Skip to main content

Antonio Gibson or Saquon Barkley

Who Should I Draft?


Looking for Start/Sit Advice? Go to Who Should I Start

Player Summaries Comparison
 
Experts' Pick
 
   
 
Default player image

Expert
Percent


76%
Recommended by
157 of 207 experts
24%
Recommended by
50 of 207 experts
Add Player
Most Accurate Experts 
    
Top ExpertsTop RB ExpertsTop Player ExpertsPadlock icon See who the Most Accurate Experts would draft
Upgrade Now
    
Rankings 
    
ECR# 9# 10-
Best Rank# 1# 5-
Worst Rank# 19# 20-
    
Fantasy Points 
    
Season Total9.4166.2-
Avg Game4.711.9-
Avg Projection223.6202.4-
    
Schedule 
    
SOS Rank3121-
    
Misc 
    
Injury Alert-
    
Expert Ranks 
Saquon BarkleyAntonio GibsonAdd Player
    
Jeff Ratcliffe J. Ratcliffe
FTN FTN
1 w
#10#12-
    
Scott Pianowski S. Pianowski
Yahoo! Sports Yahoo! Sports
1 w
#12#10-
    
Christopher Dell C. Dell
Betting Predators Betting Predators
1 w
#9#12-
    
Andy Holloway A. Holloway
The Fantasy Footballers The Fantasy Footba...
1 w
#9#12-
    
Ben Wasley B. Wasley
The Fantasy First Down The Fantasy First ...
1 w
#9#12-
    
Jordan Eisen J. Eisen
Field of Vision Sports Field of Vision Sp...
1 w
#8#9-
    
Jason Moore J. Moore
The Fantasy Footballers The Fantasy Footba...
1 w
#9#11-
    
Alex Godshall A. Godshall
Beaver Dam Beaver Dam
1 w
#9#10-
    
Jeff Smith J. Smith
FantasyData FantasyData
1 w
#9#10-
    
Muntradamus M.
Beast Dome Beast Dome
1 w
#12#9-
    
Kevin Hanson K. Hanson
EDSFootball EDSFootball
1 w
#8#12-
    
Dave Major D. Major
XN Sports XN Sports
1 w
#9#12-
    
Allie Fontana A. Fontana
Fighting Chance Fantasy Fighting Chance Fa...
1 w
#8#11-
    
The FFGhost T. FFGhost
Dynasty League Football Dynasty League Foo...
1 w
#10#8-
    
Elisha Twerski E. Twerski
OddsChecker OddsChecker
1 w
#9#12-
    
Bradley Stalder B. Stalder
FantasyData FantasyData
1 w
#9#10-
    
Tim Petropoulos T. Petropoulos
BRoto Fantasy BRoto Fantasy
1 w
#11#9-
    
Kyle Yates K. Yates
FantasyPros FantasyPros
1 w
#9#10-
    
Rudy Gamble R. Gamble
Razzball Razzball
1 w
#9#8-
    
Dennis Sosic D. Sosic
Fantasy Six Pack Fantasy Six Pack
1 w
#9#10-
    
Dalton Del Don D. Del Don
Yahoo! Sports Yahoo! Sports
1 w
#9#10-
    
Jeff Boggis J. Boggis
Fantasy Football Empire Fantasy Football E...
1 w
#10#9-
    
Joey Wright J. Wright
Razzball Razzball
1 w
#9#13-
    
Jacob Gibbs J. Gibbs
SportsLine SportsLine
1 w
#13#9-
    
Todd D Clark T. D Clark
The Fantasy Fix The Fantasy Fix
1 w
#9#8-
    
Nick Zylak N. Zylak
Fantasy Football Advice Fantasy Football A...
1 w
#11#10-
    
Bill Enright B. Enright
Sports Illustrated Sports Illustrated
1 w
#11#12-
    
Joe Pisapia J. Pisapia
FantasyPros FantasyPros
1 w
#6#9-
    
Bart Wheeler B. Wheeler
Hail to Fantasy Football Hail to Fantasy Fo...
1 w
#9#13-
    
Anthony Cervino A. Cervino
FF Faceoff FF Faceoff
1 w
#9#10-
    
Neema Hodjat N. Hodjat
Real GM Real GM
1 w
#9#11-
    
Donkey Teeth D. Teeth
Razzball Razzball
1 w
#7#8-
    
Jared Smola J. Smola
Draft Sharks Draft Sharks
1 w
#8#13-
    
Dan Clasgens D. Clasgens
Get Sports Info Get Sports Info
1 w
#10#9-
    
Sean Koerner S. Koerner
The Action Network The Action Network
1 w
#9#17-
    
Dylan Licciardo D. Licciardo
FF Gamers FF Gamers
1 w
#13#9-
    
Andy Singleton A. Singleton
Expand The Boxscore Expand The Boxscore
1 w
#9#10-
    
Doug Orth D. Orth
FFToday FFToday
1 w
#9#10-
    
Matt Okada M. Okada
BallBlast BallBlast
1 w
#9#23-
    
Dan McLellan D. McLellan
WBLZ Media WBLZ Media
1 w
#10#11-
    
Derek Dennington D. Dennington
The Good Old Boys Fantasy Football Podcast The Good Old Boys ...
1 w
#8#9-
    
Matthew Freedman M. Freedman
FTN FTN
1 w
#9#12-
    
Mick Ciallela M. Ciallela
Fantrax Fantrax
1 w
#9#12-
    
Ryan Hicks R. Hicks
Belly Up Sports Belly Up Sports
1 w
#1#10-
    
Andy Vanda A. Vanda
Take Your League Take Your League
1 w
#13#8-
    
Chris Raybon C. Raybon
The Action Network The Action Network
1 w
#14#11-
    
Kate Magdziuk K. Magdziuk
BallBlast BallBlast
1 w
#12#15-
    
Seth Miller S. Miller
Crossroads Fantasy Football Crossroads Fantasy...
1 w
#10#8-
    
Tyrell Maclachlan T. Maclachlan
True North Fantasy Football True North Fantasy...
1 w
#10#9-
    
Jake Ciely J. Ciely
The Athletic The Athletic
1 w
#9#12-
    
Francisco (Chato) Romero F. (Chato) ...
Estadio Fantasy Estadio Fantasy
1 w
#11#8-
    
Davis Mattek D. Mattek
SportsGrid SportsGrid
1 w
#7#12-
    
Tim Jablonski T. Jablonski
The Hateful 8 The Hateful 8
1 w
#9#10-
    
Matt De Lima M. De Lima
Sports Illustrated Sports Illustrated
1 w
#9#10-
    
Mike Wright M. Wright
The Fantasy Footballers The Fantasy Footba...
1 w
#10#11-
    
Scott Whitfield S. Whitfield
Roto Rankings Roto Rankings
1 w
#14#7-
    
Drew DeLuca D. DeLuca
NFL Spinzone NFL Spinzone
1 w
#11#10-
    
Ellis Johnson E. Johnson
True North Fantasy Football True North Fantasy...
1 w
#15#10-
    
David Biggs D. Biggs
Drink Five Drink Five
1 w
#9#11-
    
Kevin Wheeler K. Wheeler
The Draft Zone The Draft Zone
1 w
#9#10-
    
Brandon Funston B. Funston
The Athletic The Athletic
1 w
#8#9-
    
Nick Mariano N. Mariano
RotoBaller RotoBaller
1 w
#9#11-
    
David Zach D. Zach
FantasyPros FantasyPros
1 w
#9#12-
    
Zachary Hanshew Z. Hanshew
FantasyPros FantasyPros
1 w
#8#14-
    
Andrew Erickson A. Erickson
Pro Football Focus Pro Football Focus
1 w
#7#12-
    
Nathan Jahnke N. Jahnke
Pro Football Focus Pro Football Focus
1 w
#5#10-
    
Chalk C.
The Undroppables The Undroppables
1 w
#12#10-
    
Kent Weyrauch K. Weyrauch
Pro Football Focus Pro Football Focus
1 w
#7#17-
    
Matthew Betz M. Betz
The Fantasy Footballers The Fantasy Footba...
1 w
#9#12-
    
Ryan Noonan R. Noonan
4for4.com 4for4.com
1 w
#10#11-
    
Doug Norrie D. Norrie
Daily Fantasy Sports Rankings Daily Fantasy Spor...
1 w
#11#18-
    
Ryan Skolrud R. Skolrud
SkullKing Sports SkullKing Sports
1 w
#8#10-
    
Garret Price G. Price
Dynasty Nerds Dynasty Nerds
1 w
#8#11-
    
Jaime Eisner J. Eisner
The Draft Network The Draft Network
1 w
#13#10-
    
Marc Caviglia M. Caviglia
Bruno Boys Bruno Boys
1 w
#9#11-
    
Ricky Lemon R. Lemon
The Fantasy Champions The Fantasy Champions
1 w
#6#11-
    
Jose Ramon Llaca J. Ramon Llaca
Estadio Fantasy Estadio Fantasy
1 w
#9#11-
    
Joe Bond J. Bond
Fantasy Six Pack Fantasy Six Pack
1 w
#10#9-
    
Michelle Magdziuk M. Magdziuk
BallBlast BallBlast
1 w
#8#13-
    
Matthew McCarthy M. McCarthy
Gridiron Ratings Gridiron Ratings
1 w
#5#11-
    
Andy Behrens A. Behrens
Yahoo! Sports Yahoo! Sports
1 w
#10#9-
    
Jonathan Stone J. Stone
The Hateful 8 The Hateful 8
1 w
#8#10-
    
Derek Lofland D. Lofland
FantasyPros FantasyPros
1 w
#8#10-
    
Mike Randle M. Randle
BettingPros BettingPros
1 w
#11#7-
    
Nick Raducanu N. Raducanu
Dr. Roto Dr. Roto
1 w
#8#10-
    
Raju Byfield R. Byfield
Win My Fantasy League Win My Fantasy League
1 w
#8#11-
    
Matthew Williams M. Williams
NBC Sports NBC Sports
1 w
#9#11-
    
Jason Willan J. Willan
Gridiron Experts Gridiron Experts
1 w
#10#12-
    
Jordan Rains J. Rains
The IDP Army The IDP Army
1 w
#3#11-
    
Des Bieler D. Bieler
The Washington Post The Washington Post
1 w
#7#9-
    
Dave Kluge D. Kluge
Footballguys Footballguys
1 w
#8#13-
    
Eric Moody E. Moody
Pro Football Network Pro Football Network
1 w
#11#9-
    
Robert Waziak R. Waziak
Fantasy Life Fantasy Life
1 w
#9#10-
    
Fantasy BR F. BR
Fantasy BR Fantasy BR
1 w
#5#10-
    
Donald Gibson D. Gibson
FantasyPros FantasyPros
1 w
#6#12-
    
Steven Pintado S. Pintado
The Fantasy Coaches The Fantasy Coaches
1 w
#8#12-
    
Ryan Weisse R. Weisse
Footballguys Footballguys
1 w
#10#9-
    
Andrew Seifter A. Seifter
FantasyPros FantasyPros
1 w
#14#11-
    
Blair Williams B. Williams
Razzball Razzball
1 w
#11#9-
    
Matthew Hill M. Hill
DataForce Fantasy Football DataForce Fantasy ...
1 w
#11#10-
    
Jamie Calandro J. Calandro
Football Diehards Football Diehards
1 w
#7#11-
    
Michael Tomlin M. Tomlin
Fantasy Six Pack Fantasy Six Pack
1 w
#9#13-
    
Richard Savill R. Savill
Fantasy Six Pack Fantasy Six Pack
1 w
#12#10-
    
Tyler Orginski T. Orginski
Fantasy Hot Read Fantasy Hot Read
1 w
#3#10-
    
Ken Zalis K. Zalis
Pressbox Pressbox
1 w
#10#9-
    
Adam Murfet A. Murfet
5 Yard Rush 5 Yard Rush
1 w
#6#12-
    
Lawrence Jackson L. Jackson
Fantasy Football Lord Fantasy Football Lord
1 w
#8#11-
    
Mike Harmon M. Harmon
Swollen Dome Swollen Dome
1 w
#14#8-
    
Smitty S.
SleeperU SleeperU
1 w
#14#5-
    
Robby Jeffries R. Jeffries
The Fantasy Authority The Fantasy Authority
1 w
#8#11-
    
Dave Richard D. Richard
CBS Sports CBS Sports
1 w
#10#14-
    
Dan Harris D. Harris
FantasyPros FantasyPros
1 w
#8#10-
    
Matt Schauf M. Schauf
Draft Sharks Draft Sharks
1 w
#9#16-
    
Jon Collins J. Collins
Fantasy Sports LR Fantasy Sports LR
1 w
#10#9-
    
Rob Wilson R. Wilson
The Fantasy Footballers The Fantasy Footba...
1 w
#8#10-
    
Corbin Young C. Young
FantasyData FantasyData
1 w
#9#10-
    
Benjamin Klotz B. Klotz
Touchdown Squad Touchdown Squad
1 w
#8#10-
    
Armando Crespo A. Crespo
Eat.Sleep.Fantasy Eat.Sleep.Fantasy
1 w
#19#13-
    
M. Starks Powell M. Starks P...
New Life Fantasy New Life Fantasy
1 w
#8#11-
    
Kyle August K. August
Fantasy Football Smackdown Fantasy Football S...
1 w
#7#10-
    
Rich Piazza R. Piazza
Fantasy Shed Fantasy Shed
1 w
#8#12-
    
Jarad Evans J. Evans
Pro Football Focus Pro Football Focus
1 w
#8#12-
    
Billy Muzio B. Muzio
FantasyData FantasyData
1 w
#10#12-
    
Dave McKay D. McKay
The Fantasy Sports Brain The Fantasy Sports...
1 w
#8#11-
    
Lenny Pappano L. Pappano
Draft Sharks Draft Sharks
1 w
#9#10-
    
Mark Ringo M. Ringo
Sleepers and Busts Sleepers and Busts
1 w
#21#3-
    
Sosa Kremenjas S. Kremenjas
Pro Football Focus Pro Football Focus
1 w
#9#11-
    
Tommy Molioo T. Molioo
The Undroppables The Undroppables
1 w
#5#8-
    
Tal Malachovsky T. Malachovsky
The Fantasy Scout The Fantasy Scout
1 w
#10#11-
    
Jody Smith J. Smith
FullTime Fantasy FullTime Fantasy
1 w
#7#10-
    
Jeff Paur J. Paur
RTSports RTSports
1 w
#8#11-
    
Brendan Tuma B. Tuma
FantasyPros FantasyPros
1 w
#9#12-
    
Seth Keller S. Keller
Gridiron Experts Gridiron Experts
1 w
#3#13-
    
Justin Sablich J. Sablich
5th Down Fantasy 5th Down Fantasy
1 w
#9#10-
    
KJ K.
Fantasy Team Advice Fantasy Team Advice
1 w
#5#13-
    
Aaron Schill A. Schill
FF Faceoff FF Faceoff
1 w
#10#11-
    
Jason Petropoulos J. Petropoulos
BRoto Fantasy BRoto Fantasy
1 w
#9#11-
    
John Hesterman J. Hesterman
Dynasty League Football Dynasty League Foo...
1 w
#8#11-
    
Nick Bretwisch N. Bretwisch
Win Daily Sports Win Daily Sports
1 w
#9#12-
    
Anthony Staggs A. Staggs
4for4.com 4for4.com
1 w
#9#10-
    
Nate Hamilton N. Hamilton
The Game Day The Game Day
1 w
#10#20-
    
Mike MacGregor M. MacGregor
Draft Buddy Draft Buddy
2 w
#18#9-
    
Michael Petropoulos M. Petropoulos
BRoto Fantasy BRoto Fantasy
2 w
#10#9-
    
Dale DeMott D. DeMott
Eat.Sleep.Fantasy Eat.Sleep.Fantasy
2 w
#6#9-
    
Jamey Eisenberg J. Eisenberg
CBS Sports CBS Sports
2 w
#12#9-
    
Matt Marchese M. Marchese
Sportsnet Sportsnet
2 w
#1#12-
    
Kevin Roberts K. Roberts
Breaking Football Breaking Football
2 w
#7#13-
    
Pat Fitzmaurice P. Fitzmaurice
FantasyPros FantasyPros
2 w
#9#8-
    
Brian Strait B. Strait
FTLS Fantasy Football FTLS Fantasy Football
2 w
#4#13-
    
Dan Larocca D. Larocca
Locked In Football Locked In Football
2 w
#10#11-
    
Kevin Tompkins K. Tompkins
BallBlast BallBlast
2 w
#6#9-
    
Scott Smith S. Smith
RotoViz RotoViz
2 w
#10#11-
    
Tim Brosnan T. Brosnan
Tim's Fantasy Tips Tim's Fantasy Tips
2 w
#6#11-
    
Sebastian Ardura S. Ardura
Gurus Deportivos Gurus Deportivos
2 w
#9#12-
    
Pierre Camus P. Camus
RotoBaller RotoBaller
2 w
#5#11-
    
Jacob W. Dunne J. W. Dunne
New Life Fantasy New Life Fantasy
2 w
#8#11-
    
Clayton Cadieux C. Cadieux
Fantasy Football From Up North Fantasy Football F...
2 w
#10#12-
    
Kyle Richardson K. Richardson
The Fantasy Headliners The Fantasy Headli...
2 w
#8#10-
    
Justin Weigal J. Weigal
FantasySharks FantasySharks
2 w
#10#11-
    
Tozzi Brothers T. Brothers
Legion Report Legion Report
2 w
#4#11-
    
Dalton Kates D. Kates
APEX Fantasy Leagues APEX Fantasy Leagues
2 w
#6#10-
    
Husein Shabazz H. Shabazz
SleeperWire SleeperWire
2 w
#6#10-
    
Elvin Ryan E. Ryan
The Pregame HQ The Pregame HQ
2 w
#9#10-
    
Mitchell Carl M. Carl
Rise or Fall Rise or Fall
2 w
#8#17-
    
Aaron Larson A. Larson
FantasyPros FantasyPros
2 w
#5#10-
    
Michael Hauff M. Hauff
FF Faceoff FF Faceoff
2 w
#9#11-
    
Huseyin Aksu H. Aksu
Fantasy Couch Fantasy Couch
2 w
#6#8-
    
Michael Beller M. Beller
The Athletic The Athletic
2 w
#9#11-
    
Justin Dodds J. Dodds
SleeperWire SleeperWire
2 w
#8#10-
    
Heath Capps H. Capps
Fake Teams Fake Teams
2 w
#15#12-
    
Matt Harmon M. Harmon
Yahoo! Sports Yahoo! Sports
2 w
#5#11-
    
James Bryer J. Bryer
Gridiron Experts Gridiron Experts
2 w
#6#11-
    
Chris Kennedy C. Kennedy
The Fantasy Headliners The Fantasy Headli...
2 w
#9#10-
    
Ryan Hodge R. Hodge
FantasyLabs FantasyLabs
2 w
#7#12-
    
Daniel Mader D. Mader
Belly Up Sports Belly Up Sports
2 w
#8#10-
    
Site Rankings S. Rankings
FFToday FFToday
2 w
#8#10-
    
Walter Cherepinsky W. Cherepinsky
WalterFootball WalterFootball
2 w
#10#7-
    
Brandon Murchison B. Murchison
RotoBaller RotoBaller
2 w
#18#11-
    
Liz Loza L. Loza
Yahoo! Sports Yahoo! Sports
2 w
#11#9-
    
Adrian Alpanseque A. Alpanseque
Estadio Fantasy Estadio Fantasy
2 w
#8#11-
    
Richard King R. King
King Fantasy Sports King Fantasy Sports
2 w
#9#14-
    
Matt Camp M. Camp
Bleacher Report Bleacher Report
2 w
#6#11-
    
Staff Rankings S. Rankings
QB List QB List
2 w
#10#11-
    
Mark Ross M. Ross
Athlon Sports Athlon Sports
2 w
#7#13-
    
Adam Pelletier A. Pelletier
Sports Gambling Podcast Network Sports Gambling Po...
2 w
#7#13-
    
Jacob Wayne J. Wayne
Lineups Lineups
2 w
#6#14-
    
Mauricio Gutierrez M. Gutierrez
Estadio Fantasy Estadio Fantasy
3 w
#10#9-
    
Morgan Colby M. Colby
The Fantasy Champions The Fantasy Champions
3 w
#6#11-
    
Scott Engel S. Engel
RotoBaller RotoBaller
3 w
#13#9-
    
Brad Evans B. Evans
FadeTheNoise Podcast FadeTheNoise Podcast
3 w
#11#9-
    
Craig Phillips C. Phillips
FF Prophet FF Prophet
3 w
#8#11-
    
Michael Florio M. Florio
RotoBaller RotoBaller
3 w
#9#13-
    
Peter Rogers P. Rogers
NerdBall Fantay Football NerdBall Fantay Fo...
3 w
#12#11-
    
Jacob Hubman J. Hubman
The Fantasy Headliners The Fantasy Headli...
3 w
#5#11-
    
Mike Maher M. Maher
FantasyPros FantasyPros
3 w
#8#13-
    
Blake Fincher B. Fincher
Fantasy Football Cafe Fantasy Football Cafe
3 w
#10#9-
    
Richard Cooling R. Cooling
5 Yard Rush 5 Yard Rush
3 w
#11#12-
    
Chris Meaney C. Meaney
FTN FTN
3 w
#6#15-
    
Jeff DiMatteo J. DiMatteo
Gridiron Ratings Gridiron Ratings
3 w
#11#16-
    
Wolf of Roto Street W. of Roto ...
Roto Street Journal Roto Street Journal
4 w
#8#10-
    
Travis Seel T. Seel
True North Fantasy Football True North Fantasy...
4 w
#4#13-
    
Wayne Bretsky W. Bretsky
BretskyBall BretskyBall
4 w
#10#9-
    
Mike Tagliere M. Tagliere
FantasyPros FantasyPros
4 w
#8#13-
    
Gary VanDyke G. VanDyke
Gridiron Ratings Gridiron Ratings
08/10
#5#10-
    
Jorge B. Edwards J. B. Edwards
Fantasy In Frames Fantasy In Frames
07/28
#8#15-
    
Jake Arthur J. Arthur
Sports Illustrated Sports Illustrated
07/20
#8#10-
    
Adam Pfeifer A. Pfeifer
FTN FTN
05/30
#7#10-
    
Player Game Logs Comparison
 
2021 Schedule 
Week 1 vs. DEN vs. LAC
Week 2 at WAS vs. NYG
Week 3 vs. ATL at BUF
Week 4 at NO at ATL
Week 5 at DAL vs. NO
Week 6 vs. LAR vs. KC
Week 7 vs. CAR at GB
Week 8 at KC at DEN
Week 9 vs. LVBYE WEEK
Week 10BYE WEEK vs. TB
Week 11 at TB at CAR
Week 12 vs. PHI vs. SEA
Week 13 at MIA at LV
Week 14 at LAC vs. DAL
Week 15 vs. DAL at PHI
Week 16 at PHI at DAL
Week 17 at CHI vs. PHI
Week 18 vs. WAS at NYG
Player Projections Comparison
 
Rushing
   
Rush Attempts258.4250.6
Rush Yards1,160.11,077.6
Rush TDs8.89.3
   
Receiving
   
Receptions55.545.8
Rec Yards440.4330.0
Rec TDs2.21.5
   
Points
   
Fantasy Points223.6202.4
   
Player Fantasy Points Comparison
 
2020 Points 
Week 16.64.4
Week 22.811.2
Week 310.0
Week 418.8
Week 55.1
Week 65.5
Week 718.8
Week 8
Week 99.5
Week 1018.5
Week 1116.4
Week 1231.6
Week 131.4
Week 14
Week 15
Week 166.9
Week 178.1
Week 18
Total9.4166.2
Average4.711.9
Player Targets Comparison
 
2020 Targets 
Week 192
Week 202
Week 33
Week 45
Week 55
Week 65
Week 71
Week 8
Week 93
Week 104
Week 112
Week 127
Week 130
Week 14
Week 15
Week 164
Week 171
Week 18
Notes for Player Combination
 
Expert 
Kyle Yates
FantasyPros
From a talent perspective, Saquon Barkley is the best RB in the NFL when he's on the field. Unfortunately, the issue has been staying on the field the past two seasons. Barkley has played 15 out of a possible 32 games, which makes him a very risky investment at the top of your draft. For fantasy managers to have a shot of competing deep into their playoffs, they need their top draft pick to pull their weight all season long. Earlier on in the off-season, Barkley was being drafted as a top-3 option. He's fallen a little bit in ADP, which is more in line with where he should be going. As a late first-round draft pick, the risk is worth the reward. Anything more than that and you're playing with fire.After being barely utilized as a runner in college, Gibson came out on fire in his rookie season. He averaged 4.7 YPC and 11 rushing touchdowns, which is absurd for a player who saw only 33 total carries in college. Heading into 2021, the sky's the limit for Gibson and what he can do with this experience to his name. He should receive a larger workload this upcoming season and this offense is going to be more potent due to the QB upgrade. You're going to have to pay up for Gibson and it's hard to take him over some more proven names, but this is a swing for the fences selection that has a very good chance of making it out of the park.
Mark Ringo
Sleepers and Busts
Saquon's coming off a devastating knee injury. The Giants might ease him back by limiting his touches. Even if they don't, Barkley's running style, which involves plenty of quick stops and starts isn't ideal for an ACL injury. Can he be the same RB? Will he have the same burst of acceleration that made him special? Can he stay healthy? And I speak from personal experience having torn my ACL, albeit 24 years ago. The Giants line isn't very good and the book is still out on QB Daniel Jones. Saquon is too risky in 2021 for me as an early round pick. Note- I heard a prominent fantasy analyst mention on a podcast that Wayne Gallman is Barkley's backup. She was incorrect. Gallman isn't even on the Giants anymore. The backup looks like it's going to be Devontae Booker. With regards to Saquon, let someone else take the chance. PassWell this call could make me look really smart or really foolish. Just an fyi- the smart money is on foolish haha! Antonio Gibson is still recovering from a turf toe injury he suffered in late 2020. That's a concern. If he's okay, then things could get real interesting. Coach Ron Rivera said he wants him to be more involved in the passing game (Note- he played WR in college). He came into the NFL really raw as a RB which means he could make a huge leap. Gibson is one of the few RBs with major three down upside if things break right, well assuming it's not his toe. He's big (220 lbs), fast (ran a 4.39 40 yard dash), and a natural playmaker. Can his toe hold up? That's the million dollar question? If it does, lookout! Gibbaay!
Brandon Funston
The Athletic
ACL recovery has him on track to play Week 1, though he'll likely be limited - it could take a couple weeks, but should eventually return to heavily featured roleAfter a RB13 finish as a raw rookie, it's hard not to be seduced by all the reports out of the WFT that the team is looking develop him in a CMC-like role
Zachary Hanshew
FantasyPros
It's hard to envision Barkley returning to form as a top-5 fantasy RB, especially since targets may be scarce. New York's receiving corps is crowded, and while Barkley won't fall off the map entirely, a major selling point on top-5 upside is his ability and volume as a receiver. With that volume in question, I'm a little lower on him than consensus.I'm a huge fan of Gibson and legitimately believe Washington focuses on the run game this season and gives him plenty of work. He and Taylor both have RB1 upside, and I hate to leave either of them out of the top-12, but the bottom line is there are so many talented backs in the RB10-15 range that not everyone can make the cut. This is praise for the top-12 rather than an indictment on Gibson.
Mike Tagliere
FantasyPros
After setting the fantasy world on fire his rookie season with over 2,000 yards from scrimmage and 15 touchdowns, Barkley hasn't exactly lived up to expectations producing 1,535 total yards and eight touchdowns over 15 games the last two seasons. He tore his ACL early in the season, which should give him plenty of time to bounce back, though his violent running style could take a bit longer in recovery, and he only returned to practice in late-August. The Giants suddenly have more weapons than ever in the passing game, so Barkley is unlikely to come close to the 121 targets he saw in 2018, though he should have more scoring opportunities. There is some risk with Barkley at the top of drafts due to his knee, but when on the field, we know he'll produce.I like Gibson, it's not that I don't. The issue is that he's not heavily involved in the passing game, and he topped 94 yards on the ground just twice all of last season, with both of those games coming against the Cowboys. In fact, 28.7 percent of his fantasy points in 2020 were against the Cowboys. I can certainly see Gibson finishing higher than my ranking, but those above him have either (a) a more consistent track record, or (b) less question marks. He scored a touchdown once every 15.5 carries last year, a number that's surely to go up.
Wolf of Roto Street
Roto Street Journal
Back at practice, Week 1 remains realistic. Only back w/ the upside to challenge CMacMore positive game-scripts & TD opportunities w/ Fitz, plus Scott Turner could just decide to give Gibson the full CMac bellcow treatment he so deserves. McKissic still playing third downs in the preseason is annoying, but Gibson is flashing in all facets of the game
Kevin Wheeler
The Draft Zone
Will injuries take their toll? Saquon is a great pick for re-draft, but scares me in bestball.Last season we thought Antonio Gibson would be a receiving threat out of the backfield and likely limited rushing, given his collegiate experience. Gibson's most likely utilization comps for 2021 are Jonathan Taylor and Derrick Henry with 60-70% attempts and 5-8% of targets. *If* he does take over McKissic's passing-down work - we are talking certified beast usage. McKissic seems very likely to continue his same role, but I would put Gibson's odds as more likely to keep McKissick off the field than JT is to displace Hines or Henry to spike in targets. Gibson just barely trailed McKissic in YPRR and PFF receiving grade last year. Gibson was not good in limited pass pro chances, that's where he needs to show improvement.
Brendan Tuma
FantasyPros
The good news is that by the time Week 1 rolls around, Saquon Barkley will have had a full calendar year to recover from his ACL/MCL/meniscus injury that he suffered last September. This is the fantastic as fantasy football is more fun when Barkley is healthy. The bad news? It truly sounds as if the Giants want to limit his workload early on this year, and it's tough to blame them considering Barkley is their franchise player at the moment. I'm also a tad concerned with his ultimate PPR ceiling, as Saquon benefited immensely from Eli "dumpoff" Manning back in 2018. He's still an unquestioned three-down bell cow, but I just don't expect that type of insane usage in the passing game again. Still, f antasy managers should expect Barkley's workload -- and therefore his fantasy value -- to increase as the season moves along. 
Derek Lofland
FantasyPros
Injuries capped Barkley's 2019 season and completely derailed his 2020 season as he played only two games. I love Barkley's ability, but he needs to stay healthy if he is going to realize his unlimited potential.Gibson averaged 13.2 fantasy points per game in his rookie year and he should have a lot of upside in his second year if Washington ups his usage in his second year.
Tim Petropoulos
BRoto Fantasy
Over the last two seasons, Barkley played a total of 15 games combined. The risk of injury is just too great right now for me to take him over some proven guys who stay on the field, even if he is the most talented back in the NFL.