Josh Naylor or Rafael Devers
Baseball Stats Comparison
See which player would win in a trade View Trade Analyzer
| Rafael Devers 1B,DH - SF  | Josh Naylor 1B,DH - SEA  | |
| 2026 Stats | ||
| At Bats | 219 | 213 |
| Runs | 22 | 20 |
| Hits | 54 | 55 |
| Singles | 31 | 45 |
| Doubles | 15 | 5 |
| Triples | 1 | 0 |
| Home Runs | 7 | 5 |
| RBI | 29 | 24 |
| Stolen Bases | 0 | 12 |
| Caught Stealing | 0 | 2 |
| Walks | 14 | 20 |
| Strikeouts | 70 | 32 |
| Batting Average | .247 | .258 |
| On Base Pct | .292 | .323 |
| Slugging Pct | .420 | .352 |
| On-base Plus Slugging | .713 | .676 |
| Rafael Devers 1B,DH - SF | Josh Naylor 1B,DH - SEA | |
| 2026 Projections | ||
| At Bats | 560 | 536 |
| Runs | 88 | 73 |
| Hits | 143 | 144 |
| Singles | 81 | 92 |
| Doubles | 29 | 28 |
| Triples | 1 | 0 |
| Home Runs | 30 | 22 |
| RBI | 92 | 87 |
| Stolen Bases | 2 | 17 |
| Caught Stealing | 1 | 3 |
| Walks | 82 | 49 |
| Strikeouts | 158 | 89 |
| Batting Average | .255 | .268 |
| On Base Pct | .349 | .328 |
| Slugging Pct | .473 | .444 |
| On-base Plus Slugging | .822 | .772 |
| Rafael Devers 1B,DH - SF | Josh Naylor 1B,DH - SEA | |
| News | ||
| Rafael Devers went 2-for-4 in an 8-5 win over the White Sox with a home run, a double, one run scored, and five RBI. Chris Schommer Mon, May 25th | Josh Naylor went 3-for-4 with two stolen bases in the Mariners 6-1 win over the White Sox on Monday. Ari Koslow Tue, May 19th | |
| Rafael Devers went 2-for-4 in Tuesday’s 5-3 loss to the Diamondbacks with a solo home run and a double. Chris Schommer Wed, May 20th | Josh Naylor went 3-for-5 with a home run, three RBI and three runs scored in the Mariners 12-8 win over the White Sox on Friday. Ari Koslow Sat, May 9th | |
| Rafael Devers went 2-for-3 in a win over the Dodgers with a home run, three runs scored, two RBI, and a walk. Chris Schommer Tue, May 12th | Josh Naylor went 3-for-5 with a home run and four RBI in the Mariners 7-1 win over the Twins on Tuesday. Ari Koslow Wed, Apr 29th | |
| Rafael Devers went 2-for-4 in a win over the Pirates with a home run, two runs scored, and one RBI. Chris Schommer Sat, May 9th | Josh Naylor is back in the Mariners lineup on Monday against the Twins. Ari Koslow Mon, Apr 27th | |
| Rafael Devers went 1-for-3 with a solo home run in a 5-1 loss to the Padres. Chris Schommer Wed, May 6th | Josh Naylor is not in the Mariners lineup on Sunday against the Cardinals due to quad tightness. Ari Koslow Sun, Apr 26th | |
| Notes | ||
| Rafael Devers forced his way out of Boston early in the year and landed in the less fantasy-friendly environment of San Francisco. His numbers held steady for the most part, producing 35 home runs, 99 runs, and 109 RBI, though his batting average was the lowest since 2018. His Barrel percentage jumped from 13% to 16%, and his HardHit rate leapt to 56.1%, both the highest of his career. Projections have him essentially continuing on with these numbers, and at a thinner 1B than expected, Devers is a sneaky pick currently going in the fifth round. Kelly Kirby - FantasyPros | Let's start with the important part: Josh Naylor will not steal 30 bases again in 2026. With a previous high of 10, the 30 was a gift to managers who drafted him and will most likely be the outlier of his career. Naylor did sacrifice power in his time between Arizona and Seattle, hitting only 20 home runs after smacking 31 the year before. The .295 average helped offset this to some degree, but as a career .269 hitter, this is also suspect to continue. Even though he will only be 29 this season, the return to Seattle limits the upside we can expect. He's more of an avoid, unless he falls in drafts. Kelly Kirby - FantasyPros | |
| Mysterious spike in stolen bases, plays in the toughest offensive park in the game, and a mediocre batted ball profile - I am passing on Naylor at his ADP. Anthony Gambale - Roto Street Journal | ||
| Rafael Devers 1B,DH - SF | Josh Naylor 1B,DH - SEA | |||||
| Date | Opp | Opp Pitcher | VBR | Opp | Opp Pitcher | VBR |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Thu, Mar 26th | vs CLE | Tanner Bibee (0-7) | #38 | |||
| Fri, Mar 27th | vs NYY | Cam Schlittler (7-2) | #36 | vs CLE | Gavin Williams (8-3) | #27 |
| Sat, Mar 28th | vs NYY | Will Warren (6-1) | #61 | vs CLE | Joey Cantillo (4-2) | #98 |
| Sun, Mar 29th | vs CLE | Slade Cecconi (3-5) | #112 | |||
| Mon, Mar 30th | @ SD | Walker Buehler (3-3) | #211 | vs NYY | Ryan Weathers (2-2) | #70 |
| Tue, Mar 31st | @ SD | German Marquez (3-2) | #329 | vs NYY | Max Fried (4-3) | #34 |
| Wed, Apr 1st | @ SD | Nick Pivetta (1-2) | #144 | vs NYY | Cam Schlittler (7-2) | #36 |
| Fri, Apr 3rd | vs NYM | Nolan McLean (2-4) | #29 | @ LAA | Reid Detmers (1-5) | #47 |
| Sat, Apr 4th | vs NYM | Clay Holmes (4-4) | #169 | @ LAA | Jack Kochanowicz (2-3) | #417 |
| Sun, Apr 5th | vs NYM | Kodai Senga (0-4) | #132 | @ LAA | George Klassen (0-1) | #340 |
| Mon, Apr 6th | vs PHI | Andrew Painter (1-5) | #165 | @ TEX | Jacob deGrom (3-4) | #8 |
| Tue, Apr 7th | vs PHI | Cristopher Sanchez (6-2) | #3 | @ TEX | Nathan Eovaldi (5-6) | #20 |
| Wed, Apr 8th | vs PHI | Aaron Nola (3-4) | #37 | @ TEX | MacKenzie Gore (4-4) | #52 |
| Fri, Apr 10th | @ BAL | Shane Baz (2-5) | #83 | vs HOU | Tatsuya Imai (2-2) | #154 |
| Sat, Apr 11th | @ BAL | Chris Bassitt (4-3) | #123 | vs HOU | Lance McCullers Jr. (2-3) | #206 |
| Sun, Apr 12th | @ BAL | Cade Povich (1-1) | #208 | vs HOU | Cody Bolton (0-1) | #397 |
| Mon, Apr 13th | vs HOU | Mike Burrows (3-6) | #120 | |||
| Tue, Apr 14th | @ CIN | Brady Singer (2-4) | #140 | @ SD | Michael King (4-3) | #35 |
| Wed, Apr 15th | @ CIN | Rhett Lowder (3-3) | #203 | @ SD | Randy Vasquez (5-3) | #201 |
| Thu, Apr 16th | @ CIN | Chase Burns (7-1) | #25 | @ SD | Walker Buehler (3-3) | #211 |
| Fri, Apr 17th | @ WSH | Zack Littell (4-4) | #168 | vs TEX | Jacob deGrom (3-4) | #8 |
| Sat, Apr 18th | @ WSH | Cade Cavalli (3-3) | #88 | vs TEX | Nathan Eovaldi (5-6) | #20 |
| Sun, Apr 19th | @ WSH | PJ Poulin (3-0) | #248 | vs TEX | MacKenzie Gore (4-4) | #52 |
| Mon, Apr 20th | vs ATH | J.T. Ginn (2-3) | #130 | |||
| Tue, Apr 21st | vs LAD | Yoshinobu Yamamoto (4-4) | #12 | vs ATH | Jacob Lopez (4-2) | #200 |
| Wed, Apr 22nd | vs LAD | Shohei Ohtani (5-2) | #1 | vs ATH | Aaron Civale (5-2) | #218 |
| Fri, Apr 24th | vs MIA | Sandy Alcantara (3-4) | #77 | @ STL | Andre Pallante (5-4) | #146 |
| Sat, Apr 25th | vs MIA | Eury Perez (3-6) | #59 | @ STL | Matthew Liberatore (2-3) | #117 |
| Sun, Apr 26th | vs MIA | Max Meyer (5-0) | #72 | @ STL | Michael McGreevy (3-4) | #85 |
| Mon, Apr 27th | @ MIN | Connor Prielipp (1-3) | #125 | |||
| Tue, Apr 28th | @ PHI | Jesus Luzardo (4-4) | #9 | @ MIN | Joe Ryan (3-3) | #14 |
| Wed, Apr 29th | @ MIN | Taj Bradley (5-1) | #68 | |||
| Fri, May 1st | @ TB | Shane McClanahan (5-2) | #23 | vs KC | Cole Ragans (1-4) | #49 |
| Sat, May 2nd | @ TB | Griffin Jax (1-3) | #51 | vs KC | Seth Lugo (2-4) | #110 |
| Sun, May 3rd | @ TB | Steven Matz (4-2) | #101 | vs KC | Kris Bubic (3-2) | #78 |
| Mon, May 4th | vs SD | Randy Vasquez (5-3) | #201 | vs ATL | JR Ritchie (1-1) | #241 |
| Tue, May 5th | vs SD | Walker Buehler (3-3) | #211 | vs ATL | Bryce Elder (4-3) | #114 |
| Wed, May 6th | vs SD | Bradgley Rodriguez | vs ATL | Martin Perez (2-3) | #195 | |
| Fri, May 8th | vs PIT | Carmen Mlodzinski (4-3) | #124 | @ CWS | Sean Burke (2-3) | #138 |
| Sat, May 9th | vs PIT | Braxton Ashcraft (4-2) | #48 | @ CWS | Anthony Kay (4-1) | #183 |
| Sun, May 10th | vs PIT | Bubba Chandler (1-6) | #122 | @ CWS | Davis Martin (8-1) | #73 |
| Mon, May 11th | @ LAD | Roki Sasaki (3-3) | #126 | @ HOU | Peter Lambert (3-4) | #185 |
| Tue, May 12th | @ LAD | Yoshinobu Yamamoto (4-4) | #12 | @ HOU | Tatsuya Imai (2-2) | #154 |
| Wed, May 13th | @ LAD | Shohei Ohtani (5-2) | #1 | @ HOU | Lance McCullers Jr. (2-3) | #206 |
| Thu, May 14th | @ LAD | Emmet Sheehan (3-1) | #41 | @ HOU | Mike Burrows (3-6) | #120 |
| Fri, May 15th | @ ATH | Aaron Civale (5-2) | #218 | vs SD | Randy Vasquez (5-3) | #201 |
| Sat, May 16th | @ ATH | Luis Severino (2-6) | #116 | vs SD | Walker Buehler (3-3) | #211 |
| Sun, May 17th | @ ATH | Jeffrey Springs (3-6) | #111 | vs SD | Lucas Giolito (2-0) | #157 |
| Mon, May 18th | @ ARI | Zac Gallen (3-4) | #66 | vs CWS | Noah Schultz (2-4) | #222 |
| Tue, May 19th | @ ARI | Ryne Nelson (2-3) | #94 | vs CWS | Anthony Kay (4-1) | #183 |
| Wed, May 20th | @ ARI | Merrill Kelly (5-3) | #93 | vs CWS | Sean Burke (2-3) | #138 |
| Fri, May 22nd | vs CWS | Davis Martin (8-1) | #73 | @ KC | Noah Cameron (2-4) | #91 |
| Sat, May 23rd | vs CWS | Bryan Hudson (3-1) | #177 | @ KC | Stephen Kolek (3-1) | #167 |
| Sun, May 24th | vs CWS | Noah Schultz (2-4) | #222 | @ KC | Seth Lugo (2-4) | #110 |
| Mon, May 25th | vs ARI | Merrill Kelly (5-3) | #93 | @ ATH | Aaron Civale (5-2) | #218 |
| Tue, May 26th | vs ARI | Eduardo Rodriguez (5-1) | #115 | @ ATH | Gage Jump (0-1) | #151 |
| Wed, May 27th | vs ARI | Michael Soroka (7-2) | #71 | @ ATH | Jeffrey Springs (3-6) | #111 |
| Fri, May 29th | @ COL | Michael Lorenzen (2-7) | #423 | vs ARI | Zac Gallen (3-4) | #66 |
| Sat, May 30th | @ COL | Ryan Feltner (1-1) | #421 | vs ARI | Ryne Nelson (2-3) | #94 |
| Sun, May 31st | @ COL | Tanner Gordon (0-0) | #322 | vs ARI | Merrill Kelly (5-3) | #93 |
| Mon, Jun 1st | @ MIL | Kyle Harrison (6-1) | #69 | vs NYM | Sean Manaea (0-1) | #92 |
| Tue, Jun 2nd | @ MIL | Chad Patrick (2-2) | #129 | vs NYM | Kodai Senga (0-4) | #132 |
| Wed, Jun 3rd | @ MIL | Coleman Crow (0-0) | #189 | vs NYM | Freddy Peralta (3-4) | #28 |
| Fri, Jun 5th | @ CHC | Ben Brown (1-2) | #55 | @ DET | Framber Valdez (2-3) | #26 |
| Sat, Jun 6th | @ CHC | Edward Cabrera (3-2) | #74 | @ DET | Keider Montero (2-3) | #205 |
| Sun, Jun 7th | @ CHC | Jameson Taillon (2-4) | #108 | @ DET | Casey Mize (2-3) | #53 |
| Mon, Jun 8th | vs WSH | Miles Mikolas (1-4) | #216 | @ BAL | Chris Bassitt (4-3) | #123 |
| Tue, Jun 9th | vs WSH | @ BAL | ||||
| Wed, Jun 10th | vs WSH | @ BAL | ||||
| Thu, Jun 11th | @ BAL | |||||
| Fri, Jun 12th | vs CHC | @ WSH | ||||
| Sat, Jun 13th | vs CHC | @ WSH | ||||
| Sun, Jun 14th | vs CHC | @ WSH | ||||
| Tue, Jun 16th | @ ATL | vs BAL | ||||
| Wed, Jun 17th | @ ATL | vs BAL | ||||
| Thu, Jun 18th | @ ATL | vs BAL | ||||
| Fri, Jun 19th | @ MIA | vs BOS | ||||
| Sat, Jun 20th | @ MIA | vs BOS | ||||
| Sun, Jun 21st | @ MIA | vs BOS | ||||
| Tue, Jun 23rd | vs ATH | @ PIT | ||||
| Wed, Jun 24th | vs ATH | @ PIT | ||||
| Thu, Jun 25th | vs ATH | @ PIT | ||||
| Fri, Jun 26th | vs ATL | @ CLE | ||||
| Sat, Jun 27th | vs ATL | @ CLE | ||||
| Sun, Jun 28th | vs ATL | @ CLE | ||||
| Mon, Jun 29th | @ ARI | vs LAA | ||||
| Tue, Jun 30th | @ ARI | vs LAA | ||||
| Thu, Jul 2nd | vs LAA | |||||
| Fri, Jul 3rd | @ COL | vs TOR | ||||
| Sat, Jul 4th | @ COL | vs TOR | ||||
| Sun, Jul 5th | @ COL | vs TOR | ||||
| Tue, Jul 7th | vs TOR | @ MIA | ||||
| Wed, Jul 8th | vs TOR | @ MIA | ||||
| Thu, Jul 9th | vs COL | @ MIA | ||||
| Fri, Jul 10th | vs COL | @ TB | ||||
| Sat, Jul 11th | vs COL | @ TB | ||||
| Sun, Jul 12th | vs COL | @ TB | ||||
| Fri, Jul 17th | @ SEA | vs SF | ||||
| Sat, Jul 18th | @ SEA | vs SF | ||||
| Sun, Jul 19th | @ SEA | vs SF | ||||
| Mon, Jul 20th | @ KC | vs CIN | ||||
| Tue, Jul 21st | @ KC | vs CIN | ||||
| Wed, Jul 22nd | @ KC | vs CIN | ||||
| Fri, Jul 24th | vs LAA | @ TEX | ||||
| Sat, Jul 25th | vs LAA | @ TEX | ||||
| Sun, Jul 26th | vs LAA | @ TEX | ||||
| Mon, Jul 27th | vs MIL | @ TEX | ||||
| Tue, Jul 28th | vs MIL | @ LAD | ||||
| Wed, Jul 29th | vs MIL | @ LAD | ||||
| Thu, Jul 30th | @ SD | @ LAD | ||||
| Fri, Jul 31st | @ SD | vs MIN | ||||
| Sat, Aug 1st | @ SD | vs MIN | ||||
| Sun, Aug 2nd | @ SD | vs MIN | ||||
| Tue, Aug 4th | @ TEX | vs DET | ||||
| Wed, Aug 5th | @ TEX | vs DET | ||||
| Thu, Aug 6th | vs DET | |||||
| Fri, Aug 7th | vs DET | vs TB | ||||
| Sat, Aug 8th | vs DET | vs TB | ||||
| Sun, Aug 9th | vs DET | vs TB | ||||
| Tue, Aug 11th | vs HOU | @ NYY | ||||
| Wed, Aug 12th | vs HOU | @ NYY | ||||
| Thu, Aug 13th | @ NYY | |||||
| Fri, Aug 14th | vs COL | @ HOU | ||||
| Sat, Aug 15th | vs COL | @ HOU | ||||
| Sun, Aug 16th | vs COL | @ HOU | ||||
| Tue, Aug 18th | @ CLE | @ MIL | ||||
| Wed, Aug 19th | @ CLE | @ MIL | ||||
| Thu, Aug 20th | @ CLE | @ MIL | ||||
| Fri, Aug 21st | @ BOS | vs CHC | ||||
| Sat, Aug 22nd | @ BOS | vs CHC | ||||
| Sun, Aug 23rd | @ BOS | vs CHC | ||||
| Mon, Aug 24th | vs CIN | vs PHI | ||||
| Tue, Aug 25th | vs CIN | vs PHI | ||||
| Wed, Aug 26th | vs CIN | vs PHI | ||||
| Fri, Aug 28th | vs ARI | @ TOR | ||||
| Sat, Aug 29th | vs ARI | @ TOR | ||||
| Sun, Aug 30th | vs ARI | @ TOR | ||||
| Mon, Aug 31st | @ BOS | |||||
| Tue, Sep 1st | @ PIT | @ BOS | ||||
| Wed, Sep 2nd | @ PIT | @ BOS | ||||
| Thu, Sep 3rd | @ PIT | vs ATH | ||||
| Fri, Sep 4th | @ NYM | vs ATH | ||||
| Sat, Sep 5th | @ NYM | vs ATH | ||||
| Sun, Sep 6th | @ NYM | vs ATH | ||||
| Tue, Sep 8th | vs STL | vs TEX | ||||
| Wed, Sep 9th | vs STL | vs TEX | ||||
| Thu, Sep 10th | vs TEX | |||||
| Fri, Sep 11th | vs SD | @ ATH | ||||
| Sat, Sep 12th | vs SD | @ ATH | ||||
| Sun, Sep 13th | vs SD | @ ATH | ||||
| Mon, Sep 14th | @ STL | @ LAA | ||||
| Tue, Sep 15th | @ STL | @ LAA | ||||
| Wed, Sep 16th | @ STL | @ LAA | ||||
| Fri, Sep 18th | @ LAD | @ COL | ||||
| Sat, Sep 19th | @ LAD | @ COL | ||||
| Sun, Sep 20th | @ LAD | @ COL | ||||
| Tue, Sep 22nd | vs MIN | vs HOU | ||||
| Wed, Sep 23rd | vs MIN | vs HOU | ||||
| Thu, Sep 24th | vs LAA | |||||
| Fri, Sep 25th | vs LAD | vs LAA | ||||
| Sat, Sep 26th | vs LAD | vs LAA | ||||
| Sun, Sep 27th | vs LAD | vs LAA | ||||
| Wed, Mar 25th | vs NYY | Max Fried (4-3) | #34 | |||
| Thu, Apr 2nd | vs NYM | David Peterson (3-5) | #103 | |||
| Thu, Apr 23rd | vs LAD | Tyler Glasnow (3-0) | #39 | |||
| Thu, Apr 30th | @ PHI | Tim Mayza | ||||
| Thu, Jun 4th | @ MIL | Brandon Sproat (1-3) | #135 | |||
| Wed, Jul 1st | @ ARI | |||||
| Mon, Jul 6th | vs TOR | |||||
| Mon, Aug 3rd | @ TEX | |||||
| Mon, Aug 10th | vs HOU | |||||
| Thu, Aug 27th | vs ARI | |||||
| Mon, Sep 7th | vs STL | |||||
| Mon, Sep 21st | vs MIN | |||||
