Fantasy Baseball Draft Busts: Bobby Witt Jr., Luis Robert Jr., Gerrit Cole (2024)

Below are three MLB players I think will bust in 2024 based on their average draft position (ADP).

2024 Fantasy Baseball Busts

Bobby Witt Jr. (SS – KC)

Prior year fantasy drafts since 2021, where people were buying upside/youth in the early first round:

2021

Projected #1 – Ronald Acuna Jr. – Finished 116th, played 82 games
Projected #2 – Fernando Tatis Jr. – Finished 14th, played 130 games
Projected #5 – Juan Soto – Finished fifth, played 151 games

2022

Projected #5 – Bo Bichette – Finished 19th, played 159 games

2023

Projected #13 – Bobby Witt Jr. – Finished ninth

Other than Witt Jr., all these top picks had strong lineup protection around them at the time.

Bobby Witt Jr. finishing ninth last year with his lineup around him being guys like Salvador Perez, Vinnie Pasquantino and Hunter Renfroe is crazy impressive.

But where is everyone seeing his increase in value coming to take him over players like Corbin Carroll? Carroll had a higher batting average, higher OPS, more stolen bases (and caught less stealing), higher slugging and higher ISO for a team coming off a World Series run.

I suppose I could see the argument that no pitcher will ever challenge Witt Jr. so he might get on base more and try to steal more bases and, therefore, he is an elite OBP/SB guy.

But that’s a pretty bad argument for No. 2/No. 3 overall. He’ll finish the season outside of the top 10.

Luis Robert Jr. (OF – CHW)

Out of all qualified batters in MLB, Luis Robert Jr. is one of:

Six total that had an out-of-zone swing percentage higher than 40%.
Nine total that had a swing-and-miss percentage higher than 33%.
Twenty-five total that had an in-zone swing-and-miss percentage higher than 21%.

Surprisingly, though, he was in the top 10 for barrel percentage in 2023 at 15.4% — slightly above Ronald Acuna at 15.3%.

Is anyone curious what Luis Robert’s barrel rate was in 2022 as his swing-and-miss and chase rates were similar to 2023?

8.9%.

If I were a betting man (which I am), I’d bet the barrel rate decreases in 2024, while his swing-and-miss/chasing pitches tendencies stay constant.

Give me Adolis Garcia over Luis Robert.

Gerrit Cole (SP – NYY)

Nothing personal, I love his game, grit, energy on the mound, pitch rotation, all of it.

But at 13 overall, you are paying for what Gerrit Cole has already accomplished. Taking on high injury risk and potential for Cole to sit a few weeks mid-summer as the Yankees have their eye on the postseason is not ideal.

MLB Leaders in Pitches Thrown:

2022: #1 – Gerrit Cole
2023: #1 – Gerrit Cole

Drafting Cole in the top 15 is expecting 200 innings pitched, elite strikeout numbers and the Yankees to win 95 games. Let’s be real, even those who support Cole going in the first round, do you think he’s going to lead the league in pitches for the third year in a row? Something that has never happened this millennium?

I’ll take Jose Ramirez going one pick later. Mid-round pitching is too strong this year to draft a pitcher that early expecting a repeat Cy Young season.

More Fantasy Baseball Draft Strategy

Subscribe: Apple Podcasts | Spotify | Google Podcasts | SoundCloud | iHeartRadio

MLB Ronald Acuna Jr. Fernando Tatis Jr. Juan Soto Bo Bichette Bobby Witt Jr. Salvador Perez Hunter Renfroe Corbin Carroll Luis Robert Jr. Adolis Garcia Gerrit Cole Jose Ramirez