Alvin Kamara for Christian McCaffrey (2024)

Should I Trade... ?

Summary
Game Log
Stats
Points
Targets
Notes

Player Summaries Comparison
	Christian McCaffrey RB - SF Christian McCaffrey RB - SF	Alvin Kamara RB - NO Alvin Kamara RB - NO
Most Accurate Experts

Top ExpertsTop RB ExpertsTop Player Experts	See who the Most Accurate Experts would trade Upgrade Now

Rankings

Rest of Season	# 1	# 20	-
Draft	‐	‐	-

Matchup

Opponent	at PIT	vs. TEN	-
Matchup Rating	This is a 2 star matchup. RBs perform a little worse than their average vs PIT	This is a 3 star matchup. RBs perform close to their average vs TEN	-

Fantasy Points

Season Total	324.3	158.0	-
Avg Game	20.3	12.2	-

Schedule

SOS Rank	21	20	-

Misc

Injury Alert	‐	‐	-

Expert Ranks
	Christian McCaffrey	Alvin Kamara	Add Player

Bart Wheeler B. Wheeler Hail to Fantasy Football Hail to Fantasy Fo... 04/17	#1	#26	-

Andrew Erickson A. Erickson FantasyPros FantasyPros 04/17	#2	#28	-

Matt De Lima M. De Lima The Game Day The Game Day 04/17	#1	#19	-

Brandon Funston B. Funston The Athletic The Athletic 04/15	#1	#16	-

Scott Pianowski S. Pianowski Yahoo! Sports Yahoo! Sports 04/15	#1	#21	-

Matthew Hill M. Hill DataForce Fantasy Football DataForce Fantasy ... 04/15	#1	#27	-

Andy Behrens A. Behrens Yahoo! Sports Yahoo! Sports 01/16	#1	#21	-

Justin Weigal J. Weigal FantasySharks FantasySharks 04/12	#1	#20	-

Matt Harmon M. Harmon Yahoo! Sports Yahoo! Sports 04/12	#1	#23	-

Mark Ringo M. Ringo Sleepers and Busts Sleepers and Busts 03/14	#1	#20	-

Kevin Hanson K. Hanson EDSFootball EDSFootball 04/11	#1	#20	-

Smitty S. TheFantasyFootballShow TheFantasyFootball... 04/10	#5	#26	-

Bradley Stalder B. Stalder Player Profiler Player Profiler 01/07	#1	#16	-

Dalton Del Don D. Del Don Yahoo! Sports Yahoo! Sports 04/08	#1	#24	-

Marc Shannep M. Shannep Fantasy Knockout Fantasy Knockout 04/07	#1	#23	-

Pierre Camus P. Camus Fantasy Endgame Fantasy Endgame 04/07	#1	#30	-

Aaron Schill A. Schill FF Faceoff FF Faceoff 04/06	#1	#18	-

Kyle Soppe K. Soppe Pro Football Network Pro Football Network 04/03	#1	#21	-

Pat Fitzmaurice P. Fitzmaurice FantasyPros FantasyPros 04/03	#1	#17	-

Mauricio Gutierrez M. Gutierrez Estadio Fantasy Estadio Fantasy 04/03	#1	#20	-

Derek Brown D. Brown FantasyPros FantasyPros 01/05	#1	#18	-

Justin Fuhr J. Fuhr Pro Football Mania Pro Football Mania 04/01	#1	#19	-

Joe Pisapia J. Pisapia FantasyPros FantasyPros 03/21	#1	#20	-

Kyle Yates K. Yates Pro Football Network Pro Football Network 03/16	#1	#25	-

Site Rankings S. Rankings Gridiron Experts Gridiron Experts 03/15	#1	#22	-

Jacob Gibbs J. Gibbs SportsLine SportsLine 03/13	#1	#21	-

Aaron St Denis A. St Denis Fantasy Football Universe Fantasy Football U... 03/12	#4	#27	-

Tyler Loechner T. Loechner FTN FTN 03/11	#1	#19	-

Mike Randle M. Randle FTN FTN 03/11	#1	#18	-

Adam Pfeifer A. Pfeifer FTN FTN 03/09	#1	#20	-

Chris Meaney C. Meaney FTN FTN 04/16	#1	#20	-

Jeff Ratcliffe J. Ratcliffe FTN FTN 03/08	#1	#19	-

Kev Wheeler K. Wheeler The 33rd Team The 33rd Team 03/05	#1	#24	-

Ben Wasley B. Wasley The Fantasy First Down The Fantasy First ... 03/04	#1	#19	-

Sky Guasco S. Guasco Razzball Razzball 03/01	#1	#20	-

Lee Wehry L. Wehry FantasyPros FantasyPros 02/21	#1	#19	-

Craig Phillips C. Phillips FF Prophet FF Prophet 01/23	#1	#18	-

Jorge B. Edwards J. B. Edwards Fantasy In Frames Fantasy In Frames 01/13	#1	#18	-

Tera Roberts T. Roberts Dynasty Vipers Dynasty Vipers 01/12	#1	#17	-

Kevin Steele K. Steele The Fantasy Authority The Fantasy Authority 01/11	#2	#18	-

Matt Donnelly M. Donnelly Dynasty Vipers Dynasty Vipers 01/09	#1	#18	-

Player Game Logs Comparison
	Christian McCaffrey RB - SF Christian McCaffrey RB - SF	Alvin Kamara RB - NO Alvin Kamara RB - NO
2023 Schedule
Week 1	at PIT	vs. TEN
Week 2	at LAR	at CAR
Week 3	vs. NYG	at GB
Week 4	vs. ARI	vs. TB
Week 5	vs. DAL	at NE
Week 6	at CLE	at HOU
Week 7	at MIN	vs. JAC
Week 8	vs. CIN	at IND
Week 9	BYE WEEK	vs. CHI
Week 10	at JAC	at MIN
Week 11	vs. TB	BYE WEEK
Week 12	at SEA	at ATL
Week 13	at PHI	vs. DET
Week 14	vs. SEA	vs. CAR
Week 15	at ARI	vs. NYG
Week 16	vs. BAL	at LAR
Week 17	at WAS	at TB
Week 18	vs. LAR	vs. ATL

Player Fantasy Points Comparison
	Christian McCaffrey RB - SF Christian McCaffrey RB - SF	Alvin Kamara RB - NO Alvin Kamara RB - NO
2023 Points
Week 1	22.9	‐
Week 2	19.5	‐
Week 3	17.9	‐
Week 4	41.7	8.4
Week 5	11.8	15.7
Week 6	11.2	10.4
Week 7	19.6	17.3
Week 8	23.8	23.0
Week 9	‐	7.0
Week 10	14.2	11.5
Week 11	16.3	‐
Week 12	25.9	11.9
Week 13	19.3	22.9
Week 14	15.3	10.5
Week 15	36.7	11.0
Week 16	19.1	3.5
Week 17	9.1	4.9
Week 18	‐	‐
Total	324.3	158.0
Average	20.3	12.2

Player Targets Comparison
	Christian McCaffrey RB - SF Christian McCaffrey RB - SF	Alvin Kamara RB - NO Alvin Kamara RB - NO
2023 Targets
Week 1	5	‐
Week 2	3	‐
Week 3	5	‐
Week 4	8	14
Week 5	3	3
Week 6	3	8
Week 7	3	14
Week 8	7	5
Week 9	‐	5
Week 10	10	7
Week 11	5	‐
Week 12	6	5
Week 13	4	8
Week 14	1	4
Week 15	5	5
Week 16	10	6
Week 17	5	2
Week 18	‐	‐

Notes for Player Combination
	Christian McCaffrey RB - SF Christian McCaffrey RB - SF	Alvin Kamara RB - NO Alvin Kamara RB - NO
Expert
Derek Brown FantasyPros	McCaffrey remained "THE DUDE" at running back in fantasy last year. He was the RB1 in fantasy, finishing as an RB1 in 81% of his games and as a top 24 RB in every game he played. McCaffrey averaged 21.2 touches and 126.5 total yards per game while ranking second in carries, fourth in targets, and first in red zone touches among running backs. There's no reason to expect a falloff entering 2024. His deeper efficiency metrics all scream that he remains in the prime of his career after ranking fourth in explosive run rate and 10th in yards after contact last season (per Fantasy Points Data).	Alvin Kamara retained his every-down role last year despite the team drafting Kendre Miller. Miller spent most of his rookie season on the injury report, so we'll see if Kamara can hold him off in 2024, but at least expect Kamara to be a workhorse (maybe not a bellcow). Last year, Kamara was tenth in opportunity share, eighth in weighed opportunities, and ninth in red zone touches. While Karmara's rushing prowess took another massive hit (40th out of 49 qualifying backs in missed tackles forced per attempt per Fantasy Points Data), his receiving chops remained strong. Last year, out of 60 qualifying backs, he ranked first in target share (18.1%) and sixth in yards per route run. Kamara might not have the same bounce in his step as he did during the Drew Brees era, but his pass game and high-leverage usage in 2024 should keep him firmly planted in the RB1 ranks.