Who Should I Draft?

Frank Gore or Toby Gerhart (2016)

Frank Gore
Frank Gore
IND - RB
 
Toby Gerhart
Toby Gerhart
FA - RB
100%
Expert Pick %
0%
24
ECR
N/A
15
Best Rank
N/A
38
Worst Rank
N/A
137.5
Ave Projection (?)
0.0
100%
Expert Pick %
0%
 

No experts recommend Toby Gerhart over Frank Gore

100%
Expert Pick %
0%
24
ECR
N/A
15
Best Rank
N/A
38
Worst Rank
N/A
137.5
Ave Projection (?)
0
198
Rush Attempts
0
784
Rush Yards
0
6
Rush TDs
0
30
Receptions
0
246
Rec Yards
0
1
Rec TDs
0
193.4
Total Points
9.7
12.1
Ave Points
1.9
5.1
Week 1
5.1
Week 2
22.4
Week 3
1.0
11.7
Week 4
-0.2
15.8
Week 5
0.2
11.4
Week 6
7.9
12.5
Week 7
0.8
12.2
Week 8
17.2
Week 9
BYE
Week 10
11.0
Week 11
5.7
Week 12
18.4
Week 13
6.9
Week 14
6.9
Week 15
23.5
Week 16
7.6
Week 17
3.6
Ave Targets / Game
1.0
58.0
Total Targets
5.0
3.0
Week 1
1.0
Week 2
2.0
Week 3
0.0
7.0
Week 4
0.0
0.0
Week 5
1.0
3.0
Week 6
4.0
8.0
Week 7
0.0
3.0
Week 8
3.0
Week 9
BYE
Week 10
5.0
Week 11
3.0
Week 12
5.0
Week 13
5.0
Week 14
2.0
Week 15
4.0
Week 16
4.0
Week 17
Gore finished last season as the #11 RB in standard formats and #14 in PPR, yet hes the 29th running back off the board. The Colts are...

- John Paulsen, 4for4.com

 
I don't have a ton of faith in Gore due to his oldness, but he played well last season in the context of an awful offensive line and no quarterback to spread the defense out. That line will get better, as their franchise quarterback was nearly beat to death, so Gore could see much better running lanes and there is a good chance he'll be the lead back once again due to the Colts not adding much in the way of competition this off season.

- Chet Gresham, WalterFootball