Skip Navigation to Main Content

George Springer or Josh Naylor

Baseball Stats Comparison


See which player would win in a trade View Trade Analyzer

George Springer or Josh Naylor Player Statistics
  Josh Naylor
1B,DH - SEA
Josh Naylor
George Springer
LF,CF,RF,DH - FA
George Springer
2026 Stats 
   
   
At Bats597462
   
Runs5859
   
Hits156115
   
Singles12375
   
Doubles2323
   
Triples02
   
Home Runs1015
   
RBI5754
   
Stolen Bases3012
   
Caught Stealing92
   
Walks4547
   
Strikeouts7995
   
Batting Average.261.249
   
On Base Pct.317.321
   
Slugging Pct.350.405
   
On-base Plus Slugging.668.726
   
George Springer or Josh Naylor Player Projections
  Josh Naylor
1B,DH - SEA
Josh Naylor
George Springer
LF,CF,RF,DH - FA
George Springer
2026 Projections 
   
   
At Bats536508
   
Runs7384
   
Hits144133
   
Singles9283
   
Doubles2823
   
Triples02
   
Home Runs2225
   
RBI8772
   
Stolen Bases1714
   
Caught Stealing32
   
Walks4960
   
Strikeouts89113
   
Batting Average.268.261
   
On Base Pct.328.338
   
Slugging Pct.444.458
   
On-base Plus Slugging.772.797
   
George Springer or Josh Naylor Player Notes
  Josh Naylor
1B,DH - SEA
Josh Naylor
George Springer
LF,CF,RF,DH - FA
George Springer
News 
 Josh Naylor had surgery on his right wrist on Saturday.
Ari Koslow
Tue, Oct 6th
George Springer went 0-for-4 in a win over the Royals with one run scored, one stolen base, and one walk.
Chris Schommer
Sun, Sep 6th
 Josh Naylor went 2-for-5 with two RBI and two steals in the Mariners 7-2 win over the Angels on Wednesday.
Ari Koslow
Thu, Sep 17th
George Springer went 4-for-4 in an 8-1 win over the Mariners with a home run, one double, three runs scored, and one RBI.
Chris Schommer
Sat, Aug 29th
 Josh Naylor went 3-for-5 with two RBI in the Mariners 7-5 win over the Brewers on Wednesday.
Ari Koslow
Thu, Aug 20th
George Springer is not in the Blue Jays lineup on Wednesday against the Rays.
Ari Koslow
Wed, Aug 19th
 Josh Naylor is back in the Mariners lineup on Wednesday against the Yankees.
Ari Koslow
Wed, Aug 12th
George Springer is back in the Blue Jays lineup on Monday against the Red Sox.
Ari Koslow
Mon, Aug 10th
 Mariners first baseman Josh Naylor is out of Tuesday's lineup due to right wrist soreness.
Brenton Kemp
Tue, Aug 11th
George Springer is not in the Blue Jays lineup on Sunday against the Phillies.
Ari Koslow
Sun, Aug 9th
Notes 
 Let's start with the important part: Josh Naylor will not steal 30 bases again in 2026. With a previous high of 10, the 30 was a gift to managers who drafted him and will most likely be the outlier of his career. Naylor did sacrifice power in his time between Arizona and Seattle, hitting only 20 home runs after smacking 31 the year before. The .295 average helped offset this to some degree, but as a career .269 hitter, this is also suspect to continue. Even though he will only be 29 this season, the return to Seattle limits the upside we can expect. He's more of an avoid, unless he falls in drafts.
Kelly Kirby - FantasyPros
George Springer silenced skeptics in 2025 with his strongest campaign since 2019, turning in a monster season at age 35. He appeared in 140 games, launching 32 home runs while scoring 106 runs, driving in 84, and swiping 18 bases. His .309/.399/.560 slash line was the best of his career, and his 166 wRC+ ranked third across MLB. The obvious question is how to value Springer heading into his age-36 season in 2026. A repeat batting average is unlikely, as his .309 mark was fueled by a .340 BABIP—well above his career norm. Most projections pull his power back into the mid-20s for home runs, but the strength of the lineup around him should help preserve strong run and RBI totals, along with roughly 15 stolen bases. If Springer can once again stay on the field for around 140 games, he remains a valuable fantasy asset. While a full encore of 2025 shouldn't be expected, even modest regression still leaves him among the more reliable contributors.
Kelly Kirby - FantasyPros
 Mysterious spike in stolen bases, plays in the toughest offensive park in the game, and a mediocre batted ball profile - I am passing on Naylor at his ADP.
Anthony Gambale - Roto Street Journal
 
George Springer or Josh Naylor Player Schedules
  Josh Naylor
1B,DH - SEA
Josh Naylor
George Springer
LF,CF,RF,DH - FA
George Springer
Date OppOpp PitcherVBROppOpp PitcherVBR
Thu, Mar 26thvs CLETanner Bibee (7-15)#80   
Fri, Mar 27thvs CLEGavin Williams (14-8)#20   
Sat, Mar 28thvs CLEJoey Cantillo (11-9)#63   
Sun, Mar 29thvs CLESlade Cecconi (5-7)#164   
Mon, Mar 30thvs NYYRyan Weathers (5-8)   
Tue, Mar 31stvs NYYMax Fried (5-5)#21   
Wed, Apr 1stvs NYYCam Schlittler (14-6)#9   
Fri, Apr 3rd@ LAAReid Detmers (7-8)#16   
Sat, Apr 4th@ LAAJack Kochanowicz (2-5)   
Sun, Apr 5th@ LAAGeorge Klassen (2-2)   
Mon, Apr 6th@ TEXJacob deGrom (11-11)#12   
Tue, Apr 7th@ TEXNathan Eovaldi (11-10)#66   
Wed, Apr 8th@ TEXMacKenzie Gore (8-11)#39   
Fri, Apr 10thvs HOUTatsuya Imai (6-4)#231   
Sat, Apr 11thvs HOULance McCullers Jr. (2-3)   
Sun, Apr 12thvs HOUCody Bolton (0-1)#282   
Mon, Apr 13thvs HOUMike Burrows (4-9)   
Tue, Apr 14th@ SDMichael King (12-10)#55   
Wed, Apr 15th@ SDRandy Vasquez (10-6)#245   
Thu, Apr 16th@ SDWalker Buehler (9-6)#90   
Fri, Apr 17thvs TEXJacob deGrom (11-11)#12   
Sat, Apr 18thvs TEXNathan Eovaldi (11-10)#66   
Sun, Apr 19thvs TEXMacKenzie Gore (8-11)#39   
Mon, Apr 20thvs ATHJ.T. Ginn (9-8)   
Tue, Apr 21stvs ATHJacob Lopez (7-5)#251   
Wed, Apr 22ndvs ATHAaron Civale (6-8)#219   
Fri, Apr 24th@ STLAndre Pallante (12-9)#87   
Sat, Apr 25th@ STLMatthew Liberatore (6-14)#95   
Sun, Apr 26th@ STLMichael McGreevy (7-9)#109   
Mon, Apr 27th@ MINConnor Prielipp (6-7)#110   
Tue, Apr 28th@ MINJoe Ryan (7-10)#25   
Wed, Apr 29th@ MINTaj Bradley (12-6)#44   
Fri, May 1stvs KCCole Ragans (1-4)   
Sat, May 2ndvs KCSeth Lugo (7-9)#184   
Sun, May 3rdvs KCKris Bubic (4-2)#74   
Mon, May 4thvs ATLJR Ritchie (1-5)#103   
Tue, May 5thvs ATLBryce Elder (8-8)   
Wed, May 6thvs ATLMartin Perez (9-9)#82   
Fri, May 8th@ CWSSean Burke (11-7)#58   
Sat, May 9th@ CWSAnthony Kay (10-9)#121   
Sun, May 10th@ CWSDavis Martin (9-8)#73   
Mon, May 11th@ HOUPeter Lambert (8-10)#185   
Tue, May 12th@ HOUTatsuya Imai (6-4)#231   
Wed, May 13th@ HOULance McCullers Jr. (2-3)   
Thu, May 14th@ HOUMike Burrows (4-9)   
Fri, May 15thvs SDRandy Vasquez (10-6)#245   
Sat, May 16thvs SDWalker Buehler (9-6)#90   
Sun, May 17thvs SDLucas Giolito (2-3)   
Mon, May 18thvs CWSNoah Schultz (4-9)#154   
Tue, May 19thvs CWSAnthony Kay (10-9)#121   
Wed, May 20thvs CWSSean Burke (11-7)#58   
Fri, May 22nd@ KCNoah Cameron (9-8)#91   
Sat, May 23rd@ KCStephen Kolek (4-3)   
Sun, May 24th@ KCSeth Lugo (7-9)#184   
Mon, May 25th@ ATHAaron Civale (6-8)#219   
Tue, May 26th@ ATHGage Jump (6-11)   
Wed, May 27th@ ATHJeffrey Springs (4-14)#267   
Fri, May 29thvs ARIZac Gallen (3-9)#216   
Sat, May 30thvs ARIRyne Nelson (3-5)#132   
Sun, May 31stvs ARIMerrill Kelly (10-14)#146   
Mon, Jun 1stvs NYMAustin Warren   
Tue, Jun 2ndvs NYMHuascar Brazoban (6-2)#229   
Wed, Jun 3rdvs NYMFreddy Peralta (10-11)#51   
Fri, Jun 5th@ DETFramber Valdez (10-12)#53   
Sat, Jun 6th@ DETKeider Montero (10-9)#188   
Sun, Jun 7th@ DETJack Flaherty (3-8)#179   
Mon, Jun 8th@ BALTrey Gibson (2-3)#249   
Tue, Jun 9th@ BALTrevor Rogers (10-11)#42   
Wed, Jun 10th@ BALBrandon Young (9-6)#168   
Thu, Jun 11th@ BALKyle Bradish (7-14)   
Fri, Jun 12th@ WSHZack Littell (8-8)   
Sat, Jun 13th@ WSHCade Cavalli (13-5)#34   
Sun, Jun 14th@ WSHPJ Poulin (3-0)   
Tue, Jun 16thvs BALBrandon Young (9-6)#168   
Wed, Jun 17thvs BALKyle Bradish (7-14)   
Thu, Jun 18thvs BALShane Baz (6-15)#85   
Fri, Jun 19thvs BOSRanger Suarez (8-5)#70   
Sat, Jun 20thvs BOSConnelly Early (7-5)#76   
Sun, Jun 21stvs BOSPayton Tolle (9-6)#30   
Tue, Jun 23rd@ PITMitch Keller (6-8)   
Wed, Jun 24th@ PITBraxton Ashcraft (14-6)   
Thu, Jun 25th@ PITBubba Chandler (8-10)#59   
Fri, Jun 26th@ CLEJoey Cantillo (11-9)#63   
Sat, Jun 27th@ CLESlade Cecconi (5-7)#164   
Sun, Jun 28th@ CLEGavin Williams (14-8)#20   
Mon, Jun 29thvs LAARyan Johnson (5-9)#170   
Tue, Jun 30thvs LAAJose Soriano (12-8)#23   
Thu, Jul 2ndvs LAAWalbert Urena (9-11)#40   
Fri, Jul 3rdvs TORDylan Cease (11-6)   
Sat, Jul 4thvs TORShane Bieber (5-2)   
Sun, Jul 5thvs TORTrey Yesavage (5-6)#24   
Tue, Jul 7th@ MIAMax Meyer (9-1)   
Wed, Jul 8th@ MIATyler Phillips (5-6)#247   
Thu, Jul 9th@ MIAJanson Junk (6-9)#138   
Fri, Jul 10th@ TBNick Martinez (15-6)#208   
Sat, Jul 11th@ TBGriffin Jax (8-10)#67   
Sun, Jul 12th@ TBIan Seymour (9-7)#60   
Fri, Jul 17thvs SFLanden Roupp (9-14)   
Sat, Jul 18thvs SFLogan Webb (8-9)   
Sun, Jul 19thvs SFRobbie Ray (13-8)#198   
Mon, Jul 20thvs CINAndrew Abbott (6-11)#149   
Tue, Jul 21stvs CINChase Burns (15-3)   
Wed, Jul 22ndvs CINBrady Singer (6-15)#221   
Fri, Jul 24th@ TEXMacKenzie Gore (8-11)#39   
Sat, Jul 25th@ TEXNathan Eovaldi (11-10)#66   
Sun, Jul 26th@ TEXJacob deGrom (11-11)#12   
Mon, Jul 27th@ TEXKumar Rocker (6-11)#84   
Tue, Jul 28th@ LADJustin Wrobleski (12-5)#50   
Wed, Jul 29th@ LADEric Lauer (8-7)   
Thu, Jul 30th@ LADRoki Sasaki (5-5)#102   
Fri, Jul 31stvs MINZebby Matthews (9-11)#134   
Sat, Aug 1stvs MINConnor Prielipp (6-7)#110   
Sun, Aug 2ndvs MINTaj Bradley (12-6)#44   
Tue, Aug 4thvs DETTroy Melton (8-5)   
Wed, Aug 5thvs DETDrew Anderson (5-7)#38   
Thu, Aug 6thvs DETFramber Valdez (10-12)#53   
Fri, Aug 7thvs TBDrew Rasmussen (16-5)#26   
Sat, Aug 8thvs TBCasey Legumina (2-2)#261   
Sun, Aug 9thvs TBIan Seymour (9-7)#60   
Tue, Aug 11th@ NYYRyan Weathers (5-8)   
Wed, Aug 12th@ NYYWill Warren (11-6)#69   
Thu, Aug 13th@ NYYMax Fried (5-5)#21   
Fri, Aug 14th@ HOUPeter Lambert (8-10)#185   
Sat, Aug 15th@ HOUHayden Wesneski (6-2)#100   
Sun, Aug 16th@ HOUHunter Brown (6-4)#19   
Tue, Aug 18th@ MILKyle Harrison (11-5)#62   
Wed, Aug 19th@ MILDustin May (7-9)#35   
Thu, Aug 20th@ MILRobert Gasser (5-5)#43   
Fri, Aug 21stvs CHCMatthew Boyd (10-5)#78   
Sat, Aug 22ndvs CHCDavid Peterson (9-8)#61   
Sun, Aug 23rdvs CHCShota Imanaga (11-10)#49   
Mon, Aug 24thvs PHIZack Wheeler (14-5)#5   
Tue, Aug 25thvs PHIAaron Nola (7-12)#68   
Wed, Aug 26thvs PHIJesus Luzardo (14-5)   
Fri, Aug 28th@ TORDylan Cease (11-6)   
Sat, Aug 29th@ TORJose Soriano (12-8)#23   
Sun, Aug 30th@ TORMax Scherzer (4-9)#127   
Mon, Aug 31st@ BOSPayton Tolle (9-6)#30   
Tue, Sep 1st@ BOSJedixson Paez (1-1)   
Wed, Sep 2nd@ BOSPatrick Sandoval (1-7)#92   
Thu, Sep 3rdvs ATHJack Perkins (3-13)#171   
Fri, Sep 4thvs ATHKade Morris (0-1)#274   
Sat, Sep 5thvs ATHJeffrey Springs (4-14)#267   
Sun, Sep 6thvs ATHGage Jump (6-11)   
Tue, Sep 8thvs TEXCal Quantrill (9-5)   
Wed, Sep 9thvs TEXCody Bradford (0-5)#139   
Thu, Sep 10thvs TEXJacob deGrom (11-11)#12   
Fri, Sep 11th@ ATHJeffrey Springs (4-14)#267   
Sat, Sep 12th@ ATHGage Jump (6-11)   
Sun, Sep 13th@ ATHJacob Lopez (7-5)#251   
Mon, Sep 14th@ LAAReid Detmers (7-8)#16   
Tue, Sep 15th@ LAARyan Johnson (5-9)#170   
Wed, Sep 16th@ LAAYusei Kikuchi (1-7)#57   
Fri, Sep 18th@ COLGabriel Hughes (0-8)   
Sat, Sep 19th@ COLJose Quintana (2-3)#281   
Sun, Sep 20th@ COLTomoyuki Sugano (12-12)#263   
Tue, Sep 22ndvs HOUCristian Javier (2-6)   
Wed, Sep 23rdvs HOUEthan Pecko (2-0)#148   
Thu, Sep 24thvs LAAGrayson Rodriguez (5-8)#64   
Fri, Sep 25thvs LAAReid Detmers (7-8)#16   
Sat, Sep 26thvs LAARyan Johnson (5-9)#170   
Sun, Sep 27thvs LAAYusei Kikuchi (1-7)#57