In dynasty fantasy football startups, everyone wants young and elite talent, but the extreme scarcity of reliable quarterbacks changes the math. To maximize draft equity, managers must exploit short-sighted league mates.
This article highlights four fantasy football quarterback values — two proven young stars dismissed after down years, one forgotten former top pick and a rookie selected in the third round of the 2026 NFL draft who possesses a direct path to starting in Week 1.
- Dynasty Fantasy Football Rankings
- Best Fantasy Football Tools
- Dynasty Rookie Mock Drafts
- Fantasy Football Mock Draft Simulator
Dynasty Fantasy Football Draft Values: Quarterbacks
Caleb Williams (QB – CHI)
Caleb Williams is coming off a sophomore leap, finishing as the QB6 with 323.3 fantasy points. Despite that elite production, the fantasy community is treating his breakout like a fluke. The main driver behind the panic is the Bears trading DJ Moore to the Buffalo Bills, leaving Chicago without a high-profile veteran addition to replace him.
This overreaction drops Williams straight into the middle rounds of dynasty startups, giving sharp managers an easy bargain. The community is so busy mourning Moore’s departure that they completely ignore the elite talent left behind in Rome Odunze, Luther Burden III and Colston Loveland. To cap it off, Williams gets a five-star schedule to exploit this season.
Williams’ value remains secure because he provides a safe floor and a high ceiling with his rushing ability and off-script playmaking.
Targeting Williams in the middle rounds gives you an untouchable quarterback room if you already drafted a quarterback early; however, he has the raw talent to serve as your standalone QB1. Taking him at this discount allows you to load up on elite running backs and wide receivers early.
Trevor Lawrence (QB – JAX)
Trevor Lawrence had a rough 2024, finishing as the QB27 with 152.2 fantasy points. He broke out in 2025, exploding for 350.1 points to finish as the overall QB4. Despite proving he can play at an elite level, Lawrence is falling deep into the middle rounds of dynasty drafts due to short-sighted market adjustments.
Jacksonville is starting to put its offense together. Even though Travis Hunter is slated to play primarily at cornerback, he will likely get a solid share of playing time on offense come September.
Brian Thomas is primed for a major bounce-back season, and Jakobi Meyers is a proven, highly reliable veteran target. Additionally, they have Parker Washington, a heavy contributor late last season, whose usage will carry over into 2026 and beyond.
The upside here is huge, especially if you already drafted a quarterback in the early rounds. If you choose to take Lawrence in the middle rounds, you can secure a long-term starter as your backup without wasting draft capital. Furthermore, in Superflex leagues, he provides a high-end starting QB2 who should not be overlooked.
Bryce Young (QB – CAR)
Bryce Young is undervalued to the point where most fantasy managers are not even considering him as an option. His fall in drafts is due to his being unfairly blamed for the Panthers’ lack of success, but he is a smart player who flashed serious potential last season.
If the Panthers were not invested in Young, they would not have restructured the offensive line and acquired high-end, big-bodied weapons like 2025 Offensive Player of the Year Tetairoa McMillan and rookie Chris Brazzell II.
The rest of the receiver room leaves plenty of opportunity for growth. Xavier Legette is still looking to prove himself as a first-round talent, and Jalen Coker emerged last season as a highly reliable target. This passing game is going to be heavily utilized, elevating Young into a fantasy-friendly signal-caller.
Young finished as the QB19 with 229 fantasy points in 2025. With this overhauled setup, expect his production to jump to a floor of QB12 with a ceiling around QB11. You lose nothing by drafting him late in dynasty startups, making the former top pick an ideal target in a vastly improved offense.
Carson Beck (QB – ARI)
Carson Beck was one of the few quarterbacks worth watching from the incoming draft class. He dominated last season, showing maturity and resilience as he bounced back from a UCL tear in college.
Beck completed 72.4% of his passes for 3,813 yards, 30 touchdowns and 12 interceptions while leading the Miami Hurricanes all the way to a close NCAA College Football Playoff (CFP) National Championship matchup.
Despite that production, Beck is dismissed in dynasty startup drafts because of his landing spot. Most fantasy managers assume Arizona’s history of poor quarterback play will continue. However, he possesses the exact traits needed to resurrect this offense. Beck picks up playbooks fast, commands an offense efficiently and handles immense pressure.
The weapons in Arizona are completely flying under the radar. He gets Marvin Harrison Jr., looking to bounce back after an injury-plagued season, alongside Trey McBride, the clear dynasty TE1. The Cardinals drafted Jeremiyah Love third overall, the highest a back has gone since Saquon Barkley in 2018. Love is an elite PPR target who will get easy completions.
The immediate opportunity for a rookie to seize a starting role is right there in front of him. Veteran Jacoby Brissett is currently holding out for starting money, and with the front office holding firm, the depth chart is completely wide open.
The longer this contract stalemate drags into summer, the more first-team reps Beck gets to command. Do not let Beck slide completely past you in the double-digit rounds of dynasty startups. Take full advantage of the market’s hesitation and lock down Arizona’s future point man at a major discount.
Subscribe: Apple Podcasts | Google Play | Spotify | Stitcher | TuneIn | RSS | YouTube