Skip to main content

Who Should I Trade?

Nolan Arenado for Max Scherzer (2024)


See if your team wins or loses with this trade View Trade Analyzer

Who Should I Trade? Player Summaries
 
Experts' Pick
 
  Nolan Arenado
3B - STL
Nolan Arenado
Max Scherzer
SP - TEX
Max Scherzer
Expert
Recommendation
100%
Recommended by
8 of 8 experts
0%
Recommended by
0 of 8 experts
Rankings 
   
Rest of Season# 72# 235
VBR# 67# 129
   
Projections 
   
Runs64
Home Runs2118
RBI81
Stolen Bases3
Batting Avg.264
Strikeouts82107
Wins6
Saves0
ERA3.86
WHIP1.19
   
Misc 
   
Injury Alert-IL15
   
Expert Ranks 
   
Andy Behrens
Yahoo! Sports
# 83# 277
   
Scott Pianowski
Yahoo! Sports
# 70# 290
   
Pat Fitzmaurice
FantasyPros
# 50# 262
   
Dalton Del Don
Yahoo! Sports
# 67# 248
   
Christopher Welsh
FantasyPros
# 91# 215
   
Mike Maher
FantasyPros
# 77# 345
   
Joe Pisapia
FantasyPros
# 57# 155
   
Kelly Kirby
FantasyPros
# 95# 151
   
Who Should I Trade? Player Statistics
  Nolan Arenado
3B - STL
Nolan Arenado
Max Scherzer
SP - TEX
Max Scherzer
2024 Stats 
   
   
Runs7
   
Home Runs1
   
RBI11
   
Stolen Bases0
   
Batting Avg.283
   
Strikeouts12
   
Wins
   
Saves
   
ERA
   
WHIP
   
Who Should I Trade? Player Projections
  Nolan Arenado
3B - STL
Nolan Arenado
Max Scherzer
SP - TEX
Max Scherzer
2024 Projections 
   
   
Runs64
   
Home Runs2118
   
RBI81
   
Stolen Bases3
   
Batting Avg.264
   
Strikeouts82107
   
Wins6
   
Saves0
   
ERA3.86
   
WHIP1.19
   
Who Should I Trade? Player Notes
  Nolan Arenado
3B - STL
Nolan Arenado
Max Scherzer
SP - TEX
Max Scherzer
News 
 Nolan Arenado went 1-for-2 with a double and two RBI in the Cardinals' 12-5 loss to the Brewers.
Chris Schommer
Sun, Apr 21st
Max Scherzer (back) is likely going to make his first rehab start Wednesday.
Jesse Garcia
Sat, Apr 20th
 Nolan Arenado went 3-for-5 in the Cardinals' 9-6 win over the Diamondbacks, including a home run, three RBI, and one run scored.
Chris Schommer
Sat, Apr 13th
Max Scherzer reportedly could return as soon as early May.
Ari Koslow
Fri, Apr 19th
 Nolan Arenado produced one hit and an RBI over four at-bats in Wednesday's 4-3 loss to the Phillies.
Craig Castriano
Thu, Apr 11th
Texas Rangers right-hander Max Scherzer said he will throw live batting practice after throwing a bullpen session on Tuesday.
Brenton Kemp
Tue, Apr 9th
  Rangers manager Bruce Bochy said he expects Max Scherzer to return in June.
Ari Koslow
Sat, Mar 2nd
  Max Scherzer reportedly said at Rangers' FanFest that he should start working out again in about three weeks.
Ari Koslow
Sun, Jan 28th
Notes 
There are no recent notes for these players
Who Should I Trade? Player Schedules
  Nolan Arenado
3B - STL
Nolan Arenado
Max Scherzer
SP - TEX
Max Scherzer
Date OppOpp PitcherVBROppOpp PitcherVBR
Thu, Mar 28th@ LADTyler Glasnow (4-1)#13vs CHCJustin Steele (0-0)#36
Fri, Mar 29th@ LADBobby Miller (1-1)#41   
Sat, Mar 30th@ LADYoshinobu Yamamoto (1-1)#7vs CHCKyle Hendricks (0-3)#169
Sun, Mar 31st@ LADGavin Stone (1-1)#153vs CHCJordan Wicks (1-2)#107
Mon, Apr 1st@ SDMatt Waldron (0-2)#173@ TBRyan Pepiot (2-2)#57
Tue, Apr 2nd@ SDYu Darvish (0-1)#45@ TBZach Eflin (1-2)#12
Wed, Apr 3rd@ SDJoe Musgrove (3-2)#30@ TBAaron Civale (2-2)#46
Thu, Apr 4thvs MIARyan Weathers (2-2)#213   
Sat, Apr 6thvs MIATrevor Rogers (0-3)#84vs HOUJ.P. France (0-3)#168
Sun, Apr 7thvs MIAMax Meyer (2-0)#116vs HOURonel Blanco (2-0)#134
Mon, Apr 8thvs PHISpencer Turnbull (2-0)#205vs HOUBlair Henley (0-0)
Tue, Apr 9thvs PHIZack Wheeler (1-3)#1vs OAKAlex Wood (0-2)#171
Wed, Apr 10thvs PHIAaron Nola (3-1)#18vs OAKRoss Stripling (0-5)#109
Fri, Apr 12th@ ARIBrandon Pfaadt (1-1)#59@ HOUJ.P. France (0-3)#168
Sat, Apr 13th@ ARIRyne Nelson (1-2)#178@ HOURonel Blanco (2-0)#134
Sun, Apr 14th@ ARIZac Gallen (3-1)#14@ HOUCristian Javier (2-0)#81
Mon, Apr 15th@ OAKRoss Stripling (0-5)#109@ DETReese Olson (0-3)#104
Tue, Apr 16th@ OAKJP Sears (1-1)#92@ DETCasey Mize (1-0)#117
Wed, Apr 17th@ OAKPaul Blackburn (2-1)#122@ DETTarik Skubal (3-0)#8
Fri, Apr 19thvs MILFreddy Peralta (2-0)#9@ ATLChris Sale (2-1)#21
Sat, Apr 20thvs MILDL Hall (0-1)#141@ ATLCharlie Morton (2-0)#61
Sun, Apr 21stvs MILColin Rea (2-0)#146@ ATLDarius Vines (0-1)#188
Mon, Apr 22ndvs ARIBrandon Pfaadt (1-1)#59   
Tue, Apr 23rdvs ARITommy Henry (1-1)#245vs SEALogan Gilbert (2-0)#15
Wed, Apr 24thvs ARIJordan Montgomery (1-0)#29vs SEABryce Miller (3-1)#50
Fri, Apr 26th@ NYMJose Butto (0-0)#225vs CINGraham Ashcraft (3-1)#177
Sat, Apr 27th@ NYMAdrian Houser (0-2)#208vs CINHunter Greene (0-2)#44
Sun, Apr 28th@ NYMJose Quintana (1-2)#131vs CINAndrew Abbott (1-2)#110
Mon, Apr 29th@ DETKenta Maeda (0-1)#106   
Tue, Apr 30th@ DETJack Flaherty (0-1)#97vs WSHMacKenzie Gore (2-1)#53
Wed, May 1st@ DETvs WSH
Fri, May 3rdvs CWS@ KC
Sat, May 4thvs CWS@ KC
Sun, May 5thvs CWS@ KC
Mon, May 6thvs NYM@ OAK
Tue, May 7thvs NYM@ OAK
Wed, May 8thvs NYM@ OAK
Thu, May 9th@ MIL   
Fri, May 10th@ MIL@ COL
Sat, May 11th@ MIL@ COL
Sun, May 12th@ MIL@ COL
Mon, May 13th@ LAAvs CLE
Tue, May 14th@ LAAvs CLE
Wed, May 15th@ LAAvs CLE
Fri, May 17thvs BOSvs LAA
Sat, May 18thvs BOSvs LAA
Sun, May 19thvs BOSvs LAA
Mon, May 20thvs BAL   
Tue, May 21stvs BAL@ PHI
Wed, May 22ndvs BAL@ PHI
Fri, May 24thvs CHC@ MIN
Sat, May 25thvs CHC@ MIN
Sun, May 26thvs CHC@ MIN
Mon, May 27th@ CIN   
Tue, May 28th@ CINvs ARI
Wed, May 29th@ CINvs ARI
Fri, May 31st@ PHI@ MIA
Sat, Jun 1st@ PHI@ MIA
Sun, Jun 2nd@ PHI@ MIA
Mon, Jun 3rd@ HOUvs DET
Tue, Jun 4th@ HOUvs DET
Wed, Jun 5th@ HOUvs DET
Thu, Jun 6thvs COL   
Fri, Jun 7thvs COLvs SF
Sat, Jun 8thvs COLvs SF
Sun, Jun 9thvs COLvs SF
Tue, Jun 11thvs PIT@ LAD
Wed, Jun 12thvs PIT@ LAD
Thu, Jun 13thvs PIT@ LAD
Fri, Jun 14th@ CHC@ SEA
Sat, Jun 15th@ CHC@ SEA
Sun, Jun 16th@ CHC@ SEA
Mon, Jun 17th@ MIAvs NYM
Tue, Jun 18th@ MIAvs NYM
Wed, Jun 19th@ MIAvs NYM
Thu, Jun 20thvs SF   
Sat, Jun 22ndvs SFvs KC
Sun, Jun 23rdvs SFvs KC
Mon, Jun 24thvs ATL@ MIL
Tue, Jun 25thvs ATL@ MIL
Wed, Jun 26thvs ATL@ MIL
Thu, Jun 27thvs CIN@ BAL
Fri, Jun 28thvs CIN@ BAL
Sat, Jun 29thvs CIN@ BAL
Sun, Jun 30thvs CIN@ BAL
Tue, Jul 2nd@ PITvs SD
Wed, Jul 3rd@ PITvs SD
Thu, Jul 4th@ PITvs SD
Fri, Jul 5th@ WSHvs TB
Sat, Jul 6th@ WSHvs TB
Sun, Jul 7th@ WSHvs TB
Mon, Jul 8th@ WSH@ LAA
Tue, Jul 9thvs KC@ LAA
Wed, Jul 10thvs KC@ LAA
Fri, Jul 12thvs CHC@ HOU
Sat, Jul 13thvs CHC@ HOU
Sun, Jul 14thvs CHC@ HOU
Fri, Jul 19th@ ATLvs BAL
Sat, Jul 20th@ ATLvs BAL
Sun, Jul 21st@ ATLvs BAL
Mon, Jul 22nd@ PITvs CWS
Tue, Jul 23rd@ PITvs CWS
Wed, Jul 24th@ PITvs CWS
Fri, Jul 26thvs WSH@ TOR
Sat, Jul 27thvs WSH@ TOR
Sun, Jul 28thvs WSH@ TOR
Mon, Jul 29thvs TEX@ STL
Tue, Jul 30thvs TEX@ STL
Wed, Jul 31stvs TEX@ STL
Thu, Aug 1st@ CHC   
Fri, Aug 2nd@ CHCvs BOS
Sat, Aug 3rd@ CHCvs BOS
Sun, Aug 4th@ CHCvs BOS
Tue, Aug 6thvs TBvs HOU
Wed, Aug 7thvs TBvs HOU
Thu, Aug 8thvs TB   
Fri, Aug 9th@ KC@ NYY
Sat, Aug 10th@ KC@ NYY
Mon, Aug 12th@ CIN@ BOS
Tue, Aug 13th@ CIN@ BOS
Wed, Aug 14th@ CIN@ BOS
Fri, Aug 16thvs LADvs MIN
Sat, Aug 17thvs LADvs MIN
Sun, Aug 18thvs LADvs MIN
Tue, Aug 20thvs MILvs PIT
Wed, Aug 21stvs MILvs PIT
Thu, Aug 22ndvs MIL   
Fri, Aug 23rd@ MIN@ CLE
Sat, Aug 24th@ MIN@ CLE
Sun, Aug 25th@ MIN@ CLE
Mon, Aug 26thvs SD   
Tue, Aug 27thvs SD@ CWS
Wed, Aug 28thvs SD@ CWS
Thu, Aug 29thvs SD@ CWS
Fri, Aug 30th@ NYYvs OAK
Sat, Aug 31st@ NYYvs OAK
Sun, Sep 1st@ NYYvs OAK
Mon, Sep 2nd@ MILvs NYY
Tue, Sep 3rd@ MILvs NYY
Wed, Sep 4th@ MILvs NYY
Fri, Sep 6thvs SEAvs LAA
Sat, Sep 7thvs SEAvs LAA
Sun, Sep 8thvs SEAvs LAA
Tue, Sep 10thvs CIN@ ARI
Wed, Sep 11thvs CIN@ ARI
Thu, Sep 12thvs CIN@ SEA
Fri, Sep 13th@ TOR@ SEA
Sat, Sep 14th@ TOR@ SEA
Sun, Sep 15th@ TOR@ SEA
Mon, Sep 16thvs PIT   
Tue, Sep 17thvs PITvs TOR
Wed, Sep 18thvs PITvs TOR
Thu, Sep 19thvs PITvs TOR
Fri, Sep 20thvs CLEvs SEA
Sat, Sep 21stvs CLEvs SEA
Sun, Sep 22ndvs CLEvs SEA
Tue, Sep 24th@ COL@ OAK
Wed, Sep 25th@ COL@ OAK
Thu, Sep 26th@ COL@ OAK
Fri, Sep 27th@ SF@ LAA
Sat, Sep 28th@ SF@ LAA
Sun, Sep 29th@ SF@ LAA
Fri, Apr 5th   vs HOUHunter Brown (0-4)#67
Thu, Apr 11th   vs OAKJP Sears (1-1)#92
Thu, Apr 18th   @ DETKenta Maeda (0-1)#106
Thu, Apr 25th   vs SEALuis Castillo (1-4)#2
Thu, May 2nd   vs WSH
Thu, May 23rd   @ PHI
Fri, Jun 21st   vs KC
Thu, Jul 25th   vs CWS
Mon, Aug 5th   vs HOU
Sun, Aug 11th   @ NYY
Thu, Aug 15th   vs MIN
Mon, Aug 19th   vs PIT
Thu, Sep 5th   vs LAA