Who Should I Draft?

Willson Contreras or Buster Posey (2019)

Experts' Pick
  Willson Contreras
Willson Contreras
Buster Posey
C,1B - SF
Buster Posey
Recommended by
36 of 59 experts
Recommended by
23 of 59 experts
ECR# 94# 113
Best Rank# 56# 59
Worst Rank# 184# 167
Composite# 122# 127
Best Rank# 98# 111
Worst Rank# 128# 153
Home Runs1510
Stolen Bases44
Batting Average.260.291
Injury Alert--
Expert Ranks 
Brandon Funston
The Athletic
# 93# 108
Scott Pianowski
Yahoo! Sports
# 90# 105
Staff Rankings
FullTime Fantasy
# 144
Alan Harrison
The Fantasy Fix
# 108# 141
Steve Gardner
USA Today
# 83# 96
Grey Albright
# 81# 151
Greg Smith
The Fake Baseball
# 91# 109
Tim Young
Brewer Rat
# 93
Jeff Boggis
Fantasy Football Empire
# 104# 106
Eno Sarris
The Athletic
# 101# 123
Beast Dome
# 98# 103
Scott White
CBS Sports
# 72# 82
Heath Cummings
CBS Sports
# 56# 72
Dave McKay
The Fantasy Sports Brain
# 92# 115
Wayne Bretsky
# 106# 148
Joe Bond
Fantasy Six Pack
# 113# 142
Chris Meaney
The Athletic
# 103# 115
Andy Singleton
Expand The Boxscore
# 97# 113
Heath Capps
Fake Teams
# 101# 117
Andrea LaMont
Lenny Melnick Fantasy Sports
# 108# 163
Mario Mergola
# 74# 99
Paul Sporer
# 127
Bill Dubiel
# 109# 126
Nick Mariano
# 117# 138
Donkey Teeth
# 111# 114
Pierre Camus
# 93# 112
Andrew Seifter
# 114# 119
Brandon 'B_Don' Myers
# 107# 110
Kyle Richardson
The Fantasy Headliners
# 91# 110
Dennis Sosic
Fantasy Six Pack
# 89# 105
Jacob Gibbs
# 95# 101
Bart Wheeler
Hail to Fantasy Football
# 69# 120
Michael Petropoulos
BRoto Fantasy
# 106# 167
Jason Petropoulos
BRoto Fantasy
# 98# 143
Austin Bristow II
Pitcher List
# 77# 90
Todd D Clark
The Fantasy Fix
# 99# 125
Al Melchior
The Athletic
# 76# 73
Site Projections
# 77# 59
Dan Harris
# 78# 69
Rudy Gamble
# 80# 66
Ariel Cohen
# 93# 83
Justin Klein
The Fake Baseball
# 96# 92
Dalton Del Don
Yahoo! Sports
# 98# 79
Andrew Gould
# 101# 100
Tyler Thompson
Fantasy Six Pack
# 101# 90
Bobby Sylvester
# 102# 97
Andy Behrens
Yahoo! Sports
# 106# 91
Justin Mason
# 106# 102
Nick Pollack
Pitcher List
# 107# 95
Jake Ciely
The Athletic
# 107# 93
Joe E Gentile
Fake Teams
# 111# 100
Michael Beller
The Athletic
# 111# 108
Luke Gloeckner
Mr. Cheatsheet
# 117# 91
Nando Di Fino
The Athletic
# 118# 76
Max Freeze
Freeze Stats
# 128# 124
Mick Ciallela
# 144# 104
Brad Richter
# 173# 166
Jason Johnson
Understanding Fantasy Baseball
# 178# 144
Fantasy Team Advice
# 184# 164
  Willson Contreras
Willson Contreras
Buster Posey
C,1B - SF
Buster Posey
2018 Stats 
At Bats474398
Home Runs105
Stolen Bases43
Caught Stealing12
Batting Average.249.284
On Base Pct.340.359
Slugging Pct.390.382
On-base Plus Slugging.730.741
  Willson Contreras
Willson Contreras
Buster Posey
C,1B - SF
Buster Posey
2019 Projections 
At Bats445457
Home Runs1510
Stolen Bases44
Caught Stealing21
Batting Average.260.291
On Base Pct.333.362
Slugging Pct.429.419
On-base Plus Slugging.762.781
  Willson Contreras
Willson Contreras
Buster Posey
C,1B - SF
Buster Posey
 Willson Contreras went 1-for-4 with a solo home run in Wednesday's loss to the Reds.
Connor Rooney
Thu, Sep 19th
Buster Posey went 1-for-4 with two strikeouts as the Giants fell to the Red Sox 5-4 on Thursday.
Brendan Tuma - Too Much Tuma
Fri, Sep 20th
 Willson Contreras went 3-for-4 with a pair of home runs, three runs scored, and a walk Friday against the Pirates.
Connor Rooney
Sat, Sep 14th
Buster Posey went 1-for-4 with an RBI as the Giants beat the Marlins 1-0 on Friday night.
Brendan Tuma - Too Much Tuma
Sat, Sep 14th
 Willson Contreras went 4-for-5 with two doubles, a solo home run, two runs scored, and two RBI in Thursday's win over the Brewers.
Connor Rooney
Fri, Sep 6th
Buster Posey went 2-for-4 with two singles in the Giants' 5-0 loss to the Dodgers on Sunday.
Brendan Tuma - Too Much Tuma
Mon, Sep 9th
 Willson Contreras went 2-for-3 with a solo home run and a walk in Tuesday's win over the Mariners.
Connor Rooney
Wed, Sep 4th
Buster Posey went 1-for-4 with two strikeouts in the Giants' 5-3 loss to the Padres on Thursday night.
Brendan Tuma - Too Much Tuma
Fri, Aug 30th
 Wilson Contreras is expected to miss four weeks due to his strained right hamstring.
Brad Camara
Mon, Aug 5th
Buster Posey went 0-for-5 with four strikeouts in Sunday's 5-4 win over the Athletics.
Brendan Tuma - Too Much Tuma
Sun, Aug 25th
 Contreras was a major disappointment for fantasy owners in 2018 after starting off his career with 33 HRs, 109 RBIs and a .278 batting average through 629 at-bats in his first two years. He is still young, however, and expected to improve from last season.
Bobby Sylvester - FantasyPros
Although Posey isn't likely a .300 hitter anymore, his .280s batting average is the equivilant of a .310 hitter when compared to the replacement-level at his position. Add in a dozen homers, if he can stay healthy this year, and you've got yourself a boring, yet extremely useful top 8 fantasy catcher.
Bobby Sylvester - FantasyPros
 A rising star came crashing down when Contreras cratered to .249/.339/.390 with 10 homers in 544 plate appearances. He again hit ground balls on over half of his batted balls, but this time it came with fewer hard hits (28.9%) and more pop-ups (10.3%). A terrible second half (.264 wOBA) derailed this season, so it wasn't even a full year of regression. Even if not anticipating a full revival, the catching pool gets bleak enough to secure him as a top-eight option at worst.
Andrew Gould - FantasyPros
Posey's power is going the path of Joe Mauer. His home runs over the past five seasons: 22, 19, 14, 12, 5. A hip injury limited him to his fewest games (105) since 2011, and he set a personal worst in slugging (.382) while matching a career-low .284 batting average. He also maintained superb contact skills and hopes to be ready for Opening Day. Even an empty batting average is better than what most other catchers could offer. An aging Posey is still a top-10 choice, but not a top-tier star.
Andrew Gould - FantasyPros
 Contreras had a horribly disappointing 2018 season, hitting just 10 home runs after belting 21 long balls the previous season. The lack of homers was also responsible for lopping more than 25 points off his batting average, as his strikeout rate and BABIP were virtually identical to 2017. Of particular concern was the decline in his hard hit rate, in a year when most players saw their hard hit rates soar. Contreras is just 26 years old and didn't deal with any notable injuries last season, so the sudden drop in power is tough to explain. It stands to reason that a big bounce back could be in store, but he has to be viewed as a boom-or-bust option coming off a lost year.
Andrew Seifter - FantasyPros
Posey fell off the fantasy map in 2018, managing to hit just five home runs while playing through a hip ailment that eventually required surgery. He didn't show any obvious signs of decline in his batted ball profile, and his plate discipline remained as good as ever, so a modest bounce back should be expected. The biggest concern is that the Giants pump the brakes on Posey's playing time to preserve his health. Given his poor hitting environment, weak supporting cast, and lack of category juice, Posey needs to rack up a lot of at-bats in order for his typically high batting average to be a true difference-maker for fantasy owners.
Andrew Seifter - FantasyPros