Skip to main content

Who Should I Trade?

Josh Donaldson for Jeff McNeil (2021)


See if your team wins or loses with this trade View Trade Analyzer

Who Should I Trade? Player Summaries
 
Experts' Pick
 
  Josh Donaldson
3B,DH - MIN
Josh Donaldson
Jeff McNeil
2B,3B,LF,RF - NYM
Jeff McNeil
Expert
Recommendation
53%
Recommended by
9 of 17 experts
47%
Recommended by
8 of 17 experts
Rankings 
   
Rest of Season# 70# 90
VBR# 136# 370
   
Projections 
   
Runs33
Home Runs10
RBI32
Stolen Bases00
Batting Average.244.262
   
Misc 
   
Injury Alert--
   
Expert Ranks 
   
Nick Pollack
Pitcher List
# 71
   
Dan Harris
FantasyPros
# 82# 92
   
Pierre Camus
RotoBaller
# 66# 92
   
Mick Ciallela
Fantrax
# 65# 82
   
Ryan Amore
Pitcher List
# 50# 151
   
Brendan Tuma
FantasyPros
# 59# 167
   
Brad Camara
FantasyPros
# 86# 144
   
Chris Mitchell
FantasyData
# 84# 111
   
Corbin Young
FantasyData
# 72# 90
   
Jordan Eisen
Field of Vision Sports
# 94# 74
   
Carmen Maiorano
FantasyPros
# 95# 46
   
Mike Maher
FantasyPros
# 96# 73
   
Chris Clegg
Fantrax
# 98# 75
   
Jorge B. Edwards
Fantasy In Frames
# 114# 65
   
Chris Meaney
FTN
# 114# 65
   
Joe Bond
Fantasy Six Pack
# 124# 64
   
Joe Pisapia
FantasyPros
# 160# 79
   
Who Should I Trade? Player Statistics
  Josh Donaldson
3B,DH - MIN
Josh Donaldson
Jeff McNeil
2B,3B,LF,RF - NYM
Jeff McNeil
2021 Stats 
   
   
At Bats430372
   
Runs6846
   
Hits10695
   
Singles5868
   
Doubles2419
   
Triples01
   
Home Runs247
   
RBI6735
   
Stolen Bases02
   
Caught Stealing00
   
Walks6827
   
Strikeouts10654
   
Batting Average.247.255
   
On Base Pct.348.320
   
Slugging Pct.470.368
   
On-base Plus Slugging.818.689
   
Who Should I Trade? Player Projections
  Josh Donaldson
3B,DH - MIN
Josh Donaldson
Jeff McNeil
2B,3B,LF,RF - NYM
Jeff McNeil
2021 Projections 
   
   
At Bats1923
   
Runs33
   
Hits56
   
Singles34
   
Doubles11
   
Triples00
   
Home Runs10
   
RBI32
   
Stolen Bases00
   
Caught Stealing00
   
Walks32
   
Strikeouts53
   
Batting Average.244.262
   
On Base Pct.350.332
   
Slugging Pct.462.390
   
On-base Plus Slugging.812.722
   
Who Should I Trade? Player Notes
  Josh Donaldson
3B,DH - MIN
Josh Donaldson
Jeff McNeil
2B,3B,LF,RF - NYM
Jeff McNeil
News 
 Minnesota Twins third baseman Josh Donaldson went 1-for-4 with a run in a 5-4 win over the Cubs on Wednesday.
Matthew Terelle
Thu, Sep 23rd
Jeff McNeil went 2-for-3 with one RBI, one homer, one single, and two runs scored. The Mets won 3-2 Sunday and are 73-77 this season.
Lucas Babits-Feinerman
Mon, Sep 20th
 Minnesota Twins third baseman Josh Donaldson went 1-for-3 with a two-run homer and a walk in a 6-2 loss to the Blue Jays on Saturday.
Matthew Terelle
Sat, Sep 18th
Jeff McNeil went 1-for-3 with one single, one strikeout, and two RBIs.
Lucas Babits-Feinerman
Sat, Aug 14th
 Minnesota Twins DH Josh Donaldson went 2-for-5 with a solo homer in a 7-3 win over the Blue Jays on Friday.
Matthew Terelle
Fri, Sep 17th
Jeff McNeil went 1-for-4 with a solo home run and a strikeout.
Lucas Babits-Feinerman
Mon, Aug 2nd
 Minnesota Twins DH Josh Donaldson went 0-for-4 in a 12-3 loss to Cleveland on Wednesday.
Matthew Terelle
Thu, Sep 16th
Jeff McNeil is absent from Thursday's lineup against the Braves.
Brendan Tuma - Too Much Tuma
Thu, Jul 29th
 Minnesota Twins DH Josh Donaldson went 1-for-4 with a three-run homer and a walk in a 6-4 loss to the Royals on Friday.
Matthew Terelle
Sat, Sep 11th
Jeff McNeil went 2-for-5 with one run scored, one home run, one double, one strikeout, and two RBIs.
Lucas Babits-Feinerman
Wed, Jul 28th
Notes 
 Donaldson lasted just one at-bat before hurting his hamstring and needing an IL stint. It's a relief that it's not a recurrence of his calf problems, but still, it's a reminder of how tenuous his status is even on his best day. Even if he is not out for long, have a backup ready to go at all times.
Dan Harris - FantasyPros
 
Who Should I Trade? Player Schedules
  Josh Donaldson
3B,DH - MIN
Josh Donaldson
Jeff McNeil
2B,3B,LF,RF - NYM
Jeff McNeil
Date OppOpp PitcherVBROppOpp PitcherVBR
Thu, Apr 1st@ MILBrandon Woodruff (9-10)#11   
Sat, Apr 3rd@ MILCorbin Burnes (10-4)#4   
Sun, Apr 4th@ MILAdrian Houser (9-6)#79   
Mon, Apr 5th@ DETJose Urena (4-8)#391@ PHIMatt Moore (2-4)#369
Tue, Apr 6th@ DETCasey Mize (7-8)#54@ PHIChase Anderson (2-4)#258
Wed, Apr 7th@ DETMatthew Boyd (3-8)#101@ PHIAaron Nola (9-8)#39
Thu, Apr 8thvs SEAMarco Gonzales (9-5)#40vs MIANick Neidert (1-2)#206
Sat, Apr 10thvs SEAYusei Kikuchi (7-9)#70vs MIATrevor Rogers (7-8)#47
Sun, Apr 11thvs SEAChris Flexen (13-6)#38   
Tue, Apr 13thvs BOSMartin Perez (7-8)#381vs PHIAaron Nola (9-8)#39
Wed, Apr 14thvs BOSEduardo Rodriguez (11-8)#57vs PHIZack Wheeler (14-9)#3
Thu, Apr 15thvs BOSGarrett Richards (7-7)#223   
Fri, Apr 16th@ LAAAndrew Heaney (8-9)#105   
Tue, Apr 20th@ OAKJesus Luzardo (5-8)#152@ CHCJake Arrieta (5-14)
Wed, Apr 21st@ OAKFrankie Montas (13-9)#21@ CHCZach Davies (6-12)#377
Fri, Apr 23rdvs PITJT Brubaker (5-13)#106vs WSHErick Fedde (7-9)#251
Sat, Apr 24thvs PITTrevor Cahill (1-5)vs WSHJoe Ross (5-9)
Sun, Apr 25thvs PITWil Crowe (4-7)#393vs WSHPatrick Corbin (9-15)#324
Mon, Apr 26th@ CLEZach Plesac (10-6)#41   
Tue, Apr 27th@ CLEAaron Civale (11-5)#37vs BOSGarrett Richards (7-7)#223
Wed, Apr 28th@ CLELogan Allen (1-7)#345vs BOSNick Pivetta (9-7)#132
Fri, Apr 30thvs KCBrady Singer (5-10)#172@ PHIChase Anderson (2-4)#258
Sat, May 1stvs KCDanny Duffy (4-3)#90@ PHIZack Wheeler (14-9)#3
Sun, May 2ndvs KCBrad Keller (8-12)#385@ PHIZach Eflin (4-7)
Mon, May 3rdvs TEXDane Dunning (5-9)#134@ STLAdam Wainwright (16-7)#6
Tue, May 4thvs TEXKyle Gibson (10-8)#55   
Wed, May 5thvs TEXHyeon-jong Yang (0-3)#278@ STLJohan Oviedo (0-5)#359
Thu, May 6thvs TEXJordan Lyles (9-12)#279@ STLJohn Gant (5-9)#138
Fri, May 7th@ DETTarik Skubal (8-12)#61vs ARIZac Gallen (2-10)#89
Sat, May 8th@ DETJose Urena (4-8)#391vs ARIMerrill Kelly (7-11)#86
Tue, May 11th@ CWSDylan Cease (13-7)#32vs BALJohn Means (6-7)#51
Wed, May 12th@ CWSDallas Keuchel (8-9)#375vs BALMatt Harvey (6-14)#395
Thu, May 13th@ CWSLance Lynn (10-5)#12   
Fri, May 14thvs OAKFrankie Montas (13-9)#21@ TBTyler Glasnow (5-2)
Sat, May 15thvs OAKCole Irvin (10-14)#102@ TBShane McClanahan (9-6)#85
Sun, May 16thvs OAKChris Bassitt (12-4)#18@ TBJosh Fleming (10-6)#163
Mon, May 17thvs CWSDallas Keuchel (8-9)#375@ ATLMax Fried (13-7)#23
Tue, May 18thvs CWSLance Lynn (10-5)#12@ ATLTucker Davidson (0-0)#297
Wed, May 19thvs CWSLucas Giolito (10-9)#25@ ATLCharlie Morton (13-6)#7
Thu, May 20th@ LAAGriffin Canning (5-4)#166   
Fri, May 21st@ CLETriston McKenzie (5-7)#67@ MIAJohn Curtiss (3-1)
Sat, May 22nd@ CLEShane Bieber (7-4)#17@ MIAPablo Lopez (5-5)#44
Sun, May 23rd@ CLEZach Plesac (10-6)#41@ MIACody Poteet (2-3)#186
Mon, May 24thvs BALJohn Means (6-7)#51vs COLAustin Gomber (9-9)
Tue, May 25thvs BALDean Kremer (0-7)#374vs COLKyle Freeland (6-8)#373
Wed, May 26thvs BALJorge Lopez (3-14)   
Fri, May 28thvs KCKris Bubic (5-6)#169   
Sat, May 29thvs KCErvin Santana (2-2)#351vs ATLIan Anderson (8-5)#63
Sun, May 30thvs KCBrad Keller (8-12)#385   
Mon, May 31st@ BALJorge Lopez (3-14)@ ARIMerrill Kelly (7-11)#86
Tue, Jun 1st@ BALBruce Zimmermann (4-4)#319@ ARICaleb Smith (4-9)#157
Wed, Jun 2nd@ BALMatt Harvey (6-14)#395@ ARIMadison Bumgarner (7-10)#110
Thu, Jun 3rd@ KCKris Bubic (5-6)#169@ SDYu Darvish (8-10)#33
Fri, Jun 4th@ KCBrad Keller (8-12)#385@ SDBlake Snell (7-6)#42
Sat, Jun 5th@ KCMike Minor (8-12)#75@ SDJoe Musgrove (11-9)#14
Sun, Jun 6th@ KCBrady Singer (5-10)#172@ SDChris Paddack (7-7)#88
Tue, Jun 8thvs NYYJordan Montgomery (6-6)#62@ BALBruce Zimmermann (4-4)#319
Wed, Jun 9thvs NYYGerrit Cole (16-8)#5@ BALMatt Harvey (6-14)#395
Thu, Jun 10thvs NYYMichael King (0-4)#167   
Fri, Jun 11thvs HOUJose Urquidy (8-3)#77vs SDBlake Snell (7-6)#42
Sat, Jun 12thvs HOULuis Garcia (11-7)#24vs SDJoe Musgrove (11-9)#14
Sun, Jun 13thvs HOUFramber Valdez (11-5)#30vs SDChris Paddack (7-7)#88
Mon, Jun 14th@ SEAMarco Gonzales (9-5)#40vs CHCJake Arrieta (5-14)
Tue, Jun 15th@ SEAChris Flexen (13-6)#38vs CHCAlec Mills (6-7)#176
Wed, Jun 16th@ SEAJustus Sheffield (7-8)#382vs CHCRobert Stock (0-2)#348
Fri, Jun 18th@ TEXMike Foltynewicz (2-12)#183@ WSHErick Fedde (7-9)#251
Sat, Jun 19th@ TEXKolby Allard (3-12)#151@ WSHJon Lester (7-6)#291
Sun, Jun 20th@ TEXDane Dunning (5-9)#134@ WSHPatrick Corbin (9-15)#324
Mon, Jun 21stvs CINTyler Mahle (12-6)#27vs ATLIan Anderson (8-5)#63
Tue, Jun 22ndvs CINWade Miley (12-7)#29vs ATLCharlie Morton (13-6)#7
Thu, Jun 24thvs CLEJ.C. Mejia (1-7)#300   
Fri, Jun 25thvs CLECal Quantrill (7-3)#53vs PHIMatt Moore (2-4)#369
Sun, Jun 27thvs CLESam Hentges (1-4)#394vs PHIZack Wheeler (14-9)#3
Tue, Jun 29th@ CWSLucas Giolito (10-9)#25@ ATLCharlie Morton (13-6)#7
Wed, Jun 30th@ CWSDylan Cease (13-7)#32@ ATLMax Fried (13-7)#23
Thu, Jul 1st@ CWSCarlos Rodon (12-5)#34@ ATLIan Anderson (8-5)#63
Fri, Jul 2nd@ KCBrady Singer (5-10)#172   
Sat, Jul 3rd@ KCDanny Duffy (4-3)#90@ NYYJordan Montgomery (6-6)#62
Sun, Jul 4th@ KCBrad Keller (8-12)#385@ NYYNestor Cortes Jr. (2-2)#98
Mon, Jul 5thvs CWSDylan Cease (13-7)#32vs MILBrandon Woodruff (9-10)#11
Tue, Jul 6thvs CWSCarlos Rodon (12-5)#34   
Wed, Jul 7thvs CWSLance Lynn (10-5)#12vs MILBrett Anderson (4-9)#146
Thu, Jul 8thvs DETTarik Skubal (8-12)#61   
Fri, Jul 9thvs DETMatt Manning (4-6)#248vs PITJT Brubaker (5-13)#106
Sat, Jul 10thvs DETKyle Funkhouservs PITMax Kranick (1-3)#280
Sun, Jul 11thvs DETWily Peralta (4-3)#180vs PITChase De Jong (1-4)
Sat, Jul 17th@ DETTyler Alexander (2-3)#109@ PITWil Crowe (4-7)#393
Sun, Jul 18th@ DETWily Peralta (4-3)#180@ PITJT Brubaker (5-13)#106
Mon, Jul 19th@ CWSReynaldo Lopez (3-3)#156@ CINVladimir Gutierrez (9-6)#140
Tue, Jul 20th@ CWSDallas Keuchel (8-9)#375@ CINWade Miley (12-7)#29
Wed, Jul 21st@ CWSDylan Cease (13-7)#32@ CINJeff Hoffman (3-5)#203
Thu, Jul 22ndvs LAAAndrew Heaney (8-9)#105   
Fri, Jul 23rdvs LAAAlex Cobb (8-3)#135vs TORSteven Matz (13-7)#43
Sat, Jul 24thvs LAAPatrick Sandoval (3-6)vs TORHyun Jin Ryu (13-9)#76
Sun, Jul 25thvs LAAJaime Barria (2-4)#190vs TORRoss Stripling (5-7)#97
Mon, Jul 26thvs DETMatt Manning (4-6)#248vs ATLBryse Wilson (3-7)#173
Tue, Jul 27thvs DETTyler Alexander (2-3)#109vs ATLCharlie Morton (13-6)#7
Wed, Jul 28thvs DETWily Peralta (4-3)#180vs ATLMax Fried (13-7)#23
Fri, Jul 30th@ STLWade LeBlanc (0-2)#306vs CINSonny Gray (7-8)#59
Sat, Jul 31st@ STLJake Woodford (3-3)#301vs CINWade Miley (12-7)#29
Sun, Aug 1st@ STLAdam Wainwright (16-7)#6vs CINVladimir Gutierrez (9-6)#140
Tue, Aug 3rd@ CINTyler Mahle (12-6)#27@ MIANick Neidert (1-2)#206
Wed, Aug 4th@ CINLuis Castillo (8-16)#52@ MIAZach Thompson (2-6)#123
Thu, Aug 5th@ HOUFramber Valdez (11-5)#30@ MIABraxton Garrett (1-2)#287
Fri, Aug 6th@ HOUZack Greinke (11-6)#26@ PHIKyle Gibson (10-8)#55
Sat, Aug 7th@ HOULuis Garcia (11-7)#24@ PHIRanger Suarez (6-5)#83
Sun, Aug 8th@ HOULance McCullers Jr. (12-5)#22@ PHIZack Wheeler (14-9)#3
Mon, Aug 9thvs CWSLucas Giolito (10-9)#25   
Tue, Aug 10thvs CWSDallas Keuchel (8-9)#375   
Wed, Aug 11thvs CWSReynaldo Lopez (3-3)#156vs WSHPaolo Espino (5-5)#103
Fri, Aug 13thvs TBShane McClanahan (9-6)#85vs LADJulio Urias (18-3)#8
Sat, Aug 14thvs TBMichael Wacha (3-5)#164vs LADWalker Buehler (14-4)#1
Sun, Aug 15thvs TBLuis Patino (4-3)#133vs LADMax Scherzer (15-4)#2
Mon, Aug 16thvs CLECal Quantrill (7-3)#53@ SFKevin Gausman (14-6)#16
Tue, Aug 17thvs CLEEli Morgan (3-7)#281@ SFLogan Webb (10-3)#48
Wed, Aug 18thvs CLEZach Plesac (10-6)#41@ SFAnthony DeSclafani (12-7)#19
Thu, Aug 19th@ NYYJameson Taillon (8-6)#78@ LADCorey Knebel (3-0)#129
Fri, Aug 20th@ NYYNestor Cortes Jr. (2-2)#98@ LADWalker Buehler (14-4)#1
Sat, Aug 21st@ NYYGerrit Cole (16-8)#5@ LADMax Scherzer (15-4)#2
Tue, Aug 24th@ BOSTanner Houck (1-4)#214vs SFSammy Long (2-1)#193
Wed, Aug 25th@ BOSNick Pivetta (9-7)#132vs SFJohnny Cueto (7-7)#120
Thu, Aug 26th@ BOSChris Sale (5-0)#93vs SFAlex Wood (10-4)#80
Fri, Aug 27thvs MILEric Lauer (7-5)#95vs WSHPaolo Espino (5-5)#103
Sat, Aug 28thvs MILAdrian Houser (9-6)#79vs WSHSean Nolin (0-2)#253
Sun, Aug 29thvs MILAaron Ashby (3-1)#307vs WSHErick Fedde (7-9)#251
Mon, Aug 30th@ DETCasey Mize (7-8)#54   
Tue, Aug 31stvs CHCZach Davies (6-12)#377vs MIAEdward Cabrera (0-3)#216
Wed, Sep 1stvs CHCJustin Steele (3-4)#187   
Fri, Sep 3rd@ TBMichael Wacha (3-5)#164@ WSHSean Nolin (0-2)#253
Sat, Sep 4th@ TBChris Archer (1-1)#99@ WSHJosh Rogers (2-0)#233
Sun, Sep 5th@ TBLuis Patino (4-3)#133@ WSHJosiah Gray (1-2)#160
Mon, Sep 6th@ CLELogan Allen (1-7)#345@ WSHPatrick Corbin (9-15)#324
Tue, Sep 7th@ CLEAaron Civale (11-5)#37@ MIAEdward Cabrera (0-3)#216
Wed, Sep 8th@ CLETriston McKenzie (5-7)#67@ MIASandy Alcantara (9-13)#9
Thu, Sep 9th@ CLECal Quantrill (7-3)#53@ MIAJesus Luzardo (5-8)#152
Fri, Sep 10thvs KCDaniel Lynch (4-6)#390vs NYYJordan Montgomery (6-6)#62
Sat, Sep 11thvs KCBrady Singer (5-10)#172vs NYYCorey Kluber (5-3)#82
Sun, Sep 12thvs KCKris Bubic (5-6)#169vs NYYClarke Schmidt (0-0)#274
Mon, Sep 13th@ NYYLuis Gil (1-1)#220vs STLAdam Wainwright (16-7)#6
Tue, Sep 14thvs CLELogan Allen (1-7)#345vs STLJake Woodford (3-3)#301
Wed, Sep 15thvs CLECal Quantrill (7-3)#53vs STLJon Lester (7-6)#291
Fri, Sep 17th@ TORHyun Jin Ryu (13-9)#76vs PHIZack Wheeler (14-9)#3
Sat, Sep 18th@ TORSteven Matz (13-7)#43vs PHIAaron Nola (9-8)#39
Sun, Sep 19th@ TORJose Berrios (12-9)#13vs PHIKyle Gibson (10-8)#55
Tue, Sep 21st@ CHCAlec Mills (6-7)#176@ BOSEduardo Rodriguez (11-8)#57
Wed, Sep 22nd@ CHCKyle Hendricks (14-7)#60@ BOSChris Sale (5-0)#93
Thu, Sep 23rdvs TORSteven Matz (13-7)#43   
Fri, Sep 24thvs TORJose Berrios (12-9)#13@ MILEric Lauer (7-5)#95
Sat, Sep 25thvs TORRobbie Ray (12-6)#10@ MILCorbin Burnes (10-4)#4
Sun, Sep 26thvs TORAlek Manoah (7-2)#50@ MILFreddy Peralta (9-5)#28
Tue, Sep 28thvs DETTyler Alexander (2-3)#109vs MIAElieser Hernandez (1-3)#68
Wed, Sep 29thvs DETCasey Mize (7-8)#54vs MIAEdward Cabrera (0-3)#216
Thu, Sep 30thvs DETTarik Skubal (8-12)#61vs MIASandy Alcantara (9-13)#9
Fri, Oct 1st@ KCJon Heasley (0-1)@ ATLHuascar Ynoa (4-5)#111
Sat, Oct 2nd@ KC@ ATL
Sun, Oct 3rd@ KC@ ATL
Sat, Apr 17th   @ COLGerman Marquez (12-10)#20
Sun, Apr 18th   @ COLAntonio Senzatela (4-9)#121
Thu, Apr 22nd   @ CHCTrevor Williams (4-2)#154
Sun, May 9th   vs ARIRiley Smith (1-4)#181
Thu, May 27th   vs COLAntonio Senzatela (4-9)#121
Thu, Jun 17th   vs CHCKyle Hendricks (14-7)#60
Wed, Jun 23rd   vs ATLKyle Wright (0-1)#304
Sat, Jun 26th   vs PHIZach Eflin (4-7)
Mon, Jun 28th   @ WSHPaolo Espino (5-5)#103
Fri, Jul 16th   @ PITChad Kuhl (5-7)#225
Thu, Jul 29th   vs ATLDrew Smyly (10-4)#58
Mon, Aug 2nd   @ MIAJesus Luzardo (5-8)#152
Thu, Aug 12th   vs WSHErick Fedde (7-9)#251
Sun, Aug 22nd   @ LADDavid Price (4-2)#108
Thu, Sep 2nd   vs MIASandy Alcantara (9-13)#9