Skip to main content

Fantasy Baseball Accuracy

Who Gives the Best Fantasy Baseball Advice?

Top Accuracy Scores for 2015

Read our summary and analysis

Top Accuracy Scores for 2015
Rank Expert Name Hitters Pitchers Overall
1Jake Ciely - The Athletic84.8%71.6%78.2%
2Brandon Funston - The Athletic79.4%74.6%77.0%
3Dalton Del Don - Yahoo84.2%64.8%74.5%
4Dennis Esser - Coach Esser66.3%80.9%73.6%
5Tim McCullough - Baseball Prospectus80.6%63.0%71.8%
6Ryan Noonan - FTN80.3%61.8%71.0%
7Dan Wade - FanGraphs92.8%46.6%69.7%
8Alan Harrison - The Fantasy Fix64.8%70.1%67.5%
9Andrew Gould - FantasyPros60.0%74.6%67.3%
10Justin Klein - The Fake Baseball71.3%61.5%66.4%

All 67 Experts Analyzed in 2015

All 67 Experts Analyzed in 2015
Expert Name Site Twitter
Adam MeyerFantasy Analyst@CharlieSideHstl
Adam PfeiferFTN@APfeifer24
Adam RonisFantasy Alarm@adamronis
Al MelchiorThe Athletic@almelchiorbb
Alan HarrisonTop 10 Overall Expert for Draft Accuracy The Fantasy Fix@thefantasyfix
Andrea LaMontLenny Melnick Fantasy Sports@rotolady
Andrew EggersFantasy Couch@AndrewEggers
Andrew GouldTop 10 Overall Expert for Draft Accuracy FantasyPros@AndrewGould4
Andy BehrensYahoo! Sports@andybehrens
Brandon FunstonTop 10 Overall Expert for Draft Accuracy The Athletic@BrandonFunston
Brent NamejkoFantasy Smack Talk@fantasyadvice
Brett TalleyFantasy Alarm@TheRealTAL
Chris MeaneyFTN@chrismeaney
Dalton Del DonTop 10 Overall Expert for Draft Accuracy Yahoo! Sports@daltondeldon
Dan WadeTop 10 Overall Expert for Draft Accuracy FanGraphs@Dwade
Dave McKayThe Fantasy Sports Brain@TalktotheBrain
David GonosSoCalledFanEx@SoCalledFanEx
David GonosThe Athletic@davidgonos
David KerrFantasy Squads@askROTObaseball
Dennis EsserTop 10 Overall Expert for Draft Accuracy Coach Esser@coachesser
Doug AndersonFantrax@rotodaddy
Expert Consensus RankingsFantasyPros@FantasyPros_NFL
Gerard MartinThe Fantasy Fix@gerardowrites
Greg SmithThe Fake Baseball@gregsauce
Grey AlbrightRazzball@razzball
Heath CappsFake Teams@heathcapps
Jake Ciely#1 Overall Expert for 2012 Draft Accuracy The Athletic@allinkid
Jamie CalandroFantasy Team Advice@jac3600
Jeff BoggisFantasy Football Empire@JeffBoggis
Joe BondFantasy Six Pack@F6P_Joe
John HalpinCarolina Panthers Radio Network@jhalpin37
Jon CollinsFantasy Sports LR@joncollinsFSLR
Jonathan StulbergFFLockerRoom@Rotisguru
Josh ShepardsonFantasyPros@BChad50
Justin ElickDaily Fantasy Circuit@BigItaly42
Justin KleinTop 10 Overall Expert for Draft Accuracy The Fake Baseball@justinrklein
KJFantasy Team Advice@FanTeamAdvice
Kevin HansonEDSBaseball@EDSBaseball
Luke GloecknerMr. Cheatsheet@mrcheatsheet
Marc CavigliaBruno Boys@marccaviglia
Matt LutovskySporting News@MLutovsky
Mike PodhorzerFanGraphs@mikepodhorzer
Muntradamus Beast Dome@Muntradamus
Paul GrecoPaul Greco Sports@PaulGreco
Paul SporerFanGraphs@sporer
R.J. WhiteCBS Sports@rjwhite1
Ray GuilfoyleFake Teams@faketeams
Rudy GambleRazzball@rudygamble
Ryan FowlerFantasy Analyst@FreelanceFowler
Ryan NoonanTop 10 Overall Expert for Draft Accuracy FTN@RyNoonan
Ryan RufeRotoBaller@RyanRufe
Scott EngelRotoBaller 
Scott McCloyFantasy Six Pack@mccloy24
Scott PianowskiYahoo! Sports@scott_pianowski
Scott WhiteCBS Sports@CBSScottWhite
Seth KleinFantrax@SethDaSportsMan
Site ProjectionsRotoChamp@RotoChamp
Staff CompositeESPN@ESPN
Staff CompositeFox Sports@FOXSports
Steve GardnerUSA Today@SteveAGardner
Terrance BridgettFake Pigskin@whudey
Tim McCulloughTop 10 Overall Expert for Draft Accuracy Baseball Prospectus@TimsTenz
Tim YoungBrewer Rat@RealTimcy
Tom SchrinerFFLockerRoom 
Wayne BretskyBretskyBall@bretskyball
Zach JacobsonThe Fake Baseball@zatchj62
Zach SandersFanGraphs@zvsanders

Top Accuracy Scores for 2014

Read our summary and analysis

Top Accuracy Scores for 2014
Rank Expert Name Hitters Pitchers Overall
1Steve Gardner - USA Today93.0%75.5%84.2%
2Tristan Cockcroft - ESPN68.5%77.6%73.0%
3R.J. White - CBS Sports72.4%72.4%72.4%
4Timothy Farmer - Dynasty Sports Empire69.1%75.8%72.4%
5Jesse Sakstrup - Roto Spectrum74.5%64.2%69.4%
6Josh Shepardson - FantasyPros61.5%76.7%69.1%
7Brett Talley - Fantasy Alarm53.0%82.7%67.9%
8Luke Gloeckner - Mr. Cheatsheet71.2%62.7%67.0%
9Kevin Hanson - EDSBaseball65.2%67.3%66.2%
10Zach Jacobson - The Fake Baseball78.2%50.6%64.4%

All 66 Experts Analyzed in 2014

All 66 Experts Analyzed in 2014
Expert Name Site Twitter
Al MelchiorThe Athletic@almelchiorbb
Andrew EggersFantasy Couch@AndrewEggers
Andrew GouldFantasyPros@AndrewGould4
Andy BehrensYahoo! Sports@andybehrens
Ben PritchettFantasy Insiders@naturalslugger
Brad EvansFTN@NoisyHuevos
Brandon FunstonThe Athletic@BrandonFunston
Brett TalleyTop 10 Overall Expert for Draft Accuracy Fantasy Alarm@TheRealTAL
Chris MeaneyFTN@chrismeaney
Dalton Del DonYahoo! Sports@daltondeldon
Dave McKayThe Fantasy Sports Brain@TalktotheBrain
David GonosThe Athletic@davidgonos
David KerrFantasy Squads@askROTObaseball
Dennis EsserCoach Esser@coachesser
Expert Consensus RankingsFantasyPros@FantasyPros_NFL
Eno SarrisThe Athletic@enosarris
Eric MackFantasy Fatcast@EricMackFantasy
Greg SmithThe Fake Baseball@gregsauce
Grey AlbrightRazzball@razzball
Igor DeryshXN Sports@igorderysh
Jake CielyThe Athletic@allinkid
Jeff BoggisFantasy Football Empire@JeffBoggis
Jesse SakstrupTop 10 Overall Expert for Draft Accuracy Roto Spectrum 
Joe BondFantasy Six Pack@F6P_Joe
Jon CollinsFantasy Sports LR@joncollinsFSLR
Josh CollacchiFTN@JoshCollacchi
Josh ShepardsonTop 10 Overall Expert for Draft Accuracy FantasyPros@BChad50
KJFantasy Team Advice@FanTeamAdvice
Kevin HansonTop 10 Overall Expert for Draft Accuracy EDSBaseball@EDSBaseball
Luke GloecknerTop 10 Overall Expert for Draft Accuracy Mr. Cheatsheet@mrcheatsheet
Matt ShetlerFantasy CPR 
Matthew DewoskinPaul Greco Sports 
Michael CliffordDobber Sports@SlimCliffy
Michael HurcombCBS Sports@CBSHurc
Michael PichanFantasy Alarm@FantasyNomad
Mike PodhorzerFanGraphs@mikepodhorzer
Muntradamus Beast Dome@Muntradamus
Nando Di FinoThe Athletic@nandodifino
Nate SpringfieldBaseball Press@NateSpringfield
Neil ParkerThe Fake Baseball@naparker77
Nick RaducanuProjectRoto@ProjectRoto
Nick WilliamsLegion Report@LegionReportMLB
R.J. WhiteTop 10 Overall Expert for Draft Accuracy CBS Sports@rjwhite1
Rudy GambleRazzball@rudygamble
Ryan Hodge FantasyLabs@RyanHodge
Ryan RufeRotoBaller@RyanRufe
Scott PianowskiYahoo! Sports@scott_pianowski
Scott WhiteCBS Sports@CBSScottWhite
Seth KleinFantrax@SethDaSportsMan
Site ProjectionsKFFL 
Site ProjectionsRotoChamp@RotoChamp
Site RankingsSports Illustrated 
Staff CompositeESPN@ESPN
Staff RankingsDavidGonos.com@davidgonos
Steve Gardner#1 Overall Expert for 2012 Draft Accuracy USA Today@SteveAGardner
Terrance BridgettFake Pigskin@whudey
Tim McCulloughBaseball Prospectus@TimsTenz
Timothy FarmerTop 10 Overall Expert for Draft Accuracy Dynasty Sports Empire 
Tom SchrinerFFLockerRoom 
Tony MaurielloProjectRoto@TheTonyM
Travis Riechers eDraft@BravesFanatic
Tristan CockcroftTop 10 Overall Expert for Draft Accuracy ESPN@SultanofStat
Wayne BretskyBretskyBall@bretskyball
Zach JacobsonTop 10 Overall Expert for Draft Accuracy The Fake Baseball@zatchj62

Top Accuracy Scores for 2013

Read our summary and analysis

Top Accuracy Scores for 2013
Rank Expert Name Hitters Pitchers Overall
1Andy Behrens - Yahoo88.5%81.8%85.2%
2Brent Namejko - Fantasy Smack Talk70.6%88.2%79.4%
3Terrance Bridgett - Fake Pigskin70.9%86.4%78.6%
4Michael Clifford - Dobber Sports71.2%84.5%77.9%
5Jesse Sakstrup - Roto Spectrum77.9%77.0%77.4%
6Michael Pichan - Fantasy Alarm57.6%96.1%76.8%
7Brandon Funston - The Athletic70.6%82.4%76.5%
8Josh Shepardson - FantasyPros49.7%91.2%70.5%
9Scott Pianowski - Yahoo71.5%66.7%69.1%
10Mike Podhorzer - FanGraphs73.0%63.3%68.2%

All 66 Experts Analyzed in 2013

All 66 Experts Analyzed in 2013
Expert Name Site Twitter
Adam MeyerFantasy Analyst@CharlieSideHstl
Al MelchiorThe Athletic@almelchiorbb
Alan HarrisonThe Fantasy Fix@thefantasyfix
Andrew EggersFantasy Couch@AndrewEggers
Andrew GouldFantasyPros@AndrewGould4
Andy Behrens#1 Overall Expert for 2012 Draft Accuracy Yahoo! Sports@andybehrens
Ben PritchettFantasy Insiders@naturalslugger
Brad EvansFTN@NoisyHuevos
Brandon FunstonTop 10 Overall Expert for Draft Accuracy The Athletic@BrandonFunston
Brent NamejkoTop 10 Overall Expert for Draft Accuracy Fantasy Smack Talk@fantasyadvice
Brien BonnevilleThe Fake Baseball 
Bryan CurleyBaseball Professor@BaseballProf
Dalton Del DonYahoo! Sports@daltondeldon
Dave McKayThe Fantasy Sports Brain@TalktotheBrain
David GonosThe Athletic@davidgonos
Duncan SanfordEDSBaseball@duncarooo
Expert Consensus RankingsFantasyPros@FantasyPros_NFL
Eno SarrisThe Athletic@enosarris
Eric MackFantasy Fatcast@EricMackFantasy
Greg SmithThe Fake Baseball@gregsauce
Hector RomanHecmanRoto@hecmanbaseball
Igor DeryshXN Sports@igorderysh
Jeff BoggisFantasy Football Empire@JeffBoggis
Jeff ZimmermanFanGraphs@jeffwzimmerman
Jesse SakstrupTop 10 Overall Expert for Draft Accuracy Roto Spectrum 
Joel BeallFox Sports 
John HalpinCarolina Panthers Radio Network@jhalpin37
Josh ShepardsonTop 10 Overall Expert for Draft Accuracy FantasyPros@BChad50
KJFantasy Team Advice@FanTeamAdvice
Kevin HansonEDSBaseball@EDSBaseball
Luke GloecknerMr. Cheatsheet@mrcheatsheet
Matt EastmanFantasy Knuckleheads@Eastman5
Michael CliffordTop 10 Overall Expert for Draft Accuracy Dobber Sports@SlimCliffy
Michael PichanTop 10 Overall Expert for Draft Accuracy Fantasy Alarm@FantasyNomad
Mike HarmonSwollen Dome@swollendome
Mike PodhorzerTop 10 Overall Expert for Draft Accuracy FanGraphs@mikepodhorzer
Muntradamus Beast Dome@Muntradamus
Nando Di FinoThe Athletic@nandodifino
Neil ParkerThe Fake Baseball@naparker77
Nick RaducanuProjectRoto@ProjectRoto
R.J. WhiteCBS Sports@rjwhite1
Reggie YingerBaseball Press@baseballpress
Ryan BoyerRotoworld@RyanPBoyer
Ryan FowlerFantasy Analyst@FreelanceFowler
Ryan Hodge FantasyLabs@RyanHodge
Ryan LesterLesters Legends 
Sablich BrothersThe NY Times@5thDownFantasy
Scott PianowskiTop 10 Overall Expert for Draft Accuracy Yahoo! Sports@scott_pianowski
Scott WhiteCBS Sports@CBSScottWhite
Site ProjectionsKFFL 
Site ProjectionsRotoChamp@RotoChamp
Staff RankingsESPN@espn
Steve GardnerUSA Today@SteveAGardner
Terrance BridgettTop 10 Overall Expert for Draft Accuracy Fake Pigskin@whudey
Tim YoungBrewer Rat@RealTimcy
Tom SchrinerFFLockerRoom 
Tony MaurielloProjectRoto@TheTonyM
Tozzi BrothersLegion Report@TozziBros
Tristan CockcroftESPN@SultanofStat
Wayne BretskyBretskyBall@bretskyball
Zach SandersFanGraphs@zvsanders

Top Accuracy Scores for 2012

Read our summary and analysis

Top Accuracy Scores for 2012
Rank Expert Name Hitters Pitchers Overall
1Josh Shepardson - FantasyPros68.0%87.2%77.6%
2Andy Behrens - Yahoo74.8%78.8%76.8%
3Site Rankings - RotoChamp56.0%82.4%69.2%
4Steve Gardner - USA Today67.6%64.0%65.8%
5Ben Pritchett - Fantasy Insiders53.6%78.0%65.8%
6Scott Pianowski - Yahoo65.2%65.6%65.4%
7Mike Harmon - Swollen Dome63.6%65.2%64.4%
8Brandon Funston - The Athletic86.0%42.4%64.2%
9Alan Harrison - The Fantasy Fix70.4%58.0%64.2%
10Matt Gelfand - The Fantasy Fix78.0%45.6%61.8%

All 50 Experts Analyzed in 2012

All 50 Experts Analyzed in 2012
Expert Name Site Twitter
Alan HarrisonTop 10 Overall Expert for Draft Accuracy The Fantasy Fix@thefantasyfix
Andy BehrensTop 10 Overall Expert for Draft Accuracy Yahoo! Sports@andybehrens
Ben PritchettTop 10 Overall Expert for Draft Accuracy Fantasy Insiders@naturalslugger
Brad EvansFTN@NoisyHuevos
Brad JohnsonFanGraphs@baseballAteam
Brandon FunstonTop 10 Overall Expert for Draft Accuracy The Athletic@BrandonFunston
Brien BonnevilleThe Fake Baseball 
D.J. ShortRotoworld@djshort
Derek GerberichMidwest Sports Fans@FantasyMSF
Eno SarrisThe Athletic@enosarris
Eric MackFantasy Fatcast@EricMackFantasy
Eric RadomFans Fantasy Football 
Gavin TachibanaFantasy Baseball Champ 
Greg SmithThe Fake Baseball@gregsauce
Howard BenderFantasy Alarm@rotobuzzguy
James MeyerriecksFantasy Info Central@ficsports
Jeff BoggisFantasy Football Empire@JeffBoggis
Jeff ZimmermanFanGraphs@jeffwzimmerman
Jesse SakstrupRoto Spectrum 
Joel BeallFox Sports 
John HalpinCarolina Panthers Radio Network@jhalpin37
Jon ConnollyFantasy Baseball Champ@El_Bungalo
Joseph Buccellato Fantasy League GM@JOBOOZOSO
Josh CohenJuan Elway 
Josh Shepardson#1 Overall Expert for 2012 Draft Accuracy FantasyPros@BChad50
Kevin HansonEDSBaseball@EDSBaseball
Matt GelfandTop 10 Overall Expert for Draft Accuracy The Fantasy Fix 
Mike HarmonTop 10 Overall Expert for Draft Accuracy Swollen Dome@swollendome
Mike PodhorzerFanGraphs@mikepodhorzer
Muntradamus Beast Dome@Muntradamus
Nick FlederThe Hardball Times 
R.J. WhiteCBS Sports@rjwhite1
Reggie YingerBaseball Press@baseballpress
Robert BishopFake Teams 
Ryan FowlerFantasy Analyst@FreelanceFowler
Ryan LesterLesters Legends 
Sablich BrothersThe NY Times@5thDownFantasy
Scott PianowskiTop 10 Overall Expert for Draft Accuracy Yahoo! Sports@scott_pianowski
Site ProjectionsKFFL 
Site RankingsCBS Sports 
Site RankingsTop 10 Overall Expert for Draft Accuracy RotoChamp@RotoChamp
Site RankingsSports Illustrated 
Staff CompositeYahoo! Sports@yahoosports
Staff RankingsAthlon Sports@AthlonSports
Staff RankingsESPN@espn
Steve GardnerTop 10 Overall Expert for Draft Accuracy USA Today@SteveAGardner
Tim YoungBrewer Rat@RealTimcy
Tristan CockcroftESPN@SultanofStat
Zach GreubelGridiron Experts@ZachGreubel
Zach SandersFanGraphs@zvsanders

Top Accuracy Scores for 2011

Read our summary and analysis

Top Accuracy Scores for 2011
Rank Expert Name Hitters Pitchers Overall
1R.J. White - CBS Sports76.0%72.0%74.0%
2Andy Behrens - Yahoo80.0%63.2%71.6%
3Reggie Yinger - Baseball Press52.0%88.8%70.4%
4Staff Rankings - KFFL69.6%70.4%70.0%
5Staff Rankings - ESPN72.0%61.6%66.8%
6Brandon Funston - The Athletic57.6%71.2%64.4%
7Brad Evans - FTN44.8%84.0%64.4%
8Staff Rankings - The Scores Report68.8%60.0%64.4%
9Site Rankings - RotoChamp36.0%77.6%56.8%
10Marc Griffis - Baseball Sharks62.4%48.8%55.6%

All 25 Experts Analyzed in 2011

All 25 Experts Analyzed in 2011
Expert Name Site Twitter
Andy BehrensTop 10 Overall Expert for Draft Accuracy Yahoo! Sports@andybehrens
Brad EvansTop 10 Overall Expert for Draft Accuracy FTN@NoisyHuevos
Brandon FunstonTop 10 Overall Expert for Draft Accuracy The Athletic@BrandonFunston
Charlie SaponaraFantasy Baseball 365@CharlieSaponara
Drew MagyarBaseball Sharks@BaseballSharks
Eric MackFantasy Fatcast@EricMackFantasy
John HalpinCarolina Panthers Radio Network@jhalpin37
Marc GriffisTop 10 Overall Expert for Draft Accuracy Baseball Sharks@BaseballSharks
Mark ChamberlinBaseball Sharks@BaseballSharks
R.J. White#1 Overall Expert for 2012 Draft Accuracy CBS Sports@rjwhite1
Reggie YingerTop 10 Overall Expert for Draft Accuracy Baseball Press@baseballpress
Scott PianowskiYahoo! Sports@scott_pianowski
Site RankingsCBS Sports 
Site RankingsTop 10 Overall Expert for Draft Accuracy RotoChamp@RotoChamp
Staff RankingsDraft Buddy@DraftBuddy
Staff RankingsTop 10 Overall Expert for Draft Accuracy ESPN@espn
Staff RankingsFantasy Baseball Champ 
Staff RankingsFantasy Baseball Dugout 
Staff RankingsFantasy Phenoms@fantasyphenoms
Staff RankingsJunkYard Jake@junkyardjake
Staff RankingsTop 10 Overall Expert for Draft Accuracy KFFL 
Staff RankingsPro Fantasy Baseball 
Staff RankingsRoto Rob@rotorob
Staff RankingsTop 10 Overall Expert for Draft Accuracy The Scores Report@TheScoresReport
Tony HolmBaseball Sharks@BaseballSharks

#1 Overall Expert for Draft Accuracy = #1 Overall Expert for Draft Accuracy
Top 10 Overall Expert for Draft Accuracy = Top 10 Expert for Draft Accuracy

* Prediction Accuracy Yield (PAY™) measures the percent of total possible roto points scored, based on each expert's preseason player rankings.