Skip to main content

Who Should I Trade?

Trevor Rosenthal for A.J. Puk (2021)

See if your team wins or loses with this trade View Trade Analyzer

Who Should I Trade? Player Summaries
Experts' Pick
  A.J. Puk
A.J. Puk
Trevor Rosenthal
Trevor Rosenthal
Recommended by
7 of 12 experts
Recommended by
5 of 12 experts
Rest of Season# 158# 154
VBR# 306# 556
Injury AlertMiLBIL60
Expert Ranks 
Mike Maher
# 190# 213
Dan Harris
# 167
Pierre Camus
# 161
Ryan Amore
Pitcher List
# 186# 209
Corbin Young
# 116# 174
Chris Clegg
# 154# 183
John Albright
Fantasy Six Pack
# 45
Carmen Maiorano
# 132# 63
Jorge B. Edwards
Fantasy In Frames
# 65
Jordan Eisen
Field of Vision Sports
# 159# 67
Chris Meaney
# 70
Joe Bond
Fantasy Six Pack
# 159
Who Should I Trade? Player Statistics
  A.J. Puk
A.J. Puk
Trevor Rosenthal
Trevor Rosenthal
2021 Stats 
Games Played1
Games Started0
Innings Pitched3.0
Blown Saves0
Hits Allowed1
Earned Runs0
Home Runs Allowed0
Who Should I Trade? Player Projections
  A.J. Puk
A.J. Puk
Trevor Rosenthal
Trevor Rosenthal
2021 Projections 
Games Played2416
Games Started60
Innings Pitched49.914.8
Blown Saves00
Hits Allowed4111
Earned Runs206
Home Runs Allowed62
Who Should I Trade? Player Notes
  A.J. Puk
A.J. Puk
Trevor Rosenthal
Trevor Rosenthal
 A's LHP A.J. Puk (biceps) threw a scoreless inning at Triple-A Las Vegas on Tuesday night.
Brendan Tuma - Too Much Tuma
Wed, May 12th
A's RHP Trevor Rosenthal (shoulder) is progressing "rapidly" through his strength program, per manager Bob Melvin.
Brendan Tuma - Too Much Tuma
Fri, Jun 11th
 The Athletics southpaw A.J. Puk is slowly progressing with two recent 15-pitch sessions. The next step in Puk's recovery involves facing hitters.
Corbin Young
Wed, May 5th
Athletics reliever Trevor Rosenthal officially underwent surgery today. The operation "involved the removal of his first rib, a pec minor release, and scalene release," according to a release from the Athletics.
Andersen Pickard
Thu, Apr 8th
 A's team trainer Nick Paparesta says A.J. Puk (biceps) is expected to begin throwing at the team's alternate training site soon.
Brendan Tuma - Too Much Tuma
Sat, Apr 24th
The Athletics' bullpen was dealt a major blow on Thursday as reliever Trevor Rosenthal landed on the 60-day injured list. He's been dealing with a shoulder injury. Thoracic outlet surgery seems like the most likely outcome for the 30-year-old right-hander. Such a procedure would hold him out for at least three months.
Andersen Pickard
Thu, Apr 8th
 Athletics pitcher A.J. Puk (biceps) has yet to resume throwing off a mound.
Brad Camara
Tue, Apr 20th
A's manager Bob Melvin told reporters on Wednesday that "surgery is on the table" for Trevor Rosenthal because of his shoulder injury.
Dan Harris
Wed, Apr 7th
 A.J. Puk started throwing up to 90 feet for a second time. According to manager Bob Melvin, Puk isn't close to returning quite yet.
Corbin Young
Thu, Apr 15th
Trevor Rosenthal is expected to see a specialist in Dallas for his shoulder.
Ari Koslow
Tue, Apr 6th
  Rosenthal hit the IL with shoulder inflammation on Opening Day and underwent surgery to address thoracic outlet syndrome. He'll be evaluated in eight weeks but for all intents and purposes, his season is over. Move on for fantasy purposes.
Dan Harris - FantasyPros
Who Should I Trade? Player Schedules
  A.J. Puk
A.J. Puk
Trevor Rosenthal
Trevor Rosenthal
Date OppOpp PitcherVBROppOpp PitcherVBR
Thu, Apr 1stvs HOUvs HOU
Fri, Apr 2ndvs HOUvs HOU
Sat, Apr 3rdvs HOUvs HOU
Sun, Apr 4thvs HOUvs HOU
Mon, Apr 5thvs LADvs LAD
Tue, Apr 6thvs LADvs LAD
Wed, Apr 7thvs LADvs LAD
Thu, Apr 8th@ HOU@ HOU
Fri, Apr 9th@ HOU@ HOU
Sat, Apr 10th@ HOU@ HOU
Mon, Apr 12th@ ARI@ ARI
Tue, Apr 13th@ ARI@ ARI
Thu, Apr 15thvs DETvs DET
Fri, Apr 16thvs DETvs DET
Sat, Apr 17thvs DETvs DET
Sun, Apr 18thvs DETvs DET
Tue, Apr 20thvs MINvs MIN
Wed, Apr 21stvs MINvs MIN
Fri, Apr 23rd@ BAL@ BAL
Sat, Apr 24th@ BAL@ BAL
Sun, Apr 25th@ BAL@ BAL
Mon, Apr 26th@ TB@ TB
Tue, Apr 27th@ TB@ TB
Wed, Apr 28th@ TB@ TB
Thu, Apr 29th@ TB@ TB
Fri, Apr 30thvs BALvs BAL
Sat, May 1stvs BALvs BAL
Sun, May 2ndvs BALvs BAL
Mon, May 3rdvs TORvs TOR
Tue, May 4thvs TORvs TOR
Wed, May 5thvs TORvs TOR
Thu, May 6thvs TORvs TOR
Fri, May 7thvs TBvs TB
Sat, May 8thvs TBvs TB
Sun, May 9thvs TBvs TB
Tue, May 11th@ BOS@ BOS
Wed, May 12th@ BOS@ BOS
Thu, May 13th@ BOS@ BOS
Fri, May 14th@ MIN@ MIN
Sat, May 15th@ MIN@ MIN
Sun, May 16th@ MIN@ MIN
Tue, May 18thvs HOUvs HOU
Wed, May 19thvs HOUvs HOU
Thu, May 20thvs HOUvs HOU
Fri, May 21st@ LAA@ LAA
Sat, May 22nd@ LAA@ LAA
Sun, May 23rd@ LAA@ LAA
Mon, May 24thvs SEAvs SEA
Tue, May 25thvs SEAvs SEA
Wed, May 26thvs SEAvs SEA
Thu, May 27thvs LAAvs LAA
Fri, May 28thvs LAAvs LAA
Sat, May 29thvs LAAvs LAA
Sun, May 30thvs LAAvs LAA
Mon, May 31st@ SEA@ SEA
Tue, Jun 1st@ SEA@ SEA
Wed, Jun 2nd@ SEA@ SEA
Fri, Jun 4th@ COL@ COL
Sat, Jun 5th@ COL@ COL
Sun, Jun 6th@ COL@ COL
Tue, Jun 8thvs ARIvs ARI
Wed, Jun 9thvs ARIvs ARI
Thu, Jun 10thvs KCvs KC
Fri, Jun 11thvs KCvs KC
Sat, Jun 12thvs KCvs KC
Sun, Jun 13thvs KCvs KC
Mon, Jun 14thvs LAAvs LAA
Tue, Jun 15thvs LAAvs LAA
Wed, Jun 16thvs LAAvs LAA
Fri, Jun 18th@ NYY@ NYY
Sat, Jun 19th@ NYY@ NYY
Sun, Jun 20th@ NYY@ NYY
Mon, Jun 21st@ TEX@ TEX
Tue, Jun 22nd@ TEX@ TEX
Wed, Jun 23rd@ TEX@ TEX
Thu, Jun 24th@ TEX@ TEX
Fri, Jun 25th@ SF@ SF
Sat, Jun 26th@ SF@ SF
Sun, Jun 27th@ SF@ SF
Tue, Jun 29thvs TEXvs TEX
Wed, Jun 30thvs TEXvs TEX
Thu, Jul 1stvs TEXvs TEX
Fri, Jul 2ndvs BOSvs BOS
Sat, Jul 3rdvs BOSvs BOS
Sun, Jul 4thvs BOSvs BOS
Tue, Jul 6th@ HOU@ HOU
Wed, Jul 7th@ HOU@ HOU
Thu, Jul 8th@ HOU@ HOU
Fri, Jul 9th@ TEX@ TEX
Sat, Jul 10th@ TEX@ TEX
Sun, Jul 11th@ TEX@ TEX
Fri, Jul 16thvs CLEvs CLE
Sat, Jul 17thvs CLEvs CLE
Sun, Jul 18thvs CLEvs CLE
Mon, Jul 19thvs LAAvs LAA
Tue, Jul 20thvs LAAvs LAA
Thu, Jul 22nd@ SEA@ SEA
Fri, Jul 23rd@ SEA@ SEA
Sat, Jul 24th@ SEA@ SEA
Sun, Jul 25th@ SEA@ SEA
Tue, Jul 27th@ SD@ SD
Wed, Jul 28th@ SD@ SD
Thu, Jul 29th@ LAA@ LAA
Fri, Jul 30th@ LAA@ LAA
Sat, Jul 31st@ LAA@ LAA
Sun, Aug 1st@ LAA@ LAA
Tue, Aug 3rdvs SDvs SD
Wed, Aug 4thvs SDvs SD
Fri, Aug 6thvs TEXvs TEX
Sat, Aug 7thvs TEXvs TEX
Sun, Aug 8thvs TEXvs TEX
Tue, Aug 10th@ CLE@ CLE
Wed, Aug 11th@ CLE@ CLE
Thu, Aug 12th@ CLE@ CLE
Fri, Aug 13th@ TEX@ TEX
Sat, Aug 14th@ TEX@ TEX
Sun, Aug 15th@ TEX@ TEX
Mon, Aug 16th@ CWS@ CWS
Tue, Aug 17th@ CWS@ CWS
Wed, Aug 18th@ CWS@ CWS
Thu, Aug 19th@ CWS@ CWS
Fri, Aug 20thvs SFvs SF
Sat, Aug 21stvs SFvs SF
Sun, Aug 22ndvs SFvs SF
Mon, Aug 23rdvs SEAvs SEA
Tue, Aug 24thvs SEAvs SEA
Thu, Aug 26thvs NYYvs NYY
Fri, Aug 27thvs NYYvs NYY
Sat, Aug 28thvs NYYvs NYY
Sun, Aug 29thvs NYYvs NYY
Tue, Aug 31st@ DET@ DET
Wed, Sep 1st@ DET@ DET
Thu, Sep 2nd@ DET@ DET
Fri, Sep 3rd@ TOR@ TOR
Sat, Sep 4th@ TOR@ TOR
Sun, Sep 5th@ TOR@ TOR
Tue, Sep 7thvs CWSvs CWS
Wed, Sep 8thvs CWSvs CWS
Thu, Sep 9thvs CWSvs CWS
Fri, Sep 10thvs TEXvs TEX
Sat, Sep 11thvs TEXvs TEX
Sun, Sep 12thvs TEXvs TEX
Tue, Sep 14th@ KC@ KC
Wed, Sep 15th@ KC@ KC
Thu, Sep 16th@ KC@ KC
Fri, Sep 17th@ LAA@ LAA
Sat, Sep 18th@ LAA@ LAA
Sun, Sep 19th@ LAA@ LAA
Mon, Sep 20thvs SEAvs SEA
Tue, Sep 21stvs SEAvs SEA
Wed, Sep 22ndvs SEAvs SEA
Thu, Sep 23rdvs SEAvs SEA
Fri, Sep 24thvs HOUvs HOU
Sat, Sep 25thvs HOUvs HOU
Sun, Sep 26thvs HOUvs HOU
Mon, Sep 27th@ SEA@ SEA
Tue, Sep 28th@ SEA@ SEA
Wed, Sep 29th@ SEA@ SEA
Fri, Oct 1st@ HOU@ HOU
Sat, Oct 2nd@ HOU@ HOU
Sun, Oct 3rd@ HOU@ HOU