Skip to main content
< Back
NFL
< Back
MLB
< Back
NBA
< Back
NHL
< Back
DFS
< Back
BettingPros
< Back
More...
PGA
Nascar
MMA
< Back
Draft Wizard
< Back
My Playbook
Game Day
Live!
Apps
Premium
Help
Log In
Loading your leagues
My Account
My Leagues
Premium
Mobile Apps
Fantasy O/U
Log in
Register
Help
Log Out
MLB Home
Tools
Draft
Draft Simulator
Draft
Draft Assistant
Auction Calculator
Auction Simulator
Cheat Sheet Creator
Draft Analyzer
Draft Software
Who Should I Draft?
Draft Order Generator
2020 Draft Kit
In-Season
My Playbook
Waiver Assistant
Lineup Assistant
Trade Analyzer
Trade Finder
League Analyzer
Multi-League Assistant
Research Assistant
Who Should I Start?
Rankings
2021 Draft
Mixed Leagues
AL-Only
NL-Only
Dynasty
Average Draft Position
Player Notes
Dynasty
Mixed Leagues
Rest of Season
Mixed Leagues
AL-Only
NL-Only
Player Notes
Projections
Full Season
Rest of Season
Daily
Weekly
Stats
Season to Date
Last 30 Days
Last 7 Days
Last Year
Research
Reports
Closer Report
Points Leaders
2020 Schedule
Depth Charts
Injury Report
Most Added/Dropped
Park Factors
Expert Accuracy
Cheat Sheets
Pitcher Planner
Hitter Planner
Today's Lineups
Two Start Pitchers
Streamers
Lineup Alerts
Resources
Draft Prep Guide
Strategy Tips
Sabermetrics Glossary
Roto vs H2H
Keeper Advice
Improve Your League
Evaluating Prospects
New Season Lessons
Mock Draft Advice
Analysis
FantasyPros Podcast
Videos
Articles
Sleepers
Busts
Undervalued
Overvalued
Start/Sit Advice
Trade Advice
Mock Drafts
Articles
News
Player Updates
All News
Breaking
Injuries
Rumors
Game Recaps
Transactions
Featured
Waiver Wire
Streamers
Two Start Pitchers
Closer Reports
Injuries
Player Profiles
Stock Watch
Prospects
Podcasts
Partner Articles
Podcast
Listen
Promo Codes
Apps
Multi-Year Fantasy Baseball Accuracy
Most Accurate Draft Experts from 2017 to 2019
Analysis
|
Methodology
Multi-Year Draft Accuracy
2016 Draft Accuracy
2017 Draft Accuracy
2018 Draft Accuracy
2019 Draft Accuracy
2011 - 2015 Rankings
Rank
Expert Name
1B
2B
3B
SS
C
OF
SP
RP
1
Tim McCullough - Baseball Prospectus
2
15
7
16
1
4
13
4
2
Andrew Gould - FantasyPros
15
13
11
10
15
6
15
3
3
Jake Ciely - The Athletic
35
1
14
2
4
11
3
17
4
Heath Capps - Fake Teams
5
21
17
7
17
1
33
10
5
Scott Pianowski - Yahoo
21
3
9
25
22
18
7
5
6
Jeff Boggis - Fantasy Football Empire
24
10
35
15
9
7
11
12
7
Steve Gardner - USA Today
1
18
3
29
19
19
21
13
8
Tyler Thompson - Fantasy Six Pack
13
17
2
23
2
10
25
20
9
Josh Shepardson - FantasyPros
31
22
1
13
10
17
17
15
10
KJ - Fantasy Team Advice
6
16
34
5
6
3
26
31
11
Jason Johnson -
9
5
29
20
24
8
23
8
12
Luke Gloeckner - Mr. Cheatsheet
17
34
22
9
5
2
12
2
13
Nick Mariano - RotoBaller
32
12
15
32
8
16
8
6
14
Rudy Gamble - Razzball
19
25
26
8
27
21
5
7
15
Nick Pollack - Pitcher List
27
27
10
31
34
9
1
33
16
Justin Klein - The Fake Baseball
8
24
13
21
25
23
20
11
17
Dalton Del Don - Yahoo
33
14
28
17
37
14
2
23
18
Joe Bond - Fantasy Six Pack
12
4
25
3
16
24
34
18
19
Chris Meaney - FTN
16
11
33
18
12
25
22
29
20
Bobby Sylvester
36
20
30
14
29
15
18
25
21
Michael Waterloo - FantasyPros
30
30
4
35
18
20
10
32
22
Michael Florio - Rotoballer
4
32
23
28
3
37
9
1
23
Al Melchior - The Athletic
22
33
20
22
20
13
27
14
24
Michael Beller - The Athletic
26
6
12
19
26
29
30
21
25
Grey Albright - Razzball
3
2
5
37
21
33
28
30
26
Site Projections - RotoChamp
23
26
31
4
31
30
14
19
27
Scott White - CBS Sports
18
29
16
33
7
38
4
24
28
Heath Cummings - CBS Sports
11
23
36
24
36
34
6
27
29
Andy Behrens - Yahoo
29
19
27
12
33
35
19
9
30
Wayne Bretsky - BretskyBall
25
31
18
36
30
32
16
26
31
Site Rankings - SI.com
28
8
19
30
13
31
35
22
32
Paul Sporer - FanGraphs
34
28
21
26
35
12
24
37
33
Muntradamus - Beast Dome
39
36
38
11
32
40
37
35
34
Mario Mergola - Sporfolio
14
38
39
6
39
39
38
36
-
Dave McKay - The Fantasy Sports Brain
7
9
24
-
-
5
31
16
-
Justin Mason - FanGraphs
10
7
32
27
14
22
29
-
-
Tim Young - Brewer Rat
20
39
6
1
23
26
-
-
-
Brandon Funston - The Athletic
37
35
37
-
28
36
-
-
-
Bill Dubiel - RotoBaller
38
37
-
34
38
28
36
34
-
Chris Meyers - Athlon Sports
-
-
8
-
11
27
32
28
Draft Tools
Draft Simulator
Draft Assistant
Mock Draft Lobby
Cheat Sheet Creator
Auction Simulator
Who Should I Draft?
Auction Calculator
Draft Software
Draft Research
Expert Rankings
ADP Consensus
Projections
Closer Report
Depth Charts
Sleepers
Busts
Draft Prep Guide
Podcast
Draft Kit
In-Season Tools
My Playbook
Waiver Assistant
Lineup Assistant
Trade Analyzer
Trade Finder
League Analyzer
Multi-League Assistant
Research Assistant
DFS Lineup Optimizer
In-Season Research
Expert Rankings
Projections
Player Rater
Closer Report
Pitcher Planner
Two Start Pitchers
Hitter Planner
Depth Charts
Most Added/Dropped
Today's Lineups
Podcast
Do Not Sell
Are you looking to contact Customer Support about a subscription or account related question?
Yes
No, I'm a California resident looking for the California Consumer Privacy Act form