Who Should I Trade?

Caleb Thielbar for Colin Holderman (2026)

Summary
Stats
Projections
News & Notes
Schedule

Who Should I Trade? Player Summaries
	Experts' Pick
	Caleb Thielbar RP - CHC	Colin Holderman RP - CLE
Expert Recommendation	67% Recommended by 2 of 3 experts	33% Recommended by 1 of 3 experts
Rankings

Rest of Season	# 229	# 256
VBR	# 453	‐

Projections

Strikeouts	1	‐
Wins	0	‐
Saves	0	‐
ERA	3.88	‐
WHIP	0.93	‐

Misc

Injury Alert	-	IL15

Expert Ranks

Mike Maher BettingPros	# 208	‐

Kelly Kirby FantasyPros	# 210	# 216

Kevin Spinelli KevScores	# 323	# 258

Who Should I Trade? Player Statistics
	Caleb Thielbar RP - CHC	Colin Holderman RP - CLE
2026 Stats


Games Played	58	54

Games Started	0	0

Innings Pitched	50.0	52.2

Wins	3	6

Losses	4	4

Saves	3	1

Blown Saves	4	1

Holds	7	11

Hits Allowed	48	35

Earned Runs	27	16

Home Runs Allowed	11	1

Strikeouts	60	50

Walks	18	20

ERA	4.86	2.73

WHIP	1.32	1.04

Who Should I Trade? Player Projections
	Caleb Thielbar RP - CHC	Colin Holderman RP - CLE
2026 Projections


Games Played	1	‐

Games Started	0	‐

Innings Pitched	1.2	‐

Wins	0	‐

Losses	0	‐

Saves	0	‐

Blown Saves	0	‐

Holds	0	‐

Hits Allowed	1	‐

Earned Runs	1	‐

Home Runs Allowed	0	‐

Strikeouts	1	‐

Walks	0	‐

ERA	3.88	‐

WHIP	0.93	‐

Who Should I Trade? Player Notes
	Caleb Thielbar RP - CHC	Colin Holderman RP - CLE
News
	Chicago Cubs manager Craig Counsell said Caleb Thielbar is scheduled to throw a live batting practice session on Wednesday ahead of a minor league rehab assignment. Nicholas Rodriguez Mon, May 11th	Colin Holderman was scheduled to resume throwing on Monday. Ari Koslow Tue, Sep 22nd
	Caleb Thielbar threw a successful bullpen session on Friday. Ari Koslow Fri, May 8th	Colin Holderman will start a rehab assignment at Triple-A Columbus on Thursday. Ari Koslow Fri, Sep 18th
	Caleb Thielbar threw a bullpen session on Tuesday and is scheduled for a high-intensity session on Friday. Nicholas Rodriguez Thu, May 7th	Colin Holderman threw a bullpen session on Friday. Ari Koslow Sun, Sep 13th
	The Cubs placed LHP Caleb Thielbar on the 15-day injured list with a left hamstring strain. Ari Koslow Sat, Apr 25th	The Guardians placed RHP Colin Holderman on the 15-day injured list with right wrist inflammation. Ari Koslow Fri, Sep 4th
	Cubs’ manager Craig Counsell told reporters Thursday that Caleb Thielbar exited in the ninth inning due to left hamstring tightness. Ari Koslow Thu, Apr 23rd	Colin Holderman was scheduled to return to throwing off the mound on Tuesday. Ari Koslow Wed, Aug 19th
Notes
There are no recent notes for these players

Who Should I Trade? Player Schedules
Date	Opp	Opp Pitcher	VBR	Opp	Opp Pitcher	VBR
	Caleb Thielbar RP - CHC			Colin Holderman RP - CLE
Thu, Mar 26th	vs WSH	Cade Cavalli (13-5)	#34	@ SEA	Logan Gilbert (12-11)	#8
Sat, Mar 28th	vs WSH	Miles Mikolas (3-9)		@ SEA	Bryan Woo (12-10)	#13
Sun, Mar 29th	vs WSH	Jake Irvin (2-10)	#213	@ SEA	Emerson Hancock (7-8)	#135
Mon, Mar 30th	vs LAA	Ryan Johnson (5-9)	#170	@ LAD	Roki Sasaki (5-5)	#102
Tue, Mar 31st	vs LAA	Jose Soriano (12-8)	#23	@ LAD	Shohei Ohtani (8-2)	#1
Wed, Apr 1st	vs LAA	Yusei Kikuchi (1-7)	#57	@ LAD	Yoshinobu Yamamoto (14-9)	#4
Fri, Apr 3rd	@ CLE	Joey Cantillo (11-9)	#63	vs CHC	Cade Horton (1-0)
Sun, Apr 5th	@ CLE	Parker Messick (12-9)	#29	vs CHC	Shota Imanaga (11-10)	#49
Mon, Apr 6th	@ TB	Shane McClanahan (10-7)		vs KC	Michael Wacha (9-10)	#99
Tue, Apr 7th	@ TB	Mason Englert (0-4)	#167	vs KC	Noah Cameron (9-8)	#91
Wed, Apr 8th	@ TB	Joe Boyle (0-1)		vs KC	Cole Ragans (1-4)
Fri, Apr 10th	vs PIT	Carmen Mlodzinski (8-7)	#52	@ ATL	Bryce Elder (8-8)
Sat, Apr 11th	vs PIT	Braxton Ashcraft (14-6)		@ ATL	Martin Perez (9-9)	#82
Sun, Apr 12th	vs PIT	Bubba Chandler (8-10)	#59	@ ATL	Chris Sale (14-9)	#3
Mon, Apr 13th	@ PHI	Cristopher Sanchez (18-7)	#6	@ STL	Matthew Liberatore (6-14)	#95
Tue, Apr 14th	@ PHI	Aaron Nola (7-12)	#68	@ STL	Michael McGreevy (7-9)	#109
Wed, Apr 15th	@ PHI	Jesus Luzardo (14-5)		@ STL	Dustin May (7-9)	#35
Fri, Apr 17th	vs NYM	Kodai Senga (0-9)	#163	vs BAL	Chris Bassitt (9-5)	#175
Sat, Apr 18th	vs NYM	Freddy Peralta (10-11)	#51	vs BAL	Dean Kremer (5-5)	#81
Sun, Apr 19th	vs NYM	Tobias Myers (1-2)	#189	vs BAL	Trevor Rogers (10-11)	#42
Mon, Apr 20th	vs PHI	Aaron Nola (7-12)	#68	vs HOU	Spencer Arrighetti (9-9)	#181
Tue, Apr 21st	vs PHI	Jesus Luzardo (14-5)		vs HOU	Ryan Weiss (0-3)
Wed, Apr 22nd	vs PHI	Kyle Backhus		vs HOU	Peter Lambert (8-10)	#185
Thu, Apr 23rd	vs PHI	Cristopher Sanchez (18-7)	#6
Fri, Apr 24th	@ LAD	Emmet Sheehan (5-8)	#65	@ TOR	Max Scherzer (4-9)	#127
Sat, Apr 25th	@ LAD	Roki Sasaki (5-5)	#102	@ TOR	Kevin Gausman (9-12)	#36
Sun, Apr 26th	@ LAD	Justin Wrobleski (12-5)	#50	@ TOR	Patrick Corbin (3-4)
Mon, Apr 27th	@ SD	Randy Vasquez (10-6)	#245	vs TB	Steven Matz (6-6)	#201
Tue, Apr 28th	@ SD	Walker Buehler (9-6)	#90	vs TB	Nick Martinez (15-6)	#208
Wed, Apr 29th	@ SD	Matt Waldron (2-2)		vs TB	Drew Rasmussen (16-5)	#26
Fri, May 1st	vs ARI	Zac Gallen (3-9)	#216	@ ATH	J.T. Ginn (9-8)
Sat, May 2nd	vs ARI	Ryne Nelson (3-5)	#132	@ ATH	Jacob Lopez (7-5)	#251
Sun, May 3rd	vs ARI	Merrill Kelly (10-14)	#146	@ ATH	Aaron Civale (6-8)	#219
Mon, May 4th	vs CIN	Chase Petty (1-2)	#268	@ KC	Michael Wacha (9-10)	#99
Tue, May 5th	vs CIN	Andrew Abbott (6-11)	#149	@ KC	Stephen Kolek (4-3)
Wed, May 6th	vs CIN	Brady Singer (6-15)	#221	@ KC	Cole Ragans (1-4)
Thu, May 7th	vs CIN	Rhett Lowder (7-12)	#200	@ KC	Seth Lugo (7-9)	#184
Fri, May 8th	@ TEX	Kumar Rocker (6-11)	#84	vs MIN	Connor Prielipp (6-7)	#110
Sat, May 9th	@ TEX	Jack Leiter (3-7)		vs MIN	Joe Ryan (7-10)	#25
Sun, May 10th	@ TEX	Jacob deGrom (11-11)	#12	vs MIN	Andrew Morris (4-8)	#176
Tue, May 12th	@ ATL	Grant Holmes (10-6)	#193	vs LAA	Walbert Urena (9-11)	#40
Wed, May 13th	@ ATL	JR Ritchie (1-5)	#103	vs LAA	Reid Detmers (7-8)	#16
Thu, May 14th	@ ATL	Chris Sale (14-9)	#3
Fri, May 15th	@ CWS	Sean Burke (11-7)	#58	vs CIN	Andrew Abbott (6-11)	#149
Sat, May 16th	@ CWS	Davis Martin (9-8)	#73	vs CIN	Chris Paddack (0-7)
Sun, May 17th	@ CWS	Erick Fedde (8-9)	#157	vs CIN	Brady Singer (6-15)	#221
Mon, May 18th	vs MIL	Brandon Sproat (3-7)		@ DET	Framber Valdez (10-12)	#53
Tue, May 19th	vs MIL	Jacob Misiorowski (16-5)	#7	@ DET	Keider Montero (10-9)	#188
Wed, May 20th	vs MIL	Kyle Harrison (11-5)	#62	@ DET	Drew Anderson (5-7)	#38
Fri, May 22nd	vs HOU	Spencer Arrighetti (9-9)	#181	@ PHI	Cristopher Sanchez (18-7)	#6
Sat, May 23rd	vs HOU	Kai-Wei Teng (5-7)	#220	@ PHI	Zack Wheeler (14-5)	#5
Sun, May 24th	vs HOU	Peter Lambert (8-10)	#185	@ PHI	Andrew Painter (3-10)	#125
Mon, May 25th	@ PIT	Carmen Mlodzinski (8-7)	#52	vs WSH	PJ Poulin (3-0)
Tue, May 26th	@ PIT	Braxton Ashcraft (14-6)		vs WSH	Cade Cavalli (13-5)	#34
Wed, May 27th	@ PIT	Bubba Chandler (8-10)	#59	vs WSH	PJ Poulin (3-0)
Thu, May 28th	@ PIT	Paul Skenes (10-11)	#14
Fri, May 29th	@ STL	Andre Pallante (12-9)	#87	vs BOS	Tyler Samaniego
Sat, May 30th	@ STL	Kyle Leahy (10-5)	#79	vs BOS	Sonny Gray (18-5)	#45
Sun, May 31st	@ STL	Matthew Liberatore (6-14)	#95	vs BOS	Ranger Suarez (8-5)	#70
Tue, Jun 2nd	vs ATH	Gage Jump (6-11)		@ NYY	Cam Schlittler (14-6)	#9
Wed, Jun 3rd	vs ATH	Jeffrey Springs (4-14)	#267	@ NYY	Gerrit Cole (10-9)	#18
Thu, Jun 4th	vs ATH	J.T. Ginn (9-8)		@ NYY	Carlos Rodon (7-3)	#32
Fri, Jun 5th	vs SF	Robbie Ray (13-8)	#198	@ TEX	Kumar Rocker (6-11)	#84
Sat, Jun 6th	vs SF	Landen Roupp (9-14)		@ TEX	Jack Leiter (3-7)
Sun, Jun 7th	vs SF	Trevor McDonald (3-7)		@ TEX	Jacob deGrom (11-11)	#12
Tue, Jun 9th	@ COL	Tomoyuki Sugano (12-12)	#263	vs NYY	Gerrit Cole (10-9)	#18
Wed, Jun 10th	@ COL	Michael Lorenzen (3-13)		vs NYY	Carlos Rodon (7-3)	#32
Thu, Jun 11th	@ COL	Ryan Feltner (7-10)	#230
Fri, Jun 12th	@ SF	Landen Roupp (9-14)		vs DET	Jack Flaherty (3-8)	#179
Sat, Jun 13th	@ SF	Trevor McDonald (3-7)		vs DET	Tarik Skubal (12-7)	#2
Sun, Jun 14th	@ SF	Logan Webb (8-9)
Mon, Jun 15th	vs COL	Michael Lorenzen (3-13)
Tue, Jun 16th	vs COL	Ryan Feltner (7-10)	#230	@ MIL	Robert Gasser (5-5)	#43
Wed, Jun 17th	vs COL	Sean Sullivan (0-3)	#236	@ MIL	Brandon Sproat (3-7)
Fri, Jun 19th	vs TOR	Kevin Gausman (9-12)	#36	@ HOU	Tatsuya Imai (6-4)	#231
Sat, Jun 20th	vs TOR	Patrick Corbin (3-4)		@ HOU	Spencer Arrighetti (9-9)	#181
Tue, Jun 23rd	@ NYM	Kodai Senga (0-9)	#163	@ CWS	Sean Burke (11-7)	#58
Wed, Jun 24th	@ NYM	Sean Manaea (6-8)	#46	@ CWS	Chris Murphy (3-0)
Thu, Jun 25th	@ NYM	Freddy Peralta (10-11)	#51
Fri, Jun 26th	@ MIL	Jacob Misiorowski (16-5)	#7	vs SEA	Luis Castillo (4-11)	#97
Sat, Jun 27th	@ MIL	Kyle Harrison (11-5)	#62	vs SEA	Logan Gilbert (12-11)	#8
Sun, Jun 28th	@ MIL	Brandon Woodruff (2-2)		vs SEA	Emerson Hancock (7-8)	#135
Mon, Jun 29th	vs SD	Griffin Canning (5-9)		vs TEX	Tyler Alexander (5-2)	#159
Tue, Jun 30th	vs SD	JP Sears (3-4)		vs TEX	Jacob deGrom (11-11)	#12
Wed, Jul 1st	vs SD	Walker Buehler (9-6)	#90	vs TEX	MacKenzie Gore (8-11)	#39
Fri, Jul 3rd	vs STL	Andre Pallante (12-9)	#87	vs CWS	Anthony Kay (10-9)	#121
Sat, Jul 4th	vs STL	Kyle Leahy (10-5)	#79	vs CWS	Sean Burke (11-7)	#58
Sun, Jul 5th	vs STL	Matthew Liberatore (6-14)	#95	vs CWS	Chris Murphy (3-0)
Tue, Jul 7th	@ BAL	Shane Baz (6-15)	#85	@ MIN	Taj Bradley (12-6)	#44
Wed, Jul 8th	@ BAL	Dean Kremer (5-5)	#81	@ MIN	Connor Prielipp (6-7)	#110
Thu, Jul 9th	@ BAL	Trevor Rogers (10-11)	#42	@ MIN	Bailey Ober (7-7)	#155
Fri, Jul 10th	@ CIN	Hunter Greene (2-2)		@ MIA	Sandy Alcantara (13-11)	#77
Sat, Jul 11th	@ CIN	Nick Lodolo (3-6)	#169	@ MIA	Eury Perez (8-11)	#22
Sun, Jul 12th	@ CIN	Andrew Abbott (6-11)	#149	@ MIA	Tyler Phillips (5-6)	#247
Fri, Jul 17th	vs MIN	Bailey Ober (7-7)	#155
Sat, Jul 18th	vs MIN	Taj Bradley (12-6)	#44	vs PIT	Mason Montgomery (6-4)	#86
Sun, Jul 19th	vs MIN	Zebby Matthews (9-11)	#134	vs PIT	Paul Skenes (10-11)	#14
Mon, Jul 20th	vs DET	Jack Flaherty (3-8)	#179	vs MIN	Joe Ryan (7-10)	#25
Tue, Jul 21st	vs DET	Framber Valdez (10-12)	#53	vs MIN	Kendry Rojas (1-1)
Wed, Jul 22nd	vs DET	Keider Montero (10-9)	#188	vs MIN	Bailey Ober (7-7)	#155
Fri, Jul 24th	@ PIT	Jared Jones (5-6)	#27	@ TB	Shane McClanahan (10-7)
Sat, Jul 25th	@ PIT	Paul Skenes (10-11)	#14	@ TB	Nick Martinez (15-6)	#208
Sun, Jul 26th	@ PIT	Braxton Ashcraft (14-6)		@ TB	Drew Rasmussen (16-5)	#26
Mon, Jul 27th	@ STL	Matthew Liberatore (6-14)	#95
Tue, Jul 28th	@ STL	Michael McGreevy (7-9)	#109	@ CIN	Caleb Ferguson
Wed, Jul 29th	@ STL	Dustin May (7-9)	#35	@ CIN	Brady Singer (6-15)	#221
Thu, Jul 30th	@ STL	Andre Pallante (12-9)	#87
Fri, Jul 31st	vs NYY	Will Warren (11-6)	#69	vs ARI	Mitch Bratt (1-3)
Sat, Aug 1st	vs NYY	Max Fried (5-5)	#21	vs ARI	Kohl Drake (0-1)	#123
Sun, Aug 2nd	vs NYY	Gerrit Cole (10-9)	#18	vs ARI	Merrill Kelly (10-14)	#146
Mon, Aug 3rd	vs LAD	Justin Wrobleski (12-5)	#50
Tue, Aug 4th	vs LAD	Tarik Skubal (12-7)	#2	vs NYM	Sean Manaea (6-8)	#46
Wed, Aug 5th	vs LAD	Eric Lauer (8-7)		vs NYM	Christian Scott (4-5)
Thu, Aug 6th	vs TOR	Dylan Cease (11-6)		vs NYM	Nolan McLean (12-10)	#28
Fri, Aug 7th	@ KC	Daniel Lynch (6-6)	#256	@ CWS	Noah Schultz (4-9)	#154
Sat, Aug 8th	@ KC	Seth Lugo (7-9)	#184	@ CWS	Anthony Kay (10-9)	#121
Sun, Aug 9th	@ KC	Randy Dobnak (3-5)	#254	@ CWS	Davis Martin (9-8)	#73
Tue, Aug 11th	@ WSH	Jake Irvin (2-10)	#213	@ DET	Drew Anderson (5-7)	#38
Wed, Aug 12th	@ WSH	Jackson Kent (2-4)		@ DET	Framber Valdez (10-12)	#53
Thu, Aug 13th	@ WSH	Cade Cavalli (13-5)	#34	@ DET	Keider Montero (10-9)	#188
Fri, Aug 14th	vs STL	Matthew Liberatore (6-14)	#95	vs SD	Michael King (12-10)	#55
Sat, Aug 15th	vs STL	Michael McGreevy (7-9)	#109	vs SD	Wandy Peralta (3-3)	#264
Sun, Aug 16th	vs STL	Hunter Dobbins (3-3)		vs SD	Casey Mize (6-10)	#47
Mon, Aug 17th	vs CWS	Luis Castillo (4-11)	#97
Tue, Aug 18th	vs CWS	Bryan Hudson (5-4)	#141	vs SF	Carson Whisenhunt (3-4)
Wed, Aug 19th	vs CWS	Sean Newcomb (2-5)	#151	vs SF	Matt Wilkinson (1-3)	#150
Fri, Aug 21st	@ SEA	Emerson Hancock (7-8)	#135	@ COL	Tanner Gordon (1-6)	#222
Sat, Aug 22nd	@ SEA	Kade Anderson (2-2)	#37	@ COL	Gabriel Hughes (0-8)
Sun, Aug 23rd	@ SEA	Bryce Miller (4-10)	#31	@ COL	Tomoyuki Sugano (12-12)	#263
Mon, Aug 24th	@ ARI	Merrill Kelly (10-14)	#146	@ LAA	George Klassen (2-2)
Tue, Aug 25th	@ ARI	Brandon Pfaadt (8-3)	#130	@ LAA	Walbert Urena (9-11)	#40
Wed, Aug 26th	@ ARI	Eduardo Rodriguez (16-7)	#191	@ LAA	Grayson Rodriguez (5-8)	#64
Fri, Aug 28th	vs CIN	Rhett Lowder (7-12)	#200	vs KC	Michael Wacha (9-10)	#99
Sat, Aug 29th	vs CIN	Andrew Abbott (6-11)	#149	vs KC	Daniel Lynch (6-6)	#256
Sun, Aug 30th	vs CIN	Chase Burns (15-3)		vs KC	Seth Lugo (7-9)	#184
Mon, Aug 31st	vs MIL	Kyle Harrison (11-5)	#62
Tue, Sep 1st	vs MIL	Robert Gasser (5-5)	#43	vs TOR	Spencer Miles (6-2)	#98
Wed, Sep 2nd	vs MIL	Jacob Misiorowski (16-5)	#7	vs TOR	Dylan Cease (11-6)
Thu, Sep 3rd	vs MIL	Logan Henderson (11-3)	#11	vs TOR	Jose Soriano (12-8)	#23
Fri, Sep 4th	@ MIA	Janson Junk (6-9)	#138	vs DET	Andrew Sears (0-1)	#212
Sat, Sep 5th	@ MIA	Ryan Gusto (1-5)	#142	vs DET	Framber Valdez (10-12)	#53
Sun, Sep 6th	@ MIA	Tyler Phillips (5-6)	#247	vs DET	Jackson Jobe (3-3)	#115
Mon, Sep 7th	@ MIL	Robert Gasser (5-5)	#43	@ BAL	Trevor Rogers (10-11)	#42
Tue, Sep 8th	@ MIL	Jacob Misiorowski (16-5)	#7	@ BAL	Brandon Young (9-6)	#168
Wed, Sep 9th	@ MIL	Logan Henderson (11-3)	#11	@ BAL	Shane Baz (6-15)	#85
Fri, Sep 11th	vs PIT	Wilber Dotel (1-5)	#224	@ MIN	Taj Bradley (12-6)	#44
Sat, Sep 12th	vs PIT	Paul Skenes (10-11)	#14	@ MIN	Connor Prielipp (6-7)	#110
Sun, Sep 13th	vs PIT	Bubba Chandler (8-10)	#59	@ MIN	Joe Ryan (7-10)	#25
Mon, Sep 14th	vs ATL	Reynaldo Lopez (4-5)		vs CWS	Sean Newcomb (2-5)	#151
Tue, Sep 15th	vs ATL	Martin Perez (9-9)	#82	vs CWS	Chris Murphy (3-0)
Wed, Sep 16th	vs ATL	JR Ritchie (1-5)	#103	vs CWS	Anthony Kay (10-9)	#121
Fri, Sep 18th	@ CIN	Chase Burns (15-3)		vs ATH	Mason Barnett (1-4)	#278
Sat, Sep 19th	@ CIN	Nick Lodolo (3-6)	#169	vs ATH	Jacob Lopez (7-5)	#251
Sun, Sep 20th	@ CIN	Rhett Lowder (7-12)	#200	vs ATH	Jack Perkins (3-13)	#171
Tue, Sep 22nd	vs MIA	Janson Junk (6-9)	#138	@ BOS	Payton Tolle (9-6)	#30
Wed, Sep 23rd	vs MIA	Ryan Gusto (1-5)	#142	@ BOS	Sonny Gray (18-5)	#45
Thu, Sep 24th	vs MIA	Tyler Phillips (5-6)	#247	@ BOS	Ranger Suarez (8-5)	#70
Fri, Sep 25th	@ BOS	Brayan Bello (6-7)	#111	@ KC	Noah Cameron (9-8)	#91
Sun, Sep 27th	@ BOS	Tanner Houck (0-1)		@ KC	Daniel Lynch (6-6)	#256
Fri, Mar 27th				@ SEA	George Kirby (9-11)	#33
Thu, Apr 16th				vs BAL	Shane Baz (6-15)	#85
Mon, May 11th				vs LAA	Brent Suter (3-2)
Thu, May 21st				@ DET	Casey Mize (6-10)	#47
Mon, Jun 8th				vs NYY	Will Warren (11-6)	#69
Thu, Jun 18th				@ MIL	Shane Drohan (7-5)	#128
Sun, Jun 21st				@ HOU	Kai-Wei Teng (5-7)	#220
Mon, Jun 22nd				@ CWS	Anthony Kay (10-9)	#121
Thu, Jul 2nd				vs CWS	Davis Martin (9-8)	#73
Thu, Jul 23rd				vs MIN	Taj Bradley (12-6)	#44
Thu, Aug 20th				vs SF	Landen Roupp (9-14)
Sat, Sep 26th				@ KC	Michael Wacha (9-10)	#99

Who Should I Trade?

Caleb Thielbar for Colin Holderman (2026)

ExpertRecommendation

Expert
Recommendation