Skip Navigation to Main Content

Top 5 Fantasy Football Takeaways: Surprises & Disappointments

Top 5 Fantasy Football Takeaways: Surprises & Disappointments

Week 5 included surprises, both positive and negative. A couple of running backs either entered or solidified their spots in the fantasy football RB2 mix, and a second straight explosion from a young quarterback got them back in the circle of trust. On the negative side, a coaching change didn’t spark fantasy fireworks for a struggling offense, and a first-round running back was bottled up.

Free trial

Top 5 Fantasy Football Takeaways

Let’s dive into the biggest takeaways from Week 5.

Fantasy Football Week 5 Surprises

Ollie Gordon II Had a Fantasy-Friendly Role

Ollie Gordon II handled 18 of Miami’s 25 backfield rushing attempts (72%), rumbling for a team-high 88 yards and a touchdown. Malik Washington also carried the ball once for 18 yards, and he’s a unique talent, so it’s noteworthy. According to Nathan Jahnke and Pro Football Focus (PFF), Gordon played 43 snaps and ran 20 routes. Carlos Washington played nine snaps and ran eight routes, and Jaylen Wright played nine snaps and ran one route. None of the running backs were targeted, not entirely surprising since Malik Willis is mobile and ran eight times.

According to the Fantasy Points Data Suite, Gordon had a 59.9% snap share and 40% route participation rate, and Wright was the only other running back involved, with a 29.7% snap share and a 15% route participation rate. Per PFF, Gordon played six out of eight snaps at the goal line, 10 out of 17 in the two-minute drill and seven of eight on third downs. Ultimately, Gordon has a robust role, and he’s rattled off 188 rushing yards and two rushing touchdowns in the last two games. Gordon is firmly in the RB2 mix during bye weeks, even attached to a lousy offense.

Drake Maye is Truly Back

Drake Maye was tied with Drew Lock for the QB23 in Week 1, scoring only 12.8 fantasy points. He was the QB25 (9.0 fantasy points) in Week 2 and the QB32 (5.8 fantasy points) in Week 3. Through the first three weeks, Maye was the QB35 in points per game (9.2).

Maye flipped the switch in Week 4, finishing as the QB1 in a win in Buffalo against the then-unbeaten Bills, piling up 27.2 fantasy points. Entering Monday Night Football, Maye is the QB1 in Week 5, lighting up the Raiders for 39.5 fantasy points.

Maye has completed 48-of-71 pass attempts (67.6%) for 643 yards, seven passing touchdowns and one interception in the last two weeks. He has taken precisely one sack in back-to-back games and lost a fumble, but he also ran for 79 yards and a touchdown. Maye has officially ended his playoff and early-season skid, and he’s a set-it-and-forget-it QB1 for now.

MarShawn Lloyd Might Be Semi-Useful

MarShawn Lloyd led Green Bay’s backfield in carries (10) and rushing yards (31). No one is jumping for joy for 3.1 yards per carry, but Lloyd punched in two rushing touchdowns and added a six-yard reception on two targets.

Usually, I would caution against getting enamored with touchdowns. However, as Nathan Jahnke pointed out, Lloyd played 51.9% of Green Bay’s snaps before garbage time. Pierre Strong stepped up as the preferred third-down back (seven snaps versus two for Lloyd) and ran more routes (16 compared to 10 for Lloyd). Still, Lloyd was the lead runner and ran enough routes to add something through the air.

Perhaps most importantly, the Packers hung 31 points and 428 yards of offense on the Bears, with Jordan Love taking only two sacks. If the work-in-progress offensive line can keep Love upright, the offense can light up the scoreboard and give Lloyd touchdown equity. The running back position is a wasteland. Lloyd is a defensible low-end RB2.

https://www.fantasypros.com/nfl/myplaybook/start-sit-assistant.php

Fantasy Football Week 5 Disappointments

Sean Payton Didn’t Save Bo Nix

DeMeco Ryans conveniently took over calling the defense for the Texans in a Week 5 matchup against Cam Ward and the Titans after a run of games that included Josh Allen, Joe Burrow and Dak Prescott. The Texans stuffed the Titans in a locker, holding them to three points.

Sean Payton might have thought he was sly, too, taking play-calling duties back from offensive coordinator Davis Webb in time for a matchup against the winless Chargers. So much for Payton looking like a hero for Bo Nix and Denver’s offense.

The Broncos produced only 224 yards of offense, 3.9 yards per play and 23 points. Nix logged a pitiful 123 passing yards at 4.6 yards per pass attempt. Denver is 3-2, but the offense is still a roaring dumpster fire.

Nix has cleared 200 passing yards only twice, and he bested 225 yards only once this season. Nix has also thrown multiple touchdown passes only once, tossing two against the Rams at home in Week 3.

Jaylen Waddle caught two of his five targets for 19 scoreless yards and added a nine-yard run. Courtland Sutton salvaged his day with a touchdown reception, adding to two catches for 18 yards. Waddle isn’t a no-brainer starter, but probably remains in the WR3 mix in 12-team leagues for most managers during bye weeks. Sutton is a touchdown-or-bust FLEX. J.K. Dobbins had 18 carries for 68 yards and a touchdown, but he’s only a touchdown-or-bust RB2.

The Broncos are a fantasy wasteland. Nix has played so poorly I can’t even advocate kicking the tires on Waddle as a buy-low player. Instead, he’s a hold, and managers can pray to the fantasy football gods that Payton gets Nix back on track.

Jonathan Taylor Had an Underwhelming Sunday

I highlighted Jonathan Taylor as a sell-high player. As I noted in that piece, according to the Fantasy Points Data Suite, Taylor has averaged four yards per carry and 18.2 half–PPR points per game in four games without Alec Pierce since 2025, a far cry from his 4.9 yards per carry and 20.58 half-PPR points per game in 17 games with Pierce.

Taylor is also much better in wins than losses, scoring 25.1 half-PPR points per game in 16 wins since 2024 and only 13.5 half-PPR points per game in 19 losses before Sunday.

Taylor tallied 82 scoreless scrimmage yards on 15 carries and three receptions against the Steelers. It wasn’t a disaster, and he has a bit more of a receiving backbone now than he did for most of his career. Nevertheless, Daniel Jones hasn’t replicated his play from early last season, and Taylor will have a difficult time living up to expectations as a first-round pick unless the offense turns things around.

Obviously, gamers should bench or give Taylor away. That said, it wouldn’t hurt to put feelers out and see what you can get for him if Taylor is on your roster.

touchdown contest

Josh Shepardson is a featured writer at FantasyPros. For more from Josh, check out his archive and follow him @BChad50.

More Articles

Fantasy Football Playoffs Look-Ahead Stash & Priority Hold (2026)

Fantasy Football Playoffs Look-Ahead Stash & Priority Hold (2026)

fp-headshot by Josh Shepardson | 3 min read
3 Burning Questions: Fantasy Football Lineup Advice (Week 9)

3 Burning Questions: Fantasy Football Lineup Advice (Week 9)

fp-headshot by Josh Shepardson | 2 min read
6 Fantasy Football Waiver Wire Pickups & Injury Replacements (Week 9)

6 Fantasy Football Waiver Wire Pickups & Injury Replacements (Week 9)

fp-headshot by Mike Fanelli | 4 min read
3 Bold Predictions for Week 9 (2026 Fantasy Football)

3 Bold Predictions for Week 9 (2026 Fantasy Football)

fp-headshot by Josh Shepardson | 2 min read

About Author