Who Should I Trade?

Colby Thomas for Jeff McNeil (2026)

See if your team wins or loses with this trade View Trade Analyzer

Who Should I Trade? Player Summaries
 
Experts' Pick
 
  Jeff McNeil
1B,2B,LF,CF,RF - ATH
Jeff McNeil
Colby Thomas
LF,CF,RF - ATH
Colby Thomas
Expert
Recommendation
100%
Recommended by
2 of 2 experts
0%
Recommended by
0 of 2 experts
Rankings 
   
Rest of Season# 279‐
VBR# 341# 527
   
Projections 
   
Runs1813
Home Runs34
RBI1714
Stolen Bases12
Batting Average.262.237
   
Misc 
   
Injury Alert-DTD
   
Expert Ranks 
   
Kelly Kirby
FantasyPros		# 203‐
   
Kevin Spinelli
KevScores		# 281# 400
   
Who Should I Trade? Player Statistics
  Jeff McNeil
1B,2B,LF,CF,RF - ATH
Jeff McNeil
Colby Thomas
LF,CF,RF - ATH
Colby Thomas
2026 Stats 
   
   
At Bats279103
   
Runs2811
   
Hits6621
   
Singles5114
   
Doubles113
   
Triples00
   
Home Runs44
   
RBI3111
   
Stolen Bases21
   
Caught Stealing21
   
Walks234
   
Strikeouts3632
   
Batting Average.237.204
   
On Base Pct.301.241
   
Slugging Pct.319.350
   
On-base Plus Slugging.620.590
   
Who Should I Trade? Player Projections
  Jeff McNeil
1B,2B,LF,CF,RF - ATH
Jeff McNeil
Colby Thomas
LF,CF,RF - ATH
Colby Thomas
2026 Projections 
   
   
At Bats14897
   
Runs1813
   
Hits3923
   
Singles2713
   
Doubles85
   
Triples10
   
Home Runs34
   
RBI1714
   
Stolen Bases12
   
Caught Stealing01
   
Walks136
   
Strikeouts2131
   
Batting Average.262.237
   
On Base Pct.333.291
   
Slugging Pct.395.424
   
On-base Plus Slugging.729.715
   
Who Should I Trade? Player Notes
  Jeff McNeil
1B,2B,LF,CF,RF - ATH
Jeff McNeil
Colby Thomas
LF,CF,RF - ATH
Colby Thomas
News 
 Jeff McNeil went 2-for-4 in Wednesday's loss to the Diamondbacks with a home run, two runs scored, and one RBI.
Chris Schommer
Wed, Jul 22nd		Athletics outfielder Colby Thomas (wrist) said he felt better and was available off of the bench on Wednesday against the D-backs.
Brenton Kemp
Thu, Jul 23rd
 Jeff McNeil went 1-for-1 in a win over the Diamondbacks with two RBI and one stolen base.
Chris Schommer
Tue, Jul 21st		Colby Thomas is getting more imaging on his wrist on Tuesday.
Ari Koslow
Tue, Jul 21st
 Jeff McNeil went 3-for-5 in a win over the Nationals with two runs scored and two RBI.
Chris Schommer
Sun, Jul 19th		Colby Thomas left Monday's game early with a left wrist contusion.
Ari Koslow
Tue, Jul 21st
 Jeff McNeil went 1-for-4 in a loss to the Marlins with a double and three RBI.
Chris Schommer
Sat, Jul 4th		Colby Thomas went 2-for-3 in Tuesday’s 9-3 loss to the Dodgers with a home run, one run scored, and two RBI.
Chris Schommer
Wed, Jul 1st
 Jeff McNeil went 3-for-4 in a win over the Giants with a walk, two runs scored, and one RBI.
Chris Schommer
Fri, Jun 26th		Colby Thomas went 2-for-3 in Monday's 9-4 loss to the Dodgers with a home run, one run scored, and one RBI.
Jesse Garcia
Tue, Jun 30th
Notes 
There are no recent notes for these players
Who Should I Trade? Player Schedules
  Jeff McNeil
1B,2B,LF,CF,RF - ATH
Jeff McNeil
Colby Thomas
LF,CF,RF - ATH
Colby Thomas
Date OppOpp PitcherVBROppOpp PitcherVBR
Fri, Mar 27th@ TORKevin Gausman (4-9)#30@ TORKevin Gausman (4-9)#30
Sat, Mar 28th@ TORDylan Cease (6-5)#12@ TORDylan Cease (6-5)#12
Sun, Mar 29th@ TOREric Lauer (5-5)#389@ TOREric Lauer (5-5)#389
Mon, Mar 30th@ ATLBryce Elder (6-6)#149@ ATLBryce Elder (6-6)#149
Tue, Mar 31st@ ATLJose Suarez#179@ ATLJose Suarez#179
Wed, Apr 1st@ ATLChris Sale (11-6)#6@ ATLChris Sale (11-6)#6
Fri, Apr 3rdvs HOUCristian Javier (0-1)#199vs HOUCristian Javier (0-1)#199
Sat, Apr 4thvs HOUTatsuya Imai (6-4)#124vs HOUTatsuya Imai (6-4)#124
Sun, Apr 5thvs HOULance McCullers Jr. (2-3)#176vs HOULance McCullers Jr. (2-3)#176
Tue, Apr 7th@ NYYCam Schlittler (10-6)#22@ NYYCam Schlittler (10-6)#22
Wed, Apr 8th@ NYYWill Warren (7-4)#62@ NYYWill Warren (7-4)#62
Thu, Apr 9th@ NYYRyan Weathers (3-7)#61@ NYYRyan Weathers (3-7)#61
Fri, Apr 10th@ NYMClay Holmes (4-4)#98@ NYMClay Holmes (4-4)#98
Sat, Apr 11th@ NYMKodai Senga (0-7)#197@ NYMKodai Senga (0-7)#197
Sun, Apr 12th@ NYMFreddy Peralta (5-9)#42@ NYMFreddy Peralta (5-9)#42
Mon, Apr 13thvs TEXNathan Eovaldi (9-8)#19vs TEXNathan Eovaldi (9-8)#19
Tue, Apr 14thvs TEXMacKenzie Gore (6-8)#32vs TEXMacKenzie Gore (6-8)#32
Wed, Apr 15thvs TEXKumar Rocker (3-8)#86vs TEXKumar Rocker (3-8)#86
Thu, Apr 16thvs TEXJack Leiter (3-7)#130vs TEXJack Leiter (3-7)#130
Fri, Apr 17thvs CWSDavis Martin (9-5)#94vs CWSDavis Martin (9-5)#94
Sat, Apr 18thvs CWSErick Fedde (5-6)#411vs CWSErick Fedde (5-6)#411
Sun, Apr 19thvs CWSNoah Schultz (3-7)#250vs CWSNoah Schultz (3-7)#250
Mon, Apr 20th@ SEAEmerson Hancock (6-4)#89@ SEAEmerson Hancock (6-4)#89
Tue, Apr 21st@ SEALuis Castillo (3-9)#63@ SEALuis Castillo (3-9)#63
Wed, Apr 22nd@ SEALogan Gilbert (8-6)#10@ SEALogan Gilbert (8-6)#10
Fri, Apr 24th@ TEXNathan Eovaldi (9-8)#19@ TEXNathan Eovaldi (9-8)#19
Sat, Apr 25th@ TEXMacKenzie Gore (6-8)#32@ TEXMacKenzie Gore (6-8)#32
Sun, Apr 26th@ TEXKumar Rocker (3-8)#86@ TEXKumar Rocker (3-8)#86
Tue, Apr 28thvs KCKris Bubic (3-2)#123vs KCKris Bubic (3-2)#123
Wed, Apr 29thvs KCMichael Wacha (5-7)#68vs KCMichael Wacha (5-7)#68
Thu, Apr 30thvs KCNoah Cameron (5-8)#97vs KCNoah Cameron (5-8)#97
Fri, May 1stvs CLEJoey Cantillo (8-6)#75vs CLEJoey Cantillo (8-6)#75
Sat, May 2ndvs CLESlade Cecconi (4-7)#111vs CLESlade Cecconi (4-7)#111
Sun, May 3rdvs CLEParker Messick (8-5)#48vs CLEParker Messick (8-5)#48
Tue, May 5th@ PHICristopher Sanchez (12-4)#4@ PHICristopher Sanchez (12-4)#4
Wed, May 6th@ PHIZack Wheeler (10-2)#5@ PHIZack Wheeler (10-2)#5
Thu, May 7th@ PHIAndrew Painter (1-8)#236@ PHIAndrew Painter (1-8)#236
Fri, May 8th@ BALKyle Bradish (7-9)#41@ BALKyle Bradish (7-9)#41
Sat, May 9th@ BALShane Baz (4-9)#65@ BALShane Baz (4-9)#65
Sun, May 10th@ BALKeegan Akin (0-1)@ BALKeegan Akin (0-1)
Tue, May 12thvs STLAndre Pallante (10-6)#135vs STLAndre Pallante (10-6)#135
Wed, May 13thvs STLMatthew Liberatore (5-7)#110vs STLMatthew Liberatore (5-7)#110
Thu, May 14thvs STLMichael McGreevy (4-8)#84vs STLMichael McGreevy (4-8)#84
Fri, May 15thvs SFTyler Mahle (2-9)#83vs SFTyler Mahle (2-9)#83
Sat, May 16thvs SFTrevor McDonald (3-7)#233vs SFTrevor McDonald (3-7)#233
Sun, May 17thvs SFAdrian Houser (2-7)#204vs SFAdrian Houser (2-7)#204
Mon, May 18th@ LAAWalbert Urena (6-7)#330@ LAAWalbert Urena (6-7)#330
Tue, May 19th@ LAAReid Detmers (3-7)#40@ LAAReid Detmers (3-7)#40
Wed, May 20th@ LAAJack Kochanowicz (2-5)@ LAAJack Kochanowicz (2-5)
Thu, May 21st@ LAAJose Soriano (8-6)#44@ LAAJose Soriano (8-6)#44
Fri, May 22nd@ SDWalker Buehler (6-5)#274@ SDWalker Buehler (6-5)#274
Sat, May 23rd@ SDLucas Giolito (2-3)#349@ SDLucas Giolito (2-3)#349
Sun, May 24th@ SDMichael King (6-7)#50@ SDMichael King (6-7)#50
Mon, May 25thvs SEALuis Castillo (3-9)#63vs SEALuis Castillo (3-9)#63
Tue, May 26thvs SEAEmerson Hancock (6-4)#89vs SEAEmerson Hancock (6-4)#89
Wed, May 27thvs SEALogan Gilbert (8-6)#10vs SEALogan Gilbert (8-6)#10
Fri, May 29thvs NYYCarlos Rodon (4-2)#79vs NYYCarlos Rodon (4-2)#79
Sat, May 30thvs NYYRyan Weathers (3-7)#61vs NYYRyan Weathers (3-7)#61
Sun, May 31stvs NYYWill Warren (7-4)#62vs NYYWill Warren (7-4)#62
Tue, Jun 2nd@ CHCJameson Taillon (2-5)#103@ CHCJameson Taillon (2-5)#103
Wed, Jun 3rd@ CHCColin Rea (7-7)#195@ CHCColin Rea (7-7)#195
Thu, Jun 4th@ CHCShota Imanaga (6-8)#26@ CHCShota Imanaga (6-8)#26
Fri, Jun 5th@ HOUPeter Lambert (8-5)#136@ HOUPeter Lambert (8-5)#136
Sat, Jun 6th@ HOUTatsuya Imai (6-4)#124@ HOUTatsuya Imai (6-4)#124
Sun, Jun 7th@ HOUMike Burrows (4-9)#220@ HOUMike Burrows (4-9)#220
Mon, Jun 8thvs MILKyle Harrison (8-2)#54vs MILKyle Harrison (8-2)#54
Tue, Jun 9thvs MILRobert Gasser (2-4)#129vs MILRobert Gasser (2-4)#129
Wed, Jun 10thvs MILBrandon Sproat (3-5)#147vs MILBrandon Sproat (3-5)#147
Fri, Jun 12thvs COLSean Sullivan (0-3)#422vs COLSean Sullivan (0-3)#422
Sat, Jun 13thvs COLKyle Freeland (2-9)#351vs COLKyle Freeland (2-9)#351
Sun, Jun 14thvs COLTomoyuki Sugano (10-4)#433vs COLTomoyuki Sugano (10-4)#433
Mon, Jun 15thvs PITJared Jones (2-1)#51vs PITJared Jones (2-1)#51
Tue, Jun 16thvs PITMitch Keller (6-7)#132vs PITMitch Keller (6-7)#132
Wed, Jun 17thvs PITBraxton Ashcraft (9-4)#27vs PITBraxton Ashcraft (9-4)#27
Thu, Jun 18thvs LAARyan Johnson (2-4)#171vs LAARyan Johnson (2-4)#171
Fri, Jun 19thvs LAAJose Soriano (8-6)#44vs LAAJose Soriano (8-6)#44
Sat, Jun 20thvs LAAWalbert Urena (6-7)#330vs LAAWalbert Urena (6-7)#330
Sun, Jun 21stvs LAAReid Detmers (3-7)#40vs LAAReid Detmers (3-7)#40
Tue, Jun 23rd@ SFRobbie Ray (8-6)#101@ SFRobbie Ray (8-6)#101
Wed, Jun 24th@ SFTyler Mahle (2-9)#83@ SFTyler Mahle (2-9)#83
Thu, Jun 25th@ SFLanden Roupp (7-8)#64@ SFLanden Roupp (7-8)#64
Fri, Jun 26th@ LAAWalbert Urena (6-7)#330@ LAAWalbert Urena (6-7)#330
Sat, Jun 27th@ LAAReid Detmers (3-7)#40@ LAAReid Detmers (3-7)#40
Sun, Jun 28th@ LAASam Aldegheri (3-4)#428@ LAASam Aldegheri (3-4)#428
Mon, Jun 29thvs LADEric Lauer (5-5)#389vs LADEric Lauer (5-5)#389
Tue, Jun 30thvs LADJustin Wrobleski (11-2)#74vs LADJustin Wrobleski (11-2)#74
Wed, Jul 1stvs LADJack Dreyer (4-1)#159vs LADJack Dreyer (4-1)#159
Fri, Jul 3rdvs MIATyler Phillips (2-5)#297vs MIATyler Phillips (2-5)#297
Sat, Jul 4thvs MIASandy Alcantara (10-6)#58vs MIASandy Alcantara (10-6)#58
Sun, Jul 5thvs MIAEury Perez (5-7)#43vs MIAEury Perez (5-7)#43
Tue, Jul 7th@ DETTarik Skubal (7-5)#2@ DETTarik Skubal (7-5)#2
Wed, Jul 8th@ DETTroy Melton (5-1)#100@ DETTroy Melton (5-1)#100
Thu, Jul 9th@ DETFramber Valdez (5-7)#33@ DETFramber Valdez (5-7)#33
Fri, Jul 10th@ CWSSean Burke (7-4)#85@ CWSSean Burke (7-4)#85
Sat, Jul 11th@ CWSBryan Hudson (3-3)#153@ CWSBryan Hudson (3-3)#153
Sun, Jul 12th@ CWSNoah Schultz (3-7)#250@ CWSNoah Schultz (3-7)#250
Fri, Jul 17thvs WSHCade Cavalli (7-4)#59vs WSHCade Cavalli (7-4)#59
Sat, Jul 18thvs WSHZack Littell (7-8)#175vs WSHZack Littell (7-8)#175
Sun, Jul 19thvs WSHFoster Griffin (11-2)#60vs WSHFoster Griffin (11-2)#60
Mon, Jul 20th@ ARIMitch Bratt (0-0)#193@ ARIMitch Bratt (0-0)#193
Tue, Jul 21st@ ARIKohl Drake (0-0)#273@ ARIKohl Drake (0-0)#273
Wed, Jul 22nd@ ARIMerrill Kelly (8-8)#116@ ARIMerrill Kelly (8-8)#116
Fri, Jul 24th@ MINZebby Matthews (4-8)#112@ MINZebby Matthews (4-8)#112
Sat, Jul 25th@ MINConnor Prielipp (2-5)#120@ MINConnor Prielipp (2-5)#120
Sun, Jul 26th@ MINJoe Ryan (6-6)#15@ MINJoe Ryan (6-6)#15
Mon, Jul 27thvs BOSvs BOS
Tue, Jul 28thvs BOSJake Bennett (6-3)#93vs BOSJake Bennett (6-3)#93
Wed, Jul 29thvs BOSPatrick Sandoval (0-0)#144vs BOSPatrick Sandoval (0-0)#144
Thu, Jul 30thvs BOSSonny Gray (12-1)#28vs BOSSonny Gray (12-1)#28
Fri, Jul 31stvs DETCasey Mize (4-6)#53vs DETCasey Mize (4-6)#53
Sat, Aug 1stvs DETFramber Valdez (5-7)#33vs DETFramber Valdez (5-7)#33
Sun, Aug 2ndvs DETKeider Montero (7-5)#145vs DETKeider Montero (7-5)#145
Tue, Aug 4th@ CIN@ CIN
Wed, Aug 5th@ CIN@ CIN
Thu, Aug 6th@ CIN@ CIN
Fri, Aug 7th@ BOS@ BOS
Sat, Aug 8th@ BOS@ BOS
Sun, Aug 9th@ BOS@ BOS
Mon, Aug 10thvs TBvs TB
Tue, Aug 11thvs TBvs TB
Wed, Aug 12thvs TBvs TB
Fri, Aug 14thvs TEXvs TEX
Sat, Aug 15thvs TEXvs TEX
Sun, Aug 16thvs TEXvs TEX
Mon, Aug 17th@ KC@ KC
Tue, Aug 18th@ KC@ KC
Wed, Aug 19th@ KC@ KC
Thu, Aug 20th@ KC@ KC
Fri, Aug 21st@ HOU@ HOU
Sat, Aug 22nd@ HOU@ HOU
Sun, Aug 23rd@ HOU@ HOU
Mon, Aug 24thvs MINvs MIN
Tue, Aug 25thvs MINvs MIN
Wed, Aug 26thvs MINvs MIN
Fri, Aug 28thvs BALvs BAL
Sat, Aug 29thvs BALvs BAL
Sun, Aug 30thvs BALvs BAL
Mon, Aug 31st@ TEX@ TEX
Tue, Sep 1st@ TEX@ TEX
Wed, Sep 2nd@ TEX@ TEX
Thu, Sep 3rd@ SEA@ SEA
Fri, Sep 4th@ SEA@ SEA
Sat, Sep 5th@ SEA@ SEA
Sun, Sep 6th@ SEA@ SEA
Mon, Sep 7thvs TORvs TOR
Tue, Sep 8thvs TORvs TOR
Wed, Sep 9thvs TORvs TOR
Fri, Sep 11thvs SEAvs SEA
Sat, Sep 12thvs SEAvs SEA
Sun, Sep 13thvs SEAvs SEA
Tue, Sep 15th@ TB@ TB
Wed, Sep 16th@ TB@ TB
Thu, Sep 17th@ TB@ TB
Fri, Sep 18th@ CLE@ CLE
Sat, Sep 19th@ CLE@ CLE
Sun, Sep 20th@ CLE@ CLE
Tue, Sep 22ndvs LAAvs LAA
Wed, Sep 23rdvs LAAvs LAA
Thu, Sep 24thvs HOUvs HOU
Fri, Sep 25thvs HOUvs HOU
Sat, Sep 26thvs HOUvs HOU
Sun, Sep 27thvs HOUvs HOU