Skip to main content

Fantasy Football Accuracy

Who Gives the Best Fantasy Football Advice?

Most Accurate RB Experts from 2011 to 2015
27 of 221 tracked experts have accuracy scores for all 5 years
Most Accurate RB Experts from 2011 to 2015
Rank Expert Name 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 Multi-Year
1Mike Clay
ESPN
62.5%66.3%63.2%63.4%61.3%63.3%
2John Paulsen
4for4.com
62.9%65.8%60.7%65.1%59.3%62.8%
3Jason Sablich
5th Down Fantasy
63.8%66.5%62.1%62.9%58.5%62.7%
4Jeff Ratcliffe
FTN
62.7%65.0%61.9%62.1%59.7%62.3%
5David Dodds
Footballguys
63.2%65.4%61.8%63.0%57.6%62.2%
6Michael Fabiano
Sports Illustrated
62.4%65.2%60.8%60.4%61.4%62.0%
7Chet Gresham
DK Nation
62.3%64.8%62.1%63.4%57.4%62.0%
8Pat Fitzmaurice
FantasyPros
63.6%64.8%60.3%61.6%59.5%61.9%
9Kevin Hanson
EDSFootball
63.4%64.6%61.1%62.8%57.2%61.8%
10Ken Zalis
Pressbox
62.7%65.7%61.2%62.1%56.6%61.7%
11Scott Pianowski
Yahoo! Sports
64.1%63.2%60.3%61.4%59.0%61.6%
12Site Rankings
FullTime Fantasy
62.6%64.8%60.2%57.4%62.9%61.6%
13Sigmund Bloom
Footballguys
63.4%63.0%60.0%61.7%56.5%60.9%
14Jamey Eisenberg
CBS Sports
63.2%64.0%60.5%59.7%56.0%60.7%
15Brad Evans
FadeTheNoise Podcast
62.6%64.1%59.1%61.5%55.0%60.5%
16Mike Krueger
FFToday
62.4%65.2%57.3%59.6%57.1%60.3%
17Dave Richard
CBS Sports
64.2%63.1%60.9%58.0%54.9%60.2%
18Andy Behrens
Yahoo! Sports
60.9%64.7%59.2%61.1%55.2%60.2%
19Alessandro Miglio
Footballguys
60.3%65.5%59.3%57.5%56.7%59.9%
20Brandon Funston
The Athletic
61.0%65.5%59.3%58.6%53.9%59.7%
21Derek Lofland
FantasyPros
63.2%64.1%56.7%59.2%55.2%59.7%
22Kevin Roberts
Breaking Football
58.9%65.4%58.0%56.0%57.8%59.2%
23Eric Karabell
ESPN
61.9%62.9%57.2%57.4%56.4%59.2%
24Site Projections
scoutPRO
58.8%60.3%57.1%60.0%59.5%59.1%
25Walter Cherepinsky
WalterFootball
61.8%64.6%53.7%56.4%58.0%58.9%
26Tristan Cockcroft
ESPN
61.7%62.8%56.8%56.1%56.7%58.8%
27Eric Mack
Fantasy Fatcast
59.7%59.1%57.9%59.0%56.6%58.5%
2015 Accuracy (Weeks 1 - 16)

Summary and Analysis | IDP Accuracy | Draft Accuracy

2015 Accuracy (Weeks 1 - 16)
Rank Expert Name Overall*QBRBWRTEKDST
1Sean Koerner
The Action Network
59.9%58.0%62.9%57.8%64.7%48.7%57.4%
2Site Rankings
FullTime Fantasy
57.4%53.5%62.9%55.3%60.7%50.2%56.6%
3Michael Fabiano
Sports Illustrated
58.2%57.3%61.4%55.4%65.1%51.7%50.0%
4Mike Clay
ESPN
58.3%56.2%61.3%56.6%63.8%53.0%53.1%
5Tony Mauriello
ProjectRoto
55.1%50.9%60.3%54.6%53.1%50.5%57.2%
6Marc Caviglia
Bruno Boys
57.6%54.4%60.1%56.2%63.6%54.4%58.8%
7Emil Kadlec
Football Diehards
56.6%55.2%59.8%54.1%61.6%51.8%56.7%
8Jody Smith
FullTime Fantasy
57.5%53.0%59.8%57.3%62.0%51.0%56.4%
9Ryan Noonan
4for4.com
56.8%53.8%59.7%56.9%58.1%50.3%56.0%
10Eric Moody
Pro Football Network
57.3%56.2%59.7%56.4%61.1%53.4%52.3%
11Patrick Thorman
Establish the Run
58.7%57.6%59.7%58.2%63.8%53.1%56.9%
12Jeff Ratcliffe
FTN
59.0%56.2%59.7%59.1%65.8%49.5%54.2%
13Nathan Jahnke
Pro Football Focus
56.8%51.0%59.6%56.9%63.9%50.7%55.4%
14Jake Ciely
The Athletic
59.2%59.6%59.6%58.5%66.1%52.1%56.4%
15Site Projections
scoutPRO
56.2%53.0%59.5%55.4%58.1%50.3%58.1%
16Pat Fitzmaurice
FantasyPros
58.3%53.5%59.5%59.1%64.1%53.4%55.7%
17Kyle Wachtel
Forensic Fantasy
57.8%59.7%59.4%56.2%61.7%53.8%58.7%
18John Paulsen
4for4.com
59.2%56.0%59.3%59.4%68.0%n/an/a
19Jeff Paur
RTSports
55.8%51.5%59.3%54.8%56.8%49.5%58.2%
20Brett Talley
Fantasy Alarm
58.1%55.9%59.1%57.3%65.2%50.2%57.3%
FantasyPros Members get access to the full list of 122 experts and accuracy scores
Register (free) Login
2014 Accuracy (Weeks 1 - 16)

Summary and Analysis | IDP Accuracy | Draft Accuracy

2014 Accuracy (Weeks 1 - 16)
Rank Expert Name Overall*QBRBWRTEKDST
1Sean Koerner
The Action Network
60.6%57.9%65.9%57.4%63.1%52.9%57.5%
2John Paulsen
4for4.com
60.7%59.6%65.1%58.2%61.8%n/an/a
3Justin Boone
theScore
60.3%60.3%63.5%59.1%60.4%60.2%56.1%
4Mike Clay
ESPN
58.8%57.3%63.4%56.6%62.8%50.7%55.9%
5Chet Gresham
DK Nation
58.3%57.4%63.4%55.9%58.8%56.7%54.1%
6Kyle Wachtel
Forensic Fantasy
58.7%59.0%63.2%56.2%59.7%56.6%53.6%
7Maurile Tremblay
Footballguys
58.4%54.1%63.1%56.1%62.9%55.0%55.1%
8Jon Collins
Fantasy Sports LR
58.4%52.7%63.1%58.4%59.2%63.7%53.8%
9Staff Rankings
Pyromaniac
58.8%55.5%63.0%59.0%56.5%n/an/a
10David Dodds
Footballguys
57.7%55.6%63.0%56.3%58.3%57.1%57.5%
11Jason Sablich
5th Down Fantasy
59.4%60.1%62.9%56.9%58.9%56.6%56.2%
12Kevin Hanson
EDSFootball
57.0%55.3%62.8%56.3%52.8%59.0%56.6%
13Patrick Thorman
Establish the Run
59.4%59.7%62.8%58.6%57.2%59.8%55.6%
14Rich Hribar
Rotoworld
56.8%52.6%62.8%55.9%54.1%n/a58.7%
15Jody Smith
FullTime Fantasy
58.2%56.1%62.8%58.1%55.3%58.0%59.5%
16Jeff Brubach
The Fake Football
58.7%58.5%62.6%58.2%54.8%50.5%48.0%
17Ryan Noonan
4for4.com
58.4%57.6%62.4%57.6%57.5%56.9%56.9%
18Nathan Miller
Revelation Sports
58.4%60.4%62.4%57.5%51.9%57.2%58.4%
19Matthew Hill
DataForce Fantasy Football
58.9%59.2%62.4%57.5%57.0%n/an/a
20Terrance Bridgett
Fake Pigskin
57.8%55.8%62.4%56.7%56.4%57.5%55.9%
FantasyPros Members get access to the full list of 124 experts and accuracy scores
Register (free) Login
2013 Accuracy (Weeks 1 - 16)

Summary and Analysis | IDP Accuracy | Draft Accuracy

2013 Accuracy (Weeks 1 - 16)
Rank Expert Name Overall*QBRBWRTEKDST
1Mike Clay
ESPN
60.8%58.8%63.2%60.4%62.6%51.1%49.0%
2Tozzi Brothers
Legion Report
61.1%58.7%63.1%60.8%63.6%51.0%58.0%
3Jake Ciely
The Athletic
60.6%59.2%62.8%59.8%61.8%52.6%57.8%
4Kyle Wachtel
Forensic Fantasy
60.2%56.8%62.6%60.0%62.5%52.8%54.7%
5Mike Tagliere
FantasyPros
60.4%58.6%62.3%59.4%64.3%n/an/a
6Chet Gresham
DK Nation
59.1%53.0%62.1%58.7%65.0%46.5%57.4%
7Jason Sablich
5th Down Fantasy
60.6%59.2%62.1%59.7%65.9%50.6%59.5%
8Jeff Ratcliffe
FTN
60.1%58.1%61.9%59.1%64.3%49.9%59.3%
9Sean Koerner
The Action Network
59.9%59.0%61.8%59.9%59.9%54.1%58.9%
10David Dodds
Footballguys
60.0%58.3%61.8%59.8%61.2%52.0%58.3%
11Bryan Fontaine
RotoGrinders
59.8%57.2%61.7%60.2%61.6%54.3%56.4%
12Adrian Pereira
eDraft
59.6%55.5%61.7%60.6%61.5%50.1%63.3%
13Maurile Tremblay
Footballguys
58.6%55.0%61.4%57.6%63.5%55.6%60.0%
14Nick Raducanu
Dr. Roto
59.6%58.7%61.3%58.2%63.1%51.0%58.9%
15Zach Greubel
Gridiron Experts
58.4%57.2%61.3%57.6%59.2%n/a54.3%
16Ken Zalis
Pressbox
59.0%56.5%61.2%59.6%59.2%50.1%58.1%
17Patrick Daugherty
Rotoworld
60.2%57.4%61.1%59.7%64.2%45.1%56.4%
18Kevin Hanson
EDSFootball
59.5%58.0%61.1%58.9%63.8%53.0%55.1%
19Brendan Donahue
Sharp Football Analysis
59.4%59.1%61.1%58.9%61.0%48.3%58.3%
20Site Projections
Fantasy Football Starters
57.2%60.4%61.0%52.7%56.5%52.4%61.0%
FantasyPros Members get access to the full list of 123 experts and accuracy scores
Register (free) Login
2012 Accuracy (Weeks 1 - 16)

Summary and Analysis | IDP Accuracy | Draft Accuracy

2012 Accuracy (Weeks 1 - 16)
Rank Expert Name Overall*QBRBWRTEKDST
1Mike Tagliere
FantasyPros
61.9%59.4%67.2%61.3%54.7%n/an/a
2Eric Yeomans
Mr. 52 Pick-Up
61.6%60.6%66.6%60.5%55.5%54.2%53.5%
3John Halpin
Carolina Panthers Radio Network
61.2%62.0%66.6%58.7%56.3%51.7%53.9%
4Jason Sablich
5th Down Fantasy
62.3%61.7%66.5%60.9%59.5%57.4%56.5%
5Site Projections
numberFire
61.2%59.9%66.5%57.5%55.3%53.6%55.1%
6Staff Rankings
Bruno Boys
61.0%59.9%66.5%58.6%56.3%54.7%57.1%
7Justin Boone
theScore
61.8%61.7%66.4%60.0%57.4%60.7%57.5%
8Mike Clay
ESPN
62.3%62.9%66.3%60.8%58.0%51.0%55.6%
9Jody Smith
FullTime Fantasy
62.6%59.6%66.1%60.9%63.4%56.5%57.4%
10John Paulsen
4for4.com
62.1%62.9%65.8%60.9%57.2%n/an/a
11Chris Wesseling
Rotoworld
61.6%60.4%65.8%60.8%55.9%52.2%59.7%
12Ken Zalis
Pressbox
61.8%63.1%65.7%59.9%57.3%58.9%58.6%
13Jeff Brubach
The Fake Football
60.7%60.3%65.7%59.0%53.5%55.6%56.0%
14Raju Byfield
Win My Fantasy League
59.9%59.8%65.7%57.6%53.8%n/a52.2%
15Muntradamus
Beast Dome
61.8%62.5%65.7%61.6%52.6%59.4%56.3%
16Austin Lee
Footballguys
61.3%61.4%65.6%59.6%57.8%55.2%57.6%
17Alessandro Miglio
Footballguys
60.5%58.8%65.5%60.0%52.0%49.4%56.5%
18Brandon Funston
The Athletic
61.2%61.8%65.5%60.0%53.7%57.7%59.9%
19Mike Harmon
Swollen Dome
60.7%60.1%65.5%59.4%53.7%56.4%56.6%
20Staff Rankings
RosterWatch
61.1%61.2%65.4%59.6%55.9%57.6%56.9%
FantasyPros Members get access to the full list of 88 experts and accuracy scores
Register (free) Login
2011 Accuracy (Weeks 1 - 16)

Summary and Analysis | IDP Accuracy | Draft Accuracy

2011 Accuracy (Weeks 1 - 16)
Rank Expert Name Overall*QBRBWRTEKDST
1Dave Richard
CBS Sports
61.4%64.8%64.2%59.1%53.6%49.4%51.7%
2Scott Pianowski
Yahoo! Sports
63.7%69.4%64.1%61.6%60.4%56.8%56.6%
3Jason Sablich
5th Down Fantasy
63.3%67.3%63.8%61.5%61.5%56.5%55.3%
4Russ Bliss
Fantasy Football Starters
62.7%66.0%63.7%60.9%59.7%52.6%54.2%
5Pat Fitzmaurice
FantasyPros
62.9%68.0%63.6%59.6%63.0%58.3%56.4%
6Josh Moore
4for4.com
63.5%68.7%63.5%62.1%60.3%n/an/a
7Sigmund Bloom
Footballguys
62.4%65.4%63.4%59.5%63.2%n/an/a
8Kevin Hanson
EDSFootball
63.5%70.3%63.4%62.3%58.0%51.1%51.3%
9Derek Lofland
FantasyPros
62.3%63.9%63.2%61.5%59.4%n/an/a
10Staff Composite
ESPN
62.8%68.4%63.2%61.8%56.8%52.2%52.2%
11Site Projections
CBS Sports
62.0%67.9%63.2%59.7%56.5%54.4%54.1%
12David Dodds
Footballguys
62.1%66.0%63.2%59.5%60.6%50.7%45.8%
13Paul Greco
Paul Greco Sports
60.7%63.4%63.2%57.5%57.6%52.2%48.0%
14Jamey Eisenberg
CBS Sports
61.2%67.5%63.2%58.4%54.1%53.3%54.5%
15John Paulsen
4for4.com
63.7%69.1%62.9%62.3%63.1%53.4%52.6%
16Site Projections
numberFire
62.6%67.9%62.8%60.6%60.4%55.3%52.5%
17Ken Zalis
Pressbox
62.8%68.3%62.7%61.5%59.5%55.3%54.2%
18Jeff Ratcliffe
FTN
63.2%69.6%62.7%62.0%59.8%53.2%54.1%
19Brad Evans
FadeTheNoise Podcast
62.0%65.2%62.6%60.6%59.4%55.8%52.3%
20Site Rankings
FullTime Fantasy
62.5%68.2%62.6%60.3%60.8%55.3%50.9%
FantasyPros Members get access to the full list of 67 experts and accuracy scores
Register (free) Login
2010 Accuracy (Weeks 1 - 16)

Summary and Analysis | Draft Accuracy

2010 Accuracy (Weeks 1 - 16)
Rank Expert Name Overall*QBRBWRTEKDST
1David Dodds
Footballguys
60.4%63.4%63.3%57.4%55.8%54.7%51.7%
2Site Rankings
Fantasy Football Nerd
59.8%62.8%63.0%55.6%57.7%50.3%56.7%
3John Paulsen
4for4.com
61.3%62.2%62.8%59.3%60.8%n/a60.0%
4Site Rankings
Ultimate FF Strategy
59.0%58.5%61.9%58.0%53.2%49.4%55.0%
5Andy Behrens
Yahoo! Sports
60.2%63.3%61.6%58.5%56.1%46.2%59.4%
6Staff Composite
Yahoo! Sports
59.5%61.7%61.5%57.6%54.9%46.1%61.4%
7Chet Gresham
DK Nation
59.7%61.0%61.4%57.8%58.2%48.7%54.2%
8Josh Moore
4for4.com
59.9%62.0%61.2%58.7%55.7%n/an/a
9Site Projections
CBS Sports
59.0%63.8%60.9%56.8%52.2%n/an/a
10Ryan Lester
Lesters Legends
58.8%60.4%60.8%56.1%58.0%43.7%57.2%
11Staff Composite
ESPN
59.6%60.9%60.6%57.9%59.4%44.3%53.9%
12Scott Pianowski
Yahoo! Sports
59.1%62.4%60.5%57.4%54.8%53.6%60.8%
13
59.2%60.3%60.5%58.2%56.0%48.2%54.8%
14Brad Richter
DailyOverlay
56.1%53.8%60.3%54.0%51.3%43.6%49.4%
15Brad Evans
FadeTheNoise Podcast
57.3%59.0%60.2%55.2%51.2%46.6%58.4%
16Brandon Funston
The Athletic
58.1%57.3%60.2%56.9%55.8%43.8%56.8%
17Eric Karabell
ESPN
59.0%58.9%60.0%57.6%60.2%43.0%50.0%
18Site Projections
Yahoo! Sports
59.4%66.7%60.0%57.2%53.3%n/an/a
19Sigmund Bloom
Footballguys
58.6%63.8%59.9%55.8%55.2%n/an/a
20Site Rankings
FullTime Fantasy
58.3%61.7%59.8%56.5%53.7%47.8%52.6%
FantasyPros Members get access to the full list of 39 experts and accuracy scores
Register (free) Login
2009 Accuracy (Weeks 1 - 16)

Summary and Analysis | Draft Accuracy

2009 Accuracy (Weeks 1 - 16)
Rank Expert Name Overall*QBRBWRTEKDST
1David Dodds
Footballguys
60.2%57.3%65.2%58.0%54.6%61.1%49.1%
2Sigmund Bloom
Footballguys
59.9%56.0%64.9%58.5%52.9%n/an/a
3R.J. White
CBS Sports
59.2%55.9%63.6%56.0%58.1%55.7%55.5%
4Pat Fitzmaurice
FantasyPros
60.7%58.3%63.4%60.2%57.5%61.2%54.4%
5Erik Kuselias
ESPN
58.9%56.7%62.6%58.1%52.2%58.2%57.8%
6Andy Behrens
Yahoo! Sports
60.8%60.3%62.5%59.7%58.7%55.0%57.9%
7
58.1%56.2%61.7%56.4%53.6%52.8%58.8%
8Site Rankings
FullTime Fantasy
58.4%58.0%61.7%53.7%61.1%60.9%n/a
9Brad Evans
FadeTheNoise Podcast
59.2%57.1%61.5%57.6%59.2%55.3%59.0%
10Scott Pianowski
Yahoo! Sports
60.0%60.2%61.4%59.1%58.1%61.1%59.8%
11Staff Composite
FantasyFootball.com
59.5%58.7%61.4%58.2%58.1%60.4%49.7%
12Brandon Funston
The Athletic
60.4%60.9%61.4%60.6%56.2%57.7%60.5%
13Scott Engel
RotoBaller
58.7%53.5%61.4%57.9%59.5%n/an/a
14Staff Rankings
Fantasy Football Cafe
58.8%58.1%60.9%57.0%58.2%57.1%47.3%
15Eric Karabell
ESPN
58.5%57.6%60.2%56.5%59.9%53.5%55.4%
16
60.3%60.0%60.0%60.3%61.2%54.7%54.7%
17Christopher Harris
Harris Football
58.4%56.3%59.3%59.0%56.6%54.3%48.9%
18Site Projections
CBS Sports
53.7%51.3%58.5%50.7%49.9%51.9%55.4%
19Staff Rankings
KFFL
53.5%49.9%57.9%53.4%47.9%49.4%50.7%
20Paul Greco
Paul Greco Sports
53.1%53.3%55.6%49.5%54.5%52.3%55.1%
FantasyPros Members get access to the full list of 21 experts and accuracy scores
Register (free) Login

* Overall PAY is a weighted average of QB, RB, WR and TE (DST and K scores are not included). The weights are determined by the relative importance of each position.