Multi-Year Fantasy Baseball Accuracy

Most Accurate Draft Experts from 2017 to 2019

Analysis | Methodology

Rank	Expert Name	1B	2B	3B	SS	C	OF	SP	RP
1	Tim McCullough - Baseball Prospectus	2	15	7	16	1	4	13	4
2	Andrew Gould - FantasyPros	15	13	11	10	15	6	15	3
3	Jake Ciely - The Athletic	35	1	14	2	4	11	3	17
4	Heath Capps - Fake Teams	5	21	17	7	17	1	33	10
5	Scott Pianowski - Yahoo	21	3	9	25	22	18	7	5
6	Jeff Boggis - Fantasy Football Empire	24	10	35	15	9	7	11	12
7	Steve Gardner - USA Today	1	18	3	29	19	19	21	13
8	Tyler Thompson - Fantasy Six Pack	13	17	2	23	2	10	25	20
9	Josh Shepardson - FantasyPros	31	22	1	13	10	17	17	15
10	KJ - Fantasy Team Advice	6	16	34	5	6	3	26	31
11	Jason Johnson -	9	5	29	20	24	8	23	8
12	Luke Gloeckner - Mr. Cheatsheet	17	34	22	9	5	2	12	2
13	Nick Mariano - RotoBaller	32	12	15	32	8	16	8	6
14	Rudy Gamble - Razzball	19	25	26	8	27	21	5	7
15	Nick Pollack - Pitcher List	27	27	10	31	34	9	1	33
16	Justin Klein - The Fake Baseball	8	24	13	21	25	23	20	11
17	Dalton Del Don - Yahoo	33	14	28	17	37	14	2	23
18	Joe Bond - Fantasy Six Pack	12	4	25	3	16	24	34	18
19	Chris Meaney - FTN	16	11	33	18	12	25	22	29
20	Bobby Sylvester	36	20	30	14	29	15	18	25
21	Michael Waterloo - FantasyPros	30	30	4	35	18	20	10	32
22	Michael Florio - Rotoballer	4	32	23	28	3	37	9	1
23	Al Melchior - The Athletic	22	33	20	22	20	13	27	14
24	Michael Beller - The Athletic	26	6	12	19	26	29	30	21
25	Grey Albright - Razzball	3	2	5	37	21	33	28	30
26	Site Projections - RotoChamp	23	26	31	4	31	30	14	19
27	Scott White - CBS Sports	18	29	16	33	7	38	4	24
28	Heath Cummings - CBS Sports	11	23	36	24	36	34	6	27
29	Andy Behrens - Yahoo	29	19	27	12	33	35	19	9
30	Wayne Bretsky - BretskyBall	25	31	18	36	30	32	16	26
31	Site Rankings - SI.com	28	8	19	30	13	31	35	22
32	Paul Sporer - FanGraphs	34	28	21	26	35	12	24	37
33	Muntradamus - Beast Dome	39	36	38	11	32	40	37	35
34	Mario Mergola - Sporfolio	14	38	39	6	39	39	38	36
-	Dave McKay - The Fantasy Sports Brain	7	9	24	-	-	5	31	16
-	Justin Mason - FanGraphs	10	7	32	27	14	22	29	-
-	Tim Young - Brewer Rat	20	39	6	1	23	26	-	-
-	Brandon Funston - The Athletic	37	35	37	-	28	36	-	-
-	Bill Dubiel - RotoBaller	38	37	-	34	38	28	36	34
-	Chris Meyers - Athlon Sports	-	-	8	-	11	27	32	28