Skip to main content

Who Should I Trade?

Tommy Edman for Nick Castellanos (2024)


See if your team wins or loses with this trade View Trade Analyzer

Who Should I Trade? Player Summaries
 
Experts' Pick
 
  Nick Castellanos
DH,RF - PHI
Nick Castellanos
Tommy Edman
2B,SS,CF,RF - LAD
Tommy Edman
Expert
Recommendation
92%
Recommended by
12 of 13 experts
8%
Recommended by
1 of 13 experts
Rankings 
   
Rest of Season# 53# 174
VBR# 43# 95
   
Projections 
   
Runs98
Home Runs31
RBI106
Stolen Bases13
Batting Average.256.259
   
Misc 
   
Injury Alert--
   
Expert Ranks 
   
Andy Behrens
Yahoo! Sports
# 46
   
Scott Pianowski
Yahoo! Sports
# 75
   
Pat Fitzmaurice
FantasyPros
# 47# 118
   
Jeff Boggis
Fantasy Football Empire
# 78
   
Dalton Del Don
Yahoo! Sports
# 56# 143
   
Chris Welsh
FantasyPros
# 92
   
Mike Maher
FantasyPros
# 56# 81
   
Pierre Camus
Fantasy Endgame
# 62
   
Joe Pisapia
FantasyPros
# 47
   
Kev Mahserejian
RotoBaller
# 85
   
Kelly Kirby
FantasyPros
# 40# 84
   
Chase Davis
FantasyPros
# 59
   
Tim Kanak
Fantasy Aceball
# 162# 156
   
Who Should I Trade? Player Statistics
  Nick Castellanos
DH,RF - PHI
Nick Castellanos
Tommy Edman
2B,SS,CF,RF - LAD
Tommy Edman
2024 Stats 
   
   
At Bats55280
   
Runs6912
   
Hits13524
   
Singles8517
   
Doubles272
   
Triples31
   
Home Runs204
   
RBI8013
   
Stolen Bases55
   
Caught Stealing20
   
Walks383
   
Strikeouts12616
   
Batting Average.245.300
   
On Base Pct.304.321
   
Slugging Pct.413.500
   
On-base Plus Slugging.717.821
   
Who Should I Trade? Player Projections
  Nick Castellanos
DH,RF - PHI
Nick Castellanos
Tommy Edman
2B,SS,CF,RF - LAD
Tommy Edman
2024 Projections 
   
   
At Bats6652
   
Runs98
   
Hits1713
   
Singles109
   
Doubles43
   
Triples00
   
Home Runs31
   
RBI106
   
Stolen Bases13
   
Caught Stealing01
   
Walks54
   
Strikeouts1710
   
Batting Average.256.259
   
On Base Pct.311.314
   
Slugging Pct.440.398
   
On-base Plus Slugging.751.712
   
Who Should I Trade? Player Notes
  Nick Castellanos
DH,RF - PHI
Nick Castellanos
Tommy Edman
2B,SS,CF,RF - LAD
Tommy Edman
News 
 Nick Castellanos went 1-for-5 in the Phillies' dominant 16-2 victory over the Marlins.
Chris Schommer
Sat, Sep 7th
Tommy Edman went 2-for-4 with two home runs and two RBI in the Dodgers' 6-3 loss to the Cubs.
Jesse Garcia
Wed, Sep 11th
 Nick Castellanos played a pivotal role in the Phillies' narrow 5-4 victory over the Braves, going 2-for-4 with a home run and two RBI.
Chase Davis
Fri, Aug 30th
Tommy Edman went 2-for-4 with a stolen base in the Dodgers' 10-4 loss to the Cubs.
Matthew Adam
Tue, Sep 10th
 Nick Castellanos went 2-for-4 with an RBI as the Phillies fell to the Royals 7-4.
Chris Schommer
Sat, Aug 24th
Tommy Edman went 2-for-4 with a double, two RBI, one run scored, and one stolen base in the Dodgers' win over the Guardians.
Chris Schommer
Sun, Sep 8th
 Nick Castellanos contributed significantly in the Phillies' dominant 13-3 victory over the Nationals, going 2-for-5 with a home run and two RBI.
Chase Davis
Fri, Aug 16th
Tommy Edman went 2-for-4 with two runs scored in the Dodgers' 7-3 victory over the Rays.
Chris Schommer
Sat, Aug 24th
 Nick Castellanos went 2-for-4 with three RBI in the Phillies' narrow 6-5 loss to the Yankees.
Jesse Garcia
Wed, Jul 31st
Tommy Edman went 1-for-3 with a stolen base in the Dodgers' 3-0 victory over the Mariners.
Matthew Adam
Tue, Aug 20th
Notes 
There are no recent notes for these players
Who Should I Trade? Player Schedules
  Nick Castellanos
DH,RF - PHI
Nick Castellanos
Tommy Edman
2B,SS,CF,RF - LAD
Tommy Edman
Date OppOpp PitcherVBROppOpp PitcherVBR
Wed, Mar 20th   @ SDYu Darvish (5-3)#57
Thu, Mar 21st   vs SDJoe Musgrove (5-5)#40
Thu, Mar 28th   vs STLMiles Mikolas (8-11)#95
Fri, Mar 29thvs ATLSpencer Strider (0-0)vs STLZack Thompson (0-2)#222
Sat, Mar 30thvs ATLMax Fried (9-9)#14vs STLLance Lynn (6-4)#88
Sun, Mar 31stvs ATLChris Sale (16-3)#1vs STLSteven Matz (1-2)#135
Mon, Apr 1stvs CINAndrew Abbott (10-10)#242vs SFKeaton Winn (3-8)
Tue, Apr 2ndvs CINGraham Ashcraft (5-5)vs SFLogan Webb (12-9)#5
Wed, Apr 3rdvs CINFrankie Montas (6-10)#98vs SFKyle Harrison (7-7)#211
Fri, Apr 5th@ WSHPatrick Corbin (5-13)#202@ CHCKyle Hendricks (3-11)#213
Sat, Apr 6th@ WSHJake Irvin (10-12)#113@ CHCJordan Wicks (2-3)#114
Sun, Apr 7th@ WSHMacKenzie Gore (8-12)#53@ CHCShota Imanaga (13-3)#24
Mon, Apr 8th@ STLMiles Mikolas (8-11)#95@ MINBailey Ober (12-6)#33
Tue, Apr 9th@ STLSonny Gray (12-9)#21@ MINLouie Varland (0-6)#104
Wed, Apr 10th@ STLLance Lynn (6-4)#88@ MINChris Paddack (5-3)#301
Fri, Apr 12thvs PITBailey Falter (8-7)#134vs SDMichael King (12-9)#27
Sat, Apr 13thvs PITMarco Gonzales (1-1)vs SDMatt Waldron (7-11)#192
Sun, Apr 14thvs PITMitch Keller (11-9)#72vs SDYu Darvish (5-3)#57
Mon, Apr 15thvs COLCal Quantrill (8-9)#368vs WSHMitchell Parker (7-9)#119
Tue, Apr 16thvs COLAustin Gomber (5-10)#367vs WSHPatrick Corbin (5-13)#202
Wed, Apr 17thvs COLRyan Feltner (2-10)#340vs WSHJake Irvin (10-12)#113
Fri, Apr 19thvs CWSGarrett Crochet (6-11)#12vs NYMSean Manaea (11-5)#51
Sat, Apr 20thvs CWSMichael Soroka (0-10)#179vs NYMJose Butto (7-3)#209
Sun, Apr 21stvs CWSNick Nastrini (0-7)#362vs NYMAdrian Houser (1-5)
Tue, Apr 23rd@ CINAndrew Abbott (10-10)#242@ WSHPatrick Corbin (5-13)#202
Wed, Apr 24th@ CINNick Lodolo (9-6)#195@ WSHJake Irvin (10-12)#113
Thu, Apr 25th@ CINNick Martinez (8-6)#101@ WSHMacKenzie Gore (8-12)#53
Fri, Apr 26th@ SDJoe Musgrove (5-5)#40@ TORChris Bassitt (10-13)#49
Sat, Apr 27th@ SDDylan Cease (12-11)#19@ TORYusei Kikuchi (8-9)#25
Sun, Apr 28th@ SDMichael King (12-9)#27@ TORKevin Gausman (12-11)#15
Mon, Apr 29th@ LAAGriffin Canning (5-13)#144@ ARITommy Henry (2-3)#319
Tue, Apr 30th@ LAATyler Anderson (10-12)#143@ ARIBrandon Hughes
Wed, May 1st@ LAAPatrick Sandoval (2-8)@ ARIJordan Montgomery (8-6)#121
Fri, May 3rdvs SFJordan Hicks (4-7)#200vs ATLCharlie Morton (8-8)#91
Sat, May 4thvs SFKeaton Winn (3-8)vs ATLBryce Elder (2-5)#208
Sun, May 5thvs SFLogan Webb (12-9)#5vs ATLMax Fried (9-9)#14
Mon, May 6thvs SFMason Black (0-3)#148vs MIARoddery Munoz (2-7)#357
Tue, May 7thvs TORJose Berrios (15-9)#75vs MIAEdward Cabrera (4-6)#108
Wed, May 8thvs TORChris Bassitt (10-13)#49vs MIARyan Weathers (3-5)#238
Fri, May 10th@ MIATrevor Rogers (2-11)#273@ SDMichael King (12-9)#27
Sat, May 11th@ MIAJesus Luzardo (3-6)@ SDMatt Waldron (7-11)#192
Sun, May 12th@ MIABraxton Garrett (2-2)#100@ SDYu Darvish (5-3)#57
Mon, May 13th@ NYMSean Manaea (11-5)#51@ SFJordan Hicks (4-7)#200
Tue, May 14th@ NYMJose Butto (7-3)#209@ SFKeaton Winn (3-8)
Wed, May 15thvs NYMJoey Lucchesi (0-1)@ SFLogan Webb (12-9)#5
Thu, May 16thvs NYMJose Quintana (8-9)#163vs CINBrent Suter (0-0)#237
Fri, May 17thvs WSHJake Irvin (10-12)#113vs CINFrankie Montas (6-10)#98
Sat, May 18thvs WSHMacKenzie Gore (8-12)#53vs CINGraham Ashcraft (5-5)
Sun, May 19thvs WSHTrevor Williams (5-0)#149vs CINHunter Greene (9-4)#251
Mon, May 20th   vs ARIJoe Mantiply
Tue, May 21stvs TEXJon Gray (5-6)vs ARIBrandon Pfaadt (9-8)#50
Wed, May 22ndvs TEXDane Dunning (4-7)#183vs ARIBrandon Hughes
Fri, May 24th@ COLTy Blach (3-8)#359@ CINGraham Ashcraft (5-5)
Sat, May 25th@ COLDakota Hudson (2-12)@ CINHunter Greene (9-4)#251
Sun, May 26th@ COLCal Quantrill (8-9)#368@ CINBrent Suter (0-0)#237
Tue, May 28th@ SFErik Miller (4-5)#141@ NYMJose Quintana (8-9)#163
Wed, May 29th@ SFKyle Harrison (7-7)#211@ NYMDavid Peterson (9-2)#89
Fri, May 31stvs STLMiles Mikolas (8-11)#95vs COLDakota Hudson (2-12)
Sat, Jun 1stvs STLSonny Gray (12-9)#21vs COLCal Quantrill (8-9)#368
Sun, Jun 2ndvs STLLance Lynn (6-4)#88vs COLAustin Gomber (5-10)#367
Tue, Jun 4thvs MILJared Koenig (8-3)#97@ PITJared Jones (6-7)#68
Wed, Jun 5thvs MILAaron Ashby (1-2)#224@ PITPaul Skenes (10-2)#8
Thu, Jun 6th   @ PITBailey Falter (8-7)#134
Fri, Jun 7th   @ NYYCody Poteet (3-0)#248
Sat, Jun 8th@ NYMSean Manaea (11-5)#51@ NYYNestor Cortes Jr. (9-10)#39
Sun, Jun 9thvs NYMJose Quintana (8-9)#163@ NYYLuis Gil (13-6)#61
Tue, Jun 11th@ BOSKutter Crawford (8-14)#77vs TEXDane Dunning (4-7)#183
Wed, Jun 12th@ BOSNick Pivetta (5-10)#48vs TEXJon Gray (5-6)
Thu, Jun 13th@ BOSTanner Houck (8-10)#69vs TEXMichael Lorenzen (7-6)#353
Fri, Jun 14th@ BALKyle Bradish (2-0)vs KCCole Ragans (11-9)#22
Sat, Jun 15th@ BALGrayson Rodriguez (13-4)#64vs KCSeth Lugo (16-8)#58
Sun, Jun 16th@ BALCorbin Burnes (13-8)#18vs KCBrady Singer (9-10)#78
Mon, Jun 17thvs SDRandy Vasquez (4-7)#304@ COLCal Quantrill (8-9)#368
Tue, Jun 18thvs SDMichael King (12-9)#27@ COLAustin Gomber (5-10)#367
Wed, Jun 19thvs SDMatt Waldron (7-11)#192@ COLRyan Feltner (2-10)#340
Thu, Jun 20th   @ COLTy Blach (3-8)#359
Fri, Jun 21stvs ARIJordan Montgomery (8-6)#121vs LAAPatrick Sandoval (2-8)
Sat, Jun 22ndvs ARITommy Henry (2-3)#319vs LAAZach Plesac (1-1)
Mon, Jun 24th@ DETCasey Mize (2-6)#90@ CWSGarrett Crochet (6-11)#12
Tue, Jun 25th@ DETTarik Skubal (16-4)#2@ CWSChris Flexen (2-14)#306
Wed, Jun 26th@ DETTyler Holton (6-1)#124@ CWSErick Fedde (8-9)#92
Fri, Jun 28thvs MIAKyle Tyler (0-2)#246@ SFLogan Webb (12-9)#5
Sat, Jun 29thvs MIARoddery Munoz (2-7)#357@ SFErik Miller (4-5)#141
Sun, Jun 30thvs MIAYonny Chirinos (0-2)@ SFSpencer Bivens
Tue, Jul 2nd@ CHCHayden Wesneski (3-6)#180vs ARIJoe Mantiply
Wed, Jul 3rd@ CHCShota Imanaga (13-3)#24vs ARICristian Mena (0-0)
Thu, Jul 4th@ CHCJameson Taillon (10-8)#86vs ARIZac Gallen (12-6)#20
Fri, Jul 5th@ ATLMax Fried (9-9)#14vs MILAaron Civale (6-8)#71
Sat, Jul 6th@ ATLSpencer Schwellenbach (5-7)#55vs MILFreddy Peralta (10-8)#23
Sun, Jul 7th@ ATLReynaldo Lopez (8-5)#42vs MILDallas Keuchel (0-0)
Tue, Jul 9thvs LADBobby Miller (2-4)#84@ PHIZack Wheeler (15-6)#4
Wed, Jul 10thvs LADGavin Stone (11-5)#216@ PHICristopher Sanchez (10-9)#35
Thu, Jul 11thvs LADAnthony Banda@ PHIAaron Nola (12-7)#17
Fri, Jul 12thvs OAKHogan Harris (4-3)#320@ DETTarik Skubal (16-4)#2
Sat, Jul 13thvs OAKMitch Spence (7-9)#127@ DETKeider Montero (5-6)#196
Sun, Jul 14thvs OAKJoey Estes (7-7)#140@ DETBeau Brieske (2-4)#175
Fri, Jul 19th@ PITMartin Perez (4-5)#125vs BOSNick Pivetta (5-10)#48
Sat, Jul 20th@ PITLuis L. Ortiz (6-5)#186vs BOSBrayan Bello (13-7)#105
Sun, Jul 21st@ PITMarco Gonzales (1-1)vs BOSKutter Crawford (8-14)#77
Mon, Jul 22nd@ MINBailey Ober (12-6)#33vs SFBlake Snell (3-3)#13
Tue, Jul 23rd@ MINSimeon Woods Richardson (5-4)#137vs SFJordan Hicks (4-7)#200
Wed, Jul 24th@ MINSteven Okertvs SFRobbie Ray (3-2)#62
Thu, Jul 25th   vs SFLogan Webb (12-9)#5
Fri, Jul 26thvs CLEBen Lively (11-9)#162@ HOUFramber Valdez (14-6)#3
Sat, Jul 27thvs CLECarlos Carrasco (3-10)#343@ HOURonel Blanco (10-6)#87
Sun, Jul 28thvs CLEJoey Cantillo (1-3)#190@ HOUSpencer Arrighetti (7-12)#116
Tue, Jul 30thvs NYYWill Warren (0-3)#199@ SDMatt Waldron (7-11)#192
Wed, Jul 31stvs NYYNestor Cortes Jr. (9-10)#39@ SDDylan Cease (12-11)#19
Fri, Aug 2nd@ SEABryan Woo (8-2)#44@ OAKJoey Estes (7-7)#140
Sat, Aug 3rd@ SEABryce Miller (11-8)#30@ OAKMitch Spence (7-9)#127
Sun, Aug 4th@ SEALogan Gilbert (7-11)#6@ OAKOsvaldo Bido (5-3)#136
Mon, Aug 5th@ LADTyler Glasnow (9-6)#37vs PHIAaron Nola (12-7)#17
Tue, Aug 6th@ LADClayton Kershaw (2-2)#76vs PHICristopher Sanchez (10-9)#35
Wed, Aug 7th@ LADGavin Stone (11-5)#216vs PHITyler Phillips (4-1)#350
Fri, Aug 9th@ ARIRyne Nelson (10-6)#122vs PITMitch Keller (11-9)#72
Sat, Aug 10th@ ARIZac Gallen (12-6)#20vs PITPaul Skenes (10-2)#8
Sun, Aug 11th@ ARIMerrill Kelly (4-0)#73vs PITBailey Falter (8-7)#134
Mon, Aug 12th   @ MILFreddy Peralta (10-8)#23
Tue, Aug 13thvs MIAValente Bellozo (2-3)#369@ MILColin Rea (12-5)#123
Wed, Aug 14thvs MIAEdward Cabrera (4-6)#108@ MILFrankie Montas (6-10)#98
Thu, Aug 15thvs WSHMitchell Parker (7-9)#119@ MILTobias Myers (7-5)#106
Fri, Aug 16thvs WSHPatrick Corbin (5-13)#202@ STLMiles Mikolas (8-11)#95
Sat, Aug 17thvs WSHMacKenzie Gore (8-12)#53@ STLAndre Pallante (6-8)#152
Sun, Aug 18thvs WSHJake Irvin (10-12)#113@ STLSonny Gray (12-9)#21
Mon, Aug 19th   vs SEABryan Woo (8-2)#44
Tue, Aug 20th@ ATLReynaldo Lopez (8-5)#42vs SEABryce Miller (11-8)#30
Wed, Aug 21st@ ATLMax Fried (9-9)#14vs SEALogan Gilbert (7-11)#6
Fri, Aug 23rd@ KCMichael Wacha (12-7)#66vs TBTyler Alexander (6-4)#128
Sat, Aug 24th@ KCBrady Singer (9-10)#78vs TBTaj Bradley (6-10)#43
Sun, Aug 25th@ KCSeth Lugo (16-8)#58vs TBJacob Lopez (0-0)#223
Tue, Aug 27thvs HOUJustin Verlander (3-6)#56vs BALCole Irvin (6-5)#205
Wed, Aug 28thvs HOUSpencer Arrighetti (7-12)#116vs BALCorbin Burnes (13-8)#18
Thu, Aug 29thvs ATLCharlie Morton (8-8)#91vs BALCade Povich (2-8)#131
Fri, Aug 30thvs ATLReynaldo Lopez (8-5)#42@ ARIZac Gallen (12-6)#20
Sat, Aug 31stvs ATLMax Fried (9-9)#14@ ARIMerrill Kelly (4-0)#73
Sun, Sep 1stvs ATLSpencer Schwellenbach (5-7)#55@ ARIBrandon Pfaadt (9-8)#50
Mon, Sep 2nd   @ ARIEduardo Rodriguez (2-2)#74
Tue, Sep 3rd@ TORChris Bassitt (10-13)#49@ LAAReid Detmers (4-6)#79
Wed, Sep 4th@ TORBowden Francis (8-4)#82@ LAAGriffin Canning (5-13)#144
Fri, Sep 6th@ MIAAustin Kitchenvs CLEMatthew Boyd (2-1)#60
Sat, Sep 7th@ MIADarren McCaughan (0-0)#315vs CLEGavin Williams (3-8)#54
Sun, Sep 8th@ MIAEdward Cabrera (4-6)#108vs CLETanner Bibee (11-7)#32
Mon, Sep 9thvs TBCole Sulservs CHCKyle Hendricks (3-11)#213
Tue, Sep 10thvs TBTaj Bradley (6-10)#43vs CHCShota Imanaga (13-3)#24
Wed, Sep 11thvs TBShane Baz (2-3)#93vs CHCJordan Wicks (2-3)#114
Fri, Sep 13thvs NYMJose Quintana (8-9)#163@ ATLSpencer Schwellenbach (5-7)#55
Sat, Sep 14thvs NYMLuis Severino (10-6)#94@ ATLChris Sale (16-3)#1
Sun, Sep 15thvs NYMPaul Blackburn (5-4)#130@ ATLCharlie Morton (8-8)#91
Mon, Sep 16th@ MILColin Rea (12-5)#123@ ATLMax Fried (9-9)#14
Tue, Sep 17th@ MILFrankie Montas (6-10)#98@ MIADarren McCaughan (0-0)#315
Wed, Sep 18th@ MILTobias Myers (7-5)#106@ MIADarren McCaughan (0-0)#315
Thu, Sep 19th@ NYMLuis Severino (10-6)#94@ MIAValente Bellozo (2-3)#369
Fri, Sep 20th@ NYMTylor Megill (3-5)#112vs COLKyle Freeland (5-7)#366
Sat, Sep 21st@ NYMDavid Peterson (9-2)#89vs COLAntonio Senzatela#360
Sun, Sep 22nd@ NYMSean Manaea (11-5)#51vs COLBradley Blalock (1-3)#370
Tue, Sep 24thvs CHCvs SD
Wed, Sep 25thvs CHCvs SD
Thu, Sep 26th   vs SD
Fri, Sep 27th@ WSH@ COL
Sat, Sep 28th@ WSH@ COL
Sun, Sep 29th@ WSH@ COL
Thu, Apr 11thvs PITJared Jones (6-7)#68   
Mon, Apr 22nd@ CINHunter Greene (9-4)#251   
Thu, May 23rdvs TEXAndrew Heaney (5-13)#83   
Mon, May 27th@ SFBlake Snell (3-3)#13   
Mon, Jun 3rdvs MILJared Koenig (8-3)#97   
Sun, Jun 23rdvs ARISlade Cecconi (2-7)#156   
Thu, Jun 27thvs MIATrevor Rogers (2-11)#273   
Mon, Jul 29thvs NYYLuis Gil (13-6)#61   
Thu, Aug 8th@ ARIJordan Montgomery (8-6)#121   
Thu, Aug 22nd@ ATLSpencer Schwellenbach (5-7)#55   
Mon, Aug 26thvs HOURonel Blanco (10-6)#87   
Thu, Sep 5th@ MIAAdam Oller (1-3)#365   
Mon, Sep 23rdvs CHC