Who Should I Trade?

Matthew Boyd for Caleb Smith (2019)

See if your team wins or loses with this trade View Trade Analyzer

Experts' Pick
  Matthew Boyd
Matthew Boyd
DET @ CWS Sun, Sep 29th 3:10pm
Caleb Smith
Caleb Smith
MIA @ PHI Sun, Sep 29th 3:05pm
Recommended by
12 of 16 experts
Recommended by
4 of 16 experts
Rest of Season
Injury Alert--
Expert Ranks 
Alan Harrison
The Fantasy Fix
# 18# 40
Eno Sarris
The Athletic
# 48# 56
Andrew Gould
# 31# 69
Andrea LaMont
Lenny Melnick Fantasy Sports
# 57# 136
Paul Sporer
# 108
Nick Mariano
# 26# 46
Bobby Sylvester
# 25# 39
Dan Harris
# 39# 49
Andrew Seifter
# 46# 53
Max Freeze
Freeze Stats
# 24# 32
Mick Ciallela
# 39# 60
Todd D Clark
The Fantasy Fix
# 18# 34
Pierre Camus
# 33# 32
Joe Bond
Fantasy Six Pack
# 40# 24
Chris Meaney
The Athletic
# 51# 44
Brandon 'B_Don' Myers
# 56# 35
  Matthew Boyd
Matthew Boyd
Caleb Smith
Caleb Smith
2019 Stats 
Games Played3228
Games Started3228
Innings Pitched185.2153.0
Blown Saves00
Hits Allowed178128
Earned Runs9477
Home Runs Allowed3933
  Matthew Boyd
Matthew Boyd
Caleb Smith
Caleb Smith
2019 Projections 
Games Played
Games Started
Innings Pitched
Blown Saves
Hits Allowed
Earned Runs
Home Runs Allowed
  Matthew Boyd
Matthew Boyd
Caleb Smith
Caleb Smith
 Detroit Tigers left-hander Matthew Boyd struggled in a 7-1 loss to the White Sox on Saturday. Boyd allowed four runs (two earned) over four innings while striking out four.
Matthew Terelle
Sun, Sep 29th
Marlins starter Caleb Smith allowed five earned runs on five hits and four walks while striking out just one in Saturday's loss to the Phillies.
Mike Maher
Sun, Sep 29th
 Detroit Tigers left-hander Matthew Boyd pitched well in a 6-3 win over the White Sox on Sunday. Boyd allowed three runs over five innings while striking out six and walking two.
Matthew Terelle
Mon, Sep 23rd
Marlins starter Caleb Smith allowed four earned runs on seven hits and four walks while striking out three over six innings in Monday's win over the Mets. The win brings him to 10-10 on the year.
Mike Maher
Tue, Sep 24th
 Detroit Tigers left-hander Matthew Boyd pitched five innings in a 10-4 loss to the Yankees in the first game of a Thursday doubleheader. Boyd allowed four runs (two earned) while striking out three and walking four.
Matthew Terelle
Thu, Sep 12th
Marlins starter Caleb Smith allowed four earned runs on eight hits and one walk while striking out four over five innings in Tuesday's win over the Diamondbacks.
Mike Maher
Wed, Sep 18th
 Detroit Tigers left-hander Matthew Boyd pitched well in a 6-4 win over the Royals on Thursday. Boyd allowed three runs in 6 1/3 innings of work while striking out six.
Matthew Terelle
Thu, Sep 5th
Marlins starter Caleb Smith allowed three earned runs on six hits and two walks while striking out four over 5 2/3 innings in Thursday's loss to the Brewers.
Mike Maher
Fri, Sep 13th
 Detroit Tigers left-hander Matthew Boyd allowed five runs over six innings in a 10-7 win over the Twins on Saturday. Boyd struck out 11 and walked one in the win.
Matthew Terelle
Sun, Sep 1st
Marlins starter Caleb Smith tossed six shutout innings in a no-decision against the Kansas City Royals on Saturday, allowing four hits and two walks while striking out eight.
Mike Maher
Sun, Sep 8th
There are no recent notes for these players
  Matthew Boyd
Matthew Boyd
Caleb Smith
Caleb Smith
Date OppOpp PitcherVBROppOpp PitcherVBR
Thu, Mar 28th@ TORvs COL
Fri, Mar 29th@ TORvs COL
Sat, Mar 30th@ TORvs COL
Sun, Mar 31st@ TORvs COL
Mon, Apr 1st@ NYYvs NYM
Tue, Apr 2nd@ NYYvs NYM
Wed, Apr 3rd@ NYYvs NYM
Thu, Apr 4thvs KC   
Sat, Apr 6thvs KC@ ATL
Sun, Apr 7thvs KC@ ATL
Tue, Apr 9thvs CLE@ CIN
Wed, Apr 10thvs CLE@ CIN
Thu, Apr 11thvs CLE@ CIN
Sat, Apr 13th@ MINvs PHI
Sun, Apr 14th@ MINvs PHI
Tue, Apr 16thvs PITvs CHC
Wed, Apr 17thvs PITvs CHC
Thu, Apr 18thvs CWS   
Fri, Apr 19thvs CWSvs WSH
Sun, Apr 21stvs CWSvs WSH
Tue, Apr 23rd@ BOS@ CLE
Wed, Apr 24th@ BOS@ CLE
Thu, Apr 25th@ BOS@ PHI
Fri, Apr 26th@ CWS@ PHI
Sun, Apr 28th@ CWS@ PHI
Tue, Apr 30th@ PHIvs CLE
Wed, May 1st@ PHIvs CLE
Fri, May 3rdvs KCvs ATL
Sat, May 4thvs KCvs ATL
Sun, May 5thvs KCvs ATL
Tue, May 7thvs LAA@ CHC
Wed, May 8thvs LAA@ CHC
Thu, May 9thvs LAA@ CHC
Fri, May 10th@ MIN@ NYM
Sat, May 11th@ MIN@ NYM
Sun, May 12th@ MIN   
Mon, May 13thvs HOU   
Tue, May 14thvs HOUvs TB
Wed, May 15thvs HOUvs TB
Thu, May 16thvs OAK   
Fri, May 17thvs OAKvs NYM
Sat, May 18thvs OAKvs NYM
Tue, May 21stvs MIA@ DET
Wed, May 22ndvs MIA@ DET
Thu, May 23rdvs MIA@ DET
Fri, May 24th@ NYM@ WSH
Sat, May 25th@ NYM@ WSH
Sun, May 26th@ NYM@ WSH
Mon, May 27th@ BAL@ WSH
Tue, May 28th@ BALvs SF
Wed, May 29th@ BALvs SF
Fri, May 31st@ ATL@ SD
Sat, Jun 1st@ ATL@ SD
Sun, Jun 2nd@ ATL@ SD
Tue, Jun 4thvs TB@ MIL
Wed, Jun 5thvs TB@ MIL
Thu, Jun 6thvs TB@ MIL
Fri, Jun 7thvs MINvs ATL
Sat, Jun 8thvs MINvs ATL
Sun, Jun 9thvs MINvs ATL
Tue, Jun 11th@ KCvs STL
Wed, Jun 12th@ KCvs STL
Thu, Jun 13th@ KC   
Fri, Jun 14thvs CLEvs PIT
Sat, Jun 15thvs CLEvs PIT
Sun, Jun 16thvs CLEvs PIT
Tue, Jun 18th@ PIT@ STL
Wed, Jun 19th@ PIT@ STL
Fri, Jun 21st@ CLE@ PHI
Sat, Jun 22nd@ CLE@ PHI
Sun, Jun 23rd@ CLE@ PHI
Tue, Jun 25thvs TEXvs WSH
Wed, Jun 26thvs TEXvs WSH
Thu, Jun 27thvs TEXvs WSH
Fri, Jun 28thvs WSHvs PHI
Sat, Jun 29thvs WSHvs PHI
Sun, Jun 30thvs WSHvs PHI
Wed, Jul 3rd@ CWS@ WSH
Thu, Jul 4th@ CWS@ WSH
Fri, Jul 5thvs BOS@ ATL
Sat, Jul 6thvs BOS@ ATL
Sun, Jul 7thvs BOS@ ATL
Fri, Jul 12th@ KCvs NYM
Sat, Jul 13th@ KCvs NYM
Sun, Jul 14th@ KCvs NYM
Mon, Jul 15th@ CLE   
Tue, Jul 16th@ CLEvs SD
Wed, Jul 17th@ CLEvs SD
Thu, Jul 18th@ CLEvs SD
Fri, Jul 19thvs TOR@ LAD
Sat, Jul 20thvs TOR@ LAD
Sun, Jul 21stvs TOR@ LAD
Tue, Jul 23rdvs PHI@ CWS
Wed, Jul 24thvs PHI@ CWS
Thu, Jul 25th@ SEA   
Fri, Jul 26th@ SEAvs ARI
Sat, Jul 27th@ SEAvs ARI
Sun, Jul 28th@ SEAvs ARI
Mon, Jul 29th@ LAAvs ARI
Tue, Jul 30th@ LAAvs MIN
Wed, Jul 31st@ LAAvs MIN
Fri, Aug 2nd@ TEX   
Sat, Aug 3rd@ TEX@ TB
Sun, Aug 4th@ TEX@ TB
Mon, Aug 5thvs CWS@ NYM
Tue, Aug 6thvs CWS@ NYM
Wed, Aug 7thvs CWS@ NYM
Thu, Aug 8thvs KCvs ATL
Fri, Aug 9thvs KCvs ATL
Sat, Aug 10thvs KCvs ATL
Sun, Aug 11thvs KCvs ATL
Tue, Aug 13thvs SEAvs LAD
Wed, Aug 14thvs SEAvs LAD
Thu, Aug 15thvs SEAvs LAD
Fri, Aug 16th@ TB@ COL
Sat, Aug 17th@ TB@ COL
Sun, Aug 18th@ TB@ COL
Mon, Aug 19th@ HOU   
Tue, Aug 20th@ HOU@ ATL
Wed, Aug 21st@ HOU@ ATL
Thu, Aug 22nd@ HOU@ ATL
Fri, Aug 23rd@ MINvs PHI
Sat, Aug 24th@ MINvs PHI
Sun, Aug 25th@ MINvs PHI
Tue, Aug 27thvs CLEvs CIN
Wed, Aug 28thvs CLEvs CIN
Thu, Aug 29thvs CLEvs CIN
Fri, Aug 30thvs MIN@ WSH
Sat, Aug 31stvs MIN@ WSH
Sun, Sep 1stvs MIN@ WSH
Mon, Sep 2ndvs MIN   
Tue, Sep 3rd@ KC@ PIT
Wed, Sep 4th@ KC@ PIT
Thu, Sep 5th@ KC@ PIT
Fri, Sep 6th@ OAKvs KC
Sat, Sep 7th@ OAKvs KC
Sun, Sep 8th@ OAKvs KC
Tue, Sep 10thvs NYYvs MIL
Thu, Sep 12thvs NYYvs MIL
Fri, Sep 13thvs BAL@ SF
Sat, Sep 14thvs BAL@ SF
Sun, Sep 15thvs BAL@ SF
Mon, Sep 16thvs BAL@ ARI
Tue, Sep 17th@ CLE@ ARI
Wed, Sep 18th@ CLE@ ARI
Thu, Sep 19th@ CLE   
Fri, Sep 20thvs CWSvs WSH
Sat, Sep 21stvs CWSvs WSH
Sun, Sep 22ndvs CWSvs WSH
Tue, Sep 24thvs MIN@ NYM
Wed, Sep 25thvs MIN@ NYM
Thu, Sep 26thvs MIN@ NYM
Fri, Sep 27th@ CWS@ PHI
Sat, Sep 28th@ CWS@ PHI
Sun, Sep 29th@ CWS@ PHI
Fri, Apr 5th   @ ATL
Fri, Apr 12th   vs PHI
Mon, Apr 15th   vs CHC
Sat, Apr 20th   vs WSH
Sat, Apr 27th   @ PHI
Mon, May 6th   @ CHC
Sun, May 19th   vs NYM
Thu, May 30th   vs SF
Mon, Jun 10th   vs STL
Mon, Jun 17th   @ STL
Thu, Jun 20th   @ STL
Tue, Jul 2nd   @ WSH
Mon, Jul 22nd   @ CWS
Thu, Aug 1st   vs MIN
Mon, Aug 26th   vs CIN
Mon, Sep 9th   vs MIL
Wed, Sep 11th   vs MIL
Mon, Sep 23rd   @ NYM