Dalton Kincaid

If Dalton Kincaid could get a near full-time route share, he would be a league winner and season-defining player at the tight end position, with consideration to where he's being drafted. Last year, Kincaid was a monster on a per-route basis, leading to a TE13 finish in fantasy points per game. Last year, among 54 qualifying tight ends, Kincaid ranked FIRST in target per route run rate, yards per route run, separation score, route win rate, first downs per route run, and fantasy points per route run (per Fantasy Points Data). The problem is that, among the same sample of 54 tight ends, he was 39th in route share (44.2%) behind Michael Mayer. If Kincaid could see his route share climb near 70% (or above), he could be the TE1 overall in 2026, but the problem is that it is a BIG if. The good thing is that risk is priced into his ADP, but his soul-crushing upside isn't. Kincaid is a perfect tight end to pair with Dallas Goedert, Travis Kelce, or Jake Ferguson. It's a perfect two-tight-end build with floor and potential ceiling.

The Buffalo Bills have exercised the fifth-year option on TE Dalton Kincaid.

Fantasy Impact

Kincaid, a former first-round pick, is coming off his most efficient NFL season. The 26-year-old tight end hauled in 39 receptions for 571 receiving yards and 5 touchdowns. His contract is now guaranteed through 2027 as he continues to operate as one of Josh Allen’s top pass-catching options.