Skip to main content

Who Should I Trade?

Zach Plesac for Aaron Civale (2022)

See if your team wins or loses with this trade View Trade Analyzer

Who Should I Trade? Player Summaries
Experts' Pick
  Aaron Civale
Aaron Civale
Zach Plesac
Zach Plesac
Recommended by
6 of 11 experts
Recommended by
5 of 11 experts
Rest of Season# 116# 110
VBR# 565# 336
Injury Alert--
Expert Ranks 
Dalton Del Don
Yahoo! Sports
# 102# 119
Mike Maher
# 93# 96
Andrew Seifter
# 188# 191
Mick Ciallela
# 110# 136
Brad Camara
# 93# 102
Travis Argo
Fantasy Six Pack
# 71# 108
Pierre Camus
# 141# 121
Bart Wheeler
Hail to Fantasy Football
# 125# 121
Nate Miller
Fantasy Six Pack
# 130
Scott Youngson
Pitcher List
# 157# 135
Ryan Amore
Pitcher List
# 173# 149
Who Should I Trade? Player Statistics
  Aaron Civale
Aaron Civale
Zach Plesac
Zach Plesac
2022 Stats 
Games Played913
Games Started913
Innings Pitched40.173.1
Blown Saves00
Hits Allowed5174
Earned Runs3234
Home Runs Allowed611
Who Should I Trade? Player Projections
  Aaron Civale
Aaron Civale
Zach Plesac
Zach Plesac
2022 Projections 
Games Played1517
Games Started1416
Innings Pitched82.196.0
Blown Saves00
Hits Allowed8899
Earned Runs4748
Home Runs Allowed1416
Who Should I Trade? Player Notes
  Aaron Civale
Aaron Civale
Zach Plesac
Zach Plesac
 Aaron Civale lasted just four innings in a 6-3 loss to Boston on Sunday. Civale allowed three runs on eight hits while striking out two and walking three. He took the loss in the contest.
Matthew Terelle
Sun, Jun 26th
Zach Plesac pitched well in a 3-2 win over the Twins in Game 1 of a Tuesday doubleheader. Plesac tossed six shutout innings, allowing three hits, striking out seven, and walking three. Plesac had to settle for a no-decision in the outing.
Matthew Terelle
Tue, Jun 28th
 Aaron Civale allowed two runs on five hits over five innings of work in a 6-5 win over the Twins on Tuesday. Civale struck out seven and walked one but had to settle for a no-decision in the 11-inning game.
Matthew Terelle
Wed, Jun 22nd
Zach Plesac pitched well but wound up taking a hard-luck loss against the Twins on Thursday. Plesac allowed one run on three hits over six innings of work while striking out six and walking two. Minnesota went on to win 1-0.
Matthew Terelle
Thu, Jun 23rd
 Aaron Civale is scheduled to throw three innings for Triple-A Columbus Thursday in his first rehab outing.
Ari Koslow
Wed, Jun 8th
Zach Plesac pitched well in a 2-1 win over the Dodgers on Friday. Plesac allowed one run on five hits over six innings while striking out one and walking two. He had to settle for a no-decision in the 10-inning contest.
Matthew Terelle
Sat, Jun 18th
 The Cleveland Guardians placed pitcher Aaron Civale on the 15-day IL Wednesday night with a sore left glute. He was injured in Friday’s game while attempting to make a play at first base.
Jesse Garcia
Thu, May 26th
Zach Plesac allowed four runs (three earned) on eight hits over six innings of work in a 10-5 loss to the A's on Saturday. He struck out two, walked none, and escaped with a no-decision in the outing.
Matthew Terelle
Sat, Jun 11th
 Aaron Civale left his start Friday night against the Tigers in the seventh inning after he fell while attempting to field the ball. Before that, he was having his best start of the season, giving up only three hits and one walk in 6 1/3 innings while striking out three.
Kelly Kirby
Fri, May 20th
Cleveland Guardians right-hander Zach Plesac pitched well in a 3-2 win over the Orioles on Sunday. Plesac allowed two runs over six innings while striking out eight.
Matthew Terelle
Sun, Jun 5th
There are no recent notes for these players
Who Should I Trade? Player Schedules
  Aaron Civale
Aaron Civale
Zach Plesac
Zach Plesac
Date OppOpp PitcherVBROppOpp PitcherVBR
Thu, Apr 7th@ KCZack Greinke (1-4)#132@ KCZack Greinke (1-4)#132
Sat, Apr 9th@ KCBrad Keller (2-9)#115@ KCBrad Keller (2-9)#115
Sun, Apr 10th@ KCKris Bubic (1-5)#256@ KCKris Bubic (1-5)#256
Mon, Apr 11th@ KCCarlos Hernandez (0-3)#298@ KCCarlos Hernandez (0-3)#298
Tue, Apr 12th@ CINTyler Mahle (3-6)#44@ CINTyler Mahle (3-6)#44
Wed, Apr 13th@ CINNick Lodolo (1-2)#205@ CINNick Lodolo (1-2)#205
Fri, Apr 15thvs SFCarlos Rodon (6-4)#9vs SFCarlos Rodon (6-4)#9
Sat, Apr 16thvs SFAnthony DeSclafani (0-2)#91vs SFAnthony DeSclafani (0-2)#91
Sun, Apr 17thvs SFAlex Wood (5-6)#76vs SFAlex Wood (5-6)#76
Wed, Apr 20thvs CWSJimmy Lambert (0-2)#258vs CWSJimmy Lambert (0-2)#258
Thu, Apr 21stvs CWSDylan Cease (6-3)#20vs CWSDylan Cease (6-3)#20
Fri, Apr 22nd@ NYYJameson Taillon (8-1)#43@ NYYJameson Taillon (8-1)#43
Sat, Apr 23rd@ NYYNestor Cortes Jr. (6-3)#50@ NYYNestor Cortes Jr. (6-3)#50
Sun, Apr 24th@ NYYGerrit Cole (6-2)#2@ NYYGerrit Cole (6-2)#2
Mon, Apr 25th@ LAAMichael Lorenzen (6-5)#133@ LAAMichael Lorenzen (6-5)#133
Tue, Apr 26th@ LAAPatrick Sandoval (3-2)#64@ LAAPatrick Sandoval (3-2)#64
Wed, Apr 27th@ LAAShohei Ohtani (6-4)#28@ LAAShohei Ohtani (6-4)#28
Thu, Apr 28th@ LAAReid Detmers (2-3)#109@ LAAReid Detmers (2-3)#109
Fri, Apr 29th@ OAKFrankie Montas (3-7)#16@ OAKFrankie Montas (3-7)#16
Sat, Apr 30th@ OAKCole Irvin (2-5)#111@ OAKCole Irvin (2-5)#111
Sun, May 1st@ OAKJames Kaprielian (0-5)#182@ OAKJames Kaprielian (0-5)#182
Wed, May 4thvs SDMacKenzie Gore (4-3)#117vs SDMacKenzie Gore (4-3)#117
Thu, May 5thvs TORJose Berrios (5-4)#66vs TORJose Berrios (5-4)#66
Sat, May 7thvs TORRoss Stripling (4-2)#123vs TORRoss Stripling (4-2)#123
Sun, May 8thvs TORAlek Manoah (9-2)#13vs TORAlek Manoah (9-2)#13
Mon, May 9th@ CWSMichael Kopech (2-4)#33@ CWSMichael Kopech (2-4)#33
Tue, May 10th@ CWSLucas Giolito (4-4)#39@ CWSLucas Giolito (4-4)#39
Fri, May 13th@ MINSonny Gray (4-1)#49@ MINSonny Gray (4-1)#49
Sat, May 14th@ MINDevin Smeltzer (4-1)#148@ MINDevin Smeltzer (4-1)#148
Sun, May 15th@ MINJoe Ryan (6-3)#53@ MINJoe Ryan (6-3)#53
Tue, May 17thvs CINConnor Overton (1-0)#267vs CINConnor Overton (1-0)#267
Thu, May 19thvs CINTyler Mahle (3-6)#44vs CINTyler Mahle (3-6)#44
Fri, May 20thvs DETTarik Skubal (5-5)#36vs DETTarik Skubal (5-5)#36
Sun, May 22ndvs DETAlex Faedo (1-4)#124vs DETAlex Faedo (1-4)#124
Mon, May 23rd@ HOULuis Garcia (5-5)#40@ HOULuis Garcia (5-5)#40
Tue, May 24th@ HOUFramber Valdez (7-3)#24@ HOUFramber Valdez (7-3)#24
Wed, May 25th@ HOUCristian Javier (5-3)#65@ HOUCristian Javier (5-3)#65
Thu, May 26th@ DETTarik Skubal (5-5)#36@ DETTarik Skubal (5-5)#36
Sat, May 28th@ DETAlex Faedo (1-4)#124@ DETAlex Faedo (1-4)#124
Sun, May 29th@ DETElvin Rodriguez (0-2)#363@ DETElvin Rodriguez (0-2)#363
Mon, May 30thvs KCJonathan Heasley (1-3)#213vs KCJonathan Heasley (1-3)#213
Tue, May 31stvs KCDaniel Lynch (3-7)#254vs KCDaniel Lynch (3-7)#254
Wed, Jun 1stvs KCBrad Keller (2-9)#115vs KCBrad Keller (2-9)#115
Fri, Jun 3rd@ BALBruce Zimmermann (2-5)#243@ BALBruce Zimmermann (2-5)#243
Sat, Jun 4th@ BALTyler Wells (6-4)#72@ BALTyler Wells (6-4)#72
Sun, Jun 5th@ BALDean Kremer (2-1)#242@ BALDean Kremer (2-1)#242
Tue, Jun 7thvs TEXTaylor Hearn (4-5)#262vs TEXTaylor Hearn (4-5)#262
Wed, Jun 8thvs TEXDane Dunning (1-5)#99vs TEXDane Dunning (1-5)#99
Thu, Jun 9thvs OAKJames Kaprielian (0-5)#182vs OAKJames Kaprielian (0-5)#182
Fri, Jun 10thvs OAKPaul Blackburn (6-3)#7vs OAKPaul Blackburn (6-3)#7
Sat, Jun 11thvs OAKFrankie Montas (3-7)#16vs OAKFrankie Montas (3-7)#16
Sun, Jun 12thvs OAKCole Irvin (2-5)#111vs OAKCole Irvin (2-5)#111
Tue, Jun 14th@ COLAntonio Senzatela (3-4)#300@ COLAntonio Senzatela (3-4)#300
Wed, Jun 15th@ COLAustin Gomber (3-7)#177@ COLAustin Gomber (3-7)#177
Thu, Jun 16th@ COLChad Kuhl (5-5)#190@ COLChad Kuhl (5-5)#190
Fri, Jun 17th@ LADClayton Kershaw (5-1)#34@ LADClayton Kershaw (5-1)#34
Sat, Jun 18th@ LADJulio Urias (5-6)#15@ LADJulio Urias (5-6)#15
Sun, Jun 19th@ LADAndrew Heaney (1-0)#74@ LADAndrew Heaney (1-0)#74
Tue, Jun 21st@ MINJoe Ryan (6-3)#53@ MINJoe Ryan (6-3)#53
Wed, Jun 22nd@ MINSonny Gray (4-1)#49@ MINSonny Gray (4-1)#49
Thu, Jun 23rd@ MINDevin Smeltzer (4-1)#148@ MINDevin Smeltzer (4-1)#148
Fri, Jun 24thvs BOSNick Pivetta (8-5)#38vs BOSNick Pivetta (8-5)#38
Sat, Jun 25thvs BOSJosh Winckowski (3-1)#295vs BOSJosh Winckowski (3-1)#295
Sun, Jun 26thvs BOSRich Hill (4-4)#137vs BOSRich Hill (4-4)#137
Mon, Jun 27thvs MINSonny Gray (4-1)#49vs MINSonny Gray (4-1)#49
Tue, Jun 28thvs MINJosh Winder (2-2)#175vs MINJosh Winder (2-2)#175
Wed, Jun 29thvs MINDylan Bundy (4-4)#149vs MINDylan Bundy (4-4)#149
Thu, Jun 30thvs MINChris Archer (2-3)#126vs MINChris Archer (2-3)#126
Fri, Jul 1stvs NYYGerrit Cole (6-2)#2vs NYYGerrit Cole (6-2)#2
Sat, Jul 2ndvs NYYNestor Cortes Jr. (6-3)#50vs NYYNestor Cortes Jr. (6-3)#50
Sun, Jul 3rdvs NYYJordan Montgomery (3-1)#27vs NYYJordan Montgomery (3-1)#27
Mon, Jul 4th@ DETRony Garcia (2-2)#219@ DETRony Garcia (2-2)#219
Tue, Jul 5th@ DETAlex Faedo (1-4)#124@ DETAlex Faedo (1-4)#124
Wed, Jul 6th@ DET@ DET
Fri, Jul 8th@ KC@ KC
Sat, Jul 9th@ KC@ KC
Sun, Jul 10th@ KC@ KC
Mon, Jul 11thvs CWSvs CWS
Tue, Jul 12thvs CWSvs CWS
Wed, Jul 13thvs CWSvs CWS
Thu, Jul 14thvs DETvs DET
Fri, Jul 15thvs DETvs DET
Sat, Jul 16thvs DETvs DET
Sun, Jul 17thvs DETvs DET
Fri, Jul 22nd@ CWS@ CWS
Sat, Jul 23rd@ CWS@ CWS
Sun, Jul 24th@ CWS@ CWS
Mon, Jul 25th@ BOS@ BOS
Tue, Jul 26th@ BOS@ BOS
Wed, Jul 27th@ BOS@ BOS
Thu, Jul 28th@ BOS@ BOS
Fri, Jul 29th@ TB@ TB
Sat, Jul 30th@ TB@ TB
Sun, Jul 31st@ TB@ TB
Mon, Aug 1stvs ARIvs ARI
Tue, Aug 2ndvs ARIvs ARI
Wed, Aug 3rdvs ARIvs ARI
Thu, Aug 4thvs HOUvs HOU
Fri, Aug 5thvs HOUvs HOU
Sat, Aug 6thvs HOUvs HOU
Sun, Aug 7thvs HOUvs HOU
Tue, Aug 9th@ DET@ DET
Wed, Aug 10th@ DET@ DET
Thu, Aug 11th@ DET@ DET
Fri, Aug 12th@ TOR@ TOR
Sat, Aug 13th@ TOR@ TOR
Sun, Aug 14th@ TOR@ TOR
Mon, Aug 15thvs DETvs DET
Tue, Aug 16thvs DETvs DET
Wed, Aug 17thvs DETvs DET
Fri, Aug 19thvs CWSvs CWS
Sat, Aug 20thvs CWSvs CWS
Sun, Aug 21stvs CWSvs CWS
Tue, Aug 23rd@ SD@ SD
Wed, Aug 24th@ SD@ SD
Thu, Aug 25th@ SEA@ SEA
Fri, Aug 26th@ SEA@ SEA
Sat, Aug 27th@ SEA@ SEA
Sun, Aug 28th@ SEA@ SEA
Tue, Aug 30thvs BALvs BAL
Wed, Aug 31stvs BALvs BAL
Thu, Sep 1stvs BALvs BAL
Fri, Sep 2ndvs SEAvs SEA
Sat, Sep 3rdvs SEAvs SEA
Sun, Sep 4thvs SEAvs SEA
Mon, Sep 5th@ KC@ KC
Tue, Sep 6th@ KC@ KC
Wed, Sep 7th@ KC@ KC
Fri, Sep 9th@ MIN@ MIN
Sat, Sep 10th@ MIN@ MIN
Sun, Sep 11th@ MIN@ MIN
Mon, Sep 12thvs LAAvs LAA
Tue, Sep 13thvs LAAvs LAA
Wed, Sep 14thvs LAAvs LAA
Fri, Sep 16thvs MINvs MIN
Sat, Sep 17thvs MINvs MIN
Sun, Sep 18thvs MINvs MIN
Mon, Sep 19thvs MINvs MIN
Tue, Sep 20th@ CWS@ CWS
Wed, Sep 21st@ CWS@ CWS
Thu, Sep 22nd@ CWS@ CWS
Fri, Sep 23rd@ TEX@ TEX
Sat, Sep 24th@ TEX@ TEX
Sun, Sep 25th@ TEX@ TEX
Tue, Sep 27thvs TBvs TB
Wed, Sep 28thvs TBvs TB
Thu, Sep 29thvs TBvs TB
Fri, Sep 30thvs KCvs KC
Sat, Oct 1stvs KCvs KC
Sun, Oct 2ndvs KCvs KC
Mon, Oct 3rdvs KCvs KC
Tue, Oct 4thvs KCvs KC
Wed, Oct 5thvs KCvs KC