2019 Fantasy Baseball ROS Rankings

Expert Consensus Ranking (11 of 17 Experts) -
Rank Player (Team, Position) Overall Notes
1 Max Scherzer (WSH - SP) IL10 7 1 2 1.0 0.0 4.0 -3.0
Scherzer experienced all kinds of bad luck over the first couple months, but his stats have normalized in a hurry over the summer. He's the best pitcher in baseball and now the stats fully reflect that.
2 Justin Verlander (HOU - SP) 12 2 5 2.8 1.0 21.0 +9.0
Judging solely by his peripheral numbers, Verlander has been quite lucky this year -- he has the lowest BABIP allowed and highest strand rate of any qualified starter in the Majors. But top-tier aces like Verlander are also fully capable of making their own luck. Verlander probably won't be a sub-3.00 ERA pitcher from here on out if he continues pitching like he has been, but he could always take his performance to another level like he did last year -- and he'll still be really valuable even if he doesn't.
3 Gerrit Cole (HOU - SP) 15 1 6 3.1 0.9 27.0 +12.0
While's he's been quite good in his own right, Cole has been overshadowed by teammate Justin Verlander. But the peripheral numbers suggest Cole has actually been the better pitcher. Cole is generating more strikeouts than any other pitcher in the game, and his numbers should become even more dominant over the second half.
4 Jacob deGrom (NYM - SP) 18 2 13 3.9 1.0 10.0 -8.0
DeGrom was never going to repeat last year's 1.70 ERA, but he's still been quite good this year. He's performed like a top-10 starter, if not top-five, but his fantasy value has been hurt by a lack of wins. That could still be a bit of an issue in the second half, but expect his win total to normalize for the most part.
5 Chris Sale (BOS - SP) 17 3 9 4.4 1.0 11.0 -6.0
Sale incited early panic by going 0-4 with an 8.50 ERA through five starts. After a long stretch of vintage dominance, he has reignited those April fears by ceding five runs in three consecutive starts. This slump isn't as alarming since his fastball velocity has jumped back to normal, and the whiffs have followed. He's third in strikeout rate among all starters (34.3%) while wielding a 3.37 FIP and 3.05 SIERA. Those who took a buy-low gamble in April still look poised to receive an ace as a reward for their faith. As for his 3-9 record pitching for the defending champions, that's why gamers are never encouraged to chase wins. One would have to assume he'll straighten out his recent long-ball woes and the Red Sox will eventually offer him more run support.
6 Walker Buehler (LAD - SP) 30 5 27 7.4 1.3 40.0 +10.0
Buehler has lived up to expectations early in his second season, recording a 3.44 ERA and 1.00 WHIP with 120 strikeouts and 17 walks in 110 innings. That's despite a horrid outing at Coors damaging his ratios. As a former Tommy John recipient who tossed 153.1 professional innings last year and plays for the Dodgers, he's highly unlikely to push past 175 innings this season. While that's something to keep in mind down the road, the depleted pool of aces makes him a top-10 starter right now.
7 Blake Snell (TB - SP) 36 5 19 10.2 4.4 28.0 -8.0
Snell was cruising along towards a Cy Young-caliber season until he endured an unfathomable nightmare stretch in which he surrendered 23 earned runs over 17 1/3 innings across five starts. It's hard to say what happened, but thankfully he seems to have rebounded of late. The range of possible outcomes for the second half is quite large for Snell, and the risk factor here needs to be taken into account, but he still has the potential to be a top-five fantasy ace.
8 Zack Greinke (ARI - SP) 38 4 20 10.9 3.6 56.0 +18.0
Despite getting obliterating by the Dodgers (3.2 IP, 7 ER, 4 HR) on Opening Day, Greinke has recorded a 2.95 ERA and 0.95 WHIP this season. The 35-year-old entered 2019 with warning signs, particularly a fastball that dipped below 90 mph in average exit velocity. Those fears have not gone entirely unfounded; his strikeout rate is down to 23.2% with a subpar 9.6% swinging-strike rate. The cerebral pitcher has also issued just 16 walks in 20 starts, so he's still a steady ace who just needs to curtail the long ball to remain a top-15 starter.
9 Luis Castillo (CIN - SP) 37 6 36 10.9 2.9 128.0 +91.0
Castillo has picked up right where he left off last September, when he began dominating hitters. He is generating more swings-and-misses than he did in his first two Big League seasons, providing confidence that the breakout is real. His high walk rate is a little concerning, but Castillo is here to stay as an upper-tier fantasy starter.
10 Stephen Strasburg (WSH - SP) 39 5 24 11.0 4.2 59.0 +20.0
Strasburg is having another one of his typically-dominant seasons, the only question is whether he can stay healthy. He's broken 200 innings just once in his career, and has surpassed 150 in just one of the last four seasons. Still, injuries are difficult to predict, and there's little doubt that Strasburg is a top-12 starter for however long he can avoid the injured list.
11 Trevor Bauer (CLE - SP) 42 6 44 12.2 3.5 31.0 -11.0
Bauer is an elite bat-misser, but he's had a big issue with walks this season. Last season showed the upside Bauer possesses when he is in a groove, but the fact it was the only time he posted a sub-4.00 ERA should give fantasy owners pause.
12 Clayton Kershaw (LAD - SP) 43 10 46 12.6 2.1 54.0 +11.0
Kershaw began 2019 on the IL with left shoulder inflammation, snapping his streak of eight straight Opening Day appearances. It was a concerning development, as the star southpaw has not worked more than 175 frames in any of the last three seasons. He hasn't quite looked like vintage Kershaw in his return, recording a 3.00 ERA and 3.62 FIP with a 23.5% K rate that'd be his lowest since 2008. A slightly regressed Kershaw, however, remains a top-shelf starter when healthy. Even though he's back with plenty of time to recuperate value, investors must still worry about nagging back problems.
13 Hyun-Jin Ryu (LAD - SP) 40 7 51 12.9 5.6 181.0 +141.0
Ryu's been a solid fantasy starter for several years, but he became an elite one last year and has fully carried it over to 2019. There's really no reason to expect major regression from Ryu, so the only real concern is how many innings he'll be able to throw. He hasn't thrown more than 152 innings since he threw 192 as a rookie in 2013, and we all know the Dodgers love to rotate their starters on and off the injured list.
14 Patrick Corbin (WSH - SP) 46 11 20 15.0 2.5 47.0 +1.0
Amid an up-and-down first season with the Nationals, Corbin still carries a stellar 3.39 ERA and 139 strikeouts in 119.1 innings. His slider continues to dominate with a 21 wRC+ and 26.6% swinging-strike rate, but his fastball has gotten clobbered to a 148 wRC+. He has rebounded in resounding fashion after an ugly three-start stretch in late May and early June, so continue to treat him as a borderline top-15 starter living up to his draft-day cost.
15 Charlie Morton (TB - SP) 48 6 40 15.1 6.0 114.0 +66.0
Morton has successfully carried over the improvements he made as a pitcher during his two seasons in Houston. His walk rate can be a bit of an issue at times, but he misses a ton of bats and is also quite adept at limiting hard contact. It remains to be seen how many innings he'll be able to throw -- he's never surpassed 172 -- but he should continue to be an elite fantasy starter as long as he's healthy.
16 Aaron Nola (PHI - SP) 53 8 33 17.4 6.0 25.0 -28.0
Nola investors were undoubtedly getting antsy. After posting a pristine 2.37 ERA in 2018, he opened 2019 with a 4.89 ERA and 1.51 WHIP through 15 troubling starts. A command artist throughout his rise to ace status issued 36 walks in those 81 innings. Just when some were ready to the right flag, the righty kicked into high gear. Over his last six starts, Nola has allowed three earned runs and tallied 43 strikeouts in 35.2 innings. His first-pitch (67.9%) and swinging-strike (12.5%) rates have returned to normal during this dominant stretch. Investors who withered the storm (or bought low) looked poised to enjoy a top-20 ace in the second half.
17 Josh Hader (MIL - RP) 67 8 53 19.6 6.5 105.0 +38.0
Hader is the best reliever in the game and it has become clear that he now has ninth inning duties all to himself in Milwaukee.
18 Shane Bieber (CLE - SP) 64 12 37 19.6 3.5 149.0 +85.0
Bieber is in the midst of a full-fledged breakout, and his peripherals back it up. His combination of elite strikeout and walk rates is a recipe for long-term fantasy success.
19 Kirby Yates (SD - RP) 65 17 42 20.2 3.1 108.0 +43.0
Yates emerged as one of the best fantasy closers out there last year, and he's picked up right where he left off in 2019.
20 Jose Berrios (MIN - SP) 69 7 34 21.3 3.8 73.0 +4.0
Berrios is doing an excellent job of limiting free passes this season, but there isn't much else in his profile to suggest he is experiencing a true breakout. Given his strong surface numbers and high prospect pedigree, he is a potential sell-high candidate.
21 Aroldis Chapman (NYY - RP) 66 9 28 21.4 3.2 70.0 +4.0
Aroldis Chapman has been his typical dominant self again this year and has earned plenty of job security despite a host of other strong relievers in the Bronx.
22 Noah Syndergaard (NYM - SP) 72 12 38 24.3 4.7 35.0 -37.0
Syndergaard has had a frustrating start to 2019, posting a 4.55 ERA through 18 starts. Despite the subpar returns, he still wields a 3.81 FIP with 110 strikeouts and 30 walks in 112.1 innings. Yet even those marks aren't the dominance onlookers expect from a hard-thrower nicknamed after a god, and he's generating the fewest chases and most contact off the plate of his career while often getting burned on two-strike counts. His once lethal slider is also getting rocked. The SP1 upside remains, but the potential buy-low candidate has yet to truly make good on this ceiling.
23 Brad Hand (CLE - RP) 75 10 38 26.0 5.4 81.0 +6.0
Hand has been even better in Cleveland than he was in San Diego. He has forced his way into the top-five closer conversation.
24 Kenley Jansen (LAD - RP) DTD 77 11 41 26.2 4.6 71.0 -6.0
For the second year in a row, Jansen has had some issues with the long ball, but he's still an obvious top-10 closer.
25 Lucas Giolito (CWS - SP) 105 15 168 27.8 9.5 455.0 +350.0
Giolito has finally arrived. After posting a 6.13 ERA last season, the former elite prospect now wields a 3.23 ERA and 1.08 WHIP through 18 starts. His strikeout rate has skyrocketed to 29.4% with help from a dominant changeup and slider. Despite recent hiccups, the 24-year-old righty could end 2019 as one of season's premier waiver-wire finds.
26 Mike Clevinger (CLE - SP) 76 15 44 28.4 7.8 58.0 -18.0
Clevinger missed over two months with a back injury, but he is finally back. He endured a couple rough outings upon returning, but there's still every reason to believe he can be a top-20 fantasy starter from this point forward, if not top-12.
27 James Paxton (NYY - SP) 80 15 41 29.1 5.6 49.0 -31.0
Paxton missed a big chunk of the first half due to knee inflammation, but he's looked like his usual self since returning. Missed time is always part of the equation with Paxton, but he'll be a must-start option whenever he is healthy.
28 Roberto Osuna (HOU - RP) 86 21 40 29.8 5.1 77.0 -9.0
Osuna isn't quite as dominant as some of the other top closers, but he gets the job done with regularity and is in a great spot to pile up saves with helpful ratios.
29 Matthew Boyd (DET - SP) 84 18 45 31.8 9.4 299.0 +215.0
Boyd has emerged from relative obscurity as one of the better pitchers in the American League. His ERA has regressed some over the summer, but given his pristine strikeout-to-walk ratio, it's more likely to improve than worsen going forward.
30 Edwin Diaz (NYM - RP) 99 12 46 32.0 8.4 50.0 -49.0
Diaz's velocity and strikeout rate are just fine, and with a ridiculously high BABIP allowed you could make the case that he's a great buy-low candidate. But there's simply no sugarcoating how bad he's been this season. He still has the upside to be the number one closer over the rest of the season, but it's hard to even consider him a top-10 reliever until we see him right the ship.
31 Felipe Vazquez (PIT - RP) 88 16 44 32.0 6.5 86.0 -2.0
Vazquez is well on his way to a third-straight year as a dominant ninth inning man in Pittsburgh.
32 David Price (BOS - SP) 98 17 58 32.4 5.3 84.0 -14.0
Price missed a couple weeks with elbow tendinitis, but he's been very good this season when healthy, and he appears to be fully recovered from the injury.
33 Craig Kimbrel (CHC - RP) 93 23 47 32.6 4.9 93.0
Kimbrel has had a couple rough outings since joining the Cubs at midseason, but he's been too good for too long to be concerned at this point. He should still be viewed as a top-10 closer for the second half.
34 Mike Minor (TEX - SP) 124 24 162 38.6 7.5 320.0 +196.0
This looks like a different Minor than the man who posted a 4.18 ERA and 20.6 K% last season. He now sports a 2.40 ERA and 110 strikeouts in 112.2 innings. Bolstered velocity and an elite spin rate have led to better success with his four-seam fastball, and all three of his other offerings (slider, changeup, and curveball) have a double-digit swinging-strike rate. Even if a 4.32 SIERA suggests regression is coming once he has to pitch in Arlington all summer, the southpaw has shown more than enough to confidently deploy in all leagues.
35 Jack Flaherty (STL - SP) 127 24 53 39.7 8.9 60.0 -67.0
Buoyed by a lethal slider and a curveball that didn't yield a single extra-base hit in his rookie campaign, there's easy 200-strikeout upside if Flaherty pitches a full season. He's on the right track with 94 in 85.1 innings, but he also carries a 4.75 ERA and 4.74 FIP. His command woes have resurfaced with 21 walks in 54.1 innings since the start of May, and he has ceded nine home runs in June. A burgeoning top-15 ace now instead must prove he's a legitimate top-30 option.
36 Chris Paddack (SD - SP) 111 22 60 39.8 10.5 227.0 +116.0
The plan all along was to limit Paddack's innings total in 2019, and the Padres' decision to send him to the minors was evidence of that plan in action. Paddack is a high-end starter now that he's back, but expect San Diego to take further steps to limit his workload in the second half.
37 Caleb Smith (MIA - SP) 128 28 57 39.9 8.0 395.0 +267.0
Smith was having a breakout season prior to hitting the injured list with hip inflammation, and could be a top-20 fantasy starter in the second half now that he's healthy. He's been a bit fortunate in terms of batted balls in the field of play, and a bit unfortunate in terms of home runs, so that should cancel out and Smith should be able to maintain most of what he's accomplished so far.
38 Mike Soroka (ATL - SP) 129 23 154 40.3 6.2 416.0 +287.0
Soroka has surrendered 24 earned runs over 16 starts this season, bringing his career ERA to 2.51 in 21 big league turns. He's benefited from a .272 BABIP and 6.9% HR/FB rate this season, but the righty also boasts one of baseball's lowest exit velocities against. Even with some regression, he should continue to positive ERA contributions. The strikeouts are nothing special, but the elite command (5.6 BB%) makes him a trustworthy starter going forward.
39 Sean Doolittle (WSH - RP) 110 31 49 41.1 5.2 102.0 -8.0
Sean Doolittle was a borderline top-10 closer to begin the season, and he's back in that range now that he's recovered from the rough stretch he endured in late May.
40 Madison Bumgarner (SF - SP) 116 23 80 41.3 7.4 96.0 -20.0
A dirt-bike accident in 2017 and broken hand suffered last spring limited Bumgarner to 240.2 combined innings in the past two seasons. He had previously exceeded 200 in each of the last six seasons. While he could regain his workhorse label in 2019, the 29-year-old's 3.86 ERA is far above his current season high of 3.37. He has, however, reversed last year's declines in velocity, swinging strikes, strikeouts, and walks. Although no longer an ace, the southpaw still looks like a high-floor SP3 who has excelled since a rough turn against the dangerous Dodgers on June 20. Just don't get too excited about a midseason trade. Any gains in wins by going to a contender by offset by leaving Oracle Park.
41 Masahiro Tanaka (NYY - SP) 115 25 66 41.7 8.4 120.0 +5.0
Investors have already received the full Tanaka experience. Elite at his best, he has yielded just one or zero earned runs in eight starts. He has also allowed at least four runs in five turns, including a six-run shellacking in the first inning at London. Anyone who has rostered the Yankees righty is used to this volatility, but they have stomached it in exchange for elite strikeout rates. This season, however, his K rate has dipped to a career-low 21.0% with a drop in swinging-strike rate (11.0%). Opponents have obliterated his splitter to a .360 wOBA, and he has already served up 14 homers. Tanaka is still a solid starter sporting a 3.74 ERA, but managers must stomach the wild swings in performance.
42 Will Smith (SF - RP) 119 26 78 43.9 7.8 297.0 +178.0
Smith is one of the most underrated fantasy closers in the league. The only question is whether he ends up getting dealt into a set-up role elsewhere by the end of July.
43 Zack Wheeler (NYM - SP) IL10 117 18 66 44.2 7.7 85.0 -32.0
Wheeler was nearly as good as Jacob deGrom after last year's All-Star break, boasting a 1.68 ERA and 20.4 K-BB% in 11 starts. All that promise made his grueling start all the more disappointing. Investors might have panicked after he issued a 6.35 ERA in four starts, but he has since lowered that mark to 4.69 while notching 130 strikeouts in 119 innings. Although continually did in by home runs and one bad inning, he has emerged into a rare workhorse who has thrown at least six frames in 15 of his last 17 turns. Armed with a 3.66 FIP, he still looks like the breakout candidate many drafted as a top-25 starter. He's not expected to miss significant time with shoulder fatigue, but the timing damages the chances of getting traded at the deadline. Fantasy managers, however, could use his struggles and injury to acquire him at well below face value.
44 Brandon Woodruff (MIL - SP,RP) 142 13 179 48.3 37.5 276.0 +134.0
Despite recording a 5.81 ERA through his first five starts, Woodruff has a 3.53 ERA on the season. He sports a 2.98 FIP and 28.7% K rate for the contending Brewers with one of baseball's bests four-seam fastball and sinker. Anyone who added him after his April showers deserves props. Although still a bit too volatile for comfort - he has a 4.78 ERA in June - Woodruff is an impact arm who could reach his ace ceiling down the stretch.
45 German Marquez (COL - SP) 136 9 72 48.8 13.9 82.0 -54.0
Coors Field has claimed another victim. A source of heated debate before and during the season, Marquez overcome his surroundings with help from a favorable early schedule featuring trips to Miami and San Francisco. More exposure to his home park has deflated the breakout potential; he has a 7.07 ERA and .336 opposing average at Coors Field compared to a 3.33 ERA and .205 opposing average on the road. He may be a top-20 ace if pitching for another team, but the high altitude won't allow him to flourish as a top fantasy option. After surrendering 11 runs against the Giants, managers can only start him on the road.
46 Jake Odorizzi (MIN - SP) 137 37 121 49.9 6.3 448.0 +311.0
We can't ignore Odorizzi's success forever. A pitcher who posted an ERA of 4.14 and 4.49 in the last two years, respectively, now boasts a 3.15 ERA and 96 strikeouts in 88.2 innings. Even that's after some overdue regression; he allowed 16 earned runs in four starts before going on the IL with a blister prior to the All-Star break. He had permitted four long balls despite a 50.3% fly-ball rate through 13 starts, so it was hardly surprising to see him cede six long balls in those last four turns. The rough patch and injury have likely closed any sell-high window, but he has also made enough gains to return as a serviceable option.
47 Ken Giles (TOR - RP) DTD 134 30 74 50.2 11.7 144.0 +10.0
Giles has had a major career resurgence north of the border and looks to be a top-15 fantasy closer going forward. It will be worth watching to see if he is moved at the trade deadline, however.
48 Robbie Ray (ARI - SP) 150 30 67 52.2 11.8 116.0 -34.0
Everything went right for Ray in 2017, when he registered a 2.89 ERA despite a 3.94 BB/9 and 3.72 FIP. An oblique strain limited him to just 123.2 innings in 24 starts last season, and 70 walks led to a 3.93 ERA and 1.35 WHIP. After initially resembling the better model, he carries a 3.96 ERA and 1.13 WHIP into the All-Star break. He remains just as tough to hit with a .222 batting average, but a 4.64 BB/9 continues to cause him trouble. Enjoy the strikeouts, but expect a volatile ERA and bloated WHIP.
49 Shane Greene (DET - RP) 139 37 100 52.7 12.9 249.0 +110.0
Greene is having easily the best season of his career, and he's fully capable of remaining an above-average fantasy closer as long as he isn't traded to a team that uses him in a set-up capacity.
50 Kyle Hendricks (CHC - SP) 149 36 76 53.1 9.8 126.0 -23.0
His success defies common convention, so it was hard not to freak out over Hendricks surrendering a 5.33 ERA through five starts. Could the bottom finally be falling out for a finesse pitcher who operates in the mid-80s? Nope. A .405 BABIP and 58.8% strand rate fueled that rough beginning, and The Professor has quickly corrected course. His ERA recovered to 3.36 before landing on the IL with right shoulder inflammation. Expecting to return before the All-Star break, he's a dependable SP3 to use with full confidence when healthy.
51 Domingo German (NYY - SP,RP) 153 40 77 53.2 10.2 363.0 +210.0
After posting a 5.57 ERA and 10.72 K/9 last season, German's dominant strikeout rate (10.89) came with the ERA to match (2.37) this April. It has since risen to 3.86 after allowing 14 runs in his last three start. The Yankees placed him on the IL with left hip flexor strain. He's expected to return July 3rd against the Mets. While the regression writing was on the wall, the short absence could help him return healthy and avoid getting shut down due to an innings limit later in the season.
52 Sonny Gray (CIN - SP) 154 43 153 56.4 8.9 268.0 +114.0
Maybe Gray just needed to get away from the Yankees. The righty has rebounded from a lost 2018 with a 3.40 ERA and 1.13 WHIP in 19 starts. That doesn't even begin to properly display his dominance, as the 28-year-old has recorded 120 strikeouts in 103.1 innings with a 55.5% ground-ball rate and 3.35 FIP. Gray, who owns of a career 3.63 ERA, has gone from a sneaky waiver-wire find to an unheralded ace.
53 Alex Colome (CWS - RP) 138 36 92 57.0 10.5 203.0 +65.0
Colome has sealed 20 of 21 save opportunities with a 2.39 ERA as the White Sox's closer. While there's no job controversy, he's pitching above his 3.93 FIP and 4.39 SIERA. He's a useful option for now, but it's possible he gets traded into another team's setup role before the trade deadline. Fantasy managers with saves to spare should try to cash out now.
54 Raisel Iglesias (CIN - RP) PL 141 28 87 59.1 16.0 125.0 -16.0
Iglesias has had a rocky season, as hasn't even been used as the Reds' exclusive closer. But his track record and recent form give renewed hope that he can have a strong second half, whether it's in Cincinnati or elsewhere.
55 Kenta Maeda (LAD - SP) 155 42 96 61.2 11.8 175.0 +20.0
Maeda has a great ballpark and lineup supporting him, but his strikeout rate is down and he does struggle with walks at times. Knowing the Dodgers, he could also find himself on the injured list with a minor ailment at some point in the second half.
56 Hector Neris (PHI - RP) 167 32 152 66.4 31.2 503.0 +336.0
Early in the season, it appeared Gabe Kapler was going to play the ninth inning by ear. While Neris didn't receive many opportunities early in the season, that was has only because the Phillies kept either winning big or losing. Clearly the undisputed closer, he has recorded 12 of his 17 saves since May 15. However, his ERA has ballooned to 4.08 by allowing nine runs in his last nine outings. He's still an elite source of strikeouts, but a prolonged slump could put his status as Philadelphia's undisputed closer in jeopardy.
57 Cole Hamels (CHC - SP) IL10 162 48 118 68.6 20.5 146.0 -16.0
While Hamels didn't have the most consistent start to 2019, he carried over last year's turnaround with the Cubs by compiling a 2.98 ERA and 97 strikeouts in 99.2 innings. He was one of few veteran workhorses paying off their draft capital, but an oblique injury sent him to the IL to start June. He's awaiting results of an MRI, so stay tuned for the lefty's status. He was looking like a formidable top-40 starter when healthy.
58 Jon Lester (CHC - SP) 164 41 85 69.3 8.4 161.0 -3.0
A clear regression candidate, Lester once again got off to a tremendous start. Despite posting a 1.16 ERA through seven starts, it has ballooned to 3.72 at the All-Star break. That overall mark is still solid, and it's accompanied by improvements in walks and strikeouts. Yet his contact and swinging-strike rates are still alarming, and a .333 xwOBA is only a tad below last year's .340. There's still a chance he turns the corner. After falling off the map last year, he rebounded with a stellar September. Lester is a decent depth piece for those who temper expectations.
59 Joe Musgrove (PIT - SP) 183 52 116 70.4 17.1 208.0 +25.0
Musgrove initially pleased drafters who felt they snagged the perfect late-round flier with sneaky upside. They have since (this writer included) learned a valuable lesson about taking early victory laps. He exited April with a pristine 1.54 ERA, but it has jumped to 4.13 because of a disastrous May. He still possesses a 3.52 FIP and 11.4% swinging-strike rate while allowing one run one no walks in three starts before the All-Star break. The strong beginning may have set expectations too high, but Musgrove could still return to top-50 territory.
60 Joey Lucchesi (SD - SP) 173 52 93 71.7 11.4 196.0 +23.0
While Lucchesi hasn't taken the leap yet, he once again brandishes promising numbers behind a 3.94 ERA. The 26-year-old lefty has tallied 92 strikeouts, 26 walks, and a 47.1% ground-ball rate in 96 innings. His changeup/curveball hybrid remains a terrific putaway pitch, but his cutter has only led to trouble. Given the strikeouts, simply pitching to his 3.75 FIP would make him a worthy fantasy option. Heck, even an ERA around 4.00 is playable this year with a low WHIP and plenty of strikeouts. Although he might remain a bit of an enigma, there's upside.
61 Kyle Gibson (MIN - SP) 174 53 112 72.1 13.7 293.0 +119.0
A sneaky breakout candidate for years, Gibson has procured 94 strikeouts and 28 walks in 94.1 innings. He is missing more bats while tossing far more first-pitch strikes, both of which create a blueprint to sustained success. His 4.09 ERA and 1.26 WHIP are both playable during this season of enhanced power, especially since the Twins hurler is getting loads of run support and can constantly feast on feeble AL Central offenses. The righty should at least be rostered in all leagues.
62 Eduardo Rodriguez (BOS - SP) 187 47 115 72.2 17.4 150.0 -37.0
Rodriguez is an intriguing option when healthy, and he's well on his way to reaching 140 innings for the first time in his career. The results have been shaky, as his 4.65 ERA and 1.34 WHIP have yet to recover from a brutal start. He has still recorded 106 strikeouts through 102.2 innings at the break and is among MLB's leaders in soft contact. There are still signs of a breakout, but the southpaw lacks the consistency to reach his ceiling anytime soon. If he stays healthy, Rodriguez is more a high-strikeout SP4 or 5 to use carefully in the right matchups.
63 Jon Gray (COL - SP) 182 59 90 76.4 9.0 190.0 +8.0
Anyone could be forgiven for giving up on Gray, whose ERA climbed as high as 4.74 in May without the typically low FIP. Coors can't take the blame for his volatility; he has posted a 3.35 ERA at home and a 4.29 ERA on the road this season. His Jekyll and Hyde profile has persisted into 2019, but he has lured buyers back in with a strong stretch before the All-Star break. He lowered his ERA to 3.92 at the All-Star break with six runs allowed in four starts. Having collected 115 strikeouts in 108 innings, he might be worth the hassle for daring managers. However, this is likely another hot streak rather than the long-awaited breakout.
64 Yu Darvish (CHC - SP) 189 35 113 76.7 18.8 143.0 -46.0
Arthroscopic elbow surgery limited Darvish to eight starts in 2018. Adding insult to injury, he wasn't even good (4.95 ERA) in his brief time on the mound. He looked just as bad for most of 2019. The righty has relinquished 50 walks and 20 homers in 109 innings, an unenviable combination that has led to a 4.46 ERA. Yet he has harnessed his command with just six walks in his past seven outings. Also lost in his early troubles, the oft-injured righty has stayed healthy. He's the ultimate boom-or-bust starter whose diminished value is slowly inching back up after consecutive two-hit scoreless turns.
65 Greg Holland (ARI - RP) 175 49 130 76.9 21.6 289.0 +114.0
Holland has been playing with fire all year with a walk rate over 5.00, and that and his propensity to surrender home runs have come back to haunt him lately. He's suddenly on shaky ground in terms of job security.
66 Liam Hendriks (OAK - RP) 195 49 95 69.6 14.3    
Hendriks will serve as Oakland's closer while Blake Treinen is out with a strained rotator cuff. He currently boasts a 1.49 ERA with 50 strikeouts in 42.1 innings, so grab him now if needing saves. It wouldn't be surprising if Treinen requires a bit of an extended absence.
67 Wade Davis (COL - RP) 192 54 103 80.0 14.3 121.0 -71.0
With a walk rate well over 5.00, Davis has predictably begun to unravel in hitter-friendly Coors Field. It's no certainty he'll hold onto the closer job much longer, and he'll likely hurt your ratios quite a bit even if he does.
68 Miles Mikolas (STL - SP) 202 25 108 71.4 20.3 98.0 -104.0
Four starts into the season, Mikolas had yet to record more strikeouts than runs allowed. While he has looked better on occasion, some rough starts have kept his ERA at an inflated 4.53 with the same middling 6.8 K/9. Even if he settles down to post an ERA below 4.00, the lack of strikeouts makes him more of a deep-league arm unlikely to recoup his high draft cost.
69 Lance Lynn (TEX - SP) 188 27 96 58.9 20.9 551.0 +363.0
Lynn has a 2.98 FIP and 123 strikeouts in 115 innings, tossing 10 quality starts in his last 11 outings before the All-Star break. Perhaps this is for real. Let's not forget about his 3.43 ERA in 2017 before signing late in 2018 and never finding the strike zone. He also only has a 3.91 ERA and is set to pitch in the Arlington heat this summer, but the 32-year-old has firmly pitched his way onto all mixed-league rosters as a top-50 starter.
70 Luke Jackson (ATL - RP) 196 51 97 71.8 12.1    
With Arodys Vizcaino out for the season and A.J. Minter briefly optioned to Triple-A, Jackson became the clear closer in Atlanta. He has handled the role well so far, notching 14 saves with a 2.66 ERA and 59 strikeouts in 44 innings. The 27-year-old no longer needs to worry about the Braves bringing back Craig Kimbrel, so Jackson needs to be owned everywhere. He could become a top-15 option by tempering the long balls. Just keep an eye on the recently recalled Minter and/or a deadline deal.
71 Shohei Ohtani (LAA - SP,DH) 104 27 60 42.5 9.8 171.0 +67.0
We've now seen 162 games played so far in Ohtani's career and he has produced loads of power to go with speed, and plenty of runs and RBIs along with a terrific batting average. To put it plainly, this type of production is only reserved for top 20 fantasy hitters.
72 Carlos Martinez (STL - SP,RP) 179 42 131 82.3 27.2 194.0 +15.0
Martinez could become St. Louis' closer with Jordan Hicks (torn ACL) out for the season. The former ace wasn't generating much fantasy value as a middle reliever, but that could change. If anything, he's now better off staying in the bullpen than returning to the rotation, a notion the team recently shut down. He could make a top-20 closer with a high strikeout ceiling if given the chance, so add him now.
73 Dallas Keuchel (ATL - SP) 211 56 117 84.0 17.3 183.0 -28.0
After a frustratingly long delay, Keuchel signed with the Braves on June 6. He has since posted a 3.60 ERA in four starts, but that has come with just 12 strikeouts in 25 innings. Despite his fastball already operating below 90 mph, the southpaw hasn't regained his full velocity. Still a capable veteran who's excellent at inducing ground balls, he'll help the Braves more than fantasy managers until he can muster a passable strikeout rate.
74 Hansel Robles (LAA - RP) 194 50 92 75.3 9.5 828.0 +634.0
Robles is now the Angels' undisputed closer. Gamers can't ignore someone compiling saves with a 2.74 ERA ERA and 24.9% K rate. Just beware his fly-ball woes could eventually lead to catastrophe. His 6.0% HR/FB rate is well below his 11.5% career norm, and that's especially improbable to last in a season where everyone is homering at historic rates. He should be rostered in all leagues, but don't be shocked if he's hit hard in a couple of blow-up outings during the second half.
75 Yonny Chirinos (TB - SP,RP) 198 42 149 77.4 29.6 411.0 +213.0
Chirinos piggybacked off the opener early in the season before settling into Tampa Bay's rotation. He has posted a 3.15 ERA and 0.99 WHIP at the All-Star break, but a 4.28 FIP with 81 strikeouts in 100 innings aren't as bullish over his second-half outcome. Primarily a three-pitch hurler, he has generated tremendous success from his slider and splitter along with a passable sinker. Although likely to regress and brandishing limited strikeout with a sinker serving as his primary pitch, Chirinos is a solid depth piece for a mixed-league rotation.
76 Jose Quintana (CHC - SP) 216 57 107 77.6 13.2 165.0 -51.0
Quintana appeared to turn a corner early in 2019, posting a 2.33 ERA in eight starts after getting clobbered for eight runs at Milwaukee. He has since stumbled again, allowing 42 hits and 26 runs in 30.1 innings. After flaunting strikeout upside in April, he has 38 punchouts in his last 11 outings. He now has a 4.50 ERA, 1.40 WHIP, and 19.5 K% this season, giving the look of a mere matchup play in standard mixed leagues.
77 Blake Treinen (OAK - RP) 208 14 118 79.1 21.7 62.0 -146.0
Treinen has already allowed as many walks (21) and more than double the earned runs (16) than in all of his breakout 2018 (seven). His K% also dropped from an elite 31.8% to 23.1% before going on the IL with a strained rotator cuff. Although he quickly returned, he surrendered two walks and a game-deciding run in his first game back. In a quick about-face, Oakland is letting the red-hot Liam Hendriks keep the closer's job. Hold Treinen for now.
78 Max Fried (ATL - SP,RP) IL10 201 44 97 67.9 13.6 521.0 +320.0
Lost in the shuffle of Atlanta's plethora of young pitchers, injuries opened a door for Fried to join the rotation. He has answered the call to action with a 4.08 ERA in 103.2 innings. While the WHIP (1.39) is high and the ERA keeps rising following a stellar beginning, he is starting to miss more bats with three secondary pitches each netting swinging-strike rates of 11.5% or higher. A 3.86 FIP and 3.45 xFIP suggest recent regression swung too far in the other direction, so he should settle down into an effective fantasy starter when returning from a blister injury.
79 Taylor Rogers (MIN - RP) 230 41 102 83.1 14.5 587.0 +357.0
Expected to serve the light side of a committee when lefties emerged in the ninth, Rogers leads the Twins with 12 saves at the All-Star break. He picked up two in the last week before the intermission, so perhaps a 1.82 ERA and 27.4 K-BB% have earned him a fuller closer share. The southpaw is worth rostering in all mixed leagues, but expect Minnesota to pursue high-impact relievers such as Ken Giles near the trade deadline.
80 Griffin Canning (LAA - SP) 233 50 115 83.8 16.1 746.0 +513.0
Canning has notched a 4.43 ERA and 1.09 WHIP in 12 starts with the Angels. He has compiled 69 strikeouts in 65 frames with an elite 14.5% swinging-strike rate and 68.7% opposing contact rate. After stumbling a bit before the All-Star break, the rookie is no longer a must-own in even the shallowest of mixed leagues. But he's still an intriguing strikeout option.
81 Chris Archer (PIT - SP) 203 41 105 84.0 14.6 124.0 -79.0
Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice, well, look at all those strikeouts. Fool me three times … but what about his FIP? Archer looked poised to finally reverse his fortune before ceding six runs to the Dodgers, ballooning his ERA back to familiar heights at 4.33. He then went on the IL with right thumb inflammation. He has gotten shelled since returning and now has a 5.49 ERA with the highest FIP (5.91) of all qualified starters. While Archer continues to strike out over a batter per frame (10.07 K/9), his command has waned (4.69 BB/9) while trading ground balls for fly balls. The 30-year-old's mixed-league viability is officially in the danger zone.
82 Andrew Heaney (LAA - SP) 223 68 152 86.8 25.2 189.0 -34.0
Early elbow discomfort pushed back Heaney's 2019 debut. While he has a 5.18 ERA and 5.03 FIP through eight starts, he has also registered 49 strikeouts in 41.2 innings. His curveball is on point, posting a superb 21.4% swinging-strike rate. The 28-year-old southpaw has shown the upside that made him popular after notching a 4.15 ERA with a strikeout per frame last season. Despite the early long-ball woes, he's interesting enough to roster if still available.
83 Brad Peacock (HOU - RP,SP) IL10 209 55 119 96.0 15.6 247.0 +38.0
Since allowing seven runs to the forceful Twins on May 2, Peacock posted a 2.01 ERA in seven starts. He then ceded 16 runs in the last four outings before going on the IL with shoulder discomfort. Regression from his dominant May seemed likely, as a subpar 8.8% swinging-strike rate doesn't support his 89 punchouts in 85 innings. Also, apparently no pitcher is immune to gopheritis in 2019. He's still a useful piece to roster in all leagues when he returns.
84 Marcus Stroman (TOR - SP) 228 62 142 92.8 25.6 277.0 +49.0
Not given much attention in 2019 drafts, Stroman made the All-Star team sporting a 3.18 ERA and 57.5% ground-ball rate. The strikeouts (81 in 104.2 IP) are nothing exciting, and a 3.82 FIP aligns nearly perfectly with his career 3.81 ERA. Expect a bit of a second-half decline that would make the 28-year-old righty more of a depth piece to use in the right spots.
85 Nick Pivetta (PHI - SP) 249 56 120 95.8 16.1 151.0 -98.0
Most metrics painted Pivetta as the perfect breakout pick. On the strength of a stellar 19.7 K-BB%, he posted a 3.80 FIP and 3.51 SIERA despite a bloated 4.77 ERA in 2018. That made his abhorrent start to 2019 all the more frustrating. The polarizing pitcher had acquiesced 31 hits and 18 runs in 18.1 nightmarish innings prior to his demotion. Since dominating the Dodgers and Reds shortly after his return, he has served up seven homers in three starts, all against NL East competition. Because of his weak fastball, the erratic righty may never be trustworthy on a game-by-game basis. He'll tempt managers with a gem every now and then, but he does too much damage at his worst to trust.
86 J.A. Happ (NYY - SP) 225 43 157 89.4 31.6 131.0 -94.0
Heading into 2019, Happ owned a 3.49 ERA and 8.45 K/9 over the past four seasons. Many drafters nevertheless scoffed at him going around the pick-150 range, which seemed like a reasonable price for someone who accompanied his career-high 193 strikeouts with a career-high 10.3% swinging-strike rate and career-low 78.3% contact rate in 2018. Yet it appears the skeptics were right. The 36-year-old has coughed up a 5.23 ERA and 5.49 FIP, which is especially concerning since he has faced the Orioles in four of 16 starts. A velocity decline has led to a markedly depreciated strikeout rate (18.6%) and more hard hits. Happ could still turn the corner to post a low-fours ERA and stockpile wins for the Yankees, but he's no more than an unreliable streamer in 12-team mixed leagues.
87 Zac Gallen (MIA - SP) 197 54 102 79.3 14.1 1,016.0 +819.0
Gallen garnered a 1.77 ERA, 112 strikeouts, and 17 walks in 91.1 Triple-A innings before getting promoted on June 19. He hasn't quite met the hype, posting a 4.24 ERA and 1.53 WHIP in four starts. He has 21 strikeouts but 10 walks in uneven innings, which is to be expected from a neophyte. These command woes aren't his norm, so the upside remains, especially pitching in Miami's spacious park.
88 Corey Kluber (CLE - SP) IL60 224 49 110 80.3 20.0 24.0 -200.0
Kluber had averaged 218 innings and 245 strikeouts with a 2.85 ERA in the last five seasons, but his streak of stability ended this year due to a line-drive comebacker fracturing his forearm. Two months after getting sidelined, he was cleared to play catch, which at least creates hope of him returning in time to make a second-half impact. He threw a successful bullpen session on July 18 but remains several weeks away from potentially beginning a rehab assignment.
89 Ross Stripling (LAD - SP,RP) 227 61 129 93.4 19.9 192.0 -35.0
Despite posting a 3.07 ERA in five starts, Stripling moved to the bullpen with Rich Hill rejoining the Dodgers' rotation. This known risk deflated the cost of a potential top-25 starter, and he never stood much of a chance at working more than 160 frames. Rich Hill's injury gave him another run as a starter, but he has yet to record an out past the fifth inning. There's enough upside to roster him in most mixed leagues.
90 Wade Miley (HOU - SP) 256 63 156 102.4 24.8 358.0 +102.0
After tossing a strong start at Coors Field before the All-Star break, Miley boasts a 2.96 ERA in 34 starts dating back to last year. The limited strikeout numbers limit his fantasy worth, but his 7.6 K/9 has risen to a reasonable level. It's getting tougher to ignore his success, especially when buoyed by Houston's lineup. The 32-year-old should remain a solid source of wins and ERA. Just don't be shocked if regression eventually strikes.
91 Jose Leclerc (TEX - RP) 241 39 118 94.9 15.8 118.0 -123.0
Leclerc, who went all of August and September without yielding a run last year, already allowed as many in April (10) as all of 2018. Saddled with a 1.50 WHIP, barely lower than last year's 1.56 ERA, the Rangers removed him from the ninth-inning role. That demotion didn't look like it would last long once he rediscovered his past dominance with a 2.13 ERA and 50.0% K rate in May. A shakier June, however, has delayed his path back to the ninth inning. He's still likely to take the job back from Shawn Kelley sometime this season, but the reset may no longer be imminent.
92 Roenis Elias (SEA - RP) 270 66 124 105.1 12.7 771.0 +501.0
Seattle's closer, for now, Elias has etched out a 3.55 ERA, 38 strikeouts, and 10 saves in 38 innings. While managers must walk with Elias (16 BBs) far too often, he enjoyed a streak of eight consecutive hitless innings in June. He's worth adding for cheap saves while Hunter Strickland remains sidelined with a lat injury.
93 Brendan McKay (TB - 1B,SP) MiLB 252 76 114 91.2 14.1 807.0 +555.0
The Rays are promoting McKay to start Saturday. Prior to his promotion, the two-way star batted .265/.400/.551 in 60 Triple-A appearances. More impressively, he posted a 1.35 ERA and 88 strikeouts in 66.2 minor league innings. Like Shohei Ohtani, he's separated into a hitter and pitcher in Yahoo leagues. The pitching version is worth adding immediately, but he's not guaranteed to stay in the majors for the long haul. (See Nate Lowe.
94 Carlos Carrasco (CLE - SP) IL10 244 17 122 80.0 38.9 36.0 -208.0
A month after being sidelined indefinitely with a blood condition, Carrasco revealed that was diagnosed with leukemia. He described the condition as "under control," but his fantasy value is the furthest thing from anyone's mind now. While he still hopes to return this season, nobody should count on him pitching in 2019.
95 Emilio Pagan (TB - RP) 299 55 167 104.3 29.3 804.0 +505.0
With Jose Alvarado on personal leave and Diego Castillo out with a shoulder injury, Pagan is the last man standing in Tampa Bay's closer committee. That doesn't necessarily mean he'll receive all of the save opportunities, but the chance makes him someone to add. He also wields a 1.23 ERA, 0.82 WHIP, and 36 saves in 29.1 innings. Even a handful of saves would make him a viable asset in all mixed leagues.
96 Shawn Kelley (TEX - RP) 295 83 133 104.3 13.2 864.0 +569.0
Perceived as a seat-filler until Jose Leclerc reclaimed his job, Kelley has compiled 11 saves with a 3.00 ERA, 32 strikeouts, and five walks in 33 innings. He's far too prone to the long ball for a closer pitching in Arlington, so expect his ERA to rise. Yet he might have built up a little bit of a leash in the final frame. Ride the 35-year-old for now.
97 Ryan Pressly (HOU - RP) 258 55 118 96.5 14.8 316.0 +58.0
Pressly may not be Houston's closer, but he's still an elite middle reliever worth rostering for strikeouts and ratios. He posted a 1.36 ERA and 0.78 WHIP through the first half while stockpiling 47 strikeouts to just six walks. The 30-year-old wields three superb pitches (fastball, slider, and curveball) that generate helpings of whiffs and ground balls. He could be this year's version of Adam Ottavino, only better.
98 Sergio Romo (MIA - SP,RP) 283 89 137 113.5 17.1 399.0 +116.0
 
99 Julio Urias (LAD - SP) 269 71 128 99.3 19.4 266.0 -3.0
Urias doesn't qualify as a rookie but if he were, we might be talking about the best rookie pitcher in baseball. He looks tremendous to start the year and will carry fantasy owners as long as the Dodgers allow him to remain in the rotation.
100 Pablo Lopez (MIA - SP,RP) IL10 273 76 129 99.5 21.9 498.0 +225.0
Just as he began to turn a corner, posting a 2.27 ERA in six starts after getting ransacked for 10 runs by the Mets, Lopez landed on the IL with a shoulder injury. He's awaiting results of tests to reveal its severity. A 3.52 FIP, 17.5 K-BB% rate and 48.8% ground-ball rate all pointed to him morphing into a mixed-league mainstay, so try to make room for Lopez on the IL or bench. It's reasonable to drop him in smaller leagues if in a roster bind.
101 Tyler Mahle (CIN - SP) 307 92 117 99.5 8.6 636.0 +329.0
Mahle has one of the better strikeout-to-walk ratios in the game, and even though he is a little homer-prone, his peripherals fully back up his mid-3.00s ERA. The breakout is real.
102 Spencer Turnbull (DET - SP) 259 71 149 100.3 23.0 813.0 +554.0
 
103 Nathan Eovaldi (BOS - SP) IL60 246 69 153 102.7 25.4 159.0 -87.0
Eovaldi hasn't pitched since April after undergoing surgery to remove loose bodies in his right elbow. He posted a 6.00 ERA before landing on the IL, so the hard-throwing, but erratic righty was not an essential stash in standard mixed leagues. That, however, was before news of Boston planning to bring him back as its closer. He gave a small taste of what he could accomplish in that role when allowing three hits and one earned run in eight postseason inning. This news make him a top stash.
104 Rick Porcello (BOS - SP) 235 63 159 102.8 31.2 148.0 -87.0
Porcello appeared to settle down after a rough start. That was before allowing five runs in three of his last six turns. It's time to accept the former - look away, Kate Upton - AL Cy Young Award winner for who he is: a replacement-level innings-eater who can't be expected to deliver an ERA below 4.00. The strikeouts (76 in 93.2 IP) are also down, and those counting on the Red Sox leading him to victories have received another reminded of the stat's futility. This makes him no more than a streamer in the typical 10- or 12-team mixed league.
105 Tyler Glasnow (TB - SP,RP) IL60 265 31 121 103.0 15.0 162.0 -103.0
Looking like a lost cause in Pittsburgh, Glasnow was taking a seismic leap into ace territory with the Rays. He went 6-1 with a 1.86 ERA, 55 Ks, and nine BBs in eight starts before suffering a forearm strain that was supposed to sideline him four-to-six weeks. The Rays transferred him to the 60-day IL, and he has suffered a setback in late June weeks before his potential return. He's now shut down until August, meaning a 2019 return is no longer a certainty. He's no longer an essential stash.
106 Marco Gonzales (SEA - SP) 268 65 156 104.8 33.2 229.0 -39.0
 
107 Jordan Yamamoto (MIA - SP) 301 85 134 105.0 16.2 1,040.0 +739.0
An unheralded prospect who jumped straight from Double-A to the big, Yamamoto has surprisingly excelled right off the bat. The 23-year-old righty has recorded a 1.89 ERA in six starts, tallying 34 strikeouts in as many innings. He doesn't throw hard, and an 8.7% SwStr rate won't allow him to maintain those strikeouts. He has also issued two-four walks in each turn, so expect regression once his .190 BABIP regresses.
108 Michael Pineda (MIN - SP) 247 69 174 115.4 29.6 329.0 +82.0
Since returning from a bout of knee tendinitis, Pineda has posted a 2.95 ERA in seven starts. He allowed just one run in five of them and has collected 37 strikeouts to five walks in 39.2 innings. Although typically a maddening option, the 30-year-old righty could settle into a steady hand - or at least a valuable source of WHIP - away from Yankee Stadium. He's worth adding in all mixed leagues.
109 Brandon Workman (BOS - RP) 303 86 155 113.7 25.5    
 
110 Blake Parker (MIN - RP) 294 77 111 106.3 3.4 382.0 +88.0
Although everyone wanted Trevor May to close for Minnesota, the honor has instead mostly gone to Parker. He has recorded a team-high 10 saves but a 3.77 ERA and 5.72 FIP aren't pretty. He's bound to experience some regression once his BABIP and strand rate return to the mean, and the AL Central-leading Twins should bolster their bullpen before the trade deadline.
111 Dinelson Lamet (SD - SP) 311 93 108 99.2 6.8 514.0 +203.0
 
112 Luis Severino (NYY - SP) IL60 293 37 160 100.6 42.1 68.0 -225.0
Already sidelined through April with a shoulder injury, Severino also suffered a Grade 2 lat strain. He suffered yet another setback after throwing off the mound and is now not expected back until late August at the earliest. If he returns, he'll do so with a limited pitch count or as a reliever. At this point, it'd be understandable to drop him if not holstering an available IL spot.
113 Matt Barnes (BOS - RP) 280 81 125 110.8 9.5 205.0 -75.0
Barnes isn't receiving save opportunities in Boston, and he has allowed 11 runs and nine walks during a disastrous June. An elite 40.9% strikeout rate has made him worth rostering even without closing, but it's awfully tough to hang on to a struggling setup man in standard mixed leagues.
114 A.J. Minter (ATL - RP) 321 92 131 111.0 16.4 275.0 -46.0
Minter was supposed to be in the heat of the competition for saves in Atlanta, and while that may happen down the road, an injury setback for him has handed the job over to Vizcaino. Unless you play in a deeper league, this should make Minter undraftable, but worth keeping an eye on in free agency.
115 Trevor Williams (PIT - SP) 288 78 135 102.0 22.3 292.0 +4.0
 
116 Mychal Givens (BAL - RP) 248 67 169 114.2 29.4 255.0 +7.0
Having recorded just four saves through two months, Givens was never technically fully in as Baltimore's closer. Either way, he's now out of save situations after getting gashed to a 5.56 ERA and 1.50 WHIP in 22.2 innings. Those truly desperate for saves no longer need to hold onto him, or any Orioles reliever for that matter.
117 Luke Weaver (ARI - SP) IL10 272 69 133 90.3 25.1 310.0 +38.0
Weaver was in the midst of a big breakout, but his season was derailed when he suffered a strained flexor pronator and UCL in his throwing arm. A timetable for his return is unclear, but he should be out for at least 6-8 weeks if not the rest of the season.
118 Anibal Sanchez (WSH - SP) 316 78 147 105.6 27.0 294.0 -22.0
Sanchez has submitted a 2.29 ERA, 32 strikeouts, and five walks in six starts since returning from a hamstring strain. The veteran sported a 2.82 ERA last season, and he's among MLB leaders in average exit velocity against. While he's currently pitching over his head, he's a solid back-end depth piece and strong matchup play.
119 Trevor Richards (MIA - SP) 309 92 111 106.6 7.3 357.0 +48.0
Richards carried a 4.42 ERA with 4 wins last year and formerly played independent baseball after going undrafted. It helps, however, that he has the best changeup in baseball. Richards' changeup is Trevor Hoffman-esque. It carried a 41.2% whiff rate with a .214 xWOBA. It certainly helped his performance when he adjusted by throwing it 38% of the time instead of 23% of the time at the start of the season. In those closing months, hitters were so focused on his filthy change-up that his slider suddenly became even more deadly than the changeup. With two of the most useful pitches in baseball, Richards could breakout this year in Miami much like Jake Peavy did in in 2004 after a rough start to his career.
120 Ian Kennedy (KC - SP) 300 73 154 107.4 32.9 665.0 +365.0
The Royals as a team collected six saves through May, so most fantasy managers wrote off the situation entirely. Kennedy, however, has emerged as the undisputed closer by racking up 11 saves since the start of June. He also wields 46 strikeouts and nine walks in 38 innings, leading to a 2.26 FIP underneath his 3.32 ERA. He should be rostered in all leagues.
121 Zach Eflin (PHI - SP,RP) 322 73 177 119.3 36.9 304.0 -18.0
 
122 Jameson Taillon (PIT - SP) IL60 284 17 144 108.0 19.8 66.0 -218.0
The Pirates placed Taillon on the IL with a right elbow flexor strain on May 4 and later transferred him to the 60-day IL. A month later, they delayed his return to baseball activities, lessening the odds of him returning before the All-Star break. He didn't meet lofty expectations before going down, registering a 4.10 ERA and 19.0% K rate in seven starts. Those who have the room can stash him, but it's looking increasingly unlikely that he'll make much of an impact in 2019.
123 Steven Matz (NYM - SP) 290 75 160 108.6 29.8 258.0 -32.0
Matz had allowed five runs through three combined starts before ceding eight runs (without recording a single out) at Philadelphia on April 16. His ERA jumped from 1.65 to 4.96. That catastrophic risk comes with the territory for the Mets southpaw, who allowed seven runs in a similarly disastrous turn at Washington last year. A 9.2% swinging-strike rate - the same rate as last year -- doesn't support him continuing to strike out nearly a batter per inning, and the Mets temporarily moved him to the bullpen before the All-Star break. He's a fringe option better saved for streaming in the typical 10- or 12-team mixed league.
124 Merrill Kelly (ARI - P) 323 89 152 117.5 19.2 465.0 +142.0
Kelly has posted a 0.81 ERA in three starts, going at least seven innings each time. He doesn't have any standout pitches, and it shows in his 4.31 FIP and 6.91 K/9. He's at least shown enough to roll with during a hot streak and when the right matchup strikes.
125 Yusei Kikuchi (SEA - SP) 250 26 138 109.0 23.0 163.0 -87.0
Signed by Seattle this winter, Kikuchi hasn't shown much upside to start his MLB career. A 4.78 ERA, 16.7 K%, and 5.30 FIP portray the 27-year-old southpaw as no more than a matchup play rather than a solid mid-rotation piece, but the book isn't closed just yet.
126 Mike Fiers (OAK - SP) 317 71 166 111.8 31.2 338.0 +21.0
 
127 Jake Arrieta (PHI - SP) 287 88 158 119.5 23.6 191.0 -96.0
 
128 Diego Castillo (TB - RP) 310 81 156 120.3 21.3 468.0 +158.0
Off to a strong start, Castillo ceded four walks, four hits, and six runs in two outings before going on the IL with right shoulder inflammation. Don't dismiss the 25-year-old righty because of a 3.93 ERA; it was 2.48 prior to those two blow-up outings. He's set to return right after the All-Star break and should factor prominently into Tampa Bay's maddening closer committee with Jose Alvarado sidelined.
129 Scott Oberg (COL - RP) 403 94 126 112.2 12.7 698.0 +295.0
Wade Davis has been a disaster since returning from an oblique strain, surrendering 12 runs in 9.1 innings. If he continues to falter, Oberg could assume the closer's role he held during Davis' absence. While he'd also have to contend with Coors Field, the 29-year-old righty has recorded a 2.04 ERA and 43 strikeouts in 39.2 innings this season. He's worth a speculative add if searching for saves -- or wanting to handcuff Davis -- in deeper leagues.
130 Martin Perez (MIN - SP,RP) 328 60 163 115.2 38.5 818.0 +490.0
After moving into Minnesota's rotation in mid-April, Perez posted a 2.01 ERA and 1.05 WHIP in seven starts. He has since fallen hard, surrendering 15 runs in his last four turns with 14 strikeouts and 11 walks. Since the reclamation project still sports a 3.97 ERA and 3.81 FIP, it might be too early to abandon the southpaw beyond the shallowest of mixed leagues. He at least will get to consistency pitch against the feeble AL Central, which could help sustain his resurgence as a usable starter.
131 Matt Strahm (SD - SP,RP) 306 62 145 108.5 30.5 262.0 -44.0
A popular preseason sleeper, Strahm quickly got discarded after allowing eight hits, three walks, and five runs in his first turn. He then posted a 2.63 ERA in nine starts before getting shelled for 28 runs in his last five starts before the break. Making matters worse, that slump contained two seven-run shellacking by the Marlins and Giants. If he can't be trusted against those listless lineups, Strahm can't be rostered in the typical mixed league.
132 Jose Alvarado (TB - RP) IL10 330 63 153 119.8 34.4 166.0 -164.0
Alvarado initially appeared on the verge of becoming this year's Blake Treinen, dominating out of the gate with 16 strikeouts and four saves in 10 scoreless outings. The early monopoly on Tampa Bay's closing gig proved a mirage, and his command abandoned him long before suffering an oblique strain right before the All-Star break. Out for six to eight weeks, there's no use stashing him in any re-draft leagues.
133 Reynaldo Lopez (CWS - SP) 318 83 164 120.8 35.0 284.0 -34.0
 
134 John Gant (STL - SP,RP) 363 100 125 110.0 9.7 648.0 +285.0
Jordan Hicks is out for the season (and perhaps part of 2020) with a torn UCL. That opens up save opportunities in St. Louis. Manager Mike Shildt has hinted at Carlos Martinez as his preferred closer, but general manager Mike Girsch identified Gant as their best option. The 26-year-old righty has recorded a 2.40 ERA and 0.87 ERA in the bullpen, and that's after ceding four runs while recording one out on June 23. Pick up Gant in case he gets the saves.
135 Zach Davies (MIL - SP) 320 66 150 120.4 22.3 646.0 +326.0
 
136 Pedro Strop (CHC - RP) 319 85 142 110.5 20.5 226.0 -93.0
Given a clear path to saves with Brandon Morrow on the shelf, Strop went on the IL with a hamstring injury. Bothered by the issue, he had posted a 5.06 ERA following a three-run flare-up against the Marlins. He immediately recorded a save upon returning on June 4, but the Cubs signed Craig Kimbrel the next day. Strop could see some save chances in the next week or two before the free-agent signing is ready.
137 Andrew Miller (STL - RP) 326 95 151 113.3 22.3 214.0 -112.0
While Miller could work his way into the closer mix with Jordan Hicks out, he hasn't looked his old self this season. The lefty has 38 strikeouts in 26 innings, but it's come with a 4.15 ERA and 5.22 FIP. Allowing a bunch of walks and home runs is a dangerous combo for anyone, so don't count on him receiving saves over John Gant and Carlos Martinez.
138 Rich Hill (LAD - SP) IL60 361 62 159 114.0 34.5 174.0 -187.0
Injuries were always part of the deal for Hill, who missed time early in the season due to an MCL injury. Since returning in late April, he recorded a 2.55 ERA, 61 strikeouts, and 12 walks in 10 starts before landing back on the IL with a forearm injury. The 39-year-old began playing catch in mid-July and is aiming for a September return. A strong SP2 or 3 when healthy, he's worth stashing for those who have a vacant IL spot. Otherwise, his timetable is too murky to hold up a bench spot.
139 Jeff Samardzija (SF - SP) 342 92 141 123.4 16.9 453.0 +111.0
 
140 Tanner Roark (CIN - SP) 391 99 170 127.2 23.8 346.0 -45.0
Roark is quietly having a strong season amid a pitching apocalypse, posting a 3.36 ERA and 87 strikeouts in 85.2 innings. A middling 9.1% swinging-strike rate and 8.1% HR/FB rate don't point to much long-term sustainability, but he's a solid depth piece in larger leagues and an interesting matchup play with a hot hand worth riding in all formats. When it comes to pitching this year, sometimes beggars can't be choosers.
141 Adam Ottavino (NYY - RP) 384 101 145 126.8 17.1 287.0 -97.0
Ottavino might be stuck behind Chapman, Betances, Britton and Chad Green for the closer job, but he is a force of nature who could strike out 100 batters this season to go with sparkling ratios and a handful of wins. Don't hesitate to add him late in drafts to boost you in three categories.
142 Sean Newcomb (ATL - SP) 344 54 139 104.7 36.6 213.0 -131.0
Newcomb got optioned to Triple-A after issuing eight walks to five strikeouts through his first three starts. The lefty allowed a ghastly 90.3% contact rate while generating just nine swinging strikes. Drop him in all leagues.
143 David Robertson (PHI - RP) IL60 373 67 177 111.3 47.4 145.0 -228.0
Robertson landed on the IL with a sore elbow on April 15. Before getting sidelined, he ceded four runs in 6.1 innings with six walks and strikeouts apiece. It's still an atypical development for the veteran righty, who has logged at least 60 innings and 75 strikeouts in each of the last seven seasons. This may be burying the lede, but the 34-year-old also did not record a single save in the opening two weeks. With the Phillies declaring no closer, there's no need to stash an injured reliever in standard mixed leagues.
144 Cody Allen (MIN - RP) MiLB 374 70 178 111.7 47.4 156.0 -218.0
The Angels have removed Allen from the closer's role after relinquishing seven walks and five runs in 8.1 innings. His gopheritis has carried over from 2018, allowing three homers in 10 outings. There's no reason to roster him unless the save opportunities return.
145 Alex Reyes (STL - SP) MiLB 370 64 175 111.7 46.6 261.0 -109.0
Reyes didn't end up in the rotation but that doesn't mean he will be in the bullpen all season. Keep a close eye on your league's waiver wire in case the owner grows impatient and cuts him. There is a chance Reyes in the Walker Buehler of 2019's second half.
146 Dylan Cease (CWS - SP) 494 84 236 141.0 57.7 528.0 +34.0
Cease, who made his MLB debut July 3, possesses loaded of strikeout upside. He posted a 11.4 K/9 throughout his minor league career, but that rate dipped to 9.6 this season. The 23-year-old righty also struggles with command, issuing 32 walks in 68.1 innings prior to his promotion. For now, leave the rookie to deep leagues.
147 Jerad Eickhoff (PHI - SP) IL10 390 79 186 128.8 42.9 573.0 +183.0
Eickhoff looked like a tremendous find after allowing five runs five starts into the season. He has since surrendered 32 runs and 18 homers in seven turns, bumping up his ERA to 5.71. Those who stuck with him through that entire calamity now especially need to move on after the Phillies placed him on the IL with right biceps tendinitis.
148 Reyes Moronta (SF - RP) 371 82 142 111.0 24.5 715.0 +344.0
 
149 Sandy Alcantara (MIA - SP) 400 82 143 111.3 25.0 556.0 +156.0
Wild in his brief big league audition last year, Alcantara has shown flashes of brilliance since opening 2019 with no walks in eight scoreless frames against the Rockies. A 5.8 K-BB% certainly doesn't support a 3.72 ERA, but an 11.6% swinging-strike rate also opens the door for way more punchouts. Wielding a mid-90s heater, a wipeout slider, and a sinker that induces plenty of ground balls, the 23-year-old righty could be on the cusp of mixed-league viability if he can improve his control.
150 Chris Martin (TEX - RP) 398 97 125 111.3 11.4 774.0 +376.0
 
151 Hunter Strickland (SEA - RP) IL60 332 86 89 87.5 1.5 219.0 -113.0
Strickland opened the year as the Mariners' closer but is now on the 60 day DL and isn't even guaranteed the job when or if he returns. There is no need to waste an IL spot on him for your fantasy roster.
152 Anthony DeSclafani (CIN - SP) 353 91 169 133.8 29.5 445.0 +92.0
 
153 Ty Buttrey (LAA - RP) 389 103 175 130.8 27.8 444.0 +55.0
Buttrey looked like the top candidate for saves when the Angels officially stripped Cody Allen of his closing duties, but Hansel Robles has assumed the closer's role. While Buttrey is still worth rostering in some leagues for his 2.08 ERA and 27.2%, investors should expect more than a save here and there unless Robles implodes.
154 Julio Teheran (ATL - SP) 358 96 158 138.7 18.8 238.0 -120.0
 
155 Andrew Cashner (BOS - SP) 434 110 151 127.8 16.7 711.0 +277.0
A batting-practice pitcher in 2018, Cashner posted a 3.83 ERA and 1.19 WHIP with the Orioles before getting traded to the Red Sox. He's useful enough as an innings-eater in deep mixed leagues, but there's not enough strikeout upside to risk rostering his 5.03 SIERA. Besides, everyone pointing to his gained wins potential seems to be ignoring the fact that he went 9-3 in Baltimore before going to Boston, where Chris Sale is currently 3-9.
156 Jeremy Jeffress (MIL - RP) 397 107 164 129.0 21.7 286.0 -111.0
Jeffress, who started the season sidelined with a shoulder injury, was expected to see some save chances so Josh Hader could slide him back into a more flexible high-leverage role. He has none in 16 outings. His velocity and swinging-strike rate have also dropped, so he's not worth rostering in shallow mixed leagues that don't reward holds.
157 Chris Bassitt (OAK - SP) 383 86 173 132.3 34.0 888.0 +505.0
 
158 Michael Lorenzen (CIN - RP) 394 106 134 119.0 11.5 512.0 +118.0
Lorenzen has picked up Cincinnati's last two saves over Raisel Iglesias. While he hadn't followed through much on the preseason chatter, David Bell expressed interest in using Iglesias in a high-leverage role. Bell has denied a change in closers, but it's worth grabbing Lorenzen just in case he is at least now part of a committee.
159 Freddy Peralta (MIL - SP) 378 101 146 122.7 18.4 301.0 -77.0
Peralta's first two turns tell prospective investors everything they need to know about the volatile righty. He began the season by allowing four runs in three innings, only to rebound with 11 strikeouts over eight shutout frames at Cincinnati. He'll look like a dark horse Cy Young Award contender one day, but he'll torpedo your ratios the next. After getting rocked twice more, the Brewers placed him on the IL with a sore shoulder. There's no need to stash him beyond deeper dynasty leagues.
160 Eric Lauer (SD - SP) 460 105 193 140.8 34.0 421.0 -39.0
 
161 Josh James (HOU - SP) 372 65 176 129.0 46.9 222.0 -150.0
James missed out on his chance at the rotation because of a quad injury and landed in the bullpen instead where he is unsurprisingly dominant. Don't be shy about picking him up with expectations for him to perform similarly to Delin Betances.
162 Kevin Gausman (ATL - SP) IL10 380 86 165 125.7 32.3 209.0 -171.0
Gausman, who began 2019 on the IL with a minor shoulder injury, boasted a 2.87 ERA in 10 starts with the Braves last season. He initially brought those gains into 2019 with the help of an increased splitter usage, but blow-up outings torpedoed his ERA to 6.21 before landing on the IL. He's rehabbing the foot injury at the All-Star break, but Gausman might not have a rotation spot waiting for him after the Braves signed Dallas Keuchel.
163 Jakob Junis (KC - SP) 368 90 179 130.3 36.8 319.0 -49.0
 
164 Mike Foltynewicz (ATL - SP) MiLB 472 124 178 143.4 23.0 112.0 -360.0
Foltynewicz has followed a 2018 breakout with a 6.37 ERA and 1.42 WHIP in a dozen starts. After he got shelled for eight runs by the Nationals on June 22, the day after Dallas Keuchel's team debut, the Braves optioned him the 27-year-old righty to Triple-A. Atlanta has plenty of young pitchers (and the currently injured Kevin Gausman) who can take his spot, so don't bank on Foltynewicz returning in short order. It's fair to drop him in most mixed leagues.
165 Archie Bradley (ARI - RP) 352 91 168 127.7 31.5 207.0 -145.0
Bradley looked like the overwhelming favorite to close in the desert, but then the Diamondbacks signed Greg Holland in January. Manager Torey Lovullo named Holland the closer just prior to Opening Day. Bradley's ERA ballooned to 3.64 last season, but his xFIP and SIERA suggest he was pretty much the same pitcher as he was in 2017. He just stranded fewer baserunners and surrendered more home runs. Although unlikely to be nearly as dominant as he was in 2017, he should be better than Holland and could eventually steal the closer gig from him.
166 Kyle Freeland (COL - SP) 366 55 168 111.5 56.5 158.0 -208.0
Freeland had registered a 4.23 ERA, 25.2% K rate, and 3.98 SIERA through five starts before landing on the IL with a blister on his left middle finger. He has since ceded a 9.21 ERA, 16 strikeouts, and 15 walks in six turns. Remember when he posted a 2.40 ERA in Coors Field last year? The ballpark has exacted swift vengeance with an 8.65 ERA and .376 xwOBA. He's droppable in all mixed leagues.
167 Michael Wacha (STL - SP) 355 93 165 129.0 29.4 271.0 -84.0
 
168 Zack Britton (NYY - RP) 404 113 158 128.0 21.2 315.0 -89.0
Britton isn't going to be the closer in New York, nor is he likely the next man up since Dellin Betances is also ahead of him, but Britton is still well worth owning if your league allows you to start four or five relievers. He will help your ratios significantly while adding nearly 80 Ks as usual.
169 Ryan Brasier (BOS - RP) MiLB 381 119 141 129.0 9.1 356.0 -25.0
Brasier leads the Red Sox with seven saves, but he has recorded just one since April 22. His 3.34 ERA and 1.11 WHIP are nothing special for a reliever stuck in an unpredictable committee, and a 4.45 FIP points to a lower ceiling. This situation is too frustrating to comfortably roster anyone in leagues that don't count holds.
170 Felix Pena (LAA - SP) 386 77 191 146.3 42.2 540.0 +154.0
 
171 Forrest Whitley (HOU - SP) MiLB 375 72 180 126.0 54.0 273.0 -102.0
 
172 Collin McHugh (HOU - RP,SP) 382 79 157 118.0 39.0 210.0 -172.0
Well, that didn't last long. Moved back into the rotation, McHugh mustered a 1.96 ERA through four superb starts. Four starts, later, his ERA has inflated to 6.37. He has relinquished eight home runs among his 24 hits allowed in those 18 frames. Those who rode his fast start must either move on or bench him until he turns the corner. It might not be long until the Astros slide him back into the bullpen.
173 Jalen Beeks (TB - RP) 367 88 150 119.0 31.0 729.0 +362.0
 
174 Alex Wood (CIN - SP) IL60 388 84 174 129.0 45.0 230.0 -158.0
Wood, who was initially expected to return from a back injury in April, continues to suffer setbacks that push back his timetable. Although he initially looked like an intriguing piece to round out the rotation, most of that appeal came from the potential of logging more innings for the Reds. There's not enough upside to exert a spot on him in shallower leagues with limited or no IL spots, especially after yet encountering another detour in late June.
175 Chase Anderson (MIL - SP) 393 87 171 129.0 42.0 383.0 -10.0
 
176 Brandon Morrow (CHC - RP) IL60 423 114 205 151.0 39.0 278.0 -145.0
It sounds as though Morrow is going to miss the start of the season. That could very well turn into multiple months as we've seen with "minor" pitching injuries many times before. It is a dangerous game to draft based on injury optimism, even if the closer does have considerable upside.
177 Joe Jimenez (DET - RP) 376 88 170 129.0 41.0 397.0 +21.0
Most depth charts have Shane Greene slotted into the closer role for Detroit but this job is up in the air. Jimenez was an all-star last season, and while he pitched poorly down the stretch, don't sleep on him winning the job this spring.
178 Vince Velasquez (PHI - SP) 387 122 127 124.5 2.5 386.0 -1.0
 
179 Danny Duffy (KC - SP) 399 90 194 142.0 52.0 458.0 +59.0
 
180 Jesus Luzardo (OAK - SP) MiLB 446 120 187 146.0 29.3 259.0 -187.0
Initially a candidate for an early-season promotion, Luzardo was shut down in late March because of a strained rotator cuff in his left shoulder. Just as the 21-year-old southpaw was inching closer to a return around the All-Star break, he injured his lat in a Triple-A start. The premier prospect is not likely to make his major league debut anytime soon, so managers stashing him can move on in re-draft leagues.
181 Dylan Bundy (BAL - SP) IL10 420 113 172 141.3 24.1 280.0 -140.0
Bundy has teased us many times before, but the former top prospect has reminded everyone of his sky-high upside by cementing a 3.05 ERA in his last seven starts. Of course, that came after getting harpooned to a 6.67 ERA through April. The 26-year-old is throwing far more changeups, but his four-seam fastball is still getting staked to a .417 wOBA. Ride the hot hand at your own risk; the floor is just as notable as the ceiling.
182 Mitch Keller (PIT - SP) MiLB   95 250 172.5 77.5 593.0  
Making his MLB debut on Memorial Day, Keller surrendered six runs in his first inning of work. At least he recovered with three scoreless frames and seven total strikeouts. The 23-year-old neophyte registered a 3.45 ERA and 56 strikeouts in 47 innings prior to his promotion, which was originally scheduled as a spot-start. He may make more starts if Jordan Lyles misses time, but he still needs to prove worthy of a spot in standard re-draft mixed leagues.
183 Dellin Betances (NYY - RP) IL60 456 116 218 158.0 43.5 244.0 -212.0
Betances is merely a closer in waiting, but besides Josh Hader, the best in the game. He is a sure bet for 90+ Ks, with upside ranging to nearly 130. Likewise, his ratios will be terrific each year and you can even rely on a handful of wins and saves too.
184 John Means (BAL - P) 421 96 206 151.0 55.0    
 
185 Yoshihisa Hirano (ARI - RP) 402 97 195 146.0 49.0 359.0 -43.0
 
186 CC Sabathia (NYY - SP) 392 115 170 142.7 22.5 355.0 -37.0
 
187 Sam Dyson (SF - RP) 445 128 147 140.0 8.5 796.0 +351.0
 
188 Lou Trivino (OAK - RP) 409 135 144 140.7 4.0 486.0 +77.0
 
189 Trevor May (MIN - SP,RP) 413 106 201 153.5 47.5 240.0 -173.0
May did not win the closer job in Minnesota. While he may get a few saves here and there, Rocco Baldelli is employing a true closer by committee approach. May can be used as a Josh Hader-lite, but otherwise is droppable.
190 Zack Godley (ARI - SP) 414 107 202 154.5 47.5 246.0 -168.0
Everyone's (or at least this writer's) favorite 2018 breakout pick pitched his way out of Arizona's rotation by relinquishing a 7.58 ERA and 1.72 WHIP through six disastrous starts. Those still holding out hope for a turnaround should drop Godley in all formats.
191 Jimmy Nelson (MIL - SP) IL10 428 115 182 150.3 27.5 371.0 -57.0
Last seen in the majors on September 8, 2017, Nelson returned from a partially torn labrum and a strained rotator cuff in his throwing shoulder June 5. Before the injury cut his 2017 short, he had posted a 3.49 ERA and 199 strikeouts in 175.1 innings. Returning to ace territory, of course, isn't easy after so much time away. He allowed 14 runs in three starts spanning 12 innings before getting moved to the bullpen. Those who patiently stashed Nelson may have little choice but to cut him in standard mixed leagues.
192 Colin Poche (TB - RP)   110 246 178.0 68.0 872.0  
 
193 Brad Boxberger (RP) MiLB 416 110 203 156.5 46.5 300.0 -116.0
Boxberger is expected to hold off Peralta for the Royals' closer job, and while it may not be the most envied role, he should still be able to compile 20 to 25 saves if he can hang onto the job. His ratios won't be ideal, but he does offer some K-upside as we've seen before.
194 Jason Vargas (NYM - SP) 443 110 190 150.0 40.0 523.0 +80.0
 
195 Ryan Yarbrough (TB - SP,RP) 415 116 165 140.5 24.5 334.0 -81.0
 
196 Anthony Swarzak (ATL - RP) 465 133 220 165.7 38.7 469.0 +4.0
 
197 Kelvin Herrera (CWS - RP) 430 117 207 162.0 45.0 306.0 -124.0
Herrera was presumably signed to close for the White Sox, but they also added Alex Colome who has closing experience. This one is too close to call for now so you may want to add both in a late round just to make sure you get some saves.
198 Drew Steckenrider (MIA - RP) IL60 432 118 208 163.0 45.0 305.0 -127.0
Steckenrider missed out on the Marlins' closer role, so while he may provide 90 strikeouts, there is no point in owning him if you play in a standard-sized mixed league.
199 Jalen Beeks (BOS - SP) MiLB   120 244 182.0 62.0    
 
200 Shawn Armstrong (BAL - RP) 478 120 224 172.0 52.0 677.0 +199.0
 
201 Jhoulys Chacin (MIL - SP) 433 120 209 164.5 44.5 237.0 -196.0
 
202 Jordan Lyles (PIT - SP,RP) 468 123 204 163.0 33.1 851.0 +383.0
After spending the last few years as a subpar reliever, the unlikely breakout star posted a 3.64 ERA and 24.9% K rate in 12 starts before going on the IL with a hamstring injury. Shortly after returning, he's relinquished seven runs to the Cubs in consecutive starts. Suddenly he's underperforming his 4.44 FIP rather than the other way around. If not dropped when getting injured, he's likely on the waiver wire now. Keep tabs on his progress from a distance.
203 Clay Buchholz (TOR - SP) IL60 436 124 210 167.0 43.0 404.0 -32.0
 
204 Matt Harvey (LAA - SP) 438 126 211 168.5 42.5 390.0 -48.0
 
205 Nick Kingham (TOR - SP) DFA 440 128 212 170.0 42.0 600.0 +160.0
 
206 Mark Melancon (SF - RP) 442 129 213 171.0 42.0 408.0 -34.0
Will Smith is the closer for now in San Francisco but he hasn't been all that durable, plus he may be on the trade market before long as a coveted lefty setup man. Don't sleep on Melancon getting saves again within a few months.
207 Daniel Ponce de Leon (STL - SP,RP)   130 247 188.5 58.5 679.0  
 
208 Dereck Rodriguez (SF - SP) MiLB 448 132 214 170.7 33.6 295.0 -153.0
 
209 Tommy Milone (SEA - SP)   132 196 164.0 32.0    
 
210 Wily Peralta (KC - RP) 451 135 215 175.0 40.0 332.0 -119.0
 
211 Trevor Cahill (LAA - SP) 454 136 216 176.0 40.0 452.0 -2.0
 
212 Steve Cishek (CHC - RP)   137 185 161.0 24.0 418.0  
 
213 Adrian Sampson (TEX - SP,RP) 501 138 233 185.5 47.5    
 
214 Corbin Burnes (MIL - RP) IL10 455 139 217 178.0 39.0 296.0 -159.0
 
215 Jonathan Loaisiga (NYY - SP) IL60 457 141 219 180.0 39.0 426.0 -31.0
 
216 Luke Gregerson (STL - RP) FA 467 145 221 183.0 38.0 882.0 +415.0
 
217 Derek Holland (SF - SP) 473 146 222 184.0 38.0 388.0 -85.0
 
218 Cam Bedrosian (LAA - RP) 477 148 223 185.5 37.5 782.0 +305.0
 
219 Brad Keller (KC - SP,RP) 479 150 225 187.5 37.5 361.0 -118.0
 
220 Keone Kela (PIT - RP) IL60 480 151 226 188.5 37.5 402.0 -78.0
Vasquez is the closer in Pittsburgh for now, but Kela has immense upside if he slips up or is injured so be sure to keep him on waiver wire speed dial.
221 Logan Allen (SD - SP) 514 152 243 197.5 45.5 628.0 +114.0
 
222 Brad Brach (CHC - RP) 484 155 227 191.0 36.0 576.0 +92.0
 
223 Chad Green (NYY - RP) 486 157 228 192.5 35.5 349.0 -137.0
Green wasn't as electric in 2018 as the year before, but he still registered 94 strikeouts with excellent ratios and 8 wins. He isn't the closer, nor does he have a path to saves, but you can certainly make a case for drafting him even in standard sized leagues.
224 Fernando Rodney (WSH - RP) 487 159 229 194.0 35.0 442.0 -45.0
 
225 Alex Claudio (MIL - RP) 488 160 230 195.0 35.0    
 
226 Daniel Mengden (OAK - SP) 490 161 231 196.0 35.0 605.0 +115.0
 
227 Jeurys Familia (NYM - RP) 496 163 232 197.5 34.5 348.0 -148.0
The Mets added the best closer in baseball this off-season so Familia takes a step back, but if anything happens to Diaz, Familia is the clear closer-in-waiting and would be top 20 at the position right away.
228 Drew Pomeranz (SF - SP) 500 166 234 200.0 34.0 414.0 -86.0
 
229 Aaron Sanchez (TOR - SP) 510 167 242 195.0 33.4 328.0 -182.0
 
230 Tyson Ross (DET - SP) IL60 503 167 235 201.0 34.0 478.0 -25.0
 
231 Wade LeBlanc (SEA - SP,RP) 505 169 237 203.0 34.0 391.0 -114.0
 
232 Dakota Hudson (STL - RP) 507 171 238 204.5 33.5 370.0 -137.0
 
233 Luis Cessa (NYY - SP,RP) 508 172 240 206.0 34.0 509.0 +1.0
 
234 Brent Honeywell Jr. (TB - SP) MiLB 509 173 241 207.0 34.0 558.0 +49.0