Skip to main content

Who Should I Trade?

Dustin May for Jordan Montgomery (2023)

See if your team wins or loses with this trade View Trade Analyzer

Who Should I Trade? Player Summaries
Experts' Pick
  Jordan Montgomery
Jordan Montgomery
Dustin May
Dustin May
Recommended by
8 of 15 experts
Recommended by
7 of 15 experts
Rest of Season# 57# 66
VBR# 191# 184
Injury Alert-IL60
Expert Ranks 
Dalton Del Don
Yahoo! Sports
# 50# 61
Christopher Welsh
# 59# 60
Keith Lott
Fantasy Six Pack
# 63# 73
Mick Ciallela
# 44# 114
Joe Pisapia
# 63# 91
Scott Youngson
Pitcher List
# 35# 111
Kelly Kirby
# 69
Tristan Davis
SEMO Fantasy Sports Podcast
# 93# 95
Mike Maher
# 51# 44
Brandon 'B_Don' Myers
# 66# 49
Lucas Spence
Pitcher List
# 81# 50
Nate Miller
# 71# 52
Blake Meyer
Sports Gambling Podcast Network
# 66# 54
Aaron Schill
FF Faceoff
# 63# 58
Ethan Biddle
# 64# 63
Who Should I Trade? Player Statistics
  Jordan Montgomery
Jordan Montgomery
Dustin May
Dustin May
2023 Stats 
Games Played119
Games Started119
Innings Pitched60.148.0
Blown Saves00
Hits Allowed7029
Earned Runs3014
Home Runs Allowed71
Who Should I Trade? Player Projections
  Jordan Montgomery
Jordan Montgomery
Dustin May
Dustin May
2023 Projections 
Games Played2019
Games Started2317
Innings Pitched111.484.3
Blown Saves00
Hits Allowed11470
Earned Runs5033
Home Runs Allowed137
Who Should I Trade? Player Notes
  Jordan Montgomery
Jordan Montgomery
Dustin May
Dustin May
 Jordan Montgomery had a decent outing on Sunday against the Guardians, allowing two earned runs on seven hits and one walk while striking out three across five innings.
Chris Schommer
Mon, May 29th
Dustin May forearm) has been transferred to the 60-day IL.
Vince DiSilvio
Tue, May 23rd
 Montgomery had a decent outing, striking out seven batters over 5.1 innings pitched, but ultimately took the loss as the Cardinals fell to the Brewers 3-2.
Matthew Terelle
Wed, May 17th
Dustin May has been placed on the 15-day IL due to a right forearm strain.
Vince DiSilvio
Thu, May 18th
 Jordan Montgomery struggled in his eighth start of the season, allowing six earned runs on seven hits and three walks over five innings pitched in a losing effort against the Cubs.
Nate Miller - FantasyPros
Thu, May 11th
Dustin May was diagnosed with a flexor pronator strain and is expected to miss about six weeks.
Jesse Garcia
Thu, May 18th
 Jordan Montgomery was solid on the mound for the Cardinals Friday night, allowing two runs on six hits while also walking one and striking out six in six innings of a 5-4 loss to the Tigers.
Chris Schommer
Sat, May 6th
Dustin May was removed from his Wednesday start after just one inning. His fastball velocity was down from his season averages.
Jesse Garcia
Wed, May 17th
 Jordan Montgomery was steady on the mound for the Cardinals Saturday night, allowing one run on five hits while also walking two and striking out seven over 6 2/3 innings in a 1-0 loss to the Dodgers.
Chris Schommer
Sun, Apr 30th
Dustin May gave up 5 hits and 1 walk while striking out 3 batters in his outing against the Padres.
Jesse Garcia
Sat, May 13th
There are no recent notes for these players
Who Should I Trade? Player Schedules
  Jordan Montgomery
Jordan Montgomery
Dustin May
Dustin May
Date OppOpp PitcherVBROppOpp PitcherVBR
Thu, Mar 30thvs TORAlek Manoah (1-5)#76vs ARIZac Gallen (7-2)#5
Fri, Mar 31st   vs ARIMerrill Kelly (6-3)#47
Sat, Apr 1stvs TORKevin Gausman (3-3)#9vs ARIMadison Bumgarner (0-3)
Sun, Apr 2ndvs TORChris Bassitt (5-4)#33vs ARIZach Davies (0-1)#268
Mon, Apr 3rdvs ATLCharlie Morton (5-5)#51vs COLRyan Feltner (2-3)#364
Tue, Apr 4thvs ATLDylan Dodd (2-1)#270vs COLGerman Marquez (2-2)
Thu, Apr 6th   @ ARIMerrill Kelly (6-3)#47
Fri, Apr 7th@ MILBrandon Woodruff (1-0)#28@ ARIMadison Bumgarner (0-3)
Sat, Apr 8th@ MILEric Lauer (4-5)#79@ ARIZach Davies (0-1)#268
Sun, Apr 9th@ MILFreddy Peralta (5-4)#48@ ARIRyne Nelson (2-2)#156
Mon, Apr 10th@ COLGerman Marquez (2-2)@ SFLogan Webb (4-5)#19
Tue, Apr 11th@ COLKyle Freeland (4-6)#170@ SFAlex Wood (1-0)#96
Wed, Apr 12th@ COLJose Urena (0-4)#368@ SFAlex Cobb (4-2)#46
Fri, Apr 14thvs PITJohan Oviedo (3-4)#129vs CHCJustin Steele (6-2)#59
Sat, Apr 15thvs PITRoansy Contreras (3-4)#87vs CHCJameson Taillon (0-3)#137
Sun, Apr 16thvs PITMitch Keller (6-1)#71vs CHCDrew Smyly (5-2)#72
Mon, Apr 17thvs ARIMerrill Kelly (6-3)#47vs NYMDavid Peterson (1-6)#114
Tue, Apr 18thvs ARIDrey Jameson (2-1)#166vs NYMTylor Megill (5-3)#66
Wed, Apr 19thvs ARIMadison Bumgarner (0-3)vs NYMMax Scherzer (4-2)#18
Thu, Apr 20th   @ CHCJavier Assad (0-2)#208
Fri, Apr 21st@ SEAGeorge Kirby (5-4)#25@ CHCDrew Smyly (5-2)#72
Sat, Apr 22nd@ SEALuis Castillo (4-2)#3@ CHCHayden Wesneski (2-2)#113
Sun, Apr 23rd@ SEAChris Flexen (0-4)#159@ CHCMarcus Stroman (5-4)#31
Tue, Apr 25th@ SFJohn Brebbia (2-0)#177@ PITJohan Oviedo (3-4)#129
Wed, Apr 26th@ SFAnthony DeSclafani (4-4)#83@ PITRoansy Contreras (3-4)#87
Thu, Apr 27th@ SFLogan Webb (4-5)#19@ PITMitch Keller (6-1)#71
Fri, Apr 28th@ LADDustin May (4-1)#52vs STLJack Flaherty (3-4)#88
Sat, Apr 29th@ LADClayton Kershaw (6-4)#23vs STLJordan Montgomery (2-6)#55
Sun, Apr 30th@ LADNoah Syndergaard (1-4)#122vs STLJake Woodford (1-2)#243
Mon, May 1st   vs PHITaijuan Walker (4-2)#92
Tue, May 2ndvs LAAPatrick Sandoval (3-4)#56vs PHIMatt Strahm (4-3)#103
Wed, May 3rdvs LAAShohei Ohtani (5-1)#6vs PHIAaron Nola (4-3)#7
Fri, May 5thvs DETMatthew Boyd (3-4)#105@ SDYu Darvish (3-4)#35
Sat, May 6thvs DETSpencer Turnbull (1-4)#179@ SDBlake Snell (1-6)#53
Sun, May 7thvs DETAlex Faedo (1-3)#185@ SDJoe Musgrove (2-2)#50
Mon, May 8th@ CHCMarcus Stroman (5-4)#31@ MILFreddy Peralta (5-4)#48
Tue, May 9th@ CHCJameson Taillon (0-3)#137@ MILEric Lauer (4-5)#79
Wed, May 10th@ CHCJustin Steele (6-2)#59@ MILWade Miley (3-2)#168
Fri, May 12th@ BOSJames Paxton (1-1)#124vs SDBlake Snell (1-6)#53
Sat, May 13th@ BOSChris Sale (5-2)#45vs SDJoe Musgrove (2-2)#50
Sun, May 14th@ BOSCorey Kluber (2-6)#188vs SDRyan Weathers (1-3)#213
Mon, May 15thvs MILFreddy Peralta (5-4)#48vs MINPablo Lopez (3-3)#29
Tue, May 16thvs MILWade Miley (3-2)#168vs MINBailey Ober (3-2)#81
Wed, May 17thvs MILCorbin Burnes (4-4)#10vs MINSonny Gray (4-0)#32
Thu, May 18thvs LADJulio Urias (5-4)#27@ STLAdam Wainwright (2-1)#127
Fri, May 19thvs LADTony Gonsolin (3-1)#63@ STLSteven Matz (0-6)#120
Sat, May 20thvs LADNoah Syndergaard (1-4)#122@ STLMiles Mikolas (4-1)#49
Sun, May 21stvs LADClayton Kershaw (6-4)#23@ STLJack Flaherty (3-4)#88
Mon, May 22nd@ CINBrandon Williamson (0-0)#290@ ATLCharlie Morton (5-5)#51
Tue, May 23rd@ CINGraham Ashcraft (3-3)#163@ ATLSpencer Strider (5-2)#1
Wed, May 24th@ CINBen Lively (3-2)#257@ ATLBryce Elder (3-0)#21
Fri, May 26th@ CLEShane Bieber (4-3)#11@ TBJalen Beeks (2-2)#134
Sat, May 27th@ CLETanner Bibee (1-1)#138@ TBTyler Glasnow (0-0)#30
Sun, May 28th@ CLEHunter Gaddis (1-1)#171@ TBJosh Fleming (1-0)#143
Mon, May 29thvs KCJosh Staumontvs WSHTrevor Williams (2-3)#121
Tue, May 30thvs KCZack Greinke (1-5)#117vs WSHJake Irvin (1-3)#203
Wed, May 31st   vs WSHPatrick Corbin (4-5)#169
Fri, Jun 2nd@ PITRoansy Contreras (3-4)#87vs NYYLuis Severino (0-0)#43
Sat, Jun 3rd@ PITLuis Ortiz (1-2)#253vs NYYGerrit Cole (6-0)#4
Sun, Jun 4th@ PITRich Hill (4-5)#141vs NYYDomingo German (3-3)#60
Tue, Jun 6th@ TEXDane Dunning (4-0)#99@ CINHunter Greene (1-4)#68
Wed, Jun 7th@ TEXJon Gray (5-1)#38@ CINBrandon Williamson (0-0)#290
Thu, Jun 8th   @ CIN
Fri, Jun 9thvs CIN@ PHI
Sat, Jun 10thvs CIN@ PHI
Sun, Jun 11thvs CIN@ PHI
Tue, Jun 13thvs SFvs CWS
Wed, Jun 14thvs SFvs CWS
Thu, Jun 15th   vs CWS
Fri, Jun 16th@ NYMvs SF
Sat, Jun 17th@ NYMvs SF
Sun, Jun 18th@ NYMvs SF
Tue, Jun 20th@ WSH@ LAA
Wed, Jun 21st@ WSH@ LAA
Fri, Jun 23rd   vs HOU
Sat, Jun 24thvs CHCvs HOU
Sun, Jun 25thvs CHCvs HOU
Tue, Jun 27thvs HOU@ COL
Wed, Jun 28thvs HOU@ COL
Thu, Jun 29thvs HOU@ COL
Fri, Jun 30thvs NYY@ KC
Sat, Jul 1stvs NYY@ KC
Sun, Jul 2ndvs NYY@ KC
Mon, Jul 3rd@ MIAvs PIT
Tue, Jul 4th@ MIAvs PIT
Wed, Jul 5th@ MIAvs PIT
Thu, Jul 6th@ MIAvs PIT
Fri, Jul 7th@ CWSvs LAA
Sat, Jul 8th@ CWSvs LAA
Fri, Jul 14thvs WSH@ NYM
Sat, Jul 15thvs WSH@ NYM
Sun, Jul 16thvs WSH@ NYM
Mon, Jul 17thvs MIA@ BAL
Tue, Jul 18thvs MIA@ BAL
Wed, Jul 19thvs MIA@ BAL
Fri, Jul 21st@ CHC@ TEX
Sat, Jul 22nd@ CHC@ TEX
Sun, Jul 23rd@ CHC@ TEX
Mon, Jul 24th@ ARIvs TOR
Tue, Jul 25th@ ARIvs TOR
Wed, Jul 26th@ ARIvs TOR
Fri, Jul 28thvs CHCvs CIN
Sat, Jul 29thvs CHCvs CIN
Sun, Jul 30thvs CHCvs CIN
Tue, Aug 1stvs MINvs OAK
Wed, Aug 2ndvs MINvs OAK
Thu, Aug 3rdvs MINvs OAK
Fri, Aug 4thvs COL@ SD
Sat, Aug 5thvs COL@ SD
Sun, Aug 6thvs COL@ SD
Mon, Aug 7th   @ SD
Tue, Aug 8th@ TB@ ARI
Wed, Aug 9th@ TB@ ARI
Thu, Aug 10th@ TBvs COL
Fri, Aug 11th@ KCvs COL
Sat, Aug 12th@ KCvs COL
Sun, Aug 13th   vs COL
Tue, Aug 15thvs OAKvs MIL
Wed, Aug 16thvs OAKvs MIL
Thu, Aug 17thvs NYMvs MIL
Fri, Aug 18thvs NYMvs MIA
Sat, Aug 19thvs NYMvs MIA
Sun, Aug 20thvs NYMvs MIA
Tue, Aug 22nd@ PIT@ CLE
Wed, Aug 23rd@ PIT@ CLE
Thu, Aug 24th   @ CLE
Fri, Aug 25th@ PHI@ BOS
Sat, Aug 26th@ PHI@ BOS
Sun, Aug 27th@ PHI@ BOS
Mon, Aug 28thvs SDvs ARI
Tue, Aug 29thvs SDvs ARI
Wed, Aug 30thvs SDvs ARI
Thu, Aug 31st   vs ATL
Fri, Sep 1stvs PITvs ATL
Sat, Sep 2ndvs PITvs ATL
Sun, Sep 3rdvs PITvs ATL
Tue, Sep 5th@ ATL@ MIA
Wed, Sep 6th@ ATL@ MIA
Thu, Sep 7th@ ATL@ MIA
Fri, Sep 8th@ CIN@ WSH
Sat, Sep 9th@ CIN@ WSH
Sun, Sep 10th@ CIN@ WSH
Mon, Sep 11th@ BALvs SD
Tue, Sep 12th@ BALvs SD
Wed, Sep 13th@ BALvs SD
Fri, Sep 15thvs PHI@ SEA
Sat, Sep 16thvs PHI@ SEA
Sun, Sep 17thvs PHI@ SEA
Mon, Sep 18thvs MILvs DET
Tue, Sep 19thvs MILvs DET
Wed, Sep 20thvs MILvs DET
Thu, Sep 21stvs MILvs SF
Fri, Sep 22nd@ SDvs SF
Sat, Sep 23rd@ SDvs SF
Sun, Sep 24th@ SDvs SF
Tue, Sep 26th@ MIL@ COL
Wed, Sep 27th@ MIL@ COL
Thu, Sep 28th@ MIL@ COL
Fri, Sep 29thvs CIN@ SF
Sat, Sep 30thvs CIN@ SF
Sun, Oct 1stvs CIN@ SF
Wed, Apr 5thvs ATLBryce Elder (3-0)#21   
Thu, Apr 13thvs PITVince Velasquez (4-4)#152   
Mon, Apr 24th@ SFAlex Cobb (4-2)#46   
Thu, May 4thvs LAAGriffin Canning (4-2)#125   
Thu, May 25th@ CINLuke Weaver (1-2)#210   
Mon, Jun 5th@ TEXMartin Perez (6-1)#69   
Mon, Jun 12thvs SF   
Mon, Jun 19th@ WSH   
Sun, Jul 9th@ CWS   
Thu, Jul 20th@ CHC   
Thu, Jul 27thvs CHC   
Mon, Aug 14thvs OAK   
Mon, Aug 21st@ PIT