Skip Navigation to Main Content

Perfectly Consistent Fantasy Football Draft: Pick No. 1

Perfectly Consistent Fantasy Football Draft: Pick No. 1

Bob Lung discusses the perfectly consistent fantasy football draft.

This piece is part of our article program that features quality content from experts exclusively at FantasyPros. For more insight from Bob head to Big Guy Fantasy Sports.

Fantasy Draft Day can be one of most exciting or most horrifying days in a fantasy owner’s life each year. It’s exciting for those who prepare. It’s horrifying for those who don’t have time to prep because LIFE gets in the way.

Well, worry no more, my friends! I’m here to help give you a winning draft, REGARDLESS of the position you choose from!

Combine rankings from 100+ experts into one consensus cheat sheet partner-arrow

My friends at FantasyPros have some great tools to help you in your Fantasy Football draft preparation. One of them is the Draft Simulator. I am going to use this tool in conjunction with a tool from the Big Guy Fantasy Sports site called the Tier Draft List. The Tier Draft List is a one page Excel file that groups each position by Tier (RB1, RB2, etc.) and then separates the Tier into Grade A, B, C, and D. Each Tier correlates to an Expected Consistency Rating or how consistent that player should be in 2017. This is explained in the Guide.

By utilizing the Draft Simulator, I will perform a mock draft from each position and present the results as ranked by the FantasyPros expert rankings. Upon presenting that the mock draft results are ranked No. 1 by FantasyPros, I will also show you why it’s a great draft because of the consistency ratings of the players I drafted.

We start with a mock draft from position No. 1.

The Results

Below is the embed code from the FantasyPros site showing the results:

As you can see from the results, the team drafted ranked No. 1 by the FantasyPros expert rankings. And while that’s certainly important that our drafted team scores more points than any other team, it’s also important that the players are consistently scoring those points.

Roster with Consistency Rankings

Pick Player Position Tier Consistency
1.1 David Johnson, ARI RB RB1A 90%
2.12 Lamar Miller, HOU RB RB1B 70%
3.1 Jarvis Landry, MIA WR WR1A 75%
4.12 Drew Brees, NO QB QB1B 70%
5.1 Michael Crabtree, OAK WR WR2A 70%
6.12 Jimmy Graham, SEA TE TE1B 70%
7.1 Pierre Garcon, SF WR WR3B 65% 73% Starters
8.12 Kelvin Benjamin, CAR RB WR3B 65%
9.1 Adrian Peterson, NO RB RB3C 60%
10.12 James White, NE RB RB3C 65%
11.1 Marvin Jones, DET WR WR4C 60%
12.12 Houston Texans, HOU DEF
13.1 Matthew Stafford, DET QB QB2A 55%
14.12 Julius Thomas, MIA TE TE1B 55% 60% Bench
15.1 Stephen Gostkowski, NE K

Overall, the consistency is very good for this team. The Starters overall consistency is over 70%! That’s outstanding! If your starters can average over 65%, that’s a solid team. The Bench scoring a 60% consistency average is also a very good. (Note: There is no consistency ratings for Kickers and Defense).

So, let’s break down the starters.

STARTERS

One thing that I always stress to fantasy owners is to make sure that you draft your CORE starters (1 QB, 2 RB, 3 WR and 1 TE) within the first seven rounds (depending on your league starter lineup). Many will argue and throw out strategies like ZERO-RB or four straight WRs or no QBs until Round 8. Whatever! Don’t be that person!

The starters all have a grade of Tier 1-3 and Grade of A or B.

This is very important to try and get these tiers for your top seven starters.

In summary, this is an excellent draft for starters with a No. 1 ranking by FantasyPros and a consistency rating of 73%.

BENCH

Drafting a solid and consistent bench is just as important as your starters. Yes, there will be underperformers and injuries, but having a consistent bench gives you depth for possible trades to improve your starters, in case one of them get injured.

In this draft, I have covered a backup to all positions. This doesn’t always happen, but Julius Thomas in Round 14 was too good to pass up.

In summary, the FantasyPros ranking was No. 2 overall, but more important is the 60% bench consistency rating. I feel much better about that and it allows me to feel good about the start to the season.

OVERALL

The FantasyPros ranking of 98 out of 100 and an A+ rating says it all! This is an excellent draft, both in total points and consistency.

If you’re interested more in the Tier Draft List and Fantasy Football Consistency, go to www.BigGuyFantasySports.com and we will help you improve your Fantasy teams in 2017!


SubscribeiTunes | Stitcher | SoundCloud | Google Play | TuneIn | RSS

SaveSave

More Articles

8 Fantasy Football Waiver Wire Stashes Ahead of Week 17 (2025)

8 Fantasy Football Waiver Wire Stashes Ahead of Week 17 (2025)

fp-headshot by Tom Strachan | 3 min read
Fantasy Football Christmas Naughty & Nice List (2025)

Fantasy Football Christmas Naughty & Nice List (2025)

fp-headshot by Tom Strachan | 5 min read
8 Fantasy Football Injuries to Know for Week 16 (2025)

8 Fantasy Football Injuries to Know for Week 16 (2025)

fp-headshot by Frank Ammirante | 2 min read
3 Fantasy Football Burning Questions: Week 16 Discord AMA

3 Fantasy Football Burning Questions: Week 16 Discord AMA

fp-headshot by Josh Shepardson | 2 min read

About Author