Skip to main content

Who Should I Trade?

Dylan Carlson for Ryan McMahon (2023)


See if your team wins or loses with this trade View Trade Analyzer

Who Should I Trade? Player Summaries
 
Experts' Pick
 
  Ryan McMahon
2B,3B - COL
Ryan McMahon
Dylan Carlson
CF,LF,RF - STL
Dylan Carlson
Expert
Recommendation
93%
Recommended by
14 of 15 experts
7%
Recommended by
1 of 15 experts
Rankings 
   
Rest of Season# 103# 178
VBR# 49
   
Projections 
   
Runs20
Home Runs10
RBI20
Stolen Bases00
Batting Average.303.000
   
Misc 
   
Injury Alert-IL60
   
Expert Ranks 
   
Dalton Del Don
Yahoo! Sports
# 97
   
Christopher Welsh
FantasyPros
# 130# 191
   
Mike Maher
FantasyPros
# 76# 203
   
Aaron Schill
FF Faceoff
# 93# 163
   
Keith Lott
Fantasy Six Pack
# 128
   
Mick Ciallela
Fantrax
# 86# 238
   
Lucas Spence
Pitcher List
# 116# 168
   
Nate Miller
FantasyPros
# 115# 207
   
Joe Pisapia
FantasyPros
# 116# 143
   
Scott Youngson
Pitcher List
# 57
   
Ethan Biddle
FantasyPros
# 117# 161
   
Jesse Garcia
FantasyPros
# 108
   
Kelly Kirby
FantasyPros
# 111# 158
   
Blake Meyer
FantasyPros
# 128
   
Brandon 'B_Don' Myers
Razzball
# 187# 143
   
Who Should I Trade? Player Statistics
  Ryan McMahon
2B,3B - COL
Ryan McMahon
Dylan Carlson
CF,LF,RF - STL
Dylan Carlson
2023 Stats 
   
   
At Bats547219
   
Runs8027
   
Hits13348
   
Singles7634
   
Doubles318
   
Triples31
   
Home Runs235
   
RBI7027
   
Stolen Bases53
   
Caught Stealing50
   
Walks6826
   
Strikeouts19249
   
Batting Average.243.219
   
On Base Pct.326.318
   
Slugging Pct.437.333
   
On-base Plus Slugging.763.651
   
Who Should I Trade? Player Projections
  Ryan McMahon
2B,3B - COL
Ryan McMahon
Dylan Carlson
CF,LF,RF - STL
Dylan Carlson
2023 Projections 
   
   
At Bats140
   
Runs20
   
Hits40
   
Singles20
   
Doubles10
   
Triples00
   
Home Runs10
   
RBI20
   
Stolen Bases00
   
Caught Stealing00
   
Walks10
   
Strikeouts40
   
Batting Average.303.000
   
On Base Pct.370.000
   
Slugging Pct.598.000
   
On-base Plus Slugging.969.000
   
Who Should I Trade? Player Notes
  Ryan McMahon
2B,3B - COL
Ryan McMahon
Dylan Carlson
CF,LF,RF - STL
Dylan Carlson
News 
 Ryan McMahon went 3-for-4 with a home run in Wednesday's game.
Nate Miller - FantasyPros
Thu, Sep 14th
The St. Louis Cardinals have transferred outfielder Dylan Carlson to the 60-day injured list on Friday.
Brenton Kemp
Fri, Sep 22nd
 With 3 RBI, 1 hit, and 3 runs scored, McMahon's contributions played a significant role in the team's 14-1 win.
Jesse Garcia
Sat, Aug 19th
Cardinals OF Dylan Carlson will undergo season-ending surgery on his left ankle.
Jesse Garcia
Wed, Sep 13th
 Ryan McMahon had a solid performance at the plate on Tuesday, going 2-for-4 with a home run, four RBI, and two runs scored, but it wasn't enough to propel the Rockies to victory as they fell to the Padres by a score of 8-5.
Matthew Terelle
Wed, Aug 2nd
MLB Teams are reportedly calling on Cardinals OF Dylan Carlson but they are unlikely to move him unless they get a young MLB starting pitcher back.
Ari Koslow
Tue, Aug 1st
 Ryan McMahon launched his 17th homer as part of Monday's win over the Padres.
Brenton Kemp
Tue, Aug 1st
The St. Louis Cardinals and Baltimore Orioles have had discussions surrounding outfielder Dylan Carlson.
Brenton Kemp
Mon, Jul 31st
 Ryan McMahon went 2-for-4 with a home run, one RBI, and one run scored, helping the Rockies secure a 4-3 win against the Astros.
Matthew Terelle
Wed, Jul 19th
Cardinals outfielder Dylan Carlson is back in the starting lineup Thursday versus the Cubs.
Brenton Kemp
Thu, Jul 27th
Notes 
There are no recent notes for these players
Who Should I Trade? Player Schedules
  Ryan McMahon
2B,3B - COL
Ryan McMahon
Dylan Carlson
CF,LF,RF - STL
Dylan Carlson
Date OppOpp PitcherVBROppOpp PitcherVBR
Thu, Mar 30th@ SDBlake Snell (14-9)#15vs TORAlek Manoah (3-9)
Sat, Apr 1st@ SDMichael Wacha (13-4)#46vs TORKevin Gausman (12-9)#1
Sun, Apr 2nd@ SDSeth Lugo (8-7)#59vs TORChris Bassitt (15-8)#13
Mon, Apr 3rd@ LADMichael Grove (2-3)#190vs ATLCharlie Morton (14-12)
Tue, Apr 4th@ LADJulio Urias (11-8)vs ATLDylan Dodd (2-2)
Wed, Apr 5th   vs ATLBryce Elder (12-4)#71
Fri, Apr 7thvs WSHMacKenzie Gore (7-10)@ MILBrandon Woodruff (5-1)#2
Sat, Apr 8thvs WSHTrevor Williams (6-10)#226@ MILEric Lauer (4-5)
Sun, Apr 9thvs WSHChad Kuhl (0-4)@ MILFreddy Peralta (12-10)#16
Mon, Apr 10thvs STLSteven Matz (4-7)@ COLGerman Marquez (2-2)
Tue, Apr 11thvs STLMiles Mikolas (8-13)#48@ COLKyle Freeland (6-14)
Wed, Apr 12thvs STLJack Flaherty (8-9)#80@ COLJose Urena (0-7)#223
Thu, Apr 13th   vs PITVince Velasquez (4-4)
Fri, Apr 14th@ SEATommy Milonevs PITJohan Oviedo (9-14)#176
Sat, Apr 15th@ SEAGeorge Kirby (12-10)#32vs PITRoansy Contreras (3-7)
Sun, Apr 16th@ SEALuis Castillo (14-8)#12vs PITMitch Keller (13-9)#37
Mon, Apr 17thvs PITRich Hill (7-14)#184vs ARIMerrill Kelly (12-7)#74
Tue, Apr 18thvs PITVince Velasquez (4-4)vs ARIDrey Jameson (3-1)
Wed, Apr 19thvs PITJohan Oviedo (9-14)#176vs ARIMadison Bumgarner (0-3)
Fri, Apr 21st@ PHIAaron Nola (12-9)#3@ SEAGeorge Kirby (12-10)#32
Sat, Apr 22nd@ PHICristopher Sanchez (3-5)#50@ SEALuis Castillo (14-8)#12
Sun, Apr 23rd@ PHIZack Wheeler (13-6)#5@ SEAChris Flexen (1-8)#233
Mon, Apr 24th@ CLECal Quantrill (3-7)#73@ SFAlex Cobb (7-7)
Tue, Apr 25th@ CLEPeyton Battenfield (0-5)#188@ SFJohn Brebbia (3-4)#112
Wed, Apr 26th@ CLETanner Bibee (10-4)@ SFAnthony DeSclafani (4-8)
Thu, Apr 27th   @ SFLogan Webb (11-13)#31
Fri, Apr 28thvs ARIMerrill Kelly (12-7)#74@ LADDustin May (4-1)
Sat, Apr 29thvs ARITommy Henry (5-4)@ LADClayton Kershaw (13-4)#30
Sun, Apr 30thvs ARIRyne Nelson (8-8)#199@ LADNoah Syndergaard (2-6)#62
Tue, May 2ndvs MILFreddy Peralta (12-10)#16vs LAAPatrick Sandoval (7-13)
Wed, May 3rdvs MILEric Lauer (4-5)vs LAAShohei Ohtani (10-5)
Thu, May 4thvs MILWade Miley (9-4)#195vs LAAGriffin Canning (7-8)#64
Fri, May 5th@ NYMKodai Senga (12-7)#21vs DETMatthew Boyd (5-5)
Sat, May 6th@ NYMTylor Megill (8-8)#205vs DETSpencer Turnbull (1-4)#136
Sun, May 7th@ NYMJoey Lucchesi (4-0)#55vs DETAlex Faedo (2-5)
Mon, May 8th@ PITMitch Keller (13-9)#37@ CHCMarcus Stroman (10-8)#78
Tue, May 9th@ PITLuis L. Ortiz (4-5)#225@ CHCJameson Taillon (8-10)#90
Wed, May 10th@ PITRich Hill (7-14)#184@ CHCJustin Steele (16-5)#27
Fri, May 12thvs PHITaijuan Walker (15-5)#93@ BOSJames Paxton (7-5)
Sat, May 13thvs PHIRanger Suarez (4-6)#110@ BOSChris Sale (6-4)#39
Sun, May 14thvs PHIAaron Nola (12-9)#3@ BOSCorey Kluber (3-6)
Mon, May 15thvs CINHunter Greene (4-6)#36vs MILFreddy Peralta (12-10)#16
Tue, May 16thvs CINBrandon Williamson (4-5)#151vs MILWade Miley (9-4)#195
Wed, May 17thvs CINGraham Ashcraft (7-9)vs MILCorbin Burnes (10-8)#6
Thu, May 18th   vs LADJulio Urias (11-8)
Fri, May 19th@ TEXMartin Perez (10-4)#107vs LADTony Gonsolin (8-5)
Sat, May 20th@ TEXJon Gray (9-8)#29vs LADNoah Syndergaard (2-6)#62
Sun, May 21st@ TEXAndrew Heaney (10-6)#156vs LADClayton Kershaw (13-4)#30
Mon, May 22ndvs MIAEdward Cabrera (7-7)#58@ CINBrandon Williamson (4-5)#151
Tue, May 23rdvs MIAEury Perez (5-6)@ CINGraham Ashcraft (7-9)
Wed, May 24thvs MIASandy Alcantara (7-12)@ CINBen Lively (4-7)#218
Thu, May 25thvs MIABraxton Garrett (9-7)#63@ CINLuke Weaver (3-5)#220
Fri, May 26thvs NYMMax Scherzer (13-6)@ CLEShane Bieber (6-6)#17
Sat, May 27thvs NYMJustin Verlander (12-8)#33@ CLETanner Bibee (10-4)
Sun, May 28thvs NYMTylor Megill (8-8)#205@ CLEHunter Gaddis (2-1)
Mon, May 29th@ ARIRyne Nelson (8-8)#199vs KCJosh Staumont
Tue, May 30th@ ARIZac Gallen (17-8)#7vs KCZack Greinke (1-15)#125
Fri, Jun 2nd@ KCJordan Lyles (5-17)#221@ PITRoansy Contreras (3-7)
Sat, Jun 3rd@ KCDaniel Lynch (3-4)#206@ PITLuis L. Ortiz (4-5)#225
Sun, Jun 4th@ KCBrady Singer (8-11)@ PITRich Hill (7-14)#184
Mon, Jun 5th   @ TEXMartin Perez (10-4)#107
Tue, Jun 6thvs SFJohn Brebbia (3-4)#112@ TEXDane Dunning (12-6)#76
Wed, Jun 7thvs SFLogan Webb (11-13)#31@ TEXJon Gray (9-8)#29
Fri, Jun 9thvs SDYu Darvish (8-10)vs CINBen Lively (4-7)#218
Sat, Jun 10thvs SDRyan Weathers (1-8)#173vs CINAndrew Abbott (8-6)#111
Sun, Jun 11thvs SDBlake Snell (14-9)#15vs CINHunter Greene (4-6)#36
Mon, Jun 12th@ BOSJames Paxton (7-5)vs SFLogan Webb (11-13)#31
Tue, Jun 13th@ BOSKutter Crawford (6-8)#67vs SFAlex Cobb (7-7)
Wed, Jun 14th@ BOSGarrett Whitlock (5-5)#98vs SFAnthony DeSclafani (4-8)
Fri, Jun 16th@ ATLJared Shuster (4-3)@ NYMTylor Megill (8-8)#205
Sat, Jun 17th@ ATLBryce Elder (12-4)#71@ NYMKodai Senga (12-7)#21
Sun, Jun 18th@ ATLCharlie Morton (14-12)@ NYMCarlos Carrasco (3-8)
Mon, Jun 19th@ CINBrandon Williamson (4-5)#151@ WSHJosiah Gray (8-13)#219
Tue, Jun 20th@ CINBen Lively (4-7)#218@ WSHMacKenzie Gore (7-10)
Wed, Jun 21st@ CINAndrew Abbott (8-6)#111@ WSHTrevor Williams (6-10)#226
Sat, Jun 24thvs LAAGriffin Canning (7-8)#64vs CHCJustin Steele (16-5)#27
Sun, Jun 25thvs LAATyler Anderson (6-6)vs CHCMarcus Stroman (10-8)#78
Tue, Jun 27thvs LADClayton Kershaw (13-4)#30vs HOUFramber Valdez (12-11)#10
Wed, Jun 28thvs LADMichael Grove (2-3)#190vs HOUCristian Javier (9-5)#61
Thu, Jun 29thvs LADEmmet Sheehan (4-1)#89vs HOUJ.P. France (11-6)#77
Sat, Jul 1stvs DETBrendan Whitevs NYYIan Hamilton (3-2)#134
Sun, Jul 2ndvs DETMatt Manning (5-4)vs NYYGerrit Cole (15-4)#9
Mon, Jul 3rd   @ MIABraxton Garrett (9-7)#63
Tue, Jul 4th@ HOUBrandon Bielak (5-6)@ MIAJesus Luzardo (10-9)#26
Wed, Jul 5th@ HOUJ.P. France (11-6)#77@ MIABryan Hoeing (2-2)#129
Thu, Jul 6th   @ MIAEury Perez (5-6)
Fri, Jul 7th@ SFRoss Stripling (0-5)#65@ CWSDylan Cease (7-8)#35
Sat, Jul 8th@ SFRyan Walker (4-3)#115@ CWSTouki Toussaint (4-7)#165
Sun, Jul 9th@ SFLogan Webb (11-13)#31@ CWSLucas Giolito (8-14)#87
Sat, Jul 15thvs NYYClarke Schmidt (9-9)#88vs WSHJake Irvin (3-7)
Sun, Jul 16thvs NYYGerrit Cole (15-4)#9vs WSHJosiah Gray (8-13)#219
Mon, Jul 17th   vs MIAJesus Luzardo (10-9)#26
Tue, Jul 18thvs HOUHunter Brown (11-13)#102vs MIAEdward Cabrera (7-7)#58
Wed, Jul 19thvs HOUBrandon Bielak (5-6)vs MIASandy Alcantara (7-12)
Thu, Jul 20th   @ CHCMarcus Stroman (10-8)#78
Fri, Jul 21st@ MIABraxton Garrett (9-7)#63@ CHCJustin Steele (16-5)#27
Sat, Jul 22nd@ MIAJohnny Cueto (1-4)#183@ CHCMichael Fulmer
Sun, Jul 23rd@ MIAJesus Luzardo (10-9)#26@ CHCJameson Taillon (8-10)#90
Mon, Jul 24th@ WSHPatrick Corbin (10-15)#229@ ARIRyne Nelson (8-8)#199
Tue, Jul 25th@ WSHTrevor Williams (6-10)#226@ ARIMerrill Kelly (12-7)#74
Wed, Jul 26th@ WSHJake Irvin (3-7)@ ARIZac Gallen (17-8)#7
Thu, Jul 27th   vs CHCJustin Steele (16-5)#27
Fri, Jul 28thvs OAKJP Sears (5-13)#44vs CHCHayden Wesneski (2-5)#179
Sat, Jul 29thvs OAKPaul Blackburn (4-7)#103vs CHCJameson Taillon (8-10)#90
Sun, Jul 30thvs OAKLuis Medina (3-10)#214vs CHCKyle Hendricks (6-8)#72
Tue, Aug 1stvs SDPedro Avila (2-2)#119vs MINPablo Lopez (11-8)#18
Wed, Aug 2ndvs SDNick Martinez (5-4)#142vs MINJoe Ryan (11-10)#68
Thu, Aug 3rd   vs MINSonny Gray (8-8)#45
Fri, Aug 4th@ STLAdam Wainwright (5-11)vs COLChris Flexen (1-8)#233
Sat, Aug 5th@ STLSteven Matz (4-7)vs COLTy Blach (3-3)#228
Sun, Aug 6th@ STLZack Thompson (5-7)#127vs COLAustin Gomber (9-9)
Tue, Aug 8th@ MILWade Miley (9-4)#195@ TBZach Eflin (16-8)#51
Wed, Aug 9th@ MILAdrian Houser (7-5)#211@ TBJalen Beeks (2-3)
Thu, Aug 10th@ LADClayton Kershaw (13-4)#30@ TBZack Littell (3-6)#66
Fri, Aug 11th@ LADLance Lynn (12-11)#25@ KCDylan Coleman
Sat, Aug 12th@ LADTony Gonsolin (8-5)@ KCCole Ragans (7-4)#52
Mon, Aug 14thvs ARIMerrill Kelly (12-7)#74vs OAKJP Sears (5-13)#44
Tue, Aug 15thvs ARIJoe Mantiply (2-2)#196vs OAKSpenser Watkins (0-1)
Wed, Aug 16thvs ARISlade Cecconi (0-1)#124vs OAKPaul Blackburn (4-7)#103
Thu, Aug 17th   vs NYMJose Quintana (3-6)#94
Fri, Aug 18thvs CWSMichael Kopech (5-12)vs NYMJoey Lucchesi (4-0)#55
Sat, Aug 19thvs CWSJesse Scholtens (1-9)vs NYMKodai Senga (12-7)#21
Sun, Aug 20thvs CWSDylan Cease (7-8)#35vs NYMCarlos Carrasco (3-8)
Mon, Aug 21st   @ PITThomas Hatch (1-1)
Tue, Aug 22nd@ TBZack Littell (3-6)#66@ PITJohan Oviedo (9-14)#176
Wed, Aug 23rd@ TBAaron Civale (7-4)#42@ PITLuis L. Ortiz (4-5)#225
Fri, Aug 25th@ BALCole Irvin (1-4)@ PHICristopher Sanchez (3-5)#50
Sat, Aug 26th@ BALKyle Bradish (12-7)#85@ PHIZack Wheeler (13-6)#5
Sun, Aug 27th@ BALJack Flaherty (8-9)#80@ PHIAaron Nola (12-9)#3
Mon, Aug 28thvs ATLBryce Elder (12-4)#71vs SDBlake Snell (14-9)#15
Tue, Aug 29thvs ATLCharlie Morton (14-12)vs SDSeth Lugo (8-7)#59
Wed, Aug 30thvs ATLDarius Vines (1-0)#150vs SDRich Hill (7-14)#184
Fri, Sep 1stvs TORHyun Jin Ryu (3-3)#95vs PITMitch Keller (13-9)#37
Sat, Sep 2ndvs TORYusei Kikuchi (10-6)#69vs PITThomas Hatch (1-1)
Sun, Sep 3rdvs TORKevin Gausman (12-9)#1vs PITJohan Oviedo (9-14)#176
Tue, Sep 5th@ ARIBrandon Pfaadt (3-9)#47@ ATLMichael Soroka (2-2)
Wed, Sep 6th@ ARIZach Davies (2-5)@ ATLSpencer Strider (19-5)#4
Thu, Sep 7th   @ ATLMax Fried (8-1)
Fri, Sep 8th@ SFKyle Harrison (1-1)#79@ CINAndrew Abbott (8-6)#111
Sat, Sep 9th@ SFLogan Webb (11-13)#31@ CINCarson Spiers (0-1)
Sun, Sep 10th@ SFKeaton Winn (1-2)#164@ CINHunter Greene (4-6)#36
Mon, Sep 11thvs CHCJordan Wicks (4-1)#144@ BALDean Kremer (12-5)#117
Tue, Sep 12thvs CHCJavier Assad (5-3)#168@ BALJohn Means (1-1)#41
Wed, Sep 13thvs CHCJameson Taillon (8-10)#90@ BALKyle Gibson (15-9)#81
Fri, Sep 15thvs SFLogan Webb (11-13)#31vs PHIAaron Nola (12-9)#3
Sat, Sep 16thvs SFScott Alexander (7-3)vs PHIRanger Suarez (4-6)#110
Sun, Sep 17thvs SFSean Manaea (7-6)#96vs PHITaijuan Walker (15-5)#93
Mon, Sep 18th@ SDMichael Wacha (13-4)#46vs MILFreddy Peralta (12-10)#16
Tue, Sep 19th@ SDBlake Snell (14-9)#15vs MILTrevor Megill
Wed, Sep 20th@ SDSeth Lugo (8-7)#59vs MILAdrian Houser (7-5)#211
Thu, Sep 21st   vs MILWade Miley (9-4)#195
Fri, Sep 22nd@ CHCJameson Taillon (8-10)#90@ SDMatt Waldron (1-3)#175
Sat, Sep 23rd@ CHCMarcus Stroman (10-8)#78@ SDNick Martinez (5-4)#142
Sun, Sep 24th@ CHCJordan Wicks (4-1)#144@ SDMichael Wacha (13-4)#46
Tue, Sep 26thvs LADBobby Miller (11-4)#91@ MILAdrian Houser (7-5)#211
Wed, Sep 27thvs LADEmmet Sheehan (4-1)#89@ MILWade Miley (9-4)#195
Thu, Sep 28thvs LADRyan Yarbrough (8-6)#105@ MILCorbin Burnes (10-8)#6
Fri, Sep 29thvs MINJoe Ryan (11-10)#68vs CINBrandon Williamson (4-5)#151
Sat, Sep 30thvs MINvs CINConnor Phillips (1-0)
Sun, Oct 1stvs MINBailey Ober (8-6)#100vs CINHunter Greene (4-6)#36
Fri, Mar 31st@ SDNick Martinez (5-4)#142   
Thu, Apr 6thvs WSHJosiah Gray (8-13)#219   
Thu, Apr 20th@ PHIMatt Strahm (9-4)#86   
Wed, May 31st@ ARITommy Henry (5-4)   
Thu, Jun 1st@ ARIZach Davies (2-5)   
Thu, Jun 8thvs SFAlex Cobb (7-7)   
Thu, Jun 15th@ ATLAJ Smith-Shawver (1-0)#123   
Fri, Jun 23rdvs LAAPatrick Sandoval (7-13)   
Fri, Jun 30thvs DETMichael Lorenzen (9-9)#122   
Fri, Jul 14thvs NYYCarlos Rodon (3-7)#24   
Mon, Jul 31stvs SDSeth Lugo (8-7)#59   
Mon, Aug 7th@ MILFreddy Peralta (12-10)#16   
Sun, Aug 13th@ LADJulio Urias (11-8)   
Thu, Aug 24th@ TBShawn Armstrong (1-0)   
Mon, Sep 4th@ ARIMerrill Kelly (12-7)#74