Skip to main content

Who Should I Trade?

Gerrit Cole for Max Scherzer (2021)


See if your team wins or loses with this trade View Trade Analyzer

Who Should I Trade? Player Summaries
 
Experts' Pick
 
  Gerrit Cole
SP - NYY
Gerrit Cole
Max Scherzer
SP - NYM
Max Scherzer
Expert
Recommendation
75%
Recommended by
12 of 16 experts
25%
Recommended by
4 of 16 experts
Rankings 
   
Rest of Season# 1# 2
VBR
   
Projections 
   
Strikeouts00
Wins00
Saves00
ERA0.000.00
WHIP0.000.00
   
Misc 
   
Injury Alert--
   
Expert Ranks 
   
Chris Meaney
FTN
# 2# 13
   
Jorge B. Edwards
Fantasy In Frames
# 2# 11
   
Mick Ciallela
Fantrax
# 1# 2
   
Ryan Amore
Pitcher List
# 2# 4
   
Brendan Tuma
FantasyPros
# 2# 3
   
Carmen Maiorano
FantasyPros
# 3# 11
   
Jordan Eisen
Field of Vision Sports
# 2# 9
   
Brad Camara
FantasyPros
# 1# 6
   
Chris Mitchell
FantasyData
# 2# 9
   
Corbin Young
FantasyData
# 1# 4
   
Chris Clegg
Fantrax
# 3# 12
   
Joe Pisapia
FantasyPros
# 4# 6
   
Joe Bond
Fantasy Six Pack
# 2# 1
   
Dan Harris
FantasyPros
# 4# 1
   
Mike Maher
FantasyPros
# 6# 1
   
Pierre Camus
RotoBaller
# 6# 3
   
Who Should I Trade? Player Statistics
  Gerrit Cole
SP - NYY
Gerrit Cole
Max Scherzer
SP - NYM
Max Scherzer
2021 Stats 
   
   
Games Played3030
   
Games Started3030
   
Innings Pitched181.1179.2
   
Wins1615
   
Losses84
   
Saves00
   
Blown Saves00
   
Holds00
   
Hits Allowed151119
   
Earned Runs6549
   
Home Runs Allowed2423
   
Strikeouts243236
   
Walks4136
   
ERA3.232.46
   
WHIP1.060.86
   
Who Should I Trade? Player Projections
  Gerrit Cole
SP - NYY
Gerrit Cole
Max Scherzer
SP - NYM
Max Scherzer
2021 Projections 
   
   
Games Played00
   
Games Started00
   
Innings Pitched0.00.0
   
Wins00
   
Losses00
   
Saves00
   
Blown Saves00
   
Holds00
   
Hits Allowed00
   
Earned Runs00
   
Home Runs Allowed00
   
Strikeouts00
   
Walks00
   
ERA0.000.00
   
WHIP0.000.00
   
Who Should I Trade? Player Notes
  Gerrit Cole
SP - NYY
Gerrit Cole
Max Scherzer
SP - NYM
Max Scherzer
News 
 Yankees RHP Gerrit Cole was tagged for three earned runs in just two innings of work on Tuesday against the Red Sox.
Brendan Tuma - Too Much Tuma
Wed, Oct 6th
Jon Heyman of MLB Network reports the Mets are finalizing a three-year, $130 million contract with free agent RHP Max Scherzer.
Brendan Tuma - Too Much Tuma
Mon, Nov 29th
 Gerrit Cole will get the start for the Yankees when they face off against the Boston Red Sox in the AL Wildcard game at Fenway Park on Tuesday.
Chris Schommer
Sun, Oct 3rd
Jon Morosi of MLB Network reports the Mets are "closing in" on a multiyear contract with free agent RHP Max Scherzer.
Brendan Tuma - Too Much Tuma
Sun, Nov 28th
 Gerrit Cole allowed five runs on nine hits, did not walk a batter and struck out six over six innings Wednesday in a no-decision versus the Blue Jays.
John Aubin
Thu, Sep 30th
Dodgers starting pitcher Max Scherzer will not start Game 6 of the National League Championship Series against the Braves.
Corbin Young
Sat, Oct 23rd
 Gerrit Cole surrendered three runs on five hits with three walks and six strikeouts in six innings Friday in a victory over the Red Sox.
John Aubin
Sat, Sep 25th
Dodgers manager Dave Roberts said Dodgers starting pitcher Max Scherzer will start Game 2 of the NLCS against the Braves on Sunday night.
Chris Schommer
Sat, Oct 16th
 Gerrit Cole allowed one earned run on four hits and three walks while striking out seven over five innings to earn the win Tuesday against the Orioles.
John Aubin
Wed, Sep 15th
Dodgers manager Dave Roberts said that the plan is to start Max Scherzer for Game 1 of the NLCS. Scherzer threw 13 pitches on Thursday in the Dodgers' win at San Francisco.
Kamran Hoda
Fri, Oct 15th
Notes 
There are no recent notes for these players
Who Should I Trade? Player Schedules
  Gerrit Cole
SP - NYY
Gerrit Cole
Max Scherzer
SP - NYM
Max Scherzer
Date OppOpp PitcherVBROppOpp PitcherVBR
Thu, Apr 1stvs TORHyun Jin Ryu (14-10)   
Sat, Apr 3rdvs TORRoss Stripling (5-7)   
Sun, Apr 4thvs TORT.J. Zeuch (0-2)   
Mon, Apr 5thvs BALJorge Lopez (3-14)@ PHIMatt Moore (2-4)
Tue, Apr 6thvs BALDean Kremer (0-7)@ PHIChase Anderson (2-4)
Wed, Apr 7thvs BALJohn Means (6-9)@ PHIAaron Nola (9-9)
Fri, Apr 9th@ TBRich Hill (7-8)   
Sat, Apr 10th@ TBChris Archer (1-1)vs MIATrevor Rogers (7-8)
Sun, Apr 11th@ TBBrent Honeywell Jr. (0-0)   
Mon, Apr 12th@ TORRobbie Ray (13-7)   
Tue, Apr 13th@ TORHyun Jin Ryu (14-10)vs PHIAaron Nola (9-9)
Wed, Apr 14th@ TORT.J. Zeuch (0-2)vs PHIZack Wheeler (14-10)
Fri, Apr 16thvs TBMichael Wacha (3-5)   
Sat, Apr 17thvs TBTyler Glasnow (5-2)@ COLGerman Marquez (12-11)#4
Sun, Apr 18thvs TBAndrew Kittredge (9-3)@ COLAntonio Senzatela (4-9)#16
Tue, Apr 20thvs ATLCharlie Morton (14-6)#1@ CHCJake Arrieta (5-14)
Wed, Apr 21stvs ATLIan Anderson (9-5)#3@ CHCZach Davies (6-12)
Thu, Apr 22nd@ CLEAaron Civale (12-5)@ CHCTrevor Williams (4-2)
Fri, Apr 23rd@ CLELogan Allen (2-7)vs WSHErick Fedde (7-9)
Sat, Apr 24th@ CLEShane Bieber (7-4)vs WSHJoe Ross (5-9)
Sun, Apr 25th@ CLETriston McKenzie (5-9)vs WSHPatrick Corbin (9-16)
Mon, Apr 26th@ BALMatt Harvey (6-14)   
Tue, Apr 27th@ BALBruce Zimmermann (4-5)vs BOSGarrett Richards (7-8)
Wed, Apr 28th@ BALDean Kremer (0-7)vs BOSNick Pivetta (9-8)
Thu, Apr 29th@ BALJorge Lopez (3-14)   
Fri, Apr 30thvs DETTarik Skubal (8-12)@ PHIChase Anderson (2-4)
Sat, May 1stvs DETSpencer Turnbull (4-2)@ PHIZack Wheeler (14-10)
Sun, May 2ndvs DETJose Urena (4-8)@ PHIZach Eflin (4-7)
Tue, May 4thvs HOUZack Greinke (11-6)   
Wed, May 5thvs HOULuis Garcia (11-8)@ STLJohan Oviedo (0-5)
Thu, May 6thvs HOULance McCullers Jr. (13-5)@ STLJohn Gant (5-11)
Fri, May 7thvs WSHPatrick Corbin (9-16)vs ARIZac Gallen (3-10)
Sat, May 8thvs WSHMax Scherzer (15-4)vs ARIMerrill Kelly (7-11)
Sun, May 9thvs WSHJoe Ross (5-9)vs ARIRiley Smith (1-4)
Tue, May 11th@ TBLuis Patino (5-3)vs BALJohn Means (6-9)
Wed, May 12th@ TBCollin McHugh (6-1)vs BALMatt Harvey (6-14)
Thu, May 13th@ TBRich Hill (7-8)   
Fri, May 14th@ BALDean Kremer (0-7)@ TBTyler Glasnow (5-2)
Sat, May 15th@ BALJorge Lopez (3-14)@ TBShane McClanahan (10-6)
Sun, May 16th@ BALAdam Plutko (1-2)@ TBJosh Fleming (10-8)
Mon, May 17th@ TEXJordan Lyles (10-13)@ ATLMax Fried (14-7)#2
Tue, May 18th@ TEXMike Foltynewicz (2-12)@ ATLTucker Davidson (0-0)#10
Wed, May 19th@ TEXHyeon-jong Yang (0-3)@ ATLCharlie Morton (14-6)#1
Thu, May 20th@ TEXDane Dunning (5-10)   
Fri, May 21stvs CWSCarlos Rodon (13-5)@ MIAJohn Curtiss (3-1)
Sat, May 22ndvs CWSDylan Cease (13-7)@ MIAPablo Lopez (5-5)
Sun, May 23rdvs CWSDallas Keuchel (9-9)@ MIACody Poteet (2-3)
Tue, May 25thvs TORSteven Matz (14-7)vs COLKyle Freeland (7-8)#12
Thu, May 27thvs TORRobbie Ray (13-7)vs COLAntonio Senzatela (4-9)#16
Fri, May 28th@ DETCasey Mize (7-9)   
Sat, May 29th@ DETSpencer Turnbull (4-2)vs ATLIan Anderson (9-5)#3
Sun, May 30th@ DETTarik Skubal (8-12)   
Mon, May 31stvs TBRich Hill (7-8)@ ARIMerrill Kelly (7-11)
Tue, Jun 1stvs TBTyler Glasnow (5-2)@ ARICaleb Smith (4-9)
Wed, Jun 2ndvs TBShane McClanahan (10-6)@ ARIMadison Bumgarner (7-10)
Thu, Jun 3rdvs TBRyan Yarbrough (9-7)@ SDYu Darvish (8-11)
Fri, Jun 4thvs BOSNathan Eovaldi (11-9)@ SDBlake Snell (7-6)
Sat, Jun 5thvs BOSEduardo Rodriguez (13-8)@ SDJoe Musgrove (11-9)
Sun, Jun 6thvs BOSGarrett Richards (7-8)@ SDChris Paddack (7-7)
Tue, Jun 8th@ MINMichael Pineda (9-8)@ BALBruce Zimmermann (4-5)
Wed, Jun 9th@ MINRandy Dobnak (1-7)@ BALMatt Harvey (6-14)
Thu, Jun 10th@ MINJ.A. Happ (10-8)   
Sat, Jun 12th@ PHIVince Velasquez (3-9)vs SDJoe Musgrove (11-9)
Sun, Jun 13th@ PHIAaron Nola (9-9)vs SDChris Paddack (7-7)
Tue, Jun 15th@ TORHyun Jin Ryu (14-10)vs CHCAlec Mills (6-7)
Wed, Jun 16th@ TORRoss Stripling (5-7)vs CHCRobert Stock (0-2)
Thu, Jun 17th@ TORT.J. Zeuch (0-2)vs CHCKyle Hendricks (14-7)
Fri, Jun 18thvs OAKJames Kaprielian (8-5)@ WSHErick Fedde (7-9)
Sat, Jun 19thvs OAKChris Bassitt (12-4)@ WSHJon Lester (7-6)
Sun, Jun 20thvs OAKSean Manaea (11-10)@ WSHPatrick Corbin (9-16)
Tue, Jun 22ndvs KCBrady Singer (5-10)vs ATLCharlie Morton (14-6)#1
Wed, Jun 23rdvs KCDanny Duffy (4-3)vs ATLKyle Wright (0-1)#15
Thu, Jun 24thvs KCBrad Keller (8-12)   
Fri, Jun 25th@ BOSMartin Perez (7-8)vs PHIMatt Moore (2-4)
Sat, Jun 26th@ BOSNathan Eovaldi (11-9)vs PHIZach Eflin (4-7)
Sun, Jun 27th@ BOSEduardo Rodriguez (13-8)vs PHIZack Wheeler (14-10)
Mon, Jun 28thvs LAADylan Bundy (2-9)@ WSHPaolo Espino (5-5)
Tue, Jun 29thvs LAAAndrew Heaney (8-9)@ ATLCharlie Morton (14-6)#1
Wed, Jun 30thvs LAAShohei Ohtani (9-2)@ ATLMax Fried (14-7)#2
Sat, Jul 3rdvs NYMTaijuan Walker (7-11)@ NYYJordan Montgomery (6-7)
Sun, Jul 4thvs NYMCorey Oswalt (1-1)@ NYYNestor Cortes Jr. (2-3)
Tue, Jul 6th@ SEAJustus Sheffield (7-8)   
Wed, Jul 7th@ SEAYusei Kikuchi (7-9)vs MILBrett Anderson (4-9)
Thu, Jul 8th@ SEALogan Gilbert (6-5)   
Fri, Jul 9th@ HOUJake Odorizzi (6-7)vs PITJT Brubaker (5-13)
Sat, Jul 10th@ HOUZack Greinke (11-6)vs PITMax Kranick (2-3)
Sun, Jul 11th@ HOUFramber Valdez (11-6)vs PITChase De Jong (1-4)
Fri, Jul 16thvs BOSEduardo Rodriguez (13-8)@ PITChad Kuhl (5-7)
Sat, Jul 17thvs BOSNathan Eovaldi (11-9)@ PITWil Crowe (4-8)
Sun, Jul 18thvs BOSMartin Perez (7-8)@ PITJT Brubaker (5-13)
Tue, Jul 20thvs PHIAaron Nola (9-9)@ CINWade Miley (12-7)
Wed, Jul 21stvs PHISpencer Howard (0-5)@ CINJeff Hoffman (3-5)
Thu, Jul 22nd@ BOSTanner Houck (1-5)   
Fri, Jul 23rd@ BOSEduardo Rodriguez (13-8)vs TORSteven Matz (14-7)
Sat, Jul 24th@ BOSNathan Eovaldi (11-9)vs TORHyun Jin Ryu (14-10)
Sun, Jul 25th@ BOSMartin Perez (7-8)vs TORRoss Stripling (5-7)
Tue, Jul 27th@ TBShane McClanahan (10-6)vs ATLCharlie Morton (14-6)#1
Wed, Jul 28th@ TBMichael Wacha (3-5)vs ATLMax Fried (14-7)#2
Thu, Jul 29th@ TBLuis Patino (5-3)vs ATLDrew Smyly (11-4)
Fri, Jul 30th@ MIAZach Thompson (3-7)vs CINSonny Gray (7-9)
Sat, Jul 31st@ MIATrevor Rogers (7-8)vs CINWade Miley (12-7)
Sun, Aug 1st@ MIASandy Alcantara (9-15)vs CINVladimir Gutierrez (9-6)
Mon, Aug 2ndvs BALJorge Lopez (3-14)@ MIAJesus Luzardo (6-9)
Tue, Aug 3rdvs BALAlexander Wells (2-3)@ MIANick Neidert (1-2)
Wed, Aug 4thvs BALMatt Harvey (6-14)@ MIAZach Thompson (3-7)
Thu, Aug 5thvs SEATyler Anderson (7-11)@ MIABraxton Garrett (1-2)
Fri, Aug 6thvs SEAMarco Gonzales (10-6)@ PHIKyle Gibson (10-9)
Sat, Aug 7thvs SEAChris Flexen (14-6)@ PHIRanger Suarez (8-5)
Sun, Aug 8thvs SEAYusei Kikuchi (7-9)@ PHIZack Wheeler (14-10)
Mon, Aug 9th@ KCCarlos Hernandez (6-2)   
Tue, Aug 10th@ KCDaniel Lynch (4-6)   
Wed, Aug 11th@ KCBrady Singer (5-10)vs WSHPaolo Espino (5-5)
Thu, Aug 12th@ CWSLance Lynn (11-6)vs WSHErick Fedde (7-9)
Sat, Aug 14th@ CWSDylan Cease (13-7)vs LADWalker Buehler (16-4)
Sun, Aug 15th@ CWSLucas Giolito (11-9)vs LADMax Scherzer (15-4)
Mon, Aug 16thvs LAAJose Suarez (8-8)@ SFKevin Gausman (14-6)
Tue, Aug 17thvs BOSNathan Eovaldi (11-9)@ SFLogan Webb (11-3)
Wed, Aug 18thvs BOSNick Pivetta (9-8)@ SFAnthony DeSclafani (13-7)
Thu, Aug 19thvs MINJohn Gant (5-11)@ LADCorey Knebel (4-0)
Fri, Aug 20thvs MINCharlie Barnes (0-3)@ LADWalker Buehler (16-4)
Sat, Aug 21stvs MINKenta Maeda (6-5)@ LADMax Scherzer (15-4)
Mon, Aug 23rd@ ATLHuascar Ynoa (4-6)#5   
Tue, Aug 24th@ ATLCharlie Morton (14-6)#1vs SFSammy Long (2-1)
Thu, Aug 26th@ OAKJames Kaprielian (8-5)vs SFAlex Wood (10-4)
Fri, Aug 27th@ OAKSean Manaea (11-10)vs WSHPaolo Espino (5-5)
Sat, Aug 28th@ OAKFrankie Montas (13-9)vs WSHSean Nolin (0-2)
Sun, Aug 29th@ OAKPaul Blackburn (1-4)vs WSHErick Fedde (7-9)
Mon, Aug 30th@ LAAMike Mayers   
Tue, Aug 31st@ LAAJaime Barria (2-4)vs MIAEdward Cabrera (0-3)
Wed, Sep 1st@ LAAPacky Naughton (0-4)   
Fri, Sep 3rdvs BALJohn Means (6-9)@ WSHSean Nolin (0-2)
Sat, Sep 4thvs BALChris Ellis (1-0)@ WSHJosh Rogers (2-2)
Sun, Sep 5thvs BALKeegan Akin (2-10)@ WSHJosiah Gray (2-2)
Mon, Sep 6thvs TORHyun Jin Ryu (14-10)@ WSHPatrick Corbin (9-16)
Tue, Sep 7thvs TORSteven Matz (14-7)@ MIAEdward Cabrera (0-3)
Wed, Sep 8thvs TORAlek Manoah (9-2)@ MIASandy Alcantara (9-15)
Thu, Sep 9thvs TORJose Berrios (12-9)@ MIAJesus Luzardo (6-9)
Fri, Sep 10th@ NYMTylor Megill (4-6)vs NYYJordan Montgomery (6-7)
Sat, Sep 11th@ NYMTaijuan Walker (7-11)vs NYYCorey Kluber (5-3)
Sun, Sep 12th@ NYMCarlos Carrasco (1-5)vs NYYClarke Schmidt (0-0)
Mon, Sep 13thvs MINJohn Gant (5-11)vs STLAdam Wainwright (17-7)
Tue, Sep 14th@ BALAlexander Wells (2-3)vs STLJake Woodford (3-4)
Wed, Sep 15th@ BALJohn Means (6-9)vs STLJon Lester (7-6)
Thu, Sep 16th@ BALChris Ellis (1-0)   
Fri, Sep 17thvs CLEZach Plesac (10-6)vs PHIZack Wheeler (14-10)
Sat, Sep 18thvs CLEAaron Civale (12-5)vs PHIAaron Nola (9-9)
Sun, Sep 19thvs CLEEli Morgan (5-7)vs PHIKyle Gibson (10-9)
Mon, Sep 20thvs TEXA.J. Alexy (3-1)   
Tue, Sep 21stvs TEXDane Dunning (5-10)@ BOSEduardo Rodriguez (13-8)
Wed, Sep 22ndvs TEXTaylor Hearn (6-6)@ BOSChris Sale (5-1)
Fri, Sep 24th@ BOSNathan Eovaldi (11-9)@ MILEric Lauer (7-5)
Sat, Sep 25th@ BOSNick Pivetta (9-8)@ MILCorbin Burnes (11-4)
Sun, Sep 26th@ BOSEduardo Rodriguez (13-8)@ MILFreddy Peralta (10-5)
Tue, Sep 28th@ TORHyun Jin Ryu (14-10)vs MIATrevor Rogers (7-8)
Wed, Sep 29th@ TORJose Berrios (12-9)vs MIAElieser Hernandez (1-3)
Thu, Sep 30th@ TORRobbie Ray (13-7)vs MIAEdward Cabrera (0-3)
Fri, Oct 1stvs TBShane McClanahan (10-6)@ ATLHuascar Ynoa (4-6)#5
Sat, Oct 2ndvs TBShane Baz (2-0)@ ATLJesse Chavez (3-2)
Sun, Oct 3rdvs TBMichael Wacha (3-5)@ ATLCharlie Morton (14-6)#1
Thu, Apr 8th   vs MIANick Neidert (1-2)
Mon, May 3rd   @ STLAdam Wainwright (17-7)
Mon, May 24th   vs COLAustin Gomber (9-9)
Fri, Jun 11th   vs SDBlake Snell (7-6)
Mon, Jun 14th   vs CHCJake Arrieta (5-14)
Mon, Jun 21st   vs ATLIan Anderson (9-5)#3
Thu, Jul 1st   @ ATLIan Anderson (9-5)#3
Mon, Jul 5th   vs MILBrandon Woodruff (9-10)
Mon, Jul 19th   @ CINVladimir Gutierrez (9-6)
Mon, Jul 26th   vs ATLBryse Wilson (3-7)
Fri, Aug 13th   vs LADJulio Urias (19-3)
Sun, Aug 22nd   @ LADDavid Price (5-2)
Wed, Aug 25th   vs SFJohnny Cueto (7-7)
Thu, Sep 2nd   vs MIASandy Alcantara (9-15)