2012 Fantasy Baseball Rankings

ECR™ | Expert Consensus Ranking
Mixed League | AL Only | NL Only
Discuss

Overall Rankings: Consensus of 25 Experts [ edit experts ]

Rank Player Name Team Best Worst Ave Std Dev
1 Miguel Cabrera DET 1 4 1.5 0.9
2 Albert Pujols LAA 1 5 2.5 0.9
3 Matt Kemp LAD 1 7 2.7 1.6
4 Jose Bautista TOR 2 20 5.6 3.5
5 Troy Tulowitzki COL 3 15 5.7 2.6
6 Joey Votto CIN 3 17 7.0 2.9
7 Robinson Cano NYY 6 15 8.9 2.5
8 Adrian Gonzalez BOS 4 19 9.8 3.2
9 Jacoby Ellsbury BOS 5 19 10.0 4.0
10 Justin Upton ARI 6 20 10.7 3.5
11 Evan Longoria TB 7 23 12.4 4.0
12 Prince Fielder DET 5 25 13.3 4.5
13 Carlos Gonzalez COL 7 21 13.5 3.9
14 Clayton Kershaw LAD 3 23 14.8 5.3
15 Dustin Pedroia BOS 9 29 15.5 4.3
16 Roy Halladay PHI 2 27 15.8 5.5
17 Justin Verlander DET 6 38 16.3 6.2
18 Curtis Granderson NYY 8 43 19.3 7.0
19 Ian Kinsler TEX 6 30 19.7 5.4
20 Hanley Ramirez MIA 11 57 20.5 8.9
21 Cliff Lee PHI 5 34 21.3 5.8
22 Mark Teixeira NYY 7 32 23.1 4.9
23 Jose Reyes MIA 13 49 24.3 10.0
24 Mike Stanton MIA 13 67 25.5 10.2
25 Andrew McCutchen PIT 22 51 26.8 6.0
26 Felix Hernandez SEA 20 44 29.4 5.5
27 Tim Lincecum SF 16 50 29.6 6.6
28 CC Sabathia NYY 13 43 30.5 6.1
29 Adrian Beltre TEX 14 59 31.1 12.0
30 David Wright NYM 21 75 32.6 12.7
31 Cole Hamels PHI 14 54 34.4 8.8
32 Josh Hamilton TEX 23 49 35.3 7.2
33 Jered Weaver LAA 19 60 35.3 10.3
34 Matt Holliday STL 25 56 36.0 7.0
35 Carlos Santana CLE 16 69 38.2 11.0
36 Ryan Zimmerman WSH 27 67 38.4 8.7
37 Hunter Pence PHI 23 76 39.8 11.7
38 Mike Napoli TEX 26 74 41.7 11.1
39 Dan Haren LAA 18 79 42.4 12.4
40 Zack Greinke MIL 17 71 43.4 11.9
41 Starlin Castro CHC 24 83 46.5 13.5
42 Paul Konerko CWS 33 95 47.4 15.9
43 Jay Bruce CIN 30 88 48.8 14.5
44 Pablo Sandoval SF 31 69 49.0 12.2
45 Nelson Cruz TEX 29 98 49.4 16.5
46 David Price TB 33 75 50.0 8.5
47 Dan Uggla ATL 26 102 50.8 14.7
48 Eric Hosmer KC 28 106 54.4 16.4
49 Desmond Jennings TB 28 104 54.8 18.0
50 Matt Cain SF 39 100 56.1 12.1
51 Brian McCann ATL 40 75 56.5 10.2
52 Michael Young TEX 25 98 56.7 17.4
53 Elvis Andrus TEX 32 108 56.9 19.3
54 Brandon Phillips CIN 32 103 57.3 13.4
55 Ben Zobrist TB 41 99 58.5 14.1
56 Brett Lawrie TOR 27 90 52.6 16.3
57 Stephen Strasburg WSH 21 99 59.7 17.9
58 Alex Rodriguez NYY 37 109 60.3 14.7
59 Craig Kimbrel ATL 21 87 60.6 14.6
60 Jon Lester BOS 38 122 61.5 16.4
61 Ryan Braun MIL 35 125 61.9 25.7
62 Michael Bourn ATL 34 91 64.2 15.3
63 Yovani Gallardo MIL 36 93 64.3 14.8
64 Alex Gordon KC 42 87 64.3 14.2
65 Michael Morse WSH 38 82 64.2 11.6
66 Kevin Youkilis BOS 44 204 72.0 31.4
67 Ian Kennedy ARI 34 99 72.0 14.7
68 Asdrubal Cabrera CLE 42 90 66.9 10.9
69 B.J. Upton TB 49 98 72.6 13.4
70 Shane Victorino PHI 50 105 70.3 12.6
71 James Shields TB 35 139 77.2 18.5
72 Lance Berkman STL 51 122 73.9 14.2
73 C.J. Wilson LAA 22 97 74.0 16.2
74 Shin-Soo Choo CLE 50 121 74.7 13.5
75 Chase Utley PHI 47 150 75.7 26.7
76 Aramis Ramirez MIL 58 143 81.0 18.0
77 Rickie Weeks MIL 57 100 72.0 12.1
78 Buster Posey SF 47 127 80.7 19.5
79 Carl Crawford BOS 36 142 75.6 23.8
80 Madison Bumgarner SF 47 98 76.0 13.7
81 Jimmy Rollins PHI 49 115 77.0 15.1
82 Corey Hart MIL 62 112 84.4 11.7
83 Mariano Rivera NYY 63 110 88.7 13.8
84 Howard Kendrick LAA 51 124 84.0 17.5
85 Tommy Hanson ATL 38 136 88.4 23.1
86 Adam Jones BAL 58 118 83.4 14.9
87 Jonathan Papelbon PHI 64 113 91.6 11.4
88 Yu Darvish TEX 69 127 92.4 15.0
89 John Axford MIL 66 146 91.3 16.9
90 Joe Mauer MIN 47 132 86.9 22.2
91 Daniel Hudson ARI 62 130 94.0 13.9
92 Brett Gardner NYY 52 127 90.2 17.3
93 Josh Johnson MIA 43 234 97.7 38.4
94 Drew Storen WSH 61 160 101.2 20.0
95 Matt Wieters BAL 54 119 86.9 15.7
96 Michael Cuddyer COL 49 170 99.9 26.1
97 Matt Moore TB 67 145 93.2 17.9
98 Mat Latos CIN 46 105 89.3 16.8
99 Adam Wainwright STL 35 150 89.6 24.0
100 Jason Heyward ATL 51 184 97.5 28.3
101 Drew Stubbs CIN 67 137 101.2 18.2
102 Michael Pineda NYY 59 114 92.6 12.7
103 Nick Markakis BAL 44 145 102.5 27.7
104 Matt Garza CHC 47 147 101.1 22.0
105 Ryan Howard PHI 67 249 115.8 45.6
106 Jayson Werth WSH 63 145 110.4 23.4
107 Billy Butler KC 38 135 98.7 22.4
108 Brandon Beachy ATL 80 161 109.4 21.2
109 David Ortiz BOS 40 132 91.4 23.4
110 Miguel Montero ARI 53 129 103.9 19.8
111 Carlos Beltran STL 79 199 111.5 27.0
112 Gio Gonzalez WSH 45 202 112.4 34.0
113 Ichiro Suzuki SEA 47 162 106.6 30.6
114 Ricky Romero TOR 81 166 113.1 23.0
115 Derek Jeter NYY 66 179 114.1 27.3
116 Brian Wilson SF 86 199 118.6 26.1
117 Josh Beckett BOS 50 200 113.2 31.8
118 Heath Bell MIA 56 175 119.5 32.0
119 Alexei Ramirez CWS 88 141 112.2 18.1
120 Jesus Montero SEA 42 188 109.8 33.7
121 Ryan Madson CIN 94 152 123.5 19.4
122 Dee Gordon LAD 84 185 123.8 23.6
123 Freddie Freeman ATL 72 148 111.3 18.6
124 Chris Carpenter STL 74 146 121.8 22.0
125 Cory Luebke SD 71 173 123.2 28.5
126 Alex Avila DET 43 164 117.7 27.8
127 Dustin Ackley SEA 96 171 129.9 19.9
128 Andre Ethier LAD 69 174 124.6 24.6
129 Logan Morrison MIA 77 219 129.0 38.5
130 Ike Davis NYM 85 208 133.6 33.7
131 Jason Kipnis CLE 62 250 128.5 50.4
132 Jordan Zimmermann WSH 81 195 124.5 26.3
133 Cameron Maybin SD 82 175 127.6 24.2
134 Mark Reynolds BAL 96 156 128.8 16.5
135 Emilio Bonifacio MIA 87 214 146.1 41.1
136 Andrew Bailey BOS 91 195 142.9 27.3
137 J.J. Putz ARI 112 171 135.1 19.9
138 Paul Goldschmidt ARI 87 244 147.9 38.1
139 Anibal Sanchez MIA 94 193 136.9 24.8
140 Neil Walker PIT 94 187 142.4 22.1
141 Chris B. Young ARI 94 150 118.0 18.0
142 Ubaldo Jimenez CLE 91 206 145.1 29.9
143 Jose Valverde DET 104 177 141.4 22.6
144 Max Scherzer DET 55 228 148.8 39.1
145 Jeremy Hellickson TB 84 239 153.8 39.0
146 Joel Hanrahan PIT 119 174 142.5 21.6
147 J.J. Hardy BAL 111 184 148.8 24.0
148 Shaun Marcum MIL 116 197 149.0 25.4
149 Brandon Morrow TOR 81 222 155.4 33.7
150 Nick Swisher NYY 101 172 151.5 19.6
151 Adam Lind TOR 117 250 160.3 43.1
152 Johnny Cueto CIN 95 213 151.1 29.1
153 Erick Aybar LAA 128 188 154.6 18.9
154 Torii Hunter LAA 96 258 164.8 47.5
155 Tim Hudson ATL 92 214 157.3 36.1
156 Jemile Weeks OAK 112 202 152.5 23.1
157 Danny Espinosa WSH 87 191 157.1 30.0
158 Jaime Garcia STL 86 207 161.2 30.5
159 Jhonny Peralta DET 106 228 159.6 31.5
160 Rafael Betancourt COL 114 189 158.2 20.4
161 Ervin Santana LAA 96 244 164.6 41.7
162 Coco Crisp OAK 138 190 160.3 16.8
163 Melky Cabrera SF 113 250 163.5 34.2
164 Neftali Feliz TEX 123 245 162.9 34.8
165 Jeff Francoeur KC 129 225 168.5 27.0
166 Sergio Santos TOR 134 216 167.7 26.0
167 Joakim Soria KC 126 206 168.0 22.3
168 Jason Motte STL 131 197 168.0 21.6
169 Martin Prado ATL 124 205 166.1 23.8
170 Yadier Molina STL 94 231 174.6 36.8
171 Carlos Lee HOU 99 231 171.0 34.5
172 Mark Trumbo LAA 86 264 182.8 52.1
173 Carlos Marmol CHC 106 206 172.3 27.3
174 Jordan Walden LAA 140 233 173.1 25.5
175 Doug Fister DET 108 228 166.9 33.1
176 Ryan Roberts ARI 123 227 173.6 25.9
177 Matt Joyce TB 151 220 176.5 22.0
178 Kendrys Morales LAA 130 248 181.2 38.0
179 David Freese STL 119 216 176.2 27.3
180 Kenley Jansen LAD 118 236 179.9 35.2
181 Mike Moustakas KC 130 231 179.3 29.0
182 Gaby Sanchez MIA 117 201 172.9 22.7
183 Hiroki Kuroda NYY 140 208 174.1 20.2
184 Wandy Rodriguez HOU 138 210 175.1 18.5
185 Peter Bourjos LAA 143 238 181.4 25.4
186 Joe Nathan TEX 143 201 177.2 18.4
187 Colby Lewis TEX 95 247 185.3 38.3
188 Kelly Johnson TOR 159 238 182.7 21.4
189 Chris Sale CWS 144 220 182.1 19.7
190 Huston Street SD 145 241 189.2 27.5
191 Daniel Bard BOS 104 262 194.9 51.8
192 Josh Willingham MIN 133 218 185.5 23.9
193 Angel Pagan SF 159 208 177.9 17.5
194 Alejandro De Aza CWS 111 295 201.8 56.1
195 Russell Martin NYY 117 286 212.6 57.1
196 Austin Jackson DET 145 256 194.7 38.1
197 Ted Lilly LAD 152 255 189.0 35.4
198 J.P. Arencibia TOR 126 296 208.9 55.0
199 Victor Martinez DET 90 135 112.5 22.5
200 Jhoulys Chacin COL 156 238 190.6 28.0
201 Wilson Ramos WSH 147 260 196.5 39.9
202 Seth Smith OAK 125 287 199.6 52.0
203 Geovany Soto CHC 130 280 208.7 47.9
204 Jose Tabata PIT 141 283 205.5 40.9
205 Stephen Drew ARI 141 251 193.7 28.4
206 Brandon McCarthy OAK 151 238 196.0 24.1
207 Vance Worley PHI 155 249 194.1 29.1
208 Chase Headley SD 163 250 202.9 30.2
209 Derek Holland TEX 169 244 201.0 25.0
210 Justin Masterson CLE 158 291 207.4 38.2
211 Brandon League SEA 182 236 198.1 19.3
212 Clay Buchholz BOS 163 264 209.7 30.9
213 Colby Rasmus TOR 157 291 207.7 36.0
214 Dexter Fowler COL 166 281 222.2 38.5
215 Yunel Escobar TOR 171 208 192.9 13.4
216 Kyle Farnsworth TB 163 242 205.2 23.8
217 Daniel Murphy NYM 141 283 235.4 44.9
218 Roy Oswalt PHI 179 247 200.4 20.0
219 John Danks CWS 162 223 195.4 19.5
220 J.D. Martinez HOU 152 260 223.2 42.5
221 Brandon Belt SF 158 242 205.1 25.0
222 James Loney LAD 157 257 217.6 33.8
223 Scott Baker MIN 157 235 204.0 22.4
224 Edwin Encarnacion TOR 159 267 217.9 31.4
225 Lucas Duda NYM 174 249 210.1 23.4
226 Chris Perez CLE 151 239 215.0 26.4
227 Marco Scutaro COL 169 295 225.0 41.9
228 Ben Revere MIN 157 259 215.6 32.0
229 Delmon Young DET 160 251 209.1 24.9
230 Alex Rios CWS 169 293 218.7 39.1
231 Matt Thornton CWS 171 274 214.5 32.4
232 Carlos Pena TB 178 275 218.4 32.7
233 Yonder Alonso SD 176 281 218.1 34.0
234 Bud Norris HOU 164 293 237.2 39.2
235 Brennan Boesch DET 162 261 222.4 27.0
236 Carlos Quentin SD 177 251 218.4 23.7
237 Lorenzo Cain KC 181 241 209.0 22.8
238 Tim Stauffer SD 181 301 222.7 37.7
239 Mike Carp SEA 167 240 210.0 28.0
240 Adam Dunn CWS 170 219 197.0 17.5
241 Dayan Viciedo CWS 176 280 223.3 32.2
242 Trevor Cahill ARI 181 282 227.9 34.2
243 Rafael Furcal STL 174 297 234.3 51.1
244 Yoenis Cespedes OAK 181 241 203.6 20.6
245 Allen Craig STL 172 296 242.8 45.4
246 Aaron Hill ARI 183 276 216.8 27.6
247 Jose Altuve HOU 176 276 235.0 33.7
248 Luke Hochevar KC 180 269 224.5 44.5
249 Jair Jurrjens ATL 184 255 218.5 21.5
250 Ryan Dempster CHC 181 313 239.6 38.1
251 Alex Presley PIT 181 290 245.0 40.1
252 Justin Morneau MIN 191 272 226.1 25.8
253 Aroldis Chapman CIN 184 236 217.0 19.8
254 Chad Billingsley LAD 185 304 238.4 32.3
255 Sergio Romo SF 187 305 261.2 40.5
256 Vernon Wells LAA 195 286 229.8 34.4
257 Gavin Floyd CWS 193 265 229.4 22.8
258 Henderson Alvarez TOR 193 254 233.5 23.8
259 Mike Minor ATL 195 291 247.7 31.7
260 Kurt Suzuki OAK 195 259 232.8 23.0
261 Salvador Perez KC 196 290 243.0 47.0
262 Edwin Jackson STL 197 274 240.3 24.4
263 Bryce Harper WSH 198 243 217.8 19.3
264 Addison Reed CWS 198 275 236.5 38.5
265 Ryan Vogelsong SF 199 275 233.7 29.9
266 Jason Kubel ARI 199 252 223.6 20.5
267 Frank Francisco NYM 200 263 225.9 18.8
268 Jon Jay STL 201 308 246.8 39.0
269 Alexi Ogando TEX 202 298 254.3 35.0
270 Jonathan LuCroy MIL 204 292 248.0 44.0
271 Jim Johnson BAL 204 274 236.0 19.3
272 Michael Brantley CLE 205 284 256.8 32.1
273 Matt Capps MIN 205 263 240.1 20.2
274 Francisco Liriano MIN 207 311 259.5 36.8
275 Mike Trout LAA 207 233 220.0 11.0
276 Jason Bay NYM 209 274 255.0 26.8
277 Juan Nicasio COL 209 250 229.5 20.5
278 Jonathon Niese NYM 210 264 237.0 22.0
279 Javy Guerra LAD 211 299 250.5 29.0
280 Tyler Clippard WSH 211 286 251.0 26.7
281 Jonny Venters ATL 212 307 251.1 32.1
282 Ian Desmond WSH 212 291 252.8 22.5
283 Mat Gamel MIL 213 265 241.5 19.0
284 R.A. Dickey NYM 214 288 246.6 24.5
285 Johnny Damon FA214 280 249.6 23.8
286 Koji Uehara TEX 215 256 235.5 20.5
287 Josh Collmenter ARI 216 266 239.0 20.6
288 Alcides Escobar KC 218 303 261.8 30.6
289 David Robertson NYY 219 264 241.5 22.5
290 Javier Vazquez MIA 220 270 245.0 25.0
291 Ricky Nolasco MIA 220 262 236.2 16.0
292 Bobby Abreu LAA 221 298 255.5 28.4
293 Todd Helton COL 221 297 266.7 32.9
294 Jonathan Sanchez KC 221 285 253.2 23.9
295 Aaron Crow KC 221 272 254.7 23.8
296 Ryan Doumit MIN 222 288 267.4 26.1
297 Lonnie Chisenhall CLE 222 287 247.5 26.8
298 Devin Mesoraco CIN 222 262 242.0 20.0
299 Grant Balfour OAK 223 268 239.3 14.9
300 Jeff Niemann TB 224 294 258.0 28.6
301 Mike Leake CIN 225 314 257.8 33.6
302 John Mayberry PHI 225 295 271.3 32.8
303 Mike Adams TEX 225 284 254.3 21.5
304 Denard Span MIN 226 300 255.3 28.0
305 John Buck MIA 226 299 262.5 36.5
306 Josh Reddick OAK 226 277 251.5 25.5
307 Erik Bedard PIT 227 298 270.6 25.2
308 Jarrod Saltalamacchia BOS 227 294 260.5 33.5
309 Mitch Moreland TEX 227 275 247.0 20.4
310 Danny Valencia MIN 229 289 262.7 25.0
311 Chris Iannetta LAA 229 278 253.5 24.5
312 Johan Santana NYM 230 289 259.0 24.1
313 Travis Hafner CLE 230 288 259.0 29.0
314 Vinnie Pestano CLE 232 253 242.5 10.5
315 Chipper Jones ATL 233 269 252.5 12.1
316 Philip Humber CWS 236 300 268.0 32.0
317 Nolan Reimold BAL 237 288 262.5 25.5
318 Gordon Beckham CWS 239 283 261.0 22.0
319 Homer Bailey CIN 240 299 276.5 23.8
320 Nyjer Morgan MIL 240 295 269.0 22.6
321 Omar Infante MIA 242 247 244.5 2.5
322 Sean Marshall CIN 246 315 278.0 28.4
323 Pedro Alvarez PIT 248 310 280.0 25.4
324 Joaquin Benoit DET 248 296 272.0 24.0
325 Mark Buehrle MIA 248 290 267.0 17.2
326 Derrek Lee PIT 249 299 277.5 15.1
327 Johnny Giavotella KC 251 278 265.3 11.1
328 Greg Holland KC 255 295 275.0 20.0
329 Brett Myers HOU 258 312 291.8 20.3
330 Fernando Salas STL 258 297 277.0 15.9
331 Edinson Volquez SD 260 286 273.0 13.0
332 Cliff Pennington OAK 261 296 281.6 11.4
333 Ivan Nova NYY 261 293 280.0 13.0
334 Randy Wolf MIL 262 280 271.0 9.0
335 Zack Cozart CIN 265 300 277.3 16.0
336 Brian Fuentes OAK 265 291 278.0 13.0
337 Vladimir Guerrero BAL 266 292 279.0 9.4
338 Jake Peavy CWS 269 302 283.0 12.4
339 Alfonso Soriano CHC 269 281 275.4 4.9
340 Placido Polanco PHI 272 292 282.0 10.0
341 Jason Bourgeois HOU 278 293 287.0 6.5
342 Rajai Davis TOR 281 289 285.0 4.0
343 Will Venable SD 287 300 295.0 5.7
344 Brent Morel CWS 293 309 301.0 8.0
345 Marlon Byrd CHC 294 298 296.0 2.0