Garrett Crochet or Tyler Mahle
Baseball Stats Comparison
See which player would win in a trade View Trade Analyzer
| Garrett Crochet SP - BOS | Tyler Mahle SP - SF | |
| 2026 Stats | ||
| Games Played | 6 | 11 |
| Games Started | 6 | 11 |
| Innings Pitched | 30.0 | 56.2 |
| Wins | 3 | 1 |
| Losses | 3 | 7 |
| Saves | 0 | 0 |
| Blown Saves | 0 | 0 |
| Holds | 0 | 0 |
| Hits Allowed | 33 | 63 |
| Earned Runs | 21 | 38 |
| Home Runs Allowed | 5 | 11 |
| Strikeouts | 37 | 57 |
| Walks | 11 | 24 |
| ERA | 6.30 | 6.04 |
| WHIP | 1.47 | 1.54 |
| Garrett Crochet SP - BOS | Tyler Mahle SP - SF | |
| 2026 Projections | ||
| Games Played | 31 | 24 |
| Games Started | 31 | 23 |
| Innings Pitched | 187.9 | 129.8 |
| Wins | 14 | 7 |
| Losses | 8 | 8 |
| Saves | 0 | 0 |
| Blown Saves | 0 | 0 |
| Holds | 0 | 0 |
| Hits Allowed | 153 | 124 |
| Earned Runs | 61 | 59 |
| Home Runs Allowed | 20 | 15 |
| Strikeouts | 230 | 105 |
| Walks | 48 | 40 |
| ERA | 2.91 | 4.07 |
| WHIP | 1.07 | 1.26 |
| Garrett Crochet SP - BOS | Tyler Mahle SP - SF | |
| News | ||
| Garrett Crochet is expected to undergo more testing in the next couple of days to see if he can start throwing again. Ari Koslow Wed, Jun 10th | The Giants placed Tyler Mahle on the 15-day injured list. Ari Koslow Fri, May 29th | |
| The Red Sox transferred Garrett Crochet to the 60-day injured list. Ari Koslow Fri, Jun 5th | Tyler Mahle allowed three earned runs on three hits and three walks while striking out three over five innings in Tuesday's loss to the Diamondbacks. Chris Schommer Wed, May 27th | |
| Red Sox interim manager Chad Tracy said Garrett Crochet has been diagnosed with a low-grade lat strain. Ari Koslow Tue, Jun 2nd | Tyler Mahle allowed six earned runs on eight hits while striking out six over five innings in Wednesday’s loss to the Diamondbacks. Chris Schommer Thu, May 21st | |
| Garrett Crochet told reporters he’s expecting his MRI results on Tuesday. Ari Koslow Tue, Jun 2nd | Tyler Mahle allowed five earned runs on 10 hits and one walk while striking out six over five innings in Friday’s loss to the Athletics. Chris Schommer Sat, May 16th | |
| Red Sox interim manager Chad Tracy said Garrett Crochet has suffered a setback due to lat tightness. Ari Koslow Sun, May 31st | Tyler Mahle allowed four earned runs on five hits and two walks while striking out eight over 5 2/3 innings in Sunday’s win over the Pirates. Chris Schommer Mon, May 11th | |
| Notes | ||
| Garrett Crochet built on his breakout 2025 by sustaining elite strikeout rates and improved efficiency, alleviating many durability concerns that followed him earlier in his career. His 2026 projections continue to reflect frontline stuff, with strong K totals and solid ratios over a full starter's workload. Crochet is a premium fantasy arm whose upside justifies an aggressive draft slot and should easily be one of the first three pitchers off the board. Kelly Kirby - FantasyPros | ||
| Garrett Crochet SP - BOS | Tyler Mahle SP - SF | |||||
| Date | Opp | Opp Pitcher | VBR | Opp | Opp Pitcher | VBR |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Thu, Mar 26th | @ CIN | Andrew Abbott (4-4) | #100 |   |   |   |
| Sat, Mar 28th | @ CIN | Brady Singer (2-6) | #160 | vs NYY | Will Warren (7-1) | #67 |
| Sun, Mar 29th | @ CIN | Rhett Lowder (3-3) | #185 |   |   |   |
| Mon, Mar 30th | @ HOU | Lance McCullers Jr. (2-3) | #231 | @ SD | Walker Buehler (3-3) | #216 |
| Tue, Mar 31st | @ HOU | Hunter Brown (1-0) | #13 | @ SD | German Marquez (3-2) | #354 |
| Wed, Apr 1st | @ HOU | Mike Burrows (3-8) | #136 | @ SD | Nick Pivetta (1-2) | #145 |
| Fri, Apr 3rd | vs SD | Michael King (4-5) | #41 | vs NYM | Nolan McLean (3-4) | #38 |
| Sat, Apr 4th | vs SD | Randy Vasquez (5-4) | #210 | vs NYM | Clay Holmes (4-4) | #162 |
| Sun, Apr 5th | vs SD | Walker Buehler (3-3) | #216 | vs NYM | Kodai Senga (0-4) | #125 |
| Mon, Apr 6th | vs MIL | Brandon Woodruff (2-1) | #47 | vs PHI | Andrew Painter (1-7) | #169 |
| Tue, Apr 7th | vs MIL | Jacob Misiorowski (7-2) | #10 | vs PHI | Cristopher Sanchez (8-2) | #4 |
| Wed, Apr 8th | vs MIL | Shane Drohan (3-1) | #138 | vs PHI | Aaron Nola (3-4) | #42 |
| Fri, Apr 10th | @ STL | Dustin May (4-6) | #66 | @ BAL | Shane Baz (3-6) | #74 |
| Sat, Apr 11th | @ STL | Kyle Leahy (5-3) | #141 | @ BAL | Chris Bassitt (4-4) | #139 |
| Sun, Apr 12th | @ STL | Andre Pallante (7-4) | #140 | @ BAL | Cade Povich (1-1) | #247 |
| Mon, Apr 13th | @ MIN | Bailey Ober (6-3) | #107 |   |   |   |
| Tue, Apr 14th | @ MIN | Mick Abel (1-2) | #166 | @ CIN | Brady Singer (2-6) | #160 |
| Wed, Apr 15th | @ MIN | Simeon Woods Richardson (0-7) | #211 | @ CIN | Rhett Lowder (3-3) | #185 |
| Fri, Apr 17th | vs DET | Casey Mize (2-3) | #60 | @ WSH | Zack Littell (6-4) | #167 |
| Sat, Apr 18th | vs DET | Tarik Skubal (3-2) | #3 | @ WSH | Cade Cavalli (3-4) | #88 |
| Sun, Apr 19th | vs DET | Framber Valdez (3-5) | #26 | @ WSH | PJ Poulin (3-0) | #313 |
| Mon, Apr 20th | vs DET | Jack Flaherty (1-7) | #64 |   |   |   |
| Tue, Apr 21st | vs NYY | Luis Gil (1-2) | #264 | vs LAD | Yoshinobu Yamamoto (6-4) | #11 |
| Wed, Apr 22nd | vs NYY | Max Fried (4-3) | #37 | vs LAD | Shohei Ohtani (6-2) | #1 |
| Thu, Apr 23rd | vs NYY | Cam Schlittler (7-3) | #35 | vs LAD | Tyler Glasnow (3-0) | #39 |
| Fri, Apr 24th | @ BAL | Brandon Young (5-1) | #182 | vs MIA | Sandy Alcantara (5-4) | #62 |
| Sat, Apr 25th | @ BAL | Trevor Rogers (3-6) | #96 | vs MIA | Eury Perez (3-6) | #108 |
| Sun, Apr 26th | @ BAL | Kyle Bradish (3-7) | #45 | vs MIA | Max Meyer (6-0) | #61 |
| Mon, Apr 27th | @ TOR | Dylan Cease (3-3) | #9 |   |   |   |
| Tue, Apr 28th | @ TOR | Trey Yesavage (2-3) | #59 | @ PHI | Jesus Luzardo (5-4) | #12 |
| Wed, Apr 29th | @ TOR | Eric Lauer (2-5) | #251 |   |   |   |
| Fri, May 1st | vs HOU | Mike Burrows (3-8) | #136 | @ TB | Shane McClanahan (6-3) | #22 |
| Sat, May 2nd | vs HOU | Spencer Arrighetti (7-1) | #122 | @ TB | Griffin Jax (1-4) | #63 |
| Sun, May 3rd | vs HOU | Cody Bolton (0-1) | #396 | @ TB | Steven Matz (4-3) | #144 |
| Mon, May 4th | @ DET | Tyler Holton (1-4) | #142 | vs SD | Randy Vasquez (5-4) | #210 |
| Tue, May 5th | @ DET | Framber Valdez (3-5) | #26 | vs SD | Walker Buehler (3-3) | #216 |
| Wed, May 6th | @ DET | Jack Flaherty (1-7) | #64 | vs SD | Bradgley Rodriguez | |
| Thu, May 7th | vs TB | Griffin Jax (1-4) | #63 |   |   |   |
| Fri, May 8th | vs TB | Jesse Scholtens (5-3) | #304 | vs PIT | Carmen Mlodzinski (4-3) | #130 |
| Sun, May 10th | vs TB | Nick Martinez (6-2) | #95 | vs PIT | Bubba Chandler (2-7) | #116 |
| Tue, May 12th | vs PHI | Zack Wheeler (5-1) | #8 | @ LAD | Yoshinobu Yamamoto (6-4) | #11 |
| Wed, May 13th | vs PHI | Andrew Painter (1-7) | #169 | @ LAD | Shohei Ohtani (6-2) | #1 |
| Thu, May 14th | vs PHI | Jesus Luzardo (5-4) | #12 | @ LAD | Emmet Sheehan (3-3) | #49 |
| Fri, May 15th | @ ATL | Spencer Strider (4-1) | #32 | @ ATH | Aaron Civale (5-2) | #205 |
| Sat, May 16th | @ ATL | Bryce Elder (5-3) | #113 | @ ATH | Luis Severino (2-6) | #158 |
| Sun, May 17th | @ ATL | Grant Holmes (4-2) | #131 | @ ATH | Jeffrey Springs (3-6) | #123 |
| Mon, May 18th | @ KC | Seth Lugo (2-4) | #109 | @ ARI | Zac Gallen (3-5) | #82 |
| Tue, May 19th | @ KC | Bailey Falter (0-2) | #343 | @ ARI | Ryne Nelson (2-5) | #94 |
| Wed, May 20th | @ KC | Michael Wacha (4-5) | #77 | @ ARI | Merrill Kelly (5-5) | #97 |
| Fri, May 22nd | vs MIN | Connor Prielipp (2-4) | #104 | vs CWS | Davis Martin (9-2) | #80 |
| Sat, May 23rd | vs MIN | Taj Bradley (5-3) | #71 | vs CWS | Bryan Hudson (3-2) | #181 |
| Sun, May 24th | vs MIN | Bailey Ober (6-3) | #107 | vs CWS | Noah Schultz (2-4) | #213 |
| Tue, May 26th | vs ATL | Spencer Strider (4-1) | #32 | vs ARI | Eduardo Rodriguez (5-2) | #118 |
| Wed, May 27th | vs ATL | Bryce Elder (5-3) | #113 | vs ARI | Michael Soroka (8-3) | #58 |
| Thu, May 28th | vs ATL | Chris Sale (8-5) | #5 |   |   |   |
| Fri, May 29th | @ CLE | Slade Cecconi (3-5) | #105 | @ COL | Michael Lorenzen (2-8) | #422 |
| Sat, May 30th | @ CLE | Parker Messick (6-3) | #53 | @ COL | Ryan Feltner (2-2) | #426 |
| Sun, May 31st | @ CLE | Tanner Bibee (1-7) | #43 | @ COL | Tanner Gordon (0-1) | #326 |
| Tue, Jun 2nd | vs BAL | Shane Baz (3-6) | #74 | @ MIL | Kyle Harrison (7-1) | #54 |
| Wed, Jun 3rd | vs BAL | Chris Bassitt (4-4) | #139 | @ MIL | Robert Gasser (0-3) | #175 |
| Thu, Jun 4th | vs BAL | Trevor Rogers (3-6) | #96 | @ MIL | Coleman Crow (0-1) | #236 |
| Fri, Jun 5th | @ NYY | Ryan Weathers (2-4) | #81 | @ CHC | Edward Cabrera (4-3) | #69 |
| Sun, Jun 7th | @ NYY | Cam Schlittler (7-3) | #35 | @ CHC | Jameson Taillon (2-5) | #112 |
| Mon, Jun 8th | @ TB | Ian Seymour (3-0) | #111 | vs WSH | Richard Lovelady (2-3) | #227 |
| Tue, Jun 9th | @ TB | Nick Martinez (6-2) | #95 | vs WSH | Andrew Alvarez (1-0) | #179 |
| Wed, Jun 10th | @ TB | Drew Rasmussen (6-2) | #19 | vs WSH | Foster Griffin (7-2) | #85 |
| Fri, Jun 12th | vs TEX | Jack Leiter (3-5) | #79 | vs CHC | Javier Assad (3-1) | #208 |
| Sat, Jun 13th | vs TEX | Jacob deGrom (5-4) | #6 | vs CHC | Ben Brown (2-2) | #30 |
| Sun, Jun 14th | vs TEX | Nathan Eovaldi (5-7) | #21 | vs CHC | Colin Rea (5-4) | #153 |
| Tue, Jun 16th | vs TOR | Dylan Cease (3-3) | #9 | @ ATL | Grant Holmes (4-2) | #131 |
| Wed, Jun 17th | vs TOR | Max Scherzer (1-4) | #126 | @ ATL | Chris Sale (8-5) | #5 |
| Thu, Jun 18th | vs TOR | Trey Yesavage (2-3) | #59 | @ ATL | Spencer Strider (4-1) | #32 |
| Fri, Jun 19th | @ SEA | Bryce Miller (2-0) | #48 | @ MIA | Janson Junk (3-5) | #124 |
| Sat, Jun 20th | @ SEA | Luis Castillo (2-5) | #46 | @ MIA | Ryan Gusto (0-1) | #186 |
| Sun, Jun 21st | @ SEA | Emerson Hancock (5-2) | #86 | @ MIA | Tyler Phillips (1-1) | #212 |
| Mon, Jun 22nd | @ COL |   |   |   | ||
| Tue, Jun 23rd | @ COL | vs ATH | ||||
| Wed, Jun 24th | @ COL | vs ATH | ||||
| Thu, Jun 25th | vs NYY | vs ATH | ||||
| Fri, Jun 26th | vs NYY | vs ATL | ||||
| Sat, Jun 27th | vs NYY | vs ATL | ||||
| Sun, Jun 28th | vs NYY | vs ATL | ||||
| Mon, Jun 29th | vs WSH | @ ARI | ||||
| Tue, Jun 30th | vs WSH | @ ARI | ||||
| Wed, Jul 1st | vs WSH | @ ARI | ||||
| Fri, Jul 3rd | @ LAA | @ COL | ||||
| Sat, Jul 4th | @ LAA | @ COL | ||||
| Sun, Jul 5th | @ LAA | @ COL | ||||
| Tue, Jul 7th | @ CWS | vs TOR | ||||
| Wed, Jul 8th | @ CWS | vs TOR | ||||
| Thu, Jul 9th | @ CWS | vs COL | ||||
| Fri, Jul 10th | @ NYM | vs COL | ||||
| Sat, Jul 11th | @ NYM | vs COL | ||||
| Sun, Jul 12th | @ NYM | vs COL | ||||
| Fri, Jul 17th | vs TB | @ SEA | ||||
| Sat, Jul 18th | vs TB | @ SEA | ||||
| Sun, Jul 19th | vs TB | @ SEA | ||||
| Mon, Jul 20th | vs BAL | @ KC | ||||
| Tue, Jul 21st | vs BAL | @ KC | ||||
| Wed, Jul 22nd | vs BAL | @ KC | ||||
| Fri, Jul 24th | vs TOR | vs LAA | ||||
| Sat, Jul 25th | vs TOR | vs LAA | ||||
| Sun, Jul 26th | vs TOR | vs LAA | ||||
| Mon, Jul 27th | @ ATH | vs MIL | ||||
| Tue, Jul 28th | @ ATH | vs MIL | ||||
| Wed, Jul 29th | @ ATH | vs MIL | ||||
| Thu, Jul 30th | @ ATH | @ SD | ||||
| Fri, Jul 31st | @ LAD | @ SD | ||||
| Sat, Aug 1st | @ LAD | @ SD | ||||
| Sun, Aug 2nd | @ LAD | @ SD | ||||
| Tue, Aug 4th | vs CWS | @ TEX | ||||
| Wed, Aug 5th | vs CWS | @ TEX | ||||
| Thu, Aug 6th | vs CWS |   |   |   | ||
| Fri, Aug 7th | vs ATH | vs DET | ||||
| Sat, Aug 8th | vs ATH | vs DET | ||||
| Sun, Aug 9th | vs ATH | vs DET | ||||
| Mon, Aug 10th | @ TOR | vs HOU | ||||
| Tue, Aug 11th | @ TOR | vs HOU | ||||
| Wed, Aug 12th | @ TOR | vs HOU | ||||
| Thu, Aug 13th | @ TOR |   |   |   | ||
| Fri, Aug 14th | @ PIT | vs COL | ||||
| Sat, Aug 15th | @ PIT | vs COL | ||||
| Sun, Aug 16th | @ PIT | vs COL | ||||
| Mon, Aug 17th | vs ARI |   |   |   | ||
| Tue, Aug 18th | vs ARI | @ CLE | ||||
| Wed, Aug 19th | vs ARI | @ CLE | ||||
| Fri, Aug 21st | vs SF | @ BOS | ||||
| Sat, Aug 22nd | vs SF | @ BOS | ||||
| Sun, Aug 23rd | vs SF | @ BOS | ||||
| Mon, Aug 24th | @ MIA | vs CIN | ||||
| Tue, Aug 25th | @ MIA | vs CIN | ||||
| Wed, Aug 26th | @ MIA | vs CIN | ||||
| Fri, Aug 28th | @ NYY | vs ARI | ||||
| Sat, Aug 29th | @ NYY | vs ARI | ||||
| Sun, Aug 30th | @ NYY | vs ARI | ||||
| Mon, Aug 31st | vs SEA |   |   |   | ||
| Tue, Sep 1st | vs SEA | @ PIT | ||||
| Wed, Sep 2nd | vs SEA | @ PIT | ||||
| Thu, Sep 3rd | @ BAL | @ PIT | ||||
| Fri, Sep 4th | @ BAL | @ NYM | ||||
| Sat, Sep 5th | @ BAL | @ NYM | ||||
| Sun, Sep 6th | @ BAL | @ NYM | ||||
| Mon, Sep 7th | vs LAA | vs STL | ||||
| Tue, Sep 8th | vs LAA | vs STL | ||||
| Wed, Sep 9th | vs LAA | vs STL | ||||
| Fri, Sep 11th | vs KC | vs SD | ||||
| Sat, Sep 12th | vs KC | vs SD | ||||
| Sun, Sep 13th | vs KC | vs SD | ||||
| Tue, Sep 15th | @ TEX | @ STL | ||||
| Wed, Sep 16th | @ TEX | @ STL | ||||
| Thu, Sep 17th | @ TEX |   |   |   | ||
| Fri, Sep 18th | @ TB | @ LAD | ||||
| Sat, Sep 19th | @ TB | @ LAD | ||||
| Sun, Sep 20th | @ TB | @ LAD | ||||
| Tue, Sep 22nd | vs CLE | vs MIN | ||||
| Wed, Sep 23rd | vs CLE | vs MIN | ||||
| Thu, Sep 24th | vs CLE |   |   |   | ||
| Fri, Sep 25th | vs CHC | vs LAD | ||||
| Sat, Sep 26th | vs CHC | vs LAD | ||||
| Sun, Sep 27th | vs CHC | vs LAD | ||||
| Wed, Mar 25th |   |   |   | vs NYY | Max Fried (4-3) | #37 |
| Fri, Mar 27th |   |   |   | vs NYY | Cam Schlittler (7-3) | #35 |
| Thu, Apr 2nd |   |   |   | vs NYM | David Peterson (3-5) | #135 |
| Thu, Apr 16th |   |   |   | @ CIN | Chase Burns (7-1) | #23 |
| Thu, Apr 30th |   |   |   | @ PHI | Tim Mayza | |
| Sat, May 9th |   |   |   | vs PIT | Braxton Ashcraft (5-3) | #34 |
| Mon, May 11th |   |   |   | @ LAD | Roki Sasaki (3-3) | #99 |
| Mon, May 25th |   |   |   | vs ARI | Merrill Kelly (5-5) | #97 |
| Mon, Jun 1st |   |   |   | @ MIL | Shane Drohan (3-1) | #138 |
| Sat, Jun 6th |   |   |   | @ CHC | Ben Brown (2-2) | #30 |
| Mon, Jul 6th |   |   |   | vs TOR | ||
| Mon, Aug 3rd |   |   |   | @ TEX | ||
| Thu, Aug 20th |   |   |   | @ CLE | ||
| Thu, Aug 27th |   |   |   | vs ARI | ||
| Mon, Sep 14th |   |   |   | @ STL | ||
| Mon, Sep 21st |   |   |   | vs MIN | ||

