Who Should I Trade?

Carlos Vargas for Ryan McMahon (2026)

See if your team wins or loses with this trade View Trade Analyzer

Who Should I Trade? Player Summaries
 
Experts' Pick
 
  Ryan McMahon
3B - NYY
Ryan McMahon
Carlos Vargas
3B,SS - FA
Carlos Vargas
Expert
Recommendation
100%
Recommended by
2 of 2 experts
0%
Recommended by
0 of 2 experts
Rankings 
   
Rest of Season# 350‐
VBR# 362‐
   
Projections 
   
Runs6‐
Home Runs2‐
RBI6‐
Stolen Bases0‐
Batting Average.220‐
   
Misc 
   
Injury Alert-FA
   
Expert Ranks 
   
Kelly Kirby
FantasyPros		# 294‐
   
Kevin Spinelli
KevScores		# 403‐
   
Who Should I Trade? Player Statistics
  Ryan McMahon
3B - NYY
Ryan McMahon
Carlos Vargas
3B,SS - FA
Carlos Vargas
2026 Stats 
   
   
At Bats292‐
   
Runs29‐
   
Hits63‐
   
Singles40‐
   
Doubles13‐
   
Triples0‐
   
Home Runs10‐
   
RBI33‐
   
Stolen Bases3‐
   
Caught Stealing2‐
   
Walks26‐
   
Strikeouts96‐
   
Batting Average.216‐
   
On Base Pct.284‐
   
Slugging Pct.363‐
   
On-base Plus Slugging.647‐
   
Who Should I Trade? Player Projections
  Ryan McMahon
3B - NYY
Ryan McMahon
Carlos Vargas
3B,SS - FA
Carlos Vargas
2026 Projections 
   
   
At Bats47‐
   
Runs6‐
   
Hits10‐
   
Singles6‐
   
Doubles2‐
   
Triples0‐
   
Home Runs2‐
   
RBI6‐
   
Stolen Bases0‐
   
Caught Stealing0‐
   
Walks6‐
   
Strikeouts16‐
   
Batting Average.220‐
   
On Base Pct.305‐
   
Slugging Pct.390‐
   
On-base Plus Slugging.695‐
   
Who Should I Trade? Player Notes
  Ryan McMahon
3B - NYY
Ryan McMahon
Carlos Vargas
3B,SS - FA
Carlos Vargas
News 
 The Yankees activated 3B Ryan McMahon from the 10-day injured list.
Ari Koslow
Tue, Sep 1st		 
 Yankees manager Aaron Boone said that Ryan McMahon will rejoin the team on Tuesday.
Ari Koslow
Tue, Sep 1st		 
 Yankees manager Aaron Boone said Ryan McMahon could be activated when the rosters expand.
Ari Koslow
Tue, Sep 1st		 
 The Yankees placed Ryan McMahon on the injured list.
Ari Koslow
Fri, Aug 21st		 
 Ryan McMahon is not in the Yankees lineup on Thursday against the Orioles.
Ari Koslow
Thu, Aug 20th		 
Notes 
There are no recent notes for these players
Who Should I Trade? Player Schedules
  Ryan McMahon
3B - NYY
Ryan McMahon
Carlos Vargas
3B,SS - FA
Carlos Vargas
Date OppOpp PitcherVBROppOpp PitcherVBR
Wed, Mar 25th@ SFLogan Webb (8-8)#21   
Fri, Mar 27th@ SFRobbie Ray (11-8)#106   
Sat, Mar 28th@ SFTyler Mahle (5-10)#70   
Mon, Mar 30th@ SEALuis Castillo (4-11)#98   
Tue, Mar 31st@ SEALogan Gilbert (11-9)#16   
Wed, Apr 1st@ SEAGeorge Kirby (9-11)#24   
Fri, Apr 3rdvs MIAEury Perez (7-11)#45   
Sat, Apr 4thvs MIAMax Meyer (9-1)   
Sun, Apr 5thvs MIAPete Fairbanks   
Tue, Apr 7thvs ATHAaron Civale (6-7)#174   
Wed, Apr 8thvs ATHLuis Severino (2-6)   
Thu, Apr 9thvs ATHJeffrey Springs (4-13)#245   
Fri, Apr 10th@ TBSteven Matz (5-5)#197   
Sat, Apr 11th@ TBNick Martinez (14-4)#84   
Sun, Apr 12th@ TBDrew Rasmussen (14-5)#19   
Mon, Apr 13thvs LAAYusei Kikuchi (1-5)#81   
Tue, Apr 14thvs LAAReid Detmers (5-8)#22   
Wed, Apr 15thvs LAAJack Kochanowicz (2-5)   
Thu, Apr 16thvs LAABrent Suter (2-2)#242   
Fri, Apr 17thvs KCMichael Wacha (9-8)#78   
Sat, Apr 18thvs KCNoah Cameron (9-8)#91   
Sun, Apr 19thvs KCCole Ragans (1-4)   
Tue, Apr 21st@ BOSConnelly Early (7-5)#183   
Wed, Apr 22nd@ BOSRanger Suarez (6-4)#36   
Thu, Apr 23rd@ BOSPayton Tolle (9-6)#31   
Fri, Apr 24th@ HOULance McCullers Jr. (2-3)   
Sat, Apr 25th@ HOUMike Burrows (4-9)#287   
Sun, Apr 26th@ HOUSpencer Arrighetti (7-9)#150   
Mon, Apr 27th@ TEXJack Leiter (3-7)#189   
Tue, Apr 28th@ TEXJacob deGrom (10-9)#12   
Wed, Apr 29th@ TEXNathan Eovaldi (10-9)#162   
Fri, May 1stvs BALCade Povich (2-1)#236   
Sat, May 2ndvs BALKyle Bradish (7-13)#54   
Sun, May 3rdvs BALTrey Gibson (1-3)#336   
Mon, May 4thvs BALShane Baz (5-15)#75   
Tue, May 5thvs TEXJacob deGrom (10-9)#12   
Wed, May 6thvs TEXNathan Eovaldi (10-9)#162   
Thu, May 7thvs TEXMacKenzie Gore (8-10)#48   
Fri, May 8th@ MILJacob Misiorowski (14-5)#13   
Sat, May 9th@ MILKyle Harrison (10-4)#63   
Sun, May 10th@ MILLogan Henderson (9-3)#25   
Mon, May 11th@ BALBrandon Young (9-4)#123   
Tue, May 12th@ BALTrevor Rogers (10-9)#53   
Wed, May 13th@ BALKyle Bradish (7-13)#54   
Fri, May 15th@ NYMClay Holmes (6-7)#68   
Sat, May 16th@ NYMHuascar Brazoban (5-2)#282   
Sun, May 17th@ NYMFreddy Peralta (8-11)#51   
Mon, May 18thvs TORPatrick Corbin (3-4)   
Tue, May 19thvs TORDylan Cease (10-5)#6   
Wed, May 20thvs TORTrey Yesavage (5-5)#214   
Thu, May 21stvs TORBraydon Fisher (3-4)#159   
Fri, May 22ndvs TBNick Martinez (14-4)#84   
Sun, May 24thvs TBDrew Rasmussen (14-5)#19   
Mon, May 25th@ KCMichael Wacha (9-8)#78   
Tue, May 26th@ KCBailey Falter (0-2)   
Wed, May 27th@ KCNoah Cameron (9-8)#91   
Fri, May 29th@ ATHLuis Severino (2-6)   
Sat, May 30th@ ATHJ.T. Ginn (9-8)#254   
Sun, May 31st@ ATHJacob Lopez (6-4)#139   
Tue, Jun 2ndvs CLEJoey Cantillo (9-9)#72   
Wed, Jun 3rdvs CLEGavin Williams (13-7)#20   
Thu, Jun 4thvs CLESlade Cecconi (4-7)#180   
Fri, Jun 5thvs BOSSonny Gray (17-4)#38   
Sun, Jun 7thvs BOSRanger Suarez (6-4)#36   
Mon, Jun 8th@ CLEGavin Williams (13-7)#20   
Tue, Jun 9th@ CLESlade Cecconi (4-7)#180   
Wed, Jun 10th@ CLEParker Messick (11-9)#32   
Fri, Jun 12th@ TORTrey Yesavage (5-5)#214   
Sat, Jun 13th@ TORKevin Gausman (9-11)#23   
Sun, Jun 14th@ TORPatrick Corbin (3-4)   
Tue, Jun 16thvs CWSDavis Martin (9-6)#99   
Wed, Jun 17thvs CWSAnthony Kay (9-8)#147   
Thu, Jun 18thvs CWSBryan Hudson (4-4)#145   
Fri, Jun 19thvs CINRhett Lowder (6-9)#228   
Sat, Jun 20thvs CINAndrew Abbott (6-10)#130   
Sun, Jun 21stvs CINChase Burns (15-3)#34   
Mon, Jun 22nd@ DETFramber Valdez (9-10)#44   
Tue, Jun 23rd@ DETCasey Mize (5-9)#52   
Wed, Jun 24th@ DETTarik Skubal (9-7)#2   
Thu, Jun 25th@ BOSConnelly Early (7-5)#183   
Fri, Jun 26th@ BOSPayton Tolle (9-6)#31   
Sat, Jun 27th@ BOSJake Bennett (9-6)#74   
Sun, Jun 28th@ BOSSonny Gray (17-4)#38   
Mon, Jun 29thvs DETCasey Mize (5-9)#52   
Tue, Jun 30thvs DETTarik Skubal (9-7)#2   
Wed, Jul 1stvs DETTroy Melton (8-4)#61   
Fri, Jul 3rdvs MINMike Paredes (0-3)#339   
Sat, Jul 4thvs MINZebby Matthews (9-9)#92   
Sun, Jul 5thvs MINJoe Ryan (6-9)#29   
Mon, Jul 6th@ TBGriffin Jax (6-10)#30   
Tue, Jul 7th@ TBIan Seymour (9-6)#43   
Wed, Jul 8th@ TBShane McClanahan (10-7)#152   
Thu, Jul 9th@ TBDrew Rasmussen (14-5)#19   
Fri, Jul 10th@ WSHCarson Palmquist (0-2)#342   
Sat, Jul 11th@ WSHPJ Poulin (3-0)   
Sun, Jul 12th@ WSHCade Cavalli (12-5)#37   
Fri, Jul 17thvs LADRoki Sasaki (5-5)#178   
Sun, Jul 19thvs LADWill Klein (3-4)   
Mon, Jul 20thvs PITBraxton Ashcraft (14-6)#27   
Wed, Jul 22ndvs PITBubba Chandler (7-9)#117   
Fri, Jul 24th@ PHIJesus Luzardo (14-5)#8   
Sat, Jul 25th@ PHITim Mayza (3-3)#190   
Sun, Jul 26th@ PHICristopher Sanchez (16-5)#4   
Mon, Jul 27th@ CWSNoah Schultz (3-9)#309   
Tue, Jul 28th@ CWSAnthony Kay (9-8)#147   
Wed, Jul 29th@ CWSDavis Martin (9-6)#99   
Thu, Jul 30th@ CWSSean Burke (8-7)#65   
Fri, Jul 31st@ CHCShota Imanaga (9-10)#33   
Sat, Aug 1st@ CHCDavid Peterson (7-8)#109   
Sun, Aug 2nd@ CHCColin Rea (8-8)#211   
Mon, Aug 3rdvs STLMichael McGreevy (6-9)#107   
Tue, Aug 4thvs STLHunter Dobbins (3-3)   
Wed, Aug 5thvs STLAndre Pallante (12-6)#122   
Fri, Aug 7thvs ATLTyler Mahle (5-10)#70   
Sat, Aug 8thvs ATLChris Sale (14-9)#3   
Sun, Aug 9thvs ATLGrant Holmes (9-5)#155   
Tue, Aug 11thvs SEABryan Woo (11-9)#14   
Wed, Aug 12thvs SEABryce Miller (4-9)#50   
Thu, Aug 13thvs SEALogan Gilbert (11-9)#16   
Fri, Aug 14th@ TORShane Bieber (5-2)#198   
Sat, Aug 15th@ TORBraydon Fisher (3-4)#159   
Sun, Aug 16th@ TORDylan Cease (10-5)#6   
Tue, Aug 18th@ BALShane Baz (5-15)#75   
Wed, Aug 19th@ BALChris Bassitt (6-5)#141   
Thu, Aug 20th@ BALKyle Bradish (7-13)#54   
Fri, Aug 21stvs TORMason Fluharty (6-1)#165   
Sat, Aug 22ndvs TORDylan Cease (10-5)#6   
Sun, Aug 23rdvs TORJose Soriano (12-7)#40   
Tue, Aug 25thvs HOUEthan Pecko (1-0)#142   
Wed, Aug 26thvs HOUPeter Lambert (8-8)#137   
Thu, Aug 27thvs HOUHayden Wesneski (5-1)#86   
Fri, Aug 28thvs BOSPatrick Sandoval (1-5)#101   
Sat, Aug 29thvs BOSAlec Gamboa   
Sun, Aug 30thvs BOSRanger Suarez (6-4)#36   
Mon, Aug 31st@ LAAWalbert Urena (9-10)#168   
Tue, Sep 1st@ LAAGrayson Rodriguez (4-7)#102   
Wed, Sep 2nd@ LAAReid Detmers (5-8)#22   
Fri, Sep 4th@ SDWalker Buehler (8-6)#192   
Sat, Sep 5th@ SDRobbie Ray (11-8)#106   
Sun, Sep 6th@ SDMichael King (10-9)#58   
Tue, Sep 8thvs COLGabriel Hughes (0-7)#306   
Wed, Sep 9thvs COLTomoyuki Sugano (12-8)#411   
Thu, Sep 10thvs COLRyan Feltner (5-9)#410   
Fri, Sep 11thvs NYMNolan McLean (11-8)#35   
Sat, Sep 12thvs NYMZac Thornton (3-5)#125   
Sun, Sep 13thvs NYMChristian Scott (4-4)#39   
Mon, Sep 14th@ MINDean Kremer (3-5)#82   
Tue, Sep 15th@ MINZebby Matthews (9-9)#92   
Wed, Sep 16th@ MIN   
Fri, Sep 18th@ ARI   
Sat, Sep 19th@ ARI   
Sun, Sep 20th@ ARI   
Tue, Sep 22ndvs TB   
Wed, Sep 23rdvs TB   
Thu, Sep 24thvs TB   
Fri, Sep 25thvs BAL   
Sat, Sep 26thvs BAL   
Sun, Sep 27thvs BAL