Aaron Civale or Devin Williams
Baseball Stats Comparison
See which player would win in a trade View Trade Analyzer
| Devin Williams RP - NYM  | Aaron Civale SP,RP - ATH  | |
| 2026 Stats | ||
| Games Played | 21 | 11 |
| Games Started | 0 | 11 |
| Innings Pitched | 18.0 | 55.2 |
| Wins | 3 | 5 |
| Losses | 2 | 2 |
| Saves | 8 | 0 |
| Blown Saves | 1 | 0 |
| Holds | 0 | 0 |
| Hits Allowed | 18 | 65 |
| Earned Runs | 12 | 26 |
| Home Runs Allowed | 2 | 12 |
| Strikeouts | 28 | 39 |
| Walks | 13 | 17 |
| ERA | 6.00 | 4.20 |
| WHIP | 1.72 | 1.47 |
| Devin Williams RP - NYM | Aaron Civale SP,RP - ATH | |
| 2026 Projections | ||
| Games Played | 62 | 24 |
| Games Started | 0 | 23 |
| Innings Pitched | 60.8 | 123.9 |
| Wins | 4 | 7 |
| Losses | 3 | 8 |
| Saves | 29 | 0 |
| Blown Saves | 2 | 0 |
| Holds | 3 | 0 |
| Hits Allowed | 44 | 124 |
| Earned Runs | 23 | 64 |
| Home Runs Allowed | 6 | 20 |
| Strikeouts | 82 | 107 |
| Walks | 26 | 39 |
| ERA | 3.34 | 4.61 |
| WHIP | 1.14 | 1.32 |
| Devin Williams RP - NYM | Aaron Civale SP,RP - ATH | |
| News | ||
| Williams has converted six straight save chances since a loss against Miami on May 24, allowing four earned runs — all in that loss — with a 13:7 K:BB across nine innings during the stretch. Wednesday marked his eighth save in nine attempts on the season. Bruno Mulé Thu, May 28th | The Athletics placed Aaron Civale on the 15-day injured list with right shoulder tendonitis. Ari Koslow Tue, May 26th | |
| Devin Williams struck out one batter while allowing one hit over a scoreless inning to earn the save in Thursday’s 2-1 win over the Nationals. Chris Schommer Fri, May 22nd | The Athletics are likely to place Aaron Civale on the injured list. Ari Koslow Tue, May 26th | |
| Devin Williams struck out one batter in a scoreless inning to earn the save in Saturday's 6-3 win over the Yankees. Chris Schommer Sun, May 17th | Aaron Civale allowed five earned runs on five hits and two walks while striking out two over five innings in Wednesday’s win over the Angels. Chris Schommer Thu, May 21st | |
| Devin Williams struck out two batters in a scoreless outing to earn the save in Wednesday's 10-5 win over the Rockies. Chris Schommer Thu, May 7th | Aaron Civale allowed two earned runs on six hits and one walk while striking out two over five innings in Friday’s win over the Giants. Chris Schommer Sat, May 16th | |
| Devin Williams tossed a clean inning with two strikeouts for the save on Friday against the Angels. Ari Koslow Sat, May 2nd | Aaron Civale allowed six hits and three walks while striking out six over five scoreless innings in Saturday's win over the Orioles. Chris Schommer Sun, May 10th | |
| Notes | ||
| After years of dominance in Milwaukee, Devin Williams endured a turbulent first season in New York in 2025, posting a 4.79 ERA across 67 appearances despite still striking out 90 batters in 62 innings. The underlying indicators remained far stronger than the surface results (2.68 FIP and 13.1 K/9). FantasyPros' 2026 projections anticipate a rebound, forecasting roughly a 3.26 ERA, 86 strikeouts, and around 30 saves over about 66 innings. Given the massive ERA-FIP gap in 2025 and his sustained strikeout dominance, Williams profiles as a bounce-back fantasy riser if he retains a full-time closing role. Kelly Kirby - FantasyPros | ||
| Devin Williams RP - NYM | Aaron Civale SP,RP - ATH | |||||
| Date | Opp | Opp Pitcher | VBR | Opp | Opp Pitcher | VBR |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fri, Mar 27th | @ TOR | Kevin Gausman (4-3) | #20 | |||
| Sat, Mar 28th | vs PIT | Mitch Keller (5-2) | #98 | @ TOR | Dylan Cease (3-3) | #16 |
| Sun, Mar 29th | vs PIT | Carmen Mlodzinski (4-3) | #112 | @ TOR | Eric Lauer (2-5) | #263 |
| Mon, Mar 30th | @ STL | Kyle Leahy (5-3) | #163 | @ ATL | Bryce Elder (4-3) | #114 |
| Tue, Mar 31st | @ STL | Andre Pallante (5-4) | #143 | @ ATL | Jose Suarez | #241 |
| Wed, Apr 1st | @ STL | Matthew Liberatore (2-3) | #119 | @ ATL | Chris Sale (8-3) | #5 |
| Fri, Apr 3rd | @ SF | Tyler Mahle (1-7) | #100 | vs HOU | Cristian Javier (0-1) | #246 |
| Sat, Apr 4th | @ SF | Landen Roupp (5-5) | #66 | vs HOU | Tatsuya Imai (2-2) | #159 |
| Sun, Apr 5th | @ SF | Logan Webb (2-4) | #13 | vs HOU | Lance McCullers Jr. (2-3) | #209 |
| Tue, Apr 7th | vs ARI | Zac Gallen (3-4) | #63 | @ NYY | Cam Schlittler (7-2) | #36 |
| Wed, Apr 8th | vs ARI | Ryne Nelson (2-3) | #92 | @ NYY | Will Warren (6-1) | #65 |
| Thu, Apr 9th | vs ARI | Eduardo Rodriguez (5-1) | #116 | @ NYY | Ryan Weathers (2-2) | #67 |
| Fri, Apr 10th | vs ATH | J.T. Ginn (2-3) | #131 | @ NYM | Clay Holmes (4-4) | #167 |
| Sat, Apr 11th | vs ATH | Jacob Lopez (4-2) | #193 | @ NYM | Kodai Senga (0-4) | #135 |
| Sun, Apr 12th | vs ATH | Aaron Civale (5-2) | #221 | @ NYM | Freddy Peralta (3-4) | #24 |
| Mon, Apr 13th | @ LAD | Justin Wrobleski (6-2) | #141 | vs TEX | Nathan Eovaldi (5-6) | #19 |
| Tue, Apr 14th | @ LAD | Yoshinobu Yamamoto (4-4) | #12 | vs TEX | MacKenzie Gore (3-4) | #51 |
| Wed, Apr 15th | @ LAD | Shohei Ohtani (5-2) | #1 | vs TEX | Kumar Rocker (2-5) | #107 |
| Thu, Apr 16th | vs TEX | Jack Leiter (2-4) | #78 | |||
| Fri, Apr 17th | @ CHC | Edward Cabrera (3-2) | #73 | vs CWS | Davis Martin (8-1) | #79 |
| Sat, Apr 18th | @ CHC | Jameson Taillon (2-4) | #103 | vs CWS | Erick Fedde (0-5) | #357 |
| Sun, Apr 19th | @ CHC | Javier Assad (3-1) | #289 | vs CWS | Noah Schultz (2-4) | #220 |
| Mon, Apr 20th | @ SEA | Emerson Hancock (4-2) | #93 | |||
| Tue, Apr 21st | vs MIN | Simeon Woods Richardson (0-7) | #223 | @ SEA | Luis Castillo (1-5) | #46 |
| Wed, Apr 22nd | vs MIN | Connor Prielipp (1-3) | #123 | @ SEA | Logan Gilbert (3-4) | #11 |
| Fri, Apr 24th | vs COL | Michael Lorenzen (2-7) | #423 | @ TEX | Nathan Eovaldi (5-6) | #19 |
| Sat, Apr 25th | @ TEX | MacKenzie Gore (3-4) | #51 | |||
| Sun, Apr 26th | vs COL | Chase Dollander (3-3) | #329 | @ TEX | Kumar Rocker (2-5) | #107 |
| Tue, Apr 28th | vs WSH | Zack Littell (4-4) | #172 | vs KC | Kris Bubic (3-2) | #77 |
| Wed, Apr 29th | vs WSH | Cade Cavalli (3-3) | #90 | vs KC | Michael Wacha (4-2) | #82 |
| Thu, Apr 30th | vs WSH | Miles Mikolas (1-4) | #216 | vs KC | Noah Cameron (2-4) | #97 |
| Fri, May 1st | @ LAA | Walbert Urena (2-4) | #406 | vs CLE | Joey Cantillo (4-2) | #95 |
| Sat, May 2nd | @ LAA | Reid Detmers (1-5) | #45 | vs CLE | Slade Cecconi (3-5) | #110 |
| Sun, May 3rd | @ LAA | Jack Kochanowicz (2-3) | #408 | vs CLE | Parker Messick (6-1) | #52 |
| Tue, May 5th | @ PHI | Cristopher Sanchez (6-2) | #3 | |||
| Wed, May 6th | @ COL | Michael Lorenzen (2-7) | #423 | @ PHI | Zack Wheeler (4-0) | #8 |
| Thu, May 7th | @ COL | Jose Quintana (2-3) | #425 | @ PHI | Andrew Painter (1-5) | #166 |
| Fri, May 8th | @ ARI | Ryne Nelson (2-3) | #92 | @ BAL | Kyle Bradish (2-6) | #50 |
| Sat, May 9th | @ ARI | Merrill Kelly (5-3) | #96 | @ BAL | Shane Baz (2-5) | #83 |
| Sun, May 10th | @ ARI | Eduardo Rodriguez (5-1) | #116 | @ BAL | Keegan Akin (0-0) | #180 |
| Tue, May 12th | vs DET | Jack Flaherty (0-7) | #70 | vs STL | Andre Pallante (5-4) | #143 |
| Wed, May 13th | vs DET | Framber Valdez (2-3) | #25 | vs STL | Matthew Liberatore (2-3) | #119 |
| Thu, May 14th | vs DET | Keider Montero (2-3) | #205 | vs STL | Michael McGreevy (3-4) | #84 |
| Fri, May 15th | vs NYY | Cam Schlittler (7-2) | #36 | vs SF | Tyler Mahle (1-7) | #100 |
| Sat, May 16th | vs NYY | Carlos Rodon (0-2) | #34 | vs SF | Trevor McDonald (2-2) | #186 |
| Sun, May 17th | vs NYY | Elmer Rodriguez (0-1) | #280 | vs SF | Adrian Houser (2-4) | #188 |
| Mon, May 18th | @ WSH | Jake Irvin (2-4) | #198 | @ LAA | Walbert Urena (2-4) | #406 |
| Tue, May 19th | @ WSH | Foster Griffin (6-2) | #85 | @ LAA | Reid Detmers (1-5) | #45 |
| Wed, May 20th | @ WSH | Zack Littell (4-4) | #172 | @ LAA | Jack Kochanowicz (2-3) | #408 |
| Thu, May 21st | @ WSH | Cade Cavalli (3-3) | #90 | @ LAA | Jose Soriano (6-4) | #39 |
| Fri, May 22nd | @ MIA | Eury Perez (3-6) | #60 | @ SD | Walker Buehler (3-3) | #214 |
| Sat, May 23rd | @ MIA | Max Meyer (5-0) | #71 | @ SD | Lucas Giolito (2-0) | #165 |
| Sun, May 24th | @ MIA | Tyler Phillips | @ SD | Michael King (4-3) | #35 | |
| Mon, May 25th | vs CIN | Nick Lodolo (1-1) | #62 | vs SEA | Luis Castillo (1-5) | #46 |
| Tue, May 26th | vs CIN | Chase Burns (7-1) | #26 | vs SEA | Emerson Hancock (4-2) | #93 |
| Wed, May 27th | vs CIN | Andrew Abbott (4-3) | #102 | vs SEA | Logan Gilbert (3-4) | #11 |
| Fri, May 29th | vs MIA | Max Meyer (5-0) | #71 | vs NYY | Carlos Rodon (0-2) | #34 |
| Sat, May 30th | vs MIA | Tyler Phillips | vs NYY | Ryan Weathers (2-2) | #67 | |
| Sun, May 31st | vs MIA | Janson Junk (3-5) | #121 | vs NYY | Will Warren (6-1) | #65 |
| Tue, Jun 2nd | @ SEA | Logan Gilbert (3-4) | #11 | @ CHC | Jameson Taillon (2-4) | #103 |
| Wed, Jun 3rd | @ SEA | George Kirby (5-4) | #15 | @ CHC | Colin Rea (5-3) | #139 |
| Thu, Jun 4th | @ CHC | Shota Imanaga (4-5) | #22 | |||
| Fri, Jun 5th | @ SD | Michael King (4-3) | #35 | @ HOU | Peter Lambert (3-4) | #187 |
| Sat, Jun 6th | @ SD | Griffin Canning (0-3) | #138 | @ HOU | Tatsuya Imai (2-2) | #159 |
| Sun, Jun 7th | @ SD | Randy Vasquez (5-3) | #199 | @ HOU | Lance McCullers Jr. (2-3) | #209 |
| Mon, Jun 8th | vs MIL | |||||
| Tue, Jun 9th | vs STL | vs MIL | ||||
| Wed, Jun 10th | vs STL | vs MIL | ||||
| Fri, Jun 12th | vs ATL | vs COL | ||||
| Sat, Jun 13th | vs ATL | vs COL | ||||
| Sun, Jun 14th | vs ATL | vs COL | ||||
| Mon, Jun 15th | @ CIN | vs PIT | ||||
| Tue, Jun 16th | @ CIN | vs PIT | ||||
| Wed, Jun 17th | @ CIN | vs PIT | ||||
| Thu, Jun 18th | @ PHI | vs LAA | ||||
| Fri, Jun 19th | vs LAA | |||||
| Sat, Jun 20th | @ PHI | vs LAA | ||||
| Sun, Jun 21st | @ PHI | vs LAA | ||||
| Tue, Jun 23rd | vs CHC | @ SF | ||||
| Wed, Jun 24th | vs CHC | @ SF | ||||
| Thu, Jun 25th | vs CHC | @ SF | ||||
| Fri, Jun 26th | vs PHI | @ LAA | ||||
| Sat, Jun 27th | vs PHI | @ LAA | ||||
| Sun, Jun 28th | vs PHI | @ LAA | ||||
| Mon, Jun 29th | @ TOR | vs LAD | ||||
| Tue, Jun 30th | @ TOR | vs LAD | ||||
| Wed, Jul 1st | @ TOR | vs LAD | ||||
| Fri, Jul 3rd | @ ATL | vs MIA | ||||
| Sat, Jul 4th | @ ATL | vs MIA | ||||
| Sun, Jul 5th | @ ATL | vs MIA | ||||
| Tue, Jul 7th | vs KC | @ DET | ||||
| Wed, Jul 8th | vs KC | @ DET | ||||
| Thu, Jul 9th | vs KC | @ DET | ||||
| Fri, Jul 10th | vs BOS | @ CWS | ||||
| Sat, Jul 11th | vs BOS | @ CWS | ||||
| Sun, Jul 12th | vs BOS | @ CWS | ||||
| Fri, Jul 17th | vs WSH | |||||
| Sat, Jul 18th | @ PHI | vs WSH | ||||
| Sun, Jul 19th | @ PHI | vs WSH | ||||
| Mon, Jul 20th | @ MIL | @ ARI | ||||
| Tue, Jul 21st | @ MIL | @ ARI | ||||
| Wed, Jul 22nd | @ MIL | @ ARI | ||||
| Fri, Jul 24th | vs LAD | @ MIN | ||||
| Sat, Jul 25th | vs LAD | @ MIN | ||||
| Sun, Jul 26th | vs LAD | @ MIN | ||||
| Mon, Jul 27th | vs ATL | vs BOS | ||||
| Tue, Jul 28th | vs ATL | vs BOS | ||||
| Wed, Jul 29th | vs ATL | vs BOS | ||||
| Thu, Jul 30th | vs MIA | vs BOS | ||||
| Fri, Jul 31st | vs MIA | vs DET | ||||
| Sat, Aug 1st | vs MIA | vs DET | ||||
| Sun, Aug 2nd | vs MIA | vs DET | ||||
| Tue, Aug 4th | @ CLE | @ CIN | ||||
| Wed, Aug 5th | @ CLE | @ CIN | ||||
| Thu, Aug 6th | @ CLE | @ CIN | ||||
| Fri, Aug 7th | @ PIT | @ BOS | ||||
| Sat, Aug 8th | @ PIT | @ BOS | ||||
| Sun, Aug 9th | @ PIT | @ BOS | ||||
| Mon, Aug 10th | @ ATL | vs TB | ||||
| Tue, Aug 11th | @ ATL | vs TB | ||||
| Wed, Aug 12th | @ ATL | vs TB | ||||
| Fri, Aug 14th | vs WSH | vs TEX | ||||
| Sat, Aug 15th | vs WSH | vs TEX | ||||
| Sun, Aug 16th | vs WSH | vs TEX | ||||
| Mon, Aug 17th | vs SD | @ KC | ||||
| Tue, Aug 18th | vs SD | @ KC | ||||
| Wed, Aug 19th | vs SD | @ KC | ||||
| Thu, Aug 20th | @ KC | |||||
| Fri, Aug 21st | @ CWS | @ HOU | ||||
| Sat, Aug 22nd | @ CWS | @ HOU | ||||
| Sun, Aug 23rd | @ CWS | @ HOU | ||||
| Mon, Aug 24th | vs MIN | |||||
| Tue, Aug 25th | vs MIL | vs MIN | ||||
| Wed, Aug 26th | vs MIL | vs MIN | ||||
| Fri, Aug 28th | vs HOU | vs BAL | ||||
| Sat, Aug 29th | vs HOU | vs BAL | ||||
| Sun, Aug 30th | vs HOU | vs BAL | ||||
| Mon, Aug 31st | @ TB | @ TEX | ||||
| Tue, Sep 1st | @ TB | @ TEX | ||||
| Wed, Sep 2nd | @ TB | @ TEX | ||||
| Thu, Sep 3rd | @ SEA | |||||
| Fri, Sep 4th | vs SF | @ SEA | ||||
| Sat, Sep 5th | vs SF | @ SEA | ||||
| Sun, Sep 6th | vs SF | @ SEA | ||||
| Mon, Sep 7th | @ MIA | vs TOR | ||||
| Tue, Sep 8th | @ MIA | vs TOR | ||||
| Wed, Sep 9th | @ MIA | vs TOR | ||||
| Fri, Sep 11th | @ NYY | vs SEA | ||||
| Sat, Sep 12th | @ NYY | vs SEA | ||||
| Sun, Sep 13th | @ NYY | vs SEA | ||||
| Tue, Sep 15th | vs BAL | @ TB | ||||
| Wed, Sep 16th | vs BAL | @ TB | ||||
| Thu, Sep 17th | vs PHI | @ TB | ||||
| Fri, Sep 18th | vs PHI | @ CLE | ||||
| Sat, Sep 19th | vs PHI | @ CLE | ||||
| Sun, Sep 20th | vs PHI | @ CLE | ||||
| Tue, Sep 22nd | @ TEX | vs LAA | ||||
| Wed, Sep 23rd | @ TEX | vs LAA | ||||
| Thu, Sep 24th | @ TEX | vs HOU | ||||
| Fri, Sep 25th | @ WSH | vs HOU | ||||
| Sat, Sep 26th | @ WSH | vs HOU | ||||
| Sun, Sep 27th | @ WSH | vs HOU | ||||
| Thu, Mar 26th | vs PIT | Paul Skenes (6-5) | #2 | |||
| Thu, Apr 2nd | @ SF | Robbie Ray (3-6) | #86 | |||
| Thu, Apr 23rd | vs MIN | Joe Ryan (3-3) | #14 | |||
| Mon, May 4th | @ COL | Tomoyuki Sugano (4-4) | #426 | |||
| Mon, Jun 1st | @ SEA | Emerson Hancock (4-2) | #93 | |||
| Thu, Jun 11th | vs STL | |||||
| Mon, Jun 22nd | vs CHC | |||||
| Mon, Jul 6th | @ ATL | |||||
| Thu, Jul 16th | @ PHI | |||||
| Thu, Aug 27th | vs MIL | |||||
| Mon, Sep 14th | vs BAL | |||||
