2012 Fantasy Baseball Rankings

ECR™ | Expert Consensus Ranking
Mixed League | AL Only | NL Only
Discuss

Starting Pitchers Rankings: Consensus of 31 Experts [ edit experts ]

Rank Player Name Team Best Worst Ave Std Dev
1 Clayton Kershaw LAD 1 4 1.9 0.9
2 Roy Halladay PHI 1 6 2.1 1.0
3 Justin Verlander DET 1 7 2.4 1.3
4 Cliff Lee PHI 2 10 4.2 1.4
5 Felix Hernandez SEA 4 17 6.3 2.3
6 Tim Lincecum SF 4 13 6.6 2.1
7 CC Sabathia NYY 5 12 7.3 1.7
8 Jered Weaver LAA 5 14 8.4 2.4
9 Cole Hamels PHI 6 14 8.7 2.0
10 Zack Greinke MIL 4 16 10.6 2.6
11 Dan Haren LAA 8 17 11.0 2.3
12 David Price TB 6 18 12.1 2.2
13 Matt Cain SF 9 27 15.2 3.8
14 Stephen Strasburg WSH 5 25 15.3 5.0
15 Jon Lester BOS 10 28 15.5 4.1
16 Yovani Gallardo MIL 11 25 16.3 3.3
17 C.J. Wilson LAA 10 26 19.1 3.4
18 Ian Kennedy ARI 12 26 19.1 3.4
19 Madison Bumgarner SF 10 45 20.4 6.2
20 James Shields TB 14 34 20.9 5.3
21 Tommy Hanson ATL 10 34 23.7 6.1
22 Michael Pineda NYY 17 57 24.9 7.1
23 Josh Johnson MIA 12 55 25.7 8.6
24 Adam Wainwright STL 11 44 26.0 6.5
25 Mat Latos CIN 13 43 26.5 6.7
26 Yu Darvish TEX 17 43 26.8 5.7
27 Daniel Hudson ARI 16 34 25.3 3.9
28 Josh Beckett BOS 14 44 28.9 5.9
29 Matt Garza CHC 20 36 29.9 3.9
30 Brandon Beachy ATL 15 45 30.1 6.4
31 Ricky Romero TOR 20 46 30.2 5.8
32 Matt Moore TB 16 64 27.9 10.0
33 Gio Gonzalez WSH 18 53 31.5 7.2
34 Chris Carpenter STL 19 42 33.4 5.8
35 Jordan Zimmermann WSH 24 71 35.8 8.5
36 Cory Luebke SD 19 70 37.9 9.2
37 Anibal Sanchez MIA 27 69 38.9 7.4
38 Shaun Marcum MIL 30 53 38.5 4.6
39 Brandon Morrow TOR 19 66 40.6 8.5
40 Johnny Cueto CIN 24 63 40.6 8.2
41 Ubaldo Jimenez CLE 30 56 41.1 5.6
42 Jeremy Hellickson TB 23 72 42.5 8.4
43 Max Scherzer DET 28 68 42.6 7.6
44 Tim Hudson ATL 20 68 42.4 9.7
45 Jaime Garcia STL 25 55 44.1 5.5
46 Hiroki Kuroda NYY 32 61 46.1 5.7
47 Ervin Santana LAA 34 63 46.6 6.1
48 Doug Fister DET 26 63 47.8 8.1
49 Derek Holland TEX 37 96 52.5 12.1
50 Jhoulys Chacin COL 36 67 52.6 7.7
51 Wandy Rodriguez HOU 40 83 51.2 8.4
52 Colby Lewis TEX 35 65 53.0 8.2
53 Clay Buchholz BOS 32 73 53.8 8.8
54 John Danks CWS 37 69 56.4 8.4
55 Ted Lilly LAD 37 74 55.1 9.3
56 Ryan Dempster CHC 37 101 61.9 15.8
57 Justin Masterson CLE 41 87 56.0 9.8
58 Trevor Cahill ARI 36 84 59.9 11.0
59 Brandon McCarthy OAK 38 80 56.5 9.6
60 Scott Baker MIN 31 73 58.3 8.8
61 Bud Norris HOU 40 82 60.2 10.4
62 Jair Jurrjens ATL 35 77 58.2 8.8
63 Alexi Ogando TEX 47 122 66.8 21.9
64 Roy Oswalt PHI 41 78 59.1 7.5
65 Chad Billingsley LAD 45 95 68.2 12.0
66 Vance Worley PHI 45 74 61.8 8.3
67 Erik Bedard PIT 48 114 69.9 15.8
68 Luke Hochevar KC 44 163 85.1 33.1
69 Ryan Vogelsong SF 44 97 71.3 12.8
70 Francisco Liriano MIN 45 135 81.4 23.5
71 Tim Stauffer SD 47 79 64.1 8.7
72 R.A. Dickey NYM 46 102 75.4 13.4
73 Henderson Alvarez TOR 50 115 81.5 16.1
74 Edwin Jackson STL 50 97 68.2 12.2
75 Javier Vazquez MIA 50 94 70.1 14.2
76 Edinson Volquez SD 51 149 78.8 28.7
77 Ricky Nolasco MIA 52 114 72.5 16.4
78 Mike Minor ATL 54 125 71.1 17.7
79 Ivan Nova NYY 55 100 77.0 13.2
80 Gavin Floyd CWS 57 79 66.8 6.4
81 Juan Nicasio COL 58 126 88.3 21.0
82 Mike Leake CIN 58 92 76.4 8.6
83 Jonathon Niese NYM 58 92 72.7 10.5
84 Johan Santana NYM 58 91 72.9 9.3
85 Brett Myers HOU 60 99 83.1 12.0
86 Jake Peavy CWS 60 93 79.8 8.2
87 Jonathan Sanchez KC 61 92 73.4 8.5
88 Philip Humber CWS 62 117 92.0 18.5
89 Josh Collmenter ARI 62 108 81.0 12.8
90 Jeff Niemann TB 63 107 82.2 15.9
91 Mark Buehrle MIA 63 95 78.0 8.9
92 Aaron Harang LAD 64 134 111.0 24.6
93 Homer Bailey CIN 65 91 76.2 7.2
94 Felipe Paulino KC 66 143 111.4 25.3
95 Bronson Arroyo CIN 66 114 96.4 17.5
96 Phil Hughes NYY 68 141 89.8 23.7
97 Brad Peacock OAK 68 134 99.6 21.3
98 Randy Wolf MIL 70 106 90.0 12.7
99 Matt Harrison TEX 71 128 91.4 16.6
100 Carlos Zambrano MIA 72 121 91.5 15.4
101 Wade Davis TB 73 146 97.7 23.6
102 Julio Teheran ATL 73 137 94.3 21.9
103 Chris Capuano LAD 73 106 85.8 10.0
104 Rick Porcello DET 74 140 103.9 21.4
105 Alfredo Aceves BOS 74 113 93.5 19.5
106 James McDonald PIT 75 148 107.3 23.5
107 Drew Pomeranz COL 76 145 105.4 23.0
108 Hisashi Iwakuma SEA 77 131 95.4 18.9
109 Dallas Braden OAK 77 116 99.6 14.5
110 Jarrod Parker OAK 78 144 107.0 20.3
111 Wei-Yin Chen BAL 80 138 102.6 20.0
112 Bartolo Colon OAK 81 94 86.4 4.6
113 A.J. Burnett NYY 82 127 109.5 15.1
114 Zach Britton BAL 84 155 100.0 23.1
115 Brett Cecil TOR 86 148 112.0 20.2
116 Randall Delgado ATL 87 159 133.3 32.8
117 Bruce Chen KC 87 136 113.5 18.7
118 Guillermo Moscoso COL 87 132 116.0 20.5
119 Kyle Lohse STL 88 118 102.8 10.0
120 Josh Tomlin CLE 88 112 101.3 8.2
121 Jacob Turner DET 89 153 119.0 29.7
122 Tsuyoshi Wada BAL 92 150 113.3 26.0
123 Carl Pavano MIN 92 130 108.3 14.8
124 Jason Vargas SEA 92 115 100.3 7.9
125 Jeremy Guthrie BAL 93 114 102.0 6.9
126 Travis Wood CHC 94 144 123.0 19.4
127 Chris Narveson MIL 95 135 108.2 14.7
128 Clayton Richard SD 98 143 120.3 20.8
129 Randy Wells CHC 99 156 124.5 23.7
130 Danny Duffy KC 100 155 126.8 20.7
131 Joe Blanton PHI 103 128 112.8 9.5
132 Dillon Gee NYM 104 137 119.6 11.8
133 Tom Milone OAK 105 135 118.5 10.8
134 Jeff Karstens PIT 108 132 120.5 8.8
135 Chien-Ming Wang WSH 110 170 140.0 30.0
136 Alex Cobb TB 110 155 131.7 18.4
137 Paul Maholm CHC 110 149 132.0 13.6
138 Brett Anderson OAK 110 120 115.0 5.0
139 Kyle Drabek TOR 112 201 159.0 31.7
140 Jake Arrieta BAL 112 168 140.0 19.8
141 Alex White COL 113 172 144.0 24.2
142 Freddy Garcia NYY 114 132 122.0 6.6
143 Jerome Williams LAA 117 182 139.3 30.2
144 Dustin Moseley SD 118 144 133.0 10.3
145 Joe Saunders ARI 118 138 126.0 7.6
146 Jorge De La Rosa COL 118 127 123.0 3.7
147 Kevin Millwood SEA 119 190 154.5 35.5
148 Charlie Morton PIT 119 177 153.0 23.9
149 Kevin Slowey CLE 120 194 156.0 30.2
150 Chris Volstad CHC 120 165 142.8 16.0
151 Nick Blackburn MIN 122 205 159.8 27.5
152 Blake Beavan SEA 122 152 136.8 11.1
153 John Lannan WSH 123 179 144.3 22.7
154 Jordan Lyles HOU 123 147 138.5 9.8
155 Brian Matusz BAL 123 145 131.3 9.7
156 Brian Duensing MIN 124 175 145.0 21.8
157 Fausto Carmona CLE 125 161 140.0 14.2
158 Barry Zito SF 128 162 137.8 14.1
159 J.A. Happ HOU 129 186 157.5 28.5
160 Marco Estrada MIL 130 154 142.0 12.0
161 Jake Westbrook STL 131 157 144.7 10.7
162 Derek Lowe CLE 133 158 146.8 9.0
163 Dustin McGowan TOR 134 176 153.0 15.0
164 Jason Hammel COL 135 213 173.7 31.8
165 Mike Pelfrey NYM 136 170 153.0 13.9
166 Alex Sanabia MIA 137 203 170.0 33.0
167 Charlie Furbush SEA 139 150 144.5 5.5
168 Tommy Hunter BAL 142 209 164.3 31.6
169 Kevin Correia PIT 143 188 161.3 17.7
170 Carlos Villanueva TOR 143 149 146.0 3.0
171 Brad Lincoln PIT 147 167 160.0 9.2
172 Ross Detwiler WSH 149 189 169.0 20.0
173 Jason Marquis MIN 156 232 194.0 38.0
174 Livan Hernandez WSH 160 169 164.5 4.5
175 Sean O'Sullivan KC 177 244 210.5 33.5