Skip to main content

Justin Fields or Derek Carr

Who Should I Draft?


Player Summaries Comparison
 
Experts' Pick
 
 
Derek Carr
QB - LV
Derek Carr
Derek Carr
QB - LV
Justin Fields
QB - CHI
 
 
Default player image

Expert
Percent


81%
Recommended by
94 of 116 experts
19%
Recommended by
22 of 116 experts
Add Player
Most Accurate Experts 
    
Top ExpertsTop QB ExpertsTop Player ExpertsPadlock icon See who the Most Accurate Experts would draft
Upgrade Now
    
Rankings 
    
ECR# 14# 16-
Best Rank# 10# 11-
Worst Rank# 21# 25-
    
Fantasy Points 
    
Season Total286.0136.9-
Avg Game15.911.4-
Avg Projection287.6269.7-
    
Schedule 
    
SOS Rank2517-
    
Misc 
    
Injury Alert-
    
Expert Ranks 
Derek CarrJustin FieldsAdd Player
    
Jeff Boggis J. Boggis
Fantasy Football Empire Fantasy Football E...
3 h
#23#15-
    
Justin Sablich J. Sablich
5th Down Fantasy 5th Down Fantasy
9 h
#14#15-
    
Kyle Senra K. Senra
Going For 2 Going For 2
19 h
#14#15-
    
Andrew Erickson A. Erickson
FantasyPros FantasyPros
22 h
#13#14-
    
Andersen Pickard A. Pickard
Prime Time Sports Talk Prime Time Sports ...
1 d
#14#16-
    
Ben Rolfe B. Rolfe
Pro Football Network Pro Football Network
1 d
#18#13-
    
John Paulsen J. Paulsen
4for4.com 4for4.com
1 d
#14#18-
    
Aaron Larson A. Larson
FantasyPros FantasyPros
1 d
#14#16-
    
Ricky Lemon R. Lemon
The Fantasy Champions The Fantasy Champions
1 d
#14#15-
    
Daniel Mader D. Mader
Belly Up Sports Belly Up Sports
2 d
#14#20-
    
Matthew Hill M. Hill
DataForce Fantasy Football DataForce Fantasy ...
2 d
#12#16-
    
Walter Cherepinsky W. Cherepinsky
WalterFootball WalterFootball
2 d
#16#22-
    
Site Rankings S. Rankings
FFToday FFToday
2 d
#14#18-
    
Andrew Seifter A. Seifter
FantasyPros FantasyPros
2 d
#14#20-
    
Tyler Orginski T. Orginski
JWB Fantasy Football JWB Fantasy Football
2 d
#16#15-
    
Bart Wheeler B. Wheeler
Hail to Fantasy Football Hail to Fantasy Fo...
2 d
#13#14-
    
Jamie Calandro J. Calandro
Football Diehards Football Diehards
2 d
#13#16-
    
Richard Savill R. Savill
Fantasy Six Pack Fantasy Six Pack
2 d
#17#12-
    
Wyatt Bertolone W. Bertolone
JWB Fantasy Football JWB Fantasy Football
2 d
#14#16-
    
Tom Strachan T. Strachan
NFL Best Ball NFL Best Ball
2 d
#12#15-
    
Wilmar Chaves W. Chaves
Hablemos de Football Hablemos de Football
3 d
#14#17-
    
Dave Kluge D. Kluge
Footballguys Footballguys
3 d
#13#15-
    
Pat Fitzmaurice P. Fitzmaurice
FantasyPros FantasyPros
3 d
#13#18-
    
Justin Lampkin J. Lampkin
Clock Management Fantasy Football Clock Management F...
3 d
#13#19-
    
Nick Spencer N. Spencer
Fantasy Six Pack Fantasy Six Pack
3 d
#13#17-
    
Matthew Freedman M. Freedman
FantasyPros FantasyPros
3 d
#18#14-
    
Jordan Rains J. Rains
The IDP Army The IDP Army
3 d
#13#18-
    
Craig Phillips C. Phillips
FF Prophet FF Prophet
3 d
#13#18-
    
Dave Richard D. Richard
CBS Sports CBS Sports
3 d
#17#14-
    
Jamey Eisenberg J. Eisenberg
CBS Sports CBS Sports
3 d
#13#19-
    
David Zach D. Zach
FantasyPros FantasyPros
3 d
#14#21-
    
Andy Behrens A. Behrens
Yahoo! Sports Yahoo! Sports
3 d
#11#21-
    
Morgan Colby M. Colby
The Fantasy Champions The Fantasy Champions
4 d
#18#14-
    
Jacob W. Dunne J. W. Dunne
Triple Play Fantasy Triple Play Fantasy
4 d
#15#17-
    
Jacob Gibbs J. Gibbs
SportsLine SportsLine
4 d
#14#16-
    
Mauricio Gutierrez M. Gutierrez
Estadio Fantasy Estadio Fantasy
4 d
#14#17-
    
Austin Lee A. Lee
365 Fantasy Football 365 Fantasy Football
4 d
#15#22-
    
Michael Beller M. Beller
The Athletic The Athletic
4 d
#13#17-
    
Dennis Sosic D. Sosic
Fantasy Six Pack Fantasy Six Pack
4 d
#13#15-
    
Wolf of Roto Street W. of Roto ...
Roto Street Journal Roto Street Journal
4 d
#13#19-
    
Brandon Murchison B. Murchison
RotoBaller RotoBaller
5 d
#13#18-
    
Bo McBrayer B. McBrayer
Going For 2 Going For 2
5 d
#15#10-
    
Scott Engel S. Engel
The Game Day The Game Day
5 d
#14#18-
    
Dalton Del Don D. Del Don
Yahoo! Sports Yahoo! Sports
5 d
#17#15-
    
Luke Sawhook L. Sawhook
Dynasty Nerds Dynasty Nerds
5 d
#13#20-
    
Kyle Richardson K. Richardson
The Fantasy Headliners The Fantasy Headli...
6 d
#14#19-
    
Jacob Hubman J. Hubman
The Fantasy Headliners The Fantasy Headli...
6 d
#11#24-
    
Tim Metzler T. Metzler
FantasyPros FantasyPros
6 d
#21#11-
    
Huseyin Aksu H. Aksu
Fantasy Couch Fantasy Couch
6 d
#14#18-
    
Tommy Garrett T. Garrett
Pro Football Network Pro Football Network
6 d
#14#18-
    
Alex Caruso A. Caruso
Footballguys Footballguys
6 d
#16#17-
    
Joe Bond J. Bond
Fantasy Six Pack Fantasy Six Pack
7 d
#14#17-
    
Joey Wright J. Wright
Front Yard Fantasy Front Yard Fantasy
1 w
#12#17-
    
Jon Jeune J. Jeune
Fantasy Football Diagnostics Fantasy Football D...
1 w
#16#18-
    
Scott Pianowski S. Pianowski
Yahoo! Sports Yahoo! Sports
1 w
#12#16-
    
Benjamin Klotz B. Klotz
Touchdown Squad Touchdown Squad
1 w
#21#16-
    
Robby Jeffries R. Jeffries
The Fantasy Authority The Fantasy Authority
1 w
#16#21-
    
Joe Pisapia J. Pisapia
FantasyPros FantasyPros
1 w
#13#19-
    
Michael Tomlin M. Tomlin
Fantasy Six Pack Fantasy Six Pack
1 w
#12#18-
    
Clayton Cadieux C. Cadieux
Fantasy Football From Up North Fantasy Football F...
1 w
#15#16-
    
Jaime Eisner J. Eisner
The Draft Network The Draft Network
1 w
#15#16-
    
Site Rankings S. Rankings
Gridiron Experts Gridiron Experts
1 w
#13#17-
    
Blake Fincher B. Fincher
Fantasy Football Cafe Fantasy Football Cafe
1 w
#16#14-
    
Michael Fabiano M. Fabiano
Sports Illustrated Sports Illustrated
1 w
#14#17-
    
Connor Rigg C. Rigg
Dynasty Nerds Dynasty Nerds
1 w
#13#20-
    
Guilherme Gianni G. Gianni
Fantasy Futebolista Fantasy Futebolista
1 w
#13#17-
    
Austin Amandolia A. Amandolia
Club Fantasy FFL Club Fantasy FFL
1 w
#20#15-
    
Derek Brown D. Brown
FantasyPros FantasyPros
1 w
#14#13-
    
Adam Stark A. Stark
Everyday Fantasy Football Everyday Fantasy F...
1 w
#15#16-
    
Liz Loza L. Loza
Yahoo! Sports Yahoo! Sports
1 w
#12#18-
    
Nick Zylak N. Zylak
Fantasy Football Advice Fantasy Football A...
1 w
#18#17-
    
Billy Mansell B. Mansell
IDP Army IDP Army
2 w
#14#17-
    
Des Bieler D. Bieler
The Washington Post The Washington Post
2 w
#16#14-
    
Drew DeLuca D. DeLuca
QB List QB List
2 w
#10#15-
    
Mark Ringo M. Ringo
Sleepers and Busts Sleepers and Busts
2 w
#10#25-
    
David Heilman D. Heilman
Gridiron Ratings Gridiron Ratings
2 w
#14#18-
    
Pierre Camus P. Camus
RotoBaller RotoBaller
2 w
#14#16-
    
Tommy Molioo T. Molioo
The Undroppables The Undroppables
2 w
#13#15-
    
Tim Jablonski T. Jablonski
The Hateful 8 The Hateful 8
2 w
#14#16-
    
Steven Pintado S. Pintado
The Fantasy Coaches The Fantasy Coaches
2 w
#12#19-
    
Adam Murfet A. Murfet
5 Yard Rush 5 Yard Rush
2 w
#15#19-
    
Kyle Williams K. Williams
Fantasy Six Pack Fantasy Six Pack
2 w
#16#21-
    
Brandon Funston B. Funston
The Athletic The Athletic
2 w
#12#20-
    
Smitty S.
SleeperU SleeperU
2 w
#14#21-
    
Anthony Cervino A. Cervino
FF Faceoff FF Faceoff
2 w
#14#19-
    
Nate Marcum N. Marcum
Fantasy In Frames Fantasy In Frames
2 w
#13#15-
    
Nathan Groot Nibbelink N. Groot Ni...
JWB Fantasy Football JWB Fantasy Football
2 w
#14#15-
    
Jeff Bell J. Bell
Footballguys Footballguys
2 w
#15#14-
    
Adrian Alpanseque A. Alpanseque
Estadio Fantasy Estadio Fantasy
2 w
#14#25-
    
John Hesterman J. Hesterman
Dynasty League Football Dynasty League Foo...
3 w
#15#14-
    
Tim Brosnan T. Brosnan
Tim's Fantasy Tips Tim's Fantasy Tips
3 w
#14#21-
    
Michael Hauff M. Hauff
FF Faceoff FF Faceoff
3 w
#21#24-
    
Francisco (Chato) Romero F. (Chato) ...
Estadio Fantasy Estadio Fantasy
3 w
#13#19-
    
Mike Maher M. Maher
FantasyPros FantasyPros
4 w
#16#14-
    
David Mendelson D. Mendelson
Triple Play Fantasy Triple Play Fantasy
4 w
#14#11-
    
Matt Donnelly M. Donnelly
Dynasty Vipers Dynasty Vipers
4 w
#12#21-
    
Seth Miller S. Miller
Crossroads Fantasy Football Crossroads Fantasy...
4 w
#20#16-
    
Ellis Johnson E. Johnson
True North Fantasy Football True North Fantasy...
4 w
#13#21-
    
Kyle Krajewski K. Krajewski
First Seed Sports First Seed Sports
4 w
#14#19-
    
Kevin Wheeler K. Wheeler
The Draft Zone The Draft Zone
06/01
#15#17-
    
Zach Greubel Z. Greubel
Gridiron Experts Gridiron Experts
06/01
#15#17-
    
Richard Cooling R. Cooling
5 Yard Rush 5 Yard Rush
05/31
#15#19-
    
Jody Smith J. Smith
FullTime Fantasy FullTime Fantasy
05/28
#15#17-
    
Raju Byfield R. Byfield
Win My Fantasy League Win My Fantasy League
05/27
#17#15-
    
Dominick Petrillo D. Petrillo
The Athletic The Athletic
05/25
#13#17-
    
Brad Evans B. Evans
Bally Sports Bally Sports
05/24
#12#17-
    
Ryan Weisse R. Weisse
Footballguys Footballguys
05/17
#15#22-
    
Fantasy BR F. BR
Fantasy BR Fantasy BR
05/16
#15#17-
    
Matt Olson M. Olson
The Pigskin Pow Wow The Pigskin Pow Wow
05/14
#14#16-
    
Derek Lofland D. Lofland
FantasyPros FantasyPros
05/24
#12#18-
    
Kevin Hanson K. Hanson
EDSFootball EDSFootball
05/11
#15#16-
    
Richard King R. King
King Fantasy Sports King Fantasy Sports
4 w
#12#20-
    
Mick Ciallela M. Ciallela
Fantrax Fantrax
05/06
#15#17-
    
Matt Harmon M. Harmon
Yahoo! Sports Yahoo! Sports
05/02
#14#18-
    
Rich Piazza R. Piazza
Fantasy Shed Fantasy Shed
05/01
#13#17-
    
Jorge B. Edwards J. B. Edwards
Fantasy In Frames Fantasy In Frames
2 w
#16#17-
    
Player Game Logs Comparison
 
Derek Carr
QB - LV
Derek Carr
Derek Carr
QB - LV
Justin Fields
QB - CHI
2022 Schedule 
Week 1 at LAC vs. SF
Week 2 vs. ARI at GB
Week 3 at TEN vs. HOU
Week 4 vs. DEN at NYG
Week 5 at KC at MIN
Week 6BYE WEEK vs. WAS
Week 7 vs. HOU at NE
Week 8 at NO at DAL
Week 9 at JAC vs. MIA
Week 10 vs. IND vs. DET
Week 11 at DEN at ATL
Week 12 at SEA at NYJ
Week 13 vs. LAC vs. GB
Week 14 at LARBYE WEEK
Week 15 vs. NE vs. PHI
Week 16 at PIT vs. BUF
Week 17 vs. SF at DET
Week 18 vs. KC vs. MIN
Player Projections Comparison
 
Derek Carr
QB - LV
Derek Carr
Derek Carr
QB - LV
Justin Fields
QB - CHI
Passing
   
Pass Att598.5507.7
Pass Cmp403.2313.1
Pass Yards4,522.63,547.4
Pass TDs27.319.4
Ints13.115.5
   
Rushing
   
Rush Attempts39.1109.4
Rush Yards133.4575.9
Rush TDs1.23.6
   
Misc
   
Fumbles4.96.7
   
Points
   
Fantasy Points287.6269.7
   
Player Fantasy Points Comparison
 
Derek Carr
QB - LV
Derek Carr
Derek Carr
QB - LV
Justin Fields
QB - CHI
2021 Points 
Week 125.06.7
Week 224.24.5
Week 322.23.9
Week 415.48.3
Week 58.28.8
Week 621.514.3
Week 720.04.2
Week 826.3
Week 912.319.1
Week 1019.2
Week 119.63.5
Week 1221.0
Week 1312.4
Week 1411.520.4
Week 1511.116.9
Week 169.5
Week 1712.2
Week 1815.3
Total286.0136.9
Average15.911.4
Notes for Player Combination
 
Derek Carr
QB - LV
Derek Carr
Derek Carr
QB - LV
Justin Fields
QB - CHI
Expert 
Andrew Erickson
FantasyPros
The biggest winner in the aftermath of the Davante Adams trade is Derek Carr. He now has the luxury of throwing to a surplus of offensive weapons including arguably the best wide receiver in the NFL in his old college teammate. Let's not forget that when Carr had everybody available last season, the Raiders quarterback ranked second in the NFL in passing yards and 15th in fantasy points per game. However, his ceiling was limited due to his lack of mobility and weaponry; Carr did not finish better than a top-8 quarterback at any point in 2021. But Adams figures to provide Carr with a red-zone weapon like no other that will unlock his fantasy ceiling. He's the exact positive touchdown regression that should launch Carr's fantasy numbers. Carr's 3.7 TD rate in 2021 was below his career average (4.3). And his 23 total passing touchdowns were seven below expectation. Fully anticipate Carr throwing for 30-plus laser scores bare minimum with Adams at his disposal. Every quarterback last season that threw for at least 30 touchdowns finished inside the top-10 in 2021.Justin Fields has fallen all the way to QB18 in early best ball ADP. Everyone is afraid of the situation in Chicago. But don't forget that a washed-up Cam Newton went from irrelevant to a top-12 ranked QB in one week last year because of rushing production. Fields finished as a top-12 fantasy quarterback in his last four full games in 2021, averaging 21.7 fantasy points per game. He also averaged 56 rushing yards per game over his last six. All in all, Fields averaged 35 rushing yards per game during his rookie season. The last three rookie QBs to do so? Newton, Josh Allen and Robert Griffin III. They all finished as top-12 fantasy quarterbacks in their second seasons, with the two former QBs finishing top-6. It won't take long for the narrative to spin on the talented Fields after he starts the season hot out of the gates. Five of the Bears' first six matchups are against secondaries that are the weak part of their respective defense, lost talent in free agency and/or are unproven. In Week 1, Fields takes on the 49ers. He rushed for over 100 yards against them last season.
Derek Lofland
FantasyPros
Carr had a very nice season with 4,618 passing yards and 21 passing touchdowns in the fantasy season. The Raiders should be a good offense under Josh McDaniels and Carr has QB1 upside in a good offensive system that became even more dangerous with the addition of Davante Adams.Fields will be looking for a better second season with a new coaching staff, he has a long way to go as a passer, but his legs will keep him fantasy relevant as a QB2 with upside in 2022.
Derek Brown
FantasyPros
 Justin Fields closed the season out with a promising stretch run as a top ten fantasy quarterback in each of his final four full starts. Fields showed growth in this quartet of games, completing 62.5% of his passes with 7.6 yards per attempt. The rushing is what we covet with the Windy City signal-caller, and we got a look at that as well, as he averaged 64.2 yards per game on the ground. Losing Allen Robinson hurts even more with the team replacing him with Byron Pringle, Equanimeous St. Brown, David Moore, and Velus Jones. The massive weekly upside is still in the cards for Fields with his playmaking ability, but he's tough to trust as anything more than a QB2 or matchup play, considering the cast of characters surrounding him.
Pat Fitzmaurice
FantasyPros
Carr threw for 4,804 yards in 2021, beating his previous single-season high by 701 yards. However, he threw only 23 TD passes in 17 games and ranked outside the top 15 among QBs in fantasy points per game. Carr has reached 30 TD passes only once in eight NFL seasons, and he doesn't run much. The addition of WR Davante Adams, Carr's former college teammate at Fresno State, raises the ceiling here. Still, it's probably best to view Carr as a midrange QB2.Fields looked completely overmatched early in his rookie season but showed promise as the season wore on. He ran for 361 yards over his final seven starts, hinting at vast rushing potential. He's a work in progress as a passer, but he has a big arm and is capable of making all the throws. Alas, the Bears aren't making much of an effort to provide him with adequate pass-catching weaponry.
Wolf of Roto Street
Roto Street Journal
Now gets to throw to the best WR in the game, division looks like shootout central. Such a safe QB1 now5/2: Made 0 attempts to help him out in the draft. Even w/ Konami upside, Fields is set up to fail