Skip to main content

Who Should I Trade?

Matt Carpenter for Andrew McCutchen (2023)

See if your team wins or loses with this trade View Trade Analyzer

Who Should I Trade? Player Summaries
Experts' Pick
  Andrew McCutchen
Andrew McCutchen
Matt Carpenter
Matt Carpenter
Recommended by
10 of 11 experts
Recommended by
1 of 11 experts
Rest of Season# 164# 284
VBR# 150# 671
Home Runs118
Stolen Bases81
Batting Average.251.212
Injury Alert--
Expert Ranks 
Dalton Del Don
Yahoo! Sports
# 138
Mike Maher
# 124# 275
Aaron Schill
FF Faceoff
# 178
Brandon 'B_Don' Myers
# 207
Keith Lott
Fantasy Six Pack
# 164
Mick Ciallela
# 139# 286
Scott Youngson
Pitcher List
# 115
Kelly Kirby
# 196
Blake Meyer
Sports Gambling Podcast Network
# 134
Tristan Davis
SEMO Fantasy Sports Podcast
# 117
Nate Miller
# 190# 179
Who Should I Trade? Player Statistics
  Andrew McCutchen
Andrew McCutchen
Matt Carpenter
Matt Carpenter
2023 Stats 
At Bats180118
Home Runs84
Stolen Bases70
Caught Stealing20
Batting Average.272.178
On Base Pct.368.298
Slugging Pct.444.356
On-base Plus Slugging.812.654
Who Should I Trade? Player Projections
  Andrew McCutchen
Andrew McCutchen
Matt Carpenter
Matt Carpenter
2023 Projections 
At Bats306202
Home Runs118
Stolen Bases81
Caught Stealing21
Batting Average.251.212
On Base Pct.342.318
Slugging Pct.414.395
On-base Plus Slugging.756.713
Who Should I Trade? Player Notes
  Andrew McCutchen
Andrew McCutchen
Matt Carpenter
Matt Carpenter
 Andrew McCutchen is out of the lineup for the Pittsburgh Pirates against the St. Louis Cardinals Sunday.
Chris Schommer
Sun, Jun 4th
Matt Carpenter had a productive day at the plate, driving in three runs on one hit - a solo home run - and scoring two runs himself in the Padres' 7-0 victory over the Red Sox on Sunday.
Chris Schommer
Mon, May 22nd
 Andrew McCutchen went 2-for-4 at the plate with a walk and a stolen base, scoring one of the Pirates' seven runs in their 7-5 victory over the Cardinals on Friday.
Jesse Garcia
Fri, Jun 2nd
San Diego Padres designated hitter Matt Carpenter is not in Friday's starting lineup against the Los Angeles Dodgers.
Brenton Kemp
Fri, May 5th
 Andrew McCutchen went 2-for-5 with a home run, two runs scored, and an RBI in the 11-6 win.
Jesse Garcia
Sat, May 27th
Padres DH Matt Carpenter had a big day at the dish Sunday, leading San Diego to a 7-5 win over Arizona. He finished 3-for-3 with a home run, five RBI and two doubles.
Kendall Capps
Sun, Apr 23rd
 Andrew McCutchen went 3-for-4 with a walk, contributing to the Pirates' 13-3 victory over the Diamondbacks on Friday.
Jesse Garcia
Fri, May 19th
Matt Carpenter went 1-for-1 at the plate for the Padres Thursday night, blasting a solo home run while also walking once and scoring two runs in a 7-5 win over the Diamondbacks.
Chris Schommer
Fri, Apr 21st
 Andrew McCutchen had a strong showing at the plate, going 3-for-3 with a home run and two RBI in the Pirates' 4-3 loss to the Rockies on Wednesday.
Nate Miller - FantasyPros
Thu, May 11th
Matt Carpenter is back in the lineup for the San Diego Padres against the Atlanta Braves Tuesday night.
Chris Schommer
Tue, Apr 18th
There are no recent notes for these players
Who Should I Trade? Player Schedules
  Andrew McCutchen
Andrew McCutchen
Matt Carpenter
Matt Carpenter
Date OppOpp PitcherVBROppOpp PitcherVBR
Thu, Mar 30th@ CINHunter Greene (1-4)#61vs COLGerman Marquez (2-2)
Fri, Mar 31st   vs COLKyle Freeland (4-6)#167
Sat, Apr 1st@ CINNick Lodolo (2-1)#95vs COLJose Urena (0-4)#371
Sun, Apr 2nd@ CINGraham Ashcraft (3-4)#291vs COLAustin Gomber (4-4)#368
Mon, Apr 3rd@ BOSKutter Crawford (1-2)#165vs ARIRyne Nelson (2-3)#161
Tue, Apr 4th@ BOSNick Pivetta (3-3)#151vs ARIZac Gallen (7-2)#8
Thu, Apr 6th   @ ATLSpencer Strider (6-2)#3
Fri, Apr 7thvs CWSLucas Giolito (4-4)#41@ ATLJared Shuster (2-2)#125
Sat, Apr 8thvs CWSMike Clevinger (3-3)#144@ ATLCharlie Morton (5-6)#47
Sun, Apr 9thvs CWSMichael Kopech (3-5)#108@ ATLDylan Dodd (2-1)#270
Mon, Apr 10thvs HOUFramber Valdez (6-4)#7@ NYMMax Scherzer (5-2)#15
Tue, Apr 11thvs HOUCristian Javier (7-1)#11@ NYMDavid Peterson (1-6)#115
Wed, Apr 12thvs HOUJose Urquidy (2-2)#67@ NYMTylor Megill (5-3)#58
Thu, Apr 13th@ STLJordan Montgomery (2-7)#51vs MILColin Rea (3-3)#232
Fri, Apr 14th@ STLJake Woodford (1-2)#242vs MILEric Lauer (4-5)#86
Sat, Apr 15th@ STLSteven Matz (0-6)#119vs MILFreddy Peralta (5-5)#48
Sun, Apr 16th@ STLMiles Mikolas (4-1)#50vs MILWade Miley (3-2)#169
Mon, Apr 17th@ COLKyle Freeland (4-6)#167vs ATLMax Fried (2-1)#21
Tue, Apr 18th@ COLJose Urena (0-4)#371vs ATLSpencer Strider (6-2)#3
Wed, Apr 19th@ COLAustin Gomber (4-4)#368vs ATLCharlie Morton (5-6)#47
Thu, Apr 20thvs CINLuke Weaver (1-2)#206@ ARIRyne Nelson (2-3)#161
Fri, Apr 21stvs CINGraham Ashcraft (3-4)#291@ ARIZac Gallen (7-2)#8
Sat, Apr 22ndvs CINLuis Cessa (1-4)#363@ ARIMerrill Kelly (7-3)#37
Sun, Apr 23rdvs CINHunter Greene (1-4)#61@ ARIDrey Jameson (2-1)#166
Tue, Apr 25thvs LADNoah Syndergaard (1-4)#174@ CHCJustin Steele (6-2)#54
Wed, Apr 26thvs LADTony Gonsolin (3-1)#63@ CHCDrew Smyly (5-3)#70
Thu, Apr 27thvs LADJulio Urias (5-4)#27@ CHCHayden Wesneski (2-2)#107
Sat, Apr 29th@ WSHChad Kuhl (0-3)#294vs SFSean Manaea (2-3)#114
Sun, Apr 30th@ WSHJosiah Gray (4-5)#87vs SFAlex Cobb (5-2)#31
Mon, May 1st   vs CINLuke Weaver (1-2)#206
Tue, May 2nd@ TBJavy Guerravs CINGraham Ashcraft (3-4)#291
Wed, May 3rd@ TBShane McClanahan (8-1)#5vs CINLuis Cessa (1-4)#363
Fri, May 5thvs TORChris Bassitt (6-4)#25vs LADClayton Kershaw (7-4)#12
Sat, May 6thvs TORJose Berrios (5-4)#39vs LADDustin May (4-1)#55
Sun, May 7thvs TORYusei Kikuchi (6-2)#99vs LADJulio Urias (5-4)#27
Tue, May 9thvs COLConnor Seabold (1-2)#290@ MINLouie Varland (3-1)#92
Wed, May 10thvs COLAntonio Senzatela (0-1)#356@ MINPablo Lopez (3-3)#36
Thu, May 11th   @ MINBailey Ober (3-2)#77
Fri, May 12th@ BALKyle Bradish (2-2)#97@ LADDustin May (4-1)#55
Sat, May 13th@ BALTyler Wells (3-2)#57@ LADJulio Urias (5-4)#27
Sun, May 14th@ BALKyle Gibson (7-3)#76@ LADTony Gonsolin (3-1)#63
Mon, May 15th   vs KCBrad Keller (3-4)#277
Tue, May 16th@ DETMichael Lorenzen (2-2)#104vs KCBrady Singer (3-4)#121
Wed, May 17th@ DETEduardo Rodriguez (4-4)#40vs KCCarlos Hernandez (0-3)#209
Fri, May 19thvs ARIZac Gallen (7-2)#8vs BOSJames Paxton (1-1)#120
Sat, May 20thvs ARIBrandon Pfaadt (0-2)#162vs BOSChris Sale (5-2)#46
Sun, May 21stvs ARIMerrill Kelly (7-3)#37vs BOSCorey Kluber (3-6)#148
Tue, May 23rdvs TEXNathan Eovaldi (7-2)#29@ WSHMacKenzie Gore (3-4)#105
Wed, May 24thvs TEXMartin Perez (6-1)#74@ WSHTrevor Williams (2-3)#124
Thu, May 25th   @ WSHJake Irvin (1-3)#202
Fri, May 26th@ SEAGeorge Kirby (5-4)#20@ NYYRandy Vasquez (0-1)#338
Sat, May 27th@ SEALuis Castillo (4-3)#2@ NYYLuis Severino (0-1)#52
Sun, May 28th@ SEAMarco Gonzales (4-1)#155@ NYYGerrit Cole (7-0)#4
Tue, May 30th@ SFJohn Brebbia (2-0)#175@ MIASandy Alcantara (2-5)#23
Wed, May 31st@ SFAlex Wood (1-1)#129@ MIABraxton Garrett (1-2)#122
Thu, Jun 1st   @ MIAJesus Luzardo (4-4)#73
Fri, Jun 2ndvs STLJack Flaherty (3-4)#79vs CHCJameson Taillon (1-3)#130
Sat, Jun 3rdvs STLJordan Montgomery (2-7)#51vs CHCDrew Smyly (5-3)#70
Sun, Jun 4thvs STLMiles Mikolas (4-1)#50vs CHCMarcus Stroman (5-4)#38
Mon, Jun 5thvs OAKJP Sears (0-3)#83vs CHCKyle Hendricks (0-1)#201
Tue, Jun 6thvs OAKJames Kaprielian (0-6)#238vs SEALogan Gilbert (3-3)#26
Wed, Jun 7thvs OAKHogan Harris (0-0)#324vs SEAGeorge Kirby (5-4)#20
Fri, Jun 9thvs NYMTylor Megill (5-3)#58@ COLAustin Gomber (4-4)#368
Sat, Jun 10thvs NYMKodai Senga (5-3)#65@ COLKyle Freeland (4-6)#167
Sun, Jun 11thvs NYMCarlos Carrasco (2-2)#78@ COLDinelson Lamet
Tue, Jun 13th@ CHCvs CLE
Wed, Jun 14th@ CHCvs CLE
Thu, Jun 15th@ CHCvs CLE
Fri, Jun 16th@ MILvs TB
Sat, Jun 17th@ MILvs TB
Sun, Jun 18th@ MILvs TB
Mon, Jun 19thvs CHC@ SF
Tue, Jun 20thvs CHC@ SF
Wed, Jun 21stvs CHC@ SF
Thu, Jun 22nd@ MIA@ SF
Fri, Jun 23rd@ MIAvs WSH
Sat, Jun 24th@ MIAvs WSH
Sun, Jun 25th@ MIAvs WSH
Tue, Jun 27thvs SD@ PIT
Wed, Jun 28thvs SD@ PIT
Thu, Jun 29thvs SD@ PIT
Fri, Jun 30thvs MIL@ CIN
Sat, Jul 1stvs MIL@ CIN
Sun, Jul 2ndvs MIL@ CIN
Mon, Jul 3rd@ LADvs LAA
Tue, Jul 4th@ LADvs LAA
Wed, Jul 5th@ LADvs LAA
Fri, Jul 7th@ ARIvs NYM
Sat, Jul 8th@ ARIvs NYM
Sun, Jul 9th@ ARIvs NYM
Fri, Jul 14thvs SF@ PHI
Sat, Jul 15thvs SF@ PHI
Sun, Jul 16thvs SF@ PHI
Tue, Jul 18thvs CLE@ TOR
Wed, Jul 19thvs CLE@ TOR
Thu, Jul 20th   @ TOR
Fri, Jul 21st@ LAA@ DET
Sat, Jul 22nd@ LAA@ DET
Sun, Jul 23rd@ LAA@ DET
Mon, Jul 24th@ SDvs PIT
Tue, Jul 25th@ SDvs PIT
Wed, Jul 26th@ SDvs PIT
Fri, Jul 28thvs PHIvs TEX
Sat, Jul 29thvs PHIvs TEX
Sun, Jul 30thvs PHIvs TEX
Mon, Jul 31st   @ COL
Tue, Aug 1stvs DET@ COL
Wed, Aug 2ndvs DET@ COL
Fri, Aug 4th@ MILvs LAD
Sat, Aug 5th@ MILvs LAD
Sun, Aug 6th@ MILvs LAD
Mon, Aug 7thvs ATLvs LAD
Tue, Aug 8thvs ATL@ SEA
Wed, Aug 9thvs ATL@ SEA
Fri, Aug 11thvs CIN@ ARI
Sat, Aug 12thvs CIN@ ARI
Sun, Aug 13thvs CIN@ ARI
Mon, Aug 14th@ NYMvs BAL
Tue, Aug 15th@ NYMvs BAL
Wed, Aug 16th@ NYMvs BAL
Thu, Aug 17th   vs ARI
Fri, Aug 18th@ MINvs ARI
Sat, Aug 19th@ MINvs ARI
Sun, Aug 20th@ MINvs ARI
Mon, Aug 21stvs STLvs MIA
Tue, Aug 22ndvs STLvs MIA
Wed, Aug 23rdvs STLvs MIA
Fri, Aug 25thvs CHC@ MIL
Sat, Aug 26thvs CHC@ MIL
Sun, Aug 27thvs CHC@ MIL
Mon, Aug 28th@ KC@ STL
Tue, Aug 29th@ KC@ STL
Wed, Aug 30th@ KC@ STL
Thu, Aug 31st   vs SF
Fri, Sep 1st@ STLvs SF
Sat, Sep 2nd@ STLvs SF
Sun, Sep 3rd@ STLvs SF
Mon, Sep 4thvs MILvs PHI
Tue, Sep 5thvs MILvs PHI
Wed, Sep 6thvs MILvs PHI
Fri, Sep 8th@ ATL@ HOU
Sat, Sep 9th@ ATL@ HOU
Sun, Sep 10th@ ATL@ HOU
Mon, Sep 11thvs WSH@ LAD
Tue, Sep 12thvs WSH@ LAD
Wed, Sep 13thvs WSH@ LAD
Fri, Sep 15thvs NYY@ OAK
Sat, Sep 16thvs NYY@ OAK
Sun, Sep 17thvs NYY@ OAK
Mon, Sep 18th   vs COL
Tue, Sep 19th@ CHCvs COL
Wed, Sep 20th@ CHCvs COL
Fri, Sep 22nd@ CINvs STL
Sat, Sep 23rd@ CINvs STL
Sun, Sep 24th@ CINvs STL
Mon, Sep 25th   @ SF
Tue, Sep 26th@ PHI@ SF
Wed, Sep 27th@ PHI@ SF
Fri, Sep 29thvs MIA@ CWS
Sat, Sep 30thvs MIA@ CWS
Sun, Oct 1stvs MIA@ CWS
Wed, Apr 5th@ BOSCorey Kluber (3-6)#148   
Thu, May 4th@ TBZach Eflin (7-1)#43   
Mon, May 8thvs COLKyle Freeland (4-6)#167   
Mon, May 22ndvs TEXDane Dunning (4-1)#91   
Mon, May 29th@ SFAnthony DeSclafani (4-4)#85   
Thu, Jul 6th@ LAD   
Mon, Jul 17thvs CLE   
Thu, Aug 3rd@ MIL   
Thu, Aug 10thvs ATL   
Thu, Aug 24thvs CHC   
Thu, Sep 14thvs WSH   
Thu, Sep 21st@ CHC   
Thu, Sep 28th@ PHI