Every dynasty offseason has a handful of players who feel impossible to value. These are the guys who can swing leagues depending on how you handle them in trades. Based on current consensus rankings, usage trends, and long-term outlook, here are 10 of the most polarizing dynasty fantasy football assets right now, along with clear buy, sell, or hold advice for each.
- 2026 NFL Draft Guide
- 2026 NFL Draft Scouting Reports
- Best Fantasy Football Tools
- Dynasty Rookie Mock Drafts
Dynasty Fantasy Football Trade Advice: Buy, Sell, Hold
- Verdict: Sell
Benson still has believers, but the range of outcomes is massive. New coaching staff, James Conner‘s lingering presence, and real risk Arizona adds another back all muddy the picture. Benson hasn’t shown enough to justify waiting through more uncertainty at a fragile position.
- Verdict: Hold (Buy for contenders)
Etienne’s bounceback re-established him as a solid RB2, but his value likely peaks here. If you’re contending, paying a late first makes sense. Rebuilders should consider cashing out before age and mileage erode flexibility.
- Verdict: Sell
Marks produced when called upon, but Houston never treated him like a long-term lead back. His profile screams “replaceable,” and dynasty managers are pricing him closer to a future starter than a complementary piece.
- Verdict: Sell
Elite after the catch, but his value assumes long-term stability that may not exist. Off-field concerns, scheme dependency, and potential changes in Kansas City’s receiving room make this a clean sell at WR1 prices.
- Verdict: Sell
Dual-position intrigue doesn’t help dynasty lineups. Unless Hunter becomes a full-time offensive player, he’s unstartable in fantasy. His market value will likely keep falling as defensive snaps dominate.
- Verdict: Hold
Thomas is the definition of a frustrating talent. The efficiency crash in Year 2 is alarming, but the physical tools remain elite. A trade or offensive shift could quickly revive his ceiling, making now the wrong time to sell low.
- Verdict: Buy
Johnston quietly improved, especially with his hands, and the Chargers’ offense is trending up. He’s still young, athletic, and tethered to Justin Herbert. At WR4 prices, the risk is finally baked in.
- Verdict: Hold
Addison keeps scoring touchdowns, but usage volatility and off-field distractions cap enthusiasm. Long term, he profiles as a future No. 1 elsewhere. Short term, he’s a volatile WR2 who’s tough to move fairly.
- Verdict: Sell
Injuries, contract drama, and age are converging fast. Aiyuk is still talented, but dynasty managers are clinging to past production. If you can pivot into a younger receiver or future first, do it.
- Verdict: Hold
Kincaid’s efficiency is elite, but his snap share isn’t. Buffalo clearly prefers a rotation, and durability remains a concern. He’s properly valued as a mid-range TE1, but not the breakout some hoped for.
Dynasty Fantasy Football Takeaways
- Sell uncertainty at peak value: Rashee Rice, Travis Hunter, and Woody Marks all carry more risk than their prices suggest.
- Contenders can buy stability: Travis Etienne and Dalton Kincaid make sense if you’re chasing a title.
- Talent still matters: Brian Thomas Jr., Jordan Addison, and Quentin Johnston remain worth patience despite volatility.
- Avoid position ambiguity: Players without defined offensive roles rarely gain dynasty value.
- Dynasty trades are about timing: Most of these players will look very different a year from now. Act before the market does.
Subscribe: Apple Podcasts | Google Play | Spotify | Stitcher | TuneIn | RSS | YouTube
