Skip to main content

First-Year Player Draft Rankings (2023 Fantasy Baseball)

First-Year Player Draft Rankings (2023 Fantasy Baseball)

This list comprises players who have yet to reach the Big Leagues or guys who still qualify as rookies by MLB standards. Keep in mind this order is for redraft leagues only and for drafts that are happening fairly soon. Spring Training will bring about many changes, so think of this as a useful guide for now.

Only a handful of these guys will be drafted in standard leagues. But with so many fantasy managers branching out into much larger or restricted formats, many of these youngsters could hold value.

I moved some players around based on my projections and draft values, but I still included their ADP. Many of the evaluations are similar, but there are definitely a few discrepancies.

Also, keep in mind experts tend to draft relatively unknown sleepers a little earlier than the average fantasy player. If you’re not playing in a high-stakes league, you may be able to wait a bit longer to obtain their services.

My goal was to list 50 players for you guys, but five more made the list that I just couldn’t leave off.

There are some player notes to follow.

Fantasy Baseball Draft Kit

Top 55 First-Year Players/Rookies 2023 Redraft Leagues

ADP listed is from NFC drafts from 12-1-23 to 1-23-23

  1. Gunnar Henderson (SS/3B – BAL): ADP 89
  2. Corbin Carroll (OF – ARI): 73
  3. Grayson Rodriguez (SP – BAL): 194
  4. Kodai Senga (SP – NYM): 185
  5. Josh Jung (3B – TEX): 213
  6. Triston Casas (1B – BOS): 232
  7. Masataka Yoshida (OF – BOS): 229
  8. Logan O’Hoppe (C – LAA): 236
  9. Ezequiel Tovar (SS – COL): 252
  10. Hunter Brown (SP/RP – HOU): 254
  11. Kerry Carpenter (OF – DET): 373
  12. Gabriel Moreno (C – ARI): 243
  13. Jordan Walker (3B – STL): 264
  14. Matt Mervis (1B – CHC): 279
  15. Miguel Vargas (1B/3B – LAD): 278
  16. Esteury Ruiz (2B/OF – OAK): 286
  17. Oswald Peraza (2B/SS – NYY): 351
  18. Garrett Mitchell (OF – MIL): 291
  19. Bo Naylor (C – CLE): 297
  20. Oscar Colas (OF – CHW): 349
  21. Endy Rodriguez (C – PIT): 368
  22. Hayden Wesneski (SP – CHC): 332
  23. Drey Jameson (SP – ARZ): 340
  24. Brice Turang (SS/2B – MIL): 415
  25. Francisco Alvarez (C – NYM): 359
  26. Andrew Painter (SP – PHI): 377
  27. Brandon Pfaadt (SP – ARI): 372
  28. Anthony Volpe (SS – NYY): 391
  29. Ken Waldichuk (SP – OAK): 392
  30. Elly De La Cruz (SS – CIN): 430
  31. Luis Ortiz (SP – PIT): 412
  32. Cody Morris (SP/RP – CLE): 413
  33. Luis Campusano (C – SD): 400
  34. Cade Cavalli (SP – WAS): 457
  35. Spencer Steer (1B/3B/SS – CIN): 419
  36. Drew Waters (OF – KC): 459
  37. Brett Baty (3B – NYM): 447
  38. Royce Lewis (SS – MIN): 451
  39. Kyle Muller (SP – OAK): 461
  40. James Outman (OF – LAD): 455
  41. Jonathan Aranda (1B/2B/3B – TB): 481
  42. Gavin Stone (SP – LAD): 502
  43. Bobby Miller (SP – LAD): 486
  44. Taj Bradley (SP – TB): 542
  45. Kyle Stowers (OF – BAL): 487
  46. Kyle Harrison (SP – SF): 480
  47. Ryan Pepiot (SP – LA): 512
  48. Shintaro Fujinami (SP – OAK): 581
  49. Michael Busch (2B – LAD): 556
  50. Eury Perez (SP – MIA): 541
  51. Daniel Espino (SP – CLE): 598
  52. Conner Capel (OF – OAK): 635
  53. Stone Garrett (OF – WAS): 543
  54. Curtis Mead (2B/3B – TB): 563
  55. Gavin Williams (SP – CLE): 650

Player Notes:

1. Gunnar Henderson

I like Henderson over Carroll because he’ll likely bat in the middle of the order, whereas Corbin will probably lead off. Both may struggle against lefties a bit, but I have them 1A. and 1B. I also like Henderson’s eligibility at 3B and SS, making him a great fit at MI or CI.

2. Corbin Carroll

If Carroll can make good on his projected 60-hit tool, then he should be a valuable asset hitting atop the underrated D’backs lineup. Also, if he can take full advantage of the new rules that benefit base-stealers, then his value should increase further. Steals likely won’t have the weight they’ve had in the past, but if he wants to be worthy of a top-100 pick, he will have to do better than the two steals he collected over his first 32 games. Obviously, it was a small sample size, and he was only 21 at the time, but managers that are investing early are going to be hoping for a 20/20, .300 season.

3. Grayson Rodriguez

If it weren’t for an innings limit, GRod could be first on this list. Rodriguez is your prototypical starter with multiple plus weapons with high velo at his disposal. He’s dominated at every level and would have arrived last season if not for an injury. He’ll be 100 percent to begin Spring Training and deserves a pick well before 200.

8. Logan O’Hoppe

O’Hoppe took a major step forward in 2022, putting up video game-like numbers in the Minor Leagues. Blocked by J.T. Realmuto in Philadelphia, the team traded him to the Angels for Brandon Marsh last summer. It won’t take long for O’Hoppe to take over as the starter in Anaheim if he’s not handed the job outright. He could finish as a top-12 catcher by the season’s end.

9. Ezequiel Tovar

Tovar is the front-runner to start from day one at shortstop. The Rockies’ top prospect has the potential to have a 20/15 season with a .270 to .280 average. Everything would have to go his way for that to happen, but Tovar has the ability and opportunity to do it.

10. Hunter Brown

Brown’s role is still up in the air, but even regulated to bullpen duty, the future ace still holds value. He could play the early role of Cristian Javier, where he jumped back and forth from spot starter to reliever while throwing multiple innings in both positions. While not all pitchers are cut out for it, Brown did pitch well in relief last year, and Javier was a beast at it. However, the ‘Stros may play it safe, not wanting to stunt his development, stashing him in the Minor Leagues until a starting spot opens up.

11. Kerry Carpenter

A 19th-round pick in 2019, Carpenter burst onto the scene last year with 36 combined home runs (six at the Major League level). With the shift no longer in play, expect Carpenters numbers to continue to climb (.252/.310/.485 in 114 PA). The power-hitting lefty could find himself in the middle of the order come Opening Day, where he could be a solid four-category contributor. No one’s paying attention to him because he’s on the offensively challenged Tigers, but being the savvy drafter that you are, you’re going to target him in the final few rounds and thank me later.

12. Gabriel Moreno

Moreno technically doesn’t qualify for this list because he spent too many days on a Big League roster despite playing in just 25 games. We’ll give him a pass, however, given his new role in Arizona, he could be vastly underrated.

Carson Kelly is still on the roster, but he was atrocious with the bat last season, hovering near the Mendoza line while only clubbing seven home runs despite racking up 354 plate appearances. Unfortunately for Morano owners, Kelly’s a decent glove behind the dish and Arizona’s manager, Torey Lovullo, tends to value defense over offense. But catchers can’t play every day, and once Morano makes his way into the lineup, it’ll be tough for Lovullo to take him back out. He’s worth a late-round pick.

13. Jordan Walker

I like Walker as much as anyone, but he won’t turn 21 until the end of May and doesn’t have a clear path to join the MLB roster just yet. He also hasn’t played above Double-A. I believe he’ll be a monster by 2024 or perhaps 2025, but it’s best to keep expectations in check for now.

14. Matt Mervis

I’m also a big Mervis fan, and his Minor League numbers speak for themselves – 40 home runs last year with a .309 average. He also hit six dingers in the AZFL this year. But with the team signing Eric Hosmer and Trey Mancini, Mervis has to be downgraded a bit.

16. Esteury Ruiz

I love Ruiz at the end of the draft. No one was more aggressive on the bases paths in the Minor Leagues last year, and the A’s have nothing to lose by letting him run wild. Especially now, with the new rules in place, Ruiz could be a steal (pardon the obvious pun) this late in the draft.

17. Oswald Peraza

The 50th-ranked overall prospect in baseball got his feet wet last year by playing in 18 games for the Yanks. He registered an impressive 146 wRC+ (46% better than average) with nearly as many walks as strikeouts in the very small sample size. He looked extremely comfortable at the dish and even stole two bags (he swiped 33 in Triple-A). The Yankees seem content to roll out one of their youngsters this season at short, and Peraza will likely be given the first opportunity.

24. Brice Turang

Already with 175 Triple-A games under his belt, the 23-year-old former first-rounder could be the Brewers’ Opening Day second baseman. He possesses a ton of speed, a great eye, and some decent pop. FanGraphs has him penciled in to reach 450 plate appearances making him incredibly valuable so late in the draft.

25. Francisco Alvarez

With James McCann shipped off to the Orioles and Omar Narvaez coming off a forgettable season, not much stands in the way of Alvarez (MLB’s top-ranked prospect) taking over. He takes a wicked hack and is selective at the plate but whiffs often. His batting average will likely be in the lower tier of the league, but the homers and counting stats may just be worth it. You could try and wait until he’s called up, but for many of these guys, that’ll likely be too late.

26. Andrew Painter

Painter is still very young and is unlikely to crack the Major League roster early this season, but stranger things have happened. With five exceptional Double-A starts already under his belt and the Phillies hungry to recapture last year’s magic, the 6-foot-7 righty who turns 20 a week after Opening Day should be on your radar.

33. Luis Campusano

The Padres don’t exactly need the offense, but having a power-hitting catcher is a luxury any team would love to have. Campusano is just that, but he will back up Austin Nola to start the year. That may not last long, however. Nola’s offensive production wasn’t great, and he graded out on the negative side for most defensive metrics. One glaring stat (although many times runners steal off the pitcher and not the catcher) is the 56 stolen bases allowed with just eight caught. He didn’t fare much better in 2021 either, giving up 26 successful swipes on just 30 attempts. Nola does block the ball well, and Campusano isn’t exactly elite behind the dish, but it wouldn’t be a surprise to see them evenly splitting catching duties by mid-summer.

34. Cade Cavalli

Cavalli was a top pitching prospect entering last year and pitched relatively well in Triple-A. He came up for a single game in September and surrendered seven runs on six hits and two walks but allowed no home runs and struck out six. He was obviously wild, hitting three batters as well, but the .500 BABIP didn’t do him any favors. Because of the shellacking (and because he plays for the Nationals), he’s fallen in fantasy leagues, but he still deserves your attention in the deepest of leagues.

Beyond our fantasy baseball content, be sure to check out our award-winning slate of Fantasy Baseball Tools as you prepare for your draft this season. From our free mock Draft Simulator – which allows you to mock draft against realistic opponents – to our Draft Assistant – which optimizes your picks with expert advice – we’ve got you covered this fantasy baseball draft season.

SubscribeApple Podcasts | Spotify | Google Podcasts | Stitcher | SoundCloud | iHeartRadio

Austin Lowell is a featured writer at FantasyPros. For more from Austin, check out his archive.

More Articles

FantasyPros Baseball Podcast: Top Fantasy Baseball Dynasty Rankings: No. 26-50

FantasyPros Baseball Podcast: Top Fantasy Baseball Dynasty Rankings: No. 26-50

fp-headshot by FantasyPros Staff | 1 min read
Understanding Dynasty Fantasy Baseball

Understanding Dynasty Fantasy Baseball

fp-headshot by FantasyPros Staff | 1 min read
Dynasty Fantasy Baseball Strategy & Team Building Advice

Dynasty Fantasy Baseball Strategy & Team Building Advice

fp-headshot by FantasyPros Staff | 1 min read
Dynasty Fantasy Baseball Strategy: Player Analysis

Dynasty Fantasy Baseball Strategy: Player Analysis

fp-headshot by FantasyPros Staff | 1 min read

About Author

Current Article

time 5 min read

FantasyPros Baseball Podcast: Top Fantasy Baseball Dynasty Rankings: No. 26-50

Next Up - FantasyPros Baseball Podcast: Top Fantasy Baseball Dynasty Rankings: No. 26-50

Next Article   arrow-image