Welcome back to this week’s fantasy football trade advice. In this weekly series, I dive into my top buys, sells and holds from a redraft perspective, based on my rest-of-season rankings versus FantasyPros’ expert consensus rankings (ECR). I’ll lay out my case for each player recommendation and do my best to help you bring home the hardware this season.
Quick disclosure: The rankings I’ll be referencing are based on half-PPR scoring. If you play in a standard or full PPR league, keep that in mind before making any final decisions.
- Waiver Wire Advice
- Weekly Fantasy Football Expert Rankings
- Fantasy Football Start/Sit Advice
- Fantasy Football Trade Analyzer
Fantasy Football Trade Advice: Week 5
Here are players to buy, sell, or hold ahead of Week 5.
Fantasy Football Players to Buy
Malik Nabers (WR – NYG)
Don’t look now, but the New York Giants lead the NFC East. I’m not sure if they can keep this up with Jameis Winston and J.J. McCarthy atop the quarterback depth chart, but stranger things have happened.
Here’s the thing: Malik Nabers is not back to full health yet. He’s near the bottom of the league in separation score this season and is sitting behind Isaiah Likely in target share.
With every passing week, Nabers should be inching closer to his old self. If we can get about 90% of the rookie version of Nabers, he’ll be in line to smash his ECR’s WR17 ranking.
Tee Higgins (WR – CIN)
Tee Higgins has been dominant at the start of this season, and nobody seems to care. He’s posted three straight 90-yard games and is sitting with a 25% target share in a very pass-happy environment.
With Andrei Iosivas on injured reserve (IR), the Bengals have no clear No. 3 WR. The only options behind Ja’Marr Chase and Higgins are former CFL star Dohnte Meyers, undrafted free agent (UDFA) Mitchell Tinsley and Day 3 rookie Colbie Young.
With Higgins nursing an adductor strain, he may miss Week 5, but he should be in a great spot long term. I have Higgins as my WR14, well ahead of his WR18 ECR ranking.
Michael Wilson (WR – ARI)
Last week, I listed Michael Wilson as a “hold” and advised you to wait to see whether his elite target volume would stick. Well, it did in Week 4, as Wilson racked up another 13 targets. He now has 30 targets over the past two weeks, and it’s pretty clear this is the same version of Wilson we got in the latter half of 2025.
I wouldn’t be surprised if Marvin Harrison Jr. got moved before the trade deadline, but it doesn’t even matter. Wilson is the clear number two option (behind Trey McBride) on a team that loves to air it out. Buy high on Wilson, his WR28 price tag is still far too low.
Cam Skattebo (RB – NYG)
Cam Skattebo is getting nearly every touch in this backfield, with 46 more touches this season than Najee Harris, the Giants’ No. 2 RB. We haven’t seen much touchdown luck yet, and that total will likely remain relatively low in this offense.
Even so, Skattebo is averaging 19 touches per game. As I mentioned with Quinshon Judkins last week, I’ll bet on the volume at these prices. Skattebo is a mid RB2, according to ECR, making him a relatively cheap every-week starter.
Jalen Coker (WR – CAR)
Fresh off Tetairoa McMillan‘s legacy game and Jalen Coker‘s second straight game on the sidelines, people may be experiencing recency bias. Make no mistake: McMillan is the No. 1 WR in this offense, and he’s Carolina’s most talented receiver by a healthy margin. But Coker is the clear No. 2 WR, and this passing attack is one everyone should want to invest in. (Who would’ve thought?)
Through three games, Coker is boasting a 24.2% target rate and 2.44 yards per route run (YPRR), both excellent marks that confirm he’s a key part of this offense. While we shouldn’t expect any 192-yard, two-touchdown performances from Coker like the one we saw from McMillan this past weekend, he should be a must-start once he’s back and healthy. With an ECR ranking of WR36, buy Coker all day long.
Carnell Tate (WR – TEN)
Carnell Tate showed the world why he was the fourth overall pick in the 2026 NFL Draft, hauling in nine of his 12 targets for 145 yards this past weekend. He’s rocking a 30% target share this season, well ahead of No. 2 WR Wan’Dale Robinson.
While this offense certainly has its limitations, I’m interested in Tate as a young ascending asset who should continue trending upward as the season progresses. He’s moved up to my WR27 overall, well ahead of ECR’s WR38 ranking.
Quinshon Judkins (RB – CLE)
Quinshon Judkins was on my “buy” list last week and paid off nicely, posting 18.6 half-PPR points in Week 4. The efficiency still wasn’t there, and maybe that never comes, but it also may not matter with the volume he’s receiving. It’s been great to see his role expand in the receiving game as well, catching six balls this past weekend.
Quinshon didn’t climb ECR ranks much following this big game, so he remains a great value on paper. Judkins currently ranks as my RB18 in redraft, just ahead of Chuba Hubbard and Bucky Irving.
Travis Kelce (TE – KC)
Travis Kelce did not help your fantasy lineup in Week 4, posting a measly 2.5 half-PPR points in what turned out to be a pretty high-scoring game against Las Vegas. I’m still very bullish, considering he’s posted a 70% snap rate or higher in every game this year and is running nearly every route for the Chiefs.
We also saw Rashee Rice go down with a hamstring injury in Week 4, and Tyquan Thornton suffer a dislocated ankle. While Rice could avoid missing any time due to Kansas City’s bye this week, Thornton is one fewer receiving weapon to take targets away from Kelce.
Xavier Worthy (WR – KC)
Speaking of pass-catchers in line for a bigger role, Xavier Worthy may be relied on more heavily with Tyquan Thornton likely out for the remainder of the regular season.
Per route, Worthy has been quite pedestrian, posting a 17.3% target rate and 1.05 YPRR through four games. But he’s been running every route, and he may be asked to step into Thornton’s downfield role (if Andy Reid trusts him to do so).
He’s not a lock to pan out, but with an ECR ranking of WR51, Worthy should be dirt cheap to acquire. Stash him on your bench for now and see if his role expands as the season rolls on.
Keaton Mitchell (RB – LAC)
There’s a good chance Keaton Mitchell is still sitting on waivers, with only a 36% rostership rate on Sleeper. Mitchell has seen an uptick in carries over the first four weeks and is quickly becoming the receiving back for Los Angeles. He’s highly explosive and has made the most of his nine touches per game thus far.
If you’re dealing with injuries or bye weeks and have a thin running back room, Mitchell is a legitimate option as a spot start. And if Omarion Hampton ever were to go down with an injury, Mitchell would be a borderline every-week starter in fantasy. I’m well ahead of the consensus with this one, with Mitchell ranked as RB31 overall.
Fantasy Football Players to Sell
Chase Brown (RB – CIN)
Chase Brown simply isn’t dynamic enough as a rusher to justify his RB9 price tag. He’s averaging 3.6 yards per attempt (YPA), 2.6 yards after contact per attempt (YCO/A) and hasn’t posted a single breakaway run this season.
If Brown continues to have 11-target games as he did in Week 4, he can hit from a fantasy perspective, but I doubt that kind of receiving volume is remotely sustainable. That was mostly a product of Ja’Marr Chase leaving due to injury.
D’Andre Swift (RB – CHI)
Week 4 was a tough one to swallow for D’Andre Swift managers, as Kyle Monangai toted the rock a whopping 30 times and found the end zone twice. This won’t be the case going forward; Chicago was in a weird game script where they controlled the entire game and the Jets never really had the football.
Still, Swift’s ECR ranking of RB13 is a bit too rich for me. He’s a fine back and as consistent as they come, but Swift has never finished that high positionally in his six NFL seasons.
Saquon Barkley (RB – PHI)
Another game, another injury for Saquon Barkley. He’s likely to be sidelined for at least one game, so if you want to hold onto Barkley until he returns to maximize your return, I get it.
Personally, I’m about done with the Barkley experience. If you’re in the bottom half of your standings through four weeks, don’t be afraid to sell him now and get some actual points on your roster. The name value alone should net you a respectable return.
DeVonta Smith (WR – PHI)
Why is DeVonta Smith still valued as a top-12 wide receiver in redraft? He’s likely to miss at least one more week of football, and even when he returns, I have some serious questions about this offense.
The passing volume simply isn’t there with Jalen Hurts under center; Smith would need to post some otherworldly per-route efficiency numbers to even sniff a top-12 wide receiver finish this season. Count me out.
Bucky Irving (RB – TB)
I’ve been a Bucky Irving truther since his days at Oregon. He’s a twitchy, explosive back who plays bigger than his listed size and came into the NFL with an elite receiving profile. Unfortunately, I just don’t think this is going to be his year; at least not with Jalon Daniels under center.
This Tampa Bay offense is in shambles, and I’m not sure all their problems will magically be solved when Baker Mayfield finally returns. Maybe their successes ended when Liam Coen walked out the door.
Either way, with an ECR ranking of RB17, you can still get a nice return for Irving. I’d try to sell him for Quinshon Judkins or Chuba Hubbard. If you have running back depth, you can try sending him to a running back-needy team for Matthew Golden or Michael Wilson.
Rashee Rice (WR – KC)
The good news for Rashee Rice? His Week 4 hamstring injury wasn’t as serious as they initially thought, and with a bye week upcoming, he may not miss any time. The bad news? He’s just not that good anymore. Rice has clearly lost a step (or three) following a clean-up procedure on his right knee this offseason.
The primary issue is that the Chiefs aren’t giving Rice as many manufactured looks around the line of scrimmage, preventing him from being the PPR scam he once was. With an ECR ranking of WR23, I’d frantically look to sell. Give me players like Michael Wilson, Luther Burden III, Josh Downs or Terry McLaurin over Rice rest-of-season.
Patrick Mahomes (QB – KC)
Patrick Mahomes is one of the greatest ever to spin it; there’s no denying that. However, his ECR ranking of 51st overall in single-quarterback leagues feels a bit aggressive.
With Tyquan Thornton out and Rashee Rice banged up, Mahomes is quickly running out of reliable receiving weapons. Luckily, they have their shiny new toy in Kenneth Walker III, who can help jump-start the ground game and keep defenses honest. Still, these feel almost like prime-Mahomes prices. I can’t stomach that.
Rome Odunze (WR – CHI)
Can you believe it? We finally got a usable fantasy week from Rome Odunze. With Tyson Bagent calling the shots, Odunze grabbed six receptions for 94 yards, recording 12.4 half-PPR points.
That’s our opportunity to sell. There are still Odunze bulls out there, given his mid-WR3 price tag. I think he is likely the third receiving option on this team for the long term (behind Luther Burden III and Coleston Loveland). I prefer not to deal with the volatility. I’d sell for any of the players mentioned in Rashee Rice‘s section, and would even part ways for someone like DK Metcalf or Denzel Boston.
David Montgomery (RB – HOU)
David Montgomery has been horrendous this season. We’re looking at just 2.7 YPA, 2.26 yards after contact per attempt (YCO/A) and only seven receptions in four games. As mentioned last week, Woody Marks hasn’t been much better analytically, and the blame shouldn’t be solely placed on them. The Texans’ offensive line is flat-out bad.
But these are all reasons I’m selling Montgomery. It’s a “touchdown or bust” situation for him this year, and it seems more bust than touchdown. I’d gladly sell Montgomery for Quinshon Judkins or TreVeyon Henderson, and would even consider selling him for Aaron Jones or Rhamondre Stevenson.
Kyle Monangai (RB – CHI)
What a week for Kyle Monangai. As we mentioned in the D’Andre Swift portion of this article, Monangai was a workhorse on the ground in Week 4, amassing 28 half-PPR points. Unfortunately, he was probably benched by 90% of fantasy managers, and that’s honestly where he should stay.
Realistically, you can’t feel good about playing Monangai, barring a Swift injury; at least not until we get a much larger sample size of him outproducing Swift on the ground. Personally, I’d be fine shopping him around after this monster game. See if you can sell him for RJ Harvey, whose receiving role gives him a very safe fantasy floor.
Fantasy Football Players to Hold
Ashton Jeanty (RB – LV)
Outside of Week 1, Ashton Jeanty has been fairly uninspiring this season. Those hoping the Boise State prospect would jump into the Bijan Robinson/Jahmyr Gibbs tier have been let down thus far, with Jeanty averaging just 3.4 YPA and failing to find the end zone on the ground through four games.
Mike Washington Jr. also earned a season-high nine rush attempts against the Chiefs in Week 4. I’m slightly worried about Jeanty, but I’m far from panicking. He’s still the three-down workhorse, and his receiving role provides a solid fantasy floor. Hold Jeanty for now and wait for better days ahead.
George Pickens (WR – DAL)
What a brutal runout for George Pickens owners. In a game where Dak Prescott threw it 45 times, he earned only three targets. It was CeeDee Lamb who dominated through the air, hauling in a career-high 17 receptions for 189 yards and a touchdown.
I understand Pickens was your second- or third-round pick, and you’re probably tilted, given the lack of production through four weeks. But I urge you not to sell low now. The spike weeks are coming, and soon.
Pickens had five weeks with 130+ receiving yards in 2025, and scored a touchdown in eight different games. He may not finish with 1,400 yards as he did last season, but Pickens is still a must-start.
Chuba Hubbard (RB – CAR)
The market is slightly ahead of me on Chuba Hubbard, with an ECR ranking of RB17. He’s too expensive to recommend buying, but I’m not selling as either. He’s simply on too much of a heater, seeing 39 rush attempts over the past two weeks. While I’m not a big believer from a real-life perspective, Hubbard has virtually no competition to deal with, and this offense is humming.
Maybe things get a bit more muddled if and when Jonathon Brooks returns from IR, but I’m not counting on it. He’s had one too many injuries to trust he’ll ever carve out a legitimate NFL workload.
TreVeyon Henderson (RB – NE)
Another week, another bummer performance from TreVeyon Henderson. Despite earning 14 carries and two targets, Henderson managed only 4.7 fantasy points. The reality is that he’s not startable until further notice.
The good news? Drake Maye finally looked competent, as did this New England offense as a whole. We just have to wait for Rhamondre Stevenson to fumble a couple of more times, and we may be in line for some big weeks from Henderson.
In two games last season in which Henderson saw an 80% or higher snap share, he averaged 27 half-PPR points per game. That kind of ceiling is worth holding onto.
Parker Washington (WR – JAX)
Maybe the most disappointing Week 4 performance was Parker Washington, finishing with just one reception for seven yards. I jammed him into nearly all my DFS lineups, thinking the WR1 in the slate’s highest game total would surely post monster numbers. Boy was I wrong.
It was a weird game, with Trevor Lawrence throwing for just 227 yards and one touchdown. Ultimately, I’m willing to write this game off, but I’ll admit we may have been a bit too ambitious with our Washington projections.
Lawrence has a ton of mouths to feed, and this won’t be the last frustrating game we get from a fantasy lens. I’m holding Washington for now and continuing to start him, while tempering expectations a hair.
Jaylen Waddle (WR – DEN)
Ugh. Watching Bo Nix play football is one of my least favorite activities. This Denver offense looks anemic for three-plus quarters every week, and occasionally turns it on late in the fourth.
Jaylen Waddle has disappointed fantasy owners despite being the clear No. 1 WR, failing to hit 40 receiving yards in three out of four games. Luckily, he found the end zone in Week 4, so he didn’t actively hurt your lineup.
I’m not selling as a Waddle owner right now. With all the negativity surrounding this offense, he wouldn’t demand a big return, so I’d prefer to hold my shares and wait for a blow-up game. Waddle’s rest-of-season schedule is not ideal, so when you do get that spike week, I wouldn’t be against selling.
Makai Lemon (WE – PHI)
I was praying for a Makai Lemon breakout in Week 4 with DeVonta Smith sidelined. Unfortunately, that was never going to happen with Jalen Hurts throwing for 93 total yards on the afternoon.
While Lemon hasn’t found his footing quite yet, I wouldn’t drop him or sell low right now. He’s had four or more targets in three games this season and was a first-round selection in the 2026 NFL Draft. These are the kind of assets you kick yourself for dropping when they ramp up late in the season.
Joe Burrow (QB – CIN)
Joe Burrow technically hit from a fantasy perspective against the Jaguars, despite not playing tremendously well in real life. He got there on volume, throwing the ball 54 times and scoring once on the ground. Sadly, both Ja’Marr Chase and Tee Higgins got hurt in this game and are questionable for Week 5.
Now is not the time to sell Burrow. With the injury news and limited wide receiver depth, buyers will want a significant discount. I’d continue holding for now; there’s some risk involved, but Burrow still has top-three upside at the position.
Dalton Kincaid (TE – BUF)
After a hot start to the season, Dalton Kincaid has come back down to earth. He’s averaging 1.5 half-PPR points per game over the past two weeks, earning only five total targets during that span. Even worse, Kincaid saw just a 59% snap rate in Week 4.
I’ve dropped Kincaid from my TE3 to TE5, so while I’ve tempered expectations, I’m still very bullish on his rest-of-season projections. At the end of the day, Kincaid remains highly efficient on a per-route basis and can be the top pass-catcher in a Josh Allen offense in any given week.
Colston Loveland (TE – CHI)
Colston Loveland‘s production continues to trend in the right direction. He posted a season-best nine targets, six receptions, and 57 yards against the Jets this weekend, playing 92% of the snaps.
As I alluded to in Rome Odunze‘s section, this receiving room will be volatile all season, so I wouldn’t classify Loveland as a must-start every week. But as I mentioned in last week’s edition, you likely spent some early draft capital to acquire Loveland this season, so there’s no reason to sell low now. Just wait and hope the momentum continues into the middle part of the season.
Thanks for taking the time to check out this week’s article. If you have any redraft, dynasty, devy or C2C-related questions, I can be reached on X @jim_DFF.
Subscribe: YouTube | Spotify | Apple Podcasts | iHeart | Castbox | Amazon Music | Podcast Addict | TuneIn



