffalo kept letting Maye scramble on third downs to extend drives, and their secondary couldn’t stop the duo of Hunter Henry and Romeo Doubs. He still completed fewer than 60% of his passes, but this was a nice step forward and a major confidence builder.

Stud: C.J. Stroud (QB – HOU)

It feels odd typing that Houston’s defense came up short and cost them the game, rather than their offense, yet here we are. C.J. Stroud looked comfortable in the pocket for the first time in weeks, finally having top wideout Nico Collins back on the field. He found him twice in the end zone and passed for 347 yards on 21 completions, though it ultimately came in a loss against in-state rival Dallas.

Houston is now 0-4, largely due to the Texans’ struggles to run the ball and a major step back from a formerly stout defensive squad. Stroud will look to lead Houston to their first road win of the year against Tennessee in Week 5.

Stud: Kirk Cousins (QB – LV)

In one of the most entertaining matchups this week, Las Vegas fought furiously against Kansas City but ultimately fell short, 30-27. The Raiders’ struggles to run the ball continued, as their offensive line couldn’t open up any running room for Ashton Jeanty or Mike Washington Jr.

This forced Kirk Cousins to throw early and often, resulting in 52 pass attempts — largely to their tight ends. Cousins threw for 365 yards and two touchdowns, connecting with Brock Bowers and Ian Thomas. Las Vegas nearly tied the game on their final drive, but an untimely interception with 0:10 left spelled doom for Cousins.

Currently ranked in the top 10 at the position and having thrown multiple touchdown passes in each of his first four games, the veteran has had a stellar start.

Dud: Kyler Murray (QB – MIN)

Andy Behrens had one of the quotes of the night on X, stating, “I respect T.J. Hockenson acknowledging that Kyler Murray didn’t deserve a touchdown pass today” when he opted to slide intentionally to end the game at the 1-yard line. It was ugly out there without Justin Jefferson.

Minnesota did manage to beat Miami 15-10 to improve to 4-0 on the season, but it wasn’t due to Murray. Dinking and dunking all afternoon, Murray looked for Hockenson as his 1A, 1B and 1C option to move the chains. No wide receiver saw more than six targets, and Murray was a limited threat on the ground, rushing for just 16 yards on six attempts. Hopefully Jefferson returns soon to help the team.

Dud: Matthew Stafford (QB – LAR)

Outside of the Rams’ 28-6 drubbing of the New York Giants in Week 2, the Los Angeles offense has appeared out of sorts. Rather than taking a balanced approach between the run and pass, Los Angeles ditched the ground game in the second half, attempting 52 passes on just 25 rushes.

Matthew Stafford couldn’t find open options downfield and seemed content to throw shorter checkdowns to Kyren Williams or Puka Nacua, rather than looking to Davante Adams as in prior weeks. Los Angeles pulled off a 24-20 win as Philadelphia struggled to move the ball in the second half without any of its major offensive weapons, but I’m a little concerned about how quiet this formerly dynamic offense has been lately.

Dud: Josh Allen (QB – BUF)

Is Josh Allen actually mortal? After a blistering start to the season, where Allen was looking to set the world on fire, he’s been much more average in his last two outings. Amidst a 29-26 loss, Allen threw for just 253 yards on 33 pass attempts. He salvaged his fantasy numbers by rushing for a short touchdown late in the first half, but he failed to record any explosive plays during the contest.

New England’s defense made it a priority to keep him in the pocket and not beat him with his legs, and Allen faced an uphill battle after alpha receiver DJ Moore left the game with a shoulder injury. Buffalo will face a very stingy defense on the road in Week 5 against the Los Angeles Rams — expectations should be tempered.

https://www.fantasypros.com/nfl/myplaybook/start-sit-assistant.php

Running Backs

Stud: Kyren Williams (RB – LAR)

Earlier in the season, Kyren Williams was mired in a committee situation with Blake Corum for backfield touches, so this was a positive sign for his fantasy prospects to see him dominate in Week 4. As Los Angeles mounted a furious fourth-quarter comeback, Williams barely left the field.

Williams’ receiving chops shone, and he converted a whopping 13 targets into 10 receptions for 67 yards. Williams chipped in two rushing touchdowns and finished with 26 touches on the afternoon, to Corum’s six. As noted earlier, the Rams will square off against the high-octane Bills in Week 5. Expect Williams to see plenty of touches in what should be a shootout. This should be a fun one to watch, and a possible Super Bowl preview.

Stud: Javonte Williams (RB – DAL)

This one pains me to write, since it felt like I was going against Javonte Williams in nearly every league this weekend. Williams managed a paltry 3.3 yards per carry (YPC) on 19 rushing attempts, but Dallas kept handing him the ball near the goal line, and Houston failed to adjust. As a result, Williams scored three rushing touchdowns, catapulting him into the point-scoring leaders at the position for the week.

Dallas operates a one-man backfield, with Williams only coming off when he is absolutely exhausted. Offseason reports that the Cowboys would attempt to curb his workload were apparently overblown, as he has 77 touches through the first four weeks. We’ll see if that’s sustainable.

Stud: Kyle Monangai (RB – CHI)

Running mate D’Andre Swift entered the week questionable with a knee issue and fumbled in the third quarter of Chicago’s 23-12 drubbing of New York. Riding the hot hand and emphasizing ball security, Swift sat on the bench late in favor of Kyle Monangai, who capitalized on the opportunity.

Handling a massive 30 rushing attempts, Monangai rushed for 146 yards and two touchdowns, proving to be the superior red-zone option after Swift was stuffed repeatedly earlier. Monangai is unlikely to continue doubling up Swift’s carry count, but his red-zone success versus Swift’s failures is undeniable.

Reports surfaced after the game that Monangai was removed late in the game with a thumb injury, so fantasy managers will keep their fingers crossed this doesn’t cost the stud sophomore any time.

Dud: Cam Skattebo (RB – NY)

The good news for Big Blue fans? The team is 3-1 and in first place in the NFC East, despite losing its best player for the season on both offense and defense. The bad news? The running game that the team wanted to build its foundation on has struggled in Jaxson Dart‘s absence, and YOLO-extraordinaire Jameis Winston isn’t doing the ground game any favors.

Cam Skattebo’s usage still firmly places him as an upside RB2 for fantasy purposes, but his lack of involvement in the passing game has crippled his upside. Skattebo has just one rushing touchdown through the first four games of the season, in what was supposed to be a ground-and-pound offense.

The team is surely considering a switch at quarterback given how poorly Winston has played, and Skattebo managers have to hope J.J. McCarthy eventually gets the starting job instead. McCarthy would bring a viable rushing threat under center and force defenses to stop focusing so heavily on Skattebo.

Dud: Jeremiyah Love (RB – ARI)

In what was supposed to be Jeremiyah Love’s coming-out party against a shaky New York Giants defense that bleeds yards to the position, he was bottled up and largely rendered ineffective. Backup option Tyler Allgeier actually played more snaps than Love (54% to 46%) since Arizona curiously opted to manage his workload for “maintenance reasons.”

In an interview after their loss, Love seemed visibly frustrated at his team’s decision to hold him back, even though he was productive when given the opportunity. What is even more puzzling? Arizona played from behind all afternoon, and Love finished with just one reception. Love’s up-and-down production has been maddening so far, but it is hard to fault him when the team is treating him with kid gloves.

Dud: David Montgomery (RB – HOU)

When David Montgomery was traded to the Houston Texans in the offseason, his major saving grace was supposed to be his bell-cow upside for the Texans. I guess we should pump the brakes on that assumption. With Houston’s offense mired in reverse and struggling to score, the team hasn’t been able to play from ahead, significantly reducing Montgomery’s touches.

Even when afforded opportunities out of the backfield, Montgomery hasn’t exactly capitalized on them either — on 47 rushes, he has generated a meager 127 yards. With losses mounting and the team sitting at 0-4 on the year, it raises the question of whether the Texans are considering a switch in the backfield to Woody Marks, who has been much more dynamic. Montgomery has a get-right game upcoming against Tennessee — he needs to seize control.

Expert Consensus Rankings Featured Tool

Wide Receivers

Stud: Tetairoa McMillan (WR – CAR)

Just when I thought “there is no possible way that anyone is going to unseat CeeDee Lamb as the WR1 this week” after Sunday afternoon, the night game hit. Tetairoa McMillan torched an inept Detroit secondary for 14 receptions and 192 yards, scoring two critical touchdowns to preserve Carolina’s 32-26 victory.

The massive outing propelled McMillan to the WR5 spot on the season and bodes well for his long-term outlook. The variable fantasy managers will need to consider is Jalen Coker‘s absence, as he had outscored McMillan before his quadriceps injury flared up. The Panthers pack a tremendous punch with their 1-2 duo, and they will head into a bye during Week 5 to rest and recover.

Stud: Tyquan Thornton (WR – KC)

Other players had bigger statistical weeks, but I did want to give a shout-out to Tyquan Thornton, since I’m not sure when we’ll see him take the field again. The Chiefs’ main downfield threat to start the season, Thornton converted eight targets into five receptions for 111 yards and two touchdowns and barely missed his third.

On a 55-yard catch in the fourth quarter, a Raiders defender tackled him awkwardly, rolling him up and dislocating his ankle. What made matters more gruesome was when he tried to stand on his injured leg, not realizing that he was injured. Carted off the field, Thornton had his ankle put back in place and (somehow) flew back with the Chiefs later that day. He’s still facing an extended absence, and rumors have begun to swirl about Kansas City reuniting with Tyreek Hill.

Stud: CeeDee Lamb (WR – DAL)

You’d think that once a receiver catches double-digit passes from his team, you might want to shade additional coverage his way. Houston apparently disagrees with that notion. On a career day, CeeDee Lamb single-handedly carried the Dallas passing offense, catching 17 passes on an absurd 21 targets for 189 yards and a touchdown, the eventual score that would keep the Cowboys on top for good with 40 seconds left on the clock.

This marks the third consecutive week that Lamb has passed the century mark, and he has clearly separated himself as the alpha option over George Pickens in this Cowboys offense. Currently ranked as the WR2 in fantasy this season, Lamb will face a tougher Buccaneers defense in Week 5, which ranks in the top 10 for fewest passing yards allowed per game.

Dud: Garrett Wilson (WR – NYJ)

After New York’s 23-12 drubbing by Chicago, Garrett Wilson was asked how he was feeling physically as the team began preparing for a Week 5 home matchup against Cleveland. “I feel good; I didn’t take any hits,” he replied. I suppose it’s hard to take a hit when you aren’t the one throwing the ball.

Targeted just four times during the game, Wilson (along with the rest of the Jets’ receiving threats) was a virtual non-factor in this contest, with Geno Smith completing only eight passes all afternoon. With the Bears dominating time of possession (over 42 minutes for Chicago and barely 17 for New York), this offense simply wasn’t on the field enough to get Wilson involved much.

The team will look for a bounce-back effort against the Browns, where Wilson will certainly top the ugly 3/27 line he posted on Sunday.

Dud: Parker Washington (WR – JAX)

Cincinnati’s defense made it a priority to stop Parker Washington on Sunday, limiting him to just one reception for seven yards on three targets from Trevor Lawrence. Truth be told, the Jaguars’ passing offense was a non-factor for most of the game, as the team leaned on running backs Bhayshul Tuten and Chris Rodriguez Jr. to shoulder the heavy lifting.

Tight end Brenton Strange was the only player to see more than four targets, and no one else on the team surpassed 45 receiving yards. Jacksonville is surely happy to come away with a victory regardless, and I’ll chalk this poor outing up more to game script than anything else. Before this outing, Washington had surpassed 13 PPR points in each of his first three games, and we expected his breakout season to continue.

Dud: Christian Watson (WR – GB)

Like Washington above, Christian Watson fell victim to bad circumstances rather than poor play. With Green Bay squaring off against a rookie quarterback who looked like a deer in the headlights for most of the afternoon, the game plan was to dominate time of possession rather than trade body blows in a back-and-forth effort.

Quarterback Jordan Love completed just 22 passes all game and spread the ball to his tertiary options rather than focusing on Watson and Matthew Golden, as in prior weeks. Watson “led” the team with 47 receiving yards on three receptions, catching all of his targets on the afternoon. Green Bay will face stiffer competition in Week 5 against Chicago, where they will certainly need to put up more than 17 points — look for Watson to rebound strongly against a weak secondary.

Free trial

Tight Ends

Stud: T.J. Hockenson (TE – MIN)

Apparently this was a “turn back the clock” week for T.J. Hockenson, who emerged as the clear-cut favorite passing target for Kyler Murray, in the absence of wideout Justin Jefferson. Hockenson reeled in all 13 of his targets on the afternoon for 119 yards, eclipsing the century mark for the first time since 2024.

If Jefferson continues to miss time, Hockenson could be in store for another epic performance on the road against New Orleans in Week 5 — fantasy managers will need to keep an eye on practice reports. Hockenson’s big performance thrust him back into the top 10 at the position. For the time being, he can be treated as a reliable starter with moderate upside on a team that will need to throw the ball around to stay competitive.

Studs: Brock Bowers (TE – LV) & Michael Mayer (TE – LV)

I wanted to highlight this duo for the Raiders, since I don’t view their performances as fluky. With Brock Bowers functioning as an oversized wideout (and running their routes), Michael Mayer has been left for more of the “traditional” role in the offense, being asked to block occasionally and used as a seam-stretching threat down the middle of the field when necessary.

Bowers (6/86/1) and Mayer (8/82) were the only players on Las Vegas to see double-digit targets, as the team relied on them and running back Ashton Jeanty to move the sticks. This script has been working for the team thus far, since the Raiders boast a 3-1 record and had a shot of sending this game to overtime on Sunday.

With Kirk Cousins playing at a high level, the Raiders should continue to operate as-is, allowing both Bowers and Mayer to be starters in most standard-sized leagues.

Dud: Travis Kelce (TE – KC)

After a hot start to his season, Travis Kelce disappeared back into the shadows on Sunday, catching just two passes on three targets for 15 yards. I doubt he will complain much since Kansas City came away with the win, and the team will send more opportunities his way in the coming weeks, given the injuries to wideouts Tyquan Thornton and Rashee Rice.

The 37-year-old will have a chance to recover with a Week 5 bye before returning to action at home in Week 6 against the winless Los Angeles Chargers. Kelce will occasionally go through dry spells, but managers should never forget he’s Patrick Mahomes‘ go-to option when needed.

Dud: Dalton Kincaid (TE – BUF)

After the first two weeks of the season, it looked like Dalton Kincaid was on track for a true breakout, but he’s been dead quiet since. Amid a 29-26 loss to New England, Kincaid was targeted only twice, which was surprising given the injury woes the Patriots came into the game with. The passing offense flowed through receivers Keon Coleman (6/116/1) and Khalil Shakir (7/82), as Buffalo simply appeared out of sorts all afternoon.

Whether the team took this game for granted or not is anyone’s best guess, but the Bills appeared completely unprepared on offense and were largely stuck in neutral all day. Most tight ends are susceptible to blips on the radar like this during the season, and we are keeping our fingers crossed that Kincaid can rebound for a better effort in Week 5 against the Los Angeles Rams.

FantasyPros Fantasy Football Discord: An Exclusive Community for Premium Subscribers

Subscribe: YouTube | Spotify | Apple Podcasts | iHeart | Castbox | Amazon Music | Podcast Addict | TuneIn

More Articles

The Primer: Week 10 Edition (2026 Fantasy Football)

The Primer: Week 10 Edition (2026 Fantasy Football)

fp-headshot by Derek Brown | 15+ min read
Fantasy Football Week 10 Start/Sit Advice: 21 Sleepers & Busts (2026)

Fantasy Football Week 10 Start/Sit Advice: 21 Sleepers & Busts (2026)

fp-headshot by FantasyPros Staff | 8 min read
NFL DFS Lineup Advice: Picks & Predictions (Week 10)

NFL DFS Lineup Advice: Picks & Predictions (Week 10)

fp-headshot by Josh Shepardson | 7 min read
Fantasy Football Start/Sit Lineup Advice: Tight Ends (Week 10)

Fantasy Football Start/Sit Lineup Advice: Tight Ends (Week 10)

fp-headshot by FantasyPros Staff | 3 min read

About Author