Outfielder Aaron Hicks was dealt to the New York Yankees Wednesday in exchange for catcher John Ryan Murphy in an interesting trade for both teams. Hicks had blossomed into a Gold Glove-type center fielder for the Twins after disappointing in spells during 2013 and 2014, though he would have been blocked by Byron Buxton in Minnesota. Murphy was a backup catcher for the Yankees in 2015 and would not have started over Brian McCann in New York, but had a .284 batting average in 2015 and .277 batting average in 2014. Neither are guaranteed starting positions with their new teams, but each will have an opportunity to make a strong fantasy impact in 2016.
Stay tuned into fantasy baseball by following along with our offseason content ![]()
Fantasy Impact
On face value, the Yankees have three starting outfielders in Brett Gardner, Jacoby Ellsbury, and Carlos Beltran, with Aaron Judge waiting in the minor leagues and a lack of designated hitter availability for the aging veteran Beltran. Hicks should be a backup for the Yankees as they are currently constituted, but the team may not be done with their trading for the winter. Brett Gardner has been involved in a lot of trade rumors this offseason and Hicks may slot into center field, with Jacoby Ellsbury moving to left after a potential trade.
Although Hicks only had a .721 OPS during the 2015 season, a combined .655 OPS in 819 career at-bats, he did have 13 stolen bases in 16 attempts, adding 11 home runs in 352 at-bats, and had a .948 OPS with Triple-A Rochester in 38 games. There is a chance that Hicks is a 20-home run, 20-steal player if given 500 or more at-bats in 2016, but there is a strong chance that he spends a lot of the season on the bench or in Triple-A Scranton/Wilkes-Barre unless Gardner is traded.
The Twins, on the other hand, are filling a need at catcher with Murphy, as neither Josmil Pinto nor Kurt Suzuki filled the bill for the overachieving Twins. Murphy is 24 years old, adding to the under-25 core of Buxton, Miguel Sano, Eddie Rosario, and Oswaldo Arcia. He has hit .280 over the last two seasons, but only has 19 extra-base hits in 262 career at-bats, including only four home runs. Ironically, fantasy owners will see a lot of Joe Mauer in Murphy, as he has very little power, but a strong contact rate. Unfortunately for fantasy owners, he does not have Mauer’s plate discipline, as Mauer has a 11.9% BB% for his career and Murphy only has a 6% BB%. He will get the opportunity to start in Minnesota and could be a good late-round option at catcher for batting average leagues.
Chris Zolli is a correspondent at FantasyPros. To read more from Chris, check out his archive and follow him @thezman2010.
