2017 Fantasy Baseball Rankings

Expert Consensus Ranking (17 of 17 Experts) - Updated 1/24
Rank Player (Team, Position) Overall Best Worst Avg Std Dev
1 Clayton Kershaw (LAD, SP) 7 1 1 1.0 0.0
2 Max Scherzer (WSH, SP) 14 2 3 2.1 0.2
3 Madison Bumgarner (SF, SP) 16 3 5 3.4 0.6
4 Chris Sale (BOS, SP) 21 3 6 4.4 0.8
5 Noah Syndergaard (NYM, SP) 22 2 6 4.7 1.3
6 Corey Kluber (CLE, SP) 24 4 7 5.5 0.8
7 Jake Arrieta (CHC, SP) 38 6 12 8.0 1.6
8 Jon Lester (CHC, SP) 40 7 12 8.5 1.2
9 David Price (BOS, SP) 42 7 21 10.4 3.0
10 Justin Verlander (DET, SP) 44 7 16 10.8 2.3
11 Johnny Cueto (SF, SP) 46 8 16 11.6 2.3
12 Yu Darvish (TEX, SP) 50 7 19 11.9 3.2
13 Stephen Strasburg (WSH, SP) 52 8 22 13.1 3.2
14 Carlos Carrasco (CLE, SP) 58 10 29 14.9 4.2
15 Jacob DeGrom (NYM, SP) 60 10 28 15.6 4.6
16 Chris Archer (TB, SP) 64 13 24 16.1 2.3
17 Kyle Hendricks (CHC, SP) 68 10 30 18.0 4.2
18 Zach Britton (BAL, RP) 72 14 27 20.5 4.1
19 Masahiro Tanaka (NYY, SP) 78 15 33 21.6 4.0
20 Zack Greinke (ARI, SP) 82 19 47 24.4 7.2
21 Aroldis Chapman (NYY, RP) 80 11 70 24.8 14.4
22 Cole Hamels (TEX, SP) 86 14 37 25.1 6.0
23 Gerrit Cole (PIT, SP) 83 18 56 25.5 9.3
24 Jose Quintana (CWS, SP) 89 17 39 26.4 4.8
25 Kenley Jansen (LAD, RP) 85 14 68 26.5 15.9
26 Carlos Martinez (STL, SP) 92 20 44 27.5 6.9
27 Kenta Maeda (LAD, SP) 94 20 36 28.6 4.4
28 Roberto Osuna (TOR, RP) 97 20 41 30.4 6.5
29 Julio Teheran (ATL, SP) 100 21 55 32.9 8.3
30 Rick Porcello (BOS, SP) 101 22 47 32.9 5.8
31 Andrew Miller (CLE, RP) 104 19 60 34.9 10.6
32 Craig Kimbrel (BOS, RP) 103 22 48 35.1 7.1
33 Seung-Hwan Oh (STL, RP) 105 18 57 35.9 10.5
34 Edwin Diaz (SEA, SP,RP) 108 27 54 37.4 8.2
35 Danny Duffy (KC, SP,RP) 110 23 68 38.5 10.6
36 Danny Salazar (CLE, SP) 113 22 62 38.9 9.1
37 Mark Melancon (SF, RP) 112 20 73 39.2 14.4
38 Michael Fulmer (DET, SP) 114 32 53 40.2 5.3
39 Wade Davis (CHC, RP) 117 27 66 41.7 11.1
40 Felix Hernandez (SEA, SP) 119 30 73 42.1 11.0
41 Kenneth Giles (HOU, RP) 121 25 61 43.4 9.4
42 Dallas Keuchel (HOU, SP) 122 20 68 43.6 12.3
43 David Robertson (CWS, RP) 125 28 73 44.2 11.5
44 Cody Allen (CLE, RP) 123 30 62 44.2 7.8
45 Matt Harvey (NYM, SP) 126 19 110 45.5 20.1
46 Aaron Sanchez (TOR, SP,RP) 128 22 91 41.6 15.1
47 John Lackey (CHC, SP) 129 35 76 48.2 10.1
48 Marcus Stroman (TOR, SP) 133 29 68 50.8 8.4
49 Jeurys Familia (NYM, RP) 134 19 96 51.7 18.6
50 Rich Hill (LAD, SP) 136 24 90 52.2 19.2
51 Steven Matz (NYM, SP) DL15 137 40 67 52.7 6.8
52 Aaron Nola (PHI, SP) 141 35 82 53.2 9.5
53 Jameson Taillon (PIT, SP) 139 17 77 53.5 13.2
54 Kevin Gausman (BAL, SP,RP) 144 42 90 54.9 12.5
55 Dellin Betances (NYY, RP) 146 35 96 56.9 17.1
56 Kelvin Herrera (KC, RP) 154 30 121 59.6 25.5
57 Lance McCullers (HOU, SP) DL15 156 29 89 59.8 17.2
58 Francisco Rodriguez (DET, RP) 151 41 82 60.1 11.7
59 Tanner Roark (WSH, SP,RP) 153 46 96 60.1 14.4
60 Jeff Samardzija (SF, SP) 158 48 80 61.4 10.0
61 Jonathan Gray (COL, SP) 160 36 90 62.9 15.3
62 Sonny Gray (OAK, SP) 169 54 96 67.2 10.4
63 Anthony DeSclafani (CIN, SP) 171 45 101 67.6 16.7
64 J.A. Happ (TOR, SP) 172 55 97 67.6 9.7
65 Julio Urias (LAD, SP) 167 40 85 67.8 14.8
66 Sean Manaea (OAK, SP) DL15 173 49 91 68.2 10.1
67 Drew Pomeranz (BOS, SP,RP) 168 45 105 63.2 16.0
68 Vincent Velasquez (PHI, SP,RP) 176 54 79 69.1 7.8
69 Alexander Colome (TB, SP,RP) 179 36 117 69.8 23.5
70 Jake Odorizzi (TB, SP) 178 62 84 70.4 5.6
71 A.J. Ramos (MIA, RP) 181 40 112 73.1 18.7
72 Sam Dyson (TEX, RP) 185 52 108 74.2 15.7
73 Marco Estrada (TOR, SP,RP) 192 65 108 76.3 11.2
74 James Paxton (SEA, SP) 188 52 98 76.9 11.9
75 Drew Smyly (SEA, SP) 190 55 121 77.2 14.4
76 Tony Watson (PIT, RP) 191 58 102 77.4 10.1
77 Matt Shoemaker (LAA, SP) 194 60 100 77.4 12.5
78 Joe Ross (WSH, SP) 196 62 92 78.2 8.6
79 Adam Wainwright (STL, SP) 198 65 103 78.2 12.5
80 Robbie Ray (ARI, SP) 200 53 100 78.5 12.5
81 Michael Pineda (NYY, SP) 204 56 104 80.7 11.8
82 Carlos Rodon (CWS, SP) 202 56 132 81.8 16.8
83 Garrett Richards (LAA, SP) 205 60 96 81.9 11.1
84 Taijuan Walker (ARI, SP) 208 63 97 82.2 8.3
85 Jerad Eickhoff (PHI, SP) 209 58 116 82.8 13.5
86 Hisashi Iwakuma (SEA, SP) 211 59 103 80.3 14.0
87 Ryan Madson (OAK, RP) 217 61 140 87.2 19.2
88 Raisel Iglesias (CIN, SP,RP) 214 59 153 86.6 26.8
89 Gio Gonzalez (WSH, SP) 228 69 122 92.9 13.8
90 Matt Moore (SF, SP) 227 59 129 93.5 19.0
91 Tyler Anderson (COL, SP) 229 63 144 94.5 16.4
92 Junior Guerra (MIL, SP,RP) 230 72 99 92.0 6.2
93 Jharel Cotton (OAK, SP,RP) 235 59 115 92.7 11.5
94 Adam Ottavino (COL, RP) 237 58 119 96.5 18.9
95 Collin McHugh (HOU, SP) 243 74 112 95.0 8.4
96 Tyson Ross (TEX, SP) 231 74 155 96.8 21.5
97 Ervin Santana (MIN, SP) 246 64 119 97.6 11.7
98 Tyler Glasnow (PIT, SP) 238 52 168 98.9 25.6
99 Jeremy Hellickson (PHI, SP) 258 63 115 100.9 11.6
100 Blake Snell (TB, SP) 261 85 126 103.6 11.7
101 Ian Kennedy (KC, SP) 264 79 128 102.3 11.6
102 Ivan Nova (PIT, SP,RP) 274 66 120 106.1 14.0
103 Hector Neris (PHI, RP) 265 49 152 108.1 24.9
104 Alexander Reyes (STL, SP,RP) 247 36 122 82.7 25.9
105 Tyler Skaggs (LAA, SP) 266 81 134 103.4 15.7
106 Chris Tillman (BAL, SP) 281 80 139 107.7 12.4
107 Trevor Bauer (CLE, SP,RP) 277 61 125 105.4 19.3
108 Jordan Zimmermann (DET, SP) 275 91 147 108.9 12.9
109 Shawn Kelley (WSH, RP) 278 83 127 107.9 13.7
110 Wei-Yin Chen (MIA, SP) 289 96 141 113.8 11.9
111 Mike Leake (STL, SP) 282 98 140 108.8 12.8
112 Andrew Triggs (OAK, SP,RP) 288 89 170 116.4 22.5
113 Bartolo Colon (ATL, SP) 300 97 149 112.4 12.3
114 Mike Montgomery (CHC, SP,RP) 298 87 145 114.5 15.2
115 Matt Andriese (TB, SP,RP) 301 100 171 116.5 18.5
116 Zach Davies (MIL, SP) 303 88 119 109.4 9.1
117 C.J. Edwards (CHC, RP) 287 79 191 115.9 32.9
118 Cameron Bedrosian (LAA, RP) 295 72 136 107.8 20.7
119 Alex Cobb (TB, SP) 294 71 135 108.1 20.7
120 Dylan Bundy (BAL, SP,RP) 291 70 161 110.1 26.0
121 Luke Weaver (STL, SP) 304 79 129 107.6 16.9
122 Jeremy Jeffress (TEX, RP) 299 93 181 115.0 24.1
123 Brandon Maurer (SD, RP) 305 66 196 116.4 37.0
124 David Phelps (MIA, SP,RP) 309 103 166 119.6 20.3
125 Tyler Thornburg (BOS, RP) 313 97 156 122.5 22.3
126 Jim Johnson (ATL, RP) 306 75 152 109.3 25.1
127 Jason Hammel (SP) FA 314 82 135 109.7 16.0
128 Fernando Rodney (ARI, RP) 323 84 144 119.2 15.2
129 Joe Musgrove (HOU, SP) 308 73 133 104.7 18.0
130 Arodys Vizcaino (ATL, RP) DL15 307 66 148 116.8 25.6
131 Addison Reed (NYM, RP) 315 84 131 108.3 18.5
132 Lance Lynn (STL, SP) 330 93 133 118.0 12.8
133 Chris Devenski (HOU, SP,RP) 339 114 147 123.0 11.4
134 Brandon Finnegan (CIN, SP,RP) 329 101 154 123.7 18.6
135 Eduardo Rodriguez (BOS, SP) 340 101 150 123.4 18.5
136 Michael Wacha (STL, SP) 352 110 174 130.9 19.9
137 Jaime Garcia (ATL, SP) 324 94 169 130.5 23.5
138 Michael Foltynewicz (ATL, SP) 344 104 179 136.4 28.9
139 Daniel Straily (MIA, SP) 334 102 175 129.7 24.2
140 Kyle Barraclough (MIA, RP) 345 110 152 125.7 13.1
141 Ty Blach (SF, RP,SP) 327 109 146 117.2 14.4
142 Nate Jones (CWS, RP) 351 111 143 123.2 12.7
143 Francisco Liriano (TOR, SP) 336 90 134 119.8 16.4
144 Alex Wood (LAD, SP) 347 101 194 138.9 31.1
145 Adam Conley (MIA, SP) 368 113 166 134.0 21.0
146 Brandon Kintzler (MIN, RP) 328 78 176 127.2 34.0
147 Jose Berrios (MIN, SP) 338 98 192 147.1 32.6
148 Scott Kazmir (LAD, SP) MiLB 343 101 183 137.6 25.0
149 Daniel Norris (DET, SP) 349 103 178 136.8 29.0
150 Sean Doolittle (OAK, RP) 350 100 151 130.2 16.3
151 Joaquin Benoit (PHI, RP) 342 89 161 130.4 25.0
152 Lucas Giolito (CWS, SP) 346 103 180 145.0 29.7
153 Jeanmar Gomez (PHI, RP) 366 118 182 147.0 25.8
154 Tyler Clippard (NYY, RP) 369 118 188 137.0 29.5
155 Daniel Hudson (PIT, RP) 333 80 189 151.0 50.2
156 Steven Wright (BOS, SP,RP) MiLB 362 102 151 135.5 19.9
157 Glen Perkins (MIN, RP) 367 107 158 138.8 19.9
158 Felipe Rivero (PIT, RP) 358 101 199 148.7 40.1
159 Kevin Quackenbush (SD, RP) 361 113 142 127.5 14.5
160 Archie Bradley (ARI, SP) 389 117 165 146.2 16.6
161 Jose De Leon (TB, SP,RP) 403 124 180 152.0 24.3
162 Miguel Gonzalez (CWS, SP) 379 112 183 151.0 25.6
163 Brandon McCarthy (LAD, SP) MiLB 393 119 170 146.8 18.8
164 Carter Capps (SD, RP) DTD 407 126 173 149.8 16.9
165 Corey Knebel (MIL, RP) 395 112 200 156.0 44.0
166 Tyler Chatwood (COL, SP,RP) 380 114 177 152.8 23.5
167 Yordano Ventura (KC, SP) 405 125 140 132.5 7.5
168 Luis Severino (NYY, SP,RP) 390 116 164 149.8 19.7
169 Mike Fiers (HOU, SP) 373 120 182 152.4 20.1
170 Robert Gsellman (NYM, SP) 408 122 178 156.5 22.2
171 Shelby Miller (ARI, SP) 383 128 175 154.0 15.1
172 Kendall Graveman (OAK, SP) 414 132 195 171.8 22.5
173 Ricky Nolasco (LAA, SP) 435 134 172 155.0 13.6
174 CC Sabathia (NYY, SP) 436 135 185 159.5 17.7
175 Hector Rondon (CHC, RP) 419 138 178 158.0 15.2
176 Ryan Dull (OAK, RP) 422 143 179 157.3 15.2
177 Clay Buchholz (PHI, SP,RP) 441 137 173 160.6 12.7
178 Darren O'Day (BAL, RP) 440 138 161 149.5 11.5
179 Luke Gregerson (HOU, RP) 444 141 193 165.0 18.5
180 Matt Bush (TEX, RP) 430 146 180 160.2 13.2
181 Josh Tomlin (CLE, SP) 445 142 162 152.0 10.0
182 Huston Street (LAA, RP) 447 143 186 166.0 15.8
183 Derek Law (SF, RP) 449 146 172 161.7 11.3
184 Brian Flynn (KC, SP,RP) 451 147 168 157.5 10.5
185 Chad Green (NYY, SP,RP) DL60 479 148 187 166.7 16.0
186 Grant Dayton (LAD, RP) 453 149 171 160.0 11.0
187 Andrew Bailey (LAA, RP) 448 151 181 167.0 12.3
188 Will Harris (HOU, RP) 551 152 187 169.5 17.5
189 Homer Bailey (CIN, SP) 473 154 192 175.8 14.1
190 Keone Kela (TEX, RP) 454 154 182 168.0 14.0
191 Reynaldo Lopez (WSH, SP) 543 155 186 175.3 14.4
192 Zack Wheeler (NYM, SP) 467 155 185 170.5 13.2
193 Jimmy Nelson (MIL, SP) 462 157 183 173.7 11.8
194 Liam Hendriks (OAK, RP) 466 159 184 169.3 10.7
195 Seth Lugo (NYM, SP,RP) 485 166 188 177.0 11.0
196 Doug Fister (HOU, SP,RP) 490 167 189 178.0 11.0
197 Anthony Cingrani (CIN, RP) 498 168 190 179.0 11.0
198 Michael Lorenzen (CIN, SP,RP) 499 169 189 179.0 10.0
199 James Shields (CWS, SP) 512 170 196 183.0 13.0
200 Jhoulys Chacin (SD, SP,RP) MiLB 518 171 198 184.5 13.5
201 Edinson Volquez (MIA, SP) 505 171 172 171.5 0.5
202 Ariel Miranda (SEA, SP,RP) 501 172 191 184.3 8.7
203 Matt Garza (MIL, SP) 521 174 199 186.5 12.5
204 Hyun-Jin Ryu (LAD, SP) 510 175 193 185.0 7.5
205 Wade Miley (BAL, SP) MiLB 527 175 187 181.0 6.0
206 Chad Kuhl (PIT, SP) 519 176 197 184.0 9.3
207 Patrick Corbin (ARI, SP,RP) 513 176 194 185.0 9.0
208 Nick Tropeano (LAA, SP) 515 177 195 186.0 9.0
209 Jake Barrett (ARI, RP) 555 188 198 193.0 5.0