Charlie Smyth for Harrison Butker (2026)

Should I Trade... ?

Summary
Game Log
Stats
Projections
Points
Notes

Player Summaries Comparison
	Harrison Butker K - KC Harrison Butker K - KC	Charlie Smyth K - NO Charlie Smyth K - NO
Most Accurate Experts

Top ExpertsTop K ExpertsTop Player Experts	See who the Most Accurate Experts would trade Upgrade Now

Rankings

Rest of Season	# 15	# 19	-
Draft	‐	‐	-

Matchup

Opponent	vs. DEN	at DET	-
Matchup Rating	-	-	-

Fantasy Points

Season Total	149.0	60.0	-
Avg Game	8.8	10.0	-
Avg Projection	131.8	122.8	-

Schedule

SOS Rank	4	2	-

Misc

Injury Alert	‐	‐	-

Expert Ranks
	Harrison Butker	Charlie Smyth	Add Player

Jonathan Stone J. Stone Stone Cold Fantasy Stone Cold Fantasy 07/29	#13	#18	-

Scott Pianowski S. Pianowski Yahoo! Sports Yahoo! Sports 07/29	#11	#17	-

Kyle Krajewski K. Krajewski First Seed Sports First Seed Sports 07/29	#16	#20	-

Brad Beatson B. Beatson Bandit Fantasy Football Bandit Fantasy Foo... 07/29	#9	‐	-

Matt Harmon M. Harmon Yahoo! Sports Yahoo! Sports 07/29	#12	#13	-

Hayden Winks H. Winks Yahoo! Sports Yahoo! Sports 07/28	#15	#19	-

Dalton Del Don D. Del Don The Deep Shot The Deep Shot 07/29	#13	#19	-

Justin Bauerle J. Bauerle FantasyNow+ FantasyNow+ 07/28	#15	#18	-

Gary Davenport G. Davenport Footballguys Footballguys 07/28	#15	#21	-

Joel Smyth J. Smyth Yahoo! Sports Yahoo! Sports 07/28	#14	#17	-

Mike Bland M. Bland Points Over Expected Points Over Expected 07/27	#20	#14	-

Dr. Roto D. Roto FullTime Fantasy FullTime Fantasy 07/27	#12	#18	-

Doug Burrell D. Burrell Draft With Doug Draft With Doug 07/26	#22	#21	-

Huseyin Aksu H. Aksu Fantasy Couch Fantasy Couch 07/27	#18	#20	-

Ryan Weisse R. Weisse Club Fantasy FFL Club Fantasy FFL 07/28	#5	#16	-

Jeremy Shulman J. Shulman Fantasy Football Universe Fantasy Football U... 07/24	#12	#15	-

Joe Wiggans J. Wiggans IDP Guys IDP Guys 07/24	‐	#2	-

Rudy Gamble R. Gamble Razzball Razzball 07/23	#8	#22	-

Jacob Piccolo J. Piccolo TrueRGM TrueRGM 07/27	#16	#19	-

Luke Renton L. Renton The Franchise Tag UK The Franchise Tag UK 07/24	#10	#21	-

David Heilman D. Heilman Dynasty Trade Calculator Dynasty Trade Calc... 07/17	#15	#18	-

Bart Wheeler B. Wheeler Hail to Fantasy Football Hail to Fantasy Fo... 07/17	#18	#14	-

Matt Donnelly M. Donnelly Dynasty Vipers Dynasty Vipers 07/17	#12	#19	-

Kev Wheeler K. Wheeler Wheel Route FF Wheel Route FF 07/14	#14	#16	-

Justin Boone J. Boone Yahoo! Sports Yahoo! Sports 07/14	#19	#20	-

Jason Willan J. Willan Gridiron Experts Gridiron Experts 07/23	#15	#18	-

David Biggs D. Biggs Drink Five Drink Five 07/12	#17	#20	-

The Tecmo Weave T. Tecmo Weave Lab 52 Lab 52 07/12	#8	#21	-

Lee Wehry L. Wehry FantasyPros FantasyPros 07/10	#15	#18	-

Daniel Mader D. Mader Fantasy Football Advice Fantasy Football A... 07/14	#8	#26	-

Justin Fuhr J. Fuhr Pro Football Mania Pro Football Mania 07/25	#11	#18	-

Nick Raducanu N. Raducanu Dr. Roto Dr. Roto 07/07	#17	#18	-

Kyle Yates K. Yates Yates Fantasy Football Yates Fantasy Foot... 07/17	#14	#18	-

Mike MacGregor M. MacGregor Draft Buddy Draft Buddy 07/28	#15	#18	-

Edward Gorelik E. Gorelik End of Football End of Football 07/25	#11	#18	-

Francisco (Chato) Romero F. (Chato) ... Estadio Fantasy Estadio Fantasy 07/03	#11	#18	-

Mauricio Gutierrez M. Gutierrez Estadio Fantasy Estadio Fantasy 07/01	#17	#19	-

Brandon Murchison B. Murchison RotoBaller RotoBaller 07/24	#11	‐	-

Ken Zalis K. Zalis Pressbox Pressbox 07/29	#18	#20	-

Alfredo Brown A. Brown Footballguys Footballguys 07/27	#15	#20	-

Mick Ciallela M. Ciallela Fantrax Fantrax 06/28	#13	#22	-

Drew DeLuca D. DeLuca Going For 2 Going For 2 06/28	#15	#20	-

Matt De Lima M. De Lima Dr. Roto Dr. Roto 06/12	#18	#15	-

Pat Fitzmaurice P. Fitzmaurice FantasyPros FantasyPros 07/29	#17	#20	-

Seth Woolcock S. Woolcock FantasyPros FantasyPros 07/15	#9	#21	-

Ed Birdsall E. Birdsall Talking Points Sports Talking Points Sports 07/23	#12	#19	-

Kevin Steele K. Steele The Fantasy Authority The Fantasy Authority 06/04	#17	#16	-

Tom Strachan T. Strachan NFL Best Ball NFL Best Ball 07/25	#11	#20	-

Wyatt Bertolone W. Bertolone Player Profiler Player Profiler 07/01	‐	#1	-

Andy Behrens A. Behrens The Deep Shot The Deep Shot 07/29	#15	#19	-

Jacob Hubman J. Hubman The Fantasy Headliners The Fantasy Headli... 05/11	#12	#18	-

Richard Savill R. Savill Fantasy Six Pack Fantasy Six Pack 07/27	#13	#21	-

Brandon Funston B. Funston The Athletic The Athletic 05/11	#9	#21	-

Site Rankings S. Rankings Gridiron Experts Gridiron Experts 07/20	#13	#18	-

Elisha Twerski E. Twerski USA Today USA Today 04/28	#14	#17	-

Fantasy BR F. BR Fantasy BR Fantasy BR 04/27	#4	#27	-

Jacob Gibbs J. Gibbs SportsLine SportsLine 07/28	#1	#7	-

Wolf of Roto Street W. of Roto ... Roto Street Journal Roto Street Journal 07/07	#2	‐	-

Justin Sablich J. Sablich 5th Down Fantasy 5th Down Fantasy 04/20	#10	#20	-

Tera Roberts T. Roberts OddsChecker OddsChecker 07/09	#13	#15	-

Player Game Logs Comparison
	Harrison Butker K - KC Harrison Butker K - KC	Charlie Smyth K - NO Charlie Smyth K - NO
2026 Schedule
Week 1	vs. DEN	at DET
Week 2	vs. IND	at BAL
Week 3	at MIA	vs. LV
Week 4	at LV	vs. ATL
Week 5	BYE WEEK	vs. MIN
Week 6	vs. LAC	at NYG
Week 7	at SEA	vs. PIT
Week 8	at DEN	BYE WEEK
Week 9	vs. NYJ	vs. CLE
Week 10	at ATL	vs. CAR
Week 11	vs. ARI	at CHI
Week 12	at BUF	at CIN
Week 13	at LAR	vs. GB
Week 14	at CIN	at CAR
Week 15	vs. NE	at TB
Week 16	vs. SF	vs. ARI
Week 17	at LAC	at ATL
Week 18	vs. LV	vs. TB

Player Projections Comparison
	Harrison Butker K - KC Harrison Butker K - KC	Charlie Smyth K - NO Charlie Smyth K - NO
Kicking

FG	31.3	29.5
FGA	36.2	35.0
XPT	37.9	34.2

Player Fantasy Points Comparison
	Harrison Butker K - KC Harrison Butker K - KC	Charlie Smyth K - NO Charlie Smyth K - NO
2025 Points
Week 1	11.0	‐
Week 2	7.0	‐
Week 3	13.0	‐
Week 4	13.0	‐
Week 5	4.0	‐
Week 6	6.0	‐
Week 7	7.0	‐
Week 8	4.0	‐
Week 9	8.0	‐
Week 10	‐	‐
Week 11	7.0	‐
Week 12	16.0	‐
Week 13	4.0	5.0
Week 14	4.0	6.0
Week 15	8.0	10.0
Week 16	12.0	20.0
Week 17	10.0	14.0
Week 18	15.0	5.0
Total	149.0	60.0
Average	8.8	10.0

Notes for Player Combination
	Harrison Butker K - KC Harrison Butker K - KC	Charlie Smyth K - NO Charlie Smyth K - NO
Expert
Pat Fitzmaurice FantasyPros	Harrison Butker has become a less dependable fantasy kicker in recent years. It's not because Butker has been substantially less accurate. It's because the Kansas City offense has been scoring fewer touchdowns in recent years, giving Butker fewer freebie extra points. In Butker's first five seasons, from 2017 to 2021, he averaged 3.0 extra points per game. In 2022 and 2023, Butker averaged 2.5 extra points per game. In 2024 and 2025, Butker averaged 2.0 extra points a game. Butker's yearly finished in fantasy points per game among kickers: second, sixth, second, 13th, ninth, 20th, 10th, 26th, 15th. The Chiefs offense might not be among the NFL's most explosive in 2026 with Patrick Mahomes coming off a major knee injury. Consider Butker a second-tier kicker option.	Charlie Smyth played only six games for the Saints last season, but he averaged 10.0 fantasy points per game, tying for fifth in that category among kickers. A native of Northern Ireland, Smith made 12-of-16 field goals and 13-of-13 extra points. If Smith can hold down the Saints' kicking job in 2026, he'll get to play home games in a dome, and he'll be tied to an offense that appears to be on the rise under second-year head coach Kellen Moore.