2017 Fantasy Baseball Rankings

Expert Consensus Ranking (33 of 36 Experts) - Updated 2/24
Rank Player (Team, Position) Overall Best Worst Avg Std Dev
1 Clayton Kershaw (LAD, SP) 7 1 1 1.0 0.0
2 Max Scherzer (WSH, SP) DTD 13 2 4 2.1 0.4
3 Madison Bumgarner (SF, SP) 17 2 4 3.2 0.5
4 Noah Syndergaard (NYM, SP) 20 2 8 4.7 1.5
5 Chris Sale (BOS, SP) 22 3 8 4.7 1.0
6 Corey Kluber (CLE, SP) 26 3 10 5.8 1.1
7 Jake Arrieta (CHC, SP) 38 5 13 8.4 2.0
8 Jon Lester (CHC, SP) 40 7 17 8.8 2.0
9 Yu Darvish (TEX, SP) 45 6 18 10.6 2.9
10 David Price (BOS, SP) 46 6 18 10.8 2.8
11 Johnny Cueto (SF, SP) 47 7 17 10.8 2.1
12 Justin Verlander (DET, SP) 48 6 41 11.8 5.7
13 Stephen Strasburg (WSH, SP) 53 5 20 12.9 3.3
14 Carlos Carrasco (CLE, SP) 55 8 22 13.8 2.6
15 Chris Archer (TB, SP) 59 11 20 14.9 2.1
16 Jacob DeGrom (NYM, SP) 64 7 24 15.6 2.8
17 Kyle Hendricks (CHC, SP) 73 12 30 18.7 4.2
18 Carlos Martinez (STL, SP) 80 11 30 20.0 4.3
19 Masahiro Tanaka (NYY, SP) 85 15 31 20.4 3.3
20 Cole Hamels (TEX, SP) 89 12 29 21.6 4.3
21 Zack Greinke (ARI, SP) 94 11 47 22.5 6.5
22 Gerrit Cole (PIT, SP) 92 17 38 22.8 4.3
23 Jose Quintana (CWS, SP) 95 17 47 23.7 4.8
24 Kenta Maeda (LAD, SP) 97 13 47 25.4 6.4
25 Danny Duffy (KC, SP,RP) 107 17 50 26.1 6.4
26 Julio Teheran (ATL, SP) 108 18 49 28.1 6.3
27 Rick Porcello (BOS, SP) 109 16 43 28.2 6.4
28 Danny Salazar (CLE, SP) 111 15 48 28.8 6.4
29 Aaron Sanchez (TOR, SP) 115 19 47 30.1 7.7
30 Rich Hill (LAD, SP) 118 19 55 31.3 7.9
31 Michael Fulmer (DET, SP) 122 26 48 33.3 5.8
32 Dallas Keuchel (HOU, SP) 132 16 59 35.4 9.5
33 Felix Hernandez (SEA, SP) 130 26 49 35.5 5.6
34 John Lackey (CHC, SP) 138 27 52 36.4 5.9
35 Matt Harvey (NYM, SP) 140 21 82 37.3 12.9
36 Marcus Stroman (TOR, SP) 129 28 54 37.6 6.2
37 Kevin Gausman (BAL, SP) 131 27 54 38.9 8.4
38 Lance McCullers (HOU, SP) DL15 143 21 70 39.0 11.4
39 Aaron Nola (PHI, SP) 147 25 61 39.3 8.7
40 Steven Matz (NYM, SP) DL15 148 29 57 39.8 6.9
41 Jameson Taillon (PIT, SP) 151 13 65 41.1 9.7
42 Tanner Roark (WSH, SP) 159 22 79 44.2 10.3
43 Jonathan Gray (COL, SP) 163 30 70 46.0 9.8
44 Vincent Velasquez (PHI, SP) 162 35 68 47.7 7.5
45 Sean Manaea (OAK, SP) DL15 182 39 71 49.9 8.4
46 Jeff Samardzija (SF, SP) 174 32 77 50.0 9.7
47 Julio Urias (LAD, SP) 181 34 77 50.1 10.1
48 James Paxton (SEA, SP) 171 33 75 48.5 11.0
49 J.A. Happ (TOR, SP) 185 30 79 51.0 9.0
50 Jake Odorizzi (TB, SP) 183 41 74 52.7 8.0
51 Carlos Rodon (CWS, SP) 192 30 98 53.1 13.0
52 Matt Shoemaker (LAA, SP) 194 32 72 53.7 9.5
53 Robbie Ray (ARI, SP) 195 38 70 54.3 8.1
54 Sonny Gray (OAK, SP) 198 38 101 54.8 11.6
55 Anthony DeSclafani (CIN, SP) 199 38 80 55.2 9.8
56 Drew Pomeranz (BOS, SP) 203 38 105 54.3 12.2
57 Michael Pineda (NYY, SP) 197 31 83 56.8 12.8
58 Joe Ross (WSH, SP) 207 41 69 57.5 7.3
59 Marco Estrada (TOR, SP) 208 39 93 59.8 9.5
60 Drew Smyly (SEA, SP) 204 39 98 61.1 13.9
61 Taijuan Walker (ARI, SP) 216 26 86 60.3 12.5
62 Jerad Eickhoff (PHI, SP) 217 37 86 62.2 9.9
63 Garrett Richards (LAA, SP) 212 38 126 62.7 16.7
64 Adam Wainwright (STL, SP) 223 40 134 64.7 16.4
65 Matt Moore (SF, SP) 220 40 95 64.1 15.1
66 Hisashi Iwakuma (SEA, SP) 226 32 89 65.3 11.6
67 Blake Snell (TB, SP) 241 38 93 69.8 12.5
68 Gio Gonzalez (WSH, SP) 247 54 104 72.5 10.8
69 Raisel Iglesias (CIN, SP,RP) 218 36 108 65.2 15.7
70 Collin McHugh (HOU, SP) 246 41 91 71.3 9.8
71 Jharel Cotton (OAK, SP) 245 43 106 72.6 13.7
72 Ian Kennedy (KC, SP) 255 57 107 75.2 11.5
73 Tyler Glasnow (PIT, SP) 258 37 117 77.3 15.7
74 Junior Guerra (MIL, SP) 257 52 108 76.2 10.8
75 Ivan Nova (PIT, SP,RP) 284 52 100 76.6 11.4
76 Dylan Bundy (BAL, SP,RP) 285 44 112 76.7 16.8
77 Trevor Bauer (CLE, SP,RP) 286 32 113 79.7 15.2
78 Jeremy Hellickson (PHI, SP) 269 51 111 79.4 11.8
79 Ervin Santana (MIN, SP) 277 47 136 82.0 14.4
80 Tyler Skaggs (LAA, SP) 292 57 99 82.1 10.3
81 Jason Hammel (KC, SP) 298 52 106 82.0 14.9
82 Jordan Zimmermann (DET, SP) 297 63 122 85.2 12.5
83 Tyson Ross (TEX, SP) 266 53 138 86.8 20.0
84 Tyler Anderson (COL, SP) 263 45 135 85.4 18.4
85 Alex Cobb (TB, SP) 289 48 112 83.1 13.8
86 Chris Tillman (BAL, SP) DTD 295 62 104 83.3 8.8
87 Alexander Reyes (STL, SP,RP) DTD 281 32 75 59.4 14.6
88 Lance Lynn (STL, SP) 299 39 116 87.6 16.5
89 Zach Davies (MIL, SP) 300 72 114 87.6 11.9
90 Joe Musgrove (HOU, SP) 318 58 134 90.7 17.8
91 Wei-Yin Chen (MIA, SP) 306 52 116 89.5 15.5
92 Michael Wacha (STL, SP,RP) 349 64 120 91.4 13.3
93 Daniel Norris (DET, SP) 315 60 136 93.2 17.5
94 Eduardo Rodriguez (BOS, SP) 343 65 107 91.1 12.1
95 Francisco Liriano (TOR, SP) 313 66 123 94.8 15.5
96 Michael Foltynewicz (ATL, SP) 322 66 119 94.5 14.8
97 Mike Leake (STL, SP) 308 75 134 94.8 13.5
98 Luke Weaver (STL, SP) 324 60 135 94.3 14.7
99 Jaime Garcia (ATL, SP) 326 66 122 95.4 13.7
100 Mike Montgomery (CHC, SP,RP) 327 74 110 93.5 11.2
101 Bartolo Colon (ATL, SP) 319 71 112 94.9 11.3
102 Jose Berrios (MIN, SP) 333 38 130 98.0 19.1
103 Andrew Triggs (OAK, SP,RP) 314 71 124 97.3 13.8
104 Jose De Leon (TB, SP) 356 69 131 97.6 16.2
105 Lucas Giolito (CWS, SP) 353 78 129 99.6 15.5
106 Matt Andriese (TB, SP,RP) 328 80 215 102.8 25.9
107 Adam Conley (MIA, SP) 423 71 122 98.3 13.7
108 Scott Kazmir (LAD, SP) MiLB 354 72 132 100.2 14.2
109 Brandon Finnegan (CIN, SP) 394 72 121 99.3 13.7
110 Daniel Straily (MIA, SP) 366 71 129 102.3 13.6
111 David Phelps (MIA, SP,RP) 336 76 132 103.4 14.5
112 Luis Severino (NYY, SP,RP) 407 81 123 105.4 12.7
113 Robert Gsellman (NYM, SP) 454 73 127 102.9 12.9
114 Chris Devenski (HOU, SP,RP) 381 76 165 109.1 19.0
115 Steven Wright (BOS, SP,RP) MiLB 433 72 125 105.1 11.5
116 Matthew Strahm (KC, SP,RP) 390 71 120 100.4 14.6
117 Zack Wheeler (NYM, SP) 373 73 140 111.1 17.9
118 Alex Wood (LAD, SP,RP) 406 81 140 111.5 14.2
119 Tyler Chatwood (COL, SP) 415 75 134 111.3 14.7
120 Josh Tomlin (CLE, SP) 497 75 130 107.1 13.1
121 Homer Bailey (CIN, SP) DL60 467 80 145 117.6 16.1
122 Mike Fiers (HOU, SP) 411 89 131 112.7 10.5
123 Andrew Cashner (TEX, SP)   76 139 116.6 19.2
124 Ty Blach (SF, P,SP) 377 83 149 119.3 18.2
125 Shelby Miller (ARI, SP) 405 85 129 115.3 11.2
126 Martin Perez (TEX, SP) 583 78 157 120.5 23.4
127 Jose Urena (MIA, SP,RP) 594 79 164 121.5 42.5
128 Tyler Duffey (MIN, SP)   82 160 126.7 32.8
129 Doug Fister (HOU, SP) 609 83 169 126.0 35.1
130 Reynaldo Lopez (WSH, SP,RP) 408 83 142 126.9 17.5
131 R.A. Dickey (ATL, SP) 477 84 133 115.3 12.7
132 James Shields (CWS, SP) 638 85 147 125.5 20.3
133 Miguel Gonzalez (CWS, SP) 420 88 141 117.9 17.3
134 Archie Bradley (ARI, SP) 447 94 136 113.6 13.0
135 Brandon McCarthy (LAD, SP,RP) MiLB 474 87 145 115.2 18.5
136 Patrick Corbin (ARI, SP,RP) 582 92 139 119.8 15.0
137 Nathan Karns (KC, SP,RP) 564 88 141 121.6 14.3
138 Jeff Locke (MIA, SP,RP) DTD   89 198 143.5 54.5
139 Amir Garrett (CIN, SP) MiLB   89 181 135.0 46.0
140 Ricky Nolasco (LAA, SP) 386 93 127 113.1 11.5
141 Wade Miley (BAL, SP) MiLB 531 90 186 132.6 31.2
142 Clay Buchholz (PHI, SP,RP) 428 98 125 111.3 10.1
143 Jimmy Nelson (MIL, SP) 521 93 148 120.4 16.0
144 Phil Hughes (MIN, SP)   94 179 133.3 31.0
145 Cody Reed (CIN, SP) DL15   95 177 136.3 33.5
146 Wily Peralta (MIL, SP)   95 158 128.0 25.8
147 Jhoulys Chacin (SD, SP,RP) MiLB 517 95 153 126.4 18.9
148 Edinson Volquez (MIA, SP) 505 96 132 115.8 12.6
149 Robert Stephenson (CIN, SP) 511 97 176 124.3 31.3
150 Charlie Morton (HOU, SP) 533 98 140 126.4 14.9
151 CC Sabathia (NYY, SP) 512 99 134 118.4 12.4
152 Kyle Gibson (MIN, SP) 658 100 155 121.5 16.7
153 Kendall Graveman (OAK, SP) 458 101 139 122.7 12.2
154 Chad Kuhl (PIT, SP) 600 105 135 122.9 9.5
155 Tom Koehler (MIA, SP) 553 106 152 125.8 16.3
156 Francis Martes (HOU, SP,RP) NRI 557 110 159 125.3 20.0
157 Matt Boyd (DET, SP,RP) 551 110 128 118.8 6.0
158 Yovani Gallardo (BAL, SP)   111 178 144.5 33.5
159 Seth Lugo (NYM, SP,RP) 520 111 144 129.6 13.7
160 Joe Kelly (BOS, SP,RP)   112 197 141.7 39.2
161 Colby Lewis (TEX, SP)   114 156 135.0 21.0
162 Chad Green (NYY, SP) DL60 547 114 142 126.2 8.6
163 Rubby De La Rosa (ARI, SP) NRI 575 116 209 156.3 39.0
164 Derek Holland (CWS, SP)   117 151 137.7 14.8
165 Hector Santiago (MIN, SP) 625 117 142 130.1 7.6
166 Josh Hader (MIL, SP) 541 117 129 124.7 5.4
167 A.J. Cole (WSH, SP,RP)   118 173 145.5 27.5
168 Matthew Wisler (ATL, SP,RP) 544 118 154 134.0 11.0
169 Luis Cessa (NYY, SP,RP)   119 162 140.5 21.5
170 Ariel Miranda (SEA, SP,RP) 580 121 139 132.8 6.5
171 Cody Anderson (CLE, SP,RP)   122 214 168.0 46.0
172 Hyun-Jin Ryu (LAD, SP) 524 122 137 128.1 5.6
173 Drew Hutchison (PIT, SP,RP)   123 161 143.7 15.7
174 Chad Bettis (COL, SP)   123 150 136.5 13.5
175 Anibal Sanchez (DET, SP,RP) 654 124 163 142.2 12.9
176 Nick Tropeano (LAA, SP) 596 126 180 147.0 20.1
177 Jesse Hahn (OAK, SP) MiLB 665 128 129 128.5 0.5
178 Matt Garza (MIL, SP) 661 133 192 162.5 29.5
179 Steven Brault (PIT, SP) 671 136 174 155.0 19.0
180 Ubaldo Jimenez (BAL, SP)   148 183 165.5 17.5
181 Clayton Richard (SD, SP,RP)   149 188 168.5 19.5