Skip to main content

Who Should I Trade?

Aaron Civale for James Karinchak (2021)


See if your team wins or loses with this trade View Trade Analyzer

Who Should I Trade? Player Summaries
 
Experts' Pick
 
  Aaron Civale
SP - CLE
Aaron Civale
James Karinchak
RP - CLE
James Karinchak
Expert
Recommendation
63%
Recommended by
10 of 16 experts
38%
Recommended by
6 of 16 experts
Rankings 
   
Rest of Season# 51# 67
VBR# 190# 353
   
Projections 
   
Strikeouts126
Wins10
Saves01
ERA4.093.43
WHIP1.231.26
   
Misc 
   
Injury Alert-MiLB
   
Expert Ranks 
   
Dan Harris
FantasyPros
# 121# 140
   
Pierre Camus
RotoBaller
# 40# 66
   
Mick Ciallela
Fantrax
# 84# 90
   
Ryan Amore
Pitcher List
# 83# 133
   
Brendan Tuma
FantasyPros
# 63# 109
   
Jordan Eisen
Field of Vision Sports
# 58# 74
   
Brad Camara
FantasyPros
# 73
   
Chris Mitchell
FantasyData
# 48# 52
   
Corbin Young
FantasyData
# 54# 58
   
Chris Clegg
Fantrax
# 50# 60
   
Carmen Maiorano
FantasyPros
# 44# 40
   
Jorge B. Edwards
Fantasy In Frames
# 52# 51
   
Chris Meaney
FTN
# 62# 51
   
Joe Pisapia
FantasyPros
# 73# 59
   
Joe Bond
Fantasy Six Pack
# 74# 58
   
Mike Maher
FantasyPros
# 92# 64
   
Who Should I Trade? Player Statistics
  Aaron Civale
SP - CLE
Aaron Civale
James Karinchak
RP - CLE
James Karinchak
2021 Stats 
   
   
Games Played1759
   
Games Started170
   
Innings Pitched105.054.0
   
Wins107
   
Losses44
   
Saves011
   
Blown Saves05
   
Holds013
   
Hits Allowed9135
   
Earned Runs4425
   
Home Runs Allowed179
   
Strikeouts8577
   
Walks2632
   
ERA3.764.14
   
WHIP1.111.23
   
Who Should I Trade? Player Projections
  Aaron Civale
SP - CLE
Aaron Civale
James Karinchak
RP - CLE
James Karinchak
2021 Projections 
   
   
Games Played24
   
Games Started20
   
Innings Pitched14.53.9
   
Wins10
   
Losses10
   
Saves01
   
Blown Saves00
   
Holds00
   
Hits Allowed143
   
Earned Runs71
   
Home Runs Allowed20
   
Strikeouts126
   
Walks42
   
ERA4.093.43
   
WHIP1.231.26
   
Who Should I Trade? Player Notes
  Aaron Civale
SP - CLE
Aaron Civale
James Karinchak
RP - CLE
James Karinchak
News 
 Cleveland right-hander Aaron Civale allowed seven runs over three innings in an 11-1 loss to the Brewers on Sunday. Civale struck out three and walked two.
Matthew Terelle
Sun, Sep 12th
The Cleveland Indians have optioned reliever James Karinchak to Triple-A Columbus. His roster spot will go to first baseman Bobby Bradley, who was activated from the IL.
Andersen Pickard
Sat, Aug 28th
 Cleveland right-hander Aaron Civale allowed one run over 4 2/3 innings in a 3-0 loss to the Twins on Tuesday. Civale struck out six and walked one in the start.
Matthew Terelle
Wed, Sep 8th
Cleveland right-hander James Karinchak threw 1 1/3 scoreless innings in a 7-2 win over the Rangers on Wednesday. He struck out two and allowed just one hit.
Matthew Terelle
Thu, Aug 26th
 Aaron Civale (shoulder) has been activated from the injured list by the Indians. He will also get the start tonight for the Indians as they take on the Minnesota Twins.
Chris Schommer
Tue, Sep 7th
Cleveland right-hander James Karinchak allowed a run in his lone inning of work in a 4-3 loss to Oakland on Tuesday.
Matthew Terelle
Wed, Aug 11th
 Indians RHP Aaron Civale (finger) threw two scoreless innings during Sunday's rehab start for Double-A Akron.
Brendan Tuma - Too Much Tuma
Mon, Aug 23rd
Cleveland right-hander James Karinchak allowed three runs in 1/3 of an inning in a 12-11 win over the White Sox on Saturday. He walked one and gave up two hits, including a two-run homer.
Matthew Terelle
Sun, Aug 1st
 Cleveland starting pitcher Aaron Civale will make a rehab start on Sunday in Akron at their Double-A affiliate.
Corbin Young
Sat, Aug 21st
Cleveland right-hander James Karinchak threw a scoreless eighth inning in a 3-2 win over the Rays on Sunday. He worked around one walk in the frame.
Matthew Terelle
Sun, Jul 25th
Notes 
There are no recent notes for these players
Who Should I Trade? Player Schedules
  Aaron Civale
SP - CLE
Aaron Civale
James Karinchak
RP - CLE
James Karinchak
Date OppOpp PitcherVBROppOpp PitcherVBR
Thu, Apr 1st@ DETMatthew Boyd (3-8)#179@ DETMatthew Boyd (3-8)#179
Sat, Apr 3rd@ DETJulio Teheran (1-0)@ DETJulio Teheran (1-0)
Sun, Apr 4th@ DETTarik Skubal (8-12)#61@ DETTarik Skubal (8-12)#61
Mon, Apr 5thvs KCDanny Duffy (4-3)#116vs KCDanny Duffy (4-3)#116
Wed, Apr 7thvs KCJakob Junis (2-4)#192vs KCJakob Junis (2-4)#192
Fri, Apr 9thvs DETDerek Holland (3-2)#282vs DETDerek Holland (3-2)#282
Sat, Apr 10thvs DETTarik Skubal (8-12)#61vs DETTarik Skubal (8-12)#61
Sun, Apr 11thvs DETJose Urena (3-8)#407vs DETJose Urena (3-8)#407
Mon, Apr 12th@ CWSDallas Keuchel (8-9)#176@ CWSDallas Keuchel (8-9)#176
Tue, Apr 13th@ CWSLucas Giolito (9-9)#16@ CWSLucas Giolito (9-9)#16
Wed, Apr 14th@ CWSCarlos Rodon (12-5)#24@ CWSCarlos Rodon (12-5)#24
Thu, Apr 15th@ CWSLance Lynn (10-4)#13@ CWSLance Lynn (10-4)#13
Fri, Apr 16th@ CINJeff Hoffman (3-5)#221@ CINJeff Hoffman (3-5)#221
Sat, Apr 17th@ CINSonny Gray (7-7)#54@ CINSonny Gray (7-7)#54
Sun, Apr 18th@ CINWade Miley (12-6)#45@ CINWade Miley (12-6)#45
Tue, Apr 20thvs CWSCarlos Rodon (12-5)#24vs CWSCarlos Rodon (12-5)#24
Thu, Apr 22ndvs NYYDomingo German (4-5)#133vs NYYDomingo German (4-5)#133
Fri, Apr 23rdvs NYYJordan Montgomery (5-6)#46vs NYYJordan Montgomery (5-6)#46
Sat, Apr 24thvs NYYGerrit Cole (15-7)#8vs NYYGerrit Cole (15-7)#8
Sun, Apr 25thvs NYYJameson Taillon (8-6)#66vs NYYJameson Taillon (8-6)#66
Mon, Apr 26thvs MINJose Berrios (11-8)#12vs MINJose Berrios (11-8)#12
Tue, Apr 27thvs MINKenta Maeda (6-5)vs MINKenta Maeda (6-5)
Wed, Apr 28thvs MINJ.A. Happ (9-8)#152vs MINJ.A. Happ (9-8)#152
Fri, Apr 30th@ CWSDallas Keuchel (8-9)#176@ CWSDallas Keuchel (8-9)#176
Sat, May 1st@ CWSLance Lynn (10-4)#13@ CWSLance Lynn (10-4)#13
Sun, May 2nd@ CWSLucas Giolito (9-9)#16@ CWSLucas Giolito (9-9)#16
Mon, May 3rd@ KCDaniel Lynch (4-5)#401@ KCDaniel Lynch (4-5)#401
Tue, May 4th@ KCMike Minor (8-12)#78@ KCMike Minor (8-12)#78
Wed, May 5th@ KCBrady Singer (4-10)#138@ KCBrady Singer (4-10)#138
Thu, May 6th@ KCDanny Duffy (4-3)#116@ KCDanny Duffy (4-3)#116
Fri, May 7thvs CINWade Miley (12-6)#45vs CINWade Miley (12-6)#45
Sat, May 8thvs CINLuis Castillo (7-15)#44vs CINLuis Castillo (7-15)#44
Tue, May 11thvs CHCAdbert Alzolay (5-13)#143vs CHCAdbert Alzolay (5-13)#143
Wed, May 12thvs CHCZach Davies (6-11)#183vs CHCZach Davies (6-11)#183
Thu, May 13th@ SEALogan Gilbert (5-5)#74@ SEALogan Gilbert (5-5)#74
Fri, May 14th@ SEAChris Flexen (11-6)#55@ SEAChris Flexen (11-6)#55
Sat, May 15th@ SEAJustus Sheffield (7-8)#405@ SEAJustus Sheffield (7-8)#405
Sun, May 16th@ SEARobert Dugger (0-2)#386@ SEARobert Dugger (0-2)#386
Mon, May 17th@ LAAPatrick Sandoval (3-6)@ LAAPatrick Sandoval (3-6)
Tue, May 18th@ LAAAndrew Heaney (8-9)#95@ LAAAndrew Heaney (8-9)#95
Wed, May 19th@ LAAShohei Ohtani (9-2)#47@ LAAShohei Ohtani (9-2)#47
Fri, May 21stvs MINRandy Dobnak (1-7)vs MINRandy Dobnak (1-7)
Sat, May 22ndvs MINKenta Maeda (6-5)vs MINKenta Maeda (6-5)
Sun, May 23rdvs MINJ.A. Happ (9-8)#152vs MINJ.A. Happ (9-8)#152
Mon, May 24th@ DETSpencer Turnbull (4-2)@ DETSpencer Turnbull (4-2)
Tue, May 25th@ DETTarik Skubal (8-12)#61@ DETTarik Skubal (8-12)#61
Wed, May 26th@ DETJose Urena (3-8)#407@ DETJose Urena (3-8)#407
Thu, May 27th@ DETMatthew Boyd (3-8)#179@ DETMatthew Boyd (3-8)#179
Fri, May 28thvs TORHyun Jin Ryu (13-8)#43vs TORHyun Jin Ryu (13-8)#43
Sun, May 30thvs TORSteven Matz (12-7)#69vs TORSteven Matz (12-7)#69
Mon, May 31stvs CWSJimmy Lambert (1-1)#268vs CWSJimmy Lambert (1-1)#268
Tue, Jun 1stvs CWSDylan Cease (11-7)#50vs CWSDylan Cease (11-7)#50
Fri, Jun 4th@ BALKeegan Akin (2-9)#392@ BALKeegan Akin (2-9)#392
Sat, Jun 5th@ BALJohn Means (5-7)#32@ BALJohn Means (5-7)#32
Sun, Jun 6th@ BALJorge Lopez (3-14)@ BALJorge Lopez (3-14)
Tue, Jun 8th@ STLCarlos Martinez (4-9)@ STLCarlos Martinez (4-9)
Wed, Jun 9th@ STLAdam Wainwright (16-7)#3@ STLAdam Wainwright (16-7)#3
Fri, Jun 11thvs SEAJustin Dunn (1-3)#283vs SEAJustin Dunn (1-3)#283
Sat, Jun 12thvs SEAYusei Kikuchi (7-8)#53vs SEAYusei Kikuchi (7-8)#53
Sun, Jun 13thvs SEALogan Gilbert (5-5)#74vs SEALogan Gilbert (5-5)#74
Mon, Jun 14thvs BALDean Kremer (0-7)#396vs BALDean Kremer (0-7)#396
Tue, Jun 15thvs BALMatt Harvey (6-14)#389vs BALMatt Harvey (6-14)#389
Wed, Jun 16thvs BALKeegan Akin (2-9)#392vs BALKeegan Akin (2-9)#392
Thu, Jun 17thvs BALJorge Lopez (3-14)vs BALJorge Lopez (3-14)
Fri, Jun 18th@ PITChad Kuhl (5-6)#253@ PITChad Kuhl (5-6)#253
Sat, Jun 19th@ PITWil Crowe (3-7)#352@ PITWil Crowe (3-7)#352
Sun, Jun 20th@ PITJT Brubaker (5-13)#107@ PITJT Brubaker (5-13)#107
Mon, Jun 21st@ CHCAdbert Alzolay (5-13)#143@ CHCAdbert Alzolay (5-13)#143
Tue, Jun 22nd@ CHCKyle Hendricks (14-6)#85@ CHCKyle Hendricks (14-6)#85
Thu, Jun 24th@ MINJose Berrios (11-8)#12@ MINJose Berrios (11-8)#12
Fri, Jun 25th@ MINDanny Coulombe@ MINDanny Coulombe
Sun, Jun 27th@ MINJ.A. Happ (9-8)#152@ MINJ.A. Happ (9-8)#152
Mon, Jun 28thvs DETMatt Manning (4-6)#243vs DETMatt Manning (4-6)#243
Wed, Jun 30thvs DETWily Peralta (3-3)#212vs DETWily Peralta (3-3)#212
Thu, Jul 1stvs HOUFramber Valdez (10-5)#49vs HOUFramber Valdez (10-5)#49
Fri, Jul 2ndvs HOULance McCullers Jr. (12-4)#30vs HOULance McCullers Jr. (12-4)#30
Sat, Jul 3rdvs HOUJake Odorizzi (6-7)#77vs HOUJake Odorizzi (6-7)#77
Sun, Jul 4thvs HOUZack Greinke (11-6)#27vs HOUZack Greinke (11-6)#27
Mon, Jul 5th@ TBRich Hill (6-7)#64@ TBRich Hill (6-7)#64
Wed, Jul 7th@ TBCollin McHugh (6-1)#141@ TBCollin McHugh (6-1)#141
Thu, Jul 8thvs KCDanny Duffy (4-3)#116vs KCDanny Duffy (4-3)#116
Fri, Jul 9thvs KCBrad Keller (8-12)#199vs KCBrad Keller (8-12)#199
Sat, Jul 10thvs KCMike Minor (8-12)#78vs KCMike Minor (8-12)#78
Fri, Jul 16th@ OAKSean Manaea (10-9)#35@ OAKSean Manaea (10-9)#35
Sat, Jul 17th@ OAKFrankie Montas (12-9)#17@ OAKFrankie Montas (12-9)#17
Sun, Jul 18th@ OAKChris Bassitt (12-4)#20@ OAKChris Bassitt (12-4)#20
Mon, Jul 19th@ HOUZack Greinke (11-6)#27@ HOUZack Greinke (11-6)#27
Tue, Jul 20th@ HOULuis Garcia (11-7)#40@ HOULuis Garcia (11-7)#40
Wed, Jul 21st@ HOULance McCullers Jr. (12-4)#30@ HOULance McCullers Jr. (12-4)#30
Thu, Jul 22ndvs TBLuis Patino (4-3)#114vs TBLuis Patino (4-3)#114
Fri, Jul 23rdvs TBJosh Fleming (10-6)#123vs TBJosh Fleming (10-6)#123
Sat, Jul 24thvs TBDrew Rasmussen (3-1)#130vs TBDrew Rasmussen (3-1)#130
Sun, Jul 25thvs TBRyan Yarbrough (8-5)#121vs TBRyan Yarbrough (8-5)#121
Tue, Jul 27thvs STLAdam Wainwright (16-7)#3vs STLAdam Wainwright (16-7)#3
Wed, Jul 28thvs STLKwang Hyun Kim (6-7)#83vs STLKwang Hyun Kim (6-7)#83
Fri, Jul 30th@ CWSLance Lynn (10-4)#13@ CWSLance Lynn (10-4)#13
Sat, Jul 31st@ CWSDallas Keuchel (8-9)#176@ CWSDallas Keuchel (8-9)#176
Sun, Aug 1st@ CWSJimmy Lambert (1-1)#268@ CWSJimmy Lambert (1-1)#268
Mon, Aug 2nd@ TORRobbie Ray (12-5)#11@ TORRobbie Ray (12-5)#11
Tue, Aug 3rd@ TORHyun Jin Ryu (13-8)#43@ TORHyun Jin Ryu (13-8)#43
Wed, Aug 4th@ TORSteven Matz (12-7)#69@ TORSteven Matz (12-7)#69
Thu, Aug 5th@ TORRoss Stripling (5-6)#62@ TORRoss Stripling (5-6)#62
Fri, Aug 6thvs DETMatt Manning (4-6)#243vs DETMatt Manning (4-6)#243
Sat, Aug 7thvs DETTyler Alexander (2-3)#148vs DETTyler Alexander (2-3)#148
Sun, Aug 8thvs DETWily Peralta (3-3)#212vs DETWily Peralta (3-3)#212
Mon, Aug 9thvs CINLuis Castillo (7-15)#44vs CINLuis Castillo (7-15)#44
Tue, Aug 10thvs OAKSean Manaea (10-9)#35vs OAKSean Manaea (10-9)#35
Wed, Aug 11thvs OAKFrankie Montas (12-9)#17vs OAKFrankie Montas (12-9)#17
Thu, Aug 12thvs OAKChris Bassitt (12-4)#20vs OAKChris Bassitt (12-4)#20
Fri, Aug 13th@ DETTyler Alexander (2-3)#148@ DETTyler Alexander (2-3)#148
Sat, Aug 14th@ DETWily Peralta (3-3)#212@ DETWily Peralta (3-3)#212
Sun, Aug 15th@ DETDrew Hutchison (1-1)#288@ DETDrew Hutchison (1-1)#288
Mon, Aug 16th@ MINGriffin Jax (3-4)#224@ MINGriffin Jax (3-4)#224
Tue, Aug 17th@ MINBailey Ober (2-2)#147@ MINBailey Ober (2-2)#147
Wed, Aug 18th@ MINLewis Thorpe (0-2)#208@ MINLewis Thorpe (0-2)#208
Fri, Aug 20thvs LAAJaime Barria (2-3)#198vs LAAJaime Barria (2-3)#198
Sat, Aug 21stvs LAAReid Detmers (1-3)#271vs LAAReid Detmers (1-3)#271
Sun, Aug 22ndvs LAAJose Suarez (7-7)#99vs LAAJose Suarez (7-7)#99
Tue, Aug 24thvs TEXTaylor Hearn (6-4)#122vs TEXTaylor Hearn (6-4)#122
Wed, Aug 25thvs TEXJake Latz (0-1)#344vs TEXJake Latz (0-1)#344
Thu, Aug 26thvs TEXJordan Lyles (9-11)#167vs TEXJordan Lyles (9-11)#167
Fri, Aug 27thvs BOSEduardo Rodriguez (11-8)#91vs BOSEduardo Rodriguez (11-8)#91
Sat, Aug 28thvs BOSNathan Eovaldi (10-8)#29vs BOSNathan Eovaldi (10-8)#29
Sun, Aug 29thvs BOSTanner Houck (0-4)#261vs BOSTanner Houck (0-4)#261
Tue, Aug 31st@ KCJakob Junis (2-4)#192@ KCJakob Junis (2-4)#192
Wed, Sep 1st@ KCJackson Kowar (0-3)#169@ KCJackson Kowar (0-3)#169
Thu, Sep 2nd@ KCMike Minor (8-12)#78@ KCMike Minor (8-12)#78
Fri, Sep 3rd@ BOSNathan Eovaldi (10-8)#29@ BOSNathan Eovaldi (10-8)#29
Sat, Sep 4th@ BOSTanner Houck (0-4)#261@ BOSTanner Houck (0-4)#261
Sun, Sep 5th@ BOSKutter Crawford (0-1)#359@ BOSKutter Crawford (0-1)#359
Mon, Sep 6thvs MINBailey Ober (2-2)#147vs MINBailey Ober (2-2)#147
Tue, Sep 7thvs MINJohn Gant (5-9)#157vs MINJohn Gant (5-9)#157
Wed, Sep 8thvs MINJoe Ryan (1-1)#258vs MINJoe Ryan (1-1)#258
Thu, Sep 9thvs MINAndrew Albers (1-2)#273vs MINAndrew Albers (1-2)#273
Fri, Sep 10thvs MILAdrian Houser (9-6)#60vs MILAdrian Houser (9-6)#60
Sat, Sep 11thvs MILCorbin Burnes (10-4)#5vs MILCorbin Burnes (10-4)#5
Sun, Sep 12thvs MILEric Lauer (6-5)#113vs MILEric Lauer (6-5)#113
Tue, Sep 14th@ MINCharlie Barnes (0-3)#241@ MINCharlie Barnes (0-3)#241
Wed, Sep 15th@ MINGriffin Jax (3-4)#224@ MINGriffin Jax (3-4)#224
Fri, Sep 17th@ NYYCorey Kluber (4-3)#72@ NYYCorey Kluber (4-3)#72
Sat, Sep 18th@ NYYLuis Gil (1-0)#235@ NYYLuis Gil (1-0)#235
Sun, Sep 19th@ NYYGerrit Cole (15-7)#8@ NYYGerrit Cole (15-7)#8
Mon, Sep 20thvs KCCarlos Hernandez (6-2)#165vs KCCarlos Hernandez (6-2)#165
Tue, Sep 21stvs KCDaniel Lynch (4-5)#401vs KCDaniel Lynch (4-5)#401
Wed, Sep 22ndvs KCBrady Singer (4-10)#138vs KCBrady Singer (4-10)#138
Thu, Sep 23rdvs CWSLance Lynn (10-4)#13vs CWSLance Lynn (10-4)#13
Fri, Sep 24thvs CWSLucas Giolito (9-9)#16vs CWSLucas Giolito (9-9)#16
Sat, Sep 25thvs CWSvs CWS
Sun, Sep 26thvs CWSvs CWS
Tue, Sep 28th@ KC@ KC
Wed, Sep 29th@ KC@ KC
Thu, Sep 30th@ KC@ KC
Fri, Oct 1st@ TEX@ TEX
Sat, Oct 2nd@ TEX@ TEX
Sun, Oct 3rd@ TEX@ TEX