Who Should I Draft? Bijan Robinson or Jahmyr Gibbs (Fantasy Football)

Who should I draft? It’s a question fantasy football managers ask regularly this time of year. Whether you’re going through a fantasy football mock draft to prepare for the real deal or you are live on draft day mulling over how to build your team, it’s one of the most important questions to answer. We have you covered with our Who Should I Draft tool which gives you advice based on 100+ expert rankings. Let’s take a look at who the fantasy football experts are drafting: Bijan Robinson or Jahmyr Gibbs.

2026 Fantasy Football Advice: Who Should I Draft? (Bijan Robinson or Jahmyr Gibbs)

Here are how the fantasy football expert consensus leans as of Thursday, 8/13.

Who Should I Draft: Bijan Robinson or Jahmyr Gibbs

Fantasy Football Outlook: Bijan Robinson

Last year, Bijan Robinson was the RB2 in fantasy points per game. For most of the season, he was pacing towards a 1,000-yard season for rushing and receiving before tailing off at the end of the season (820 receiving yards). Robinson was also crushed by the heavy usage of Tyler Allgeier near the goalline. Allgeier finished with eight rushing touchdowns, while Robinson had only 11 total touchdowns. Robinson had a pitiful 49.3% red zone rushing share (per Fantasy Points Data). With Allgeier and the previous coaching staff gone, Robinson should enjoy more usage near paydirt in 2026. Robinson was incredibly efficient with his workload last season, which is a reflection of his insane talent. He finished top-three among running backs (minimum 100 carries, 20 targets) in receiving yards per game, target share, yards per route run, first downs per route run, missed tackles forced per attempt, and yards after contact per attempt. Robinson is my favorite bet to be the RB1 overall in 2026.
– Derek Brown

Fantasy Football Outlook: Jahmyr Gibbs

Last year, Jahmyr Gibbs finished as the RB3 in fantasy points per game. After Week 10, his usage got a massive bump as he didn’t play less than 68% of the snaps in any game for the rest of the season while averaging 20 touches and 114.9 total yards pre game. This stretch of games from Weeks 11-18 also coincided with Sam LaPorta‘s absence, which increased Gibbs’ passing game usage. In Weeks 1-10, Gibbs had a 12.7% target share, 25.2 receiving yards per game, and an 11.1% first-read share (per Fantasy Points Data). In Weeks 11-18, Gibbs saw a huge increase in work through the air without LaPorta, with a 19% target share, 48.6 receiving yards per game, and a 19.6% first-read share. Gibbs led all running backs in those statistical categories in the final eight games of the season. Gibbs is in the running for RB1 overall for 2026, but if the rest of the weapons for Detroit remain healthy all season, it could be tough for him to do so. I still expect him to be a top-three back this season who is insanely efficient with his passing game and early down work. Last year, he ranked ninth in explosive run rate and third in missed tackles forced per attempt. Gibbs will and should be a top 3-5 pick in every fantasy draft this year.
– Derek Brown

View the Best Fantasy Football Team Names