Skip to main content

Who Should I Trade?

Tyler Mahle for Aaron Civale (2021)

See if your team wins or loses with this trade View Trade Analyzer

Who Should I Trade? Player Summaries
Experts' Pick
  Tyler Mahle
Tyler Mahle
Aaron Civale
Aaron Civale
Recommended by
11 of 16 experts
Recommended by
5 of 16 experts
Rest of Season# 44# 56
VBR# 175# 203
Injury Alert-IL60
Expert Ranks 
Joe Bond
Fantasy Six Pack
# 18# 62
Chris Meaney
# 25# 62
Mike Maher
# 39# 64
Dan Harris
# 54# 111
Mick Ciallela
# 46# 100
Ryan Amore
Pitcher List
# 54# 124
Jordan Eisen
Field of Vision Sports
# 57# 58
Brad Camara
# 47# 78
Chris Mitchell
# 45# 48
Chris Clegg
# 41# 50
Joe Pisapia
# 36# 73
Pierre Camus
# 44# 40
Jorge B. Edwards
Fantasy In Frames
# 60# 52
Corbin Young
# 64# 54
Brendan Tuma
# 67# 57
Carmen Maiorano
# 103# 44
Who Should I Trade? Player Statistics
  Tyler Mahle
Tyler Mahle
Aaron Civale
Aaron Civale
2021 Stats 
Games Played2115
Games Started2115
Innings Pitched112.198.2
Blown Saves00
Hits Allowed9481
Earned Runs4636
Home Runs Allowed1614
Who Should I Trade? Player Projections
  Tyler Mahle
Tyler Mahle
Aaron Civale
Aaron Civale
2021 Projections 
Games Played118
Games Started108
Innings Pitched59.349.5
Blown Saves00
Hits Allowed5346
Earned Runs2722
Home Runs Allowed98
Who Should I Trade? Player Notes
  Tyler Mahle
Tyler Mahle
Aaron Civale
Aaron Civale
 Tyler Mahle (8-3) picked up the win Wednesday against the Cubs. He tossed six scoreless innings while allowing five hits and one walk. He struck out two.
Connor Rooney
Thu, Jul 29th
Cleveland Guardians pitcher Aaron Civale (finger) was transferred to the 60-day injured list Monday.
Brad Camara
Mon, Jul 26th
 Tyler Mahle did not factor into the decision Friday against the Cardinals, allowing two runs on five hits and four walks across five innings. He struck out five.
Connor Rooney
Fri, Jul 23rd
Indians RHP Aaron Civale has been diagnosed with a sprained middle finger and is expected to miss 4-5 weeks.
Brendan Tuma - Too Much Tuma
Wed, Jun 23rd
 Tyler Mahle did not factor into the decision in Friday's loss to the Brewers, allowing five runs on six hits and three walks across 5.1 innings. He struck out eight.
Connor Rooney
Sat, Jul 17th
The Indians are planning to put RHP Aaron Civale on the 10-day IL due to his finger injury.
Brendan Tuma - Too Much Tuma
Tue, Jun 22nd
 Tyler Mahle did not factor into the decision in Thursday's loss to Milwaukee. He allowed three runs on four hits and four walks across six innings. He struck out six.
Connor Rooney
Fri, Jul 9th
Indians RHP Aaron Civale will be sent to visit a hand specialist after leaving Monday's start with an injury.
Brendan Tuma - Too Much Tuma
Tue, Jun 22nd
 Tyler Mahle did not factor into the decision Saturday against the Cubs, allowing two runs (one earned) on five hits and four walks across five innings. He struck out seven.
Connor Rooney
Sat, Jul 3rd
Aaron Civale was removed from his start on Monday against the Cubs in the fifth inning with an apparent finger injury,
Dan Harris
Mon, Jun 21st
There are no recent notes for these players
Who Should I Trade? Player Schedules
  Tyler Mahle
Tyler Mahle
Aaron Civale
Aaron Civale
Date OppOpp PitcherVBROppOpp PitcherVBR
Thu, Apr 1stvs STL@ DET
Sat, Apr 3rdvs STL@ DET
Sun, Apr 4thvs STL@ DET
Mon, Apr 5thvs PITvs KC
Tue, Apr 6thvs PIT   
Wed, Apr 7thvs PITvs KC
Fri, Apr 9th@ ARIvs DET
Sat, Apr 10th@ ARIvs DET
Sun, Apr 11th@ ARIvs DET
Mon, Apr 12th@ SF@ CWS
Tue, Apr 13th@ SF@ CWS
Wed, Apr 14th@ SF@ CWS
Fri, Apr 16thvs CLE@ CIN
Sat, Apr 17thvs CLE@ CIN
Sun, Apr 18thvs CLE@ CIN
Wed, Apr 21stvs ARI   
Thu, Apr 22ndvs ARIvs NYY
Fri, Apr 23rd@ STLvs NYY
Sat, Apr 24th@ STLvs NYY
Sun, Apr 25th@ STLvs NYY
Mon, Apr 26th@ LADvs MIN
Tue, Apr 27th@ LADvs MIN
Wed, Apr 28th@ LADvs MIN
Fri, Apr 30thvs CHC@ CWS
Sat, May 1stvs CHC@ CWS
Sun, May 2ndvs CHC@ CWS
Tue, May 4thvs CWS@ KC
Wed, May 5thvs CWS@ KC
Fri, May 7th@ CLEvs CIN
Sat, May 8th@ CLEvs CIN
Mon, May 10th@ PIT   
Tue, May 11th@ PITvs CHC
Wed, May 12th@ PITvs CHC
Thu, May 13th@ COL@ SEA
Fri, May 14th@ COL@ SEA
Sat, May 15th@ COL@ SEA
Sun, May 16th@ COL@ SEA
Mon, May 17thvs SF@ LAA
Tue, May 18thvs SF@ LAA
Wed, May 19thvs SF@ LAA
Thu, May 20thvs SF   
Fri, May 21stvs MILvs MIN
Sat, May 22ndvs MILvs MIN
Sun, May 23rdvs MILvs MIN
Tue, May 25th@ WSH@ DET
Thu, May 27th@ WSH@ DET
Fri, May 28th@ CHCvs TOR
Sat, May 29th@ CHC   
Sun, May 30th@ CHCvs TOR
Mon, May 31stvs PHIvs CWS
Tue, Jun 1stvs PHIvs CWS
Thu, Jun 3rd@ STL   
Fri, Jun 4th@ STL@ BAL
Sat, Jun 5th@ STL@ BAL
Sun, Jun 6th@ STL@ BAL
Tue, Jun 8thvs MIL@ STL
Wed, Jun 9thvs MIL@ STL
Thu, Jun 10thvs MIL   
Fri, Jun 11thvs COLvs SEA
Sat, Jun 12thvs COLvs SEA
Sun, Jun 13thvs COLvs SEA
Mon, Jun 14th@ MILvs BAL
Tue, Jun 15th@ MILvs BAL
Wed, Jun 16th@ MILvs BAL
Thu, Jun 17th@ SDvs BAL
Fri, Jun 18th@ SD@ PIT
Sat, Jun 19th@ SD@ PIT
Sun, Jun 20th@ SD@ PIT
Mon, Jun 21st@ MIN@ CHC
Tue, Jun 22nd@ MIN@ CHC
Thu, Jun 24thvs ATL@ MIN
Fri, Jun 25thvs ATL@ MIN
Sat, Jun 26thvs ATL   
Sun, Jun 27thvs ATL@ MIN
Mon, Jun 28thvs PHIvs DET
Tue, Jun 29thvs SD   
Wed, Jun 30thvs SDvs DET
Thu, Jul 1stvs SDvs HOU
Fri, Jul 2ndvs CHCvs HOU
Sat, Jul 3rdvs CHCvs HOU
Sun, Jul 4thvs CHCvs HOU
Mon, Jul 5th@ KC@ TB
Tue, Jul 6th@ KC   
Wed, Jul 7th@ KC@ TB
Thu, Jul 8th@ MILvs KC
Fri, Jul 9th@ MILvs KC
Sat, Jul 10th@ MILvs KC
Sun, Jul 11th@ MIL   
Fri, Jul 16thvs MIL@ OAK
Sat, Jul 17thvs MIL@ OAK
Sun, Jul 18thvs MIL@ OAK
Mon, Jul 19thvs NYM@ HOU
Tue, Jul 20thvs NYM@ HOU
Wed, Jul 21stvs NYM@ HOU
Fri, Jul 23rdvs STLvs TB
Sat, Jul 24thvs STLvs TB
Sun, Jul 25thvs STLvs TB
Mon, Jul 26th@ CHC   
Tue, Jul 27th@ CHCvs STL
Wed, Jul 28th@ CHCvs STL
Thu, Jul 29th@ CHC   
Fri, Jul 30th@ NYM@ CWS
Sat, Jul 31st@ NYM@ CWS
Sun, Aug 1st@ NYM@ CWS
Tue, Aug 3rdvs MIN@ TOR
Wed, Aug 4thvs MIN@ TOR
Thu, Aug 5thvs PIT@ TOR
Fri, Aug 6thvs PITvs DET
Sat, Aug 7thvs PITvs DET
Sun, Aug 8thvs PITvs DET
Mon, Aug 9th@ CLEvs CIN
Tue, Aug 10th@ ATLvs OAK
Wed, Aug 11th@ ATLvs OAK
Thu, Aug 12th@ ATLvs OAK
Fri, Aug 13th@ PHI@ DET
Sat, Aug 14th@ PHI@ DET
Sun, Aug 15th@ PHI@ DET
Mon, Aug 16thvs CHC@ MIN
Tue, Aug 17thvs CHC@ MIN
Wed, Aug 18thvs CHC@ MIN
Thu, Aug 19thvs MIA   
Fri, Aug 20thvs MIAvs LAA
Sat, Aug 21stvs MIAvs LAA
Sun, Aug 22ndvs MIAvs LAA
Tue, Aug 24th@ MILvs TEX
Wed, Aug 25th@ MILvs TEX
Thu, Aug 26th@ MILvs TEX
Fri, Aug 27th@ MIAvs BOS
Sat, Aug 28th@ MIAvs BOS
Sun, Aug 29th@ MIAvs BOS
Mon, Aug 30thvs STL   
Tue, Aug 31stvs STL@ KC
Wed, Sep 1stvs STL@ KC
Fri, Sep 3rdvs DET@ BOS
Sat, Sep 4thvs DET@ BOS
Sun, Sep 5thvs DET@ BOS
Mon, Sep 6th@ CHCvs MIN
Tue, Sep 7th@ CHCvs MIN
Wed, Sep 8th@ CHCvs MIN
Fri, Sep 10th@ STLvs MIL
Sat, Sep 11th@ STLvs MIL
Sun, Sep 12th@ STLvs MIL
Tue, Sep 14th@ PIT@ MIN
Wed, Sep 15th@ PIT@ MIN
Thu, Sep 16th@ PIT   
Fri, Sep 17thvs LAD@ NYY
Sat, Sep 18thvs LAD@ NYY
Sun, Sep 19thvs LAD@ NYY
Mon, Sep 20thvs PITvs KC
Tue, Sep 21stvs PITvs KC
Wed, Sep 22ndvs PITvs KC
Thu, Sep 23rdvs WSHvs CWS
Fri, Sep 24thvs WSHvs CWS
Sat, Sep 25thvs WSHvs CWS
Sun, Sep 26thvs WSHvs CWS
Tue, Sep 28th@ CWS@ KC
Wed, Sep 29th@ CWS@ KC
Fri, Oct 1st@ PIT@ TEX
Sat, Oct 2nd@ PIT@ TEX
Sun, Oct 3rd@ PIT@ TEX
Thu, Apr 15th   @ CWS
Tue, Apr 20th   vs CWS
Mon, May 3rd   @ KC
Thu, May 6th   @ KC
Mon, May 24th   @ DET
Wed, May 26th   @ DET
Thu, Jul 22nd   vs TB
Mon, Aug 2nd   @ TOR
Thu, Sep 2nd   @ KC
Thu, Sep 9th   vs MIN
Thu, Sep 30th   @ KC