Who Should I Trade?

Marcelo Mayer for Shay Whitcomb (2026)

See if your team wins or loses with this trade View Trade Analyzer

Who Should I Trade? Player Summaries
 
Experts' Pick
 
  Marcelo Mayer
2B,3B,SS - SF
Marcelo Mayer
Shay Whitcomb
2B,3B - SF
Shay Whitcomb
Expert
Recommendation
100%
Recommended by
3 of 3 experts
0%
Recommended by
0 of 3 experts
Rankings 
   
Rest of Season# 274‐
VBR# 710# 1196
   
Projections 
   
Runs102
Home Runs21
RBI102
Stolen Bases11
Batting Average.232.215
   
Misc 
   
Injury AlertIL10MiLB
   
Expert Ranks 
   
Mike Maher
BettingPros		# 241‐
   
Kelly Kirby
FantasyPros		# 234‐
   
Kevin Spinelli
KevScores		# 360‐
   
Who Should I Trade? Player Statistics
  Marcelo Mayer
2B,3B,SS - SF
Marcelo Mayer
Shay Whitcomb
2B,3B - SF
Shay Whitcomb
2026 Stats 
   
   
At Bats20523
   
Runs192
   
Hits453
   
Singles321
   
Doubles100
   
Triples00
   
Home Runs32
   
RBI225
   
Stolen Bases30
   
Caught Stealing00
   
Walks161
   
Strikeouts4411
   
Batting Average.220.130
   
On Base Pct.282.167
   
Slugging Pct.312.391
   
On-base Plus Slugging.594.558
   
Who Should I Trade? Player Projections
  Marcelo Mayer
2B,3B,SS - SF
Marcelo Mayer
Shay Whitcomb
2B,3B - SF
Shay Whitcomb
2026 Projections 
   
   
At Bats8720
   
Runs102
   
Hits204
   
Singles133
   
Doubles41
   
Triples00
   
Home Runs21
   
RBI102
   
Stolen Bases11
   
Caught Stealing00
   
Walks71
   
Strikeouts226
   
Batting Average.232.215
   
On Base Pct.294.266
   
Slugging Pct.359.371
   
On-base Plus Slugging.654.638
   
Who Should I Trade? Player Notes
  Marcelo Mayer
2B,3B,SS - SF
Marcelo Mayer
Shay Whitcomb
2B,3B - SF
Shay Whitcomb
News 
 Marcelo Mayer is expected to join Triple-A Sacramento on a rehab assignment next week.
Ari Koslow
Fri, Aug 7th		Shay Whitcomb was claimed off waivers by the Giants on Thursday.
Nate Miller - FantasyPros
Thu, Aug 13th
 Marcelo Mayer will be re-evaluated by the Giants on Wednesday.
Ari Koslow
Tue, Aug 4th		The Astros designated INF Shay Whitcomb for assignment.
Ari Koslow
Mon, Aug 10th
 The Giants are acquiring Marcelo Mayer from the Red Sox for Erik Miller.
Ari Koslow
Mon, Aug 3rd		The Astros optioned INF/OF Shay Whitcomb to Triple-A Sugar Land.
Ari Koslow
Thu, Jun 11th
 Marcelo Mayer has progressed in his hitting program and has begun to hit off a tee.
Nicholas Rodriguez
Sun, Jul 26th		The Astros recalled Shay Whitcomb from Triple-A.
Ari Koslow
Mon, Jun 8th
 Marcelo Mayer has been cleared to start a hitting program.
Ari Koslow
Mon, Jul 20th		The Astros optioned Shay Whitcomb to Triple-A.
Ari Koslow
Tue, May 19th
Notes 
There are no recent notes for these players
Who Should I Trade? Player Schedules
  Marcelo Mayer
2B,3B,SS - SF
Marcelo Mayer
Shay Whitcomb
2B,3B - SF
Shay Whitcomb
Date OppOpp PitcherVBROppOpp PitcherVBR
Wed, Mar 25thvs NYYMax Fried (4-4)#15vs NYYMax Fried (4-4)#15
Fri, Mar 27thvs NYYCam Schlittler (10-6)#16vs NYYCam Schlittler (10-6)#16
Sat, Mar 28thvs NYYWill Warren (8-6)#53vs NYYWill Warren (8-6)#53
Mon, Mar 30th@ SDWalker Buehler (7-5)#278@ SDWalker Buehler (7-5)#278
Tue, Mar 31st@ SDGerman Marquez (4-2)#417@ SDGerman Marquez (4-2)#417
Wed, Apr 1st@ SDNick Pivetta (1-2)#119@ SDNick Pivetta (1-2)#119
Thu, Apr 2ndvs NYMDavid Peterson (7-7)#152vs NYMDavid Peterson (7-7)#152
Fri, Apr 3rdvs NYMNolan McLean (8-8)#28vs NYMNolan McLean (8-8)#28
Sat, Apr 4thvs NYMClay Holmes (5-5)#71vs NYMClay Holmes (5-5)#71
Sun, Apr 5thvs NYMKodai Senga (0-8)#109vs NYMKodai Senga (0-8)#109
Mon, Apr 6thvs PHIAndrew Painter (2-8)#174vs PHIAndrew Painter (2-8)#174
Tue, Apr 7thvs PHICristopher Sanchez (15-4)#3vs PHICristopher Sanchez (15-4)#3
Wed, Apr 8thvs PHIAaron Nola (4-9)#63vs PHIAaron Nola (4-9)#63
Fri, Apr 10th@ BALShane Baz (4-12)#58@ BALShane Baz (4-12)#58
Sat, Apr 11th@ BALChris Bassitt (4-4)#176@ BALChris Bassitt (4-4)#176
Sun, Apr 12th@ BALCade Povich (2-1)#224@ BALCade Povich (2-1)#224
Tue, Apr 14th@ CINBrady Singer (5-11)#173@ CINBrady Singer (5-11)#173
Wed, Apr 15th@ CINRhett Lowder (4-8)#215@ CINRhett Lowder (4-8)#215
Thu, Apr 16th@ CINChase Burns (14-2)#26@ CINChase Burns (14-2)#26
Fri, Apr 17th@ WSHZack Littell (8-8)#212@ WSHZack Littell (8-8)#212
Sat, Apr 18th@ WSHCade Cavalli (10-5)#47@ WSHCade Cavalli (10-5)#47
Sun, Apr 19th@ WSHPJ Poulin (3-0)#349@ WSHPJ Poulin (3-0)#349
Tue, Apr 21stvs LADYoshinobu Yamamoto (12-7)#12vs LADYoshinobu Yamamoto (12-7)#12
Wed, Apr 22ndvs LADShohei Ohtani (8-2)#1vs LADShohei Ohtani (8-2)#1
Thu, Apr 23rdvs LADTyler Glasnow (3-0)#44vs LADTyler Glasnow (3-0)#44
Fri, Apr 24thvs MIASandy Alcantara (13-7)#65vs MIASandy Alcantara (13-7)#65
Sat, Apr 25thvs MIAEury Perez (6-9)#32vs MIAEury Perez (6-9)#32
Sun, Apr 26thvs MIAMax Meyer (9-1)#140vs MIAMax Meyer (9-1)#140
Tue, Apr 28th@ PHIJesus Luzardo (11-5)#11@ PHIJesus Luzardo (11-5)#11
Thu, Apr 30th@ PHITim Mayza (3-3)#149@ PHITim Mayza (3-3)#149
Fri, May 1st@ TBShane McClanahan (9-6)#36@ TBShane McClanahan (9-6)#36
Sat, May 2nd@ TBGriffin Jax (6-9)#84@ TBGriffin Jax (6-9)#84
Sun, May 3rd@ TBSteven Matz (5-4)#175@ TBSteven Matz (5-4)#175
Mon, May 4thvs SDRandy Vasquez (8-6)#379vs SDRandy Vasquez (8-6)#379
Tue, May 5thvs SDWalker Buehler (7-5)#278vs SDWalker Buehler (7-5)#278
Wed, May 6thvs SDBradgley Rodriguez (3-2)#145vs SDBradgley Rodriguez (3-2)#145
Fri, May 8thvs PITCarmen Mlodzinski (6-5)#113vs PITCarmen Mlodzinski (6-5)#113
Sat, May 9thvs PITBraxton Ashcraft (12-5)#30vs PITBraxton Ashcraft (12-5)#30
Sun, May 10thvs PITBubba Chandler (6-8)#114vs PITBubba Chandler (6-8)#114
Mon, May 11th@ LADRoki Sasaki (5-5)#90@ LADRoki Sasaki (5-5)#90
Tue, May 12th@ LADYoshinobu Yamamoto (12-7)#12@ LADYoshinobu Yamamoto (12-7)#12
Wed, May 13th@ LADShohei Ohtani (8-2)#1@ LADShohei Ohtani (8-2)#1
Thu, May 14th@ LADEmmet Sheehan (4-8)#141@ LADEmmet Sheehan (4-8)#141
Fri, May 15th@ ATHAaron Civale (5-7)#156@ ATHAaron Civale (5-7)#156
Sat, May 16th@ ATHLuis Severino (2-6)#243@ ATHLuis Severino (2-6)#243
Sun, May 17th@ ATHJeffrey Springs (3-11)#297@ ATHJeffrey Springs (3-11)#297
Mon, May 18th@ ARIZac Gallen (3-9)#207@ ARIZac Gallen (3-9)#207
Tue, May 19th@ ARIRyne Nelson (3-5)#291@ ARIRyne Nelson (3-5)#291
Wed, May 20th@ ARIMerrill Kelly (8-10)#158@ ARIMerrill Kelly (8-10)#158
Fri, May 22ndvs CWSDavis Martin (9-6)#121vs CWSDavis Martin (9-6)#121
Sat, May 23rdvs CWSBryan Hudson (3-4)#155vs CWSBryan Hudson (3-4)#155
Sun, May 24thvs CWSNoah Schultz (3-9)#405vs CWSNoah Schultz (3-9)#405
Mon, May 25thvs ARIMerrill Kelly (8-10)#158vs ARIMerrill Kelly (8-10)#158
Tue, May 26thvs ARIEduardo Rodriguez (12-4)#94vs ARIEduardo Rodriguez (12-4)#94
Wed, May 27thvs ARIMichael Soroka (8-3)#68vs ARIMichael Soroka (8-3)#68
Fri, May 29th@ COLMichael Lorenzen (3-11)#437@ COLMichael Lorenzen (3-11)#437
Sat, May 30th@ COLRyan Feltner (5-6)#439@ COLRyan Feltner (5-6)#439
Sun, May 31st@ COLTanner Gordon (0-3)#368@ COLTanner Gordon (0-3)#368
Mon, Jun 1st@ MILShane Drohan (6-4)#96@ MILShane Drohan (6-4)#96
Tue, Jun 2nd@ MILKyle Harrison (9-3)#46@ MILKyle Harrison (9-3)#46
Wed, Jun 3rd@ MILRobert Gasser (3-5)#132@ MILRobert Gasser (3-5)#132
Thu, Jun 4th@ MILColeman Crow (0-1)#280@ MILColeman Crow (0-1)#280
Fri, Jun 5th@ CHCEdward Cabrera (5-5)#75@ CHCEdward Cabrera (5-5)#75
Sat, Jun 6th@ CHCBen Brown (4-2)#234@ CHCBen Brown (4-2)#234
Sun, Jun 7th@ CHCJameson Taillon (2-6)#216@ CHCJameson Taillon (2-6)#216
Mon, Jun 8thvs WSHRichard Lovelady (2-4)#340vs WSHRichard Lovelady (2-4)#340
Tue, Jun 9thvs WSHAndrew Alvarez (2-4)#120vs WSHAndrew Alvarez (2-4)#120
Wed, Jun 10thvs WSHFoster Griffin (13-4)#52vs WSHFoster Griffin (13-4)#52
Fri, Jun 12thvs CHCJavier Assad (6-1)#209vs CHCJavier Assad (6-1)#209
Sat, Jun 13thvs CHCBen Brown (4-2)#234vs CHCBen Brown (4-2)#234
Sun, Jun 14thvs CHCRyan Rolisonvs CHCRyan Rolison
Wed, Jun 17th@ ATLJR Ritchie (1-2)#261@ ATLJR Ritchie (1-2)#261
Fri, Jun 19th@ MIALake Bachar (1-2)#184@ MIALake Bachar (1-2)#184
Sat, Jun 20th@ MIAMax Meyer (9-1)#140@ MIAMax Meyer (9-1)#140
Sun, Jun 21st@ MIARyan Gusto (0-3)#194@ MIARyan Gusto (0-3)#194
Tue, Jun 23rdvs ATHAaron Civale (5-7)#156vs ATHAaron Civale (5-7)#156
Wed, Jun 24thvs ATHGage Jump (5-7)#93vs ATHGage Jump (5-7)#93
Thu, Jun 25thvs ATHJeffrey Springs (3-11)#297vs ATHJeffrey Springs (3-11)#297
Fri, Jun 26thvs ATLReynaldo Lopez (4-3)#106vs ATLReynaldo Lopez (4-3)#106
Sat, Jun 27thvs ATLBryce Elder (8-7)#161vs ATLBryce Elder (8-7)#161
Sun, Jun 28thvs ATLChris Sale (12-8)#7vs ATLChris Sale (12-8)#7
Mon, Jun 29th@ ARIEduardo Rodriguez (12-4)#94@ ARIEduardo Rodriguez (12-4)#94
Tue, Jun 30th@ ARIBrandon Pfaadt (7-1)#98@ ARIBrandon Pfaadt (7-1)#98
Wed, Jul 1st@ ARIZac Gallen (3-9)#207@ ARIZac Gallen (3-9)#207
Fri, Jul 3rd@ COLRyan Feltner (5-6)#439@ COLRyan Feltner (5-6)#439
Sat, Jul 4th@ COLSean Sullivan (0-3)#427@ COLSean Sullivan (0-3)#427
Sun, Jul 5th@ COLTanner Gordon (0-3)#368@ COLTanner Gordon (0-3)#368
Mon, Jul 6thvs TORKevin Gausman (6-11)#21vs TORKevin Gausman (6-11)#21
Tue, Jul 7thvs TORSpencer Miles (5-2)#117vs TORSpencer Miles (5-2)#117
Wed, Jul 8thvs TORDylan Cease (7-5)#10vs TORDylan Cease (7-5)#10
Thu, Jul 9thvs COLRyan Feltner (5-6)#439vs COLRyan Feltner (5-6)#439
Fri, Jul 10thvs COLTanner Gordon (0-3)#368vs COLTanner Gordon (0-3)#368
Sat, Jul 11thvs COLKyle Freeland (4-10)#384vs COLKyle Freeland (4-10)#384
Sun, Jul 12thvs COLMichael Lorenzen (3-11)#437vs COLMichael Lorenzen (3-11)#437
Fri, Jul 17th@ SEABryce Miller (4-6)#35@ SEABryce Miller (4-6)#35
Sat, Jul 18th@ SEABryan Woo (9-8)#13@ SEABryan Woo (9-8)#13
Sun, Jul 19th@ SEALogan Gilbert (9-7)#9@ SEALogan Gilbert (9-7)#9
Mon, Jul 20th@ KCMichael Wacha (5-8)#70@ KCMichael Wacha (5-8)#70
Tue, Jul 21st@ KCLuinder Avila (5-4)@ KCLuinder Avila (5-4)
Wed, Jul 22nd@ KCSeth Lugo (5-7)#138@ KCSeth Lugo (5-7)#138
Fri, Jul 24thvs LAAGrayson Rodriguez (3-5)#92vs LAAGrayson Rodriguez (3-5)#92
Sat, Jul 25thvs LAARyan Johnson (2-7)#248vs LAARyan Johnson (2-7)#248
Sun, Jul 26thvs LAAJose Soriano (9-6)#38vs LAAJose Soriano (9-6)#38
Mon, Jul 27thvs MILBrandon Sproat (3-7)#189vs MILBrandon Sproat (3-7)#189
Tue, Jul 28thvs MILLogan Henderson (7-2)#37vs MILLogan Henderson (7-2)#37
Wed, Jul 29thvs MILThomas Pannone (0-1)#380vs MILThomas Pannone (0-1)#380
Thu, Jul 30th@ SDJP Sears (3-4)#325@ SDJP Sears (3-4)#325
Fri, Jul 31st@ SDBradgley Rodriguez (3-2)#145@ SDBradgley Rodriguez (3-2)#145
Sat, Aug 1st@ SDWalker Buehler (7-5)#278@ SDWalker Buehler (7-5)#278
Sun, Aug 2nd@ SDKyle Hart (0-3)#177@ SDKyle Hart (0-3)#177
Mon, Aug 3rd@ TEXCal Quantrill (4-4)#260@ TEXCal Quantrill (4-4)#260
Tue, Aug 4th@ TEXMacKenzie Gore (7-9)#41@ TEXMacKenzie Gore (7-9)#41
Wed, Aug 5th@ TEXCody Bradford (0-1)#77@ TEXCody Bradford (0-1)#77
Fri, Aug 7thvs DETKeider Montero (9-7)#142vs DETKeider Montero (9-7)#142
Sat, Aug 8thvs DETJackson Jobe (1-1)#241vs DETJackson Jobe (1-1)#241
Sun, Aug 9thvs DETTroy Melton (7-1)#62vs DETTroy Melton (7-1)#62
Mon, Aug 10thvs HOUHayden Wesneski (2-1)#88vs HOUHayden Wesneski (2-1)#88
Tue, Aug 11thvs HOUHunter Brown (3-3)#19vs HOUHunter Brown (3-3)#19
Wed, Aug 12thvs HOUBryan Kingvs HOUBryan King
Fri, Aug 14thvs COLKyle Freeland (4-10)#384vs COLKyle Freeland (4-10)#384
Sat, Aug 15thvs COLMichael Lorenzen (3-11)#437vs COLMichael Lorenzen (3-11)#437
Sun, Aug 16thvs COLGabriel Hughes (0-4)#313vs COLGabriel Hughes (0-4)#313
Tue, Aug 18th@ CLEFoster Griffin (13-4)#52@ CLEFoster Griffin (13-4)#52
Wed, Aug 19th@ CLEParker Messick (9-7)#42@ CLEParker Messick (9-7)#42
Thu, Aug 20th@ CLEGavin Williams (11-7)#17@ CLEGavin Williams (11-7)#17
Fri, Aug 21st@ BOSJake Bennett (7-6)#80@ BOSJake Bennett (7-6)#80
Sat, Aug 22nd@ BOSSonny Gray (15-3)#27@ BOSSonny Gray (15-3)#27
Sun, Aug 23rd@ BOSPatrick Sandoval (1-2)#105@ BOSPatrick Sandoval (1-2)#105
Mon, Aug 24thvs CINChase Burns (14-2)#26vs CINChase Burns (14-2)#26
Tue, Aug 25thvs CINBrady Singer (5-11)#173vs CINBrady Singer (5-11)#173
Wed, Aug 26thvs CINNick Lodolo (3-2)#91vs CINNick Lodolo (3-2)#91
Thu, Aug 27thvs ARIvs ARI
Fri, Aug 28thvs ARIvs ARI
Sat, Aug 29thvs ARIvs ARI
Mon, Aug 31st@ ATLSpencer Strider (4-2)#281@ ATLSpencer Strider (4-2)#281
Tue, Sep 1st@ PIT@ PIT
Wed, Sep 2nd@ PIT@ PIT
Thu, Sep 3rd@ PIT@ PIT
Fri, Sep 4th@ NYM@ NYM
Sat, Sep 5th@ NYM@ NYM
Sun, Sep 6th@ NYM@ NYM
Mon, Sep 7thvs STLvs STL
Tue, Sep 8thvs STLvs STL
Wed, Sep 9thvs STLvs STL
Fri, Sep 11thvs SDvs SD
Sat, Sep 12thvs SDvs SD
Sun, Sep 13thvs SDvs SD
Mon, Sep 14th@ STL@ STL
Tue, Sep 15th@ STL@ STL
Wed, Sep 16th@ STL@ STL
Fri, Sep 18th@ LAD@ LAD
Sat, Sep 19th@ LAD@ LAD
Sun, Sep 20th@ LAD@ LAD
Mon, Sep 21stvs MINvs MIN
Tue, Sep 22ndvs MINvs MIN
Wed, Sep 23rdvs MINvs MIN
Fri, Sep 25thvs LADvs LAD
Sat, Sep 26thvs LADvs LAD
Sun, Sep 27thvs LADvs LAD