Skip to main content

Who Should I Trade?

Frankie Montas for James Karinchak (2021)


See if your team wins or loses with this trade View Trade Analyzer

Who Should I Trade? Player Summaries
 
Experts' Pick
 
  Frankie Montas
SP - OAK
Frankie Montas
James Karinchak
RP - CLE
James Karinchak
Expert
Recommendation
63%
Recommended by
10 of 16 experts
38%
Recommended by
6 of 16 experts
Rankings 
   
Rest of Season# 41# 67
VBR# 101# 209
   
Projections 
   
Strikeouts117
Wins10
Saves01
ERA3.663.43
WHIP1.251.26
   
Misc 
   
Injury Alert-MiLB
   
Expert Ranks 
   
Mike Maher
FantasyPros
# 31# 64
   
Dan Harris
FantasyPros
# 37# 140
   
Pierre Camus
RotoBaller
# 28# 66
   
Mick Ciallela
Fantrax
# 30# 90
   
Ryan Amore
Pitcher List
# 55# 133
   
Brendan Tuma
FantasyPros
# 25# 109
   
Jordan Eisen
Field of Vision Sports
# 65# 74
   
Brad Camara
FantasyPros
# 64
   
Chris Clegg
Fantrax
# 53# 60
   
Joe Pisapia
FantasyPros
# 19# 59
   
Jorge B. Edwards
Fantasy In Frames
# 54# 51
   
Chris Mitchell
FantasyData
# 55# 52
   
Chris Meaney
FTN
# 66# 51
   
Joe Bond
Fantasy Six Pack
# 67# 58
   
Carmen Maiorano
FantasyPros
# 79# 40
   
Corbin Young
FantasyData
# 81# 58
   
Who Should I Trade? Player Statistics
  Frankie Montas
SP - OAK
Frankie Montas
James Karinchak
RP - CLE
James Karinchak
2021 Stats 
   
   
Games Played3059
   
Games Started300
   
Innings Pitched174.054.0
   
Wins127
   
Losses94
   
Saves011
   
Blown Saves05
   
Holds013
   
Hits Allowed15735
   
Earned Runs6925
   
Home Runs Allowed199
   
Strikeouts19277
   
Walks5332
   
ERA3.574.14
   
WHIP1.211.23
   
Who Should I Trade? Player Projections
  Frankie Montas
SP - OAK
Frankie Montas
James Karinchak
RP - CLE
James Karinchak
2021 Projections 
   
   
Games Played24
   
Games Started20
   
Innings Pitched10.34.4
   
Wins10
   
Losses00
   
Saves01
   
Blown Saves00
   
Holds01
   
Hits Allowed93
   
Earned Runs42
   
Home Runs Allowed11
   
Strikeouts117
   
Walks33
   
ERA3.663.43
   
WHIP1.251.26
   
Who Should I Trade? Player Notes
  Frankie Montas
SP - OAK
Frankie Montas
James Karinchak
RP - CLE
James Karinchak
News 
 Frankie Montas took the no-decision on Sunday against the Angels, allowing one hit over seven shutout innings with seven strikeouts and four walks.
Ari Koslow
Mon, Sep 20th
The Cleveland Indians have optioned reliever James Karinchak to Triple-A Columbus. His roster spot will go to first baseman Bobby Bradley, who was activated from the IL.
Andersen Pickard
Sat, Aug 28th
 Frankie Montas took the no-decision on Tuesday against the Royals, allowing four runs on eight hits over 3.1 innings with four strikeouts and two walks.
Ari Koslow
Wed, Sep 15th
Cleveland right-hander James Karinchak threw 1 1/3 scoreless innings in a 7-2 win over the Rangers on Wednesday. He struck out two and allowed just one hit.
Matthew Terelle
Thu, Aug 26th
 Frankie Montas earned the win on Wednesday against the White Sox, allowing one run on six hits over seven innings with seven strikeouts and two walks.
Ari Koslow
Thu, Sep 9th
Cleveland right-hander James Karinchak allowed a run in his lone inning of work in a 4-3 loss to Oakland on Tuesday.
Matthew Terelle
Wed, Aug 11th
 Frankie Montas earned the win against Detroit on Thursday, allowing three runs on five hits over 6.2 innings with seven strikeouts and three walks.
Ari Koslow
Fri, Sep 3rd
Cleveland right-hander James Karinchak allowed three runs in 1/3 of an inning in a 12-11 win over the White Sox on Saturday. He walked one and gave up two hits, including a two-run homer.
Matthew Terelle
Sun, Aug 1st
 Frankie Montas is having his next scheduled start bumped up to Thursday afternoon against Detroit.
Brendan Tuma - Too Much Tuma
Thu, Sep 2nd
Cleveland right-hander James Karinchak threw a scoreless eighth inning in a 3-2 win over the Rays on Sunday. He worked around one walk in the frame.
Matthew Terelle
Sun, Jul 25th
Notes 
There are no recent notes for these players
Who Should I Trade? Player Schedules
  Frankie Montas
SP - OAK
Frankie Montas
James Karinchak
RP - CLE
James Karinchak
Date OppOpp PitcherVBROppOpp PitcherVBR
Thu, Apr 1stvs HOUZack Greinke (11-6)#31@ DETMatthew Boyd (3-8)#135
Fri, Apr 2ndvs HOUCristian Javier (4-1)#93   
Sat, Apr 3rdvs HOULance McCullers Jr. (12-5)#24@ DETJulio Teheran (1-0)
Sun, Apr 4thvs HOUJose Urquidy (8-3)#87@ DETTarik Skubal (8-12)#71
Mon, Apr 5thvs LADDustin May (1-1)vs KCDanny Duffy (4-3)#100
Tue, Apr 6thvs LADClayton Kershaw (10-7)#22   
Wed, Apr 7thvs LADTrevor Bauer (8-5)vs KCJakob Junis (2-4)#169
Thu, Apr 8th@ HOUCristian Javier (4-1)#93   
Fri, Apr 9th@ HOULance McCullers Jr. (12-5)#24vs DETDerek Holland (3-2)#277
Sat, Apr 10th@ HOUJose Urquidy (8-3)#87vs DETTarik Skubal (8-12)#71
Mon, Apr 12th@ ARIMadison Bumgarner (7-10)#105@ CWSDallas Keuchel (8-9)#387
Tue, Apr 13th@ ARIZac Gallen (2-10)#91@ CWSLucas Giolito (10-9)#29
Thu, Apr 15thvs DETTarik Skubal (8-12)#71@ CWSLance Lynn (10-5)#16
Fri, Apr 16thvs DETJose Urena (4-8)#396@ CINJeff Hoffman (3-5)#215
Sat, Apr 17thvs DETCasey Mize (7-8)#65@ CINSonny Gray (7-8)#69
Sun, Apr 18thvs DETMatthew Boyd (3-8)#135@ CINWade Miley (12-7)#41
Tue, Apr 20thvs MINJose Berrios (12-8)#11vs CWSCarlos Rodon (12-5)#25
Wed, Apr 21stvs MINKenta Maeda (6-5)   
Fri, Apr 23rd@ BALJorge Lopez (3-14)vs NYYJordan Montgomery (6-6)#57
Sat, Apr 24th@ BALWade LeBlanc (0-2)#375vs NYYGerrit Cole (15-8)#7
Sun, Apr 25th@ BALJohn Means (6-7)#45vs NYYJameson Taillon (8-6)#83
Mon, Apr 26th@ TBRich Hill (6-7)#73vs MINJose Berrios (12-8)#11
Tue, Apr 27th@ TBMichael Wacha (3-5)#157vs MINKenta Maeda (6-5)
Wed, Apr 28th@ TBTyler Glasnow (5-2)vs MINJ.A. Happ (9-8)#239
Thu, Apr 29th@ TBShane McClanahan (9-6)#60   
Fri, Apr 30thvs BALJohn Means (6-7)#45@ CWSDallas Keuchel (8-9)#387
Sat, May 1stvs BALMatt Harvey (6-14)#401@ CWSLance Lynn (10-5)#16
Sun, May 2ndvs BALBruce Zimmermann (4-4)#359@ CWSLucas Giolito (10-9)#29
Mon, May 3rdvs TORSteven Matz (13-7)#54@ KCDaniel Lynch (4-6)#397
Tue, May 4thvs TORAnthony Kay (1-2)#347@ KCMike Minor (8-12)#86
Wed, May 5thvs TORRobbie Ray (12-6)#13@ KCBrady Singer (5-10)#176
Thu, May 6thvs TORHyun Jin Ryu (13-9)#113@ KCDanny Duffy (4-3)#100
Fri, May 7thvs TBRich Hill (6-7)#73vs CINWade Miley (12-7)#41
Sat, May 8thvs TBTyler Glasnow (5-2)vs CINLuis Castillo (8-16)#33
Sun, May 9thvs TBShane McClanahan (9-6)#60   
Tue, May 11th@ BOSNathan Eovaldi (10-8)#37vs CHCAdbert Alzolay (5-13)#107
Wed, May 12th@ BOSEduardo Rodriguez (11-8)#66vs CHCZach Davies (6-11)#390
Thu, May 13th@ BOSGarrett Richards (7-7)#229@ SEALogan Gilbert (6-5)#97
Fri, May 14th@ MINMatt Shoemaker (3-8)#298@ SEAChris Flexen (13-6)#38
Sat, May 15th@ MINJose Berrios (12-8)#11@ SEAJustus Sheffield (7-8)#393
Sun, May 16th@ MINKenta Maeda (6-5)@ SEARobert Dugger (0-2)#376
Tue, May 18thvs HOUCristian Javier (4-1)#93@ LAAAndrew Heaney (8-9)#115
Wed, May 19thvs HOUZack Greinke (11-6)#31@ LAAShohei Ohtani (9-2)#36
Thu, May 20thvs HOULuis Garcia (11-7)#28   
Fri, May 21st@ LAAJose Quintana (0-3)#213vs MINRandy Dobnak (1-7)
Sat, May 22nd@ LAAPatrick Sandoval (3-6)vs MINKenta Maeda (6-5)
Sun, May 23rd@ LAADylan Bundy (2-9)#89vs MINJ.A. Happ (9-8)#239
Mon, May 24thvs SEAYusei Kikuchi (7-9)#82@ DETSpencer Turnbull (4-2)
Tue, May 25thvs SEALogan Gilbert (6-5)#97@ DETTarik Skubal (8-12)#71
Wed, May 26thvs SEARobert Dugger (0-2)#376@ DETJose Urena (4-8)#396
Thu, May 27thvs LAAPatrick Sandoval (3-6)@ DETMatthew Boyd (3-8)#135
Fri, May 28thvs LAAShohei Ohtani (9-2)#36vs TORHyun Jin Ryu (13-9)#113
Sat, May 29thvs LAAAlex Cobb (8-3)#132   
Sun, May 30thvs LAAJose Quintana (0-3)#213vs TORSteven Matz (13-7)#54
Mon, May 31st@ SEALogan Gilbert (6-5)#97vs CWSJimmy Lambert (1-1)#275
Tue, Jun 1st@ SEAMarco Gonzales (9-5)#51vs CWSDylan Cease (12-7)#48
Wed, Jun 2nd@ SEAChris Flexen (13-6)#38   
Fri, Jun 4th@ COLJon Gray (8-11)#128@ BALKeegan Akin (2-10)#378
Sat, Jun 5th@ COLKyle Freeland (6-8)#317@ BALJohn Means (6-7)#45
Sun, Jun 6th@ COLGerman Marquez (12-10)#35@ BALJorge Lopez (3-14)
Tue, Jun 8thvs ARIJon Duplantier (0-3)#313@ STLCarlos Martinez (4-9)
Wed, Jun 9thvs ARIMatt Peacock (5-7)#172@ STLAdam Wainwright (16-7)#5
Thu, Jun 10thvs KCMike Minor (8-12)#86   
Fri, Jun 11thvs KCBrady Singer (5-10)#176vs SEAJustin Dunn (1-3)#258
Sat, Jun 12thvs KCJackson Kowar (0-4)#162vs SEAYusei Kikuchi (7-9)#82
Sun, Jun 13thvs KCKris Bubic (5-6)#156vs SEALogan Gilbert (6-5)#97
Mon, Jun 14thvs LAADylan Bundy (2-9)#89vs BALDean Kremer (0-7)#385
Tue, Jun 15thvs LAAAndrew Heaney (8-9)#115vs BALMatt Harvey (6-14)#401
Wed, Jun 16thvs LAAGriffin Canning (5-4)#154vs BALKeegan Akin (2-10)#378
Fri, Jun 18th@ NYYJameson Taillon (8-6)#83@ PITChad Kuhl (5-7)#230
Sat, Jun 19th@ NYYDomingo German (4-5)#72@ PITWil Crowe (4-7)#400
Sun, Jun 20th@ NYYJordan Montgomery (6-6)#57@ PITJT Brubaker (5-13)#121
Mon, Jun 21st@ TEXKyle Gibson (10-8)#58@ CHCAdbert Alzolay (5-13)#107
Tue, Jun 22nd@ TEXTaylor Hearn (6-5)#144@ CHCKyle Hendricks (14-7)#88
Wed, Jun 23rd@ TEXMike Foltynewicz (2-12)#194   
Thu, Jun 24th@ TEXKolby Allard (3-12)#273@ MINJose Berrios (12-8)#11
Fri, Jun 25th@ SFJohnny Cueto (7-7)#134@ MINDanny Coulombe
Sat, Jun 26th@ SFAlex Wood (10-4)#49   
Sun, Jun 27th@ SFSammy Long (2-1)#216@ MINJ.A. Happ (9-8)#239
Tue, Jun 29thvs TEXMike Foltynewicz (2-12)#194   
Wed, Jun 30thvs TEXKolby Allard (3-12)#273vs DETWily Peralta (4-3)#167
Thu, Jul 1stvs TEXDane Dunning (5-9)#148vs HOUFramber Valdez (11-5)#40
Fri, Jul 2ndvs BOSEduardo Rodriguez (11-8)#66vs HOULance McCullers Jr. (12-5)#24
Sat, Jul 3rdvs BOSGarrett Richards (7-7)#229vs HOUJake Odorizzi (6-7)#59
Sun, Jul 4thvs BOSNick Pivetta (9-7)#143vs HOUZack Greinke (11-6)#31
Tue, Jul 6th@ HOUFramber Valdez (11-5)#40   
Wed, Jul 7th@ HOULuis Garcia (11-7)#28@ TBCollin McHugh (6-1)#114
Thu, Jul 8th@ HOULance McCullers Jr. (12-5)#24vs KCDanny Duffy (4-3)#100
Fri, Jul 9th@ TEXJordan Lyles (9-12)#381vs KCBrad Keller (8-12)#391
Sat, Jul 10th@ TEXMike Foltynewicz (2-12)#194vs KCMike Minor (8-12)#86
Sun, Jul 11th@ TEXKolby Allard (3-12)#273   
Fri, Jul 16thvs CLEEli Morgan (3-7)#219@ OAKSean Manaea (10-10)#63
Sat, Jul 17thvs CLECal Quantrill (7-3)#56@ OAKFrankie Montas (12-9)#23
Sun, Jul 18thvs CLEZach Plesac (10-6)#53@ OAKChris Bassitt (12-4)#20
Mon, Jul 19thvs LAAShohei Ohtani (9-2)#36@ HOUZack Greinke (11-6)#31
Tue, Jul 20thvs LAAJose Suarez (7-8)#129@ HOULuis Garcia (11-7)#28
Thu, Jul 22nd@ SEAChris Flexen (13-6)#38vs TBLuis Patino (4-3)#81
Fri, Jul 23rd@ SEAYusei Kikuchi (7-9)#82vs TBJosh Fleming (10-6)#96
Sat, Jul 24th@ SEALogan Gilbert (6-5)#97vs TBDrew Rasmussen (3-1)#108
Sun, Jul 25th@ SEAMarco Gonzales (9-5)#51vs TBRyan Yarbrough (8-6)#152
Tue, Jul 27th@ SDChris Paddack (7-7)#50vs STLAdam Wainwright (16-7)#5
Wed, Jul 28th@ SDBlake Snell (7-6)#47vs STLKwang Hyun Kim (6-7)#95
Thu, Jul 29th@ LAADylan Bundy (2-9)#89   
Fri, Jul 30th@ LAAPatrick Sandoval (3-6)@ CWSLance Lynn (10-5)#16
Sat, Jul 31st@ LAAJaime Barria (2-4)#218@ CWSDallas Keuchel (8-9)#387
Sun, Aug 1st@ LAAReid Detmers (1-3)#280@ CWSJimmy Lambert (1-1)#275
Tue, Aug 3rdvs SDBlake Snell (7-6)#47@ TORHyun Jin Ryu (13-9)#113
Wed, Aug 4thvs SDJoe Musgrove (11-9)#12@ TORSteven Matz (13-7)#54
Fri, Aug 6thvs TEXMike Foltynewicz (2-12)#194vs DETMatt Manning (4-6)#214
Sat, Aug 7thvs TEXDrew Anderson (1-1)#255vs DETTyler Alexander (2-3)#120
Sun, Aug 8thvs TEXJordan Lyles (9-12)#381vs DETWily Peralta (4-3)#167
Tue, Aug 10th@ CLETriston McKenzie (5-7)#84vs OAKSean Manaea (10-10)#63
Wed, Aug 11th@ CLECal Quantrill (7-3)#56vs OAKFrankie Montas (12-9)#23
Thu, Aug 12th@ CLEEli Morgan (3-7)#219vs OAKChris Bassitt (12-4)#20
Fri, Aug 13th@ TEXDane Dunning (5-9)#148@ DETTyler Alexander (2-3)#120
Sat, Aug 14th@ TEXJordan Lyles (9-12)#381@ DETWily Peralta (4-3)#167
Sun, Aug 15th@ TEXKolby Allard (3-12)#273@ DETDrew Hutchison (2-1)#246
Mon, Aug 16th@ CWSDallas Keuchel (8-9)#387@ MINGriffin Jax (3-4)#207
Tue, Aug 17th@ CWSReynaldo Lopez (3-3)#153@ MINBailey Ober (2-3)#126
Wed, Aug 18th@ CWSLance Lynn (10-5)#16@ MINLewis Thorpe (0-2)#174
Thu, Aug 19th@ CWSDylan Cease (12-7)#48   
Fri, Aug 20thvs SFAlex Wood (10-4)#49vs LAAJaime Barria (2-4)#218
Sat, Aug 21stvs SFKevin Gausman (14-6)#17vs LAAReid Detmers (1-3)#280
Sun, Aug 22ndvs SFLogan Webb (10-3)#30vs LAAJose Suarez (7-8)#129
Mon, Aug 23rdvs SEAMarco Gonzales (9-5)#51   
Tue, Aug 24thvs SEAChris Flexen (13-6)#38vs TEXTaylor Hearn (6-5)#144
Thu, Aug 26thvs NYYJameson Taillon (8-6)#83vs TEXJordan Lyles (9-12)#381
Fri, Aug 27thvs NYYGerrit Cole (15-8)#7vs BOSEduardo Rodriguez (11-8)#66
Sat, Aug 28thvs NYYNestor Cortes Jr. (2-2)#98vs BOSNathan Eovaldi (10-8)#37
Sun, Aug 29thvs NYYJordan Montgomery (6-6)#57vs BOSTanner Houck (1-4)#208
Tue, Aug 31st@ DETTarik Skubal (8-12)#71@ KCJakob Junis (2-4)#169
Wed, Sep 1st@ DETWily Peralta (4-3)#167@ KCJackson Kowar (0-4)#162
Thu, Sep 2nd@ DETMatt Manning (4-6)#214@ KCMike Minor (8-12)#86
Fri, Sep 3rd@ TORAlek Manoah (7-2)#39@ BOSNathan Eovaldi (10-8)#37
Sat, Sep 4th@ TORJose Berrios (12-8)#11@ BOSTanner Houck (1-4)#208
Sun, Sep 5th@ TORRobbie Ray (12-6)#13@ BOSKutter Crawford (0-1)#338
Tue, Sep 7thvs CWSJimmy Lambert (1-1)#275vs MINJohn Gant (5-9)#138
Wed, Sep 8thvs CWSDallas Keuchel (8-9)#387vs MINJoe Ryan (2-1)#220
Thu, Sep 9thvs CWSReynaldo Lopez (3-3)#153vs MINAndrew Albers (1-2)#285
Fri, Sep 10thvs TEXGlenn Otto (0-3)#287vs MILAdrian Houser (9-6)#55
Sat, Sep 11thvs TEXWes Benjaminvs MILCorbin Burnes (10-4)#6
Sun, Sep 12thvs TEXTaylor Hearn (6-5)#144vs MILEric Lauer (6-5)#92
Tue, Sep 14th@ KCJackson Kowar (0-4)#162@ MINCharlie Barnes (0-3)#227
Wed, Sep 15th@ KCCarlos Hernandez (6-2)#146@ MINGriffin Jax (3-4)#207
Thu, Sep 16th@ KCDaniel Lynch (4-6)#397   
Fri, Sep 17th@ LAAJhonathan Diaz (0-0)#335@ NYYCorey Kluber (5-3)#67
Sat, Sep 18th@ LAAJose Suarez (7-8)#129@ NYYLuis Gil (1-1)#193
Sun, Sep 19th@ LAAShohei Ohtani (9-2)#36@ NYYGerrit Cole (15-8)#7
Mon, Sep 20thvs SEATyler Anderson (7-9)#70vs KCJoel Payamps
Tue, Sep 21stvs SEAMarco Gonzales (9-5)#51vs KCDaniel Lynch (4-6)#397
Wed, Sep 22ndvs SEAChris Flexen (13-6)#38   
Thu, Sep 23rdvs SEAYusei Kikuchi (7-9)#82vs CWSMichael Kopech (4-3)#130
Fri, Sep 24thvs HOUZack Greinke (11-6)#31vs CWSDylan Cease (12-7)#48
Sat, Sep 25thvs HOUFramber Valdez (11-5)#40vs CWSLance Lynn (10-5)#16
Sun, Sep 26thvs HOUJake Odorizzi (6-7)#59vs CWSLucas Giolito (10-9)#29
Mon, Sep 27th@ SEAChris Flexen (13-6)#38vs KCJackson Kowar (0-4)#162
Tue, Sep 28th@ SEAYusei Kikuchi (7-9)#82@ KCBrady Singer (5-10)#176
Wed, Sep 29th@ SEA@ KC
Fri, Oct 1st@ HOU@ TEX
Sat, Oct 2nd@ HOU@ TEX
Sun, Oct 3rd@ HOU@ TEX
Sun, Apr 11th   vs DETJose Urena (4-8)#396
Wed, Apr 14th   @ CWSCarlos Rodon (12-5)#25
Thu, Apr 22nd   vs NYYDomingo German (4-5)#72
Mon, May 17th   @ LAAPatrick Sandoval (3-6)
Thu, Jun 17th   vs BALJorge Lopez (3-14)
Mon, Jun 28th   vs DETMatt Manning (4-6)#214
Mon, Jul 5th   @ TBRich Hill (6-7)#73
Wed, Jul 21st   @ HOULance McCullers Jr. (12-5)#24
Mon, Aug 2nd   @ TORRobbie Ray (12-6)#13
Thu, Aug 5th   @ TORRoss Stripling (5-7)#74
Mon, Aug 9th   vs CINLuis Castillo (8-16)#33
Wed, Aug 25th   vs TEXJake Latz (0-1)#330
Mon, Sep 6th   vs MINBailey Ober (2-3)#126
Thu, Sep 30th   @ KC